"Science" of why women can't go to Sabarimala: Sinu Joseph
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 12. 2023
- Main Channel: / scienceisdope
Free Pseudoscience Game - Spot the BS: bingobaker.com/#65349335c8b652a6
Biases and Fallacies:
docs.google.com/document/d/1X...
One-time support:
UPI: scienceisdope@icici
buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope
Patreon: / scienceisdope_
To join my WhatsApp community: nas.io/scienceisdope
Discord: / discord
Subbreddit: / scienceisdope - Zábava
Talks a lot. Says very little.
Is travelling on aircraft considered for this rule of 5000 feet?
Says a lot about their psyche which is still chained by patriarchal religious dogma
@@shiroyasha_007 what does patriarchal religious dogma means?
@@dannystark7668 Dogma means rules/beliefs which should be followed without any questioning. This is a religious belief and gives power to men so it's patriarchal.
@@shiroyasha_007😂 these are the same people kneebrain women who were made to protest against hindu code bill 😂 and they did too lol
Indians when humans with xx chromosomes: 🤯
moye moye!
Lol.
Society man society.
Man society man @@Ragdoll6
@@Smolfloofs ?
By her logic women can't go in planes and helicopters
Wait if altitude reduces fertility, then is Goddess Parvati infertile. I don't think so, she is the Goddess of fertility herself.
hhhhKHASHIhhhh
How can you possibly know that 🤓? How many kids did she have, as per the mythology?
She is infertile bro, Kartikeya is not her son and she made Ganesha out of dirt of her body, she didn't bore any children at all😂
she is cursed to be infertile by Kama's wife
@@aswinbabu1630no bro! Until now everyone including Kama's wife, parvathi, the storyteller and us thought that it happened due to the curse. Now we know that she became infertile due to the altitude affecting her chakras.
Now wait till Shiva gets to know the reason
I want to hear the science behind 'Sati System'.
there's no science behind it , it originated as a way to escape humiliation and save dignity from invaders , the unmarried women were take as concubines by the commanders or sold as s3x slaves in arabian market , JAUHAR and SATI are same the only key difference is JAUHAR was mass su!cide and for royal women and SATI for local widows .
but it continued as a practise for a few time
also SATI has been exaggerated , there were very few cases of SATI IN the late 18th,19th and 20th century
They won't tell it, they will call it a "milawat" by Mughal+Angrez😂
@@RR_theproahole In the vast available hindu literature dating back thousands of years, why is sati mentioned so few times and far between? If sati was a "norm", surely it would have a lot more mention. Why is the earliest known case of sati available after the invasions from central asia began? Why is sati heard only among royal families and not the common folks?
@@sachinjoshi1386even one satti is far too many.
@@sachinjoshi1386 Wasn't sati mentioned in the Mahabharat? One of the most important books in Hinduism. And I am certain of the fact that Mahabharat is older than any known central Asian invasion. That is enough. Even one sati is bad enough.
Junko tabei , first women to climb mount everest has one daughter and a son.
😂😂😂😂 exactly 🙌🏻
Gazab
It’s because they believe in themselves and listen to themselves instead of people claiming to see life in rocks and stones!! 😂
😂😂
😂
Why is everything restricted to women in the name of fertility? How come climbing any other mountain does not affect their fertility?
Yeah women go to vaishno devi at such high altitude. So women should be restricted if it makes sense😅
Let’s say it does affect their fertility, then they should be warned about it not restricted. Every religion only thinks of women as incubators you are as good as your uterus
@@Smolfloofs agreed on this on
Bcz the chakras TOLD her. Don't you understand? The chakras know EVERYTHING (except evidence based reasoning).
Abb kya kahy yha to mahila khud apni side nhi lyy rhi . Paglo ki tarah behave kr rhi hai isasy acchi to feminist hoti hai atleast wo women kyy sath kadhi to rehti hai
All the Hindu Goddesses with human female body ,who went to or lived in higher altitude are punching air right now .
Please name them?
@@dannystark7668 Parvati devi, Laxmi devi, Saraswati devi and every other Goddess, they literally live in heaven dude.
@@lasyak6355 but the sabrimala temple which is in question I s dedicated to a bhramachari. If it's a requirement, people should not find ways to justify it using science.
@@Asianboy1 I say it's not justifiable to the least.
