Obi Wan Tells Luke Anakins History (Flashbacks)
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 03. 2010
- Ben Kenobi tells Luke about his father Anakin Skywalker (Darth Vader) with flashbacks.
The Piano Song: • A sad piano song
I have followed the copyright law correctly, its non-profit and the songs are credited." or "Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
I have a good faith belief that the material was disabled as a result of a mistake or misidentification, and that I am not intentionally abusing this dispute process. - Zábava
When I get kids, I will show them Star Wars, like my father before me
Show them machete order.
+Mollendokter boer salty
So be it. Peter. If you will not show the prequels first. You will be destroyed. Young fool, only now at the end, do you appreciate Jar Jar.
+ojideagu Darth jar jar is the best sith lord ever dude...
+Peter Tran Ha actually I agree, that would have been an awesome idea, and he seems scary as fuck. The perfect Usual Suspects deception. Although Palpatine did kind of fill that role for the first 2 movies.
Luke: "I can't kill my own father."
Kylo: "Hold my beer."
but he can try to kill his nephew that makes a lot of sense
"Hold my blue tiddy milk"
@@t3jf Luke could sense some good in Vader during their fight on Cloud City when he looked inside Ben Solo, he saw something far more Sinister that was worse than what Vader was. Given the history of the Skywalkers I don't blame Luke for acting on instinct there...
Well JJ Abrams did describe him as the anti Luke Skywalker
Actually kylo couldn’t kill Han so he asl Han to help
Obi Wan : That is the reason why your sister remains safely anonymous.
Luke : ...Leia. Leia is my sister.
Obi Wan's inner thoughts : FUCK!
MickMaan
Luke: OH GOD!!!!!!! I KISSED HER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Well it can't be worst
Kyle Shea well technically it was her that kissed him... ha ha
Fuckk ypu
+Jay Mills true she did kiss luke....to prove a point to Han........ but neither new the truth about each other... at that time. but It must have been shocking for luke to find the crush he had on her that she was his sister..... a bit unnerveing I would have to say.
I love how obi wan tries to keep Luke's sister a secret but he realizes immediately that it's leia
Jonathan Amalidosan he searched his feelings.
Jonathan Amalidosan He searched them like Google
Jonathan Amalidosan 😂
Well there are only 3 women in the whole trilogy so it’s kinda easy to narrow it down
He didn't try to keep it secret he wanted him to know
"I can't kill my own father"
I can attempt to murder my own nephew in his sleep though.
Makes me wonder if the writers of The Last Jedi even watched the original trilogy. Luke was so out of characteristic that film. If you watched How the Last Jedi Should’ve Ended on CZcams. You’ll probably get s better Star Wars vibe from that than the actual film.
Yeah did kylo ren kills his father and try to blow up his mother
@@Christopher_Woods Did you? He almost killed Vader when but decided to turn back at the last moment. He did exactly the same thing in TLJ flashbacks. Only this time...it was too late. Kylo Ren was already made.
I didn’t get it at first
@@nathanharris6450 yeah im sure evil cloned Luuke Skywalker is so much better and no that isn't a misspelling. And that one time the gang talked to a trans-dimensional blob from a universe parallel to the galaxy and Luke was dying or whatever. A lot of legends is fucking stupid and doesn't make any sense and half the time they contradict each other.
You really can't be mad at Obi Wan for not revealing the complicated truth to Luke early on, when his father Vader played a huge part in killing the Jedi off, also killing Luke's mother Padme, the younglings, etc. If Obi Wan never hid Luke and Leia away from the Empire, there wouldn't be a SW saga. After Anakin turns evil, Obi Wan basically becomes the godfather of the Skywalker twins, watching over them from a distance. That shows that he truly cared about Anakin all along, who was like his younger brother all that time.
+SwaggerLikeUz He encouraged Luke to kill Vader, he wasn't able to feel that there was still good in him
+Rosita Mariposita and killed his mom
+matthew trikha actually anakin didnt kill padme child birth did ana kin only hurt her a bit knocking her out.
+devon brown she died. Because she lost the will to leave because her heart was broken because anakin was evil she even said "you're breaking my heart" so I think he did in a way
old
Luke: "i cant kill my own father"
Kylo ren:"you can if you go emo"
Ben solo*
x__x
+PrincessDiamond12 MSP Kylo Ben*
lol
+Sting-Ray Studios long hair=emo
K
Luke, did I ever tell you about the high ground? I used it to dismember your father and watched as his disfigured body slowly sunk into a lava river, searing the flesh from his bones. He was a good friend.
+kris tindell LOL!
How does leaving him in lava indicate that Anikan wasn't still a good friend to him? I know you're joking but it doesn't make sense
+Joshua Willis (Yea it was a joke) I read your comment a couple of times and it's unintentionally really funny lol.
+kris tindell lmao;p
Stop copying people's comments.
Luke reminds me of Padme. Although only movies and make believe, I am sure Padme was proud of Luke for also seeing and knowing there was still good in him.
Elizabeth Schiada I think it's safe to say that Luke took after his mother than his father.
Haha, she died because she was sad
Saw on another video someone comment that Luke's personality is more like Padme while Leia's is like Anakin. So while Leia is a strong female leader like her mother she's easily agitated and quick with sarcastic comments like her father. And while Luke is a strong Jedi like his father he is is calm and caring and at least in the OT positive and a bit of an idealist like his mother. I like the subtle parallels.
@@bond007osu Actually Luke has Anakin's anger but still good in him and very strong about it like him Padme.
Toby Thurlow White anakin broke her heart.
At the end of the day Qui Gon was right Anakin Ultimately defeated the emperor.
this aged poorly
Psionic How so, no canon piece of Star Wars media had contradicted that.
