About the Mongolian language
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 06. 2024
- The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/julingo11211
Today we’re going to explore the language of the nomadic people who were probably one of the most successful conquerors in history - Mongolian. It is spoken in Mongolia, but not only. It has many equally important dialects. And it has one of the coolest writing systems out there, but it's not the one that Mongolia actually uses.
Support the channel here: / julingo
Music used:
Sharp Focus by Deskant
Videos used:
Лааны гэрэлд ярилцлага - • Лааны гэрэлд ярилцлага
[ep2-Tongliao] Let’s Speak Pure Mongolian Challenge (ENG&CHN SUB) - • [ep2-Tongliao] Let’s S...
The HU - Yuve Yuve Yu (Official Music Video) - • The HU - Yuve Yuve Yu ...
The first 1,000 people to use this link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare: skl.sh/julingo11211
Why u look so serious ?
@@nikhilPUD01 No, she looks perfect
Thank you for your insights and knowledge, thanks for explaining it so good
It's not sinitic but probably has a lot of Chinese loanwords?
steppe and step are pronounced alike in english they sound just the same.
steppe in english isn't pronounced like it is in german. the final e is silent in english, generally speaking, and this is an example.
As a Mongolian, this was the best video about Mongolian language I've seen on youtube!
try this one ; ) czcams.com/video/HEoi6CpaUWw/video.html
@@sergelenboldoyunbat5261 Yeah, I've seen that before. That's more about old mongolian than modern mongolian.
Same ^-^
@@manduul.bakhdal So you are outer Mongolian not inner Mongolian. Does your country still use the old Mongolian?
@@emmanuelsung By Old Mongolian I was referring to the language used by the medieval Mongolians. Nothing to do with the scripts. And yes, we still use the old script but its usage is very limited, and most people aren't familiar enough with it to read a book for example.
Hello. I am Mongolian. Your research was good, point is so specific and topic also so interesting. Thanks for sharing video about our Mongolian language with foreigners. 🥰
Yoo anh udaa angli hel meddeg mongol hun olloo XD
Yea the research was very cool and i am Mongolian too.
@@saotomedesu2225buten yurtunts angli hel surdag
Hi I'm mongolia
I'm Mongolia either my name is ErkhemBayar
Mongolian is a fascinating and magical language like the Country. I was surprised that letters change whether they are at the beginning, middle or end of the word so they blend well. Thank you for your video. Ciao from Italy 🇮🇹
Sono mongolo e grazie mille!
@@yabur8093 grazie amico mio! талархал илэрхийлье Миний найз
Bi mongol hun
ተሀaነከ
Баярлалаа
Thanks
This video is gold, Mongolian learners face one of the biggest issues of language learning sometimes which is lack of information. Mongolian has no much information about it, so it is always difficult to study! It is such a heartfelt video in my opinion, I feel happy for the ones studying the language even though I am not part of them.
Where u frum u taiwanese or hong kongnese
@@anandsjjsjd5830 lmfao talk english when you learnt it properly
I ll give you a basic example "Sain baina uu?" ( in Khalha) The Turkic root here is "Sa/Sa-ğ or Sa-y". "Sayın". Meaning, healthy, good, respectful etc. Sa-p-an->Sa-b-ın. ( in Börü-üt/Bury-t, meaning mythic Wolves in Turkic) And Sain ( from Russian kiril to Latin transliteration ). These are "consonant softenings" in Turkic. Baina ( from Russian kiril to Latin transliteration) is Turkic verb "Bol" (to be) ' s present tense. Bol-on - > Been/Bain etc. And "uu" is question suffix in Turkic. Originally it' s "mu-bu/gu->/ğu/uu" etc. As an Oguz (Turkish) i can give Mongh Ul Hel (Dil / Language) lessons here. :) Sayın/ Sağan bolon mu? But in Oguz ( Turkish) we say ; "İyi misin?" Edgü/Edge->İyi mi / ii / uu / mu etc. and "sen" (you) "Chi/Çi/Si + n" etc. As an Oguz ( Turkish) , i dont understand other Turkic languages ( for instance Kazakh say "Jaksı" instead of "İyi", but we use "Yakışık" in Oguz, so it doesnt mean that they are not Turks) but it doesn't mean that these are not Turkic languages. Alao these languages have arabic, sanskrit, russian etc words so be careful when you compare. (Ex: "kitap" in Oguz (Turkish) which isArabic origin word and "nom" in Mongh Ul which is Sanskrit origin word. In Turkic it's Bitig or Biçig.) Cheers👋
@@anandsjjsjd5830 Japan gej bn.
