Israeli hostage Yarden Roman-Gat shares details of her captivity in Gaza | 60 Minutes
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 12. 2023
- Israeli mom Yarden Roman-Gat saved her child from Hamas captivity, but spent 54 days in Gaza after the Oct. 7 massacre. Her mother-in-law was killed in the attack and her sister-in-law is still a hostage.
#news #israelhamaswar #gaza
"60 Minutes" is the most successful television broadcast in history. Offering hard-hitting investigative reports, interviews, feature segments and profiles of people in the news, the broadcast began in 1968 and is still a hit, over 50 seasons later, regularly making Nielsen's Top 10.
Subscribe to the “60 Minutes” CZcams channel: bit.ly/1S7CLRu
Watch full episodes: cbsn.ws/1Qkjo1F
Get more “60 Minutes” from “60 Minutes: Overtime”: cbsn.ws/1KG3sdr
Follow “60 Minutes” on Instagram: bit.ly/23Xv8Ry
Like “60 Minutes” on Facebook: on. 1Xb1Dao
Follow “60 Minutes” on Twitter: bit.ly/1KxUsqX
Subscribe to our newsletter: cbsn.ws/1RqHw7T
Download the CBS News app: cbsn.ws/1Xb1WC8
Try Paramount+ free: bit.ly/2OiW1kZ
For video licensing inquiries, contact: licensing@veritone.com
The interviewer is trying to put words in her mouth trying to get her to fit into a certain narrative. Just let her speak and allow her to express what she had been through.
Indeed
This interviewer is dated at best, she is so out of touch it’s just unbelievable. There was no need to inject words in to this interview everyone knew what she meant.
I get what you are saying but also it could be as simple trying to helping someone find the right English words, like guards vs guardian
I definitely felt the same way. The interviewer definitely picked a side and was pushing a narrative during this interview.
@@brimichelleg5480she's a grossly overpaid out of touch tv personality
I like this woman, she is speaking for herself and not letting the reporter put the words she wants to hear in her mouth.
Reporter, echoing the standard psychological dogma: "Do you think at some level you just shut down, almost as if it was happening to another person?" Hostage, with a bit of an impatient look: "No. It was happening to me." She recognized what the reporter was doing and just set the record straight.
Reporter absolutely trying to get "material" out of the interview
Also this statement that the reporter wanted to put in her mouth, that the hostages were drugged to make them look happy and smiling when they were handed over. They want to show a very specific image. The fact that children in Gaza miss their mothers because they sit in Israeli prisons for a long time, often without charge, is also very tragic and sad. All people want is to live in peace! 😢 I hope 'all' hostages will be free soon and healthy!
Umm excuse me but where exactly did you get your info about Gazans sitting in Israeli prison without charges? @@bilqis8044
@@dh4130 WTF. You gaslight her. You do not think she was traumatized?
@@dh4130how do you know?
I was listening to one of the Palestinian women taken captive by israeli soldier where they tortured her, she had a breast feeding 9 month old kid, they neither let her or her husband go, continuously questioning her about hamas, to which she said I don't know but they said you're a liar, they used to hit her, many days held her arms tied to her back and hit her in this condition, took her hijab off, psychology torture her by shooting in the air and telling her that they killed her husband, and then ask about hamas, for the first days she was the only women in all the men, then she was taken to a room where there were other women the youngest being 15 years old, they (women there) told her that here they were sexually assaulted and raped, and after 54 days of continuous torture she was released, now that was the interview of Palestinian woman and this of an israeli held captive by hamas. The difference in treatment is loud and clear. It doesn't take much of a brain to figure out what propaganda media is trying to do and what the reality is.
I don’t usually watch ANY of the 60 Minutes videos and I am sure many people know WHY, but this one was calling for me to watch. It was close to what I expected from one side but the guest was heroic in my eyes. God Bless her and her family.
Totally agree!
Amen !🙏🏻
Same here, stopped watching 60 Minutes years ago for the same reason. I watched this video because of the subject matter and even here, the reporter kept asking her leading questions that were completely wrong. You know what, just let her tell her story, you're just there to report it, that's all.
@@Gamble661it’s literally her job to ask questions, but when the woman didn’t want to answer she didn’t push her too. She did a great job with this interview.
What's the reason?
This line of questioning is insane. Just let her talk about her experience freely, without feeding and directing her answers
No it was almost like they are making it sound nice so I have to make it sound bad
she probly didnt understand the questions proply
Don't you just love the intermediate shots of the interviewer's facial expressions?
@@MartinMaatit's all a tv formula dated circa 1975 ..
@@MartinMaat 🤣
I wish everyone had the ability to feel empathy for everyone and not just their own kinds
I can sense the lack of empathy coming from you. Sad to see.
That’s true. There are some who believe that anyone who is not of their tribe are no better than cattle to be disposed of.
I pray for those ignorant people who will be judged by the Messiah Yashua.
Why is that so. Hard
I don’t understand it. When I see the little children crying or buried under rubble I see my own children..
@@moshefund1 Like to elaborate on how did you deduce that from my comment? Or did you make a judgement call from my name instead? Extremely Sad to see.
I love how strong this woman is not falling into answering the questions or fill in the blanks, good for you, thats one problem with media all they want is the story and questions they want answered
Yarden thank you for sharing....not easy for any weak-hearted to do an interview and share your experience, you wanted to share and held up...more power to you and prayers for all the hostages to be released safe and soon. Thank yo 60 minutes.
It feels like the interviewer wants her to say what she wants, she didn't let her describe things her way.
Mainly she wanted her to admit rape but the girl was careful enough to not go down her way as she avoids it many times cause deep down she knew what they want her to admit.
Because once she actually is verbally expressing it, it becomes real for her, and she wants to still feel like that did not happen to her.
Poor poor woman.
@@nechamascher7199if the Hamas raped or tortured this women she would definitely said that but the truth is that not happened thats happened only with Palestinians children in israel prisons for years !!!!
She said she wasn't raped, and I assume her story is accurate. It could turn out that someone was raped, and they don't want to say so on television, however we don't know this is the case. The constant fear of rape may have been terrifying even if it didn't happen.
@@nechamascher7199 Wow! Are you implying she was actually raped?
It was too notable that the interviewer consistently steered the conversation to align with their agenda: "mostly peaceful" Palestinian Arabs kidnappers protecting their hostages from Israel in both questions and comments.
All released captives were threatened by their government, not to say a good thing about how they were treated
That’s why she had a complete sarcastic smug look and said she wasn’t treated as a human being and several other ridiculous behaviors of her captors! I think she isn’t going to let them Win by letting them see her tore down by them she instead was strong!
Imagine saying good things about someone that kidnapped you and killed innocent people 🙄
@@shoponadimellc3413 If it matters if she was treated bad, then it should matter if she was treated well. don't you think?
@@AmrluluShe held as a HOSTAGE! Wake up!
Their government is not like a muslim or authoritarian govt. People can say what they want.
What a dear woman. I am so happy she is safe now. ❤️
You sound very low info..
This was a prove that the kombatents of Gaza didn't harm or try to harm her
Amazing mother and father. Putting it all on the line to save their children.
Have you ever imagined all the Palestinian children who were murdered by IDF ??? Is that even a conscious possibility for you?
