Catherine has arrived! | Roze of the Recapture Episode 2 LIVE REACTIONS
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- Subscribe for more here: tinyurl.com/63dtaswc
Join my Discord Server: / discord
Here are my reactions to the first episode of Roze of the Recapture.
Time Stamps:
01:09: Reactions begin here
15:35: Why This Episode was Awful
Discord: / discord
Reddit: / mymediachops
Facebook: / mymediachops
Myanimelist: myanimelist.net/profile/mymed...
Pinterest: / mymediachops
_______________________________________________________________________
Gear I Used:
Microphone: amzn.to/49ktvo6
Monitor: amzn.to/3Snf38R
Pop Screen: amzn.to/45ZzhZm
Boom Arm: amzn.to/46ZH0bl
Camera: amzn.to/3MwroDY
Mouse: amzn.to/3FJ5gSO
Videos on the alternative anime timeline
• The Most Important Cha...
• How To Start Code Geas...
• Code Geass New Alterna...
• Lelouch of the Re;surr...
• Was Shirley's Role in ... - Krátké a kreslené filmy
Let me know your thoughts of Roze of the Recapture episode 2.
Also sorry about the nasally voice.
I will work towards not sounding like that in future reaction videos.
Personly I think the Resson Neo Brittian doesn't have more Advance Weaponery is becaue 1 Lelouch destroyed 70% the Main source of Sakudite used to make many of the weapons you talked about, 2 they closed themself off from rest of the world using the Sakura Wall so they don't have access to alot of Resources, So it makes sense there using less Advance Knightmares And the Resisntance is Kinda of an the same boat.
As for how they have a Damocles Neo Britannia from what I've seen in the last episode brought there Own to Hokkido before sealing it off, and is it that Farfetched that Maybe some Members of Cammbodia managed to sneak out the Blueprints before Lelouch purged them, brilliant as he is, Lelouch has proven that he's far from Perfect.
As for the Sakura Wall is it that hard to Believe that maybe it's more Powerful then the Ginjufu disrupters used in the Past, also you should also take into account there might be another unknown reason the Black Knights don't invade the Hokkido block
Also from how I understand it, it's only been 2 Years Sense Neo Britannia occupied the Hokkido Block not 4
@@Omegadra It's been four years, the prologue takes place in Kowa Period 3, on the website it says Kowa period 7.
That means 4 years have passed.
I didn't say the wall was same as the Gefian disturber just has smiliar technology, so why can't they find a way to disable it.
@@MyMediaChops Maybe there's another reason the Black Knights don't invade I think its to Early to Judge before seeing the Whole series, I also remind you that the black Knight are probably Hesitant to act due to NB (Neo Brittannia) holding the Entire Hokkido block Hostage, so if they start poking at the Sakura Wall NB may start killing a Massive amount of Hostages
Personly I don't mind the mirroring of several events from the Anime and Perhaps the reason were getting so little info about the world is for a builded up to something big
On another note after seeing the second episode would you say Ash is on the same level as Suzaku
There is literally a carrier mounted with machine guns not far from them. Did you think they would’ve actually escaped simply because they hustled up and boarded that shuttle?
When your guns get a debuff XD.
These aren’t impactful moments because they aren’t suppose to? It’s not like Todo getting rescued was such a hype thing back then other than being something that happened so that Lelouch can move forward with his plans. Ash and Roze should be the main focus with everything else taking a side step back and playing support with only 12 episodes currently(season 2 maybe?) This kind of pacing works here for things like this that don’t need to be dragged out. As for grievances with the setting I think You just gotta have the right expectations going in. You can’t expect everything to be explained in the first 2 episodes without an info dump. This Is what we have Almaria of Novelty for, it’s a prequel to Roze that takes place in the time gap to explain the setting. Roze of the Recapture should focus purely on its main thing and leave out the setting stuff to out side materials and this prequel.
Catherine really carrying the Einberg through looks alone. I hope more success for this series!
Mandatory Nunally character - Check
Mandatory Rolo Character - Check
Mandatory Todoh Character - Check
Mandatory Rebel Group - Check
Its just sped up Season 1, also how does a universe with the likes of Nina, Rakshata and Lloyd working together fail to break a simple barrier for 3 damn years, rough to watch
There's difference in most of those cases. For instance, Sakura is not a child who is younger than the protagonist, nor is she blind and crippled. Ash's personality is literally nothing like Rolo's. Nor did Lelouch ever use Geass on Rolo, so that's a major and significant point of divergence. Rebel groups exist in millions of stories, so that's not an issue.
