"Bob Dylan Is the Shakespeare for Our Time" -Penn Jillette

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 10. 2016
  • Bob Dylan has been awarded the 2016 Nobel Prize in Literature "for having created new poetic expressions within the great American song tradition."
    In this clip from our in-depth interview with magician, author, and noted libertarian Penn Jillette, Jillette discusses his deep love of Bob Dylan and why he considers Dylan "a freak, not a cheerleader."
    To watch the full interview, go here: • Penn Jillette on Donal...
    ---
    Subscribe to our CZcams channel: / reasontv
    Like us on Facebook: / reason.magaz. .
    Follow us on Twitter: / reason
    Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: goo.gl/az3a7a
    Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
    --

Komentáře • 243

  • @michaelreidperry3256
    @michaelreidperry3256 Před 4 lety +38

    When I saw Dylan live in person, I was very much conscious to, “ This is as if I am fortunate to watch Shakespeare doing Shakespeare. Remember this evening forever, Michael. It’s very special.”

  • @iancowlishaw2987
    @iancowlishaw2987 Před 7 lety +43

    Dylan is Shakespeare with a guitar!

  • @glbale
    @glbale Před 7 lety +88

    Well, Shakespeare, he’s in the alley
    With his pointed shoes and his bells
    Speaking to some French girl
    Who says she knows me well
    And I would send a message
    To find out if she’s talked
    But the post office has been stolen
    And the mailbox is locked.

    • @AnnaLVajda
      @AnnaLVajda Před 4 lety +13

      Oh mama can this really be the end? To be stuck inside a mobile with the Memphis blues again.

    • @CHlEFFIN
      @CHlEFFIN Před 4 lety +5

      Classic

  • @bradleymarquette6224
    @bradleymarquette6224 Před 6 lety +42

    You either "get" Dylan or you don't.

    • @PatrickJDylan
      @PatrickJDylan Před 3 lety +4

      TRANSLATION: You're either a Dipshit or a Dylan fan.

    • @KingMinosxxvi
      @KingMinosxxvi Před 3 lety +1

      That's bullshit cause there are plenty of amazing Dylan songs and plenty that are just garbage

  • @EK-yf8nk
    @EK-yf8nk Před 7 lety +6

    Every year we have a family gathering, sometimes its for Christmas, sometimes for New year's and if our busy schedules completely get in our way we manage to find a meaningless date on our calendar to get together and on each and every occasion ]whilst we drink sip on some wine and munch on some snacks we always play music in the background and each time Dylan comes on Dad always says "Is that Dylan, can you turn it down he sounds like hes about to break down crying, man that guy can't sing at all, he is terrible".,.. and every time i reply " Dad, theres more to it than just the singing, if you just listen to what he is singing and the music you might just get something out of it" and he''s reply is " yeah yeah, for you maybe but for me he sounds like a whaling child"... i kept persisting for about 6 years until one year i had a realisation that it didint matter how dylan sounded or what he was singing, i realised my father would never get it, i mean, when it comes to music/arts he is a big zero, hes hates art galleries and has never been to a music concert and has spent way too many years watching sports.. im sure if i asked him something about chemistry or to solve a mathematical equation he would get that as he studied a bachelor of chemical engineering at university but how was he every going to appreciate dylans music?
    My personal conclusion is, Dont force your views on others, people will only see and hear what they want to see and hear and if you happen to find others who see and hear as you do, enjoy the moment.

  • @sistersuetube
    @sistersuetube Před 3 lety +6

    Dylan lyrics are the only poetry people can quote that meant something to them....

  • @mikefannon6994
    @mikefannon6994 Před 3 lety +6

    Mr. Gillette is very perceptive. I've seen Dylan 3 times (74. 85. 2019) and Springsteen once. Dylan is always intriguing, always changing. Springsteen, while a great performer, once is enough. Dylan seems to be always looking for something in himself. Why else is he still performing so much after more than 50 years? Surely doesn't need the money. I continue to be intrigued and enlightened by Dylan.

  • @kathleenburke45
    @kathleenburke45 Před 3 lety +8

    Dylan tought us how to appreciate, or not, what was written, or painted, or just out there. It's a personal journey.

  • @robertfmorton
    @robertfmorton Před rokem +2

    Penn Jillett's introduction to Dylan's 'Trouble No More' bootleg album is a revelation. I totally agree with his assessment of the mighty BobDylan. I truly feel sorry for people who tell me that they don't get Dylan. They are missing so much.