@@lasyak6355 there are thousands of temples in India. And sabrimala doesn't prohibit all women from going in. Only menstruating women. Bhramacharis don't interact with menstruating women and hence it is no permissible to go there.
I also don't get why they would try to justify it using science. If it's a tradition you don't need to keep justifying it.
What about women who live at high altitude places or go for vacations at high altitude places, shouldn't they all grow moustaches by now?
😂😂😂 omg
Literal dream for a transmasc individual
There are no women in Himalayas, come on dude thats basic knowledge.
@@affanalam6123 Many women have climbed mt. Everest multiple times!! And for your kind information, climbing mt. Everest isn't a 1 day trip.
So what about the women living their whole life in hills like nilgiri or himalayas which are more taller than sabarimalai?
The confidence these people have in speaking whatever nonsense helps me to boost my confidence in life whenever I feel low.
Because listeners are fcuking blind and don't question and happily accept everything
Hairani ki bat hai logg aise logo ko follow bhi krty hai . Just bcz of religion . Acha hai main nastik hu .😂😂
@@kira_bl8qy Thank God I'm an Atheist 😂😂
Well Said bro👏👏
What abt women pilots then😂
Hence women can't be skydivers or pilots. Air hostesses must suffer from infertility for sure.
😅😅😅😅😅😂😂
Listening to pranav and spot the bs i improved my debating skills lol
What's febating?
@@AkhileshKumar-fk3od typo lol
@@AkhileshKumar-fk3od yeah but first complete 12 th
Another point which I think is cherry picking is that she said that testosterone is converted into estrogen in ovaries and that needs activation of swadishtana chakra. She completely dismissed the fact that testosterone itself is formed in ovaries and testes by action of LH, and thus if that chakra thing is true (which it isn't), no testosterone will be formed at the first place.
Exactly, the testosterone is produces in both male and female gonads. Which according to her logic would require the activation of swadisthana chakra in males too. It's easy to fool people by sprinkling some science as everyone will be impressed by such words.
You remembered the verbiage too well !
Sabarimala's altitude is 468 m while Bangalore's altitude is 900+ m
Then why are women allowed to roam freely in Bangalore? I don't hear any research articles about Bangalore being bad for female fertility(although I will probably check)
it is not about article, it about the 41 days fasting , and trekking up the hill. moreoever the deity is considered a brahmachari.
@@User-x2f3ef4s4fs6g but trekking and fasting is something equally dangerous for a man, isn't it?
If a woman wants to, why can't she go to the Sabarimala?
@@awesomepotato4499 men and woman are biologically different. it is not about danger lol. it is about health. And the deity they worship is in a state of brahmacharya. There are other ayyappa temples where woman can enter . those temples ayyappa is not in a brahmacharya state.
@@User-x2f3ef4s4fs6g the problem is that women are barred from entering simply so that the priests do not get 'distracted'
For some reason, we rationalise it
@@awesomepotato4499 priests getting distracted? only for sabarimala ? what a stupid thng tp say
I don't get it ! why in Hinduism women are only considered for fertility only
A women is more than just being fertile to give kids
She's a human, not a children producing machine
It's not something present in one religion. It's not something present in Hinduism.
@@DanielRajan-sx3mg But in other religion you can criticize...but hindu people try to present it as something sort of achievement that we respected women always, and when asked how did they respected her ? By considering her for only fertility...people just justify their dumb non-scientific rituals in name of fertility
If it was only pseudo-science I could accept, but even in there, they are only considerate about fertility
Though still, any such religion which regards women as only child producing machine is to be condemned
@@user-st2do8oo4i I don't know much about hinduism but here in my place when a Hindu girl starts her menstrual cycle, people celebrate it as she can bring a life to this world. And I don't find anything wrong with that. Does that mean they see her as a baby maker I don't think so. Plus in the major part of this world women have been treated as a baby maker and a business, that's why I said that it's not only in Hinduism they see women for fertility and stuff
@@DanielRajan-sx3mg Okay that celebration stuff could be a regional thing. In South India, I do have heard that they celebrate it, may be North India left such celebration due to invasions which is a good reason because invaders often kidnapped the virgin women. So that's logical to say that they treated women as good fertile machine.
But I want to claim that there understanding wasn't as developed as we see it today, and they were primitive than our understanding of subject.
@@user-st2do8oo4i Does makes sense, it can be the reason. Yeah I am from Kerala and it's celebrated in here. Don't know if caste has anything to do with it.
