FYI: All clips used in here are all 100% live! Also I just missed that one Love Takes Time clip 😭 She actually did the C5 in first chorus (WAS bliiiIiiIind)
@@Misterdeverauxif lambs see Mariah as a human, they need to stop defining her by her high notes. I love when Mariah sings what feels right rather than what is expected of her. Mariah is human but she needs to be treated like one, rather than this machine that's supposed to hurl out F#s and Gs every night. They also need to stop calling her a lyric. It's ridiculous at this point.
You can’t sound great if you are in a bad place emotionally. Body and soul really affect each other. It must be really hard for her, she is after a break up, she will sound better when she’s gonna feel better❤
I don't understand why some people say she can't sing anymore. She's not in her prime but she can still sing better than some of the so-called singers of today. Her voice is definitely improving too, this 2024 era seems soo good!
Keep in mind. She’s older and she has nodules. She never had the nodules taken out so sometimes, even if she’s really well wested, her nodules will get in the way. Plus, she spent years singing THROUGH her nodules.
@@dayzour123 she definitely sang more than 20% Id say she sang more like 60% or 50% because yes a lot was lipped but a good chunk of it was live and yeah it might not be tired necessarily but more so just dry or raspy
This sounds like someone who doesn’t trust their voice and is testing the waters to gauge what she has to work with but also someone who is so afraid to mess up that she won’t even let herself reach her full potential bc she’s so inhibited. And perhaps the most concerning thing of all, this sounds like someone who’s heart just isn’t in it. Idk what her road is like right now, but the voice itself sounds healthier and more natural than it has in a few years, I think she really just doesn’t have enough faith in her voice bc it doesn’t sound like she isn’t capable of doing more vocally, it sounds like she’s having doubts at the last second and retreating. Im sure the breakup is affecting her and maybe other things, but she doesn’t look happy on that stage. Maybe she needs to take some time for herself. Wishing this wonderful woman the very best.
Decades ago never would I have thought that I would see the light of day where the Lambilies are yassing over vocal squeaks & creaks & labelling them as legit notes 💀☠️
She is a legend and she has done her contribution to music and to us, we enjoy her songs no matter what. theyre just beautiful. Imagine the pressure shes had for all this time to sing high notes over and over and overrrr again. for yeaars! Concerts, tours, gigs.. man Im happy this woman can even speak!
this wasn't bad actually,her phrasing here is so good that 2023 can't even do(except for Merry Christmas One and All) and yeah her confidence is growing too and i see some comments that her Xmas tour was better but because she basically singing 6 song with much live vocals, while this concert she's literally singing more live than her Xmas tour and attempting more notes that she's much afraid to attempt back in earlier 2023 and this is a good start of the year and i remember she had a cold after the tour you can hear it actually when she post singing all i want for christmas is you with her children and i hope that she have a world tour again!!!!!
@@StanEdits. Shake it off???? Only "It's like that" that shooked me the most because she's hitting every note in that song(except for "cause it's baby baby“)
She is not stable vocally or mentally, but it is not a bad start for this year, we must be sure that she will improve little by little and that in future performances she will be much more confident.
Hasn't she been expected to improve over the course of 2023? The best vocals we got from her since her return to live singing in 2022 is the Global Citizen rehersal
Wow it's so great to see her performing full songs again. When last! Like the full emotions etc... This was good. I don't expect much from her now because she's done A LOT. she just gotta have fun on stage and sing her songs with enjoyment that's it.
What i still dont understand is why shes doing all these shows instead of recovering and trying to work on hee voice instead of making it worse. But i digress
Yes, she need full rest for her voice, and comeback again when she release her lead single for next album. I'm afraid with the condition of her voice after 2021 2024 is improve, but I need her more rest and take care with her voice
Contracts, she still signed to a music label so she has to make money for her label and the best way is to do concerts since streaming isn’t as profitable as selling CDs and Vinyl’s
‘slayed’ is an hyperbole. she did her best. at least it’s better then #that era lmfao. she just got out of tour. she needs to rest. she didn’t sing live ALL the time, but when she did, she put in effort to sing well. with her vocal state, we can’t just expect her to deliver continuously. yeah her instrument is picky but hey it’s life 😁
How are people not able to understand that on top of the nodules, her voice is simply maturing. You can literally tell in the opening of the video that her comfortable speaking range is substantially lower, and exceptionally dark and husky.
