When To Walk Away From A Porsche 911
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 08. 2024
- Josh takes a 1999 Porsche 911 to IMA Motorwerke for pre-purchase inspection and learns a thing or two about the process and what to look for in a used Porsche 996. Will RFD have a new project car? Find out here: www.rightfootdown.com/car-spot...
WARNING: Spoiler Below:
Repair list:
1. Passenger Seat Belt Receptacle
2. Oxygen Sensor
3. Ignition assembly
4. Front dampers
5. Rear sway bar bushing
6. RMS / IMS - Auta a dopravní prostředky
The mechanic in this video patiently and clearly gives so much information and advice.
That's one good mechanic.
That mechanic was great. Learned a bunch of things I didn’t usually look for when analyzing a car
I like that the tech locked that shifter linkage in properly even though its just an inspection. I couldn't in good conscious let a car drive away with something like that waiting to put the occupants at risk. That's a good tech right there.
Straight forward presentation. No cheesy music, intros or predictable cringe-worthy humor.
diablo3724 exactly. I'm starting to hate these youtube TV car shows.
I nearly dropped my ipad at the price. Wow. Also, this guy can check my cars anytime he wants. I have never, ever, seen a "mechanic" so clear, thorough and professional.
Good advice, and a pleasure to watch a technician who knows what he is doing.
+Hopelessand Forlorn where was his German accent??? LOL I didn't expect ole Bubba to be doing the work.
knows about what he reads online and as a mechanic. But he's no Porsche mechanic for sure
Joe Joe
Hopefully you're not referring to Porsche dealers - they are by far the worst place to get an old Porsche serviced. Find an independent Porsche mechanic who races their personal 911's on the weekends (not hard to find) and you'll get the work done for half the price + the empathy that no Porsche dealer mechanic will ever have. The dealer-serviced value boost, if it even exists, is more than made up for by the money you save on repairs. The dealer will flat-out lie and RAPE you on parts and labor.
Source: owned two Porsches and wifey runs a Porsche shop. She gets dealer victims every. single. day. Horror stories - as in $3k estimates that turn out to be $100.
knows what?? have a lot of money , to have a big shop and expensive equipment doesnt give the right to say ,this dude is NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOT better than others... diagnostics is 1 thing and have money to buy everything its other
John Davis - Dang that is sad as hell to hear.
This is the best guide I've ever seen to buy an old Porsche........mechanic knows he's stuff👍
Not even just for a Porsche, but this is a great tool and reference to any car when buying. Thanks for the upload, very informative.
Love the video, I don't think most people understand the fact that a lot of mechanics wouldn't let you film them while they work, let alone explain everything they're doing and looking for. I would love to see a more detailed breakdown of that $5k repair bill (I know it lists the specific problem areas in the description, but there's no cost next to each item), as well as the cost of the inspection itself. Keep up the great content!
actually thank you for this Video , i am currently in training to be a mechanic in germany, after watching quite some car Videos daily, from lots of american shops, and so on, after seeing this, this is the first out of id almost say hundreds of Videos , i saw that a shop actually does their inspection very detailed, i have Seen shops where they just look for oil leaks and thats it, they say everything else wont break :( , Good to See there are still professionals working in garages across the US
Go to 2:47 I would shy away from this car because there is no engine under the hood. Just a spare tire and a bottle of wiper fluid.
+hyzercreek Yup, one of the many reasons to avoid 911s altogether.
chuckle
Elon Musk drive.. quite advanced..
I guess you didn't see that pesky flat six motor tucked in the back behind the rear wheels.
parteibonza
Yeah, just a glorified VW bug engine
You’ll want to go see this mechanic. He's a good man, and thorough.
I would like to thank you for posting this video. Very informative and the best is that you documented the whole process unlike other youtubers that only give their comments
Brilliant video! Well shot, good audio and followed the mechanic as he showed everything. Well done!
Being an air-cooled bug fan for many years... this was quite a change of scenery :Oo Wow, worlds collide.. GR8T information. Thanks for posting.
It's good to see an automotive technician at the top of his game. This dude has the knowledge experience and equipment to get the job done. I'm a form of diesel tech with 30 years experience. If I found a shop like this I would still be turning wrenches. Sad to say this is the exception rather than the rule. Either way mad props to the tech, you did a good job buddy.
nice video, basically this inspection works out for most cars
That's a great car. I had the 1998 Porsche 911 Carrera and it was a great car. It sat for several years and a random engine problem occured with no Engine Warning Light coming on which was a weird fault Porsche said. Totaled at 39,000 miles...