@@Dwing_urmom lmfao
bruh
😂Is this like a new form of harrassment or somethin
Thank you for another great video! At 2:32 the photo is actually the 팔만대장경 (Tripiṭaka Koreana or Palman Daejanggyeong) - the Korean collection of the Tripiṭaka, carved onto 81,258 wooden printing blocks in the 13th century 😊 The work on the first Tripiṭaka Koreana began in 1011 during the Goryeo-Khitan War and was completed in 1087. Choi's Goryeo Military Regime, which moved the capital to Ganghwa Island due to Mongol invasions, set up a temporary organization called "Daejang Dogam". The act of carving the woodblocks was considered to be a way of bringing about a change in fortune by invoking the Buddha's help.
You've read my mind. I was just researching about the Mongolian language. Your video helped me a lot. Thank you so so much.
Julie I am so happy for your sweet and delicate contribution to the world for understanding the importance of linguistics, all languages should be preserved because each one of them hold treasures of our history
Thanks Julie! I have waited a long time for one on Mongolian. Awesome job!
Girl what a great, great video! Love it! We don't really hear about the Mongolian language and its history. I can't imagine all the time and dedication this took for you to make this educational video. You made want to learn more about this language and learn some words and commun phrases. I thank you! Congrats for your flawless job.
Thank you for the interesting video! Btw, I'm quite impressed by your accurate pronunciation of Mongolian words.
Thank you for a very clear explanation of the Mongolian language. It was very interesting to watch my native language in English. Good luck😊
WOW. I am truly amazed how did u guys collected and analyzed all of those information. Thank you so much for the work.
I’m amazed by the sheer amount of *accurate* research you’ve put into this video. I have access to the mongolian part of the internet and i still cant dig up even half the information you’ve included in ur video.
Монголоор байдаг судалгааны материалууд нь өөрөө бага, бараг байдаггүй шүү дээ. Юу ч хайсан тэр.
As a Mongolian. I impressed. Mongolian is one of the most difficult language to speak. Good work.
hy, can you help me to translate few sentence? thanks:)
Your research was very informative and looked at a different perspective on Mongolia. Thanks a lot,
JuLingo
Thanks for the longer samples showing the language. Great video as per usual.
In the case of Early Pre-Proto-Mongolic, certain loanwords in the Mongolic languages point to early contact with Oghur (Pre-Proto-Bulgaric) Turkic, also known as r-Turkic. These loanwords precede Common Turkic (z-Turkic) loanwords and include:
• Mongolic ikere (twins) from Pre-Proto-Bulgaric ikir (versus Common Turkic ekiz)
• Mongolic hüker (ox) from Pre-Proto-Bulgaric hekür (Common Turkic öküz)
• Mongolic jer (weapon) from Pre-Proto-Bulgaric jer (Common Turkic yäz)
• Mongolic biragu (calf) versus Common Turkic buzagu
• Mongolic siri- (to smelt ore) versus Common Turkic siz- (to melt)
The above words are thought to have been borrowed from Oghur Turkic during the time of the Xiongnu.
Later Turkic peoples in Mongolia all spoke forms of Common Turkic (z-Turkic) as opposed to Oghur (Bulgharic) Turkic, which withdrew to the west in the 4th century. The Chuvash language, spoken by 1 million people in European Russia, is the only living representative of Oghur Turkic which split from Proto Turkic around the 1st century AD.
Words in Mongolic like dayir (brown, Common Turkic yagiz) and nidurga (fist, Common Turkic yudruk) with initial *d and *n versus Common Turkic *y are sufficiently archaic to indicate loans from an earlier stage of Oghur (Pre-Proto-Bulgaric). This is because Chuvash and Common Turkic do not differ in these features despite differing fundamentally in rhotacism-lambdacism (Janhunen 2006). Oghur tribes lived in the Mongolian borderlands before the 5th century, and provided Oghur loanwords to Early Pre-Proto-Mongolic before Common Turkic loanwords.
Golden 2011, p. 31.