@@ABCodeX Episode 9: Am I a joke to you?
MrUltimatum 11 Yes
MrUltimatum 11 what’s episode 9?
Obi wan is so old that he thinks in black and white
Kenobi:Your Father Wanted You To Have This,I Stole It From His Dismembered,Burning Body,Oh And He Also Killed Dozens Of Children With It.
+Darkstar1399 But He REALLY Wanted You To Have This!
+TheGeno8765 lol
+Darkstar1399 Had he not fallen to darkness he probably would have
from a certain point of view
+Darkstar1399 , Ben should have said this to Luke:. "He Also Killed Dozens Of Children" but you go ahead and believe your father who you don't know at all is a good person.
if he was such a good person he wouldn't have fallen to the darkside of the Force and killed Jedi's and Children. along with anyone else who got in his way. including your mother who he choke forced and left for dead....... Give Luke the stone cold truth.
Obi Wan in Episode 3: "I can't kill him. He's like my brother!"
Luke: "I can't kill my own father!"
To be fair, neither of them did.
@@TheOtherNeutrino Obiwan thought he did though, I mean, he left him with no legs and on fire next to a river of lava on an uninhabited planet.
@@SteveLeser An uninhabited planet that was only used for mining/smelting no less.
@@SteveLeser well Vader should have died because no normal person can survive having his limbs chopped off and being burned alive but for vader,it was his hatred and the dark side inside him was what kept him alive and it happened to maul as well because maul survived after being cut in half due to his hatred towards obi wan
@@SteveLeser He left him for dead and didn't confirm the kill because he couldn't bear to watch, or finish him off. He found out within the next ten years (as of the current Kenobi series) that Vader was not dead, so by the time this happens in the original trilogy, Obi-Wan had known for a long time, since Leia and Luke were still around 10, that he did not kill him on Mustafar. Obi-Wan reached out and reached out and begged him on Mustafar and it was just not enough to make Anakin see that what he was doing was wrong. In the end, the only thing that could save him was his love for Padme, and the children that it brought into the galaxy. Luke truly inherited her personality, he never gave up on him even after their first duel. I think Vader saw Padme in him, and it truly brought Anakin back. If you ask me, it was just as much Padme as it was Luke that brought him back to the light.
"You were our only hope....because even though I was only in my late-30's at the time, had handily defeated Vader at the very peak of his powers and he was subsequently reduced to a lumbering brute dependent on a life support suit just to stay alive, I just couldn't bring myself to do my own dirty work. So instead I kept you hidden for two decades and then misled you about Vader because tricking his own son into committing patricide just somehow seemed less painful than killing my old friend and student myself."
"As for your sister, well, she was a *girl*, and a princess, despite the fact that she was a secret rebel since her mid-teens and would have probably been easier to train. It just seemed preferable to keep her as a safely anonymous backup in case you screwed up. Oh, and while I can chime in from the afterlife whenever I think it's necessary, I didn't feel I had to when you two got to first base. What can I say? We old school Jedi were raised in what amounted to a giant monastery. Our attitude towards sexual morality is understandably messed up. But rest assured, I would have never allowed things to progress to the point where you would have married her. Oh, did Yoda not mention that Jedi aren't allowed to get married? Surprise!"
Hilarious! Made my day.
John Doe
Thanks! :-)
+Daniel S do quigon now hahahah
"Remember, concentrate on the moment. Feel, don't think. Trust your instincts....Now, just to clarify, when I say: "feel, don't think", that means feel the *Force* and don't overthink things. It does *not* mean to follow *any* random impulse that enters that empty little head of yours! Because if you do you'll be more dangerous than an army of drunken frat boys with stun rifles at Spring Break on Zeltros!
Likewise, when I say: "trust your instincts", I am again referring to the instinctive guidance that you receive through the Force. The instincts that allowed you to pod race when no other human could. *Not* your instinct to bone smoking hot politicians, no matter how much of a tease they are when it comes to their wardrobe and playing hard to get even when they're shamelessly flirting with you. That's bad, and could lead to you violating the Jedi code and marrying in your late-teens like the Outer Rim hick you are!
By choosing the life of the Jedi, a hard life, literally, you're not allowed to marry or fall in love. Although some strange bearded guy who I *think* was the creator of the Jedi Order *did* say that we can have casual sex so long as there is no emotional attachment. No, you don't need to back away. That's what I keep Obi-Wan around for. *You* should watch out for aged ephebophiles who invite you to the Mon Calamari water ballet and want to sit alone with you. I just have a sense that may be a problem you'll run into...
Now get that sulky look off of your face before it gets practically seared on there and somebody ends up shoving a mask over it so that they don't have to look at it anymore!"
Because Obi Wan could have thought he was dead or would have died from his wounds. It was Luke Skywalker's destiny and was most likely better suited for the training(then there is the age to consider). "Tricking"...............no, Luke was the only one strong enough. If you are going to try to point out errors.........just don't.
Well Yoda failed in his training of Count Dooku.
Well dooku was played by Christopher lee so obviously he was going to be evil
Yeah, yoda fail.
Actually, I think the reason dooku turned to the dark side was because qui gon jin died.
+Ty Jumawan-Raguirag You're right! Qui Gon's death was large part of the reason Dooku turned dark
+Owen Dayton wasnt it qui gon dying as well as the jedi agreeing to be war generals? i always thought the count turned away from his riches and title because of jedi ideology and the stature but once they agreed to be soldiers in the military he thought they were straying from their ideals and he thought it was ridiculous to turn away from a title, riches and royalty just for the jedi to give him a title and rank below what he was before he was a jedi
Notice how Obi-Wan doesn't talk at all about Qui-Gon Jinn.