This mechanic's awesome. Knows his stuff, patient, explains stuff properly.
Neat video! I've heard a few things about the 996 and what to watch for. Glad to see a video that covers it.
Well done. This is why using an expert that services these cars every day and has seen the things that are not obvious but can be expensive. Pay the man. He saved you much more than he charged.
Todd Sadler That is the unvarnished truth. On the other hand, the Mercedes I have owned have been relatively inexpensive to own. True parts were not cheap, but they rarely needed anything.
Guy is not a joke, this is IMA Motorsports or IMA Motorwerke. They did my 911 Turbo and know what they're doing. Talk to Ivan.
What a tremendously useful video. Miles better than the vast majority of internet 911 advice, largely because its based on facts and a great deal of experience.
This was the best You Tube video I have ever see. Nice photo work, nice editing and great subject matter even if I never want to own a Porsche. Thank You
The IMS was the only thing that scared me away, everything else on that car was a piece of cake. The IMS scared me so bad that I went Turbo to avoid it ;)
That’s valid. So there are ways to know if the car has the IMS problem. For the 996s is simply to ask if the IMS bearing was done. If not, then any prospective buyer should account in the purchase price the $2.5k cost of replacement. Then you have a real sport car to drive. I can tell you that for me there is nothing (in this price range) that give you this driver’s experience.
@@nelran2009 I have a higher mileage 01 996 at 80,000miles without IMS done. Ims literally affects like 8% of the vehicles and usually shows up on garage queen low mileage cars that aren't driven much. My car has been driven every year since 01 and I'm not worried about ims at all. I'll probably have it inspected when it needs a clutch but not worrying about it till then.
That was very interesting and informative. That gentleman with the handy flashlight knows his stuff! Thanks for the video.
Every word spoken in this video glitters with gold that is the value of such information. Thank you for sharing!
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you for putting the time in to make this informative video....
This tech is thorough. Master at work
$5000 is a huge exaggeration. Replaced the shocks on both the hood and the trunk recently on ours and replacing an o2 sensor and some sway bar links is easy enough. All parts can be found online dirty cheap. And a rear main seal leak is usually caused by the car sitting for a while and some driving around stops it. Did with ours anyway. For the year, that car was in really good condition.
FreeSpirits hes going by prices he would charge avreage dummy...yea parts zims..parts haven...racers net would be chump change not what he is quoting everything else is standard maintenxe
That's why the owner didn't budge on his price...
This vehicle not being a turbo is subject to IMS bearing failure. The oil leak is indicative of this possibility. More investigation into any metal debris in the oil should be tested. Dissecting the oil filter for metal debris is imperative. Since this vehicle was born, there has been two upgrades for the IMS replacement. To repair an IMS requires removing the engine. Not cheap. to do this work, consideration to which model of 911, miles, desirability for the vehicle has to be considered. For sure, an IMS bearing that goes bad will destroy the entire engine. Do not roll the dice that this will not happen. It will. Bottom line is to have a trusted tech provide answers.
@@scdevon Leaking seal is the clue that the IMS bearing has not been replaced. The leak itself isn't s big deal. The IMS bearing is. When it fails, it takes out the engine.
FreeSpirits more like 12008
Thank you SO very much for doing this. These are not the type of cars that many of us know well but want so this is really valuable info!
great informative video on 911; i wish i had a mechanic like that local to me in Australia; he really knows his stuff
I'm sure someone got a good deal buying that. Repairs were minor.
Yep. 5000$?? Wat?
The gearbox/tranny has to be dropped out to replace the seal that's why it was quoted $5000. The rest of the repairs were minor
Cajun9000 I had three 996's. Two had rear main seal issues multiple times which eventually resulted in engine replacements in order to resolve the problem. That's why it isn't a minor issue, it's a sign of a screwed up block. It was redesigned and fixed for the 997. (This doesn't apply to the GT3 or turbo cars which still used the block from the 993.)
Anyone looking to buy a 1997 Porsche 911 Red with Black interior, about 52,000 original miles, garage kept. Has been off the road for two years. Faster than hell.
Great video, very informative!
Excellent video and how to inspect most cars in general. Great work!
Thanks for a very informative video. I want to get a P car and this has convinced me to get a PPI from a Porsche expert as opposed to doing it myself with most cars I buy.
unless there was a lot done on that PPI we didn't see that was a terrible PPi and was not thorough at all. I would have been livid if I had paid for that PPI that could have been done at home .. how about using that fancy camera to check for cylinder scoring as it is quickly becoming the biggest 996/7 issue. how about checking for intermix in the coolant, or even a compression check or leakdown. There is no way that was 5K work of work in what he pointed out. did he even pull out the dipstick to look for frothing or emulsion ?
