A simulated war between Thailand and Vietnam. Who'd win?
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 07. 2024
- Get the Binkov plushie here: www.amazon.co.uk/Binkovs-Batt...
Check out our Graphy educational series - War transformed: share.graphyapp.co/MHNG
This video talks about Vietnamese and Thai armed forces and their overall military potential, seen through the lens of a hypothetical war between the two. Geography, economy and neighbor countries would direct the course of such a war beyond the pure numbers and specifications.
Music by Matija Malatestinic www.malatestinic.com
Go to / binkov if you want to help support our channel. And enjoy the perks such as get access to our videos with no ads and get early access to various content.
Suggest country pairs you'd like to see in future videos over at our website: www.binkov.com
You can also browse for other Binkov T-Shirts or Binkov merch, via the store at our website, binkov.com/
Subscribe to Binkov's channel for more videos! / binkovsbattlegrounds
Follow Binkov's news on Facebook! / binkovsbattlegrounds
Follow us on Twitter: / commissarbinkov - Zábava
Thailand and Vietnam do not go to war against each other except football.
Perfection.
Lol!.. It's just 'hypothetical'.. and when war breaks out, it's usually between the country leaders and whoever behind them anyway. So say if I hate Thais (hypothetically speaking), the Malaysian army is not gonna march to Bangkok tomorrow. Us ordinary folks, we are not in the elite club my friend.
@@SuffianMohammed well the only reason we are going to war with you is about the southern insurgents
Theyre all malaysians
Doesnt even look like thais..
@@SobaYatai There are Thai Malays living there. Historically there was a Malay sultanate exist there - The sultanate of Pattani.. and I can tell u they looked just like some typical Kelantanese. Could there be Malaysians involved? Maybe, who knows. I don't! But u do right? Must be exciting having to buy into a narrative, a reason to go for war isn't it? Feeling of empowered and superior to see other people (of different association like country, ethnicity, religion, ect) to be exterminated. And if u get the chance to kill maybe u'll even get a medal! Yay!.. I, for one, will not let other people tell me who to hate. Let alone wanting a war.. but do carry on with whatever float ur boat.
I'm Thai and I'm sure that Thai military will win in a golf tournament. Most Thai Generals and Majors play golf in the morning and go to work in the afternoon.
XD
Bruh
i here too
😂😂😂😂
haha bruhh
Hello my Vietnamese brothers and sisters! Much love from Thailand!
I'm Thai i love Vietname
Hello there from Vietnamese bushes
@@nguyenkimvv7686 vietnam is poor and evil.
@@stoggafllik it's true tho I mean people always say Vietnam will be 10 time's ahead of Thailand somehow I see illegal Vietnam immigrants working in Thailand but I don't think they are evil
@@stoggafllik What kind of meme that u say Vietname is E V I L. I think that ur comment make nonsense tho
P/S:Bóc phét ít thôi nhá, bớt mồm điêu đi, ăn gì mà mồm điêu vãi cả nồi>:V
I'm from Vietnam. I don't care who will win, who is stronger. I just want peace and a partner, the past war has slaughtered my country and my people, I don't want that to happen again.
But our football war is endless bro
It's just simulated not real war
@@notno.11 that's competition for progess. Not war
@@levanha2564 seem you not getting my joke
@binh nguyen yes and why do you ask?
Thailand and Vietnam are friend nowadays. people in south east asia don't want war anymore
Yeah they build big community for friendship
Turkish Army vs Greek Army Military Comparision
czcams.com/video/yUMnF1-kKfE/video.html
true i live in thai and people say if there is a war in one coutry the invaders
mess with all of us
@@nguyentintrong5123 wtf? Cái gì vậy thanh niên
@@nguyentintrong5123 bị ngáo hả ???
Laos and Camboya: guess I am about to die...
Yeah if this happen they both are so f_ck lol
They are the Belgium and Luxembourg in this case while Thailand and Vietnam are like France and Germany.
Lol aight Imma die 😔
even the relatively low intensity / unconventional warfare that happened during the cold war has essentially crippled the two countries even to this day...
@@pranganao7395 well in Belgium and Luxembourg’s cases, France and Germany fought on the countryside. Most of their population are in cities.
In Laos and Cambodia’s cases, majority of their population are in the countryside...
I’m Viet and growing up in Vietnam, I’ve never seen anyone spread hate against Thai, we are also taught at school quite less about conflicts between Viet-Thai. In fact, young Viet are seeing Thai as a place for food and travel, sometimes we have arguments about football and economics, that’s all. Hope Thai mates have same perspective.
yes i am thai and i like vietnam because my friend is vietnamese
No reason to fight between the two countries.
Its in the title guys, it's a simulation of war not a testament to the probability of war.
@Hieu Nguyen ?????
What about the Laos and Cambodia?
Western people: what if Vietnam and Thailand fight each other
Vietnamese and thai : come on bro , let’s sit down and drink a shot of fish sauce , your brain need some fish sauce to think more :)) why we have to fight
But why fish sauce of all things
@@thanhvinhnguyento7069 because it so yummy and umami
We all love fish sauce 😌💗
i think we should drink ba kich instead
The only fighting we do is in football
Vietnam: Advances on highways towards Bangkok
Traffic Jams: I’m gonna stop you right there
LoL it do be like that
As a Thai myself its pretty normal here about the traffic that im used to it because i never really notice
Then come to realise that bangkok is world worst on thing traffic around 2017 when im getting to learn eng
Well shit thats good for me bc i dont feel bothered by it
That one thai tuk tuk driver blocking an entire tank collumn
Now I'm interested in ASEAN vs China! Hopefully you'll do this in the near future.