@@markbeyerauthor The problem with that line of thinking is that Hamas is the one who started this latest conflict. And if the Palestinians refuse to accept the Israeli state then there really is no resolution that can exist.
And a further problem with that line of thinking is that IDF doesn't slaugther civilians in the same manner Hamas does. So it's not equivalent.
On the other hand released minors from West Bank were beaten starved tortured and you could see physical signs of torture on them
and no interview
They weren’t the ones massacred on Oct 7. Stop taking attention away from the true victims aka Israelis slaughtered on Oct 7.
@@alnibodycare lmao how did you decide Israelis are the true victims? Palestinians have been massacred for nearly 75 years and almost 20,000 of them have died in these two months alone. if you don't think Palestinians are humans just say that next time.
I saw the interview of the fat woman that claimed Israel starved her. Obviously the woman had not missed a meal in her life.
Lies! Palestinian prisoners eat better than the civilians in Gaza... no one is starving them and torturing them... They are in prison for choosing terror - and that is on them!
Why Israeli hostages were forbidden to give interviews when they were first released?
The ones that didn’t give interviews had family members still in Gaza and were threatened by Hamas, and most were also too traumatized to give details.
@@lenoreandreas4000so do you always believe everything at face value or is this something you recently decided to do?
Because Natanyahu is afraid of what they might say 😅 like the fact that they shot their own people on October 7th
They needed time to coach them first. We been knew this was coming.
they weren't
Praying for the safety of the hostages 😢❤
Yeah the Palestinian hostages that have been held captives for over decades
@@zeinabsleiman2572 These are violent prisoners, not hostages.
@@Sarah456ertucjare kids and people in hospitals violent?
@@Sarah456ertucj5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12 year olds are violent criminals? 🤡🤡🤡🤡
Praying for Palestinians who are being oppressed in their own country.🙏
Total respect to this lady. A very brave woman and a powerful communicator. I wish her every success for her future.
Well trained for this interview... hilariously clear😂😂😂😂
Yes, even IDF admitted that those destruction was from IDF tanks, Hamas didn't have big weapons to make big holes to concrete.
Exactly
So if they where waybing a white flag, how was their killings accidental?
The military thought they were Palestinians , Those are not humans , This is the attitude in the IDF .
Because isreals enemies routinely raise false white flags in order to ambush and hurt isreali soldiers
@@Colt.173 exactly
they thought they were just gonna commit a war crime, but turned out they just shot more Innocents
Soldiers are frightened also. Casualties from friendly fire are not unusual in a hot firefight in active combat. Getting back to friendly lines during active combat is a difficult thing to do under such circumstances. Recently, a 4 year old little girl was sent out into open by Hamas fighters during the morning to see if the IDF in front of them were awake. She was almost shot because the IDF soldiers heard rustling after being ambushed the day before. It’s what war is like, especially against an enemy like Hamas who use asymmetrical warfare tactics and view civilians as protection.
Stay strong Yarden, you are a special person to have survived the atrocities inflicted upon you and the people of Israel. May you and your family recover fully and grow from strength to strength. God bless you.
😅😊
Atrocities???
@@Melina521-ei7vj Have you already forgotten what happened on 7/10 or do you deny it even happened? Or who was responsible?
@@SaxonsGlory In Hebrew we would say: Ata ma habets et emet. And applying that phrase I will explain each point. On October 7, you saw images of Hamas entering Ofakim, Sderot, Kfar Aza, Zikim, Re'im and Nahal Oz, with weapons, but maybe you and all the people in the West don't know that all the Jewish settlers who are in the settlements and kibbutzim are armed people.
It's not like your neighborhood in your city, where you see neighbors in a neighborhood and you assume they are unarmed civilians, no, not at all, the Jews who are going to settle in the occupied Palestinian land have good guns, and assault rifles. THEY ARE NOT UNARMED PEOPLE.
On Israeli news on babies slaughtered? Firstly, you have to be very naïve to believe such a thing, secondly the whole region is full of cameras and drones flying and recording..
Possibly you don't know that at the northern entrance of Gaza there is an Israeli military checkpoint called Erez where there are many cameras and drones……. Also to the northwest in front of Gaza there is an Israeli military barracks that is also a military training center called Zikim, where there are cameras and drones as well……….. . Also to the east of Gaza, in Nahak Oz, there is a LARGE UNIT of Israeli Artillery that is FULL of cameras and drones……
In addition to that, in the settlements, houses and kibbutz there are ALSO cameras and drones..
In other words, if what the Israeli government says had been true, surely the whole world would already be flooded with videos of Hamas militants killing babies, children and unarmed women. There's none of that.
The Supernova Sokkol festival full of naive Jews supporting the ocuppation? FYI, there was a fight there. There was crossfire between the Israeli army and Hamas. How many people killed at the festival were killed by Hamas and how many people killed at the festival were killed by the Israeli army?
About the defenseless people who were in the path of Hamas from October 7 until the next day, for moral reasons I cannot refer to that without first referring to the tens of thousands of Palestinian children, women, elderly that the Zionist power has murdered since 1930... For the Zionist State of Israel to be founded, thousands of Palestinians had to die during the bombings carried out by the Jewish terrorist groups Haganah, Lehi and Irgun in the 1930s and 1940s, and during the great Palestinian revolt, and during the massacres committed in 1947 and 1948, more than 300 massacres of Palestinian villages have been documented. committed by Zionist irregular militias to force Palestinians to flee Palestine, and to be able to found the State of Israel.
And since 1948, more than 100,000 Palestinians have been killed by the Israeli IDF in bombings, in military raids, and so on. Doesn't that matter? But if the Palestinians react and defend themselves, they are condemned?. Do you expect the Palestinians to allow themselves to be killed in silence, without reacting?
First, then, let's talk about the atrocities committed against the Palestinian population over decades. Otherwise, we fall into immoral discrimination. The facts and numbers are clear.
On innocent Jewish deaths on October 7 should also be taken into account the Israeli tanks that have fired on Jewish houses in some settlements where Hamas militants were hiding.... . Not only can you see the testimonies of neighbors on Hebrew websites, but also the Israeli police themselves have released videos taken from their helicopters where Israeli tanks shoot on houses killing Jewish families.
There are also independent meida that have investigated the truth of October 7, neutral media that say the truth and not the victimist propaganda of the Israeli government. You can even search on the internet.
About the former hostages, surely you don't know but since the first elderly woman was released and shook hands with a member of Hamas, the Netanyahu government issued a resolution where the hostages are forbidden to make statements, so it is understandable that very few say that they had good treatment and medicines, and most only speak to say "bad things". that is, to maintain the propaganda of the Israeli government.
Mu suggestion: Don't believe the propaganda of Israel's government, because since 1905 the propaganda strategy of the Zionists (I repeat Zionists, not Jews, to be a Jew is not to be a Zionist) is one of their greatest resources to distort the truth and hide their crimes.
After this long explanation I don't have any more time, but I will tell you that I am always surprised to find people in the West who are neither Jewish nor Israeli who make a fierce defense of the crimes committed by Israel.
That is understandable inside Israel, because all Jews there are socialized and educated from birth to assume that Palestinians are inferior and savage beings who are worthless. And the Zionist project needs to keep that racism and discrimination alive in order to sustain itself. I know Israel and Palestine well, so I know what I'm talking about. But why some people in the Western can be so blind and support the massacre of tens of thousands of Palestinians?