He could've told Luke why he took it upon himself but didn't tell him. It would've made more sense if obi wan told Luke the truth that he only did train anakin because he promised qui gon because Qui gon believes that anakin bring balance to the force.
***** Ik but tell it to MichaelBrookham here
Because this was made in 83 and Phantom Menace in 99. Your point? Nice try, buddy.
BroBroNelly there prequels in 99-2000
Qui-Gon Jinn didn't live long enough to see Anakin become an apprentice. Obi-Wan was Anakin's master.
Real Star Wars fans love all six movies ❤️
+The Gravemind true. although I really LOVE ROTS. its the best prequel if u ask me
Alberto Garcia yup
I'll never understand why people don't like the prequels
SIX movies. That business with the sequel trilogy doesnt.... doesnt count.
x2
“You didn’t kill Anakin Skywalker. I did.”
"The same way... I will DESTROY YOU!"
“Then my friend is truly dead.”
Goodbye…Darth.
Bill Clinton " I did not have sexual relation with that woman" well it was true from a certain point of view
It depends on what the meaning of the word "is" is.
Haha good one
You just gotta be that guy lol
It depends on which woman he was talking about. If he was talking about Hillary then he was telling the truth.
Bill Clinton: I wasn't on Jeffery Epsteins Lolita Express and I was never on the Lolita Island, from a certain point of view.
"there is still good in him" makes me fucking cry like a baby
His mom said it too, yeah :(
And he was right
Obi-Wan: Yeah...maybe...it's kinda hard to see that after seeing him snap the neck of small children and cut down defenseless younglings by the dozens.
Episode 4, Kenobi hands Luke the light saber: "Your father wanted you to have this, when you were old enough"
"I stole it from your flaming, dismembered Dad while he screamed curses at me, but he really DID want you to have this."
"Certain point of view" my ass.
Catzilla my god the prequels sucked
Well Anakin probably would have given it to Luke if that ish hadn't gone down. Vader doesn't seem to mind in ESB lol
AHAHHAAAHHHAHAAHA!!!
Spadizzle92891 "from a certain point of view" ha ha
The first time I watched the vids I liked them. I liked that Anakin and Padme were falling for each other, got married, and that she got pregnant.
I mean if she died because of med complications then I'd understand why he'd join the dark-side. (that's the second person in his life to die and he couldn't help them) but she died BECAUSE of him doing that!!! D'X
Now when I watch the movies when I know that I can't stand when they even TOUCH each other because I know that their wedding/love is going to run strait into a wall because of him!!! :P
+Catzilla luke actually did fall to the dark side temporarily, *slowly claps* great JOB, luke!
“Leia. Leia’s my sister.”
_flashback to when they kissed in TESB_
*SWEET HOME ALABAMA*
Sweet home Naboo
@@Animatronics884 naboo was a beautiful place
Luke: You tell me that you don't remember owning a droid, but you knew R2-D2!
Obi Wan: R2 never was my droid, so what I told was true from a certain point of view.
Wait... didn't he own R4, that red one?
Martin A. Maguire - [Music]
I think only during ship battles but not walking around with it I think
@@martinmaguire-music6692 Jedi don't have possessions, because they fear they will lead yo the dark side. The droids were owned by the republic.
@@martinmaguire-music6692 NO. it was the Republics. Why would he own R2? He didn't own anything. Jedi they only they owned was their smug dogma.
@@CaptainSpalding72 yeah, but R2 was a gift from Padme to Anakin
I like how after all Vader’s suffering, his own son believed he was good and saved him
"When I first knew him, he was already a great pilot...but he was also a whiny brat who didn't like sand."
C. Dawg Knight Well wouldnt you hate sand if you lived on a planet filled with that shit. And everyday thats all you fucking see.
C. Dawg Knight yeah what's wrong with sand😂
madison hawkins It's rough, coarse and it gets everywhere. The heck with sand!!!
And then he would go on to have a grandson just as whiny but far more pathetic in his transition to becoming a sith lord....
xkee2013 yep i wonder if hating sand was in the family bc it was obiv the reason he went to the dark side. when anakin was going to the dark side i dont know if he was talking to obiwan or to the sand bc there was alot around him lol
"The good man who was your father..."
"The women, and the children too....I slaughtered them like animals....I HATE THEM!"
Mr.Ridley STOP IM LAUGJING SO HARD
I don't like sand its course it's rough and irritating and it gets everywhere
That statement was from the point when Anakain was turning towards the Dark side. Obi Wan is no doubt referring to his memories from before that point.
Mr.Ridley it was the sand. It gets everywhere.
"To be angry is to be human."
The older you get the more you realize how flawed the jedi's way of thinking is. Like here obi wan was guilt tripping luke into thinking the only choice he had was to kill his own father or everyone else would die. But Luke found another way. Qui gon will always be the wisest jedi in my eyes. He was one of the few that understood true balance in the force was to have both light and dark side inside yourself but not to be consumed by one or the other. He saw the arrogance of the counsel and would not put himself there.
That’s why the force destroyed both of them in the end. First the Jedi and then the Emperor. George Lucas must believe in providence. It moves mysteriously and brutally.
Have you played Knights of The Old Republic II?
This here is why I believe that Anakin fulfilled the prophecy that he would bring balance to the force. The Jedi Council had grown complacent potentially even corrupt. Allowing them to die and then later killing Sidious (I'm going to pretend RoS doesn't exist) allowed for peace and balance to be restored.
Not true. Obi wan knew the only way to free anakin was to kill Vader, that’s why anakin’s force ghost is of his younger self, because vader didn’t die a jedi.