Before the rise of Genghis Khan Mongolic was spreading at westward and absorbing Turkic speakers (Janhunen, 2008). During the Mongol expansion, Turkic speakers whose tribes and states had been incorporated into the Mongol empire were so much more numerous than Mongols that, although Mongolian was the language of command, it was Turkic rather than Mongolic speech that was chiefly spread across Central Asia and the central and western steppe.
Antonio Benítez-Burraco, Steven Moran 2018 p.92
The period of Bulghar Turkic influence on Mongolic seems to have lasted until the fourth century, when the Bulghar Turks withdrew to the west. In Southern Siberia, a few cen- turies without Turkic speakers followed, but most of Mongolia was rapidly covered by a population speaking an early form of Common Turkic, the direct ancestor of Old Turkic and all the modern Turkic languages with the exception of Chuvash. Since the Turkic empires of the Türk and Uighur were for most of the time politically superior to the con- temporary linguistic ancestors of the Mongols, Mongolic (Pre-Proto-Mongolic) bor- rowed a layer of Common Turkic elements that can be distinguished by the absence of the specifically Bulgharic features characteristic of the earlier loanwords.
The Mongolic Languages Juha Janhunen 2003
But these 2 languages are completely different languages. Of course, there are some loanwords cause they were nomadic neighbours at the time on the huge territory of Central Asia, but that's all. In our language there are loanwords from Greek, Persian, Arab, Chinese, Manchu and Tibetan languages because of our history. Also some loanwords from Russian and German languages due to communist period in Mongolia in the last century... There are a lot of things to research...
Mongolian and Turkish have no common words. There are Turkish words in Mongolian.
Just the opposite...even chengis and temuchin are Göktürk and hunnic words@@boburjonteshaboyev2872
I love this channel. Brilliant presentation! Most interesting facts about Mongolian language and history. It must have take some doing to have worked all the scripting out and how it works. Rather like getting a degree in cracking secret modern and ancient codes. It's fascinating! Thank you! for sharing your amazing gift that you have worked hard to accomplish it. The tones, phrases, and rising intonations etc when spoken in any language to me are universal as music is throughout the world. Something I cannot quiet explain.
Thank u for the video about our mongolian language. Баярлалаа, сайн сайхныг хүсье :)
Thank you so much Julie. Good job 👏
I like your video about the mongolian language. It is very informative and enlightening.
I would be very happy if one day you make a video about the Turkish language. It is not easy, but you would do it brilliantly.
Liebe Julie, vielen Dank für dieses neue, schöne Video! Deine Videos sind einfach wunderbar und total interessant, eines auf's andere. Schöne Grüße aus Sachsen!
Du bist kind
@@joshuddin897 Unless you mean to say that Markus is a child(!?), you should probably say: "Du bist nett".
This is the first video I've watched from your channel and I enjoyed it a lot , really like that you make videos about some of these extraordinary languages. Great content.
Julie, please feature one of the native languages from New Guinea / Papua 🥺 This region is packed with language *families* and they are all so mysterious.
I was so happy when i saw the notification
Anyway could you make a vedio about coptic language?
It's the last ancestor of ancient Egyptian
Which modern Egyptians have a mixture between it and Arabic in their modern Egyptian dialect
Thank you! Appreciate your work!
ty for this 🥺
Thank you for a nice video! I teach Mongolian online to foreigners and I shared this video with my students. I'm sure they'll enjoy it. I'm not a Mongolian language professional but I'm a native speaker. When you said that Mongolian doesn't have K and Л sounds it was a surprise for me! We do have these sounds but K appears only in loan words and Л has varieties of pronouncing. It can be pronounced as a soft consonant with feminine vowels and soft sign Ь but not with the masculine ones. Anyway, this is a great video! I'm proud of my country and its language and rich traditions!
Монголчууд бид өөрсдөө яагаад CZcams-д бичлэг тавьж эх хэлний түүх, гарал үүсэл, онцлогоо Англи хэл дээр гадныханд тайлбарлаж сурталчилж болдоггүй юм бэ!!! Энэ эмэтгэй бас алдаатай, буруу ташаа зүйл нэлээд хэлж байна.