I think it's because of a lack of information, because the Zionist propaganda that is spread by the mainstream media is the only thing that reaches most people.
Anyway, I believe that Zionism must be confronted, Zionism is only destroying the humanist legacy that always existed in Jewish culture, Zionism is even going to destroy the memory of the Holocaust because the world no longer believes the justification of the Holocaust as a Zionist excuse to justify any killing of Palestinians.
And assuming you don't know that for decades the military has killed tens of thousands of Palestinian women, men, children, babies, YOU DO KNOW what's going on now. In just three months, Israeli bombs have killed more than 10,000 Palestinian children and babies. But you don't ask about that atrocity.
FYI Hamas is the Palestinian resistance, Hamas is defending its land and its people.
In case you didnt know it, until the nineteenth century, a majority Arabic population of local origins and a smaller Jewish population, also native to the area, lived peacefully in the region of Palestine. And the two populations would have continued to coexist peacefully, finding their way after colonialism, if the Zionists had not appeared with their violent political project, using economic power, political power and massacres to expel the Palestinians Arabs from that land.
The Palestinian Arabs were natives of that land, so they had a natural right to it, because their parents and their parents' parents and their fathers' parents were born there.
Letroot, shalom.
Have you already forgotten what lead to 7 Oct? Or do you deny it even happened and who was responsible?
well, now she knows how the gaza'ns feel for the last 30+ years!, being prisoners on their own lands......
How do you reckon the Palestinian people feel now? Did they even no what happened on Oct. 7, until the storm hit??
this is a crazy thing to say to a literal hostage. i am also pro-palestine, but it’s insane for you to act like this woman PERSONALLY occupied and mistreated gaza. she also went through something traumatic, even if taking hostages was necessary for a ceasefire deal. she didn’t deserve this as far as i know.
1. We watch this aware that their PM has warned them against speaking good about their captors.
2. We wonder if 60 Minutes would ever interview at least one of those Gazans many of whom are now orphans.
Or at least interview a released palestinian hostage.. the 13 year old with the broken arms!!!
Or maybe the poor lady with the burned disfigured face...
This type of media negligence is very dangerous...
that was fake a video showed him fine before his release dont fall for this crap@@miram227
Like the lady from Germany in the back of the truck she was treated so well@@miram227
@@miram227at least she kept her arms and her head and wasn’t raped thank allah
she said it herself (on getting bombed) "you cannot ignore it, its very intense". now imagine the locals, for the past how many years.
yeah! It's inhumane!!!!
I guess they should stop electing terrorists and rejecting peace!
But they keep f'ing around, and refuse to keep finding out
They were not bombed everyday for the last 75 years.What are you talking about? I have no compassion for people who elected terrorists as their leader.
There are far more rockets from Gaza than from Israel. Think about why that is. Think about why one Rocket from Israel causes more destruction than a hundred from Gaza. Both Sides have Access to certain technology. And Money.
Israel doesn't kidnap rape and abuse terrorists. that's the difference.
These conditions are much better than what the other side does. She is healthy and alive. Much much better what the other side does.
The other side shall not be named as YT will censor this comment.
Blah, blah, blah.....
@@Motty-tj3ok Blah blah blah blah banana
wow this lady is very brave, she looks so positive after what happened to her.
Anyone else notice how she was not allowed to talk about the fact that she was fed, or about the fake drugs accusations? It definitely was a traumatic experience, but everything that she said was rather the trauma from her expectations, she was expecting to be raped, but instead was given clothes to be covered, she was expecting to be held in a terror tunnel, but instead was kept in an apartment, she was expecting to be killed but returned home. I mean the horror of her kidnapping experience is mostly from fear and not actual experiences. And I wouldn’t be surprised if her sister was killed by the Israeli bombs, that seemed to be the most terrifying part.
@@DiamondWhite91yeah she was probably fed by Israel because they spread the narrative that they’re being starved. It’s obvious by her reunion video that she was fed.
What a brave woman. Bless her and her family. It’s irritating how the journalist tries to put words in her mouth with the questioning. (Did you feel hidden? Did it feel like it was happening to someone else?) Just let her talk.
"happening to someone else...". The lady gave a good, down to earth, Middle Eastern reply, "no, it was happening to me". None of the pop psychology the interviewer attempted.
Journalism is dead and I despise what passes in its place. This is why I don't watch 'the news' on TV.
@@healthyself7941The "happening to someone else" is a coping mechanism that some people use for very traumatic situations like sexual abuse. Thank goodness she didn't go through that.
You must remember the that the interviewee is speaking in her 2nd language. Wouldn't hurt to be helped find her words at times.
And the drugs question as if they were given drugs to appear happy upon leaving. The woman refused to be drawn into that.
you are very lucky to be back safe, unlike 20000++ people who lost their lives
Man, you got Hamas' numbers wrong. It's already 200,000 or more! In a few months these Hamas "Ministers" will claim that 105% of Gazans have been killed. Just give it time
Et les sourcils bien épiler en plus, étrange
@@ehnon 我不懂你在说什么
@@ehnon Un commentaire vraiment stupide. Pourquoi ne pas dire ce que vous insinuez? :)
@@driss409 j insinue rien je constate.
You can see the hurt you tell she is a very honest woman . Am so glad she is back
Brave couple, they prioritized their child and persevered through this horror they were forced to live. God bless them.
This suffering is experienced by Palestinian prisoners who have been in prison for decades. Hamas's desire was to get the prisoners back. The story did not begin on October 7, but rather before that.......
She was able to discuss being dragged half naked and a fear of being violated but she won’t confirm or deny the drugs story or discuss food. Of all the things you won’t talk about…very interesting. Almost as if she was told not to talk about that stuff specifically. I hope she is safe after giving this interview. The witch hunt is in full effect right now:/
People are stupid. Many of these hostages have said people still have family that are hostages. These people have class and don’t want people to think or know what they are going through. This lady was probably starved for manipulation for want men wanted and given drugs. People are stupid and can’t see she is protecting others.
My feeling was that she was not willing to participate in propaganda. That she WAS dragged half naked and in fear. It happened, but that she (and as far as she knows) nobody else was drugged to "look happy" and friendly with the captors. Smiling and handshakes was an image of the release that Israel felt hurt its position. Kids were coming out of Israeli detainment with broken arms. Neither Israel nor Hamas fed captives well, but one of those parties was under seige and had little food to offer. That may be why she did not want to comment on food. She knows the food situation in Gaza is insecure for everyone.
Couldn’t agree with you more. Thats what happened with the 85 year old hostage Yocheved Lifshitz who was pressured by the Israeli government to not discuss how well Hamas treated her so the world wouldn’t sympathize with Hamas.
She isnt ready. PTSD is there.
Yes, they were treated with respect and Israel don't want the truth to come out, so they are told to make up a stories of anti God activities
From 60 minutes we got around 2 minutes of actual interview, of which 90 seconds was this pathetic interviewer putting words into the hostages mouth.