Draupadi literally went to the Himalayas at the end of Mahabharata LOL
And died there
@@dannystark7668yeah because of sins 😂 lol and a dog was able to cross her lol
@@jen4ra-vs5og The dog was Yamma
She died because of her sin of favoring one husband over another
The dog was not Yama but Dharma, Yudhisthir's father, who was testing him
If high altitude effects women's fertility then all our women in northeastern hilly states, Himachal and kashmir would have had issues with giving birth.
FOOTBALL LEGANDS BAICHUNG BHUTIA,
SUNIL CHETTRI,AND COUNTLESS TEAKWONDO,ARCHERIES,
SPORTPERSONALITIES FROM NORTH EAST ARE HAVING "HIGHLY" LOW MALNUTRITION😂😂😂😂😂...
ONEMORE
KERALA LAND PEOPLE ARE CALLED.
"MALAYALEES"
MEANS MOUNTAIN PEOPLE 😂😂😂..
ALL SPORTSPERSON FROM KERALA ARE😂😂😂😂 WHATT??
P.T.USHA..
SHINY WILLSON,
SREESHANTH,DEEPIKA PALIKALL,
GEORGE ALL ARE MALNUTRION SPORTSPERSON😂😂😂😂😂😂
Female Sadhguru 😂
But sadhguru simply said that temple was built after death of a monk who practiced celibacy
I best she also has a science for why women should not go to school or even learn Sanskrit whose word she used.
Like also, women shouldn't even know the man she's marrying.
People please add few from you too in the replies!
Science behind dowry? Judging by the extremities they reach I don't think it would be surprising.
@@MuskanSingh-kw7ux15 dowry yes, so called gifts.
Science behind domestic violence? Well, you see, the Male chakra sometimes needs to have an influx of feminine quantum chakra, so they need to abuse their partner so that they can achieve good sperm count. And doing so will create a natural embryo inside women, so they can produce babies like a fucking factory.
Science behind female foeticide - no sinning, instant Moksha
All praises to Allah for giving me a brain to think with which is why I'm an atheist! 😛😅
😂😂😂 young blood
Ironically, when I looked up the effects of altitude on fertility, I found more articles about how it affects men than women 😂
Before Pranav comes for me: I know my google search is only anecdotal articles and not representative of the scientific consensus :P
That's due to low pressure hence less Oxygen!
But after 2-3 days, it comes back to normal! Even if you stay there!
@@rrrr3666 That's what I saw too!
Ayappa's lore has to be one of the most misogynistic in Indian myth.
Probably his crush rejected him!! 😂
@@satwikskatti oh god! 😂😂😂
What is the misogynistic thing u had identified about ayyapas lore ?
@@satwikskattiincel, huh? 😂
At least that's just a lore, we have men practicing Brahmacharya who are like women can't even come near us, not even our mothers. Because for some reason even after attaining "enlightenment" we get distracted merely by seeing women.
i Just felt like 'matlab kuch bhi'
Female ANIMALS are banned to avoid distracting male monks? Man it sounds so messed up on so many levels
Zoophile monks 😂
Shouldn't women be allowed to decide whether they care about their fertility or whatever? Or does our "culture" look at women as "fertility" objects 😅
If it would've been independence 😂 era time these people would've given reason why dalit can't enter temples too lol
😂😂
Even ayyappa won't agree with this 😂😂😂
@2:55 : so does that mean we should stop women from flying in planes too?
Dear Pranav, This is a classical example of "stockholm syndrome". Muslim women try to justify Burkha and claim it is good for them scientifically. This is really sad. Such charlatan women like in the video should be called out. Good work brother.
These few woman always have been against welfare of woman ,these woman in their bhakti don't look that what are they doing
It's ironic but in every social power structure there are a bunch of oppressed people who will systematically support the systematic oppressors and cater to their own oppression... They have succumbed to successful brainwashing by the oppressor group...
Take the example of so many indians elite class bootlicking the Britishers in colonised india
"There's evidence that Kalpana chawla lost her uterus in space". This comment was epic.
So what u wants to convey sir?
@@DevKumar-cv3yp nothing. Just saying it was a funny comment.
No women who took a flight have given birth? Flights go around 30000 ft and shabarimala is only about 4000 ft. Women even going to space now.
