Honor Magic 6 Pro vs Magic 5 Pro - Camera Comparison
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 03. 2024
- The brand new flagship from Honor the #Magic6Pro has to compete against its predecessor in this very detailed camera comparison. Which one comes on top? Let's find out.
I explore the photo and video performance after the newest Update 8.0.0.127 for the Magic 6 Pro to see how well it can compete in light and dark conditions with various different lenses, portrait and macro tests.
If you want to support my work you can become a member to get exclusive access to my videos as soon as they are uploaded.
You can also support my channel via a donation.
PayPal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/lesze...
LiberaPay: liberapay.com/leszek/
Or you can regularly support me by becoming a patreon: / leszeklesner
What do you think about the performance of the Magic 6 Pro? Is it a good sucessor to the Magic 5 Pro?
The ranking listn shown in the video might change in the future. So checkout the latest ranking list here: llelectronics.neptuneos.com:8080 - Věda a technologie
Thanks for another extremely detailed comparative review.
Great work. I loved the RAW sample comparison part, I wish that you include more of this in the future with more smaples because in that one shot you provided, the focus wasn't matched.
Best of luck.
Awesome content and camera comprision as always brother
Great video ....
Damn, Honor magic 5 seems to be better than 6 in camera comparison!
Very interesting review, thanks!
Im very satisfied with Magic 6 Pro. I changed from Mate 50 Pro, so its very smooth, due that the sw environment is very similar and gesture control is same. What is better for me in 6 days of use after buy, is sound from speakers, is more detailed with more "bass", camera give more details than on Mate 50 Pro. battery life is longer, in my case its 0,5 day longer (I using it with 2 SIM cards: private and work number). only one cons after these few days of use is when I played with the camera especialy only focusing on objects/ people less then 5 minuts the Magic 6 Pro began to feel noticeably warm and Huawei was still cold. One cons which that disappeared is a weight of the device - more than 220g is about habit. Feeling the weight in my hand and in my trouser pocket :)
Thanks for the test.
that was quick! haha you're a legend mate, thanks so much!!🙏
Nice video dear brother..keep up the good work❤
Ty for the great work 👍🏻
Great video sir, I'll wait to upgrade. I might even switch to a Xiaomi 14 ultra for a change 👌🏾
very, very good, detailed review! I always found here one of the best, unedited, detailed, reliant information! Thank you! From your experience... I wonder... is there a mid-ranger phone which actually gets close to these high end phones, when it comes to photo and video? My old Huawei P30, recently broke, was not too far of these phones, sadly. So I can't tell what to buy.... I don't want to break the bank, but the difference for the money is not really proportional :(
You may go for Huawei p50 pro
At timestamp 22:20 you show massive smoothening out on Magic5Pro side... I wonder if with the new update to MagicOS 8 (delivered starting today) they actually fixed this wiping out details behaviour... Thank you again for you work!
I hope they did. I sold my Magic 5 Pro so I cannot check.
The end spreadsheer summary is good, but perhaps as a suggestion the last column total rating could convert the 4.XXX three decimal places rating into a percentage score out of 100 so its more digestible. 87%, 91% etc
can you do a video comparing the bright, natural, and texture shooting modes on m6p?
Thanks for comparsion. I have m5p and i think about change to m6p but now, after this test i change my mind. Meaby ill wait for Honor 5 ultra or vivo x100 plus, dunno :d
I got the 5 pro as well and the vivo must be a better one, but the 5 pro is so great. No need to change for now 😅
Thanks a ton, great review, helped me to stay on my Magic 5 Pro, instead of upgrading.
Brother.Can honor magic 5 pro take portrait with its 3.5x camera?
No the portrait mode on works with the main sensor. Having said that the 3.5x lens makes the perfect natural portraits that are better than the portrait mode.
Its time to buy the 5 pro in my opinion its on sale 699€ here in spain😊 nice comparisons too if you have some time can you do it with the xiaomi ultras thanks
En que tienda vale eso?
@@aldrichthorne7404honor espańa
Nice comparison.
Thank you sir!
