How Modi govt’s welfare schemes have changed rural lives: Ground Report from UP’s Unnao
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 04. 2024
- #ThePrintOnGround #loksabhaelection2024
How have Modi's welfare schemes changed the lives of rural families? ThePrint's Shubhangi Misra spent days with families in Uttar Pradesh's Unnao, to bring you this ground report.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read full article here: theprint.in/the-fineprint/two...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Finally Print is actually talking something that 99% of the people actually care
Fr, atleast once in a blue moon and also just enough to not get clubed into godi media
Upaye nahi, Babu bhi sab paise ka khel 😂 electronic media depends on TRP/Viewership 👍
UP?
Okay boss
@@anandgarhwal1421 Godi Media ??? . Tum log bhi toh Chate ho Rahul Pappu ka Gh#nd . like that German Shephard eating Congressi Biscuit .
Its really amazing that anti Modi and anti BJP THE PRINT has atleast appreciated ground level work done by Modi.
It is due to impending de-dollarization. Print has an imported ideology created by the west (the deep state) which wants to play soft ball with the present government due to the impending currency reset after 2025. So, the usual anti-BJP rhetoric are going to be toned down. eg Shiela Rashid - a notorious anti-bjp person is playing along with the BJP right now.
Print is not anti modi and anti bjp
The pro fake degree modi can watch propaganda fllms of Feku and jump like idiots. Ur 20 lakh suit adani dalal feku is an illiterate idiot who only does time pass whole day
Up is a big state. First congress ruled upto 1985, then bsp,so also ruled. If some one expect electrifying result then it should be asked to earlier rulers.
@@pravinzatakia6520 Bhakt are illiterate like their fake degree leader. Today we have better technology that too not something their illiterate inveneted. These idiots make excuses for their illiterate leaders incompetnce by comparing to 1970 and 1980s hahaha.
This is the level of WORK PM Modi has done.
Modi can't control local corruption but Direct benefits transfer has helped people.
Everything cannot be done by DBT. The local bodies and the State government should be made responsible for the speedy and corruption free implementation.
@@pichumanisankar2617 I agree. Modi has done his part by bringing schemes & DBT.
Nothing has changed
Corrupted buercracy
As an indian from other part , i feel horrible about them that how their govt doesnt change them, they are still living in 18th century.
Its good to bring modern things to people with the passage of time.
People cant live like 18th centuary in 21st centuary and dont say they are saving traditions atleast 😂.
Modi can't do everything he is the prime minister of india, look at other countries they can't deliver a dam thing to the people. I know if u show union govt they will make sure these people that should have got the benefits get the benefits and imprison those corrupt middlemen.
Who said that preserving mud houses meant safeguarding tradition? Not on this program, at least. Yes, corruption exists, but the scale of the issue is so vast that no matter the effort made, only a fraction of the populace can be addressed. If prior governments hadn't robbed resources through corruption and if politicians hadn't solely lined their pockets, the problem could have been significantly mitigated. Two factors are at play: size of the population and a sizeable portion of the population not earning wages. Indian rural folk lacks ambition. An ambitious individual would take any job to supplement his income, but many aspire solely for government positions for the promise of lifelong pensions, with work being merely incidental. They eschew jobs like domestic work due to perceived lack of dignity, even though wages are good, and there is a constant demand yet continue to live in substandard conditions without considering the loss of dignity. Dignity is in being able to elevate your living conditions.
This is what we want from Print. Ground level reality check. Appreciate the effort from the team. Unfortunate that schemes don’t reach each and every household. The upper and middle class should not ever forget this reality of rural Indian amid all the noise outside. This is our India after 75 years.
this will be the case even after 175 years if the low level corruption and caste discrimination is abolished.
Corruption is a major problem because all schemes are implemented by local level govenment administration and employees.
who is running local government, isn't that the Double engine mass murderer duo of modi and amit?
“Panchayati” raj was unrealistic
@@user-moye-moye sarpanchs were mostly scamsters frauds
Print sending staff to such remote places is very commendable. If possible, the print should give contract jobs to journalists born in similar backgrounds. It will create a few days of higher-level jobs in the village itself. Over the period they will develop skills, language, and confidence too.
wow that's a brilliant idea
such an amazing idea!!
start a blog and do it why ask a diff private enterprise to do your bidding
@@varunms850 audience
Much needed reality check for us Indians who live comfortably.
The horrible reality of India where the PM's schemes have reached but still denied due to local corruption & caste discrimination. Hindutva is so important to abolish caste discrimination. Unfortunately hindutva keeps getting bashed for trying to unite all Hindus.
