Legends Summarized: The Epic of Gilgamesh
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 07. 2023
- 📌 NEW PIN TIME WOOOOOOO! Check out the Gilgamesh & Enkidu and Taurus pin packs HERE:
📌 GILGAMESH - crowdmade.com/collections/ove...
📌 TAURUS - crowdmade.com/collections/ove...
When it comes to the oldest known work of literature, it turns out you really can't beat the classics. We've got adventure! Romance! Just guys bein dudes! Two giant monsters for the price of one! Divine smiting of hubris! Even a cataclysmic flood or two!
QUICK NOTE: If you noticed the audio got fuzzy around minute 4, that's because twelve hours after it went up we got a manual copyright claim on one of the background tracks that vampirized all the video monetization, which was an absolutely brutal no-win scenario (reupload a video after a day where it hit 13 on trending? unlikely to fly) so I had youtube edit out the song and leave the narration as best it could manage. Sorry, gang, I hate it too.
Our content is intended for teenage audiences and up.
PATREON: / osp
PODCAST: overlysarcasticpodcast.transi...
DISCORD: / discord
MERCH: overlysarcastic.shop/
OUR WEBSITE: www.OverlySarcasticProduction...
Find us on Twitter / ospyoutube
Find us on Reddit / osp
Want this video in another language? Check out our guide to contributing translated captions: www.overlysarcasticproduction...
📌📌📌 NEW PIN TIME WOOOOOOO! Check out the Gilgamesh & Enkidu and Taurus pin packs HERE:
📌 GILGAMESH - crowdmade.com/collections/overlysarcasticproductions/products/overly-sarcastic-productions-gilgamesh-enkidu-pin-pack-pre-sale-1
📌 TAURUS - crowdmade.com/collections/overlysarcasticproductions/products/overly-sarcastic-productions-bull-of-heaven-glow-in-the-dark-pin-pre-sale-1
Praise the OSPins!
Sup guys
𒁉𒀭𒄩𒊏𒀀 𒂊𒈬𒁉 𒈨𒁉𒅕𒈠𒈠 𒅕𒅕𒅕
𒁉𒀭𒄩𒊏𒀀
𒂊𒈬𒁉 𒈨𒁉𒅕𒈠𒈠
𒅕𒅕𒅕
XD That's right. I translated an old meme into an even older language! You're welcome.
Hey, could we see something covering more OLD English stuff like Beowulf?
Or maybe just epics in general like Ovid - Metamorphoses, Firdawsi - The Shahnameh, The Nibelungenlied, or the Song of Roland?
So little question... I listen to the OSPod and you guys mentioned a few times vinyl _Sun Wukong_ figures... was that a limited thing or are they still out there and I am too stupid to find them?
i first encountered this story from a song by the band Nile
The fact that the battle between Gilgamesh and Enkidu is obscured due to damage to the tablet seems hilariously poetic to me. Bros were fighting so hard they broke the record.
And then they kissed :)
@@wyvernscale9634 Enemies to lovers
@@jann_07 in literally record time
Oh my GOOOOOODS!!!
Virals Mech in Gurren Lagann is named after the bro who died in the epic of Gilgamesh wtf?!?!
@@fangsabre Modern Japanese authors seem to _love_ giving characters/story elements in all kinds of fantasy/sci-fi stories names lifted from all over all kinds of mythological traditions, often seemingly at, or almost at, random (ie with no apparent, or just the flimsiest, thematic or other relation to the source).
I don't consume a lot of anime, manga and/or story-heavy Japanese games, but that seems like a pretty strong tendency...
It's oddly adorable to me.
Pretty sure I've encountered Gilgamesh _multiple_ times, and that doesn't slot nearly as neatly into Japanese phonetics as Enkidu
The irony of Enkidu wondering who'd Remember such a pointless death only to be part of the oldest known story in humanity is just brilliant
Makes you wonder about all the forgotten Enkidu’s left to fade into history because they were just simple farmers or a mother who died in childbirth. How many stories have been lost?
@@frownyclowny6955 it's somenthing i ofthen think about the pepole that lived there : they had lives like our own , yet their day to day living must have been soo alien for us : they had no scissors , no metal , wood was a precius commodity ,
their idea of richness was immensly different from our own , as a whole their life was really different from our , and it's one of the few times in wich i can only get glimses of , rather than fully formed visions , trough my minds eye , it's hard to picture that life when you have few movies set in that period with regular pepole living their lives ...
@@frownyclowny6955i think that's the reason why people turn to things like culture and religion. There is tremendous fulfillment in having one's way of life endure through the ages.
For an instant, whoever the inspiration for Enkidu is... I felt a kinship with you, across these seas of time, a moment of memory. Sail on, and one day, soon or late, I shall set sail myself.
@@ShahriarXV - That would make a fascinating story prompt: tell the story of someone who was a vital part of an epic story, but who was nonetheless tangential to the plot and so forgotten when the stories were written. For example, the woman whose prayer led to the creation of Enkidu and thus setting the whole epic of Gilgamesh into motion: what would her story look like?
Interesting note on Shamat teaching Enkidu about being civilized through sex as well as her role as a sacred prostitute: for awhile orgasms were actually seen as a moment of clarity and connection with higher realms, etc. The euphoria and all that being a glimpse of enlightenment, so some old cultures actually thought having people around who could bring about the hardest nuts possible were good people to have around.
So anyway, basically it seems the Epic of Gilgamesh was implying that by having sex for a fortnight, Shamat gave Enkidu post-nut clarity to last him the rest of his life.
Wish that perspective on sex work stuck around tbh
This explains far more than it has any right to.
@@sashasscribblesit’s called hedonism
@elderpebler9482 it's not. Fucking google it before you just say whatever.
a better societal standard truly
Fun fact: the man who first translated the tablets of the Epic, George Smith, was employed by the British museum only because of his sheer passion about the discoveries happening in Mesopotamia in those decades.
He had no formal higher education, being from a poor family he had to abandon school and work at a low level job in a bank from the age of 14.
He learned cuneiform and Akkadian by himself, reading the books and texts being published in those years by the first people studying the recent archaeological discoveries, during his free time.
He was employed by the British Museum after the people working there noticed this “non academic” guy, who during every day the museum required no ticket/ had free entrance would spend his lunch break from the bank there, wasn’t simply looking at but actually reading the clay tablets exposed, and after talking to him they realized he was better at it than those museum employees themselves!
About a decade later while randomly translating tablets from Ashurbanipal’s massive royal library, stored in the basement archive of the museum, he saw a tablet with a reference to what looked like the biblical flood myth (specifically the part about releasing birds to find land), he looked up which other tablets were supposed to go with that one and BAM now the world knew of the Epic of Gilgamesh (and the museum finally financed an expedition of his in Mesopotamia as he had dreamed to do for the longest time)
Sometimes passion can truly get you places, kids
That is absolutely _wild_ s&>/! I needed to read this story. Thanks!
I love how Europeans are so often accused of destroying cultures, when in reality they tend to be the only ones interested in finding them and preserving them.
@@tomosjackson4760 Its mostly christians
@@adlerofrowe9224 Even better.
@@adlerofrowe9224 bruh
"Immortality isn't out running death, it's outlasting it"
Brilliant quote
I want that on my tomb now
Too bad that even story will die too
Not really once the last human dies, and the last script reduced to ash. Death outlasts all.
@@poenpotzu2865 death does not outlast all because death is death
@@whiteeye3453 Additionally, death can't outlast all because it cannot outlive the potential of life. Long after the potential for living has faded away-as entropy whittles down everything that ever could've lived and all the energy that ever could've sustained it into nothingness-all that will remain is that which innately could never live and thus by nature can never die; death itself dies just in time to see an eternally dark universe, surrounded by an ever expanding nothingness.