Probably not sing her songs like she did on record. I always feel like she should have taken a more Whitney approach when it comes to recording. Recording the songs fairly straight. But going all out and doing what you want on stage. But because her material is recorded the way it is its just so hard to replicate live and doesn't leave her much room to improvise and play around with notes
@@ryanallen8455it hasn’t prevented her from experimenting with her musicality tho also we can’t blame her. she is extra and is known for her vocal s**c*de songs, her range, her versatility, her agility !! (for some, her lyricism ) idk whitney’s discography much but i feel like mariah’s stands out more. whitney’s most outstanding asset was her voice (other than the music)
Mimi is clearly afraid to take risks vocally in her current state, I even think that she wanted to attempt tye E flat in "it's like that" but she chickened out
We're off to a good start at least, she did so good in It's Like That and One Sweet Day, no pushy/tense midbelts and she's very slowly working on regaining strength in her upper range. Emotions was so good too, she's clearly training which is a relief.
im only realizing now 💀 ppl been said this, but her dynamics/volume control are non existant when she belts « high ». it’s as if she had to shout to hit a C5 🥲
There are a number of unknowns in considering surgery on her vocal folds. Best scenario: more reliable voice, smoother, whistle intact. Other scenarios: might lose access to whistle register, might sound too different post-surgery to her original voice despite improved ease in singing, or might permanently damage voice like Julie Andrews. In her position, though, I would consider it, since my voice has already changed, anyway, and my career is made. Continuing to sing with unreliable vocals would just be hurting my legacy and credibility as an artist.
Hear me out. Do her fans care if shes singing live? I would be ok with a spectacle and believable lip sync of classics. Maybe she can do 2 songs live that she can still sing unstrained but I saw her at LA Pride and it was kind of a mess 😢
that's becuase her voice get easily tired and if were talking about Xmas tour yeah it's much better but she barely even singing until emotions to make it happen while in this concert she's singing live much more and attempting some notes that 2023 can't
Hero and LTT sounds just beautiful. That chick is great. As a lamb from more than 2 decades, I'd say that she doesn't sound bad, she just need to retire those songs she can no longer keep up with. Emotions should go because it's embarrassing. Same for One sweet day.
Much better than MC-AG vocals video It is very noticeable that that channel is a hater disguised as a "fan" and he even worsened the audio quality of the videos. In this video you can hear it much better, you can better appreciate the quality of Mariah's voice, it was a little raspy but she tried to sing notes that a few months ago she didn't try, although I still say that her current technique seems very bad to me
@@animatroniczone pretty much. she can't predict how her voice will be sounding during the actual show, so she just has the tracks just in case. sometimes she'll sing over the track if her voice is in good shape, though
Fun fact - after Rainbow Tour she’s lipped every whistle that make the lead vocal of a song. The only exceptions I can think of to that were the Never Too Far performances, the song Caution and the GMA rehearsal of Beautiful. Every other live whistle was either improvised or an adlib (like VOL) rather than being built into the song.
Unfortunately she is lip syncing for 99% of the show. Not in these clips. But there is nothing fantastic here. Even her sad 2014 version was doing better. I hope everything is alright. We no longer have falsetto transitions or belts. Her voice is dry and she seems very afraid to push.
Love Mariah and will always be a fan but as fans, we're scared to admit she struggles to sing even just a sentence in a song without it sounds straned or out of breath. It's not about age cos she's in her mid 50s and that is still young. It's the fact that she needs to rearrange her songs to fit her current sound/voice. Half of the time I think she doesn't even know if the part coming up is pre-recorded. This on top of her being lazy on the stage. Maybe she could stick to acoustic performances.
She needs some serious vocal exercises to fine tune her instrument. Mariah has always sang her songs the way an instrument would play it. Vocal rest is good for rest and recovery, but what about the training?
FYI: All clips used in here are all 100% live!
Also I just missed that one Love Takes Time clip 😭 She actually did the C5 in first chorus (WAS bliiiIiiIind)
0:48 isn't that D5 because everytime she attempts it back then mariahxlambily always often label them as D5
yeah i just see it from another angle she did the B4 instead the D5
I don't understand why some people say that she can't sing anymore. She's not in her prime anymore but she can sing.
it’s probably based on the overall state of her voice
ive seen this exact comment like 2 times now i think we get it bestie or r u being paid 😭
@@MariahIsolatedy’all are too overcritical
They simply don’t understand she’s human ! Plus lambs don’t see Mimi as human it’s disgusting !
@@Misterdeverauxif lambs see Mariah as a human, they need to stop defining her by her high notes. I love when Mariah sings what feels right rather than what is expected of her. Mariah is human but she needs to be treated like one, rather than this machine that's supposed to hurl out F#s and Gs every night. They also need to stop calling her a lyric. It's ridiculous at this point.