I am a Dutch grandmother and never knew war, however I learned a lot about the horrible Holocaust and the attacks on GOD's Israel. Now Oct. 7th. 2022. And the world did not united stand up against he terrorists. You people and hostages are in my mind every day and I pray for you. 🌷🌷🌷
Amazing actually. She wasn’t raped, footage of her release show that she clearly wasn’t starved. She had not one bad thing to say about her captors. And she made it out alive! What ever they are trying to portray here, clearly isn’t working.
She’s not allowed to talk about them, feeding her
Some memories are painful, if you talk about them you break down. I guess she is not ready yet to talk about it, in time she will as she heals.
The jewish reporter tried to make her say that she was rape. But she said the true.
Half of what the reporter is saying/questioning her about is engineered lies. And she doesn’t/can’t go along with it all as you can see. So at these parts she says she can’t speak on that particular matter.
I personally think she may have had a protector and a sexual partner that’s all many people are trying to survive in any way they can
Probably because she was very well fed and didnt want to make them look good 😂
She was allowed to speak about everything. But when they asked her about getting fed and if they treated her properly. She said I didn't want to talk about it. I find it strange!
Exactly… she should’ve shed light.. even the topic of the hostages getting drugged
She may have been warned not to, because of those still in captivity. She may not have wanted to lie, either.
the goal is to show how hamas are evil ...at same time she said they didn't touch her ...and now she is free while thousands of people in gaza died and no one will interview their relatives to show you the real truth of israeli evil
What are you trying to say that Hamas is humanitarian? Come on... babies and children were murdered with knives. We will not forget, we will not forgive.
The apartheid state of Israel had warned all freed hostages not to speak about any positive treatment afforded to them by Hamas. They were too worried about how barbaric Israel looked when all of their released Palestinian hostages were beaten, not fed, left naked and came out with broken bones. All the videos we saw of the freed Israeli hostages showed them to be smiling, thanking their captors, in good spirits, and when forgetting to shake their hands, turning back and then shaking their hands and thanking them.
Weird how most hostages have nothing negative to say, but a few do.
They are afraid to jeopardize the lives of those left behind
What about the thousands of children murdered without mercy? Can someone share their stories as well.
exactly...
LOL "you know some of their hostages were given drugs upon their release". Ex hostage dismissed the interviewer straight away. Let her tell the truth stop trying to twist things and put words into her mouth.
That's exactly what came to my mind
You are the only intelligent person here
She certainly didn't deny it. That statement obviously triggered something she didn't want to discuss.
Her sister in law is still a hostage, anything she says that is negative that Hamas don't like would put her at great risk.
@@Indonesiansurftravel Very valid point!!
I'm glad she's back with her family. I hope the others are soon. Peace for Palestine and peace for Israel. Something needs to change.
I tell you what needs to change: Palestinians (as well as other Arabs) should stop making a condition on the Israelis: stop existing, or you will not know peace. Guess what... of the two conditions, Israelis see "stop existing," as a little bit less compatible with life than having to wage war. They return war for war, and they win. Thank G-d
Do not forget that out of 9 million Israeli citizens, only 7 million are Jewish. The other 2 million are various Arab ethnic groups: Druze, Bedouin, settled Muslim Arabs, settled Christian Arabs. They are citizens with full rights, often quite patriotic about being Israeli, serving in the army, participating in the legal system, education, etc.
If
Yeah, peace for all the Israelis who pay to build and maintain concentration camp walls and military blockade. Peace to those Nasi Nazis 🙃
yes, islamic death cult must change!!
islam is what brings the suffering, all over the world@@daisylovett
That something is Hamas
This is heart breaking at least she is home safe now.
She’s alive 11 k children’s are dead a torso 23 k people innocent civilians are dead !
@@sacredintimacytarotwho started this on October 7?
@veenapalanisamy8185 those 11K children did
This suffering is experienced by Palestinian prisoners who have been in prison for decades. Hamas's desire was to get the prisoners back. The story did not begin on October 7, but rather before that.
@@MohamedAbdullah-zr6ofprisoners who attacked military officers?
Thankfully the world can truly see what Islam is all about.
You were seen as a person or you wouldn’t be alive.
The husband was very smart, saving their child.
Joe Biden has dropped almost 100,000 bombs on innocent women and children in 5 countries and is dropping a bomb about every 12 minutes somewhere. How can come this lady isn't talking about what the UNITED STATES MILITARY is doing?
If Israel wants stop being called Nazis, they must stop behaving like Nazis and using the lives of thousands of children as collateral damage.
No, he was smart enough to think that his wife could be one of civillians killed in bombings
Btw that skeleton journalist reaction did show what she wanted to hear,
And that skeleton should interview in presence of other hostages also, for contradiction to be seen
I believe we should call for a referendum.
The most rightful thing is a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want.
Simple. Very simple.
It's not a thousands of years matter.
Otherwise, the immigrants who stole the land should go back to where they came from.
@@youssefdiraniits all about Water, if the Jews would just do them and not want to RULE/RESTRICT ect the Natives then it would ve chill
I don’t want to go there meaning I don’t want to lie 😂😂😂😂
Meaning she doesn't want to say something that might endanger the hostages still being held, including her sister-in-law.
exactly! why so many people cant understand those hostages cant talk because it might put in danger the hostages still held captive?@@Decision_Justice
If she came back as the same person. She’s been treated well and not abused like thousands of children and women are abused in Israeli jails since decades.
I pray you heal within the love of your family. I am sad for what happened to you and my heart hurts for the other hostages and those who were killed!
The fact that an Israeli hostage video gets dislike bombed, but palestinan hostage videos are praised for bravery. Good job idiots, not biased at all!
We don’t care about Israhell settlers colonizers hostages they were treated well and returned unlike of Palestine hostages that got killed tortured sexually abused in their homeland and land stolen and more settlements for these settlers 😒.
Wait, how can you tell how many dislikes videos have?
I have never seen an interviewer try to feed the interviewee responses like this one. Despite the hardship that she faced, this hostage did the honorable thing and did not lie about her captivity. She made it clear she was not raped.
there were other things she didn’t want to mention, but you could see it in her eyes something happened
So true. Putting words or feelings in her mouth.
It is not easy what she did go trough, thats for sure.
I wonder what she thinks about P@lest1nian hostages...
@@nilgunozturk-pehlivan7500 theres always things you would never say on tv not even with family, so i guess we will never know what these poor people went through
@@cyberpun2552offcourse she was affraid and that is not going to get away soon.
Many other where together but she was alone she says so that is scary.
About the food... maybe she didn't like it but they feed her what they got and we all know that was not much because the food supply was stopped by isr@e.l
Her sister in law still in captivity. She can't tell everything now but we'll know later maybe
So glad this woman is safe and with her family and gets to share her story. Its ironic hearing the things she points out that are terrible knowing those same things are the daily lives of Palestinians. She said said they dont care, but i think they cared…one must reflect on how the israeli education system literally teaches its kids to hate palestinians- to not care, and it’s ironic that this woman is wanting palestinians to care about her.
She doesnt want to talk about how she was fed or not drugged… considering how many Palestinians are starved daily well before oct 7. And how 105 released hostages all were pleasant. I didnt see all of the release aired. Would be curious if someone has that footage.
What a dramatic voice and face expressions of the interrogator! 😂
'Staying in war zone is horrific' & 'I don't wanna go there'. Speaks deep of happenings despite the interviewers narratives. I can't imagine those who were living there how terrible jt would be for them. May God bring a lasting peace to the two states.