Asean and China are friends you do realise that right and if they really did attack us assuming we have no other allies we will be crushed
@@ke._njil.o.h2458 You know that this Channel does hypothetical wars. Yeah China is befriended with parts of Asia, does that matter? I think you don't understand the channel.
@@ke._njil.o.h2458 dont worry its a just a speculation not an agression
@@derlasercrafterwally4342 because ASEAN was part of china since ancient times
@@fcuagency2163 CCP propagandist or plain old ignorance?
Uncle Ho Chi Min has a hide out house in Nakorn Panom , in North EastThailand during the Indochina War. Now, it is like a little museum.
Thai-Viet enemies wait for our war :D
actually, through out 3000-4000 years history of our people (not country) we lived beside each other, withour wars, sharing lots of culture and heritage
@@hahdanghongha7810 Thái Lan đem quân đánh VN vài lần rồi, đọc lại lịch sử đi
@@hahdanghongha7810 đánh nhau suốt
@@danemhaonam156 cái đánh nhau thời Thái Việt chỉ là rất nhỏ nhẹ thôi.
nhiều bạn trẻ không biết trống Đồng ở Thái và đất tổ của Thái cực kỳ nhiều, và các di tích các dân tộc Thái, Lào cổ luôn so le nằm kề với các di tích của Việt. Điều đấy chứng tỏ hai bên sống lẫn nhiều nghìn năm và ko có cuộc chiến nào tự như diệt chủng, mà vẫn tách biệt văn hóa.
điều này rất hiếm trong lịch sử thế giới
Love Vietnamese food and culture.
As a Vietnamese, I have never thought about a war between Vietnam and Thailand. Love from VN
as a thai, i'd always thought that historically speaking we were mostly fighting againts myanmar
Much love to you to Vietnam 🇻🇳 love Thailand 🇹🇭 hope we don’t go to war at each other ❤️❤️❤️
Vietnam and thailand is equal at military power that why they divided cambodia into 2 but it is lucky for cambodia that france come.
we have a lots of wars in football.lol
ใช่ I agree
America : Don't
Thailand : why?
America : JUST DON'T
5555
@@fbi1412 (5555)ถ้าไม่ใช่คนไทยเขาไม่เข้าใจนะครับ
5555=hahahaha
@@user-tl5yd5of1y คนไทยชอบลืมว่า 5 มันเป็น five ในภาษาอังกฤษ
แล้วก็คงลืมว่าเราไม่ใช่พ่อทุกสถาบันเหมือนอังกฤษ
Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Philippines: "Yeah... please go on, continue."
Don't stop for us... maybe just a sec.. lemme get my popcorn
Maybe even a soda
I'm going to upload a Korean caption of Korea vs Japan video. Is it okay?
More like china, because they dispute the territory over southchina sea. China is the real winner here
@@constantiniasmith4231 video: about viet-thai
This dude: chinese victory
Never will this happen Thailand and Vietnam will be good friends 🇹🇭❤️
🇻🇳❤️
Too bad it already happened many years ago,lol
For people of both side yea probably dont rlly hate each others that much except about football
But politically both of us gonna get fucked someday
@@SobaYatai dang i was gonna say that
@hoàng nguyễn you fool polpot lived his life to his last day and dies of old age didnt get any punish
This would be a disaster scenario, the price of fish sauce and rice would skyrocket around the world.
Do Sweden vs Denmark, The two countries that have the world record in waging war against each other.
do they?
@@appa609 yeh they fought for hundreds of years , most of southern Sweden was Denmark
Denmark is gonna lose
@Dank Waifu Sweden and Denmark have fought each other for centuries and hold the record for most wars fought between them. It all adds up to around 30 wars since the 15th century.
@Dank Waifu And Maybe they want to duke it out one final time!
Winner: Malaysia, Singapore and Indonesia.
Reason: Money.
@@vietnamstompsonchineseroac9948 Well, duh.
That's ASEAN's mission since day 1.
@@Raul_Menendez But they were fail to do that...
Long live china 🇨🇳
China will eat Vietnam alive lol
@@Alamdar- lmao they tried time and again for 4000 years, yet couldnt :)
@@juliandamen9804 because Vietnam eats dogs
Vietnam : unfortunately drove a tank lost a few kilometers into Thailand
Bangkok : we will fight until our last man down
Dark dark, bruh bruh lmao
@nguyễn thịnh khôi ok Traffic : stop right there Mtfk
Traffic police : license please? No speak Thai? 500 baht, c’mon
Most Vietnamese love and respect Thailand , except football.
yeah but only football, ASEAN is, or should be ONE!
Hahaha Big match of South East Asia.💪🏻
Also AoV
no. THai is almost gay
@@canhtrinh3442 Vietnam has more gay men than Thailand.
there will no be Laos resistance, Laos always love Vietnam
The Lao (especially their armies) have always shown a great reluctance to fight for anything.