That guy really knows his stuff.
Wow! That was a very good video! Thanks for all of the great information.
Excellent use of my time ahead of purchasing. Thank you for such a great video
Great video !!
The only really big showstopper might be the leaking oilseal, all the other stuff is a bit of bushings, some bumpstops and getting rid of a few non major error codes which is perfectly normal for a 16 year old car...
+Rick te Kronnie Except that leaking seal will probably lead to a bad clutch, and as I recall that intermediate shaft problem can lead to catastrophic engine failure (as in time to buy a new engine). A seal you might let go for a while and plan on replacing the clutch at the same time but that bearing is bad news and needs to be taken care of right away.
+Jeff DeWitt you're probably right that all that could happen.
And they could smash it into a tree driving it home, which would cost a lot more than $5k to fix.
touristguy87 Yes... but a catastrophic engine failure from a failed intermediate shaft bearing is a lot more likely.
Jeff DeWitt ....sure, it's probably going to happen tomorrow.
@@JeffDeWitt About 4% of 996`s were affected by IMS failure as it turned out, so its certainly not universal by any measure. Bore scoring would probably be more of a possible issue.
The technician is good and obviously knows what he is doing. Very professional. The shop owner should be proud this man is working for them.
Well done and the shop appears to know what they're doing very informative for my purchase.
Great video. Very informative/knowledgeable mechanic. I'd hang on to him:)
My apologies in advance if I did not get the content of the video properly but I own 911's and $5k in repairs for a 15+ year old 911? It's absolutely nothing. I read also your post on rightfootdown site. On a Porsche when you replace the clutch you don't replace just the clutch alone but you need to replace the entire set. $20k in total for a good 911 is really a great price in my experience but running costs are just high, like for any 911 out of warranty.
+turbophileas My thoughts were similar. Yes, we all want the 15K enthusiast owned car, but in reality unless you buy from a friend of a desperate seller it isn't very likely.
Excellent video, very informative. Thank you.
Good to know about IMA Autoworke! I'm in in the DMV area and I'll keep them in mind for a PPI, once I track down a 997.2! Can't imagine that mechanic is still there, but he seemed quite knowledgeable!
Pre-purchase inspections are vital with high-end cars. The mechanic doubling the inspection seemed very thorough. Great video.
very proof. inspection- how much does a PPI LIKE THAT COST?
Just bought my Porsche in the Chesterfield area of Va! Been a good car to me sorta so far but have another vehicle just in case. Great video.
Very informative. Excellent tips on maintenance too. Thank you !
5 grand? Was that for something not shown? Looked like it was in great condition.
IMS is 2k+ alone
Car Geeks Anonymous Yeah this seems like basic maintenance
RMS Leak is big labour... and ims is another 1100 if it needs it.
Probably worth going to a specialist who knows you can only read the data from Range 1 and 2 on 996s......
Amen. Was going to say the same.
Very impressed with this technician. For those who think his repair estimate is out of range:
1. He is pricing it at the Dealership
2. Has everyone forgotten the Rear Main Seal and the IMS?? Those are price repairs, clearly!
Excellent and truly useful video, nice summary at end!
I was really surprised for a 996 PPI that he didn't change the oil filter and cut it open for inspection. You don't have to change the oil, just the filter. Debris in the filter tells me way more about the engine condition than a visual inspection of the outside. To me this is just standard practice for a PPI on a 996 engine.
+Mark H good tip!
The 996 does not log overrevs in more than 2 ranges. Only the from the 997 on they increased the number of ranges. On the 996 overrevs in range 2 are considered bad. Back in the day this would have disqualified the car from being eligible for Porsche's used car warranty.
+jamessmithe Is this car manual? Does that mean that the driver accidentally downshifted way to low a gear and forced the engine speed past it's rev limit, like say you are in 5th gear doing 60 mph and you accidentally select 1st gear and dropped the clutch?
+SI0AX Exactly, this is basically the only way to get overrevs in range 2 on a 996. Automatics are virtually immune from that as the ecu would not let the car downshift at revs that are too high. Just running into the limiter will produce overrevs in range 1 and is considered no issue
@@jamessmithe You would have thought that Porsche could have fitted a rev limiter to that car, but maybe that tech had not arrived yet ???
As the old saying goes, "There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche".