You haven’t seen the little boys and girls shaking uncontrollably from fear on youtube. It is horrific.
She literally took a trip to a war zone 😂
If Israel wants stop being called Nazis, they must stop behaving like Nazis and using the lives of thousands of children as collateral damage.
Gaza is not a state. Israel and the US has prevented the Palestinians from having their own state for decades. The Palestinian territories are under military occupation by the apartheid state if Israel for more than 5 decades and Gaza has been under a brutal blackade for almost 20 years. Women, children and innocent men are being taken hostage in the dark of night weekly and sometimes daily in the occupied West Bank. Peaceful protests only resulted in more slaughter of innocent people.
as they say from the mountains to the sea israel must be free!
but god must decide which side he wants to be on!
but yes he will probly pick israel because there is more people on that side!
7:50
Interviewer: Did they feed you?
Hostage: Ye..
Interviewer: You don’t want to talk about that
🤣🤣🤣
She'd go to jail if she said it was delicious
I can't imagine the anxiety the poor brother had to feel every night to hear if she was free. Bless him.
I believe we should call for a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want.
Simple. Very simple.
It's not a thousands of years matter.
Zionism is danger and should not be adopted by a state.
@@youssefdirani What rubbish!
The Jews are the indigenous people of Israel. The bible, history, and archeological evidence proves it. However, Many Palestinians actually came from neighbouring countries. They should go back to them. Even more than that, millions of Jews were displaced from other countries both in Europe and the middle eastern Muslim countries. They were forcibly expelled with no compensation for the property and homes and businesses they were forced to leave behind. No one gave anything back to them. So your suggestion is very 1 sided@@youssefdirani
@@user-fr3md1dh4m population density of people living there was probably higher than that in Syria. Population count in the 1922 census was around 750,000 and area is 25,483 square kilometers, which means a population density is about 29 individuals per square kilometer. May you explain why is this few ? Even in 1922, after that many Zionists actually came to Palestine, when jews were 11% of the population (again my problem is Zionists, not jews), things could have worked out if the right to self determination was considered. Regardless, it's not relevant whether they were few or not. Indigenous, of all religions, own the land !
No one is saying there weren't jews there ! So of course those indigenous jews are Palestinians and have the right in the referendum as much as any other native whatever religion they belonged to.
I think there are some nuances behind "forcibly expelled". PJCA was the Palestinian section of ICA or JCA (Jewish Colonisation Association) led by Baron Maurice de Hirsch. The aim of ICA was to support Jewish emigration from Europe and Asia to other parts of the world; to create agricultural settlements in North and South America; and to obtain authorization and autonomy for these settlements.
I wonder how, assuming antisemitism is true, the Zionists preferred the fight with Palestinian natives over living in Argentina, US, or Canada ?
Wasn't it clear from the beginning they're making a mistake. I imagine the immigrants not really knowing what is awaiting them.
Besides any refugee should come in peace and be polite, but here's what happened :
I quote from Ahad Ha’am one of the foremost pre-state Zionist thinkers who died in 1927 (that is during early British mandate):
They treat the Arabs with hostility and cruelty, deprive them of their rights, offend them without cause and even boast of these deeds; and nobody among us opposes this despicable and dangerous inclination
end of quote, from a study made by UN. "Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem: 1917-1947 (Part I)" it's published on UN's website.
Glade to see you telling your story unlike 20000 human who did not manage to do
Next interview a Palestinian in Gaza
NO THANK YOU
@@michaelg1279arent they human who are under attack.. arent they civilians being starved, bombed indiscriminately, taken hostages, sexually assaulted and others .. u dont want to hear their voices because hamas on Oct 7 attacked israel, surprise thats the definition of collective punishment..
tired of palywood
Yawn
No
I hope her sister or sister in law makes it home safe.
They will when Israel stop attack palstine
Hope IDF doesn’t mistake the hostages for mere civilians again
It won't help her mother in law that was murdered by the Human animals.
@@Peaceman324Peaceman is war mongering.
@@Johnny-dh2pjor wana be Johnny drop when hamas stops attacking
Why do people have hatred in them? We all came from the same source!! Life is too short. Let’s use our energy to make this world a better place!🙏🙏🙏
Hmmm maybe the white lady with blue eyes should bring a Palestinian and interview to speak the torture, rape and killing that's been happeiing to the Palestinians for over 75 years.
You are delusional 😂
It' was the way to get hostages held by Israel in exchange - in many cases the Palestinian hostages were children and were tortured and raped in Israeli prisons.
As you heard in the video, getting kidnapped is terrible but it doesn't look like she was tortured or worse. In contrast, look up the story of the 13 year old Layan as an example. Horrific I can't type it even but she needs constructive surgery if you understand what that means.
I can't believe they were risking the hostages' lives with the bombing - and they've killed some (besides the ones they shot). The hostages' families are right to lose their mind on the israeli gov.
Yes, let's focus on ending injustices, occupation, apartheid, and oppression. Justice is essential for peace and it starts by learning what's really happening. Learn as much as you can without relying on the mainstream media.
@@inctimber "learn as much as you can without relying on mainstream media " -when all your views are from al jazeera. Maybe take a look at the israeli side and you will will see what we have to deal with.
@@gshap1258 I know what you're saying. you're correct that views shouldn't come from similar sources or one place or else you risk getting propagandized.
I invested a lot of time, reading the history of the issue in detail, studied international politics/law, did my masters at a school that helped connect with people with good insights on the topic.
Right now, I'm reading about South Africa then I'll read about Ireland, black people, and the indigenous people in America to have a nuanced view and understand connections. I still have a lot to learn about history of activism in the US. The more I'm learning, the more I'm disappointed with the system and how it's wasting some of the potential of the US.
II have strong opinions that are loosely held about these areas. I'm pretty aware of the propaganda that I was fed growing up and I have some principles that help me check my biases. I tested this when I worked in social media tech and my work touched on how people get propagandized or influenced during elections.
I'm assuming you think I'm a liberal, I'm not. I haven't voted democrat in a very long time. It's not practical to talk about myself like this to an internet rando. I guess i felt like explaining myself.
Happy to hear what other suggests you have in case also tried to overcome being propagandized.
Objective journalism is Non existent!❤❤
Would be great to see an interview with a Palestinian who was detained in prison without charge as well.
we will never see that
There is plenty of that, go watch the interviews with one of the hamas founders sons, he was arrested by israel and turned to their side and now lives happily in the US. You should try look for it instead of writing that comment..
Ha ha. Not on an American network. You can count on that!!
They are in prison for a reason and not taken hostage and treated horribly
Yes, in prison, awaiting trial. How is that the same?
The interviewer wanted the lady to say that the hostages are given drugs to be shown happy but the lady just dismissed her
If you mean “drugs” edit your comment 😉
@@westaussie965 thank you
The interviewer wanted to get the truth. You can see in her eyes she did not want to give all the details of what they did to her. She doesn’t realize she’s helping them by holding back all that information.
@@AR-rn8okinteresting how you ignored what she said and instead you're trying push your narrative created from the hatred you fed up with
Run to Jesus
Rapture of Church is now..