Laos and Vietnam are brothers
@@schoolssection but Laos also likes Thai
Then Thailand will have to fuk Lao too
@Peach Peach really?
Meanwhile Lao and Cambodia shout at Vietnam and Thailand in despair "Hey, this land you guys are fighting on, is owned!!!"
lol :v
Love Thailand from Vietnam! :D
Thanks, I love Vietnam too ( ◜‿◝ )♡
@@montri4653 I love ThaiLand too ♡ (>.
No thailan
Love Vietnam 🇻🇳 from Thailand 🇹🇭
@@cuongphan197 what???
Vietnam and Thailand: *declare war*
Laos and Cambodia:*chuckles* I'm in danger
True, in any scenarios, Laos and Cambodia become battle field and gain nothing.
@AJ_Exiled USA and China : are you sure about that?
@@lavendertee No, you also No, China wouldn't let any war happens in neighbour countries, USA nowadays are ally to Vietnam more than Thailand and Phillipines. Check out, Prime President have just visited Vietnam last 2 weeks then Wang Yi have just visited Vietnam also last week. USA and China try to get more effect to Vietnam.
@@lavendertee Think please, do USA ally with China to protect Thai from Vietnam? reason why they have to do that? no benefit
@@lavendertee China have a crazy relationship with Vietnam. same culture, same people, do they let a country with no any connect about language or culture even ally with USA take Vietnam? NO.
Actually Vietnam and Thailand have been fighting over the suzerainty of Laos and Cambodia since the 16 to 18 century, Vietnam and Thailand both carved Laos and Cambodia lands for ourselves. If the French hadn't arrived, there would be no modern day Laos and Cambodia.
So a Thai vs Vietnam war will be about who will take most of the territory of Laos and Cambodia.
But then these two nations will share a border which will result in a proper battle. It is always better to keep a weak neutral buffer in between.
@@masoodjalal1152 thats why thailand survived the 1800s, france and britain needed a weak buffer between their colonies lol
@@mxn1948 Google search Dainam Empire and Siamese Empire, you'll get your answer
@@masoodjalal1152 Back then Vietnam have to step up to protect Laotians kingdoms and Cambodia, we want tributary, when Emperor Minh Mạng of Dainam (Nguyen dynasty) came along, he expanded Vietnam territories, 2 Laotians kingdoms and 90% of Cambodia was annexed to Vietnam, Siam get little.
@@ucminhvo295 Siam got one Laotian kingdom but with very heavy casualty when they resisted tributary, so much so that the place where said kingdom used to be was completely abandoned and rediscovered when the french did some geographical survey after acquiring french indochina. The event was really brutal and is part of the reason the current Laos kinda hate thailand in the historical context.
Also the city of Siem Reap means Siam lost in Khmer, when Siam was in control of the city on some occasions it was called Siam Rat instead, which means Siam win
After the Vietnam War, Vietnam boasted that their superior army can and will, “...be in Bangkok within 6 hours.” To which the Thai said, “Yeah right, Not with this traffic you won’t.”
Been to Bangkok and can confirm 😂
Finally....... a non-toxic Thai nationalist comment that invites total keyboard war on a 'what-if Thai-Viet war' video. Thank you from a fellow Thai
@@TheBasara555 Thailand’s economy and army outmatches Vietnam. Vietnam is just a poor shiethole
@@stoggafllik really? Vietnam economy will surpass Thai in the next 20 years. Meanwhile, the firepower of the 2 countries are almost equivalent, but VN has more experience and population. In anyway, VN is not something to be underrated.
@@alissekim Nice shill for the Vietnamese Communist Party.
I love Vietnam and Thailan ❤️🇻🇳
Turkish Army vs Greek Army Military Comparision
czcams.com/video/yUMnF1-kKfE/video.html
Thai win
5555
@@funwithfernie4862 inconclusive i think :))
@@funwithfernie4862 Việt Nam: xe tăng đánh polpot đã qua biên giới Thái Lan🇹🇭
Thái Lan: tử thủ Bangkok 😂😂😂😂🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂😂
Not many people talked about it, but Siam (Thailand) and Vietnam used to go to war in the early 1800s. The war was to conquer or establish their dominance over Khmer (Cambodia). The victor couldn't be decided, and thus Cambodia was divided into East and West respectively. So for us to not repeating the tragedy, let's just say we are tied militarily, and compete in sport or economy instead.
the war in the 1800s, although both countries were equally strong, on the Cambodian battlefield the Vietnamese army often won.
I was told that the Vietnamese won, and reinstated the Khmer king after Asian retreated.
What about the war with Siam and nguyen hue where Vietnamese completely wipe out the Siam army?
Cambodia used to be just a military exercise for Siamese empire before guns and colonial time. Siam empire loves going there for shits and giggles. Siam never wanted to fight with the viets though because they knew the viets were no pushover with all the mountainous terrain, military and all. Cambodia is largely flat you just ride in and topple the big guy and that's it. The viets never really came to visit Siam either. Props to them.
Thailand ans Vietnam have crashed actually many times in the past and its a tie.