Thank you so much
Would be great to see a comparison with a pixel 7 or 8 pro. Great job though! I'm so close to buying the M6P!
better get a hm5p for a sweet deal, the difference is not that huge and the hm5p even has a bigger main sensor.
regarding your question about how it compares to the pixel: i had a pixel 7 pro and it was a fine device, speed wise the tensor is obviously no match for the sd8g2 or g3, so for gaming and heavy tasks it isn't the best device, otherwise it runs very stable and smooth though.
camera wise i was pretty happy with my pixel 7 pro aside from one annoying thing: the tele-lens of the pixel 7 pro can't focus on close things at all, unlike my magic 5 pro which can take beautiful close-up shots of butterflies, autumn leaves, little flowers and so on.
other than that both have great cameras.
nice review from previous flagship to new its very helpful for consumer who dont change phones every year keep it up.. by the way do you sell the previous phones like that magic 5 pro, find x6 pro and the xiaomi 13 ultra for half the price? 😊
If you become a member you have the chance to get it for a good price if you live in Europe.
Thank you very much for your work.
Really a complete test, clean and well detailed.
I have the honor 5 pro and I have just ordered the 6 pro which I am waiting for, a little disappointed with the zoom after the x10, I hope that Honor will do a global update soon to claim to be the best camera phone.
What version of Update do you have? That I can compare with my h6p once received.
THANKS
I have version 8.0.0.127
is this the update that had almost 7 gigabyte ?? @@lltechview
Is the zoom in 5 pro better?
Great video as always,could you do S24U maybe?
No funds and interest in the S24Ultra
@@lltechview thanks for replying , fair enough!
Thank you for the detailed comparison. Will you compare Huawei P60 Pro vs Honor Magic 6 Pro? Would appreciate that a lot
Don't have the P60 Pro anymore
Hey Leszek, wann updatest du eigentlich den Vivo X100 Pro Frontcamera score? Der ist ja immernoch auf 4,1 gesetzt, obwohl ja mittlerweile das 4K Update kam. Du meinstest ja auch in deinem Updatvideo, dass du den Score anpassen willst.
Liebe Grüße aus Köln
Hatte ich. Aber Video und nicht Front Cam.
Just for consideration, maybe zoom camera score must have more weight than uw?
MY THOUGHTS :
19:22 i MUCH prefer the less processed image of the magic 6 pro
22:05 idk, it feels like the magic 6 pro is overexposing a very little too much, but again the processing is better overall and there is more details
25:20 I don't understand how it is possible to have such a bad zoom on the magic 6 pro going after like 10 times (or even maybe 6 / 7 times zoom lol)... seriously this is very bad and sad, they have to optimize this urgently
28:55 would have liked to see the result with the 1.4 aperture
32:18 : why is there so much "bouncing" with the lights on those chinese phones ? it is so bad when in low light conditions, I am pretty sure this is coming from the strong EIS they are implementing, they have to fix this (if not on the 6 pro, in their next phone) because this is very bad lol
doesn't seem to do it that badly on the 5 pro, so they can fix this on the 6 pro... this is one of the thing that are just blocking me from buying the 6 pro to be honest
34:05 i find the magic 6 pro much better overall, the branch on the trees are dark as they should be, you can discern them much better, no "blob" effects, on the tree trunk
you can see it at 34:35 , more details, more natural colors (the tree is illuminated a little, then the more you go up in the tree and in the branches, the more it starts to darken), the grass is more natural and way more refined than on the 5 pro too with better colors (5 pro = grass having the same color in the foreground and background, while 6 pro you can see the different shade of green)
+ the 6 pro is less overexposed so it is very good (overexposing is seriously bad from my point of view), the 6 pro doesn't try to get useless / unnatural details from things that are too dark, it is a VERY VERY nice behavior, I hope they'll keep up in this way of processing
2.5 times zoom in this scenario, magic 6 pro maybe a tad too much ISO ? but otherwise, going to 5x, again i prefer this processing against the 5 pro, less processing / noise reduction, love this
the selfie, again 5 pro overexposed, 6 pro very good exposure I love this behavior, good job honor on this, hopefully they fixed overexposure on day time too (since you made the day time shots before this update)
-------------------
THANKS FOR THIS VIDEO DUDE
amazing video, very detailed, nice shots, nice scene that gives us a lot of information about the behavior of the two phones, you show us a lot of things (and even if I can have a different analysis than you, that's not a problem, you showed us what we had to see)
thank you very much for your work dude, amazing videos, looking forward to all your tests, videos, reviews... lol
The old Huawei P30 Pro (4-5years) makes better zoom photos. Incredible!