Yeah I feel the same. It just feels very rushed how they are going about it and it is due to the episode count. The world building is slow and they are not really showing how this neo Britannia came to be or what it is in this present day series. I feel as more episodes come out the world will be more clear. But I feel they are trying to make a twist in each episode and slowly reveal the world. Like how we got a little more of Ash, who he was and how he became a nameless mecerenary. Which I wasn't surprised of Rose using their Geass of Ash. I wonder if she gave him a choice, like either serve the daughter of the man you killed or follow his fate and die. We don't hear the command so I am sure that will play somehow. But neo Britannia still seems like this black hole with little information which makes the deaths of characters we are literally introduced to and die in the same episode doesn't really care much weight. Hopefully these deaths have meaning to other characters which builds the world up.
I am honestly I'm the same boat. I love this series and happy for these new episodes. I just hope they are able to recapture that Code Geass spark and make it one that goes with the series and not just a copy and paste let's do area 11 again.
It's obvious that we haven't seen the Neo Britannian side of the story so far. I don't see why we should have though. This is all still within the start of the story.
@@knightmarepilot4832 Dude please don't be so agressive in the comments.
You can go after me as much as you want but not towards other people.
I am not saying this particular comment applies but you are responding to everyone who has issues with the episode.
It is just a warning.
@@MyMediaChopsI don’t think that’s a problem as long as he’s not being rude to anyone. Which he isn’t here. He’s free to give his opinions to everyone. It’s a discussion. Plus I agree with him that it’s just the start of the story. You can’t info dump in one episode when it isn’t relevant at the moment . It’s so slow burn build up of the world. Let’s see how it continues by the end of the season.
What do you mean by meaning of their deaths? And their weight? The characters who died like Arnold serves a purpose to reveal information about Ash. Maybe you thought he was supposed to be a big character when he wasn’t. The original series was like this in the first 3 episodes. Let’s see how it goes in the next episode.
What I think, is that in R1 by the end of episode 2, we only just wrapped up the stolen C.C./Shinjuku Ghetto conflict. Pretty much all the time we saw Clovis here, it was in the context of that specific conflict, and then he died. R1 needed time to build up the image you have of it, so would Roze. That leaves less time for other things afterwards, but that is something for later. It almost sounds like you are saying that anything that does not have more than 4 hours of runtime (12 episodes) is by definition a bad story, which I am sure you agree is absurd. I don't think this series is aiming for a story on the same scale as R1+R2.
And yes, strolling leisurely when you know danger is approaching looks kind of awful. I hope they show it later on as a recognized part of their failing.
By the way, the situation with the Situmpe wall next to the prison was indeed quite confusing. It seems both attacks came from the same side, but in one shot the giant purple field was not visible when it should be.
On another note, said wall is very distinct from Gefjun disturbers both technically and narratively: It's a giant, stationary structure that acts as a barrier for things crossing it, not an easily launchable small device disabling things in an area. It's entirely reasonable that it would not be as easily countered as the disturbers. Though that does not explain why the Black Knights could not just bombard the towers from outside...
As for the lack of higher tech equipment like float systems: it is odd that they have not explained it, but at the same time they are very consistent with it. I'm willing to forgive them, because the combat is just much more interesting to me this way.
Ping Pong the animation is only 11 episodes and is fantastic.
The problem here is they are coping moments from the og anime without the setup.
So the payoff doesn't feel earned.
Arnold's fate and Kuroto's rescue has no gravatas to it.
If the series wants to copy these moments then it has to devote to time to set them up.
They only need to make the story on the same scale as R1 + R2 if they want to copy those moments.
If the limit was 12 episodes then I would focus one major thing not several to build towards.
A prison rescue could be a whole arc to itself.
@@MyMediaChops An event can reference the previous series without being an attempt to copy or recreate it.
Like you said, rescuing tohdoh was the rescue of a well-established character. Here, the rescue was a character introduction. I.e. more similar to Lelouch revealing his face to Kirihara. Arnold's death was not at all similar to Jeremiah's defeat, instead it was used to set up intrigue about Ash's past. Yes he did get a slightly extended death scene, but he was the main antagonist of this episode. Can't exactly give him nothing after that.
You're reading a ton of author intent into this, but that's entirely your own interpretation. Perhaps question those assumptions you're making?