I want to start off by saying I am a huge fan of this channel, but having watched for years I have come to the conclusion that they may need to adjust the conditions of their scenarios. Unless it is a lopsided match or a ficitional setting (i.e. the US and Russia sharing a land border) almost no nation has the standing forces to project sufficient power to conquer a near peer. I would suggest changing the conditions to a multi-year war that allows for each combatant to mobilize it's population and industry. I understand it would make the videos more complex and difficult to make, but I feel it would also make them better.
Even if the above advice is ignored I wholeheartedly support this channel and hope they continue to make such high quality videos far into the future.
You are one of the best unbiased military comparison CZcamsrs.
Yep no stupid music or robotics
"one of the best"?
The Best.
Also he looks at the quality of the weapons and their actual logistical limitations and capabilities of said weapons and countries as opposed to just saying “ugh...big weapon...fast weapon...more weapon...me take world now” lol
i wouldnt call him unbiased
I'm going to upload a Korean caption of Korea vs Japan video. Is it okay?
Thailand: Germany
Vietnam: Soviet
Cambodia: Poland
Molotov-Ribentrop infensities. But it actually run in 18 and early 19 century when Dai Nam and Siam shaking hand to exploit and annex Khmer Kingdom and fighting to each other also.
So funny
But i like it
ภูมิใจที่ได้เกิดเป็นคนไทย 🇹🇭❤️
Next for the world championship finals; Vietnamese rice field farmers versus Afghan sheep herders.
I'm going to upload a Korean caption of Korea vs Japan video. Is it okay?
@@user-vh1ob3rp7p yeah.
2 banes of empires. I like this matching
@@user-vh1ob3rp7p that would be great
Until a dog eater comes up with a bowl of bat soup.
Another wonderful content! SEA vs China would sound like another good edition
Thailand Never lose in ww2 I’m thai and Thailand never lose in ww2
Thailand sided with Japan during WWII and was a minor nation in the Axis powers, The Axis and Japan lost in the Second World War so technically Thailand lost.
@@TheGruntGuy321 I mean, they gained some territories, was treated as an enemy conquered nation since they had an underground force helping the US so they got away with a slap on the wrist in term of war crime, got into the United Nation, and got world recognition which led to tourism boom. Sounds like a win to me.
Viet-Thai friends never fighting. From Vietnam
Love you Vietnam 🇻🇳❤🇹🇭 from Thailand.
Both are subservient allies to the US of AIDS empire under Satan's Israhell.
Gút chóp
Có đánh đi nữa thì bọn Thái thấy Việt cộng cũng chạy thôi 🤭
❤️❤️❤️
Thailand, Korea, Philippines, Australia, New Zealand are the countries that sent troops to fight in Vietnam, they had massacred the Vietnamese. Vietnamese blood used to shed for them. We can forgive, we are ready to forgive, but we must not forget, never forget, friends.
Vietnam Paramilitary: *5 million*
Entire population of Laos: 7 million
I'm not sure if Laos can survive this one.
Not my home country!?!
OOF
mountain guerrilla warfare. vietnam would bleed 10 times as much for every inch of territory, not like vietnam has the sats/toys/weapons/equipment that the us has
@@mxn1948 you clearly havent heard of the Vietnam war
@@mxn1948 Dude... the US drop more bombs than the force of Hiroshima and Nagasaki combined and they still withdrew from Vietnam. Get your facts straight.
So vietnam vs thailand would end in a "thai"?
Good one👍🏽
Xaxaxajajajahahaha
I was going to make a joke about Thailand... but Phuket...
@@DoctorDeath147 the perfect reply
I well Siam super 💪
You haven’t mentioned the advantage of Gepard frigate class in compare to Thai frigates. Also, the largest VNmese naval base is actually in the south of Vietnam, the Cam Ranh naval base.
This is somewhat unlikely to happen the most out off all scenario. Their bond of relation ship are too strong through H3ntai Artist and the Tea Alliance. Thailand and Vietnam would join forces and invading Cambodia are more likely going to happen than this.
Thanks Xter for preventing the war.
Viet Nam loves peace and no more war, please.
If Vietnam get in War again = Your Country WIll Doomed
No, thailand WIll Doomed
@@conmuabuon7801 Rationally speaking, both countries will be doomed economically and politically. And you can't seriously thought that vietnam or thailand can dedicate themselves to war without losing any benefits from tourism, trade, agriculture, right?
We Vietnamese love peace because we know all too well how hard it was during (or even after) war time.
janan berserker this is the mentality, mainly , the emperor Chinese thought whenever they invaded us throughout thousands of years history, and each time they tried - they FAILED
Is that the real Binkov in the Ad? Nice to see you in person finally.
Review the clip a bit. for the RTAF In the clip it seems to give Gripen the only feature that can support the company. Fighting, not talking about training the F-16eMLU and the upgraded F-5 may be able to get the old data attached, especially Python, and now I-Derby can be installed. Therefore, I believe that if given a little more information, the results of the air fight will likely change from comparable to Northern Thailand. But I agree with the clip that Thailand has been pressed with SAM, allowing at least some aerial trajectory.
I like the animation at the end of your videos with the two combatants names clashing... Sad it wasn't in this video.
Kinda reminds me of that one during the Rouge Khmer incident an NVA T55 got lost and ended up near Bangkok, which made the Thai went full panic mode and prep a “to the last man” defense
Yes, lmfao
Not NVA but PAVN
Bruhh can I get an info on that? 😂very interested
Vietnam could do that because of Soviet Union support all weapon for free. If the war continue, there will have no more Vietnam country on the world. It will be another province of China instead of Vietnam.