  • @zenhaelcero8481
    @zenhaelcero8481 Před 2 lety +4

    I'm listening to this today, and Penn's observations seem so true. Norm MacDonald recently passed away, and he was also a huge Dylan fan. Similar to Dylan, Norm seemed to do comedy for the sake of his own entertainment almost, like he was more amused with his jokes the less the audience liked them. It's hard to describe. But the way Penn described Dylan as not trying to please people, and so being universally relatable because of it... I think Norm was the exact same thing. And how fitting, since he loved Dylan.

  • @michelle88960
    @michelle88960 Před 7 lety +6

    Totally agree with this man. I'm so pleased Dylan has got the Nobel Prize for Literature. He is our modern day poet. I have friends who tell me they can't understand what I like about his music and lyrics. I just send them off to listen to Positively 4th Street :)

  • @balerjohnson3099
    @balerjohnson3099 Před 7 lety +25

    This one of the many reasons I love Penn Jillette . I am also a Dylan fan who feels the same way but I could never articulate it as well as Penn did here . BTW Penn looks great Ive been following his model to reduce weight and high blood pressure and am doing well . Hope all is well with Penn .

  • @ghostrider2664
    @ghostrider2664 Před 3 lety +2

    I saw Dylan in '99 with Paul Simon. I went to see Paul Simon. How silly I was. Paul was awesome, loved his set. Then Dylan came on. I had no idea what I was in for. Dylan snatched my soul from my body, and forced me to be born again. Completely unexpectedly. I still to this day cannot describe the whole effeyct. It had on me. I went to see Paul Simon. I didn't know I was actually there to see Dylan.

  • @victoriaconnor1236
    @victoriaconnor1236 Před 7 lety +8

    Bob Zimmerman Dylan is: True Pure Present Tense While at the same time Past and Future Tense Sheer Crystal True Blue. Dylan is like the fragrance of the Rose and the Light Shining on it waiting for the water that makes it grow, but he is not the water, nor the flower. It's up to the listening heart and mind to initiate the bloom happen, which Dylan offers the world a possibility for if only millions would simultaneously ponder on the thought. His work is Simplicity Genius connecting souls. Like Shakespeare, Dylan is gifted.

  • @gordo608
    @gordo608 Před 7 lety +5

    I may not see what Penn sees in Dylan, but I appreciate how passionate he is about his music.

    • @halburd1
      @halburd1 Před 7 lety +1

      then you are an idiot he sold his soul to satan its the only reason that no talent is even known. dont believe me look up the 60 minutes interview. bob dylan sold soul 60 minutes he calls satan the "cammander in chief in this world and the other one" direct quote you ignorant fool.

    • @zachjohnson637
      @zachjohnson637 Před 7 lety +3

      Satan doesn't exist you mark

    • @mamoon7049
      @mamoon7049 Před 5 lety +4

      no he doesnt,he said hes holding up his end on a deal he made with the commander of chief of this world and the other,its god,its true cause hes religious

  • @albertandrews130
    @albertandrews130 Před 5 lety +11

    I commend Penn for his efforts but it is impossible to nail down Bob Dylan. Dylan is so far beyond that he has constructed himself so as to defy definition .

  • @cliffordadams8353
    @cliffordadams8353 Před 3 lety +6

    Dylan is a true artist
    Absolutely one of the greats. A genius

  • @mattgrimmer9909
    @mattgrimmer9909 Před rokem +3

    ‘‘Twas in another lifetime, one of toil and blood, when Blackness was a virtue the road was full of mud. I came in from the wilderness, a creature void of form. Come in, she said, I’ll give ya shelter from the storm.” -words as poignant as any ever written.

  • @LisaOutrequin
    @LisaOutrequin Před 7 lety +2

    ok it's a nice splice, but what did you do with the rest of the interview???!!!

  • @stoicite7
    @stoicite7 Před 7 lety +40

    "Don't criticize what you can't understand."
    Or more applicably here, don't criticize what you don't understand. If you want to make a valid assessment of Dylan's merit as an artist, you have literally dozens of songs to explore and ruminate upon first. To many who know the man's work, he's the greatest living artist in the world. Before you beg to differ, you might consider putting a modicum of effort into appreciating what they're all on about. Don't, and you're just about as enlightened as the unlearned adolescent who makes fun of the English of Willie the Shake.

    • @halburd1
      @halburd1 Před 7 lety +1

      maybe you should not comment on what you dont understand either praise or criticism you stupid fool.

    • @tpowell453
      @tpowell453 Před 7 lety +2

      Nobody gives a shit about what you think is "valid" or otherwise. Some people like him, others don't. Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Full stop.