@@kts437 Алдаатай зүйл гэдэг нь үгсийн сан, дүрэм, дуудлагыг хэлж байна уу? Монголын тухай бичлэгүүд байдаг шүү дээ
@@batjargaldamdinjav8311 Жишээ нь Ионгол хэлэнд л, к үсэг байдаагүй гэж хэлж байна. Мөн Ойрд Монгол, Буряд Монгол, зэрэг нь тусгай салангид хэл ч байж болно, аль эсвэл Монгол диалект ч байж болно, тухайн хэлээр ярьдаг хувь хүний юу гэж хариулахаас шалтгаална гэж хэлж байна. Эдгээр зүйлс нь бүгд буруу ба ер нь л Монголчуудыг хооронд нь талцалдуулж, баруун, зүүн, төв аль эсвэл Халх, Ойрд гэж хуваах зорилго агуулсан еврейчүүдийн л явуулга яваад байна. Еврей эрдэмтэд л сүүлийн үед ийм явуулга хийгээд байгаа. Монголыг Зүүн Хойд бүсийн улс биш, Евроази гэсэн тодотгол хийх гэж оролдоод байгаа. Евроази бүсэд энэ Исламийн шашинтай болон Жүүдийн шашинтай татарууд ихэвчлэн байдаг мөн тэнд суурьшсан байдаг болохоор. Энэ бол нэг ёсондоо геополитикийн бодлого. Энэ эмэгтэй еврей юмуу аль эсвэл Исламын шиашинтай, Оросын бага ястан ч байж болзошгүй. Еврейчүүд болон Исламын шашинтай Евроазийн хүмүүстэй би гадаадад олон жил хамт ажиллаж, харилцаж явдаггын хувьд тэднийг сайн таньж мэдэх болсон.
@LanguagesPro Зүүн биш Зүүн Хойд Азийн бүсэд Хятадын хойд хэсэг буюу Өвөр Монгол аймгууд, Монгол улс, зүүн Сибир, Хойд Солонгос, Өмнөд Солонгос улс, Япон ордог. "Historical Atlas of Northeast Asia" гэдэг түүхэн газарзүйн судалгааны бүтээлд шинжлэх ухаантай батлагдсан зүйл. Халимагууд чинь Монголоос тасарч Европт суурьшсан Монгол угсааны хүмүүс. Бурядууд чинь өөрийн уугуул нутаг дээрээ амьдарч буй нэгэн цагт Монголын хэсэг байсан Монгол угсааны хүмүүс. Бид бүгдээрээ шашин соёл, хэл, угсаа гаралаар холбогдсон Монгол хүмүүс. Өнөөдөр 40 сая хүн амтай, хөдөө аж ахуй, эрчим хүчний арвин нөөцтэй Украйн улс геополитикийн тоглоомын бай болж нуран сүйтгэгдэж байна. Монгол бол хоёрхон л гарцтай. Хятад Орос хоёр улсын дунд хавчуулагдсан байгаа болохоор л дэлхийн түүхнээс арчигдан алга болчихгүй, суурин дээрээ оршин тогтносон хэвээр байна. Хэрэв бид Евроази гэж тэнэгтэх юм бол Ислам, Жүүдийн шашинтнуудын геополитикийн тоглоомын бай болж амархан арчигдана шүү. Израйлууд Палестинуудыг яаж шахан гаргаж байна. Афганистаны Талибанчуудыг хар. Орос Украйн хоёрын дайныг хар.
@LanguagesPro Хэлж ярьж байгаа зүйлийг чинь харахад чи бол казак, нэг бол муу еврейн гар хөл болсон зомби үгүй бол туранист Туркуудын гар хөл болсон тэнэг үхэр л байна. Чамтай маргалдаж энергээ барах шаардлага надад байхгүй. Чиний хэлж буй зүйл бол юм үзэж нүд тайлаагүй, эрдэм боловсрол эзэмшиж тархиа цэнэглээгүй хүний л үг байна.
As a Mongolian I dont know why but whenever i see these types of videos about mongolia i always get so happy
I am Mongolian, too but made several inaccurate claims. Why we as a native Mongolian speaker can educate people about our own language, its history, and features!!!
hy, can you help me to translate few sentence? thanks:)
Thank you for the video. It is really comprehensive and detailed... Great work!
Thank you for this fascinating video!
A Mongolian here, the research and preparation of this video are perfect, you can trust her, great video.