You can’t sound great if you are in a bad place emotionally. Body and soul really affect each other. It must be really hard for her, she is after a break up, she will sound better when she’s gonna feel better❤
oof yeah i keep forgetting that
maybe that’s why her voice got the way it was in 98
@@whoevr yes, she was under a lot pf stress during the 1997-2001 period. Also in 2008 her voice sounded very dry - she had a miscarriage…
And yet she sounded here best since 2020
I don't understand why some people say she can't sing anymore. She's not in her prime but she can still sing better than some of the so-called singers of today. Her voice is definitely improving too, this 2024 era seems soo good!
Because standards have always been high for Mariah. People compare her once limitless voice to how her voice is now and it's a drastic change.
@@AnonymousXtinaSinger yes definitely!
because it sounds quite bad
Omg she can do this song anymore wow sad
Omg hero was horrible not good at all
Strong C#5s😍
Omg E5!
I'm already loving the 2024 Era
she’s doing more falsetto transitions than during the christmas tour
She's truly come a long way since Xmas 2022...I hope her voice stays like this and this isn't just a good phase her voice is going through
Keep in mind. She’s older and she has nodules. She never had the nodules taken out so sometimes, even if she’s really well wested, her nodules will get in the way. Plus, she spent years singing THROUGH her nodules.
I think her voice is tired again from all those shows but she's clearly still going strong with the C5’s so I'm here for it
She lipped 80% of her Christmas shows her voice should not be that tired
She doesn't sound tired to me, she just sounds dry
Naa not this year she sang more live I would say 60%
@@dayzour123 she definitely sang more than 20% Id say she sang more like 60% or 50% because yes a lot was lipped but a good chunk of it was live and yeah it might not be tired necessarily but more so just dry or raspy
This sounds like someone who doesn’t trust their voice and is testing the waters to gauge what she has to work with but also someone who is so afraid to mess up that she won’t even let herself reach her full potential bc she’s so inhibited. And perhaps the most concerning thing of all, this sounds like someone who’s heart just isn’t in it. Idk what her road is like right now, but the voice itself sounds healthier and more natural than it has in a few years, I think she really just doesn’t have enough faith in her voice bc it doesn’t sound like she isn’t capable of doing more vocally, it sounds like she’s having doubts at the last second and retreating. Im sure the breakup is affecting her and maybe other things, but she doesn’t look happy on that stage. Maybe she needs to take some time for herself. Wishing this wonderful woman the very best.
0:05 I got so excited…
Decades ago never would I have thought that I would see the light of day where the Lambilies are yassing over vocal squeaks & creaks & labelling them as legit notes 💀☠️
She is a legend and she has done her contribution to music and to us, we enjoy her songs no matter what. theyre just beautiful.
Imagine the pressure shes had for all this time to sing high notes over and over and overrrr again. for yeaars! Concerts, tours, gigs.. man Im happy this woman can even speak!
Her tone is giving caution🫶
Okay i was scared for a second: shes still hanging okay mariahhh ❤
the head voice/falsetto really shocked when was the last time she used it
Thank god we have decent footage from this concert 🥹
so many C#5!!!
Her C#5s are becoming so clear and effortless
Really thought she was going to do the Eb5s in It's Like That help😭
this wasn't bad actually,her phrasing here is so good that 2023 can't even do(except for Merry Christmas One and All) and yeah her confidence is growing too and i see some comments that her Xmas tour was better but because she basically singing 6 song with much live vocals, while this concert she's literally singing more live than her Xmas tour and attempting more notes that she's much afraid to attempt back in earlier 2023 and this is a good start of the year and i remember she had a cold after the tour you can hear it actually when she post singing all i want for christmas is you with her children and i hope that she have a world tour again!!!!!
Also the fact that there's 15 C#5's in this concert,she's already eating up earlier 2023 or whole 2023
@@StanEdits. Shake it off???? Only "It's like that" that shooked me the most because she's hitting every note in that song(except for "cause it's baby baby“)
she sang one sweet day much better than 2023 😭
She is not stable vocally or mentally, but it is not a bad start for this year, we must be sure that she will improve little by little and that in future performances she will be much more confident.
Hasn't she been expected to improve over the course of 2023? The best vocals we got from her since her return to live singing in 2022 is the Global Citizen rehersal
@@SPexHoS2137Huh no, the best vocals we got are from December 2023 if we ignore the first few dates
@@MariahIsolated could you tell me which renditions you were impressed by, so I can look them up?