@@rathalos1522 it's not just that the referenced it's how they executed those events it seemed like they were trying to recreate it. Conceptually I don't disagree with the idea that a rescue can be an introduction to a character. I just think if they want to go that route then don't outright copy what happened in stage 17.
Gran and greed didn't get an epic death. With Arnold he did but it's not just it was a longer death sequence. But it was how it was executed.
The circumstances were different but if you compare the scenes they are quite similar.
My interpretation comes from interviews with the actors who claim that this show is going to recapture the magic of Code Geass. The fact that the previous stuff also references the original anime and in some cases tries to recreate stuff from it.
Resurrection was a clear example of this and this is just continuing the legacy.
I have been burned enough by this IP to know when they are doing stuff like this.
@@MyMediaChops This isn't trying to be Ping Pong. Is there any golden rule that you can't have a prison rescue at the beginning of a show and develop the characters later? No, there isn't anything like that. Anyway, I liked the scenes with Arnold here, without needing to learn the whole story of his life in advance. We still got some sense of his arrogance and that he had previous connection to Ash, which might be important as a clue to future events. It doesn't need to be a huge subplot before Arnold is even allowed to fight Ash. It's like saying we should have learned more about Villetta first, before Lelouch was allowed to use Geass on her. You can argue there's not a huge payoff for the prison break now, but I think that's part of the point: establishing that the first prison break failed. Now we're seeing the effects of that situation on Sakuya/Roze, which will likely feed into future events.
@@knightmarepilot4832 You weren't following the conversation.
The user said that I wouldn't disagree with the concept of a 12 episode series.
And I mentioned Ping Pong as an example.
No comparison was made between that series and Roze.
Of course a prison break can come at the beginning of the series it just won't have the same effect if it happened later on.
The problem with this prison break is that the impression is I the viewer am supposed to be emotionall impacted by this.
As if rescuing this guy is going to make a major difference or feel the emotional connection between him and his subordinates.
But I don't feel anything in either case.
Later on I probably but not here when I was supposed to.
You can't compare Villetta to Arnold.
Villetta doesn't have a lengthy death scene nor the same role as Arnold.
Btw if you liked the Arnold stuff great.
I didn't we both have different opinions and arguments to back them up what is the problem?
Yeah Roze said that she underestimated Neo Britannia and will try harder next time.
This emotional moment is better because of the prior setup.
So when Roze fails despite the stupidity of the scene I still feel bad for the character.
I also agree that failed attempt to rescue Sakura will play into events.
I just don't agree with how they handled Arnold and Kuroto.
Ash is essentially Rolo without a possible geass power.
I think his personality is different and less messed up than Rolo's. Shy around women, but not literally a Geass cult puppet.
Don't remember the specific details, but Lelouch destroyed most of the sakuradite reserves in the world.
Considering they only occupy Hokkaido and probably need to use whatever reserves they have to keep that wall active, they probably didn't have enough to spare on a hadron cannon or any of the other energy weapons.
The black knights could probably only manage to use such weapons since they basically act as the world military, you know, kind of like marines from one piece.
You do have a fair point about the urgency thing. She should have been running for her life or at least not taking her own sweet time.
Even if she didn't get Kuroto out, getting Sakura out would have been a pretty big deal for morale if nothing else. But I mostly chalk that up to naive optimism. We still don't have a full grasp of any of the characters in the show, so it may be too soon to say.
Now Kuroto, my dumb brain honestly confused him for Todo. I had to pause for a second and go check the wiki to make sure yeah, that's some new guy. I genuinely thought he was Todo but older when I saw him.
Where is Nunnally and Suzaku in all of this? Surely they wouldn’t want this bullshit to be happening in Japan.
The japanese don't care for quality they just want fanservice
'Tis the case so far.
Catherine and Ash are by far the best characters right now.
When you have no Lelouch... Everyone becomes stupid and technology declines. XD
Suprise they haven't developed a counter to the jammers.
This show has such an identity crisis
Bro you are one of onlu youtubers that makes still code geass videos , now nobody talking about this😢
Gee, I wonder why.
Is the author of this and the original code geass different?
So the Einbergs' White Queen finally joins the fray.