Of course she cannot talk about the fact that they fed and clothed her 7:50
The reporter is a big liar and the editing made sure to cut the part where she and the other hostages where laughing with hamas soldiers at the day of their release and they didn't mention how on the 7th of october israel started firing shots frol apache on the houses and civilians in that festival
It was not an accident. Israel thought that they were Palestinians waving a white flag.
And they still shot them
Exactly. They didn't expect hostages to be out there. And who usually waves white flags are Palestinian people.
So it’s okay to shoot shirtless Palestinians waving white flags? Yeah that just proves what we’ve all known.
The soldiers may have thought it was a ruse to lure them into an ambush ..
Hamas use recorded children voices to lure Israeli troops into Traps, they are 18-20 kids that can be get shot any moment by any Hamas the entire context isn't clear, yes we know they wave a white flat, but they might have been other factors we can't think of and not even imagine because that's a situation we haven't experienced, not even anything close to that. Urban warfare is very elusive, I think it's best if you hear the entire testimony of the soldiers and wait for the final investigation, before making any judgment.
It would have been a better story If the reporter refrained from inserting her own little horrible guesses and sexual innuendos into the conversation. Ick.
60 minutes interviewers do that all the time. It’s so unprofessional and manipulative.
@@DearProfessorRF Thanks 4 the info DPRF. .
Absolutely despicable. There is no justification NONE. And shame on you if you think there is.
Thanks for the love, support and prayers you have shown i and my fellow member in the force do appreciate
To be a soldier isn't an easy task 😮💨
Sending healing to the husband. For all he has wnet through jeez. I just am soo sad. I hope the sister comes back to them soon.
This suffering is experienced by Palestinian prisoners who have been in prison for decades. Hamas's desire was to get the prisoners back. The story did not begin on October 7, but rather before that.
@@MohamedAbdullah-zr6ofHamas is laying underneath rubble now.
@MohamedAbdullah-zr6of The problem is the ideology if Jihad and Intifada is encouraged.
@@amethyst4990The problem is Israelis stealing land and wiping out Palestinians for decades. But I guess you are blind to that??
Please listen to what Zionist mentality is about :
I quote from Ahad Ha’am one of the foremost pre-state Zionist thinkers who died in 1927 (that is during early British mandate) :
They treat the Arabs with hostility and cruelty, deprive them of their rights, offend them without cause and even boast of these deeds; and nobody among us opposes this despicable and dangerous inclination
end of quote, from a study made by UN. "Origins and Evolution of the Palestine Problem: 1917-1947 (Part I)" it's published on UN's website.
Whats happening in our world is truly heart breaking💔
reply
Who are u
@@shalomsobji5448 It is sad and no one should unalive anyone period. But also no one should take over anyone's land... you should not steal people's land, or displace them, or subjugate them (for almost a century now), or abuse them, or sabotage them, or terrorize them, or bomb them in the little tiny crammed land you left for them (after ethnically cleansing them), the cycle of violence has to stop, the killing of children has to stop, the strip has been almost completely destroyed at this point...over 2 million people now homeless, starving, with no water, some mutilated and loosing limbs, these are atrocities too.
Yeah! This is why thousand Palestinian women are in Israeli captivity.
🐒🦍🦍🐒@@Mentega2
I hope there will be an opportunity for 60 Minutes to interview the mothers in gaza, their experience with no food, no water, having to go here and there as instructed by the IDF, kids died, with just their parts in plastic bags. I feel sorry for all the victims from both sides..it is heartbreaking.. but i feel more for the mothers in Gaza..70 days of daily misery and its still going on.
Mothers in gaza wanted to be in that position. What did they think was gonna happen because of their son's raping and killing of jews. They celebrated on oct 7th. No crying now!
@@nienie68what If I told you the opposite happened?!
@@nienie68I just want to understand one point why everytime someone mentions Gaza or Palestinian you think that they're supporters of Hamas? I've met Palestinians in my life that Hamas bombed their house.... Palestinians are human beings not all of them marked as terrorists...
Don't hold your breath. The Corporate Media are complicit in the genocide of Gaza, and the unwavering support of the apartheid state of Israel.
@@nienie68Did their infants and babies celebrate too?
Did you know Israel killed their own civilians in October 7 report was released in Haartz a Jewish newspaper
Did you also know the idf Admitted killing their own hostages?
This woman is strong. I cannot even imagine this experience.
They could do anything to me but .. they didn't? Is that what I understand? I love how white journalists are always so full of empathy for Israeli's but have never done the same for Palestinian people who have been through much worse. Watch my words, the conditions in the prisons are not going to be hidden much longer. The world is listening to the Palestinians now. Justice for 13 year old Layan who was gang graped by IDF soldiers and was completely ripped open, after being threatened to not contact the media or "they would do the same to her 9 year old sister".
That destoyed house seems to have been shelled by army heavy artillery
It's obviouse but the truth will come out one day
It was. And only IDF had the kind of equipment to cause such destruction.
Exactly what I was thinking as soon as I saw it
In RPG seven can destroy a tank can imagine what it can do to a house and that is not counting what a hand grenade can do I would stress that you would watch some videos on the damage when RPG can do to a house and get back to me thank you have a nice day@@DearProfessorRF
A Hebrew-language Haaretz article published on 20 October, which only appears in English in a must-read Mondoweiss article, paints a very different story of what went down in Be’eri that day. A Kibbutz resident who had been away from his home - whose partner was killed in the melee - reveals stunning new details:
“His voice trembles when his partner, who was besieged in her home shelter at the time, comes to mind. According to him, only on Monday night (9 October) and only after the commanders in the field made difficult decisions - including shelling houses with all their occupants inside in order to eliminate the terrorists along with the hostages - did the IDF complete the takeover of the kibbutz. The price was terrible: at least 112 Be’eri people were killed. Others were kidnapped. Yesterday, 11 days after the massacre, the bodies of a mother and her son were discovered in one of the destroyed houses. It is believed that more bodies are still lying in the rubble.”
Why did that house from beginning of the video looked like it was destroyed by bulldozer if every single video they showed or “Hamas terrorists” they only had guns with them?
a ) Certain guns hold extreme power. b ) they had rocket launcher. c ) there is a chance once the kibbutz was cleared that they had to use tanks to move around, the kibbutz were the direct frontlines when things started d ) rockets were also launched from gaza
edit: ...also grenades. grenades can do terrifying damage
Your conspiracy theories are pretty rude in a video like this. I don't care how the house looks I saw what Hamas did. Thats enough proof.
When Idf arrived they didn't know who was who. They shot their hellfire missiles and tank shell at everyone. Was reported in an israeli newspaper when the released hostages was interviewed.
@@ellchenelle1682 and there are also reports (and Israeli people testimonies) that tanks were actually shelling houses so there’s that…
@@ellchenelle1682it's vastly more likely it was tank fire or a something plowing through it
When an interview to a gaza mother?
Assuming that her husband and child were fine and not dead means she knew the terrorists were not out for their blood. Read between the lines.
Saying that hostages were given drugs to seem happy is the biggest horseshit I've ever heard LOL
It sounds logic giving them something to be calm in that situation, but "to seem happy"...
Where is hamas getting these drugs when they can't even get medical supplies and food. Of course it's ridiculous
It is? Seems pretty sensible to me....