    • @stoicite7
      @stoicite7 Před 7 lety +4

      +Ima SuperPerson
      So who then cares about your repudiation of my viewpoint? You are right about people's right to their own opinions, of course, but it's normal to be wrong. Plenty of people don't like baroque music, so they don't care about Bach. Others don't care for art, so Picasso makes no sense to them. Some don't appreciate fine architecture, and to them Frank Lloyd Wright's designs look staid and dated.
      All of these people are missing something. There are a few intelligent and well-educated critics of literature who deny the value of Dylan's contributions and who can defend their positions, but the vast majority of those who say the bard is overrated simply don't know what they're talking about.

    • @tpowell453
      @tpowell453 Před 7 lety +1

      *****
      - He just writes music. It doesn't matter.

    • @aliasdyln33
      @aliasdyln33 Před 7 lety +4

      Excuse me? Dylan "just writes music". I have seen him live dozens of times, and he is an artist on stage. Take every show for what it's worth. Oh, and he does write books (e.g. "literature"), and draw. I wish most folks on planet-Earth could do a fraction of what this man does.

  • @Bob-fz7pd
    @Bob-fz7pd Před 6 lety +4

    Shakespeare? Ask again in a hundred years.

  • @janetwebb1507
    @janetwebb1507 Před 2 lety

    God, Bless & Keep dearest Bob with Us for As long as He (BD) Desires to Stay among Us. And To be Blessed by his gentle prodding & nudging for All of us...for the expanding our Awarenessrs, curiosity, & Journey which will Culminate in Benefit
    From those Storehouses of TREASURE he has Discovered & Interpreted for Us. Treasure of TRUE Spiritual Knowledge which have been has lying Dormant but Still Awaiting ( Our) self Realization & Discovery of our own significance of ( Our) Existence, our Ceation, & Purpose, along with Folly foilables, & Alsi the Reality of the Gift of Life at Bob Dylans gentle pointing of 'The Way'/by THOSE who Desire to HEAR & Learn from his humble Attempt to lead Us by his metaphors, ques,, foot note's & Sharing of personal experience & pointing us to Ancient BLESSED We'll of Universal Truths, Wisdom(s), Archetypes..&, ultimately to the
    Spiritual TRUTH that Unlocks LIFE & Victory in This World.

  • @mygic183
    @mygic183 Před rokem

    Beautifully put

  • @vincent7520
    @vincent7520 Před rokem

    This is an excellent comment, the more so there it has no intellectual, littérarités fashion some expect from a discussion about Dylan.
    I particularly like the comparison between Springsteen and Dylan…
    Again Penn Gillette is an excellent analyst of today’s world and creation.
    Thank you.

  • @RavenMadd9
    @RavenMadd9 Před 5 lety

    thank you

  • @ListenWell
    @ListenWell Před 3 lety +1

    Absolutely

  • @guitarfunn
    @guitarfunn Před 7 lety +1

    Well deserved recognition!

  • @13mgreg
    @13mgreg Před 7 lety +1

    Any one who disagrees... You got any objective criticism to back your claim?

  • @jorgejohnson451
    @jorgejohnson451 Před 6 lety +3

    Penn nails it.

  • @CeruleanFawkes
    @CeruleanFawkes Před 7 lety +4

    Wait, so one of the cruxes of his arguments for this is that Dylan is like Shakespeare because "he isn't trying to please other people" and isn't trying to describe some kind of inclusive human experience?
    What do you think Shakespeare was doing? He was writing for an active and borderline participatory audience, trying to pull them in with universal human emotions wrought through extraordinary circumstances. If you want to call Dylan talented, fine whatever, but your description of him seems completely counter to what Shakespeare actually did with his work.
    Either you don't understand Dylan, or you don't understand Shakespeare.

    • @mamoon7049
      @mamoon7049 Před 5 lety +1

      i think he didnt relate their work but the level of talent and originality in their work

    • @Lonesomepoet
      @Lonesomepoet Před 4 lety

      @@mamoon7049 No

  • @wingwaves940
    @wingwaves940 Před 6 lety

    A-holes and opinions, we all have them but you don't have to choose to be one. You dont have to agree with Mr. Jillette but you dont have to be rude about it either. Personally I agree with Penn but that's just my opinion. Check out the Penn Point on Dylan vs. Mcartney for an even better explanation.
    I hope I'm my lifetime I do get a chance to see Sir Paul live, yet there would be no reason to pay to hear him live more than once other than for the fun of it. You Know what you'd get at those shows.
    Bob doesn't give a damn what you, I or anyone else thinks of much of his work and that's the joy of a Dylan show. He will often change up his work in so many different ways it's mind boggling. But always, whether playing his Vast body of work or covering someone else, Dylan rips his guts and heart out over and over again for others even those who don't appreciate it!
    I'm doing my damndest to figure out how the hell I can get to Philly and get a ticket see Bob on his upcoming tour 11/11! Lord only knows what gems he might pull out of his hat with this next installment of his Bootleg Series. Someone else asked, What does Penn think of those 79-81 yrs.? Well, we will find out soon because Mr. Jillette wrote about it in one of the package deals. I don't need fancy books of old photos or other stuff but I certainly look forward to reading what Penn Jillette has to say there! Dylan's spirituality is none of my business and I don't have much of a base of reference on some of the topics of that time period. What I do know is the fact that those years gave us some of his most Explosive and Wonderful music ever! Dirty, dirty, sexy guitar on Groom's Still Waiting at the Alter and his harp work alone at the end of What Can I Do For You brings me to tears every single time! That period of his work has given me some of my favorite prayers of all time!
    And as Penn pointed out, Bob is always searching to find his own self. Or so I paraphrase. The downright guts and bravery it takes for him to share that with us is absolutely Amazing!!!!
    Wishing Peace, Love & Joy to All!