HINDUTVA is to ensure caste hierarchy and not abolish caste discrimination
@@rehanahmad5056your muhammad was a pedo and so are most of your maulanas
@@rehanahmad5056 now a Muslim will teach us about hindutva wow 😂
@@Intellect_007seems like ur too blinded and it has had to come to that
@@adarshs4553 really have you even read Savarkar do you even know what’s hindutva your BS propaganda is the reason why opposition losses. Gone are the days when you can divide us on the basis of caste. Yes there are still problems not denying that. But bring 1960s caste politics is gonna hurt your side.
Low level corruption destroys all well laid development policies
That how political parties are funded.Local political strongman extract money from welfare schemes for their personal and political benefits.
Nothing has changed
Corrupted buercracy
As an indian from other part , i feel horrible about them that how their govt doesnt change them, they are still living in 18th century.
Its good to bring modern things to people with the passage of time.
People cant live like 18th centuary in 21st centuary and dont say they are saving traditions atleast 😂.
Should definitely send this report to the prime Minister asap. Need more of such work to be done. In every state, district. If need we as a public can fund such initiatives
Kudos for making an effort to understand rural India with an open mind without any prejudices and pre-conceived notions. This is what journalists are supposed to do. Congrats to Print for this episode.
I think only 4 crores houses were built in 10 years, more 3 cores will follow in next 5 years. It is impossible to build everyone's house in short span. They will get the house eventually.
@@VOLTuwu usa ko b 300 saal lge idr pahunchne me
5 saal me atleast 3rd largest economy toh bnenge
policies implement krna mushkil h mzk bnana asaan.
gawar kahin ka.
@@VOLTuwu haan bhosdi he, tere pappu ki family ne tp india ko kypton bana diya tha
Indeed shameful that after so many years of Independence, there is abject poverty and hunger still in the Villages. Wasn’t Roti, Kapda aur Makan a slogan some decades back .. and yet successive governments playing vote bank politics haven’t delivered. 😢..
Mainly local lever corruption should be taken off and then these schemes will transfer directly…
Atleast as of now 90% people are benefitting from the schemes ..
Now government should give contract to these individual
@@indiavspakisthanmatches5493 that's what modi and bjp did, by making everyone open bank accounts. So that people can get money directly in bank accounts.
Secondly if anyone openly claims that they didn't get complete money, or some consession was given to someone....
Than agencies should round up the corrupt person and take actions against him/her/them on rural level as well.
ThePrint I support the ground zero journalism……..the only thing this reporter is missing is in the knowledge of thing she want to analyse ….a)PM Gram sadak yojana was launched in 2000 Not in 2014
b)It is centrally sponsored scheme …meaning funding to the tune of 40 % (general states) 10 % NE and Himalayan states need to be borne by respective states….
c)It is implemented by state govt via District Rural Development Agencies (so again onus of delay or lack of development lies on states )
d)also problem of land acquisition and requisition at ground level further makes the implementation murkier…..so long and short of this is You CANNOT and SHOULD NOT reduce the complexities of implementation on ground level to reason as “casteism’’
e)Also 3Lakh KMs of road was constructed under this scheme during 2016 to 2022 i.e in 6 years vis a vis 1.88 lakh KMs in 2009 to 2014 .
I know everything is NOT hunk dory in Modi regime yet it is way far better than previous UPA regime …..
Government Giving dignity to human life. The Print giving dignity to generalism
The Print, thank you for showing the real face of India.
Marvelous reporting. Such ground reports help build democracy. Keep up the good work, Print.
Such journalism is rare to find these days.
Thanks to print.
In my area the food grain distributor takes 1 KG from everyone that is one gets only 4 KG per month. Also in PM Awas you have to give some money like 10K to 20K to the Village head/pradhan/mukhiya. I am from Bihar and this system is in all places near my district no exceptions.
Same from Bengal , we call it cut-money
In Odisha people need to pay bribe in advance during paperwork, or the BDO/PM Awas Block coordinator/ Civil JE etc would not pass and forward the paperwork. Because the Central Grant is directly debited to directly to the bank a/c of beneficiaries via DBT, the corrupt state level officials take bribe in advance. The BDO collects cuts (also PC) from all block level staff and sends his cut to the DM/Collector who then sends all PC collection directly upstairs to State CM. That's how the clean and honest government of Naveen Patnaik is running Odisha for more than quarter of a century. Modi gives and Naveen takes his cut in advance from the public because he owns the state machinery responsible for executing the welfare schemes. Modi can't scrutinize too closely because BJP doesn't have a clear majority in Rajya Sabha. Also, what can he do when the people keep electing the same government for 25 years.
@@acswain6720 will not matter if your state elects other party this system of corrouption is in genes of Indians. Even dalit will exploit other dalit if he becomes officer
Complain karo
@@mountolympus1098 I am not beneficiary bro.. most people here also are not eligible according to rule but are getting grains for free.
The schemes are much better than Congress, however, they can be much better!