Oh wow, you were there?
@@birdsinparadise3113 what's with all these Hamas bots on all these sites. Are people really this gullible?
Can you please also interview the children who were held captice by Israëli idf for years without any charges and visites from their parents.
I think those would be difficult to find as they don't exist
Geshem Israel Geshem Israel elehenu Adonai Hashem. I was born March 11th in Bethlehem 61 years ago. What is your covenant with God?
@@dafnadolinko6613thank you for your concise answer.
Any proof of that? I know there're some teenagers, like 16-17 y.o., in prisons, mostly for attempted murders. But they were tried properly, had a lawyer etc.
@@dmitrygorbunov9219 please do not make me laugh. I did my internship at the UN and there are many reports on this. There was even a session on this. You just have the google these documents. Thwy are avalaible for the public. If you e-mail they also send you these documents. There are also dozens of documents of rape and abuse by Israëli IDF soldiers within the UN and Amnesty. They have many on rape with Palestinian hostages, including children. And these children are now adults but they were underage when they were abducted. And they were abducted. There hasnt been one single court trial. Not one! Some arent charged with anything and some are charged and without trial jailed. And there families werent aloud to visit once. To punish these children they were left without light for weeks on end. They were told not to sleep for days. They were hit and beaten and raped. They were denied food for days and then given just enough to survive. Like fellow jews Finkelstein. It is not about being pro Israël or pro Palestinian. It is about pro truth, pro fact and pro justice. Now think about why werw there so many meetings about Israël and Palestine within UN? Why are the border of Israël still not recognized by the UN. Why is Israël facing an international court trial for not a few but hundreds of war crimes? There is proof everywhere. You just have to listen and see.
She refuses to answer if she was fed or if hostages were drugged. Why
Because they weren’t drugged and they very fed well and treated w respect
I like how none of these media ppl talk about the thousands of Palestinians imprisoned in the isnotreali jails for literally nothing
There have been 8,000 Palestinians held hostage in Israeli jails for years.
9 to 13-year-old kids are in Israeli prison, but they never interviewed them, and they never showed them. What are they going through? A Palestinian 13-year-old boy, Israel released him breaking his arms. That's how Western media has a double standard.
'Criminals' to be more precise.
Free Palestine
@@ThetopDjMarcexactly, those Palestinian hostages were being held by criminals
@@ThetopDjMarcOh. You seem to know all of them by names..
It is heartbreaking. I’m glad you guys are now safe. I hope we can hear more of these testimonies to bring awareness including testimonies from the families of the over 20000 civilian Palestinians killed in the last 80 days. I hope for peace.
Pure lies. Israel gave ample time and warning to those folks to move south. Those that refused to do so are likely hamas supporters. Even those numbers are bogus and without any basis in reality.
You won't hear that because whole palestinian generations have been wiped out.
Yeah, I also want to hear the testimonies of hamas leaders of their mentality that, even though 20,000 people were killed why they still can't return hostages?
@@Daredevil-tg9lg they should just give up and let some europeans take their land right ?
@@Daredevil-tg9lg Because before Israeli hostages were taken hostage by Hamas during Oct. 7th, thousands of Palestinian hostages already existed in Israeli prisons.
Or you only want to show one side of the story?
Makes me sick what Hamas does, Yarden - bless you , your husband and your little girl ❤ can’t imagine what you and your family is going through. Sending you and your family so much love 💕 #bringthemhomenow!
which country bombs innocent women, children and hospitals??
Interestingly, no one claimed that they were raped, just a thought.
It looks she was briefed about what to say and how to respond.
What ever may be your thoughts, will never change the reality.
Definitely
Did it ever acure to you to ask or interview 1 of the over 6 thousand palastinians who have being captured and detained indefinit years with no charges 500 of that are childrens.
We saw the palatinian children hostages after they were being released how they were tortured and their arms broken
How many of them were repeatedly gRaped by savages? These are middle - eastern men were talking about, there is literally no way she wasn't gRaped. It's just too traumatic for her to talk about. Israel is bad but Hamas is evil.
Check your resources the Palestinians released were NOT hostages! Those were convicted terrorists that were released from PRISONS, they might be weman and children but they were nonetheless convicted criminals terrorists sitting in prison for trying and succeeding killind jews
The world have really gone mad if you think those were hostages that isreal just casually took
Ikr, that would be too much like humanizing them. What is this drug that makes all the hostages look happy? She repeated it as if it was a fact, not alleged despite all the lies Israel has had to walk back, and all the videos that were propaganda.
Nevertheless, Im glad she is home and reunited with her family and she can eat while Gazans slowly starve to death.
@@msavina9129 The same Gazans who cheered and celebrated her brutal abduction? I'm sure she feels SOOO bad for them. What disgusting "people".
@@rowena3867sub humans, evil on two legs.
Hmm.. even her husband said shes still the same person. No trauma? What a shame.
I hope children of colonials (the West) would one day value the lives of those whose generations are affected by the crimes of colonialism as they do value the lives of their fellow colonials around the world.
Truly a horrific experience for any human, I wish the interviewer would stop leading the people being interviewed with words for the victims to describe their feelings and experiences.
Very misleading questions
I so agree with you. Those questions sounded so imposing. Practically putting words in her mouth.
@@micheledemos9587 If anything the suffering in Gaza gets more exposure from news outlets.
@@micheledemos9587 Well then what's your solution? As long as Hamas is in Gaza, the Palestinian people will continue to suffer. Israel is the only country that can do something about it. It's not pretty, but overthrowing a brutal regime never is.
Not commonly understood, but most of the suffering in Gaza is due to Hamas, not Israel. Most of those stories are local things that nobody ever reports on.
@@dschwartz783isreal has been killing gazans for years. Long before hamas
I hope she can recover and her sister gets back home safely. Same for all the hostages both Israeli (held in Gaza) and Palestinian (those taken by the IDF without due process or even charge).
Where are you getting your information about Palestinians arrested without due process or charges? It's not like there's a shortage of terrorists trying to collect money for pay to slay.
"64% of Palestinian refugees taken in by Denmark in 1992 now have criminal records"
Did Denmark also not give them due process?
Pretty sure that's propaganda about those kept in Isrl without "due process or charge". Meaning that there's def a clear procedure to regulate things & ppl aren't just arrested randomly without checks & balances.
Preventive detention is a very common procedure in many Western countries btw. Like when Andrew Tate was arrested for up to 6 months before charges needed to be filed - but that *didn't* mean that he didn't face a judge within 24h, had no legal representation, couldn't appeal, or wasn't informed on the accusations.
HRW, Amnesty, B'tsellem and many others including all major western news outlets (BBC, France24, WashPost, etc...) have all reported on this. More than 2,000 Palestinians are held without charge or trial. Just google it; the sources are there including Israeli sources like Haaretz. Save the Children also has a report showcasing that most of the children are physically beaten and tortured (which is legal in Israel for Palestinians), and many experience sexual abuse at the hands of Israeli soldiers (this is with reference to the Save the Children report on the issue).@@marydidyouknow5826
@@marydidyouknow5826israel is the only terrorist here 🤦♀️
1:15 "he took us to the rubble that were his parent's home " before his parents came, who used to live there ???