I love Red's rant at the end. "Gilgamesh wasn't some twink, he was a bear."
Omg the fate rant killed me.
I can only imagine the rant on Fate’s take on Enkidu
She's gonna have such a field day looking at the character designs of the Fate franchise. I want that livestream.
Honestly I’m still seriously disappointed with Paul Bunyan
@@mirage809amen to that and pray for her sanity as what type-moon did for the character design and lore’s in the massive convoluted timeline that of the fate franchise. And/or she’ll watch either one of gigguks videos where he discusses the fate franchise altogether.
The myth of consensual sex
“I consent!”
“I consent!”
Gilgamesh: Isn’t there someone you forgot to ask?
Kinda occurs to me that Enkidu was probably only alive for like, a couple years. He got made, lived in the wilderness, boned for two weeks, beat a guy up, became his best friend for life, killed two divine beasts and died. What a chad
Dang I didn’t realize how short his life really was.
I love how it does the "gaaahh I'm going to die and it's all because of a woman" but then Enkidu is talked down from that misogynistic statement. Real progressive stuff from the first story ever recorded.
@@maxinesenior596 Man vs. Misogyny is the oldest conflict type
Honestly the fact that the oldest story we know was preserved so well was because it was HOMEWORK is quacking hilarious to me.
At least in various parts. The first copy we found was found in a library as part of its collection (The Library of Ashurbanipal, which got preserved because it burnt down and people forgot about it) while others are from scribal training literature.
While the preservation ability of homework right now isn’t that good, I’m glad that I don’t have to do my summaries and analyses on stone tablets.
@@bobaoriley1912Thankfully it was mostly clay and wax for these people
And this is way you always need to do your homework. So that in 2000 years we know about this stories we telling today
Millions of years from now, aliens will wonder why the long gone intelligent species of earth was into tales of leaking bathtubs.
The fact that the details of Enkidu and Gilgamesh's fight are obscured by literal damage to the text creates this beautiful symbolism of a fight so destructive it damaged the stone it was carved in- epic.
So true
Imagine a film of this where they do a "missing reel" due to the damage.
Clay, not to be pedantic
It was pretty Epic of Gilgamesh
I reckon it's like how a favourite book gets worn out - everyone wanted to read the epic fight between demigods
Shamhat is the perfect example of why you gotta respect sex workers.
That woman gave Enkidu a full education in a single week, while boning the whole time. That’s beyond impressive.
Yeah… no. I’m not gonna respect prostitutes because a fictional one from thousands of years ago taught a fictional character.
@@KaiserCeaser
Well, it’s a good thing that no one asked you, then
@@XescoPicas you posted a comment on CZcams. It’s a open invitation for comment.
The original teacher kink?
@@KaiserCeaseryou've got a family guy pfp and you don't respect sex workers? Its like you wanna die alone
I love the irony of Gilgamesh being in Civ 6. Like his entire story is about accepting his mortality, and in Civ 6, he really is an immortal ruler
But a very good friend still
@@shigekax honestly he's too good for me. One time I invaded him and took his capital, and then the turn after we'd made peace, I asked if he wanted to be friends, and then he accepted. The whole "You are a good friend and ally" cutscene played and everything. I felt so bad about that afterwards
@@seanspindleshanks2529I mean he did that with Enkidu
I dunno, in a meta way it's even more of a testament to the *true* immortality he found at the end?
Millennia later, a popular game still references him as the awesome ruler of a mighty Summer
The same happened to me! Playing a Gorgo vampires game, I waited until my alliance ended, BETRAYED him, took his capital, made peace and we were IMMEDIATELLY best buds again! Priceless!@@seanspindleshanks2529
Shamhat: "This is my boyfriend, Enkidu."
Enkidu: "Hi."
Shamhat: "And this is Enkidu's boyfriend, Gilgamesh."
Gilgamesh: "Sup."
Farmer: Im sorry whats the situation?
@@lucasisofdarkness5423love...love is the problem.
@@lucasisofdarkness5423
Shamhat: Enkidu is gay, but he's straight for me, and he's gay for Gilgamesh, and Gilgamesh is really gay for Enkidu. And I hate Gilgamesh.
Enkidu: It's not that complicated.
Gilgamesh: No.
@@KarlKristofferJohnssonor they are bisexual
@@zedwillbaws2280Unfortunately that term would not be coined for several million years.
I'm amused that Gilgamesh is genre savvy enough to know that sleeping with a goddess is a terrible idea, but not savvy enough to realize killing multiple divine beasts might have consequences.
I feel like this is because many, many, MANY people were screwed by Ishtar, who then followed up by screwing them over, but the number of legends where the hero has more then a single Divine Beast on their trophy wall is considerably, uh, less.
I think it is less "sleeping with a goddess" and more sleeping with Ishtar, since she is just the worst.
I like to imagine he is but just wanted an opportunity to kill a really cool beast with his bare hands and his newly-appointed husband
We all have our blindspots...
He actually did bring misfortune to his people by not bedding Inanna/Ishtar since she got revenge. That's what you get for not engaging in hierogamy as any respectable Sumerian Lugal would.
Hey so as an Australian palaeontology student whose current lab project literally involves cleaning and preparing Diprotodon fossils, the acknowledgement of Aboriginal stories and their connection to history and the fossil record was a super cool surprise to see pop up!! Just another lil tidbit, the giant flightless bird Genyornis newtoni is referred to in the language of the Djab Wurrung people as mihirung paringmal (giant bird). That is a NAME for a specific animal that died out 30,000 years ago that has persisted in the language until today! Genyornis and its older and even bigger relatives like Dromornis are often referred to in Australian palaeontology as mihirungs for this reason.
Damn cool
yes, as a fellow aussie it was a wonderful surprise!! there’s also evidence of multiple aboriginal and torres strait islander creation stories from different nations across the country reflecting geographic events from around 60,000 years ago! one studied in 2015 found one story that accurately depicted the change in sea levels that led to an island… becoming an island off the coast of QLD.
(and that’s of course without mentioning the amazingness of song lines and dance in community as a way to pass on messages about the environment and surroundings)
So cool
Yesss! Unfortunately, still I will tell ppl about the latter- bc I mean how often do you find a story about the land freaking changing that you can verify like that- andddd ppl are still dummies about oral traditions 🙃
Even crazier since New Zealand is believed to be first settled by humans the same time the Hundred Years War was happening in Europe
The great thing about Gilgamesh's immortality isn't that he got his immortality in the most backward way, but the fact that his first journey failed and he came back to his city with nothing, but the second time he left he returned to a new city with immortality not just for him, but everyone he has ever met. It's beautiful.
What i find most beautiful is Inanna/Ishtar bading Gilgamesh to return home because he has to accept his fate.
when did he return with immortality for everybody?
@BlockyBookworm It's the stories. Even after everyone else alive when he was have fallen away, his story and the people he met and interacted with in it are still being talked about to this day. Not even some gods have had that luxury.
@@calamityjehn true. we don't even remember the gods, we just remember gilgamesh.
Man the comedic timing of the tablet breaking right as the fight begins like: “and they charge toward each other. Only one would possibly make it out alive from this…
…tenderly held him in a warm embrace as they kissed”
The punchline is that you're only missing two sentences
Also, first recorded use of the bury your gays trope? Yes.
we need to find the middle part pronto, I need context!!! but yes, that is indeed hilarious XD
@MoonSlimeEli3219 no way… this is the way it has always been
The middle part was intentionally destroyed by Akkadian parents worried about too much violence.
You just gotta love Enkidu literally JUST joining human society, still learning how to use a fork, hearing about Gilgamesh and just going "OH HELL NAW, WHAT A DICK!" and going down to his place to beat some manners into him.