Excellent work.... I hope the attention of CM and PM is drawn to such families who have been left out of these very useful schemes. I hope these families will be positively impacted by stories such as these.....
You mean 80% of UP..??
@@user-nm9qx8os9oand who give u that data
I am looking at the little Girl, she looks happy and better looked after , which is heartening to see.
This is real reporting from the ground. I wonder how many reporters are actually doing this now a days. Sitting at air conditioned studio and reading reports made by the corrupt officers will create an illusion of “acche din”. Modi has great schemes and vision but execution and implementation of these schemes are very poor where States Machinery is involved.
Every government should be criticised like this ..ground level work. .. wonderful...real jounalism
Good work. Video Should be tagged to PMO account so that they know how local level corrption is putting people not to enjoyy the benefits of the good policies due to caste discrimination. Reallyy sad to see this.
Really dude? All govt intelligence is sleeping? They know everything but they dont do sh*t
At last Lutyens Media is going out of their AC home
Wow.. remarkable coverage. Pls do more of this from across India. We need a strong third tier of government to solve complex local problems. Center and State can't solve them sitting at a distance
The print should also show the report card if its beloved Congress governments and rulings for past 65 year how Congress had retained the poverty even after poverty elevation programs.
Yogiji, sort out these panchayyat, rascals!
Yes ,most of the schemes reached 80% but we want 100% . Good development
Most of the Delhi based media thinks about rural India only in economic terms. But first time there is an effort to look at them as a "culture" which is praiseworthy.
10 saal ke baad Print ka batti jala hai. Itna saal kya so rahete
This is an amazing story, and great journalism. Goodjob print. more like this!!
Thank you to open up my eyes.. Though I claimed I have travelled across a India and stayed and lived villages, how shallow I was...
Brilliant questions and reporting. Thank you so much.
In the initial 15 years, when competitive politics was not as intense as it is today, Indian central and state governments could have hard-pushed to implement these basic fixes. Kind of a Chinese-type model to fix basics was possible in those exclusive politics.
Naya Desh tha, garam desh tha..jitna Paisa loot sakte the, loot liya sabne
Thank you for bringing this kind of ground reporting...block level corruption is keeping poor away from schemes.
Who is the reason for corruption with 97% taxes?? Speak abou that also
Modi
Ask your people in USA ,how much they pay their taxes. Development comes out from taxation, and not a tax dodgers like you.
Excellent reporting.
This is what people want to see and hear
thanks for this video the print
हांथ में स्मार्ट फोन है, फर्राटे से बोल रहा है,कोन कहेगा इसे गरीब,महिला कुछ बोलना चाह रही थी उसे रोक दिया इसे कहते है एजेंडा पत्रकारिता सब पहले से स्क्रिप्टेड होता है😂
Best journalism.....but why only during voting time. . ...i never seen documentary of Indian media on real issue. . . . . . If journalists do there job than political also accountable but sadly both have no pain for people of India thy busy with politicians and take part in corruption . . .why not asking issue related officer, grampradhan , block officer ,mp mla. . . .
Much needed video ❤
Very good reporting
out of all PRINT is talking about Modiji.
A pleasant surprise akka SHOCK
Good video. Shows what is done and what is still a challenge. Hope to see more like this.
India needs a huge, massive investment in people oriented policies such as education, healthcare, public services, governance. Modi is focussing on big ticket items and despite the mandate does not seem to focus on real issues.
Great work print
The problem is of corruption of elected representatives at local level. Unnecessary angle of caste discrimination should not be brought here. As it is neither possible nor can go unnoticed in govt. Offices.
Here in the United States we have schemes like habitat for humanity in which college students volunteer their time for building houses for the poor. The materials come from private companies. These voluntary hours are compulsory for admission to colleges. It also creates a sense of responsibility and empathy among students.
I wish we had such schemes in India too.
That's why welfare schemes are very important for our country.
Gems of reporting
If in govt account u already got house under Indira house, makes u disqualified for PMnivas
It pm awash yojna not Indira yojna
Thank you for this ground level reporting 🙏
The biggest problem of most Indians is that we don’t consider other Indians as our own. We are selfish and think only of ourselves. All these poor people for which our country gets the ‘land of poverty’ tag, have to suffer so much under the hands of corrupt and selfish officers. Even if the top level government makes ambitious decisions, without alleviating greed and corruption, it’s impossible to alleviate poverty. We need extremely strict legal schemes against corrupt individuals. The Indian legislative system also needs a complete overhaul. It’s unacceptable that it takes decades for justice to be meted out.
These are the stories media should cover. Kudos Print.
This is great reporting!
Good work by ThePrint.
Got an insight into the rural India.
But keep in mind that Dist.Unnao is one of the most deprived ones in India (₹60,000 per capita).
This is an extrimity.