@@nirapongpansai2792 do you know the war between Vietnam and China in 1979? China was lost
Laos is the Belgium of Asia.
You have to go through
Poor Belgium in South East Asia
i get the joke.
Germany always uses belgium to go to France, yes they annexed them too
And cambodia is netherlands
Realisticly speaking.
Belgium is a flatland, easy to invade.
Laso isn't. Attacking through Laos is like attacking through Switzerland with a fraction of military.
Cambodian is actually closer to Belgian(IMO) due to being flatland and should be a better route in Total war. but for limited war, the area in this video should be better
Who is germany, who is france.?
Well in my opinion, there are 2 things needed to be adjusted:
1. Vietnam has experience of using Ho Chi Minh trail through Laos jungle in Vietnam War and considering Lao - Vietnam tight relationship, I don't think there would be any trouble for Vietnam to "borrow" a pathway to North-Eastern Thai. (In fact Laos would likely support Vietnamese if there's any conflict coming)
2. 4 out of 5 Vietnam's Navy Regional Commands are in the Central and South Regions, also the Navy Academy is based on Nha Trang in the very south of Central Vietnam (which is also the place to train officers for Cambodian and Laos Navy), so I don't think either Vietnamese Navy would have any trouble in mobilize most of their fleets to Gulf of Thailand.
เราเรียกพวกคุณ 3 ประเทศว่า "3พี่น้องตะวันออก" ไทยเรารู้อยู่แล้วว่าถ้าเกิดสงครามจริงๆมันจะกลายเป็น 3vs1 ซึ่งในอดีตก็เป็นเช่นนี้มาแล้ว
bỏ à Laos Navy :))))))
Thai win ❤️
Bru stop dreaming kiddo
May I give a couple of recommendation for future videos?
Italy vs Turkey
Italy, Greece and Egypt Vs Turkey, Libia and Algeria
Please, don't ally with egypt
Well actually I have to say that in my country, lots of high school male students go in the military called Thai reserve officer training corps or TROTC (in thai:"raksa dindan" or "ro dor" for short) and the number of students that have completed this course is at least 45,000 a year and have the level of training equal to the 90 days wonders of ww2
we do that in vn too but with addition of 2-3 months for university students.
@@thangnguyenvan7863 ของเราระดับมัธยมเรียน 3 ปี แต่ถ้าเป็นทหารเกณฑ์จะเป็น 2 ปี
@@gordonfreeman336 try learning some proper English, my friend.
ตลกละประสบการณ์นักเรียนรด.เท่ากับ 90 วันในสงครามโลกครั้งที่2 พี่ชายอยู่ประเทศไหนเนี่ย นี่เราฝึกรด.กันโหดขนาดนั้นเลยเหรอ ผมเรียนรด.จนจบปี 5 มันก็หนักแหละ แต่ไม่ถึงขั้นนั้นแน่นอน 😂
@@RamRockTHทางทฤษฎีครับ ประสบการณ์รบจริงมันไม่เท่ากันหรอก
50$ for that plush? That seems a bit expensive....I love you're videos, very entertaining. Actually downloaded that Battle Warship app game...I'm doing pretty good.
I can see vietnams and thailands commanders watching this and prepping accordingly.
Internet commander or keyboard commander?
@@bezero2005
just regular commanders.
probably sitting at their respective computer desks while taking notes.
Cambodia: "Land mines. Lots and lots of land mines."
Laos: "I guess we should rent the center on our nation to Thailand and Vietnam when this war starts. Alexa...
... locate me a good realator."
no Thailand commanders are busy with corruption and getting richer. lol
Vietnam and Thailand: *Decide to go to war*
Laos and Cambodia: *Chuckles* We're in danger.
You mean Laos and Cambodia?
@@darker6328 yeah, my focus ran off lmao🤣
Nah we busy with our own political bullshit while Vietnam is bussy with china
Thai Laos Vietnamese are friends.
That one safe zone:*popcorn noises*
REAL WAR is comment section.
Chill people, this is a simulated war.
Support Vietnam to defeat DogThai.
From S.Korea!
If there was a Korean War with Japan, I would support Japan. Let Japan act as in the past 🤫
@@whatwhat.2679 Like genocide tens of millions of Chinese for fun in WW2 ?
@@kimwoonsuk4375 What's with the hate? Why are you inciting flame wars in this comment section im genuinely curious. I don't remember Thailand going to war against S.Korea in the past.
@Mr Doggo Lads while that's quite an interesting piece of information in and of itself, it still doesn't answer my question though.
Hello, Binkov!
Your works are amazing and wonderful! I like your works. Your works makes me comfortable,
Can I reprint your works to Chinese website? I will indicate the author and your tubing address.
Thank you !
Laos is that dude who awkwardly sit in the middle of the backseat while the the two dudes beside him are fighting eachother while Cambodia is driving drunk and Myanmar sitting shotgun snorting coke.
Always has been.
Could China invade İndochina?
Could Russia invade Ex Soviet states?
No
Yes.
Russia's army is actually quite underrated. It's the only one which compares to the USA in terms of training (not weapons or firepower though). Russia could probably invade all of Eastern Europe and overrun it in a few weeks, but then get stuck at Germany and get rekt by the USA.