Long live Qui Gon
Whoa, same conversation Obi had with Yoda. Obi couldn't kill Anakin because Ani was like a brother. But Obi had too.
+Emily West But he didn't and it made George Lucus SOOOOO much money ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡ °)
+monkeyman123321 well if some one is left to burn alive by a river of lava i would think that he died from it. But yea Obi was just to lazy to finish the job.
mikkel hansen
It's not so much lazy more of, he just couldn't go up and just kill him. He still loved him like a brother and he just left him to die because he was not strong enough to stop him for sure.
Obi Wan didn't have it in him to end Anakin either.
Okay we already know the awkwardness of Luke finding out Lea was his sister, AFTER the whole kiss stuff. But what if they went further and did stuff?? Obiwan would have some serious explaining to do then. Obiwan took a huge risk not telling Luke the truth. Stuff could've happened man. Weird, awkward stuff.
Obi-Wan wasn't counting on dying in the next few days after he and Luke left Tatooine; he was planning to explain everything to Luke bit by bit. After all, like I always say, you don't tell an Allied soldier fresh out of Sandhurst that his father is Josef Mengle.
Remember, Obi Wan didn't know Leia was Luke's sister in the original trilogy, Yoda revealed it to him in V. Of course the prequels, incongruent as ever, had Obi Wan deliver the twins.
But I guess if you take the prequels as canon, then Obi Wan was hoping for an incest Super Force baby
Marcus Joyner Of course he knew, but as with everything else, he was waiting for the right time; fine thing it would have been for Luke to have been captured by the Imperials and his mind probed, revealing that bit of info! Luke hadn't had the training in resisting interrogation that Leia had undergone as a senator.
It's all one story; the fact that you don't like the first third of it is your problem.
Dude, he flat out says in V that Luke was the only hope. Now when it comes to the transition from V to VI, where Obi Wan appears more informed, it is assumed that Yoda filled him immediately after Luke left for Cloud City, so Obi Wan could give more details about his own family history when Yoda died.
When of the great inconsistencies from the VI origin story with what is shown in the prequels is Anakin already being a great pilot when Obi Wan met him. He was no such thing, he wasn't even a pilot at all
Marcus Joyner
Because Leia has had no Force training. But having seen what great Force aptitude Luke possesses even as old as he is, Yoda has decided to make Leia a contingency.
As for Anakin's piloting skills, you have obviously forgotten the Podrace.
"From a certain point of view" Kenobi
"you're full of s***" Luke
Sean Eubanks anis son
full of Sith?
Anakin: From my point of view, the Jedi are evil.
This three minute clip has gotten me to exhibit more emotion than the entirety of the sequel trilogy did
It's crazy how the episode III & the Kenobi series gives even more weight to Kenobi's lines and his point of view in the trilogy. "Bury your feelings deep, they give you power but they could be used to serve the emperor". Obi-wan knows this very well because he witnessed this exact thing happen to Anakin. Vader murdering his father, Obi-wan heard from Vader himself that he killed him. All Obi-wan does at that point is pity him because he knows whatever is left of Anakin is gone. If Obi-wan were to kill him, he would only turn to the dark side.
If you watched the 6th episode of Kenobi it will make all sense now
"There is still good in him."
"He is more machine than man now, twisted and evil."
Obi Wan doesn't deny what Luke said.
Because Luke had a luxury of not seeing his atrocities first handed. Remember that before Mustafar Obi-Wan also didn't want to kill Anakin.
He Kind of does with the “twisted and evil” line, unless he’s talking about the machine parts but I’m not sure that would make sense.
@@bayabooz4855 He could tell that Luke still felt good in him, hell even on Mustafar even Obi-Wan himself could still feel the good in him. He was no farther gone by the end of Return of the Jedi than he was the day he was defeated on Mustafar, Obi-Wan never wanted Anakin to die. He knew that if even Luke, someone who was still very new to the force and searching the feelings of others, could still see the good in him, then it must still be there. Practically speaking Vader did have to die in order to restore balance. Luke found a way to save him from the Dark Side without having to forsake his own values and kill him, himself. He knew deep down that his father would not be able to coexist, with all the things he had done, and his father was quite old, living mostly off of the machines. He was tired. Luke did what both Yoda and Obi-Wan missed AND failed to prevent, he didn't have the shroud of the dark side blinding him as the Jedi did, so he found another way. Much like how Anakin always went out of his way to find a better solution in every situation. Luke and Anakin are nearly identical, both in personality and in that they relied on their emotions to get them through hardship.
"He's more machine, now, than man."
He didn’t deny it, but he clearly no longer believed it.
wish Luke would ask Obi wan about his mother too
He told Lela, then he (Luke) said that he has no memory of his mother.
Man behind a cameras yea but lela told luke about her adoptive mother, didn't she? Cuz i doubt that she can really remember about her birth mother when she was a baby
Pablo Perez well Padme was sad
Man behind a cameras true
Obi-Wan couldn't say anything because Padme wasn't made :/
Luke: Leia, Leia is my sister?
Ben: Your insight serves you w---
Luke: MY FIRST KISS WAS MY SISTER!!
Ben: Now that's nothing to be upset about--
Luke: I HAD A BONER!!
Angel of Sarcasm oh god, that's family there
Ben: Okay that's something to be worried about
Angel of Sarcasm I wanted to bang her and everything... Oh by Force...
*As if I just read a detail from Game of Thrones lol*
TheVocalTune WHAT IF I'D SLEPT WITH HER?
This scene now make sense after Kenobi episode 6
That's the beauty of the prequels - they provide the necessary clips to make great flashback-included versions of OG Trilogy scenes.