Amazing comment. Thanks for so much detail and analysis
Hi, will you test magic 5 pro after android 14 / magic os 8 update? we hope to get this update soon.... the camera app will get some improvements like the one on magic 6pro
Yeah
Honor 6 Pro vs Xiaomi 14 Ultra please. Great video!
Yeah on todo.
@@lltechview Nice one, looking forward to it.
Is there possible to shoot heif on m6 pro for more dynamic range?
No HEIF format that I see in settings.
xiaomi 13U vs 14U , detail Night Mode capability comparison please..
HM5PRO or One+12 wolud You chose? Or other camera with great camera, battery . THX
Did not test the OnePlus 12. The Magic 5 Pro is good. Magic 6 Pro amd Xiaomi 14 as well
Absolutely no need to upgrade to magic 6 pro ,if you own 5 pro. The only real difference is slightly better processor and battery.
Selfie camera is much much better but yeah no point wasting money. Maby 7 pro will be worth it.
i feel like with today's flagship phones you can easily skip every second new generation, in some cases like the pixel series you can even skip 2 in a row lol.
So is 6 has a better battery and maybe a little faster processor but the difference is not big
@@CZcams-Censorship-Policeyeah the same concept with every brand
yes after 4 to 5 yrs if its good to change then that's the time for it but yearly upgrade is just a waste
Does it worth the 200 $ diffrence
Today I tested the front camera, which the Magic 5 is far superior to the Magic 6 in terms of clarity. The difference is beyond discussion.
Not really. Not sure what happened there to your Magic 6 Pro but it has the way better higher resolution sensor plus auto focus. So definitely more clearity.
Does Honor push new camera app features, from their new phones, to older phones?
Yeah if its possible to do with hardware
@@lltechview super! Thank you and have a great week forward,
Honor magic 6 pro vs Vivo x 100 pro please 🙏❤
لو سمعت من اين اشتريت غلاف هونر ماجيك 6 برو اريد شراء نفس الغلاف انهو حلو جداا
Came with the device's pre order directly from Honor.
main sensor video on m6 doesn't look warmer, it tries to beautify your face with blur and red oval in the middle. It's difficult to watch that, the image is ruined.
HONOR MAGIC 6 PRO VS OPPO FIND X7 ULTRA Camara video Please Sir
Will come at one point. Its on the todo.
@@lltechview Thanks Sir g Love you 🙏🙏👍🌹❤️
Is there much difference in the main camera???
Not really
❤❤❤
👍
Honor phone software updates tell me about
HM6 PRO: 4 Years Android & 5 Years Security Updates
After that, Magic 5 Pro come with 3 Android updates. The security updates remain the same.
I'm watching on my Xiaomi 14 ultra ❤
Test Oneplus 12
Hi, I'm Enrico from Italy. Have you seen? Dxomark gave the 1st place in photo quality - score ranking to the Honor Magic 6 Pro... is that possible? Has Honor updated the phone? (I'm speaking about camera )
... so that now photo quality is far better than before?
Thanks for notifying. Have to check. Did not see it.
i own both mate 50 pro and honor magic 5 pro theres no way mate 50 pro is better on the honor magic 5 pro
Newer phones do not automatically produce better... Remember that for your reviews
Dont understand why the newer flagships look that bad in portrait and human photos. Too dark, Adams look. Hate that. Why?
I think they failed to optimize that.
Yes i reconized that too. Maybe because of AI? Maybe the AI is still not at a professional level
Xiaomi 14 Ultra..... Excelente job!
6 pro is worse than 5 pro...thats new that a successor is worse than its predecessor
1st ✌️
Honor Magic 5 pro and Magic 6 pro are great smartphones overall but cameras... they produce "drawings" but not photos, I am disappointed :(... I could not switch to Honor after Nubia Z50 Ultra only because of the cameras...
how do you mean "drawings"?
have you tried gcam yet? it's a great app and it fully supports all lenses of the magic 5 pro, personally i prefer the photos made by gcam, they look crisper and the color pallette is very realistic.