Only to stay there and say the same thing under wildly different context
@@d1g1beastpr1me7 "OH HELL YEAH, WHAT A DICK!"
And then they kiss
And then is like “your kinda hot 😍” and then they kiss
Cringe
“This? THIS is supposed to be Gilgamesh? This broomstick of a man?”
I got a good laugh out of that spiel 😂
Lancer died
@@SirsasthNigam. no kidding, I’ve already seen the show
@@SirsasthNigam.Youre not human!
*Respect lancer, lancer did died some times because of the grail so I can't use gilgamesh's repeating deaths for it as argument, but in the first death he endured for 12 fucking hours*
"Immortality is not about outrunning death but outlasting it."
I love that line and I'm using it for our DND game. 😅
At least in Forgotten Realm it's actually possible (although very very hard to put it mildly) for mortals to become gods, and relatively easy to become immortal (with some caveats), so I'm not sure how well that would work. Of course it's a whole different case if you're running a homebrew world.
Bards & Enchanters achieving immortality be like:
@@azathothbaudelaire1642 wait bards can achieve immortality? asking as a bard player in my first campaign ever, though my chara wouldnt wanna become immortal i wanna see how it works
@@horuho245
Its not likely. In fact my comment was partially based off of a video of the ways different magic classes/schools can achieve immortality (since being a Lich is how necromancers stay alive forever).
A bard trying to be immortal would essentially be someone how has played & performed & adventured so much that they become famous throughout the land, and when their body dies, their essense continues on as a spirit that can be called upon whenever anyone sings a song the bard made or tells of a story that the bard went on. So essentially if Beyonce was just as famous in the D&D universe, she would be immortal in spirit. Just imagine singing your heart out to defeat a big bad evil guy, and the (now godly) soul of lady gaga was conjured to assist you in power.
@@horuho245Go look up "Finder Wyvernspur" :)
You know if you think about it Gilgamesh crime was to force women to sleep with him instead of their husbands AND THEN when Gilgamesh finally found someone he loved and wanted to spend the rest of his life with he couldn’t do that because someone more powerful than him decided she HAD to sleep with him regardless of his opinions on the matter.
That is the ultimate poetic justice coming in a way I’m sure not even the gods could plan for.
Oh wow I didn't even consider this
Oh, right. Ishtar tried to do exactly the same he was doing... Only he didn't end up r*ped, he just lost someone to an illness. That looks worse to me, but again, he r+ped a lot of married woman.
Probably just our modern perception of events. The historical issue was probably more due to stealing the sex from the men then the idea of people having consent.
@@onyxgrnr666 I feel that a big difference not yet mentioned is the perspective of “deflowering” that had significant meaning in those days. A man couldn’t even have his wife, and a woman couldn’t just have her husband, because of Gilgamesh
Yes! Hadn't noticed
“HOW DARE HE RUIN THE WHOLESOME FUN OF CONSENSUAL BONING!” is yet another peak OSP moment for the books
I know I need it on a t-shirt! But maybe replace "he" with "they", lol.
This should be a sticker.
Beep bop... I'm the Philosophy Bot. Here, have a quote:
"Waste no more time arguing about what a good man should be. Be one"
~ Marcus Aurelius
Enkidu was enlightened beyond his time.
I like how 5:47 Enkidu has the peachy censored treatment, but when it comes to 10:54 Gilgamesh is all buns out.
That just means Enkidu is swangin' and Gilgamesh is overcompensating
@@PieNumber4Gilgamesh is a bottom
While seeing Red ranting about Fate Gil is funny as hell...I'm more surprised she's not ranting about Fate Enkidu.
To be fair, I know almost nothing about Fate and I know that it has a character named after Gilgamesh. Fate!Gilgamesh seems like a more prominent Gate character than Fate!Enkidu.
@@timothymclean That is true. However, one of the more mainstream Fate projects of the last few years was the Babylonia anime and there Enkidu was pretty prominent.
And I meant it in the way that Fate!Enkidu is even farther away from the mythological inspiration than Fate!Gilgamesh is.
@@Chaotic42Kami If it helps, in Fate canon Enkidu at least *used* to look like how he was described in the myths, but he's Made Of Clay and apparently that means he can reshape what he looks like (in that version), so after his two-week session with Shamhat who taught him everything about everything, he decided she was really cool and he wanted to look like her now.
@@pseudonym6387 oh, I am aware of that. But that doesn't stop Enkidu's usual look being way more separate from the "og" visuals than Gil.
...also, Enkidu is one of those "Astolfo" Servants. As in not male or female but just Enkidu. At least it isn't like D'Eon, who is always the same gender as your avatar.
@@Chaotic42Kami Fate astolfo is a male and is straight
he just looks like a twink.
enkidu is genderless though.
you skipped over the hilarious part where when Ishtar confronts Gilgamesh and asks him to marry her, he literally goes "oh you don't think I've heard about this before in the ancient stories, beautiful goddesses seducing heroes and leading them to horrible fates? Get better material." He's literally riffing about unoriginal tropes in THE OLDEST STORY EVER.
A trope older than any form of memory.
ONLY the oldest story written... NOT necessarily the oldest ever... Long before humans had any form of writing or even symbols in a story-format on stones or walls, there were stories told and lessons of sorts provided from them. It's one of (if not THE) oldest forms of learning. ;o)
*Oldest story written that we’ve been able to recover thus far
Gilgamesh: Has an existential crisis, tries to find immortality, fails in a sense
Monkey somewhere in the distance: Pathetic (Laughs in stacks on stacks of immortality)
Ah yes. monkey pioneered the Destiny Light/Dark buffs, and has at least 7 stacks of immortality
I was not expecting a destiny reference bit I am glad to see it!
Shut up, Wukong.
As an enormous Fate fan, the mini rant at the end about Gil and Bro-skander had me cackling at how accurate it was, ESPECIALLY once you brought one of the numerous gender-bends in the franchise up. So thanks for that one, Red.
Red does mention Fate in her Arthurian legends video as well, when Red talks about how the legends can and are reimagined
@@wonderlilane3724 Oh I know. That was also fun to see. Any reference to Fate in other stuff makes me a happy boy.
The first written story that we know of has both enemies to lovers and implied zombies. Nothing changes
Gilgamesh panicked trying to think of a fake name, "Uh... uh... I'm not Gilgamesh, I'm... Bilgamesh." Truly an individual worthy of great tales.
"I'm not Gilgamesh! I'm my original character Bilgames!"
...Ohsea Donutsteel?
@@GalvatronRodimus”I’m not Gilgamesh. I’m Hsemaglig!”
(Hsemaglig my balls)
@@GalvatronRodimus"I-I'm... I am *Bill Gates"*
Ah, the original Nobody gambit. Another way of dodging death, guaranteed to leave 'em blindsided.
“Immortality isn’t outrunning death. It’s outlasting it.”
Damn… this one was moving.
Yeah now that I think of it, death’s still winning. Eventually, things are forgotten and to reference coco, die a final time.
There’s a chance they’ll be picked up again and remembered again tho. Still will be a time something will never come back in memory. Like those cave paintings that are worn away
as an aussie its so refreshing to see some acknowledgement of how much cool history can be found in the stories passed down through aboriginal songlines! fun fact there are stories about the formation of the great barrier reef that align almost perfectly with how marine scientists estimate it wouldve been formed tens of thousands of years ago
it would be really awesome to read more of these myths one day!
Gil and Enkidu's fight being obscured by destruction to the tablet is amazingly poetic
A fight between two so destructively powerful individuals that even its recounting was destroyed
Beowulf and Gilgamesh are proof that any story that involves the protagonist swimming to the bottom of an impossibly deep body of water is going to be a fantastic read
Also Tokoyo and the Sea Monster.