Yes
Yes
Assuming no other countries intervene and for China, that they willing to stomach the casualties to gain basically nothing in return. (Seriously, apart from fishing and other small commercial industries, China has nothing to gain from invading Indochina)
@@markhenley3097 No Russian training is not comparable to the US army they depend on Conscripts.
@@thekaiseroftheeast3895 China has historically failed multiple invasions of Indochina when it was a major power. I really doubt they would try it again with the exact same situation.
@@juanmola2000 If China went all out conventionally, it would most likely be able to subdue Indochina. Historically, as I mentioned above, it's just because China didn't have much to gain from invading Indo china.
"Uncle Ho is with us"
Ho Ho Ho Chi Minh!
COMRADE HO PROTECC
@@soman5348 freedom you say?
Germany: Erika
Russia: Katyusha
Vietnam: HO CHI MINH
@@capitalismisfairfucksocial3020 hahahahaha lmao I'm dead
Vietnam didn’t want to fight with any country in ASEAN, if we fought against each other, another giant will win after all.
Well thats true.. we are asean..
vietnam is trash
@@user-jf7kz5kw6e same to you
The US and China would capitalize on the situation and support side that they like and probably...maybe provide air and ground support
@@missymiami6798 it seems that: china will support thailand and cambodia, usa support vietnam, and laos would not follow vietnam again.
More Thailand video pls!!!
1. First Indochina war : Vietnam vs French --- 1-0 for Vietminh
2. Second Indochina war : Vietnam vs US --- 2-0 for VC
3. Third Indochina war : Vietnam vs Polpot & China --- 3-0 for Vietnam
4. Fourth Indochina war : Vietnam vs Thailad --- I guess :)))
well the second one had many other belligerents
You forgot about Siamese-Vietnamese Wars before the French came.
@@11popk87 small war , but i remember Tay Son destroy and cut 50.000 Thai head on Rach Gam - Xoai mut river ...
@@11popk87 czcams.com/video/8YNRXlxH_HI/video.html this battle .. you can tranlaste to Thai laguage
There was only one indo china war in 1962 how can there be 3
Binkov's Videos always end in stalemate. In reality it never ends up being a stalemate because of the political hand-tying or because someone brings a friend (or a friend's airforce).
Hahah “hey buddy can I borrow your Air Force for ummm a scientific study”
No? Few nations end in draws
the chinese did stored military equipment in Thailand when vietnamese forces ocupied cambodia, in case vietnam decided to invade Thailand aswell to wipe out the remenants of khmer rouge who seeked refuge behind That borders
I love Thailand 🇹🇭 Vietnam 🇻🇳 from korea 🇰🇷
@@anarchocapitalism9201 You don't know anything about Vietnam, we don't want to eat * dog * meat, in 1945 Vietnam suffered from starvation over 1 million people, we had nothing to eat so we had to eat our pets😔Now it is the habit of the old people in Vietnam, the young people are condemning the eating of pets, but if you hate us, what can you get?Want the Viet Cong to crush your head🙂!?
@@anarchocapitalism9201 Thailand has no door to Vietnam. there that make war You don't like peace. Are you bored of living. We all have the spirit of patriotism in Vietnam. If the enemy was an enemy, he was determined to fight even though the enemy was strong. But to be honest, it's not easy to chew. Don't you guys be there, dreaming. I'm the one I hate the most about the war
@@kehuydien4044 It's such a peacefull comment, we all hate the war in nowadays, from thailand.
@@Aunna286 no one likes war. Love from vietnam. Still tho, the media thinks that some 12 year olds online is the Vietnamese voice, kinda trigger me tbh most of the good part is just working, living and trying to contribute to make the country greater and then there's toxic 12 year olds who think they're our voice making hate comments.
Nice video. Love from Laos
Nice video, I hope both Thai and Vietnamese don't fight over this video. We are not enemy, our enemy is big guy up north.
No. Thailand bow to China already.
@@HaiPhan-1107 Well then, you know nothing about Thai international politic.
Doesnt china have several SEZes with 100 year lease terms in Vietnam?
Yes, it is China 🇨🇳
Enemy china
So how about a Malaysian-Indonesian war in modern times cause they did had a war back in the 1960s and a Saudi-Iranian war sounds cool the two big militaries in the middle east go at each other.
Also i like how Binkov calls the Thai Army as the Thigh Army mmmmmppphhhhh...now that's an army
Malaysia would lose most likely. Indonesia's GDP and population way overshadow Malaysia's.
Turkey: *laughs in regional hegemony*
@@Joker-yw9hl Saudi Arabia has more money and a more modern military
Btw there is video for Saudi Arabia and Iran
Binkov need to consider this
But remember one thing, vietnamese troops are pretty crafty and can made traps from common stuff we use
Late comment, but a small clarification on the 5 million Paramilitary Security units Vietnam has: those troops are always only for defensive use. There would be none of them in the Vietnamese push towards Thailand unless some of them are conscripted.
I heard about the 11 times the Vietnamese army accidentally cross Thai border and the government ordered the patriotic last stand
Rồi nói vậy chi?
4:42 The *Thigh* Army
How do I join?
Hahaha nice one
Loool u funny man i love you
As Vietnameses, war is never an option for us. If possible, we would make as many friends as we could.