  • @brianstoltz2838
    @brianstoltz2838 Před 3 lety +2

    Shakespeare would be in complete awe of Bob. Shakespeare was the Norman Lear of his day. Not too shabby, but then, not Bob.

  • @williamdiaz2645
    @williamdiaz2645 Před rokem

    From where I'm sitting, "Bob Dylan Is the Shakespeare for Our Time", that title would belong to Bruce Springsteen, "A screen door slams, Mary's dress sways Like a vision she dances across the porch As the radio plays Roy Orbison singing for the lonely…", My two Cents!

  • @user-wl4rv7pi4h
    @user-wl4rv7pi4h Před 6 měsíci

    Well said. Thats why dylan gets me. Even now when he is 82

  • @carlarisoldi5740
    @carlarisoldi5740 Před 3 lety +1

    Love the comparison with Springsteen, thanks! OMG and the Velvets, too, wow!

  • @marakaretsos5204
    @marakaretsos5204 Před 3 lety +2

    Il piu Grande Poeta Musicale!!
    🎵🎶⭐️

  • @0otee
    @0otee Před 3 lety

    If Shakespeare lived in our time Dylan and he wouldve met surely❣️Like I wouldve gone seeing/listening Live Shakespeare expressing/performing his Poetry and all, for so many people! Today❣️🌺🌞🌹❤️Like we have now Poetry International arranged in the ‘60’s by Dutch Poets. Allen Ginsberg and many came!
    Yeah lets have Shakespeare there too!
    And you know, he is! We luckily have his works to see in theaters, books❣️

  • @MrHappy70
    @MrHappy70 Před 7 lety

    Bob Dylan kicks ass. Growing up my dad would always have old music playing, Dylan being one. I never read Shakespeare though, my attention doesn't span that length.

  • @pkpapers
    @pkpapers Před rokem

    "Time will tell / who has fell / and who's been left behind."

  • @austinhogarth
    @austinhogarth Před 6 lety

    agreed

  • @jameskenny8821
    @jameskenny8821 Před 2 lety +1

    I'm a Phil Ochs fan, there was a big rivalry between them.

  • @boxingjerapah
    @boxingjerapah Před 5 lety +2

    Get’s it

  • @mythicsin3083
    @mythicsin3083 Před 3 lety

    I agree

  • @lesterbarret317
    @lesterbarret317 Před 3 lety

    if i thought about it, i never would of done it i just would of let it slide,if i paid attention to what others were thinking something inside me would of died, i was just to stubborn to every be governed by enforced insanity someone had to reach for that rising star i guess it was up to him. dylan ! the master and legend love your work!

  • @drewzydog1710
    @drewzydog1710 Před 7 lety

    People are crazy and times are strange. Johnson/Weld 2016

  • @juliojjesgmailcom
    @juliojjesgmailcom Před 3 lety

    Penn did not mention Cervantes.
    ''Don Quijote'' is the Best Selling Book of All Time (selling an ''eye watering'' 500 Million copies worldwide).
    Many scholars place Cervantes above Shakespeare.

  • @jamesmalveira4983
    @jamesmalveira4983 Před 3 lety +2

    Shakespeare was the dylan of his time

    • @antel704
      @antel704 Před 2 lety +1

      Shakespeare didnt made sircule Dylan make full sircule

  • @MrUndersolo
    @MrUndersolo Před 7 lety +1

    Shakespeare could never have written "Tarantula", right? Anyone?

  • @andrewmartin6445
    @andrewmartin6445 Před 6 lety

    That's a compliment where I come from btw

  • @superfuzzymomma
    @superfuzzymomma Před 2 lety

    Amen friend Penn

  • @rickyelvis3215
    @rickyelvis3215 Před 4 lety

    happy birthday bob ... thanks.