They are so simple people live in our villages... And feel very sad for their condition😢😢😢😢...
Good to see these ground reports. Keep up the good work!
Please please show this documentary to Yogi Ji and PMO, I hope they do something about the lives of these villagers. We need digital tools to root out the corruption
Hope, Print Economic experts are looking at this video. Thanks once again🎉🎉
Excellent report from Print. What journalists should be doing, verify and report on facts not agendas.
Hats off for exposing the truth
Please come to meghalaya sister
I'm from Malaysia watching this.
Pls have major schemes to uplift the poor condition in all parts of India.
Govt must connect the schemes wt organisations which run by good souls.
The media should bring out more of such videos and bring to light local level corruption.
Good Work, Team Print...
I wonder what all the IAS are doing
True
CZcams / Insta pe motivational videos
the first case was the IAS lady asking for a bribe of 20k for the housing scheme.
They are now full time social media vlogger, part time influencer and in the remaining time motivational speaker.
@@wassuphomies263 I want to know how much she scored in GS 4
One of the best episodes... may be print can do a follow up after two years and send a copy of this video to CMs office
Yo go there, and speak in english around the villagers. What kind of role models those kids end up looking at. This is the kind of elite Nehru Gandhi family was raising - creating a class of brown englishmen. At least speak Hindi around them. I thought Modi was able to usher India in a country where citizens are proud of their culture and language. Jai Shree Ram.
wow , makes my contribution to print worth every penny
11:06- what creativity! 😍 She should use this skill to earn a living
The government has done good works so far on ground level but the problem lies in filling the gap and timely grievance redressal. Hopefully the coming days would be much better and we will see smart villages all across our nation☺
Good Job this is called journalism.
I cant imagine rahul gandhi hasn't done anything for this poor people
Bet TL 9.54 and 10.30 the lady shares such an important point about self respect dignity and hygieneThe Print didn't put the subtitles.why?
Please do more such shows
The Print and SG chatugiri at the best!
do these news channels have programs to sponsor education of these kids ? we can crowd fund and assist those families - its heartwrenching to see those kids lose hope
Good journalism❤
24:07 It truly moved me to tears
Everything is good but 12:11 is an eternal.conflict😂
Good work 👍
Print recognises development under NDA. Good to see.
Excellent coverage. The print needs to do more of this ground level reporting. Would be happy to become paid subscribers if theprint does more of this (and less of that IIPM guy).
Caste Discrimination and corruption is the major problem India is facing, Eventhough our govt applies better plans for poor people it wont get on the hand whom it has to be getten, I hope modi govt would take essential measures to change this crisis
There is so much demand for proper housing. Local and State government should focus on skill retraining in housing. They should teach them - about masonry work, carpentry work, build toilets, installing doors, windows, electric fans, AC units, building pucca terrace and roofs, build fences. All this should be done as per building codes also, so there should be permit requirement and there are no violations also . This will sustain regular employment in the long run also. This things the local politicians needs to fix this at the earliest.
Now that some cases are discussed in this video; will some action be taken? Hope you can report if some solution is found.
OmG shekar Gupta ji what is this !!!! Unlike you this team is speaking ground reality ..
From print? Surprising!!
The PM Schemes have definitely benefited the BJP (support) Heartland. He is a super CM of the BJP support heartland. It is good for the people no doubt.
The Print doing there real work, spreading propaganda, search for a poor village and make it that this is the whole situation across india. I dare you to show Reality of Amethi and Raibareli (bastion of Gandhi family for 70 years).
🙏🏽🙏🏽
Well done guys❤....this things should be more coverd...reality check to govt scems...so that message reache to the govt...modi govt has done well in providing dignity with toilet building schems but more things still needed to be done
The same
In my village, gam panchyat Mukhiya is very close to our family and a good man, he said in Indira awas yojna, there were 90% corruption, most of the money used to go to leaders, BDO even district magistrate had percentage. But the implementation in PM Modi awas Yojn a, its fabulous, leakage is almost none. Yes few officer does demand from bank some perks of 5000-10000 but that also not everywhere and now fear of corruption charges is high. And also its all DBT, so very difficult.
What a great ground reporting by The Print. Whenever other reporters have gone to the ground, they have always cherry picked issues to show BJP’s work in bad light and have often directly criticised Modi instead of criticising the mega corrupt babus and Sarpanchs and block heads.
If 10 years of Modi couldn’t weed out this corruption, if Indi alliance comes to power, it will be free ride
Why not Indira awas not given can any one answer before modi govt.
Can any one conform that people are only Indians or infiltrarors
What happened to the gas connection ?
Rita put on makeup for the camera 😅 So cute 🥰
Print, choose the reality over money. People will bless your family of journalists wholeheartedly. I'm dying because of my brain damage, but with great pride that I'm dying honestly... Do good(always) n never expect back.