Also women fertility be like - aisi dangerous situation mein m pta nhi automatically agge kaise aa jata hu😂😂
Haha 😂😂😂 I laughed so hard
Nothing but it's all about how male and religion disrespect women from past and it continued in some forms. And I am shocked how a women talking about how good their restriction is. Like death is good for me. 😂
More like chicken defending kfc 😂
@@Ragdoll6 yes
there are 600,000 temples which allow women to enter but u have trouble with the one which has special beliefs , what about the temples which do not allow men ?? KAMKHYA DEVI TEMPLE , MATA TEMPLE , ATTUKAL PONGLA temple ,
in hinduism there are both male and female priests , women are literally worshipped ( I A NOT IGNORING THE FACT THAT SOCIETY INDEED HAS DISRESPECTED AND DISCRIMINATED WOMEN )
out of all the religions HINDUISM seems to be the least patriarchal ,
not a single mosque allows women to enter but noone cares , and 1 out of 600,000 temples doesnot allow women and everybody loses their shit , the hypocrisy is UNMATCHED !
Anyways this false scientific justification was bullshit , .
@@Ragdoll6I agree! Well said...
yes
Are there any female astronauts at ISS ? 😅 checking the elevation/Altitude 😂😂😂
Arey haan 😂😂😂 didnt think of that
@@dendaGulliLapochyes gulli danda bro 🎉🎉😂
yes there are female astronauts in ISS, but when they return to Earth, people call them "Bro" coz the chakra did its thing 😂😂😂
@@rdm5547 🥲🥲
She never goes to Himachal Pradesh, Nepal and Tibet
lets give her that high altitude has an adverse effect on fertility, then what if a woman is willing to put her fertility to risk for going to the temple?
You an atheist?
Do Female passengers in a plane flying over shabrimala turn into males?😂😂
When u miss the endocrine system class…😂😂
Aurat hi aurat ki dushman hai
Naa bruh, organised religion is inherently patriarchal. Anyone who is high on it will talk shiz like this. I used to believe all this too until I knew better...
Usse internalised patriarchy bolte he
@@iu9130 Internalized misogyny
Only reason is Ayyappa was Celebate.😑
No need to so much explanation.😂
If monks are supposed to be celibate, why would they even care about fertility to begin with?
Meanwhile Vaishno Devi's shrine is situated at a height of 5,200 feet above sea level and there are no restrictions to gender 😂.
Confidence toh dekho aunty ka
I think she is suffering from Acrophobia and Aerophobia.
This has nothing to do with chakras or science it is all Patriarchy and Misogyny 😅😅😅😅
PS: Trigger alert 😂😂😂
You made a perfectly illogical argument then cry about hey: trigger alert
@@anchitbose4151 🤣🤣🤣 you got triggered congratulations 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
It's NOT about gender or misogyny. You are misrepresenting the very basis of it. It's a certain tradition with proper origin and reason behind it.
@@slayer6225 🤣🤣 Reason that women can't enter because of the altitude then explain the the first woman in space 🤣 , tradition 😉 why only menstruating woman is barred from entering the Temple 🤣🤣🤣 ? You are not trying to read between the lines or are you defending the Misogyny and Patriarchy 🥲🥲🥲
@@YawningforReasondelusional take🤦
They'll say everything affects fertility except for pollution. Even if they know that pollution does that to women, they'll never take any steps to help ALL women out of the conditions where they are exposed to large amounts of pollution.
Even if we assume her "science" is true and women develop men like characteristics when they go to ayyappa... Why should they stop women who are fully aware of that effect and want that effect!.
I guess, this lady watches too much of Naruto.🙊 I dare her to make one shadow clone.😏
She's literally Talk No Jutsu-ing her way to fame
@@lasyak6355 Yeah, I wish i had that confidence.
The glory of sanatana dharmam... Follies galore
lets assume for the sake argument that " going to this places are not good for women " but even then who are u to tell them what to do with their body
its her choice
whats with these people. I dont understand 😂😂
2:59 High altitude in fact interfere with normal reproductive endocrinology. But it affects both men and women. And it’s very rare that something untoward might happen, like this “Learned” person is claiming.
@Pranav Radhakrishnan - hey someone had sent me the second video and asked me to debunk it on my channel but I forgot all about it. 😢 Thanks for debunking it bro. On the topic of Sabarimala my stance is that women should be allowed in there because that is gender equality. But on the other hand getting more women in there would be adding to the superstition and more ones for the temple. So my view is that they should be allowed but they should not go ( so should men too 😝).