First 3 minutes in Im already crying. The bravery the mother had handing off her child to the father. Omg.
This suffering is experienced by Palestinian prisoners who have been in prison for decades. Hamas's desire was to get the prisoners back. The story did not begin on October 7, but rather before that.
@@MohamedAbdullah-zr6ofwith all due respect, give this woman some respect and don’t jump in to make comparisons. This woman very bravely shared her story. This video is about her experience.
@Devotionalpoet Stfu. Why can't he? He is not diminishing her story he is giving context to why it happened and the underlying problem. Why can't he add that?
@@chriselias3881 not the right place. He can do whatever he wants. I was just expressing that I disagreed with adding that here specifically under a hostage’s personal story. I spoke very respectfully, unlike how you are speaking to me.
This all over social media. The suffering of these hostages is not respected when you can’t even have one post that speaks to it without trying to shine a light in the other direction. The whole situation is horrifying and upsetting to all who are involved.
But just let this woman tell her story.
This post is not about why it happened or the backstory. It’s about what she endured. She deserves respect to speak without people commenting on others who have suffered.
This is not a post about Palestinian prisoners. It’s about one family’s experience, and the experience is hers to tell. Again, this specific story is her story to tell. It’s about showing her respect.
@Devotionalpoet He is not disrespecting her or diminishing her tragic experience by adding what he said about it. Comparing her tragedy to others does not diminish it.
She was open to talk about the hypothetical fear of being assualted, which never happened .
And her amazing personality made them care for her .
And shes to tramatized to discuse if she was fed food.
During active hostage negotiations former captives are often briefed about what they can say and what they cannot. Common sense really.
I caught that too, even when asked about them being drugged to appear happy, she said I don't want to go there, wth.
I feel bad for her, I really do, but it is obvious that the interviewer wanted to hide many things.
So what was her experience then? You said being assaulted never happened. I assume you have some info to share
There are still 130 hostages in Gaza. And she carefully chooses her words. For those of you who think the fear is hypothetical, it is real. If she says anything nasty about the Hamas, its gonna have repercussions on those that are still held captive.
The interviewer giving dirty leading questions to her.
She was not raped, she given food , she is the same person described by her husband.
So stop lying 60 minutes, be transparent, be righteous.
Interview Daniel and her daughter to hear the true story of the hostages
Frrrr
yaa,
1.israel started media propaganda project to recover world sympathy again. this interview part of this. check interviewer questions.
2. interviewer never interview Palestinian hostages in Israeli prison. bcz horrible brutality in zionist prison.
an propaganda project will fail 😊
She got kidnapped, dafuq?
100%
i will tell you to study Palastine history@@inhenyerongkalbo9382
This is what people in gaza have gone throughout for the last 70 years
read the history again please
The people of gaza could live in peace for the last 70 years if they had accepted the two-state solution back then. They didn't though and attacked Israel again and again for the last 70 years. What they are going through they brought on themselves.
Something seems off on this interview...the interviewer trying to push an agenda and not getting answers to anwser some of the rumors so not complete.
Feel the same too
That hug by her daughter.. one very lucky family in between all these chaos.. God bless them more
And where’s the interview of Palestinian women? the women who are being raped in Israel prisons in a daily basis? 60 mins why don’t you interview Palestinian women? are scared to show the reality of Israel? Be brave for once!!
If Israel wants stop being called Nazis, they must stop behaving like Nazis and using the lives of thousands of children as collateral damage.
I believe we should call for a referendum.
The most rightful thing is a referendum made by true original land owners (Palestineans, including native Palestinean jews) and they decide the state they want.
Simple. Very simple.
It's not a thousands of years matter.
Otherwise, the immigrants who stole the land should go back to where they came from.
yes while in Gaza the families werent as lucky as her they are nice family but they should know or they already knew they are taking anther people lands
@@youssefdirani. There has never been a palestinian people/history/language/nation. The multinationals calling themselves palestinians do so only because Arafat, an Egyptian, ordered them to in the 1960s as propaganda against Israel. Most were kicked out of Jordan for their participation in the failed Black September coup; others are gypsies from Egypt, some from Syria. They all have homelands they should be able to return to but their Islamic brothers refuse to allow them to return home, not even for employment or educational opportunities. Egypt flooded Gazan tunnels with sewage to keep them out of Egypt, and Jordan is decidedly unapologetic for those they gave the boot, so why aren’t moslems incensed with their own nations who won’t take them back? They shouldn’t be in Israel or Israel’s problem at all.
60 Minutes is supposed to show also: `Female Israeli hostages played arm-wrestling with Hamas guard'
She said the Palestinians were very kind towards her and she would be happy to do it again. That is the summary of the video.
😂😂😂😂
she said palestine makes her like a trophy parade around gaza😂😂😂
The reporter really feels for these people. I Hope western main stream media would feel the same for the Palestinian women, children and elderly.
Zionists controlling the Medias, and ruling Asutralia, i doubt they will be neutral about this
Agreed
Exactly
They do.
We are human dust for the Western media, dream, they will never feel that way, they fed on Hiroshima and Nakazaki, Vietnam, and Iraq, Afghanistan, they act like heroes in these wars that took millions of people's lives, and the daily attacking on other countries that we don't know about like Syria and Yemen,
I'm glad you are safe. Thank you for doing the interview. Praying for your family and prayers for Carmel continue.
I am Glad she is free , Sad that the Palestinian hostages that were released ( 30 of them are less than 18 years old when they capture , many of them never charged ). don't have the same luxury of safety.
You say that like this lady’s responsible.
@@christerry1773 I was talking about the woman who got out of Gaza, released by Hamas.
Anyone else notice how she was not allowed to talk about the fact that she was fed, or about the fake drugs accusations? It definitely was a traumatic experience, but everything that she said was rather the trauma from her expectations, she was expecting to be raped, but instead was given clothes to be covered, she was expecting to be held in a terror tunnel, but instead was kept in an apartment, she was expecting to be killed but returned home. I mean the horror of her kidnapping experience is mostly from fear and not actual experiences. And I wouldn’t be surprised if her sister was killed by the Israeli bombs, that seemed to be the most terrifying part.
Glad i'm not the only one that caught that. Her demeanor as well, sits very sarcastic, borderline entitled body language. Not something i'd expect from someone traumatized. I agree with your points
She knows that there are other innocents, especially women including her sister, who are still being held captive. Make of that what you will but be aware of it. They are not being held in four star hotels and have done nothing deserving what they are being subjected to. Watch the husband’s eyes when asked if he’s still the same man. These people have been to hell and back. For no reason.
Same way Palestine has been for the past 75 years
Each person of those 20 000 civilians who died in Gaza have also a story.
they don't count in the u.s.
Yes!! It’s obviously all about the trauma of the Israeli only. Of course, the loss of life on their side was terrible but somehow the extermination of Palestinians goes on as it has been for 75 years.
wagh wagh... who started it?
@@angusthompson2110 easy - Israel in 1948
@@angusthompson2110 zionist terrorists like the stern gang, haganah and irgun even BEFORE 1948 were attacking palestinians and british troops with bombs and molotov cocktails
and 1948 they displaced 700,000 arabs IMMEDIATELY from their ancestral homes
this is why they have NEVER (and never WILL) known peace in palestine