That one medieval legend about Alexander the Great going underwater
I still say Beowulf didn't make that swim. It's all his own word that he did, and I got the feeling he was a braggart. So he was probably like "I'll swim down there and kill the monster!" and then dived in... swum just far enough away to be out of eyeshot of his companions, and camped out for a week. Then when he figured he'd been gone long enough, he picked up the old rusted handle of a forgotten sword he found on the road, and maybe the rotting head of some animal that'd been caught in a trap (or maybe the head of the owner of that sword hilt, which would also be almost rotted to monstrosity), swam back over to his buddies and wove an AMAZING TALE OF TACTICAL GENIUS. One that included a magical awesome Damascean sword (sorry pals, the blade melted after I killed the monster!)
And it's only when the Dragon attacks his town holdings later that he's actually forced to fight with people watching him (as until that point, all his fantastic fights happened when no one else was around), and it ends up costing him his life in the end because pride and reputation wouldn't let him back down.
@@KalebfenoirConsidering that both Grendel and his mother were actively killing people and then stopped after Beowulf fought them, unless he’s spending his alone time doing some serious monster diplomacy think it’s safe to believe he did actually just kill them
@@Kalebfenoirthat's an interesting interpretation and I could believe it
Ah Gilgamesh, history's first recorded jerk that turned his life around after losing his Bromance and was then immortalized into a legend that man will speak of so long as we exist.
The more I hear these old myths we discover via archeology, the more I start to doubt this is the last time civilization will collapse. And with that, maybe the legend of Gilgamesh will be forgotten.
@@VashdaCrash Well got morbid
@@jacobberg373 yeah why not
@@VashdaCrashNah, it's pretty poopy. You bring poop with your words. Distasteful, it is.
How about instead we work hard to populate the whole solar system with more cheap real-estate than a thousand Earths and so grant ourselves manifold resiliencies to the the forces driving collapse, perhaps going so far as to pull heavy materials from our star extending its life and preventing the ocean-boiling red giant phase from even happening; in so doing seeing these legends persist to the ragged edges of time. That just sounds _better_ to me.
@@Archgeek0 oh it sounds better. Time will tell though.
5:20 Fun Fact: “The Royal Game of Ur” Gilgamesh is talking about here is an actual board game, predating the earliest writing of _The Epic_ by about 500 years.
I wonder how it's played
Very uh
"Related" shape it is to the context its mentioned in here too
@@hassanalkhalaf1115 The Histocrat has a video about the Royal Death Pits of Ur that goes into detail about how it's played. It's kind of like backgammon and it has d4s. Irving Finkel of the British Museum translated the tablet that has the game's rules. The video is great, strong recommend if you're interested in this kind of thing.
I find it interesting how when they go off the kill Humbaba, Enkidu is initially hesitant, but goes along when Gilgamesh insists on it, but then later when Gilgamesh starts to get second thoughts, it’s Enikdu who is all encouraging and supportive and urges him on, and after that they take turns having doubts with the other assuaging them. Such a wholesome picture a loving couple mutually supporting each other, f it were not for the fact that the whole enterprise they are engaging in is careening ever forwards towards epic disaster for them both.
The phrasing of this always makes me think of Thelma and Loise driving off the cliff, which then leads me to imagine Gilgamesh and Enkidu driving full-speed over a cliff in a 1966 Ford Thunderbird, throwing their arms up at the last moment like they're on a roller coaster. It's definitely not an accurate comparison, but it is a wonderful mental image.
they're not a couple
@@whiteraven181 Even better, the freeze-frame at the end of the movie is meant to make Thelma and Louise symbolically immortal. Gilgamesh and Enkidu would approve, I think.
@@halflifeger4179 VERY debatable
@@halflifeger4179yeah let me go kiss my best bro on the lips rq
One of the best parts of Gilgamesh for me is when after they kill the bull of heaven, Ishtar appears on the walls of Uruk and starts shouting insults and curses at Gilgamesh. Enkidu wasn’t having anyone insulting his bro Gilgamesh so he TEARS OF THE BUTTOCK OF THE BULL AND YEETS IT AT HER. It hits her in the face. She then sets her priestess to mourn this butcheek and then disappears.
Gilgamesh is a story of the ultimate bromance.
Nothing stronger than brotherhood.
Lmao
No wonder she wanted Enkidu gone. She must have known that otherwise, those two muscleheads would be talking about it for freaking YEARS.
"Hey, bro, remember that time you hit one of our pantheon's most important goddesses square in the face with a bull's ass?"
"HAHAHAHA BRO YEEEEAH"
@@redwitch12 Tbf, Ishtar combines all the worst traits of Zeus and Hera with some of the positives of Aphrodite.
It gets even wilder than that, though - it can be inferred that Enkidu actually threw the Bull’s ‘sausage and beans’ at Ishtar! 🤣
Many translations of the Epic of Gilgamesh say that Enkidu threw the Bull’s right “thigh” at Ishtar… But some researchers *also* advise that the word “thigh” is often used as a euphemism for the genitals in several ancient Near Eastern cultures.
Combine that with Gilgamesh’s thorough ‘slut-shaming’ of Ishtar a few scenes earlier - along with the recurring phrase “[he] clapped his thigh” whenever one of the male characters sees a beautiful woman… and the picture seems to fit the rest of the story, at least in my own head canon.
Apparently, when the first translator (George Smith) realised he'd found the oldest known version of the Flood story, he got so excited he stripped off his clothes and danced around the room in front of startled museum staff, crowing "I AM THE FIRST MAN TO READ THAT AFTER TWO THOUSAND YEARS OF OBLIVION!" 😆
Also, everyone oohs and aahs over Enkidu and Gilgamesh's bromance, but my favourite bit has always been the part where Enkidu curses Shamhat, but is gently rebuked for it and takes it back. These stories seem to come from a time before the 'whore stigma', when prostitution or 'cultic sexual service' still had sacred / religious aspects to it, meaning prostitutes were more respected than they would later become. (Though of course that's sometimes disputed.)
George pulled an Arquimedes
the innate human impulse of stripping your clothes and dancing whdn you discover something
@@KagamineNachy me when I find 20 dollars on my hoodie:
@@airplanes_aren.t_real I hope you take the $20 out of the hoodie before you take off the hoodie
Given her general status and the fact that she taught him civilization, it's clear that Shamhat isn't a "wham bam, thank you ma'am" whore, but a Courtesan, an Oiran not just a Geisha.
For a history/mythology buff, the Fate franchise is the ultimate endurance test for willing suspension of disbelief. I’ve been a fan for over a decade; love the music, the awesome fights and storylines, the absolute labyrinth of backstory for lore gremlins like me to dig into. And I still encounter Servant designs that make me think, “what the hell were they thinking!?”
All we can do is cope by saying "the characters appear how society as a whole would view them" even then it's a stretch
I myself enjoy and love history and myth but i din't really have any problem with it. Its pretty much set in an alternate universe as deapite having some similar history, the backstory and personality of the characters are different. Its not about it being historically accurate anyways so i don't really bother.
@@reveredrogue9725yeah.
It's definitely an alternative universe cause Nasuverse is literally a multiverse, most of each are dreams of Gaya.
So yeah
I love the eulogy Gilgamesh sings for Enkidu on his death bed, "I weep for Enkidu my friend...I weep for you my brother".
Damn touching, it is.
Aside from the monumentous realisation of a story about immortality that has been immortalized, can we give an applause to Shamhat for being so damn good at what she does that she enlightened Enkidu.
The wildman experienced intense post-nut-clarity for an entire week to the point where he became a gentleman.