Thanks for a great episode! Oirat and Kalmyk is the same, pretty much. We (Kalmyk/Oirats) are the same ppl but called differently, depending on georaphical location :).
Do you guys still keep your original Mongol language and traditions, or has Russian culture engulfed everything? It's so crazy to think that a part of the Mongol nation has survived somewhere in Europe haha
@@osasunaitor Im half Kalmyk half Russian and we (the young generation) have basically abandoned our language, but the old generation speaks it pretty well. I’m one of the few ppl who care about our Mongol identity so I learned both khalkha mongolian and kalmyk
@@mincarve7697 oh, that's so discouraging to hear... :(
At least you did your part, you can be proud of that!
What a great research !!! Loved it 😍
Privet! :D
Mne ochen priyatno chto ti sdelala krutoe video o moyom yazike! Spasibo! :D
Nas shyot tvoego youtube kanala, ni puha ni pera!
What I love most about your channel is that you push yourself waaaay out of your "comfort zone" to tackle obscure languages. And you have to spend gobs of time doing research.
I like your CZcams handle. I am guessing Timur Lank 😀
As a mongolian i wanted to say баярлалаа for researching our country!
Love the content, thanks for sharing
Thank you for the informative video. As a Mongolian, I didn’t even know some of the information and histories about my own language and country. You did a great research, appreciate it🙏🏻
Энэ эмэгтэй еврей хүн юм шаг байна. Еврейчүүд сүүлийн үед Монголыг их буруу улс төрийн бодлоготой сурталчлах оролдлого хийгээд байгаа. Аль болох Монголчуудыг хооронд нь салгаж тусгаарлах бодлого явуулаад байгаа. Жишээ нь энэ эмэгтэй, баруун Монгол болон Ойрд Монгол аялгууг тусгай өөр хэл ч байж болно Монгол диалект ч байж болно гэж тайлбарлаж байна. Бид энэ тал дээр өөрсдийн дуу хоолойгоо өргөх хэрэгтэй.
Fun fact: in Swedish we also have a word meaning "people mouth"; folkmun. But it refers to the style of language spoken in normal everyday contexts.
Your Mongolian pronunciation is very good. Almost every foreigners can’t say Mongolian words.
hy, can you help me to translate few sentence? thanks:)
Thank you so much for the video.
Nice job girl. Great effort put into the whole video. 👏👏👏
As a linguist I found this video very well-made and informative. However, I would like to point out, politely but firmly, that the image that appears around 02:32 is a photo of Tripitaka Koreana, a national treasure of Korea (South) and a UNESCO world heritage. Tripitaka Koreana was written in Chinese characters during the Mongol invasions of Korea in the 13th century, with arguably little influence of the Mongolian language.
You’ve already done a Semitic language (Amharic), but I would really like to see a video about Maltese.
This video is very suitable for the new learner for mongolian language. Good job!
Good job Thank you.
monghol bichig is one of my favourite subjects!
You're so cute 🥰 I don't know mongol really well but I think I will learn it one day !! The landscapes are so magnificent 😁
@@aulea-no-nihon she's Mongolia :^
Thank you for giving our Mongolia even its language♥
Thank you. That is so interesting, Good luck for your next content
Thanks for sharing this
I am Mongolian, and I am learning a lot. Great Video!
I am 14 and I am understanding more from this vid than i do in our Mongolian history class😌💖Love the vid🤩I can't imagine how many hours you spent to do all these research and making this video💛And your pronunciation is so good btw!
Exactly!
Clarity Shine, dear! Please don't misspell.
Thank you wonderful video.
I am impressed! Very accurate and linguistic data information! Keep up the good work 👏👏👏
Very interesting, informative and worthwhile video. Classical Mongolian script is similar to Manchu script. The calligraphy of these scripts can be quite beautiful. Mongolian throat singing, a polyphonic form of vocalizing sounds is a quite interesting and unusual form of singing, and the effects can be fantastic when enhanced with electronic ( such as echo) and synthesizer effects.
thats because manchu/s were part of mongol empire after mongol empire they created own empire and copied alphabet
@@jamiejesus1563 Thank you for your comment.
"Classical Mongolian script" is almost exactly Uyghur script.
@@MB-rb9tk Interesting to know. Thank you for your comment.