Really like your content sir. Keep posting. You're one of the only voices of reason on Indian youtube. Also, I would love to see you do live streams.
So do you think hijab, burkha must be banned to put an end to patriarchy And advocate gender equality?
Hey Pranav, do her claims not come under “fear mongering” .
When she says that the girl told her to tell her story to others so others may be “saved”, they won’t have to suffer the same fate…. to an average unsuspecting person, it would feel like he/she just dodged a bullet, this is very useful information, and it’s their responsibility to protect their friends and loved ones by sharing this vital info, and then they too start forwarding and sharing such videos !
Sinu talks glibly with no evidence, sprinkling scientific terms in her misogynistic speeches
why didnt u upload yesterday?? 😒😔
Women who have gone to space, women who have climbed Mt. Everest, women who have climbed till the Alps, all have low fertility??? What about those women who live in the mountains in Kashmir, Shimla, Nepal, Bhutan, and Pakistan??
At 9:05.. the bespectagled young guy who is nodding with complete approval at Sinu Joseph's mumbo-jumbo claims is an excellent example of how bad things are.
I once went to a temple in south india. I was very much disappointed that men had to enter the temple premises topless, but not women.
As someone who believes in equality, I am disheartened by this discrimination. Men and women - all should enter the temple topless.
😢
Naughty boy😂
According to her women should not travel in aircraft 😂
In Ladakh Buddhist monks (females) go on bicycles at high altitudes and do all the work themselves, there was this documentary on CZcams. I suspect why some things are only restricted to women in some religions and when it comes to human rights why every woman wants to have them?
If you had BS as a category, you can get rid of a lot of squares.
Sir I'm extremely thankful to you and your channel. I've always felt that our India is going in wrong direction and people are supporting it in name of religion. Moreover, they're also trying to spread it across the world.
But this gives me a little hope that there are people out there who dare to question and see truth as truth and untruth as untruth.
Tqsm❤
@xen5917
“Sir I'm extremely thankful [...] and untruth as untruth. Tqsm❤”
=================
It gives you *A* little hope, not ‘little’ hope.
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist oh sorry and tq for noticing! i checked
@@xen5917
"oh sorry and tq for noticing! i checked"
========================
Thank you. 🙂
There is a small BUT IMPORTANT difference between
'little' and 'a little',
'few' and 'a few'. 🙏
@@ex.hindu.now.atheist Take the tq easy na! hahaha that was hilarious. I'll take care next time teacher ji🙏
@@xen5917
"Take the tq easy na! ha [...] I'll take care next time teacher ji"
=========================
Teaching English IS one of the things that I do for real, to keep myself busy.
🙂🙏
Very clear! Thanks
Talk to humanist Babu gogineni. He destroyed so many people on telugu tv . He is a legend . Do a 2 hr video with him about various questions
Over 500 Million people globally live at or above 1500m (~4900 ft). They reproduce just fine.
We truly live in a post-truth world
The fact that so many of them have jumped into the bandwagon of pseudoscience lately with the sole aim of buying rice (livelihood) can pose serious danger to society.
She's yapping
Women with facial hair, usually suffer from PCOD. A very common gynecological disorder in recent times because of fatty diet, lazy lifestyle, and hormonal changes. This can cause infertility. She is trying to link pcod with her pseudoscience. In reality, both male and female fertility mainly depends on the lifestyle they live in and diet which they follow. Male and female have equal chances of being infertile, but male infertility is less reported becauss they feel insecure to do so. Incase you wanna improve your sperm qualify start taking vitamins, especially vit E.
Is travelling on aircraft considered for this rule of 5000 feet?
"CHAKRAS ! " Here we go again , baby ! 🤣🤣🤣
I want to announce right now that there is no chakra that facilitates my excretory glands like she's saying. I am not a freak.
*Endocrine glands
"Chakras"
So what if the altitude affects women's fertility, your ayurveda must have a remedy to it, isn't it?
i live in nepal . here , you can see is only hill and mountain.
The simple explanation of why women of a certain age group can't go to sabarimala is because ayyappa is a Brahmachari thats it.
All of the reasons mentioned are stupid ,Sabrimala is a temple of a god who is a brahmachari hence it is not some amazing science rather just the choice of the deity
Man are u making up content for the main channel as well or no??