No aside at all. It's like Blue's Ramses video. Sure, Shelley's whole "look upon my works and despair" thing is good poetry, but given that we're still talking about the guy thousands of years later, I think Ramses wins that round.
a risky play! he could have easily gotten post-nut _regret_ just as intensely. and with THAT amount of post-nut regret, he might just an hero on the spot.
Explains where the trope of the wild man who gets civilized through beauty comes from. See Tarzan or King Kong.
@@wjzav1971 Or Disney's interpretation of Beauty and the Beast.
@@brigidtheirish I don't think that clarifies, the Beast was never that removed from civilization
I am partially convinced that the reason this video exists is because Red was so enraged by Fate's Gilgamesh design.
Can you blame her also they are the same people turn London infomos serial killer in to a skimpy little girl🤦♂️
also Enkidu's design... (he was soposed to be EQUAL to Gil, not a twunk...)
i still love them tho
For context, the reason why Gil looks like that to begin with is as a reference to Gilgamesh from the Tower of Druga series. Being designed back when Fate was Nasu's weird Makai Tenshou fanfiction that he wrote on the side of his mainline work, there wasn't actually any in-depth research being done, unlike *most* of the more modern designs (side-eyes Tezcatlipoca)
@@PutoMedicoBrujoo be fair, Fate's Enkidu, because they were made of clay, could essentially take on various forms. And the form they currently take is supposed to be of the woman who "tamed" them, which I think is a kinda neat twist on it.
Hell hath no furry like an irritated Red
Gilgamesh grilling Ishtar over her dead husbands was so funnyy💀
Gil really said ' nah Bishtar- your body count is an actual count of bodies, ain't gonna be me'
@@jaysuscrass9119 for real thoughh😭
Now it just makes “other media” seem like a multi-layered joke.
Anyone notice how STRICKINGLY similar that flood story is to the Noah story?
Yeah, it's almost like whoever wrote the Noah version had heard this one. Also flood stories are about as ubiquitous as cinder girl stories.
As far as we can tell, this is literally what the Noah story is based on.
@@tjarkschweizer I guess copyright hadn’t been invented yet cause they basically cut and pasted the entire thing
“Great Flood” type stories are very common in classic myths. This suggests one of two things: either there really was an extinction-level flood that only a small handful of humans survived but that somehow left no geographical evidence, or early civilizations usually lived in river valleys where severe flooding was a common enough problem that a flood devouring the whole world didn’t seem too impossible.
@@icarusty6481 Let's not kid ourselves. That first scenario is absolutely impossible and shouldn't even be considered.
Red: "The gist of it is that when a woman gets married she spends her night with Gilgamesh FIRST and her actual husband second."
Zeus: "Blimey! Why didn't I think of that?"
So the husband has to watch another man have sex with his wife maybe even take her virginity 😮
"Cause unlike you, Gilgamesh didn't have a super vindictive Goddess as a wife, who curse anyone anywhere close to your dick"
Because Zeus is picky. Gil just bangs whoever.
droit du seigneur
@@caryymytank8300 yep. He's closer to Apollo in terms of his standards on who to bang.
The way Red's voice fades away as she says "I can't believe they'd do this to me" as if she's walking away is amazing
Should we tell her Fate made King Arthur a blonde pretty boy as well instead of a red head with a beard?
@@Dadan-dan Don't forget how Mordred went from a dark haired, troubled and conniving lad to an angsty blond tomboy.
@@Dadan-dan So... funny story. King Arthur, or Artoia Pendragon as Fate renamed the character, is a woman. Mordred exists because Merlin decided to play a prank and temporarily give the needed equipment.
Fate is a lot of fun, but accurate it is not.
@@wanderingstorytellerj7758I think they were talking about King Arthur from fate prototype not Artoria from the normal fate universe
@@wanderingstorytellerj7758 *friend, in the original visual novel, saber did not had anything with mordred's birth, it was morgan with her own lover and just that, but yes Shirou is supposed to be galahad but Emiya Shirou is not only destroying the grail, something against the rules, and also being "actually satan³", but he really said "I am the bone of my sword" to Saber*
$10 says that the translators insisted that Enkidu and Gilgamesh were just really good friends, even after Gilgamesh makes a statue of his favorite man-snack
Petition for Red to do a tier list of all the fate designs
Yes that would be so entertaining and interesting to watch to hear her opinion on the fate design
@@marquisofhell244 I agree. 90 minutes of Red screaming sounds like fun.....
My only exposure to the Fate franchise are these comment sections, and I would _love_ that.
My senior project in high school was a study of the evolution of stories. I wrote a short story and then passed it on to a volunteer, who read through it a few times, then rewrote it from memory, using their imagination to fill in any gaps or parts they didn't like. That volunteer then passed it to the next volunteer, who repeated the process. The opening section of this video reminded me a lot of what I was trying to highlight with my project!
I'd love to see the results of something like that!
That sounds awsome!
What a brilliant idea I hope you got an A
That sounds really fun actually. I wanna do it with my friends.
How recognizable was your original story by the end of it?
I love how Gilgamesh gets in trouble, not for killing the divine beast, but for enumerating the red flags that makes him rescind his consent from Ishtar.
Ishtar being a massive bitch even in modern times. Ishtar's most recent appearance in Shin Megami Tensei V is very true to her arrogant character.
Gilgamesh delivered the first 'begone THOT' in history
Gilgamesh understood about don't put your dick in crazy and got punished for it
Sounds about right for all powerful egotists with no checks
Remember kids, Yandere is literally a trope aa old as fiction itself.
Typemoon's Gilgamesh is a blessing on this earth. I like the way the bull of heaven is drawn because the bull might have been identified with the Taurus constellation
Which would make sense given the epic was written during the Age of Taurus (when the sun rose in the constellation Taurus during the Spring Equinox). This was the same time TONS of cultures engaged in bull cults. The most iconic art at the time being of the Egyptian god Hep/Apis, a bull-headed god of fertility that wore the sun as a crown- because the sun was in Taurus during the spring! I love this stuff!
I’d really love to see aboriginal australian stories more represented on youtube and even better by you guys. This channel reignited a passion for history that i lost when i was younger and now i plan to go to university with a major in history. Being aboriginal myself its so rare to see our traditional stories given any light on this platform or even in general.
Holy hell, OSP is doing a Mesopotamia streak!
Enuma elish!! 💥
hol up, we still need 1 more Mesopotamian video before it counts as a streak
@@lightO_Owhat does that mean?
U could say it's a "mesopotreak" 😏
Or a mestreakpotamia
So instead of running away from death, Gilgamesh MADE himself worthy of immortalizing
A great moral for the story, “Don’t seek immortality and instead make yourself worthy of immortalising”.
in this case Immortalizing means Gilgamesh MADE himself worthy of having his tale be redicsovered so that his Legacy can be immortal
Beep bop... I'm the Philosophy Bot. Here, have a quote:
"All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely players: they have their exits and their entrances; and one man in his time plays many parts, his acts being seven ages"
~ Shakespeare
Gilgamesh has that Achilles or Quetzalcoatl vibe to him, where in a way his name has been remembered for so long that everybody knows it even if they don't know WHY they know it. And if they bother to look further into it, they start to learn all about him and his story.
It's kind of an impressive feat to be able to fade into cultural ubiquity, even centuries later.
@@philosophy_bot4171 good bot
...wait
I love how trope-y this epic really is, as highlighted by the one guard saying that one of them only lies and the other only tells the truth before being cut off.
Hmm, I assumed that was just a joke on Red’s end. (Not something from the story itself.)
@@pinkajou656 I think it was a joke by Red as well to highlight it. (Why do I always end up explaining my dumb comments?)