  • @73psalm
    @73psalm Před 7 lety +1

    Dylan a Shakespeare of our time?- unless our times have descended from the sublime to the ridiculous.

  • @thebacons5943
    @thebacons5943 Před 2 lety

    The Shakespeare parallel is clear for many reasons, though I’ll take Bob’s body of work any day of the week

  • @ladicius
    @ladicius Před 7 lety +9

    Hahaha, no. No he's not.

  • @shanexyz3972
    @shanexyz3972 Před 7 lety +6

    I wonder if Penn liked Bob Dylan's Christian phase lol.

    • @ronreynolds1610
      @ronreynolds1610 Před 6 lety

      Imagine the two doing the other's work ... in their own style.

    • @jeffreywebb7932
      @jeffreywebb7932 Před 6 lety +2

      Shane XYZ Later on.....yes he did.

    • @hewsonk
      @hewsonk Před 6 lety +5

      Jillette's positive views of these songs are expressed in the powerful essay he wrote. It is included in the photo book, "Pressing On", in the recently released "Trouble No More" (Bootleg #13 re the 1979-'81 period)

    • @albertandrews130
      @albertandrews130 Před 5 lety +1

      Of course he does

    • @oliveeisner8964
      @oliveeisner8964 Před 5 lety

      Well considering Dylan was on 🔥 during that period and gave jaw dropping passionate performances and tore open his heart and expressed his connection to spirit...yeah. he dug it.
      People who dismiss those albums out of hand because of some prickly atheist world view are missing out and missing the point. That period ROCKED.

  • @eamonnmaccionnaith5761

    I don't agree with the comparison. I'm a huge Dylan fan, but that's based on his music. A lot of his writing doesn't hold up without the music carrying it. Besides, Shakespeare was a playwright, so there really isn't a comparison.

  • @holisticpsychologybyobrien

    Penn says, "Shakespeare, Burns, Dylan." - Does anyone know who Burns is?

  • @Charles-Anthony
    @Charles-Anthony Před 7 lety +2

    At the end, Jillette said that people he "knows and reads about who are really literary", name Shakespeare, Burns and Dylan. In that case, I doubt he has many literature-loving friends. I'm an avid reader and I love literature; I'd nominate Shakespeare, Radcliffe, Dickens and Charlotte Bronte.

    • @ghiribizzi
      @ghiribizzi Před 7 lety

      Charles well Shakespeare did not only was a good writer who depicted the human condition but he was influential to the language expanding and elevating to a higher cultural standard (like Dante did with italian) by creating new words that we are still using these days (Shakespeare was a modernist in a James Joyce fashion), so compraring him with The Bard it is not only pretentious but arrogant too. People like this Pen Jillete the only thing they do its to enhance and procure the exegesis (like those little explanatory notes bellow a trashy pretentious post modernist piece or -shit- art) among their acolytes. But it's we have a pop -mass- culture prize in the ages of a pop -mass- president (Obama was too) and so on. Dylan does not depict neither a human condition nor universal values asociated with humanity but only a instantaneous determinateness in sapace and time like a narrow snapshot

    • @GameKiller2435
      @GameKiller2435 Před 6 lety

      I'd argue that Dylan's work did not only represent a snapshot in time. Dylan captured the pains of the human condition relating to most of modern society. Analyze Gates of Eden, It's alright Ma, or Last Thoughts on Woody Guthrie. I believe you might find something in those if you can come to understand them.

    • @robertnewell5057
      @robertnewell5057 Před 4 lety

      Your gonna need a bigger list

  • @remalim9471
    @remalim9471 Před 2 lety

    I love Dylan.

  • @a.k.550
    @a.k.550 Před 5 lety +5

    i bet most of the commentators below dont even know much about dylan.

  • @BrotherWoody1
    @BrotherWoody1 Před 7 lety +2

    Shakespeare I get; Dylan I get; but Burns???

    • @jeffcowdrey1578
      @jeffcowdrey1578 Před 5 lety +1

      Burns was a folksinger, too. Compare "A Man's a Man for a' That" and "Blowin' in the Wind".

  • @pandoraphalange5723
    @pandoraphalange5723 Před 3 lety

    Dylan is amazing. He deserved the Nobel Prize. But anyone who compares him to Shakespeare, had never read the plays of Shakespeare, let alone the Sonnets. Comparisons are almost always odious, but in this case it’s ludicrous.

    • @dylanthompson8511
      @dylanthompson8511 Před 10 měsíci

      They're both inheritors of the bardic tradition, is what people mean when they say it. So I absolutely agree with the comparison, in that sense. Obviously a play isn't a lyric or song but they are both bardic.