“You will find that many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.”
Why that quote doesn’t get mentioned more is astounding. It’s such a good quote, and very true as well.
The piano music is just too loud!
Watch the remastered version. The audio editing is proper.
Yeah, he should've put Igore pruit and Prophecies by Phillip Glass.
+Tom Nichol Totally agree with you. This is good but needs a better musical arrangement.
Yes I agree.
Watch the remastered version.
I never understood Yoda and Obi-Wan's apparent obsession with training Luke with the idea of killing Darth Vader. The one they needed to kill was Darth Sidious, and Luke couldn't beat Sidious because he wasn't experienced enough to defend against Force lightning. What they needed all along was what Luke finally resolved to do--find a way to turn Vader back to the light side, because as Anakin, he was strong enough to kill Sidious. If Luke had killed Vader and let Sidious live, he'd just find a new apprentice. He'd already had three.
Wonder, what Sith-name would've Palpatine given to Luke. Like... Darth Nova?
I don't think they were obsessed with Luke killing Vader, that was just a smokescreen to hide the fact Vader was his father originally. Another reason Obi-Wan felt only Luke was capable of defeating Vader is because he knew Vader wouldn't kill Luke. Vader toyed with Luke in the first fight when he could have killed him easily and even had Luke in his grips and still refused to so in Return. Anyone else, Vader would have killed them without thinking twice. Not to mention Luke's presence around his father did remind his father of the good he was capable of. What other factor would have made Vader kill the Emperor?
I think you forgot that Yoda and Obi-Wan didn't want Luke to kill his father because they knew he would turn to the dark side. They didn't want him to kill Darth Vader; They wanted him to spread the ideas of the Jedi Knight to make more jedis.
***** But, even in yoda's old age he still heavily believed in the ideals of restoring the power of the force. For that, he must not consume hatred or revenge.
I think Darth Vader's death isn't entirely killing somebody, but to kill off the personality, therefore sparing anakin's life. Luke entirely believed he could do it.
In ESB, when Luke cut off the fake vader's head he saw his own face. It probably meant that if Luke were to go and kill Darth Vader then he would lose himself doing it. Probably what Yoda had feared that would bring Luke to the dark side of the force.
The idea wasnt killing Vader, was confronting him, and then find some good inside of him. Vader (Anakin) was the one who would bring balance to the force.
Luke is the Ultimate Jedi. He had hard times and times of strife. But he stayed on the path of light. He overcame his anger and hate, but kept his attachment to people. The jedi council belived that attachment was a path to the sith. They belived no sith could be turned back to the light. Anakins attachments led him to the darkside yet his attacment to his son brought him back. Balance was brought back to the force in a way no jedi could have foresaw. Lukes beleif in the good in his father.
it's rather silly to think that you should avoid all attachments, like a lot of people try to avoid all desires. It's probably healthier to find a way to manage and channel them in a healthy way than to deprive yourself from learning how to handle them.
@@jamessanders145in the real world perhaps.
But this is the star wars universe where you have people who are psychic space wizards who can kill people with just a thought if they were to lose their temper.
The Jedi principles and avoiding emotional attachments, seems pretty darn rational within the context of the Star Wars universe
@@merlith4650 It's clear that what you're saying was what the intent was all about. However the point is that it had a lot of potential to backfire and it did in many cases, Anakin wasn't the only one and with that approach there was no way to mitigate the consequences because there was no preparation for it.
I actually have the utmost admiration for Obi Wan. He had to keep things secret if there was ever to be any hope of restoring peace to the galaxy and defeating the empire. Also, I liked the music and editing in this video. Very cool.
The only time luke ever called him obi wan
Lol
It's a shame that the prequels cause us to develop a love for padme but she's hardly mentioned in the classics except when Luke asks leia about her...
I thought when Luke told obiwan here that there is still good in him, would be a good time to say "your mother thought so. Those were her last words." To add a little something about her....
Then continue with "but he's more machine now than man..."
Lisa Thomasson Padme wasn’t even envisioned in the 70’s when this movie came out, dummy.
Lisa considering Obi Wan wanted Luke to find out on his which he finds out his mom's name, you can't be walked through everything. Luke had to learn on his own.
I always wonder if people understood Leia wasn't talking about Padme she was talking about the actual mother who raised her bail organa's wife
I wish In the scene with vade and luke. Vader says something like, you're mother once thought as you do instead of obi wan or have him say someone once thought as you do.
anyone here after Kenobi's season 1 finale?
I just want a comedy sketch with Hayden Christensen and mark Hamill pretending to be father and son...with Hayden being the stern father and Mark being the happy go lucky son.
(Mark rides into the living room on a scooter with a Star Wars T shirt on.)
(Hayden is sitting in his reclining chair in a suit and wearing thick glasses, reading the latest newspaper, the headline says something about Star Wars.)
HAYDEN
"No scooting in the house son..."
MARK
"Sorry dad...."
"Hey dad?
HAYDEN
What is it sport?"
MARK
"Have you ever had to do something you were afraid to do in order to keep a friend?"
HAYDEN
(sets the newspaper aside.)
"Come here son, sit on my lap..."
(Mark sits on his father's lap.)
"Oooo, getting big now are we?"
(Mark smiles innocently.)
"Now Luke, I'm gonna tell you a story about me when I was a young boy, not so much older than you..."
MARK
"You had to do the same thing when you were my age?"
HAYDEN
"That's right."
MARK
"I find that hard to believe."