@@lazulenoc6863 fair point, the story is impressively trope-y even without Red’s intervention.
I read a retelling of this story for school the other year. Maybe it was that the writer was good, maybe it was that I was going through some grief myself, but Gilgamesh's grief and "existential crisis" over Enkidu really hit close to home. It's honestly so cool how human the core of the story feels. People have always grieved over lost loved ones, and even in a story as mythical as this, the OLDEST ONE WE HAVE, the raw feeling is the exact same.
One of the more recently recovered portions actually gives some sense about why it might be bad that Gilgamesh killed Humbaba. When they first encounter Humbaba, even though he's been constantly described as this awful monster, he's just making all the animals happy. The forest around him is beautiful, the animals are all singing. He's maybe not quite the monster they thought he was, but they go and kill him anyway.
Another recently discovered passage-possibly that same one-also revealed that Humbaba and Enkidu have backstory; they know each other. This shows that Enkidu’s concerns about killing him weren’t just from what he’d heard about him, but from personal experience.
Oooof
I also recall that Humbaba got lines despairing about the expansion of civilization is destroying nature and the wilderness, which makes the hippy hermit and environmentalist trope even older than we thought it was
it was like killing the deer god in princess mononoke
Not going to lie, I have to admire Ishtar's energy when she wanted to destroy the barrier between the living and the underworld in order to allow the dead to consume the living just because her romantic interest of the week turned her down.
Even gods can be bratty
This is the same Ishtar who, annoyed that a mountain wouldn't bow to her, broke the mountain apart. It's kind of on-brand for everyone's favourite useless goddess.
Relatable
According to the other video on Ishtar's worship leading to the cult that founded Aphrodite, total Aphrodite move too. I can see the thread
As a not-story teller (but avid story consumer) I am also firmly of the opinion that storytelling it the single most important aspect of our society. Points for:
1. It's how we pass on wisdom, it's the foundation of our communication across generations and allows us to share everything from lessons to emotions with people we've never met and who may even not have existed.
2. It's a form of creation, which is humanity's defining trait. Without creation there's no invention, no art, no song, no jokes and no dancing. We made all these things, but a song without a story is just pretty noise, and without meaning ascribed to it will be lost as soon as it falls out of the short-term memory of whoever heard it (and maybe whistled it for a week). Same with a dance, a painting. Even a joke needs context to be funny.
3. It allows societies to form. Storytelling is the root of all forms of creation mentioned above. Stories impart identity and context, and as stories are told and retold and woven into our heritage they form the basic fabric of society and its image of itself. That shared image creates a sense of cohesion, tradition, and identity that is essential for keeping a group together, especially when that group is millions, even billions strong.
Sir Terry Pratchett was right, humans need fantasy to be human. We're an animal of lies, like "justice, mercy, duty, that sort of thing." And we use stories to share them, until we can make them true.
in the times of pharaonic egypt since its unification by narmer, the political stability of the region was heavily supported by the myth of the divinity of kingship and the ruling monarch being the earthly administrator of divine order. pharaohs could not be imagined without representations of horus and ra.
so your third point makes a lot of sense - stories have the power to create societies! storytelling was essential to create the first stable sovereign state in our history, which would be the precursor to monarchy all around the world til present day.
honestly this story always makes me tear up a bit. like we still remember enkidu and gilgamesh, they both got what they wished for most through the most perfect series of events we could have ever imagines. the universe is beautiful sometimes
if Red is that distraught by Gil's fate design, NOBODY SHOW HER ENKIDU
Yeah Enkidu is a twink. And both wrestle using magic.
tbf Enkidu's design is supposed to be the beautiful prostitute that tamed him and- well it definitely matches that description
@@24mb34 eh.... yeah this is still the same issue I have with fate though. Ngl
I shouldn't have looked it up.
I actually think that one is a really fun decision, unlike Gil. Making Enkidu take on the form of Shamhat, having Enkidu be non-binary - it's a unique yet fitting take. Also, the voice actor in the new OVA is fantastic.
there is a bit of irony: Gilgamesh, in the end he achieved the immortality he sought by the fame he achieved through his great deeds being remembered for millenia
Meanwhile, over in Ur, Ea-Nasir has managed to achieve the same thing through selling really bad copper
Can you imagine Ea-Nasir as a kid practicing his tablets with the story and thinking "Man I wish my name will be remembered like this..."
And keeping all his hate mail apparently.
I love the accuracy of the artwork to the story. Unlike the Bible version of the Ark which was rectangular shaped the Epic of Gigemesh version of the Ark was actaully cubed shaped. The story also demonstrates that the Gods needs Man as much as Man needs the Gods showned by how all the Gods actually mourn the loss of mankind in the flood and all flock to Unapiscuns sacrifice as the only Human left.
And that makes sense because an Ark the word is used to refer to a box or chest. The weirdness of a king building a treasure chest larger than his house is going to stick around longer than some guy building a boat next to a river. Yes Noah would have been living next to a river - wood isn’t cheap in a desert.
There has been lots of theological, semi-theological and culturally righteous essays and treatises scribed on the boatness of the Ark and why it is built in this way and this manner. But ultimately Ark means box not boat
On the topic of the ark I’m fascinated how many cultures across the world all talk of an apocalyptic flood and the ones that don’t mention an insane flood instead talk about fire falling from the sky and the earth cracking open. Mesopotamia, Greeks, Africans, many middle eastern countries and even as far as Japan all say “their was this crazy flood that nearly destroyed the world” it so common I’m willing to believe it did actually happen. This is a theory I personally have, we got hit with another meteor strike and rather than kicking up a bunch of dust that choked out the sky like with the dinosaur instead it made the mother of all tidal waves and knocked so much water into the sky that it was raining almost constantly
Okay, the Fate tangent was pretty funny but I do wanna say that the whole "Gilgamesh being a gold plated broomstick" works pretty well when you take into account that its supposed to represent his cockier, no fear of death part of his epic. There's another variant of Gilgamesh (less gold, still a broomstick) where he's shed his golden armor AND his cockiness and is a better person all around. Still, calling him a broomstick is hilarious and just wait till you see what they did to Enkidu
Exactly! It is so funny to me that the historian people who complain about the accuracy of characters in design don't understand a lot of design principles.
Astolfo is also another example I want to bring up.
Astolfo's fate design is both appealing and lore accurate to the original tale. Stolfy was canonically a femboy in the original tale and while in the og he might not have worn women's clothing full time, it is still based on a scene of him crossdressing in order to give Ronaldo his vile of sense after Ron couldn't stop simping for Angelica to the point where being rejected by her had him go streaking in the streets of France.
Its amazing that that flood story is literally bar for bar the same as Noah's Ark. Really goes to show you the cultural roots by which a lot of these modern cultures share and the longevity of Mesopotamia's legacy.
Well story like Abraham and Noah with different names existed all over the Fertile Crescent from what we know
Only adds credibility to those stories, they're probably (wildly exagerated) retaling of event that truly happened. The flood probably didn't recovered the entire earth, but it must truly have been an event of mythical proportions that deeply marked the memories of those who survived it.
@@bdletoast09Isn't it thought to be around the end of the ice age?
@@bdletoast09it could also well have been that for these people who lived between two rivers and were probably very familiar with floods and how badly a big one can mess things up, a giant world-swallowing flood making its way into the mythos as a disaster of legend wasn't a giant stretch
I do think the narrative works way better in a polytheistic setting where the god that causes the flood and the god that saves humanity and promises not to let it happen again aren't the same god.
Also it's funnier when the Great Deluge was just created because Enlil wanted to sleep and humanity was too loud. Relatable.
One of my favourite jokes is that new Epic of Gilgamesh chapters release faster than some authors.