  • @karikantonen9353
    @karikantonen9353 Před 3 lety

    Thats realy show if you andosstandin first what he sey.lyrigs.take meny yers at you noin somtting vaht meen bob.50 over i have like he.samtaime gomin tolktekst isee at i first noin roon. andostandin tree times same song.

    • @karikantonen9353
      @karikantonen9353 Před 3 lety

      Jos ja kun olen.kuunellut bob dylania yli 50 vuotta .hän ollut tulkinnoissaan tärkeä myös rauhan asioissa tietyn laiset epäkohdat elämässä.olen hänestä pitänyt muusikkona että julistajana.aluksi en ymmärtänyt häntä lainkaa,kun en osanut englantia.aloin eri tyyleillä kysymään mitä hän tarkoitti biisessä.hyvät rytmit ääni piti messissä.monet biisit on sittemin muuttuneet sisällöltään kun olen nähnyt suomennoksen.että olen joskus aavistanut oikein laulun sisällön.kiva matka hänen kanssaan.tcemppiä hänelle.

  • @kristinwagar9366
    @kristinwagar9366 Před 6 lety

    Dylan has nothing to do with Shakespeare. He is a musician and a poet.

    • @AnnaLVajda
      @AnnaLVajda Před 2 lety

      He's a wordsmith as was Shakespeare bards if you will.

  • @sspbrazil
    @sspbrazil Před 3 lety

    Penn is spot on. I’m a Dylan nut too.

  • @richardmattingly7000
    @richardmattingly7000 Před 7 lety +1

    Oh Penn their not called the Me Generation for nothing. Well before a little boy named Zimmerman conjured up the name Bob Dylan singer Woody Guthrie sang of the dispossessed and before he ever toured Jack Keroauc was already on the road. Yet Baby Boomers never grow tired of their own reflection, and its why putting Dylan with Shakespeare isn't outrageous its just par for the course.....

  • @JSTNtheWZRD
    @JSTNtheWZRD Před 2 lety

    The title on this video is incorrect, Shakespeare is the Shakespeare of our time, and even he wasn't Shakespeare - and Dylan ain't no Shakespeare.

  • @stephenbainbridge7204
    @stephenbainbridge7204 Před 6 lety +1

    'Oh Mercy!' Yes I confess, I am a Bobaholic. 'Compare & Contrast D&S'? An interesting but ultimately fruitless pursuit as is looking at say 1604 artistic works solely through the focus of 21st century spectacles. A much more demanding serious approach to D's poetic canon requires an informed analysis such as that by Christopher Ricks' 'Visions of Sin', a creditable attempt. I think what is being approached here is the current popular impact of D & of course duly & crudely announced by an ad man's stripe by a comparison with the bard to gain attention. Well it does work but this is lazy and trite fodder for the lumpen proletariat. This persistent contemporary approach in a consumptive consumerist society is crass. Remember this, S's popularity was never consistent or indeed global until the 19th century & poor young Keats only sold c200 copies when he died. D's present impact on contemporary life is undoubtedly colossal but only time will tell. However, he does merit serious attention. So send in the clowns? Better still, some seriously informed distinguished grown-up writers like Ricks et al rather than those blessed with embarrassing happy-clappy, wishy-washy adolescent unrefined minds. After all, this is an ever so-so serious industry isn't it? D must be laughing all the way to the bank. Alas, the tragedy is that poor Keats and countless others were not. But hey, thanks for the publicity: 4/10 - Must do better. Oh dearie me, have I unwittingly upset some fragile snowflakes who are now duly going into Victim Mode? Is this modern culture? 'Oh Mercy!' Ha Ha.

  • @joanabernethy7525
    @joanabernethy7525 Před 7 lety

    You nailed it.

  • @lacikollar64
    @lacikollar64 Před 4 lety +1

    Some tunes are great some very average very very simple i am saying as a composer but lyrically speaking Bob is the best of all no wonder he inspired many musicians like John Lennon Bruce etc... even he inspired me in some way no wonder he won Nobel price.

  • @skronked
    @skronked Před 7 lety

    "Dylan has no idea who he is?" one could take that out of context, pretty easily. I wonder what Jillette thinks of the "man upstairs." this guy is long winded. I don't really think he fully grasps the singularity of it all. Vegas card man. Magic is boring

  • @jimmaculate3802
    @jimmaculate3802 Před 2 lety

    What does he know? It sounds like he actually said stay within the 21st century as his recommendations for what to listen to with Bob Dylan. So that would be from 2000 onward and not 1990 or 1975 or 66. That's what I mean. What the hell does he know? I hate these people that make all these products proclamations

  • @infamouscomments6885
    @infamouscomments6885 Před 7 lety +6

    And the last good song he wrote was... when exactly?