Lol they should do that for SNL that would be gold
Especially since mark hamil is older
Ahahahahaahha. Ay. Ay. This will make gold.
czcams.com/video/PZFCqS6B-wo/video.html
Ironic, the son is older than the father
Kenobi episode 6 shows why kenobi said that way becoze Anakin himself told him he kill himself and became Darth Vader
and still Kenobi let him live... because reasons
@@toddpacker1015 Imagine if the conversation between Luke and Obi-Wan in ANH went: "How did my father die?" "I killed him." What do you think Luke's reaction would be?
@@gamestation2690 "You didn't kill Anakin, I did" - Darth Vader
Obi Wan in A New Hope: "Vader betrayed and murdered your father"
Saying "I killed him" doesn't make sense in either the Disney Canon nor the Lucas Canon
@@toddpacker1015 It's not the Jedi way to strike an unarmed prisoner/victim/man.
@@gamestation2690 Not admitting you're wrong but moving the goalpost... interesting tactic. Vader had a lightsaber and the force so not unarmed. Also revisit the Battle on Mustafar in Episode 3: Obi-Wan struck the head of an unarmed Anakin who was lying flat on the ground.
I hope if there is an Obi wan solo movie.
That its shows another interaction with him and Vader. Showing why Obi wan had given up on trying to bring Anakin back, even refusing to call him by that.
DaYoungWolf that would be Revenge of the sith
Gary McLellan
Revenge of the sith was about Anakin becoming Darth Vader.
I'm saying I wanna see why Obi Wan gave up on Anakin so easily. ROTS made it seem like Obi wan didn't even try to bring him back to the light. I wanna see another confrontation between Obi wan and Anakin. Showing Obi wan trying to bring Anakin back.
Obi Wan had no hopes on Anakin after what he had saw in the Jedi Temple's holorecord. Considering even his discovery that Anakin had his affairs with Padmé. Maybe Obi would forgive Anakin for the lies about Padmé, but not about the murder of Mace Windu and the younglings. Obi Wan found himself deeply frustrated, and the only feeling he had in his body was Justice for those deaths. His last hope was to see Anakin in agony and suffering for the deaths he had caused by menace of Palpatine, not the confiant hero "that brought peace and security to the new Empire" as he had found on Mustafar. Padmés torture was truly the end for him.
That won't happen, Disney fucked it up by putting the only logical story in a shitty kids TV show.
Alexandre Lot I disagree with that. When Anakin said he hated him was when he lost most hope. I believe he knew that there was a slim chance that he was good deep down.
I love how Luke had a great character development, he sounded more mature and serious in ROTJ compared to his rookie days in ANH.
“He’s more machine now than man, twisted and evil”
After watching Obi-Wan it makes sense why Ben didn’t believe that Vader could be redeemed. He thought he was too far gone.
Then why leave him alive?
@@toddpacker1015 He left him to die not wanting to watch.
@@julioviloria3289 Are you calling Kenobi a failure?
@@toddpacker1015 He did apologize to Anakin for losing him to the Dark Side.
@@julioviloria3289 Did Kenobi fail in killing Darth Vader in Episode 6: Yes or no.
The crazy thing is that Anakin is still the chosen one he killed Darth Sidious and restored balance. And after he did that he died so in actuality he still was the chosen one.
This is good. Putting flashbacks of the prequels into THIS mix.
"When I first knew him, your father was already a great pilot."
"Wow. A great pilot? So he was like 20 when you met him?"
"No, he was 11."
-_-
*9
Lol he was 9
Dumbass hé was 9
He was 9 and he was a pod racer
"I was amazed how strong the force was with him" -- Nope, Qui Gon Jin was amazed
"I took it upon myself to train him" -- Nope, you were honour bound to train him because your master made you, and you had previously agreed with the council it was probably not a good idea.
"I thought I could train him better than Yoda" -- At no point was Yoda going to train him, so any comparison here is just bizarre and redundant?
from R2D2s message: "You served under my father during the clone wars" --- To word it like that is reeeally stretching the reality. It's like saying to David Beckham: "You served under my father (one of the team physios) during the Premier League.
"Your Uncle didn't agree with your father's ideal and thought he shouldn't have gotten involved" --- Umm, yeah those brother's didn't see eye to eye throughout their long childhood together!?
Lucas probably could've spent the time to write 2 sequels to his overnight phenomenon that made all of the above make sense and still be a compelling and interesting trilogy... but it was probably too much like hard work for him and he had deadlines and needed to get something "flashy", "twisty" and "exciting" made in double quick time. Once he realised he could do a lot more with Star Wars than he originally alludes to in his "test movie", his only option to preserve an absolute sense of brilliant narrative quality is to start again from scratch and reshoot A New Hope. That wasn't gonna happen, so he was happy to retcon as he went along whilst printing off the vast amount of money he was almost guaranteed to make anyway....
This conversation was actually much longer then shown.
After Obi-Wan said that many truths depend on points of view, he said,"I don't blame you for being angry. If I was wrong with what I did, it wouldn't be the first time. You see what happened to your father was my fault."
After Luke says, "There is still good in him," Ben says, "I also thought that your father could be turned back to the good side. It couldn't be done. He's more machine now than man. Twisted and evil."
After Ben says, "You can not escape your destiny," Luke says, "I tried to stop him once. I couldn't do it." Ben tells him that the reason Luke couldn't stop Vader before was because he was so impatient to go off and face him. Ben says that if he had stayed here with Yoda and completed the training, he would've been prepared to face Vader. Luke, in his defense, says, "But I had to help my friends." Ben then says, "And did you help them? It was THEY who had to save YOU. You accomplished very little by rushing back, prematurely, I fear." Luke says with sadness that he did find out Darth Vader was his father. Ben tells Luke that he has been able to pass the line that his father was unable to pass and become calm and patient. THEN, Ben says, "You must face Darth Vader, again."