@@CZcams-Censorship-Police
No . Magic 5 pro dont support fully Gcam : no stabilization for telelens .
Do you mean the front or main camera?
@@Jasmin586 main camera...
@@CZcams-Censorship-Police I know that gcam can improve photo capabilities significantly but... gcam is not ideal (not stable). Ideally I prefer to use stock camera if it can give me acceptable and stable result (not too much overprocessing)
Bro Vivo x100 pro Vs Xiaomi 14 ultra man cmonnn 😭
Yeah coming
M5p definitely in all mode better, expect night mode, how this rating???🧐🧐
I am amazed how you think that the M5p is better in all modes. I do not see that.
27:09 😅 How come lens flare solved on m6p and it's still on the half of the building and not exist on the m5p !!!
For me magic 5 pro did a good job and still better in most situations.. I don't know why you are on magic 6p side for most situations ..?! even on raw pictures you said they are the same but magic 6p is darker and more noise !!? And you back and said it's downgrade for m6p sensor and then you said it's equal !?... Even 10x is better on m5p and natural at least there's 10x shortcut existing..
noone ever tested the movie mode in youtube
I did. Multiple times.
@@lltechview in this video?
@@kereminion6049 not here other videos. I also did a dedicated video test video about smartphone and which one records better. I used the movie mode of Honor there.
thank you so much i will look for it
@@lltechview
I counted it. You have mistakes!!! Oppo find x7 ultra - 4.425, vivo x100pro - 4.475, oppo find x6 pro - 4.4
What where?
@@lltechview add up the numbers in each column and divide by 8??? Isn't that how you got the average?
@@MTiNOZ No. See the weighting by clicking on each phone
@@lltechviewI don't understand what weight has to do with it. you have a video about comparing cameras. At the end is a table with an estimate of certain camera parameters. At the end of each line is the average value. The average value is calculated incorrectly.
At the end of each line is the total rating not the average. The total rating is calculated like you see for each smartphone by clicking on the link including the weights for each category. Otherwise it does not make much sense as the main camera photo quality should have more priority then the front camera.
Magic 5 Pro Zoom camera is a gimmick. So useless, every photo is like a watercolour painting. I am so disappointed, I will never buy this crap again. If you don't need cameras, this is the best phone, other than that, the front camera is trash, 3x zoom cam is terrible, and you only have a main camera that is good, which in this price range is ridiculous!
Try GCAM , with 3x camera will you better pictures, and no painting. Gcam don't use strong noise reduction like stock camera, maybe the pictures need some sharpening but they are better ! i got magic 5 pro, non just speaking about ;-)
bro, i don't think it can be fixed a lot but please give me the link for proper gcam that is not a malware. Thank you
@@CrashV5
@@CrashV5 Well hopefully. The front camera is still complete trash but can you give me a link for proper Malware free GCAM? I really need it since I have full gallery of paintings 😅
you can type the link here or send me a private message. Thanks!
con honor này tuy chụp ảnh ko quá xuất sắc nhưng gọi là ổn trong năm nay, chê cái quay video thôi, năm 2024 rồi mà honor còn chơi với chống rung EIS mà ko thèm làm OIS, không thì cũng phải tích hợp cả 2 cho ngon, nên độ rung khi quay thật vcl với 1 mẫu đắt tiền như vậy
ngu
Honor Magic5 Pro needs to finish their homework ASAP - selfie camera and video are not up to today's standard compared with my previous Huawei P30, even though my phone has the latest updates on as I'm writing this. Please try WhatsApp video call on both, I couldn't believe how bad the video is. I have messaged Honor support about it, some others have mentioned it as well. Zoom 3.5x if you are lucky to get a focused shot, forget 10x-100x, non existent. Battery life, even on battery saving mode does not last a full day. Maybe a faulty device, but for this price tag I somehow expect trouble free phone. The icing on a cake - very difficult to find a screen protector that works properly, so far tried 7, rounded corners collect dust, buttons won't respond let's say on YT video to press x, etc. Anyone else or is it just me? 🫣 On a positive note: amazing screen quality, some really good shots without zoom, duo speakers. 🔈