After 12 years of owning a 1988 Porsche 928 S4, I can attest that saying is absolutely true!
Nice! Several years of well maintained Boxsters aren’t too bad, usually very affordable (compared to just about every other Porsche). Sport brakes, clutches, and rubber are the major expenses (especially if you aren’t doing them yourself). And of course... the itch most of us have to upgrade everything. Love the late 928, especially a manual S4 (or ultra rare GTS).
Well to be fair to yourself you bought a very expensive model to care for. Such a gorgeous model the 928 but they are getting so rare in good condition. Keep it up . Those are a real treasure if you ask me.
That was a great video. Very informative. Hope you find a great deal.
In addition to worrying about the IMS bearing, you want those coolant pipe fittings pinned so you don't get a pop-out. If you don't have that done, here is a video on how to do it. ;) czcams.com/video/1UGLVJdHM28/video.html
The type of negotiation that usually goes down with specialty vehicles, especially when they're in the exact color combination and with the exact options you desire, begs a slightly different approach in most cases... For example, seller asking $20k, PPI uncovers $5k worth of potential repairs (good PPIs nitpick, which can be a great bargaining tool, but there are things that might not be critical to a car's longevity), seller only willing to go down a couple of grand... At this point, you need to ask yourself.. How much do you really want the car AND can you afford the overage and its continued ownership...? Cars like this aren't purchased to haul the family around... They're usually emotional purchases. And, if you're a true enthusiast, there is always opportunity to nurse the right car (for you) back into health and its former glory.
This playing field isn't for everyone.
For these types of cars unless the owner can do some work on them, they are a complete moneypit. I have saved a ton of money doing maintenance both preventative and repairs myself.
This is why I love CZcams...Very informative $$$ saving advice. I'm going to buy a 2008 Cayenne S so I'll be looking for info on it.
i love this kind of repair shop... this is extremely hard to find
i have so much respect for honest people... don't care who you are and where you from
salute sir!
Im still waiting to see what the fail point in the inspection was.. I mean shocks go bad, that small oil leak on the rear main might have been an issue if it was a major leak, but I drive cars that leak a bit of oil from time to time and just make sure to keep up on oil level checks..
Good subject / info, please keep-up the good work. You guys/gals selected IMA Motorwerke as a shop, I would like to know why IMA vs other Porsche shops in the DMV area? Thank you in advance.
+BrainDesmo Thanks. We chose IMA dude to location and recommendation from other local Porsche owners.
+Right Foot Down Thanks for the reply. Noted. They seem to be a detailed shop.
Thank You for posting that. Very helpful and appreciated:)
thanks for this useful and informative review. the other thing I would check would be the seat belt adjusters. they are quite flimsy.
good job.
Good mechanic explains well. I liked this a lot.
+minimalistinlife He likes you a lot too. Or would be customers.. I mean come on, these cars are used. Who would pay 996 money for a car then keep it in 100% perfect condition? No car is perfect and if it is, it wouldn't be in his budget anyway.
+MagicAyrtonforever I do
Andy Dickens Good, so you're going to sell your 996 for peanuts then?
Too bad seller wouldn’t budge on price. Any 996 without the IMS repair already done needs to be cheap or walk away.
The ims repair isn't required if the car is taken care of and driven then the ins will be fine.
Wow thanks! Very comprehensive consumer advice for these under-rated cars.
Impressively thorough & knowlegable technician.
I think the scope he used to look at the air filter was worth more than my entire car
Roland Anderson bore scopes aren't that bad. worth having in the tool box. u might be surprised what u can get one for
Fair enough - just never seen that many gadgets in one garage, guess it makes sense though considering the cost of every car he had in there.
Roland Anderson I bought a boroscope for construction but now I use it for cars and everything,them diagnostic scan tool,paint depth guage etc etc but I think if you get them one at a time you'd be suprised how little you can get some for,not all but some
Roland Anderson it
They have very basic ones now that you can connect to your smartphone for REALLY cheap.
Good video
Great video and some really useful info. Thanks
Thanks for this video. Have just started to look at 996/997s maybe next summer and wondered where I could get an inspection like this done. Turns out, they are only 30 minutes away! Thanks!
Good luck!
That mechanic knew his stuff! I'm sure you can still drive it as is for a while not big issues. Nothing major was wrong but you never mentioned miles. How many miles on this 99? I can't believe my e36 m3 is the same year is that! 996 is timeless design
+ihsnshaik I agree. The 996 is really coming into its own as a classic design. I loved them from new, so I'm not too surprised they are getting a following.