    • @fastenbulbous
      @fastenbulbous Před 7 lety +6

      2012

    • @halburd1
      @halburd1 Před 7 lety

      wrong

    • @legend9948
      @legend9948 Před 7 lety +3

      you're right they should have given him the prize 40 years ago

    • @aliasdyln33
      @aliasdyln33 Před 7 lety +7

      Actually, truth be told. Bob Dylan should have been awarded the Nobel Prize after "Song To Woody", like 1962. Yes, tomorrow is a long time.

    • @aaron1269
      @aaron1269 Před 7 lety +2

      InfamousComments
      As a whole, it's been a while, but he has some good lines in somewhat average songs.

  • @1337BananaL33TVostok
    @1337BananaL33TVostok Před 7 lety +1

    But Harambe died for our sins!!!

  • @simba94
    @simba94 Před 3 lety

    I’ve just recently started listening and analysing his music, after 3 months I understand he is a great songwriter but i still haven’t seen him above the beatles,radiohead,oliver mtukudzi,kanye,Kendrick lamar,etc .Im gonna revisit my comment after another 6 months

    • @PhilipSchmitz
      @PhilipSchmitz Před 3 lety +2

      Could you recommend some Kanye or Kendrick Lamar songs that you find superior to Dylan? I listened to some songs of them both and they gave me absolutely nothing. I find the song "Humble" atrocious. Or I am missing something.

    • @simba94
      @simba94 Před 3 lety

      Philip Schmitz I’m still visiting his(Bob) discog and absorbing his artistry...Kanye i dnt view him as an individual since his craft is based on collaborative effort but Kendrick is more of a fair comparison (though the artistry is worlds apart) w/ that said ;

    • @simba94
      @simba94 Před 3 lety

      Humble has a message but its masked as a trap song(again which is something out of the ordinary for Bob) Id suggest Sing about me im dying of thirst...How much a dollar costs...untitled 5...Duckworth..

  • @bjorkstrand7773
    @bjorkstrand7773 Před 3 lety

    reincarnationwise, dylan = shakespeare, both have jupiter conjunct saturn

  • @normandylander
    @normandylander Před 7 lety +2

    @Penn Jillette - You're way off the mark with this claim, way, way off.
    Mr Robert Zimmerman, aka Bob Dylan, has been given the Nobel prize
    for literature, with a slew of commentators saying that he's America's
    and his generation's Shakespeare. I'm sorry, as much as I love
    the lyrical genius of Dylan, he's not Shakespeare, nor anywhere close to
    his genius. Dylan being compared to him is like comparing Chocolate and
    Ice Cream, apples and oranges, it's an unfair comparison, both to
    Shakespeare and to Mr Zimmerman.
    Shakespeare was the greatest exponent and proponent of the English
    language, beating both Chaucer and Milton to the throne of most revered
    wordsmith, and he also has the distinction of having added over 300
    words to the English language, at least half of which are still in the
    dictionary, and many of which words and phrases we still use today.
    No-one has a chance, ever, of equalling such an amazing body of work,
    work which contains humour, philosophy, politics, love, hate, war,
    intrigue, betrayal, loyalty, magic, death, and, above all, the poetic
    romance of Shakespeare's sixteenth century English.

    • @mamoon7049
      @mamoon7049 Před 5 lety +1

      well you know the thing with that is that both had very creative minds but shakespear had a headstart,he had a time advantage where he could be completely loose with english as he was one of the developer and there hadnt been much done in literature until his era,with dylan it was different,people like shakespear had used so many rhymes and words,so many stories,so many instances that it was increasingly harder to become what dylan became,original.both had the same level of creativity but shakespear statistically achieved more because of the very minute number of competition and no literary history.In creativity and potential aspect dylan was as good as shakespear,but shakespear couldnt have touched what dylan did,but dylan did with all along the watchtower what shakespear was all about

  • @zriter59escritor33
    @zriter59escritor33 Před 7 lety

    Not to denigrate Dylan. I like a good many of his songs; and there is no denying his influence on American popular culture during the past 50 years or so.
    Having said that, COME ON, EVERYBODY. Shakespeare is the greatest poet in the English language. Dylan is nowhere near that level; and let us not dodge the most relevant question here: Do popular-song lyrics qualify as poetry?
    I think not. In a first-rate pop song, the lyrics are closely allied to the music. Neither, therefore, can stand effectively on their own.
    Judging Dylan as a poet based on his lyrics, I would rate him well below W.B. Yeats, T.S. Eliot and W.H. Auden, at least. I would also nominate Dylan Thomas, Robert Frost, Hart Crane, Robert Penn Warren, Robert Hayden, Richard Wilbur -- that's off the top of my head --

  • @shuddupeyaface
    @shuddupeyaface Před 3 lety

    The 92 people who thumbed this down.