We will have a completed version of the Epic before we get to see the end of One Piece.
@@requiem6465 Or before Patrick Rothfuss finishes The Doors of Stone
@@theshig9618or before we get the last book of game of thrones
Good old Billgamesh
Hunter x hunter anyone?
I love the fact that the protagonist of humanities earliest recorded story is a massive himbo
You reminded me of my literature class where the teacher pointed out the translation described Enkidu as having soft ling hair “like a woman” and I haven’t been able to I imagine this since so thank you, I am not the only one thinking that now.
The Gilgamesh Epic is the earliest proof that there's no love or romance like a good BROmance.
Kiss the homies after you brawl
Nothing stronger than brotherhood.
Bromance so powerful that it blurs the line to brother love to romantic love
Yeah what bro doesn’t love his bro like he would a wife.
@@islasullivan3463 Wrong. A bro should love his best bro even more than his own wife.
I love how Gilgamesh gives us a look into just how universal many of these themes are. It’s an amazing glimpse into early civilization and what is timeless about it.
Death and Taxes are the constant between the natural state and modern civilization
As my dad likes to say, "Humanity doesn't change."
@@brigidtheirishonly its surroundings
@@backbak100 Exactly.
Turns out the whole "hero kicks rival's ass, rival and hero become best buds" trope is a lot older than it seems.
What’s really interesting to me is that Gilgamesh inhabits an extremely similar mythological role as Achilles and Cú Chulainn, an extremely talented warrior hero with some noble/Royal tie who is partly divine. Also the same-sex or at the very least homoerotic relationship with another warrior who is between them the first to die. Achilles and Patroclus, Gilgamesh and Enkidu, Cú Chulainn and Ferdia . Enkidu’s death drove Gilgamesh to seek immortality, where in contrast Patroclus’s death made Achilles stop caring for his own.
And then there's Ferdiad and Cu Chulain, who ended up fighting each other to the death...
My dad was thinking of naming me Gilgamesh, my mom wasn't gonna have any of that but I still like to go by it occasionally. The epic of Gilgamesh holds a very special place in my heart.
Man, that could've been cool though. I hope you at least got saddled with "Gil" or something similar.
Naming my future kid Nasir after another summerian legend
Bless your mother.
@@hassanalkhalaf1115 lets hope he doesnt get into metallurgy 🙏
My favorite thing about the epic of Gilgamesh is that the introduction starts off with
“ in those far off and ancient days”
Like even these people that we consider “ancient” also had a concept of ancient, and I find that so cool!
Another good example is the Greeks. We have a time period we call "Ancient Greece," but there is an Ancient Greece to that Ancient Greece, the Mycenaeans. And it can get pretty wild to think about that.
And even after all this, there are people like the Romans, who considered this stuff ancient and are still ancient to us.
I recall the opening lines being something like "A time before bread" which implies it was prior to agriculture and the social contract. This really puts things in perspective for how civilization started if it took a demi god for people to get together and found cities.
@@OsKarMike1306This is a conflation of ideas as those lines refer to the world’s creation. Gilgamesh comes some time after the creation of civilization. The gods gave humanity civilization and agriculture either themselves or via messenger sages depending on the story in question
"Hark, we spear danes in days of yore"
Seems to be a running theme in ancient epic poetry
It will never cease to delight me, that the oldest story humanity has is about how individuals achieve immortality through the value of civilization. It feels like everything that came after is just trying to fulfil that promise.
What a beautiful thing to say
I really love the Fate series, and Red's rant about the designs gave me LIFE
Now I kinda wanna see Red rant about the designs of the Fate series characters for like, 30 minutes straight
I'm not crying over the idea of storytelling as immortality you're crying.
I can imagine the Fate series being much different if Gilgamesh was just called Bil.
Everyone in the fantom would call him Bill instead of Gil lol
I present you the greatest hero in all creation, the one that withstood oblivion and held on to humanity as it's immortal king.
So what's his name?
Oh he's just Bil. Btw don't let him near your gf.
Or maybe Greg
For designs in fate , they actually pointed that out multiple times in the series as a running gag.
Alexander's partner points out how he's too tall to be the real Alexander.
Maybe I should also point out that sense the type monk franchise has a multiverse it's possible there's a gilgamesh out there that looks like are real world depiction.
Just to be clear Fate/type moon isn't the first series to redesign historical or mythological figures for their own settings there's so many Japanese franchises that does the same thing, but Fate is more popular.
@@happymate8943and also the loosest with designs, just from the amount of gender bending they do alone, like Nobunaga, King Arthur and the monk from Journey to the West.
I cannot believe that you managed to tell a story this important and significant in 17 minutes and still make it interesting and complete.
But that's literally the point of the series. It summarize legends
@@legs9086 there's a difference between "summarizing" and "explaining a complicated and extremely intricately fascinating story in a concise way that also manages to retain the original depth and appeal of the legend".
Anyone can do the former, but Red is a uniquely gifted and practiced storyteller who pulls off the latter and makes it seem simple.
@@richeybaumann1755’d say summarizing does what you just listed. Or at least good summaries do. What OSP does is make it entertaining or just not boring no matter what
I can believe it. Red is a story demigod.
6:09 Other men get death by Snu-Snu, Enkidu gets a college degree by Snu-Snu
I've always thought of death by snu-snu as a life goal, so thanks for giving me a much better one.
It's interesting how old the concept of "prima nocti"( or somesuch) is to describe how someone was a tyrant or how some part of the past was terrible.
There may never have been a time when that was the law but it speaks to how fundamentally horrifying the idea is and was to more or less everyone that's ever been around that it's one of the longest running ways to tell the audience that the king was a dickhead.
Immortality isn't outrunning death; it's outlasting it. Damn, Red, way to wax philosophical! Well done! 🙂
Don't let blue hear of it........
*Fun fact:* There is a comic called Gilgamesh II, written by Jim Starlin, which tells the story of an alternate reality's Superman landing on a dystopian Earth and becoming, in a journey pretty similar to the plot of "the Epic Tale", the future version of the legendary Gilgamesh. it's quite a fun read
Interesting
Hmmm might read it
Jim Starlin, as in the creator of Thanos and killer of Jason Todd Jim Starlin?
Gilgamesh ||: electric boogaloo
@@Nzosaba_MatengeTo be honest, Starlin didn't want to kill Jason. There are actually some pretty emotional unfinished pages of "Detective Comics 428" that show Jason surviving the explosion
I absolutely love the Epic of Gilgamesh and the thing that started it all for me was this one time I participated in an essay competition where the prompt was ‘who is the most important fictional character of all time?’ I ended up going with Gilgamesh simply because he’s quite literally the oldest. The argument I made was how stories carry on through time, so the older and more well known they are, the more important they are to how worldwide cultures are shaped. Quite literally, Gilgamesh is the first ever ‘Manly Man’ trope, (obviously) tied to older themes of masculinity and warriors and glory and stuff. Then there’s the story itself that you see in tons of other stories as well. The biggest example is Utnapishtim, which is basically the story of Noah’s Ark. It’s just so cool to think about how those elements in storytelling (which the Epic of Gilgamesh is full of) have carried on throughout time to the present. Gilgamesh and the Epic itself inspired other stories, which by extension could very well mean Gilgamesh inspired countless other people, making him so important to modern culture, even though most don’t even realize it. Anyway, I only won a minor prize for that competition (cuz let’s be honest, someone could write their whole senior thesis on that topic and debate alone so a 500 word limit was definitely not enough) and I couldn’t even use the prize cuz it was just a discount for something else that was ridiculously expensive. But yeah- really fun topic to think about
sometimes, old stories are told in a way that is lost on me. But the epic of Gilgamesh is one that actually made me cry reading it even today.