This guy is GOOD!!!!!! Wish he was in my area.....
Useful, Thank you. Saw a couple of new things I can check on my car. The rear brake cable and the brake fluid tester, I'm gonna get one of those right now on eBay :)
Great review I learnt a few things from it. thanks
5000 is way over exaggerated. I know for a fact an o2 sensor $30.00x2, Poly bushing for the sway bar = $79.99. Some rear main seals leak from just sitting so it's not like it was banged on. The clip I know is a mere $10.00. Im going to add shocks and struts for all four sides including bumpstops. These were the honda civics of Porsche. It's not a GT3. I have worked on several of these in my time
Guy is a joke, car was in amazing condition. All those little things are normal for used car and not expensive to fix. I would be pisses If I was a seller.
Oh ok, I wasn't talking amack or anything I was just like "WTF" lol
He did say the IMS seal or the rear main seal were leaking. That's not a cheap or easy job.
WHAT i JUST SPENT $300 FOR FOUR SHOCKS AND INSTALLED THEM MY SELF
Those $100 shocks will feel like shit as budget shocks are $25 each.
and Whom ever would put cheap and nasty in a sports car deserves to have their hands cut off so they dont ever drive said sports car or any other car
Never cheap out on suspension, brakes or tires, use mineral oil in the engine, transmission
How much did the inspection alone run you?
I use IMA to work on my car. The shop and its owner (Ivan) are great to deal with. They are located in Chantilly VA, suburbs of DC.
Thank You > Thorough & very informative!!
Thank you for taking the time. Great insight! What does a PPI cost?
couple hundred bucks
Thank you!
The dude's thorough. I'd take his advice on automotive matters.
You would be the guy I go to next time Im selling the Brooklyn Bridge.
That is insane. I would never have thought a computer in a car holds historical info. And the leaves. Well, thanks man, I have a 2013 BOSS and I am going to give it a good look tomorrow even though I rarely drive it
He knows a Porsche inside and out that's for sure you did a great inspection as far as I can tell.
ALWAYS have an inspection done. On any vehicle.
when I walk away: after reading the sticker price in the window lol
Fascinating clip. Walnut Creek Porsche rep said she knew my prospective purchase well and it was perfect. $45,000 to Pittsburg Chevy dealor and it was mine. $5,000. to Reno Porsche dealer and it was finally perfect.
I have a 150 mile round trip commute on the twisties of central KY. I wanted something that got pretty good mileage and would be fun to drive. The car I chose back in summer of 2013 now has 140k miles on it. The only thing I've done to it is change the oil, and replace the spark plugs at 134k miles (and it made no difference in gas mileage nor performance). It gets about 31 mpg and has a six speed manual. Because I corner pretty hard it's been through 7 sets of tires, my favorite being the Michelin PSS's.
The only maintenance issue has been having to come up with my own rock solid water seal for the tail lights.
I absolutely love this car and it has been a blast these 5 years. It's a Scion FR-S.
Damn, wish I had watched this 6 weeks ago..,,,,
Forget the Porsche but keep the mechanic!
FreedomForce100 was thinking the same.
FreedomForce100 was thinking the same.
no homo
Im sure on camera and off camera is a whole different ball game.
@Mike Elmezian don't you mean "too much money"
Awesome, short, informative video! We just picked up a 996 which we KNOW has IMS failure, but we couldn't beat the price, and the wheels on the car have already ended up being worth more than we paid, so it looks like a good buy right now!
honeynut_ichiro you bought a 996 because it's ugly and no one wants one since most people lease cars. thats why the price was low enough for a middle class person like you to get one.
Frank Assnot whats wrong with that? it's a good deal on the car for how it drives and it's still easily worth $15-17k in my region on craigslist alone. No need to be an elitist about it.
awesome video!
Where in Virginia are you located? That yellow and blue carerra looks like one I've seen at a VA meet near me
+AJHedges I'm sure it's the same car. We've got writers throughout NOVA, 1 in Bull Run and the others in Arlington and Alexandria.
Oh sweet, thanks for answering
should have known DMV. I love it, so much money in this area
#RVA
Chantilly
Wouldn't cracking the oil filter to check for shavings been an important step considering the IMS possible issue?
+ben8jam As I understand it with IMS failure it is either failed or not - ie if it fails you are out an engine. If it hasn't failed, but maybe failing, you are fine, but it should be replaced.
Excellent video. Thanks!
Excellent information in this video!!!
Opt for a turbo and you don't have to worry about the IMS.
+Michael Graham And double the price
Yeah, just the cams spinning