  • @harryhenderson792
    @harryhenderson792 Před 7 lety

    bruce copied Dylan, just as tom petty and mark knophler did

  • @HoratioTalbot771_a
    @HoratioTalbot771_a Před 7 lety

    Not Shakespeare

  • @requiemforamerica8432
    @requiemforamerica8432 Před 7 lety +30

    Pepe is the shakspeare of our time

    • @requiemforamerica8432
      @requiemforamerica8432 Před 7 lety +1

      Rinstinkt Rat u r just upset bc Trump is your real daddy

    • @DavidSmith-ss1cg
      @DavidSmith-ss1cg Před 7 lety

      Requ.iemFor America - Be nice to Mr Rinstink, he's in his prime, you know.

  • @rkoorse
    @rkoorse Před 4 lety

    Love Dylan. But Chronicles? Terrible. Every writing cliche ever used. He didn't simply mix metaphors, he put them in a blender. Found it painful to read.

  • @JoakimWesterbring
    @JoakimWesterbring Před 4 lety

    and this is where we all meet. only the nuts make it to these kind of videos i suppose

  • @skronked
    @skronked Před 6 lety

    Jillette is not the Harry Houdini of our time? The guy has zero rap for a sleight of hand man. stick with magic and tv manipulation. Who asked for Jillette's opinion? NO one.

  • @enabiah
    @enabiah Před 4 lety +1

    god damn, penn's getting old

  • @zaidbolarin5739
    @zaidbolarin5739 Před 7 lety

    only an intellectual giant would conflate Shakespeare and Dylan together!

  • @skronked
    @skronked Před 6 lety

    Penn Jillette is like the Harry Houdini of Magic or sleight of hand. I'd like to know what the fuck Jillette knows of the Bard of Avon. Dylan has a kind of ancient uh, mystical like (Dylan doesn't know who he is?). Jillette is kind of transferring his need for real worship. He is so quick to dismiss the spiritual and religious traditions of America with his confident Atheism. I'm not really what Dylan knows like ala: Blake or Erasmus, (Shakespeare?) Who made Jillette the commentator? Dude, you couldn't write a handbill for the Fillmore East. You need to kind of back up your Shakespeare/Dylan work comparisons. I don't find them much alike at all. even Bob Zimmerman went with Dylan, not Shakespeare. Stick with the causal singularity of nothing.

  • @spittingvenom9148
    @spittingvenom9148 Před 5 lety

    How am I the only person to comment on his one pained fingernail, it’s driving me crazy,,,,you’re a grandpa, don’t paint your god damn nails

  • @alvincay100
    @alvincay100 Před 7 lety +3

    Mumbling is the equivalent of a Shakespeare play now? How far we've fallen...

    • @henriktheonly3874
      @henriktheonly3874 Před 5 lety

      Calvin Smith mumbling?

    • @jonathanb1406
      @jonathanb1406 Před 5 lety

      Yeah, because that's the comparison he was making. Writing and singing, not writing and writing. Come on, now.

    • @patburlewcox7736
      @patburlewcox7736 Před 5 lety

      looks like someone needs a cheerleader

  • @davidclarke9783
    @davidclarke9783 Před 6 lety +2

    Bob Dylan and John Lennon same vibes

    • @mamoon7049
      @mamoon7049 Před 5 lety

      lennon was average

    • @Lonesomepoet
      @Lonesomepoet Před 4 lety

      @@mamoon7049 Prove it.

    • @mamoon7049
      @mamoon7049 Před 4 lety

      John Kevin take any lennon songs lyricism and compare it with dylan or leonard cohen or George Harrison

  • @tpowell453
    @tpowell453 Před 7 lety

    Penn's opinion means no more and no less than anyone else's. He's as full of himself as Dylan. lol

  • @kmg501
    @kmg501 Před 7 lety +2

    Really Penn? Really?

  • @letsrelaxwithtexts2114
    @letsrelaxwithtexts2114 Před 10 měsíci

    Dylan is a mastwr of deception

  • @anonymouslakernerd7214

    Says someone who probably doesn't read any contemporary poets.

  • @coffeefish
    @coffeefish Před 7 lety +7

    I call BS.

  • @alvincay100
    @alvincay100 Před 7 lety +1

    Not even close. Maybe the Robert Burns of our time, but not Shakespeare.

  • @Samuel-sd7yl
    @Samuel-sd7yl Před 7 lety

    n'importe quoi

  • @Felix9lives
    @Felix9lives Před 7 lety +1

    Penn Jillette's brain is not functioning well:((

  • @Dambo96
    @Dambo96 Před 7 lety +1

    21st century are you kidding