It’s actually the ancient Uyghur script, modern Uyghur uses Arabic script
Absolutely Beautiful
Mongolian needs more recognition
In order to please the former Soviet Union, Mongolia changed the writing of its own language and made it closer to Russian. Now the younger generation of Mongolians are not able to read and understand all the history books of their own country a hundred years ago, including all the records about Genghis Khan that they are so proud of! What a pity! What kind of country would a country without historical heritage be like? Does the history of the country only need to be counted from the day of independence?
@@jongshingpan3629
Make it your mission to get them translated! Also use the old stories and scripts for learning to read in the ancient way!
thank you for the vid Julie, i've always wondered about this language after messing around with it on google translate lol
thank you for interessting our language and history, I've seen on your youtube chanel!
Yeah...
Sums up my language pretty well 👍
10:41 Shar Ayragh in Turkish would be Sarı Ayran.
But I didnt understand why you replaced Ayran with Kımız later in the example. Both are milk drinks but they use different yeasts and fermentation processes. There is also Kefir for example.
True! As a Turkish, I was not ready for that much similarity :D
@@karaaslan7402 Esenlikler Beğdili.
IYI
⋊|
ayran değil o. airag, kımız ın Moğolcası.
@@PimsleurTurkishLessons Kımız ayran ayrag aynı şey, eskiden ayran yoğurttan yapılmazdı, başka mayalar onlar. Eskiden kullanılan mayayla alkollü idi hepsi.
@@suntzu2812Götümden atma seviyem:
thank you so much✨
Juli that was very interesting and educational 👌😃
Great video! However, you used the wrong translation for the word gasoline at @10:20. Тоормос (Тормоз in Russian) is a Brake, not gasoline.
Mongolia is a country with a great history
thank you very much Thank you very much for really liking this video you made while informing others about our country 😁
Баярлалаа Жу Линго !!! (Thanks, Ju Lingo)
very interesting :) curiously the written Mongolian language is still used in the Chinese province of Inner Mongolia
It is still used in State of Mongolia, it is just that we the independent Mongolians don’t feel the need to hold on and protect our identity as much as South Mongolians. Mongolian language and writing will continue to evolve as it has done for the past 1000 years otherwise it will be doomed for the history books.
All Mongols can understand each other. The main dialect is Khalkha as of today. Khorchin, Ordos, Buryat, Kalmykia and Oird are dialects.
Sain baina uu (mongol) and (i am a buryat) sabonou or sain
Translate: hello, hi
No
The Turkic root here is "Sa/Sa-ğ or Sa-y". "Sayın". Meaning, healthy, good, respectful etc. Sa-p-an->Sa-b-ın. ( in Börü-üt/Bury-t, meaning mythic Wolves in Turkic) And Sain ( from Russian kiril to Latin transliteration ). These are "consonant softenings" in Turkic. Baina ( from Russian kiril to Latin transliteration) is Turkic verb "Bol" (to be) ' s present tense. Bol-on - > Been/Bain etc. And "uu" is question suffix in Turkic. Originally it' s "mu-bu/gu->/ğu/uu" etc. As an Oguz (Turkish) i can give Mongh Ul Hel (Dil / Language) lessons here. :) Sayın/ Sağan bolon mu? But in Oguz ( Turkish) we say ; "İyi misin?" Edgü/Edge->İyi mi / ii / uu / mu etc. and "sen" (you) "Chi/Çi/Si + n" etc. As an Oguz ( Turkish) , i dont understand other Turkic languages but it doesn't mean that these are not Turkic languages.
Nope
Thank you for the information
I’m Mongolia
Very facinating and informative. Thank you.
After listening to how Mongolian language sounds, it make learning Vietnamese a walk in the park
Could you do a video on Ossetian? The last living language descended from the legendary Scythians. The original Steppe peoples and ancestors to the Mongols and a lot of their traditions.
Would love to, it’s a very interesting topic!
Although I would disagree that the Scythians were the Mongols' ancestors. Maybe some admixture but still not since they had their own ancestry different from the Scythians.
Love to all Ossetians from Iran, your western iranian brother🇮🇷❤ your language is interesting and really hard to understand as a Persian
@@rvat2003 not direct ancestors. What I meant was that they were the original steppe peoples and later peoples of different ethnicities and races (such as Turkic, Mongolic, Germanic, and the like) would later adopt these lifestyles and make them their own.