After Ben says that Luke's feelings do him credit but could be made to serve the emperor, there was more that was said. Ben explains to Luke, "When your father left, he didn't know your mother was pregnant. Your mother and I knew he would find out eventually. We wanted to keep both of you safe as possible for as long as possible. So I took you to live with Owen on Tatooine...and your mother took Leia to live as the daughter of Senator Organa on Alderaan."
Luke says, "You can't let her get involved now, Ben. Vader will destroy her."
Ben says, "She hasn't been trained in the ways of the Jedi the way you have, Luke...but the force is strong with her. As it is with everyone in your family. There's no avoiding this battle. You must face and destroy Vader!"
Scene then ends.
In the book, Ben tells Luke that when Anakin turned to the dark side, the 2 of them fought each other and Anakin fell into a molten pit. Ben says that when Anakin clawed his way out of the pit, he was forever changed and scarred. His anger had been burned into him. Ben says that all these years, Vader has been kept alive by machinary and his own evil desires.
Alexander Edward Pytko but he knew she was pregnant
@@ramonapiercesalvatore5917 but he didn't know that was twice
One of the best interpretations I've saw. No post-modern rubbish, no cynical crap, or Grimderp. Only perfect, logic understandment. Respect, bro :)
@@ramonapiercesalvatore5917 The people who made the prequels changed it around a bit. It's because that dialogue was deleted that they were able to get away with it. Plus, Padme lived on Alderaan for a few years but slowly died of a broken heart which is why Leia would remember her a little. Again because the dialogue was deleted, they got away with having Padme die.
@@alexanderpytko5394 George Lucas retconned that backstory to where Owen was originally Obi-Wand brother and not Anakins.
It's easier to believe and accept a beautiful lie than the ugly truth.
Andree Tungcab more like it is easier to accept
"Leia is my sister"
"Your insight serve you well" *Only female in the Galaxy*
What
@@alternaterealityspecialist635 Back in the day, Leia was only major female character in SW franchise.
I´m not starting about Lando... Watch Family Guy
@@haskapaska There was one female rebel officer in ESB. We don't know her name but Luke does.
I am loving all the flashback videos , it's show how genius lucas was with his stories, they fit in perfectly.
“From a certain point of view.” - little did we know, that line would become iconic lol
Am I the only one that absolutely loves the piano music? If you love the original score so much go watch the original movie and stop crying.
Nope, I like it but eh. Haters gonna hate
Now it makes sense why he told him Vader killed his father
I have always loved this scene, really brings back memories. And I love how Ewan always mentions Alec Guiness in any conversation involving his character or Star Wars.....such respect he has for that man. He was a legend
Obi Wan: I loved your father like my own brother. As I have loved you, Luke like my own nephew. As your friends love you.
If only this was in blue ray
That's the remastered version.
blue rey
+Bedthekemnehtayem Alec yeag
NNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoOOOOooooooooooo.......
But Obi-Wan could`ve told him that Anakin also killed his own wife,Padme.
Alex King He knew he had to. As much as / realized,she mostly died giving birth to Luke and Leia so recently,Padme`s could`ve been mentioned in this clip. And don`t call me that by the way.
Sam Kresil I just wished he could've told him about his mother and the way he was born
Code Lyoko Warrior But he didn't because the prequels didn't happen then.
Code Lyoko Warrior Also,why did they make Episode 4 first?
Sam Kresil right
This is heartbreaking story
It hits hard luke, knowing all the things his father had done, was wise and saw the good in vader when he could not see himself
I liked the prequels, is that against the law?
You are the law.
@@user-xx6vy9ri8p you’re kind of three years late
@@itsnina6616 you’re kind of one month late
I will make it legal.
How is it not realistic? He was young and in love.. men will do stupid shit to impress a woman. It makes perfect sense to me. He saw visions of his mother dying, she passed away. He saw visions of his love dying, he wouldn't let that happen... that with Jedi laws could totally explain him turning to the darkside however it would NOT explain any kind of hatred for Jedi... in episode 3(which I love) he says 'in my point of view the Jedi are evil) the movie doesn't every explain why Jed think that. Not once. Look a lot of people hate episodes 1-3 . That okay, if you hate them then stop watching. There is absolutely No reason to ruin it for other people who do enjoy the movies. And vice versa. There really isn't much point of arguing unless you're a Hollywood director then by all means make a bid for making it the way YOU want. That's my opinion. Good video by the way. Can be somewhat emotional if you appreciate the whole story. Although the music is a bit distracting.
smj3productions palpatine convinced of a jedi plot to take over the republic, which of course never really existed, and hence thats wy he thought the jedi were evil. remember when windu had done in palpatine, he shouted "you see anakin, the jedi are taking over!!"
smj3productions "she has lost the will to live"
you're telling me the mother of two of the most powerful beings in the star wars universe simply "lost the will to live"? the dumbest crap i have ever heard in a movie
the jedi were already being questioned if they were the good guys throughout the clone wars. Anakin would look for answers to solve his problems in the jedi council, but the way of the order, they didnt give him the answers he wanted to hear. So he turned to Palpatine, and Palpatine got in his ear and convinced him the Jedi were wrong, lying to him, hiding stuff from him. Also Palpatine basically said if you join the dark side you can bring the dead back to life. Anakin being so desperate, took the bait
+Spadizzle92891 She was heartbroken because her love (Anakin) had fallen to the dark side, She never would of thought Ani would force choke her, she was so distraught by all of this...Well she lost the will to live like the robot said lol
typical beta male behavior trying to impress a woman or even another man
10 years later this is still my favourite movie
That's just sad I missed obi wan and Anakan as a jedi😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
wow this video made me cry! This is so good! : )
Great job! Love the piano and flashbacks a lot! ^_^
Turns out Luke is a better Jedi than Obi Wan was.