9:33 my exact emotions😂
Listening to the whole video carefully...and trying to convince people about the non scientific claims.... So difficult 😢
Great patience and dedication sir❤😢
What abt women who live in Himachal villages with high altitude?
Not 'making'. 'PEDDLING'. She's peddling. Like a peddler peddlin snake oil. And to the others credit they atleast provided a bottle and some oil. This one simply needs to breathe - same effect
Wtf is she talking about with such confidence
GNRH attain peak in boys at puberty.
GNRH release is related to age of an individual, it has nothing to do with altitude 😂
It take a lot of courage to speak such bullshit with confidence. We all wish we have that courage.😂😂
That means air travel is also not good for them? What happens to the females living in high altitude?
With respect to this issue, I have one thing to say. It is religious place of worship, works on belief system and if that place prescribes something for the believers, then they follow it. It is the atheists who poke into these issues. Bringing science into this is illogical. It's the home of Ayyappa. His rules, comply or don't go. Simple. There is no debate. Discrimination and other bs are cried by non believers who don't have a place to enter the temple.
Sinu has different videos, gives different "scientific" reasons for the ban....chakras, women's purity grabbing the deity's purity, rest for women....etc.etc. Pretty inventive, huh ?
The guy who named swadishtana chakra to reproductive organs : 😏😏
this kind of stupidity needs to stop, we dont need to use some made up b.s scientific reason to enforce religious traditions in a temple.temples are not public property and do not need to allow entry to everyone.the deity himself has some preferences,and if you follow and are devoted to the said god,you would respect his wishes wouldnt you ?
Theory!!!! These bullshit are not even hypothesis at all.
there is no harm in hypermasculinity just by the way😊. this woman is totally nuts!😅 Hi Pranav dada please make a detailed video on the following whatsapp forward as a reply is much needed otherwise the more the share, the more harmful it is for the society. Please read and help me out.
"Forwarded as received
*Science behind Gotra (Genetics)*
Do you know why every time you sit in a puja the priest asks you for you *Gotra* ?
What is *Gotra system?*
Why do we have this? Why do we consider this to decide marriages?
*Why should sons carry the gotra of father, why not daughter?*
*How/why does gotra of a daughter change after she gets married? What is the logic?*
*Infact this is an amazing genetic science we follow.*
Let's see the science of genetics behind gotra systems.
The word *GOTRA* formed from two sanskrit words *GAU (means cow) and Trahi (means shed)*
Gotra means cowshed.
*Gotra is like cowshed protecting a particular male lineage.*
We identify our male lineage / gotra by considering to be descendants of the *8 great Rishi (Sapta rishi + **#Bharadwaj** rishi).*
All the other gotra evolved from these only.
*Biologically, human body has 23 pairs of chromosomes (one from father and one from mother) on these 23 pairs, there is one pair called sex chromosomes which decides the gender of person.*
During conception
if the resultant cell is XX chromosomes then the child will be girl,
if it is XY then it is boy.
*In XY - X is from mother and Y is from father.*
*In this Y is unique and it doesn't mix. So in XY, Y will supress the X and son will get Y chromosomes.*
*Y is the only chromosome which gets passed down only between male lineage. (Father to Son and to Grandson).*
*Women never gets Y.*
Hence Y plays a crucial role in genetics in identifying the genealogy.
*Since women never get Y the Gotra of the woman is said to be of her husband.*
*There are 8 different Y chromosomes from 8 Rishis.*
If we are from Same Gotra then it means we are from same root ancestor.
*Marriages between same Gotra will increase the risk of causing genetic disorders as same Gotra Y chromosomes cannot have crossover and it will activate the defective cells.*
If this continues, it will reduce the size and strength of Y chromosome which is crucial for the creation of male.
*If no Y chromosome is present in this world, then it will cause males to become extinct.*
*So Gotra system is a method to avoid genetic disorders and attempt to protect Y chromosome.*
*Amazing bio-science by our Maharishis. Our Heritage is unarguably THE GREATEST.*
_They had the "Gene mapping" sorted out thousands of years ago._"
if two persons are too much in love but same gotra and want to marry they can marry, just avoid children birth or take risk and have children or go to laboratory and have child with minimum risk of genetic disorders. The BEST way to minimize genetic defects is to marry out of gotra /caste/religion/country for thousands of years but no ancient indian which come to claim gene mapping done that. 7 gotra on basis of saptarishi because only males have Y chromosome which is unique way to identify lineage is FALSE. if i trace back my dna on basis of Y chromosome only , I will know my father ,grand father and so on but no infomation about mother , grand mother etc.