@@camrendavis6650 The germanic tribes were not steppe people and were not nomadic.
Just excellent!
Wow this is amazing! Good luck.
im mongolian!!!
and sometimes our language can be pretty tough for people from around the world (that are not mongolian)
khorqin mongol
Mongolian: Written in Mongolian script.
Also Mongolian: Written in Cyrillic alphabet.
@پیاده نظام خان Inspired doesn't mean it's straight Aramaic or Uyghur. Especially Aramaic and Mongolian have different systems. Cyrillic is inspired by Greek script but we still call them separately right?
@پیاده نظام خان Mongols adopted Uyghur. Uyghur script inspired by Aramaic . Technically it's not Aramaic🙂.
Omg you did really good research. ❤️🔥❤️🔥
Wow! Great channel!
MONGOLIC AND BULGHAR TURKIC
There are several criteria that allow the Bulgharic loanwords in Mongolic to be identi- fied. For one thing, Mongolic often has a native word synonymous with a Bulgharic bor- rowing, cf. e.g. Mongolic *ele.sü/n ‘sand’ vs. *kumaki id. ← Bulgharic *kuma.kï = Common Turkic *kum (qum). Moreover, the borrowings often show a specialized mean- ing, whereas the native words have a more general semantic profile, cf. e.g. Mongolic *xüsü/n ‘hair’ vs. *kilga.su/n ‘hair of a horse’ ← Bulgharic *kïlka = Common Turkic *kïl (qïl) ‘hair’. Other items have an internal etymology on the Turkic side, cf. e.g. Mongolic *ikire ‘twin/s’ ← Bulgharic *ikire = Common Turkic *eki.z, derived (plural) from *eki ‘two’. In still other cases, the Bulgharic original ultimately appears to derive from a third language, notably Tocharian, cf. e.g. Mongolic *xüker ‘ox’ ← Bulgharic *xekür = Common Turkic *(x)öküz id., Mongolic *jer ‘weapon/s’ < ‘bronze’ ← Bulgharic *jer = Common Turkic *yäz ‘bronze’, possibly borrowed from the cognates of Proto-Tocharian *xokso ‘ox’ and *yes ‘gold’, respectively.
Two culturally and historically important semantic fields for which Bulgharic borrowings are abundantly attested are the terminologies of animal husbandry and metal working. Bulgharic animal names in Mongolic include, apart from *xüker ‘ox’, Mongolic *eljige/n ‘donkey’ (Common Turkic *eshkäk), *biraxu ‘calf’ (Common Turkic *buzag/u), *koni/n ‘sheep’ (Common Turkic *kony), *ajirga ‘stallion’ (Common Turkic *adgïr), and others. Relevant metal terms include, apart from *jer ‘bronze’, Mongolic *korgoljin ‘lead’ (Common Turkic *korgashun), *alta/n ‘gold’ (Common Turkic *altun), and *siri- ‘to smelt (ore)’ (Common Turkic *sïz- ‘to melt’). Some Mongolic metal terms, e.g. *temür ‘iron’ (Common Turkic *tämür) and *jes ‘bronze’ (Common Turkic *yäz) were borrowed from Turkic only later, while others have been variously reborrowed from Mongolic into Turkic, especially into Northeastern Turkic. Mongolic also has a number of metal terms of other origin, notably *mönggü/n ‘silver’ and *küril ‘bronze’, but the basic picture is one of intensive and continuous inter- action with Turkic, starting with the Bulgharic period.
The most important property of the Bulgharic loanwords in Mongolic is that they carry a number of diagnostic phonological characteristics, which distinguish them from the later Turkic (Common Turkic) elements. Owing to the relatively large size of the Bulgharic loanword corpus, it is possible to establish a set of regular correspondences between Turkic (Bulgharic) and Mongolic. It is largely these correspondences that have served as the basis for the Altaic Hypothesis in the past. However, a closer look at the features involved shows that they represent either archaisms or innovations that once characterized the Bulgharic (Proto-Bulgharic) branch of Turkic.
Els-sand
Us-sair
Ikhir-twin
Ukher-ox
Zewseg-weapon
Khurel-bronze
1. Please learn Mongolian if you're going to make assumptions about the language because half of what you wrote is completely incorrect.