After 2nd Episode Im now Concinced, Lelouch was a Monster, He Didn't even Need To use Geass on some people in the Black knightsbto work for him , Here sakuya using geass on Ash and also Failing at their First Mission as well i.e to save Sakura ,Lelouch plans Everything out, Even his Fake Death. Imma waiting for Lelouch screentime atleast Once so bad
YES
Man, you instantly complain whenever something doesn't follow your own personal logic. That attitude really is the single worst way to consume media. I just shrugged when you were ranting about the wall once again. Anyway, why should the local forces of Hokkaido have Vincent Wards? Not only is that also an older model by now, just like the Akatsukis, they're not members of the Black Knights. It also sounds like you want them to maintain the same pacing as the original show, but that's impossible in 12 episodes. True, we aren't going to immediately care about every character beforehand, but you're not even giving them a chance to start moving before you say "I don't care". That's the one-way road to becoming impossible to please, my man.
I don't like the framing of this because your implying this is a specific thing only I do vs other people.
In reality everyone will get upset at something that bothers them for a smiilar reason.
This situation isn't about my personal logic it is the logic of the series.
There are already established lore that's being ignored so this plot can plot.
that is why I am angry.
I am not going into this series to hate it that has never been the case.
If you watch the first reaction, I enjoyed the episode despite having similar world building problems to this episode.
The seven shinning stars work with the Black Knights.
Even if they didn't at this point the BK and Britannia militaries are united so Japan should have access to those KMFS.
Given how weak these new KMFs are, even older Vincet Wards would be better than this.
Of course this assumes they wouldn't have new ones which they would.
If they want to copy moments from the original anime then yeah that would require following the pace of og series.
They don't have to do this and they don't have to make this a 12 episode one season anime.
The reason why I talked about my apathy is because the series is creating these moments that are supposed to cause the audience to care.
For example everyone is happy that Kuroto is back or Arnold's death is supposed to sad or something.
But if we don't have much time with them prior to it why would I care.
Not sure overtime I probably will start to like the characters but that doesn't remove this problem.
You must be new to the channel in that case welcome.
Because otherwise you would know that I am not a hard person to please just make a good story.
I give alot of leeway to Code Geass.
@@MyMediaChops Just keep in mind that I think your take is respectable, but I didn't agree with it. That's all. Nobody is an official loremaster here, so we can't make final judgments about anything. If they wanted, they can always rewrite the lore to make anything fit better. The 7SS are on the same side as the Black Knights, but they aren't one and the same organization. I think it's fine for the characters to be happy about rescuing someone, even if I don't know that person yet. He can be developed afterwards and they can still show us why he was so important.
@@knightmarepilot4832 thanks for respecting my opinion.
I don't agree with your statement about lore.
You can't just do whatever you want in your preestablished universe if contradicts past stuff.
This sets a bad precedent and will lead to future problems.
Also I don't like the implications of saying there is no loremaster.
Because you are suggesting that since no one monitors it (officially) there isn't an officially established lore that writers should take into account.
That isn't true and you wouldn't be saying this if the writers made a change that you didn't approve of.
IThe 7SS must be working with the BK or how else did they get those KMFS then?
I am pretty sure they are working together it doesn't change my argument.
I hope they explain it either way.
My head canon is that they are former members who got caught off during the Hokkaido Block occupation.
I don't think you read my previous response because I never argued against your point on characters reactions.
I said the story wanted to get an emotional response from me using the characters and it wasn't earned so it didn't happen.
Yeah hopefully we get more from Kuroto.
@@MyMediaChops Kuroto being back wasn’t meant to let the audiences feel happy, it’s just to establish the fact that characters have preexisting ties. And thinking the show wants you to feel bad for Arnold’s death just screams media illiteracy. That’s like saying Clovis’s death was supposed to be sad turning point of the story but isn’t one because lack of setup and poor execution
@@MyMediaChops Also there is no Britanian military, there is only this watered down BK that went through demilitarization efforts after Resurrection. Keep in mind that according to information revealed in the pamphlets for movie goers, the wall not only disable units that passes through it but also suppresses Sakuradite reactions for units inside. All sakuradite based machines have their outputs halved and advanced weaponry like the hadron cannons or float units of kmf scales are disabled across the board with the energy wings variant seeming to be the sole exception. And a frame having more advanced weapons doesn’t keep it safe from being outclassed in other areas. Just like how Albion arguably having more fire power with hadron blasters doesn’t make it a better kmf than Sin or Nagid Shu Mane when it is indeed inferior. So no a Vincent would not have shared better if the Akatsuki-Upgrade are outdated relics compared to the Camedens despite your biases.