@@SPexHoS2137pretty the other two dates that weren’t in madison square garden were miles better
@@anornpath1587Boston and Philadelphia were great, Pittsburgh too from what we have!
the hv and transitions!!!
Wow it's so great to see her performing full songs again. When last! Like the full emotions etc... This was good. I don't expect much from her now because she's done A LOT. she just gotta have fun on stage and sing her songs with enjoyment that's it.
how are people still complaining about her vocals even in 2018, 2019, it’s always every year 💀
hasnt it been like that since 1997 😹 just jobless people because the fans enjoy this but if they dont then just dont watch...
@@WhitneyElizabethHouston.hating since 1997 is insanity like 😭
As soon as she started to have her vocal issues in like 1997 they won't let her escape this “she lost her 90’s voice ” narrative even in the 90’s 💀
The emotions live tho damnn she still got it!!
This is really good to be honest
WE NEED
Yassss Mariahhh
it's like that got more c#5s than emotions in comparison with the xmas shows woww im shookt
❤❤❤ voir Mariah Carey tellement belle souriant charmante belle femme Carey mimi Love you fan Sandrine french 🇨🇵
What i still dont understand is why shes doing all these shows instead of recovering and trying to work on hee voice instead of making it worse. But i digress
Yes, she need full rest for her voice, and comeback again when she release her lead single for next album.
I'm afraid with the condition of her voice after 2021
2024 is improve, but I need her more rest and take care with her voice
Contracts, she still signed to a music label so she has to make money for her label and the best way is to do concerts since streaming isn’t as profitable as selling CDs and Vinyl’s
And now another run of shows to fuck her voice up even more 😂
@@agusfaizal6638she doesn't need no more rest. What she really needs is getting back to performing and working with a good singing teacher
❤❤❤
‘slayed’ is an hyperbole. she did her best. at least it’s better then #that era lmfao.
she just got out of tour. she needs to rest. she didn’t sing live ALL the time, but when she did, she put in effort to sing well. with her vocal state, we can’t just expect her to deliver continuously. yeah her instrument is picky but hey it’s life 😁
SHE IS ALREADY GIVING 2024
ate
How are people not able to understand that on top of the nodules, her voice is simply maturing. You can literally tell in the opening of the video that her comfortable speaking range is substantially lower, and exceptionally dark and husky.
What matters the most hitting the note or singing the note properly 💀💀
She is a legend regardless ❤
HER TONE SOUNDS 2019 CHRISTMAS TOUR
And kinda looks like one too 😭
This actually wasn't as bad as I originally thought😭
Yass 😍
@@DaydreamCarey1234 the way you changed my mind😍
@@Fishriah_Ari As i should 💅💅💅
At times I imagine if we showed the current Mariah to young Mariah, what would she do, vocally speaking
"Great gowns"
Probably not sing her songs like she did on record. I always feel like she should have taken a more Whitney approach when it comes to recording. Recording the songs fairly straight. But going all out and doing what you want on stage. But because her material is recorded the way it is its just so hard to replicate live and doesn't leave her much room to improvise and play around with notes
@@daydreameraY’ALL 😭
@@ryanallen8455it hasn’t prevented her from experimenting with her musicality tho
also we can’t blame her. she is extra and is known for her vocal s**c*de songs, her range, her versatility, her agility !! (for some, her lyricism )
idk whitney’s discography much but i feel like mariah’s stands out more. whitney’s most outstanding asset was her voice (other than the music)
@@ryanallen8455imagine Whitney was known for one or two takes. And Mariah is in there for 100 takes just for honey alone? 😬😬😬😬😬😬
Eu acredito que Mariah Carey esta mais confiante do que nunca
Mimi is clearly afraid to take risks vocally in her current state, I even think that she wanted to attempt tye E flat in "it's like that" but she chickened out
tone is giving 2015 rn
We're off to a good start at least, she did so good in It's Like That and One Sweet Day, no pushy/tense midbelts and she's very slowly working on regaining strength in her upper range. Emotions was so good too, she's clearly training which is a relief.
im only realizing now 💀 ppl been said this, but her dynamics/volume control are non existant when she belts « high ». it’s as if she had to shout to hit a C5 🥲
the “its like that” i feel like she was gonna hit the Eb5 but she didnt last second
She's felt insecurity.
Where did you get these clips?