Gặp Việt cộng mấy anh Thái chỉ có chạy thôi 😎
Yo Vietcong would wiped them all you know. TALKING TREES
We'll Trading together
@@nguyenkimvv7686 Đùa chẳng vui gì hết
I love how the comments are just like "why would we fight we can just have a violent football game and that can be used to determine who wins lol
Both countries maintain peaceful bilateral relations today, but they do share historical rivalry in the past.
Laos and Cambudia : Why we stil here just to suffer?
Laos would not have as much suffer because of their mountainous terrain so i'd say Cambodia would suffer worse dual to their more plain terrain
aren’t we just like this many years ago ???? smh
Geography and historical inabilities to form cohesive governments.
@Shimohira Reika when u looking for the helping of an other country for ur country problems, ur already lose.
@Shimohira Reika it's better not trying to oppose Vietnam as your lesson with Pol Pot still remains, and especially don't playing with China cause you will only hurt yourself, china cannot help you but Vietnam can and we are helping Cambodia at the moment,from training, education to investing. China investment on Cambodia is for china and they benefits from them most,not khmer who cannot controlled it
To be fair though, the majority of RTAF F-16 are fairly modern, while not all were up to the block 52 standards, most were at least updated to ADF (which mean they can fire AIM-120), there is really only a single square that is still in full A/B configuration so the ratio is more like 1/3 rather than 2/3.
Vietnam on the other hand though do have formal defence agreement with Laos. While they will most likely have to fight their way through Cambodia, over Laos they should be at no risk of direct intervention from the Laos military (and might even enjoy some support, had they honoured their agreement.) I think that was one factor you should factor in (not that it'll make much of a differences, Laos corridor really isn't great for military crossing)
How about making Hand Puppet Binkov’s instead of the plushies ? I’m pretty sure they’d be a huge hit. I know I’d buy one.
Please make video if INDONESIA vs MALAYSIA, because in fact there is a feeling of dislike between the two countries, especially between of their citizens, and that caused by the past history.
and in 1962-1966 Indonesia tried to confront Malaysia
I think that will be a good video and will get a lot of views especially from that 2 countries.
And a war in the comment section lol.
@@commanderwaltz7388 definitely! Hhh
Moral of the story, don't fight. Let's be friends. lol
Army = congestion (narrow corridors)
Navy = distance (staging areas to battlefront)
Airforce = cannot conduct air superiority missions in enemy airspace.
ชนะหรือแพ้ไม่รู้ ? แต่ในฐานะคนไทยคนหนึ่งก็คงไม่ยอมแพ้ง่ายๆหรอก เราก็ต่อสู้ปกป้องประเทศชาติของเราเหมือนกัน 🇹🇭❤️
người thailand bảo vệ pol pot và khmer đỏ và tự hào :))
@@TinTrong-jc8orใช่ และเรารู้สึกผิดกับการกระทำนั้นจนทุกวันนี้ ความจริงเราทำเพื่อป้องกันตัวจากคอมมิวนิสเท่านั้น
We do it because in that era we not want to be communist hope you understand
Việt Nam and Thailand are trusted friends and partners, we should always live in harmony and sympathy
Vietnam: Let they tremble before our might.
Thailand: I am gay.
Vietnam: Sorry.Just a misunderstanding. Stay right there !!!
Switzerland VS Italy would be interesting ngl
Yes
Early on the Swiss would have a massive advantage, but it would die out later on. The Swiss have a virtually equal army in size, but have 1.5 million men in reserves, while Italy has 18,000 in reserves.
The air war would break Switzerland
@@marcofava Air Defense in Switzerland isn't that bad as far as I'm concerned. Especially considering the system in the Alps.
@@oof5020 but italy has 8 regiments (recruited regionally until 2000s ) of mountain warfare troops, a bigger and more modern air force (while still using AMX and Tornados, it has Eurofighters and F35s) and a average bigger caliber and range artillery (and A LOT of light-weight howitzer for mountain war). Italy need simply to stay safe and advance slowly through the mountain while keeping Swiss army under constant fire. It will take time and it will not be bloodless, but Italy could take Switzerland with not too much effort.
Funfact: mules were still used sometimes by the Italian army (last one died in 2019). They can carry a lot of weight (over 150Kg) and move through rough terrain quite easily. Even the US Army used mules on the Afghan Mountains.
Laos and Cambodia:We feel like Belgium
Tôi lại tưởng giống poland
The entire ASEAN : Da fuck they are doing over there?
Cambodia and Laos both have closer ties to the Vietnamese in terms of military ties so they will just let the Vietnamese go on without interference
War with Vietnam is suicidal term, vietnam in 1979 could handle Khmer Rouge and Chinese invasion at the same time
@@PumpkinEater-dm1xx yeah I agree our country Thailand have modern tanks like vt-4 tanks and t-84 oplot and more
China vs ASEAN without US or Commonwealth interference.
One Sean should be able to take on a few measly countries.😎
China wouldn't even be able to take Vietnam, but they can probably take South Korea by bribing Moon Jae-in.
One Chinese fleet outweighs the entire ASEAN fleet.
@@markhenley3097 I doubt China would try to take Vietnam in the first place. They have failed multiple invasions throughout history all under the same circumstances.