2. Many of the words you mentioned are originally Mongolian and were borrowed by Tureg peoples, this is obvious because the meaning of these words are more unambiguous in Mongolian. For example, "biraxu" in Mongolian "Byaruu", which is an age group for bovine: 0-"tugal", 1-"byaruu", 2-4(depends on gender, but "gunj" is acceptable), and then >5(depends on gender and whether castrated, "unee", "buh", or "uher"). "Kilga-su" in Mongolian "Khyalgas" is a very thin type of hair found under dermal areas or involving mucus membranes. These words you mentioned have proper meanings in Mongolian and lost their "semantic profile" when borrowed by Turkic languages.
3. It's probably most important to note that Mongolian people have more Turkic lineage than any other central asian peoples. It is not possible to separate Mongolians from the real Turkic peoples because Mongolians are the closest surviving relatives.
@@MB-rb9tkyou tungus🇲🇳
@@MB-rb9tk...were the Göktürks and Mongols the same people in the past?
Маш их баярлалаа
very informative and interesting
Really hope there will be more resources (CZcams, websites in general) for learning Mongolian. There really are so few, it puts the language much further out of reach for those wanting (or needing) to learn Mongolian.
Thanks / Баярлалаа
Hi Julie, regarding the word 'steppes', the 'e' is steppes is a short e sound (like the e in egg). In fact, the two words steppes and steps are pronounced exactly the same. English can be so confusing sometimes! xxx
I’M MONGOLIAN... THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR MAKING THIS VIDEO!!!😊🙏 БАЯРЛАЛАА
you shouldn't be using cyrillic language
@@user-zx6dm6rf7w Cyrillic alphabet*
Great channel Julie. Very interesting and informative. The videos have both quantity and quality of content. And you are so charming.
Maybe you could do a video on ancient Egyptian. That's a tough language to do, but if anyone can do it, you can.
Thanx so much! Your work is amazing, I’m doing notes to make analogues, maybe one day I’ll arrive in Atlantis ;). Cheers!
Mongolic peoples and Para-Mongolic peoples are ethno-linguistic groups that means a group unified by both common language and ethnicity such as Slavic, Baltic, Turkic, Hellenic, Tai and others
The difference of Para-Mongolic and Mongolic is like Baltic and Slavic
god for a small second i thought you were saying all those groups were one group unified by related languages and ethnicities and i was like hmmmm seems suspicious lol
Para-Mongolic is a linguistic diaspora not an ethnic one.
@@MB-rb9tk Both
@@papazataklaattiranimam Thats like calling turkish people Turkic. They may speak a turkic language, but they are definitely not Turkic.
Great Video
I love this content,keep going this content 😘
Listening as Mongolian, your pronunciation of "Genghis Khan" is spot on.
sup
Hahah
Genjis kan
Waiting for the Kazakh🇰🇿language 🙏🏻
we're waiting for the kazakh language as soon as possible
Thank you❤️✨
sooooo informative and educational. i luve your videos. you are the prettiest language expert ive ever seen!!
9:05 an article was actually released recently finding that speakers of the so-called "Altaic languages" were likely part of a civilization that harvested millet in china some 9,000 years ago. the title of the article is "Triangulation supports agricultural spread of the Transeurasian languages"
That article seems very interesting and it was published in Nature just earlier this month. Thanks!
Thank you for sharing!
You must have mistaken шүүс (shuus, almost shoes) with ширэ (shir) which i've never heard 😂
Shir means unprocessed leather, or just basic animal hide. It is a very common word in Mongolian.
good job! keep going
Great video 👏. Greeting from Mongolia😇🙌.
Interesting. In Mongol - "language" = Khel. In Finnish - Kieli
I'm native Finnish speaker and find it cool that all Turkic languages have vowel harmony, just like Finnish. A, O, U are back vowels, E, I are neutral vowels and Ä, Ö, Y are front vowels.
Mongolian 'hel' or 'khel' could be a loanword from a now extinct Uralic language. Proto-Uralic apparently had the form 'kele', which has later yielded 'keel' in Estonian and 'kieli' in Finnish.
The loan etymology is suggested by Edward Vajda in The Oxford Guide to the Transeurasian Languages, (p.726) "Transeurasian as a continuum of diffusion".