Twitter and instagram mostly 😭
There are a number of unknowns in considering surgery on her vocal folds. Best scenario: more reliable voice, smoother, whistle intact. Other scenarios: might lose access to whistle register, might sound too different post-surgery to her original voice despite improved ease in singing, or might permanently damage voice like Julie Andrews. In her position, though, I would consider it, since my voice has already changed, anyway, and my career is made. Continuing to sing with unreliable vocals would just be hurting my legacy and credibility as an artist.
Hear me out. Do her fans care if shes singing live? I would be ok with a spectacle and believable lip sync of classics. Maybe she can do 2 songs live that she can still sing unstrained but I saw her at LA Pride and it was kind of a mess 😢
Sounded a bit hoarser than Xmas 2023
she's probably still recovering from the tour
OMG a fellow sailor moon fan + lamb
@@venteanarime three ^_^
@@venteanari She barely sang during the last tour, there is nothing to recover from. It was just a not-good day for her voice.
that's becuase her voice get easily tired and if were talking about Xmas tour yeah it's much better but she barely even singing until emotions to make it happen while in this concert she's singing live much more and attempting some notes that 2023 can't
I’m That Chick supremacy
Okay not too bad, sounds like she was drinking over the holidays drying out those chords! Some great c#5s tho
and the Whistle notes?
She somehow barely does those since France 2023 😭 But her belts are stronger compared to 2022.
PAUSE. We got a Im that chick moment????
Yes @Im That Chick!!! She needs to start opening up her catalogue. It’ll give people less to talk about. Doing the same songs doesn’t work anymore.
Hero and LTT sounds just beautiful. That chick is great. As a lamb from more than 2 decades, I'd say that she doesn't sound bad, she just need to retire those songs she can no longer keep up with. Emotions should go because it's embarrassing. Same for One sweet day.
Much better than MC-AG vocals video It is very noticeable that that channel is a hater disguised as a "fan" and he even worsened the audio quality of the videos. In this video you can hear it much better, you can better appreciate the quality of Mariah's voice, it was a little raspy but she tried to sing notes that a few months ago she didn't try, although I still say that her current technique seems very bad to me
They fastly released a vocal video. There was very little content on the internet. Only fans do this.
@@viniciusvarella3965 I know, OP is jumping to conclusions for some reason.
i’m confused on why she lips the whistles so much especially on emotions aren’t those often stronger for her?
I think she generally lips anything the song 'relies' on structurally (the long note in Hero, whistles in Emotions, climax of WBT).
@@heeheeriah is it just to play it safe basically
@@animatroniczone pretty much. she can't predict how her voice will be sounding during the actual show, so she just has the tracks just in case. sometimes she'll sing over the track if her voice is in good shape, though
Fun fact - after Rainbow Tour she’s lipped every whistle that make the lead vocal of a song. The only exceptions I can think of to that were the Never Too Far performances, the song Caution and the GMA rehearsal of Beautiful. Every other live whistle was either improvised or an adlib (like VOL) rather than being built into the song.
@@Solo-vh9fm there were some live whistles like don’t forget about us and fly like a bird
The vocals are not bad, what bothers me is that she seems tired and out of breath sometimes
2024riah already ate 2006
💀
Do you realise its all live even the High parts the other parts areher normal speak voice
i think she must be get off this nodules
Unfortunately she is lip syncing for 99% of the show. Not in these clips. But there is nothing fantastic here. Even her sad 2014 version was doing better. I hope everything is alright. We no longer have falsetto transitions or belts. Her voice is dry and she seems very afraid to push.
HELP I'M THAT CHICK???? I DIDN'T KNOW SHE DID THAT😭
Gurl- 😭
@@DaydreamCarey1234 I didn't see the full concert leave me alone😞
Mariah is going through a breakup so her confidence is lower than usual
Love Mariah and will always be a fan but as fans, we're scared to admit she struggles to sing even just a sentence in a song without it sounds straned or out of breath. It's not about age cos she's in her mid 50s and that is still young. It's the fact that she needs to rearrange her songs to fit her current sound/voice. Half of the time I think she doesn't even know if the part coming up is pre-recorded. This on top of her being lazy on the stage. Maybe she could stick to acoustic performances.
I think she needs to rest after performing throughout the holidays she seems tired she seems to be struggling
I wish she stop performing live, MC the living legend needs to focus on a new character in life.
She needs some serious vocal exercises to fine tune her instrument. Mariah has always sang her songs the way an instrument would play it. Vocal rest is good for rest and recovery, but what about the training?
Oh wow what happened she can’t really sing anymore so sad 😔
Yikes…..
Most of C#5's are sharp C's. Funny are those people who compare Mariah to mediocre or bad singers to make her look good.