@@LOL-zu1zr Certainly true but they've got some subs and aircraft enough to cause problems, though Hainan would likely be turned into a massive airbase
as a Filipino I'm laughing my ass out why the heck would they go to war
for real, even I don't know why
At old time both countries used to have war against each other to snatch Laos and Cambodia. I dont know about Vietnam but that war result a very long man made canal as envidence in Bangkok nowaday is became a very important for everyday life public transportation.
thats why this is a hypothetical scenario...
Believe it or not there is probably a scenario if war does break out
@@anhtunguyen781 me too bro😂😂
Thailand and vietnam are friends.make peace forever together.love thailand and hope visit thailand once on the future.from vietnam with love
Binkov: Come here little one
Me: Bruh he's literally the same size as you
Thailand's reserve troops do train, but not each year so far I am aware. It's more a refreshment course so far I understood from my Thai friend who is actually currently serving in the Thai army.
Thailand does have huge pontoons that can be converted to floating bridges, this however would cause trash to pile up in Bangkok severely. Which is likely not the best idea for morale.
Gripens are far more potent fighters then you realize, in the hands of good pilots those 11 fighters will tear the opposition to shreds. The air war is likely fairly quickly won by Thailand for that reason. Also the Gripens could be equipped to attack shipping which makes it harder for Vietnam to get near Thai shores. It will more be a stick to keep the Vietnamese at a distance.
I don't think Vietnam will risk a all out war with 3 of it's neighbors as it will be suicide pretty much, this also is the case for Thailand. Going trough China would become a massacre as the Chinese covered all borders there with a lot of their troops.
Thailand is definitely not Vietnam's enemy though, their true rival is Ch*ina due to the South China Sea conflict.
@@bbalziery3697 That's right, bro, even Southeast Asia is hostile to China, because China arbitrarily claims the territory of other countries.
Love thailand from việt nam 🇹🇭🇻🇳🤝🏽🇻🇳🇹🇭
I love you too.
Yes a
@kubin sexy bad girl damn
👌
Great video as always, it would be quite interesting if we could see an analysis of an hypotetical conflict in Balkans as Serbia VS Croatia.
Or maybe a conflict in Middle East as "What if Modern Day Iraqi Army fought the Gulf War"
TBH, the only reason Cambodia and Laos exist for such a long time, is because Thai and Viet have beef which each other. Therefore, buffer states between 2 of them is prefered
Laos and Cambodia: Why am I here just to suffer?
@Shimohira Reika naw - Cambodia will still suffer. No country or superpower is going to directly intervene two warring nations over a proxy battlefield.
Better off sitting back and applying economic pressure than putting boots on the ground. Unfortunately that means a lot of dead civilians.
@@davidluong8370 actually China attack Vietnam over Cambodia
Mekong River has dried up from countless dam on the upper stream of the river from china to laos so this day we can easily drive pickup truck cross some part of the Mekong River especially in the summer when the water level drop very low that can even walk cross the river
Sad that the entire video got demonetized :(
Can you do a scenario about the American's invading Cuba during the Cuban Missile Crisis without Allies and nukes except for the tactical nukes the Russians had in Cuba to be used against an American invasion and the Russians who were in Cuba at the time?
Bruh it's already a given that Cuba would lose, Plus not to mention Cuba isn't really gonna be effective on defense, even if they do somehow to have a defense it wouldn't be too long due to them heavily rely on the soviets for armaments, so it would be a lose lose to Cuba rather than a lose lose to both sides...
@@Donpru still will be interesting to watch
The US would definitely respond to any Soviet use of tactical nukes with our own tactical nukes.
I've always thought the Soviet, and now Russian, thoughts about using tactical nukes as weird, as if assuming only they will use them. Or maybe they don't assume that and are just willing to suffer the casualties.
it would end in nuclear war
@@argosime that's why I said no nukes and allies. The US can't use their nukes and the Russians can't get involved. The Russian tactical nukes as well as the soldiers the Soviet Union sent to Cuba at the time are exemptions in my scenario request
Thailand backs the Polpot genocide regime. Fortunately for Thailand, the Vietnamese army had no intention of entering Bangkok.
In the end, after all, the pain in our arses is Cambodia. 😂
@Shimohira Reika You wouldn't be here to type these ungrateful words if VPA wasn't there. 😂
TV personality Quyền Linh's project on the Giếng Tiên Culture Complex has begun in Châu Thành District, the southern province of Sóc Trăng.
Linh has invested VNĐ200 billion (US$8.6 million) into the five-year project to preserve and promote the culture and religion of Khmer ethnic minority group.
Just look at the way how your people treat the Vietnamese people in Cambodia. Very ungrateful.
@Shimohira Reika i see, so Vietnam was the evil when helping u guy from Polpot? I guess none of ur relatives was killed by Polpot, lucky for u.
@@HS-jt2fl .You're right . We made a mistake in saving Cambodia's ungrateful people. they will pay the price for that ungratefulness
If VN never help the KR there would not no killing field and Lon Nol would have won. The root was in Vietnam since uncle Ho in the 1950 with pol pot
Thais that never heard about this channel until this video :
Lets us present ourselves.
ใครจะไปรู้
Who else is from cambodia ?🇰🇭🙏❤️. Let hope it's not happen