if we say one rishi has one girl A and boy B and another one has a boyC and girl D , now A married C and child is AC , B married D and child is BD , gotra of BD and AC is different so they marry according to gotra system ?? NO NEVER they are cousins in first generation.
genetic disorders caused due to common genetic pattern in chromosomes of both mother and father of a baby are reason not only father or only Y chromosome .we have 23 pairs of chromosome out of which 22 pairs called autosomes and last pair is sex chromosomes ,if it is XX then i will be born as female if XY then i will be male , in some exception there are more or less chromosme number
than 46. In gene mapping there are two types of genes one dominant and other recessive, for example when intercourse occured between my parents a ovum containing 22 autosome and X waiting for sperm with 22 autosome with X or Y , our father decide our sex . let us say sperm with Y chromosome fused with ovum then next story be like - there are 22 autosomes from father +Y and 22 autosome from mother+x, and one of there chromosome has genetic pattern for my height , my father is 6feet but his 23 chromosomes have both tall(dominant gene) dwarf/short(recessive gene) similarly my mother is 5 feet but her 23 chromosomes have both tall(dominant gene) dwarf/short(recessive gene) , to decide my height if Tall gene matched with Tall/dwarf my height will be more when i grow but if both dwarf gene matched then my height will be shorter , it is possible that mother was black father was black but child is white because white gene in child is activated when both genes of white in parents that were recessive now combined . you cannot say that white chromosome will extinct if all black people marry each other only, even if same gotra people marry you can not say that Y chromosome will extinct and no male will be born in future and we need to preserve it.there is always 50% chance that child will be girl or boy , neither man nor woman will extinct genetically due to this without intervention like embryo killing by artificial means.
let us say your father's lineage has recessive gene of cancer and you marry your wife from another gotra and she has cancer but not yet known , your child has high chances if cancer now not only beacuse of your wife's cancer but also your father's lineage which always contain cancer gene but inactive. instead of your wife which have cancer , you marry your sister(no offence) then there is high chances of cancer to child because both parents have same gotra and cancer gene. no one can identify gotra or cancer gene with Y chromosome that is unscientific, may be mothers gene contain cancer gene.
Dope
I think it will be more appropriate to approach it as it is a temple dedicated to brahmacharis
I would say, if you believe in religions and all its principles shouldn't you abide by whatever rules they give and not question it? I mean the questioning is only till their comfort zone. 😂
Well said bro..one can see 100 of Mariappan,murugan temple,all women are going,it's a normal civil life there..Ayyappa temple is just a religious marketing...
Tirupati Balaji temple is there actually it's in mountain forest only..sophisticated pilgrim centre..
THERE IS ONE VELLIANGIRI SHIVA TEMPLE DEEP INSIDE FOREST,7 MOUNTAINS ONE HAS TO TRAVEL, EILD FOREST ,ALL WOMEN,MEN KIDS, WD FAMILY AND FRIENDS,,OFCOURSE SEASONAL ONKY..
NO RESTRICTION..😂😂😂
What about plenty of women mountaineers climbing the Everest or other very high altitude mountains each year successfully?? All of them are infertile now? 😅😅
What about even a minority of population of human & non human animals permanently inhabiting in high altitude mountains area for years? Are women not breeding there? 😅😅😅 Then how the next generations are coming into existence?😅😅
And wtf in some places she mentioned even female animals aren't allowed to enter? So if a male monk can not control himself on his celibacy regarding a female sheep or deer or bird etc ....then definitely he can't be trusted with being female humans 😅😅😅.. and i shall argue he is actually an incel??😂😂😂🤷🏻♀️🤣
Human bones have been found on hills that are millions of years old. If women's fertility was affected due to altitude or weather similar to high altitude places, humans would be close to extinction by now.
Anybody can go to sabrimala but they have to keep 41 days fast otherwise there is no point
It is simply a worship tradition involving inter se prescribed rules of physical austerity over a length of time, which women of menstruating age cannot fulfill. That is belief based. Female devotees of other ages do go there. Science and rationality are not part of it. Those adhering to science and rationality cannot adjudge a matter of faith. The worship mode, tradition and belief about the deity's wishes held on to by millions of devotees including women take precedence over the judgement of the rationalists. That is all there is to this issue.