Where Obi Wan saw no hope, Luke saw an ember of good in Vader and chose to attempt the impossible. Not kill his father for "the greater good"
Luke understood the Jedi way better than Ben did even at his young age.
To be fair, Luke was probably the only one who could turn Vader
@@adrianamontalvo7472 True, then again he was raised by Obi Wan.
@@adrianamontalvo7472 indeed, and a more reasonable example is the redemption of Kylo Ren. His parents save him not his mentor, even if it was Luke Skywalker that face the same path of obi wan in this case
She lost the will to live........oh wait you have two new born kids? guess she missed that small detail.
I always hated that lazily written reason as if having two kids isn't incentive to live like oh I'm just gonna die and burden my kids to people I barely know and my senator friend
Rick Steck Damn dude =D
That is just one of the many nonsenses of the movies, now as an adult I find the series poorly written stories. Still enjoyable but they cannot stand to scrutiny.
How Anakin survived when lava burned his hole body? He probally would die that Palpy didn't used force stuffs so he saved him. So I think Palpy killed Padme. He lied that Anakin killed her , but she was alive . Remeber Obi-wan checked is she alive before battle with Anakin. I was thinking about that... Maybe I am wrong , but not what ever xD
You're only wrong because George said she lost the will to live your logic makes more sense than the actual writer of the film. I applaud you.
Luke has such a good heart. one of my favorite childhood characters growing up with
Obi Wan: ”So what I told you was true from a certain point of view.”
Vader: “From my point of view the Jedi are evil.”
So then you are lost!
This is an excellent video thank for share AWESOME!!!!!
"You're going to find that many of the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view."
Yeah let me try using that line the next time I'm in court under oath.
Got a feeling it won't fly.
"Bury your feelings deep down"
Yea cause that advice worked out for his father real good......
I love how Lucas describes the god by using the term "The Force"... so wise and relateable.
Amazing how many profound lessons Lucas masterfully weaves in between lines of what is essentially a kids movie.
So many lessons that have served me so well in adult hood. Four or five that can be taken from this small clip alone.
His work was about mythology and that itself is about mythos of the past teaching the right things for the future, so people coming of age can learn from past mistakes of the older generation and do it better in their lives.
Its very poetic and profound stuff, and the perfect way to deliver a powerful movie.
"Leia, Leia is my sister"cuts to Ace Ventura Einhorn is a man scene
If I were Luke Id be pissed with that "point of view " bullshit. Obi Wan said clearly that Vader killed his dad. I would say "listen old man, just literally tell me what happened next time". And by the way, Obi Wan forgot to mention that he left Luke's dad for dead burning to death from hot lava.
I like to pretend that that didn't happen. I prefer to stick with the canon I made up in my head over that awful bullshit of a trilogy
Was what Obi Wan said all that crazy? I probably wouldn't come right out and tell some kid that his dad was Hitler or whatever either. And Kenobi knew the Emperor would hunt down and kill Anakin's kids if word got out.
Obi-Wan was speaking metaphorically; he orig said Anakin was betrayed & murdered b/c at that point Luke might not have embarked on the path that led him to redeem his father. Also, if he knew the truth, he might have gone down the path to the dark side to get revenge, rather than taking the path of the Jedi. Obi-Wan was being strategic.
Yeah, right. You'd tell a young Allied soldier about to fight the Nazis that his father is Josef Mengele. Anakin did die when Vader took over; Obi-Wan wasn't lying; in fact, he didn't know how right he was. You need to apply some real brain power to this story.
fahd s Blame George Lucas for that
Beautifully Done !
I like how Obi Wans force Ghosts can sit on a log lol
The Emperor lol
This music fits the movie very well and the flashbacks are alright.
Very good video. Love how everything makes sense.
Good video, and I like the piano music. It fits this scene :)
Luke's face after he realize Leia is his sister: She kissed me twice......shit....
Sick LOL
Irony is the wanted him to kill his father to save them but killing his father would of corrupted him and turn him to the dark side
We'll done flashback, Much appreciated!
Well the people who cut this together sure do love the piano. Thank goodness I’ve seen this movie a ton of times so I know what Obi-Wan is saying.
If Leia ever complained about her life she hopefully remembered one fact: she got the palace. Luke got the desert.
I don't like The Sequel Trilogy, it's coarse, rough and irritating and it gets everywhere.
2/3rds of the sequel trilogy isn’t even out yet lmao
Matthew butler sand
@@istinkofpoobut5602 Two movies are out now.
Would that make it a bilogy?
Toby Thurlow White If that’s a thing yes 😂
@@istinkofpoobut5602 Lovely
That is a really good work
Very creative..that was great..👍👍👏👏
Luke: I can't kill my own father.
Obi-Wan: Then the emperor has already won.
Luke: Only a sith deals in absolutes.
Poor Luke, such a burden to bear along with being borderline manipulated by people who are supposed to be your allies (i.e. The Jedi).
Yet he shoulders the responsibility forced upon him by his predecessor anyways. He was never the first choice to save the Galaxy from the Sith.
Yet he did it anyways. And for that, I will always love and look up to Luke Skywalker.
Who ever made this video I thank you and I feel you brother may God bless you on your journey
This is an amazing edit
This video should have been in return of the Jedi some people can hate the prequels I found them entertaining. This video is a good example to know more on how Luke Skywalker learned more about his life and looking back on what happened before.