Tower of Druaga, a video game on SNES, features a protagonist named Gilgamesh. Nothing to do with mythological Gilgamesh, at all, just borrows his name. He's a typical anime boy, but wears an all-gold armor. Fate's creator was a fan of the game, and insisted on having the golden armor design for Gilgamesh. That's all there is to it. They didn't think about it beyond that.
People: There is some deep and meaningful symbolism to why Nasu designed them like this
Nasu/Takeuchi: I think it's cool
The problem isn't the gold armor (it suits for a king) the problem is he's 16 and most importantly not buff.
@@evanpereira3555 He's not 16 though he is repeatedly described as an adult and by japanese standard he is quite buff. As in they prefer the lean kind of buff and you would need a different kind of body and legend to convince them to make them Heracles level of buff
Different cultures simply have different standards of how they want to look. Even Heracles is not exempt from this look up Fate's version of Alcides. Their standard of "buff" is simply different and most do not go for the actual Bara muscle body look
@@doctoc684 my comment was an exageration about how he looks young and not muscular.
Anyways I look at Fate's Alcides and while the sheet on the head is well a bold choice, the muscular part is good (either for Heracles or even Gilgamesh actually). I too don't think we need to go all bara/buff body type, this isn't a culture difference (I mean my vision of a good muscular guy is the David).
@@evanpereira3555 For Japanese that is in the "older man" look, canonically Archer EMIYA is in his late 30's and Kirei in Fate/Zero was 28 in the prequel. Due to the art and anime look they would look younger but that is just the aesthetics when everyone considers their look "adult" like
I like how Red doesn’t give the word for word details of these stories. It encourages us to enjoy her videos AND read the stories ourselves to get the full experience!
I get this from Blue’s videos as well. Makes history and folktale homework enjoyable when I can easily supplement my studies with their videos.
Yeah she also changes some stuff. I'm still mad at her for changing an intersex person into a "gender non-binary" person.
@@Samm815 what video was that?
@@dufimaxi I think they're referring to the Underworld Myths video
@@Samm815 But isn't that the same thing? That sounds like the same thing...
The most important thing that the Epic of Gilgamesh teaches us is this: there is nothing more manly, than loving another man.
Bara is the purest form of love a man can experience 🌹
I love how Red's mic goes from stereo to mono just before she talks about the tablet being fragmented. And then goes back to stereo once she starts detailing the actual epic.
I think she had to cut out some background audio that was copyright-struck, so the voiceover suffered
Like any story, there are versions. In one, the goddess at the edge of the water where Gilgamesh finds the boatman is an alewife (think tavern keeper) named Siduri. After hearing Gilgamesh's sob story (like so many bartenders have since) she gives some pretty profound advice:
"When the gods created mankind,
They allotted to him death,
But life they retained in their own keeping.
As for you, Gilgamesh, fill your belly with good things,
Make thou merry by day and by night.
Of each day make thou a feast of rejoicing,
Day and night dance and play!
Let your clothing be sparkling fresh,
Thy head be washed; bathe thou in water.
Love the child that holds on to thy hand,
Make your wife happy in your embrace!
For this is the lot of mankind!"
Ecclesiastes approves.
Why is the advice in shakesperean English? It wasn't written in English so you had to actively make the choice not to translate it into contemporary English
@@cyan6483Can you read ancient Akkadian then?
@@cyan6483Perhaps because it isn't suppose to look deep, and it's supposed to look mundane, like wisdom hidden in plain sight forgotten by us?
@@cyan6483 And this is why you should always read the translator's notes.
Love how they just completely forget about Gilgamesh being an ass to his people after he got his bestie. Maybe the power of friendship and manly kisses just made him change his ways.
Bcause it worked and he was actually responsible and not an ass, he angered the gods, but he becam a better kingor far far worse
Well it's he's the king and a demigod, also his new friend distracts him from being a jerk towards his subjects.
I like to imagine there doing this epic fight that looks something out of a yakuza game. Enkidu was giving speech about how munch a jerk being while giving a Gilgamesh a pile driver or suplex
It helps he stopped afterwards
I named my cat Enkidu because he is a "wild man who eats grass".
The fact it was a training tool shows just how big of a deal this story was at the time, and even with that it's miraculous it was able to resist entropy enough to still exist well enough to be coherent at all.
It's genuinely heartbreaking that so much of our literary history is lost forever. So much history, so many personal experiences, just... gone...
I was watching an LP of Pentiment by a European Medieval history student (who enjoyed it a lot), and one thing they reflected on (with great sadness) is how so much individuality and uniqueness has been lost, either maliciously or otherwise, and will never be recovered.
I think that may be the reason why people really like when there are historical artifacts that do not describe epic biographies of kings or prophets, but are instead of just people doing things, like that Novgorodian boy's homework, or the Greek letter of a man asking for the other person to PLEASE return his millstone, or Ea-asur and his copper complaints. They make the past, and the people, at least in a little way, more HERE. And maybe us more THERE.
Only kind of related, this is why I love colourized vintage photos, because even if they aren’t 100% accurate, it makes that period in history more relatable, which in a weird way is doing a better job at preserving history than sheer accuracy ever will.
And with the way digital media is actively prevented from being preserved legally (for example, shows getting taken off streaming services after just a couple of months, games requiring connections to servers that are no longer running, and so on) our current era is in a huge preservation crisis. So much of current and recent art and culture is going to irrecoverably disappear, at a faster rate than ever.
@@samovarsa2640 I thought his name was Ea-Nasir????
...like tears in rain. Sorry not sorry.
I remember back in 8th grade, my teacher ATTEMPTED to teach my class about Gilgamesh. I say ATTEMPTED because the copies of the story he gave up had many lines blacked out, mostly the parts with anything considered sexual or inappropriate. But as such, we, the students, kept losing out on important parts of the story. We were annoyed because we actually thought the story was interesting and missing out on it was frustrating.
Both my older sister and two cousins had the same teacher, and this became such an issue that all four of us asked our parents for a complete copy of the story.
If that isn't a metaphor for lost media, I don't know what is.
It's like, if you don't want your students reading about the sex stuff, DON'T give us stories about the sex stuff!
They don’t realize that kids don’t care and even want to read the sex stuff lmao
So they gave a bunch of teenagers a cool story full of sexy boning and cool fight scenes, censored all the good parts, then told the teenagers they were too young for all the mature sexiness and violence that would make this cool story even better.
I assume this was an elaborate double-bluff scheme to run this story past overzealous censors and parents, because that was only ever going to end one way.
As a writer who think about death very often, this got me emotional! Immorality is found is stories and the people who read and tell them ❤
We cannot promise to conquer death, but we can promise to remember those who have left us. And above all else, we must remember that we have to try.
6:17 "Tarzan speedrun any%" is such a perfect sentence.
I think it needs to be underlined.
It's a phrase, not a sentence, and even as a phrase it is nonsense.
When you described how the story ends the same way it begins, I literally got shivers. It's actually incredible how we use some of the _exact same_ literary devices nowadays as 5000 freaking years ago.
We as humans just fucking love cliches and I love it
I mean, if it ain’t broke…
Legends say that the missing chapter where Enkidu and Gilgamesh make sweet, sweet love was actually the first brick thrown at Stonewall.
As this was Ancient Mesopotamia, it was called Mudwall at the time.
Its a FAD!
Says the man befor being hit with a wary normal and wary old stone
That's not a brick that's tablet 13!!
Guess Gilgamesh really MOLDED the clay at that time
I’ll leave don’t worry
The roots of so many later legends, myths, religions, and even almost every major action and adventure trope being present is fascinating. It was like, we are writing it All down as soon as we can write , every local legend and story into one epic story.