Dark Side Of Mainstream Media And Politics In Pakistan - Syed Muzammil Shah | NSP
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 06. 2024
- Connect with me:
/ naeem.sikandar
www. NaeemSikandarPodcast/
In this podcast episode, we hear from Syed Muzammil Shah about his life journey from his initial education to his career in journalism and political science. He shares his critical self-reflection and thoughts on topics such as biological determinism, critical thinking, and the lack of freedom for media in Pakistan. @syedmuzammilofficial7067 also discusses the importance of region-specific content in mainstream media and the lack of coverage of Baluchistan and Tribal Areas. He sheds light on the establishment of Pakistan, the state within the state, and the hybrid democracy and dependent economy.
Furthermore, Muzamil talks about promoting a humanistic secular model to survive, the dirty politics of Pakistan, and Imran Khan's dangerous social vision. He also emphasizes the rights of minorities, women, and the need for progressive societies and forward-looking minds.
Muzamil shares his insights on toxic masculinity and the importance of balanced living, social activities, and entertainment. He also shares his philosophy in life and his favorite books that changed his life. Towards the end of the episode, Muzamil talks about his goals and purpose, and how progress follows destruction. He also shares his contact details for those interested in reaching out to him. Join us for an insightful discussion with Muzamil as we explore the journey of a journalist-turned-political scientist in Pakistan.
00:00 Highlights
1:15 Career choice and initial education
3:53 Landing to journalism and political science
5:17 Biological determinism for political science
7:17 Critical Self-reflection by Syed Muzammil Shah
10:44 Critical thinking, toxic optimism, and pessimism
13:26 Pessimism in journalism
15:12 No freedom for Media in Pakistan
16:10 Lack of reading and knowledge in the Media industry
19:43 Region-specific content in mainstream media
23:13 Not highlighting Baluchistan and Tribal Areas
24:36 Media channels by businessmen in Pakistan
26:36 Social media revolution and liberal audience
29:30 Controlled mainstream media
32:11 Establishment of Pakistan
33:45 State within the state
36:47 Hybrid democracy and dependent economy
40:20 Real estate model, no wealth creation
42:17 Promoting humanistic secular model to survive
43:35 Ties with Afghanistan
46:32 Dirty politics of Pakistan
49:01 Politics is an art of effectiveness
51:20 Imran Khan’s dangerous social vision
55:14 Minorities in Pakistan
58:08 Secularism, liberalism, and Islam in Pakistan
1:01:18 Left wing, right wing - then and now
1:02:45 Liberal leaders and parties in Pakistan
1:05:07 Literacy plays a crucial role in awareness
1:07:40 Progressive societies and forward-looking minds
1:09:50 Rights of women
1:16:00 Toxic masculinity
1:21:10 Institutional education vs self-taught life
1:23:11 The books that changed Muzamil’s life
1:24:56 Philosophy in life
1:29:35 Genre of reading books
1:31:12 Living a balanced life-social activities and entertainment
1:33:15 Sports and games
1:35:07 Books vs video content
1:37:37 Reason for initiating video content
1:39:29 Preparing for content
1:41:22 Money is not passion for Muzamil
1:44:12 Muzammil’s goals/purpose
1:47:36 Progress follows destruction
1:50:50 Thank you note and Contact details of Muzammil Shah
Follow Syed Muzammil Shah
/ syedmuzammilofl
/ syedmuzammilofficial
CZcams: @syedmuzammilofficial7067
Follow us on the following Podcast Platforms:
* Spotify: spoti.fi/3aPdIE3
* Google Podcast: bit.ly/392pbje
* Apple Podcast: apple.co/3mt7Cfa
Subscribe to our channel and press the bell icon to keep yourself updated: czcams.com/users/Back2BasicsPodcast
Had a great time being on the podcast, Naeem. Best wishes to your audience. A minor correction: I was referring to Pakistan being one of the happiest countries in South Asia and not Globally (above India). Freudian Slip. Hope that’d be ignored.
You are amazing 🙂
Hey @Syed Muzammil, I was wondering if you could please provide us a list you must read books. I think it would enable us to delve a bit deeper into the ideas that inspire your position on various topics.
Syed muzammil the age of dawn is goes away now that type of podcast enlightened the mind ...
But you said instead of listening personality built i recommended that your podcast or debates will be dowloaded on audio by vidmate!!!
Your greviance will be eliminate when we are do this !!
Kindly give the name of some books!!!
Thnx for passionable time, for enlightening the minds of others big fan of you ...
If you read this kindly reply ...
Best wishes and greetings to you love u!!❤❤
perfectionist
You are a complexed person i think not a self conscious
IF YOU COULD DO US A MASSIVE FAVOUR AND LIKE the video 👍🏽 By doing that, you’re helping us out more than you know 🙏🏽 thank you
Wherever Syed bhai will go ...I will surely go there ❤
Came here only for Syed bhai❤
Lots of love from India 🇮🇳
Just out of curiosity, do you guys do podcasts in lndia over these topics and others?
@@patricksavage242on pakistan or on indian issues ?
@@whysoserious5594 Just podcasts about things
@@patricksavage242 yes we have many , like u will find podcast on every issue whether its politics , geopolitics , social , religion etc , eg beerbiceps nd dostcast hence they r not the only source of knowledge in india there r many individual content creators which works on giving clarity to the public like dhruv , nitish rajput , soch by mohak , abhi nd nihu , world affairs ( prashant dhavan ) etc
@@whysoserious5594 Cheers mate 🥂
So nice to hear an honest Pakistani giving his unfiltered opinion ❤ Syed Muzammil is a gem
This guy is pure love. Stunned by his intellectual and critical mind. Highly recommend to all the youngsters.
Muzammil Bhai, I am your huge fan from India. Only because of you I started reading philosophy and sociology.
Lol then
@@ayeshaqureshi143 he is very handsome
You should be one, when we were young, say 21 years old in 1977, we had so many people in India to idolize 😊😊 Vajpayee ji was a fantastic orator, parliamentarian and firebrand opposition leader. George Farnandis was a hero for all ! There were lots of journalists like kuldip Nayyar, janardan thakur, mj Akbar and so on ! Film makers like satyajit ray and all that. Now I feel students movement ( exception Kanhaiyya), leftist congregations, very respected opposition leaders , journalists are conspicuously absent on Indian scenario. Whosoever are there they wouldn’t enthuse young guys. Muzammil is also a product of dismal circumstances in Pakistan, very charismatic so no wonder if he finds admirers, followers, fans beyond Pakistani borders. I am his fan because he reads a lot, promotes reading and thinking.
@@bbhusari mj akbar lmao
@@ayeshaqureshi143
Theek hai lol hai to,,, Bhugto TLP vaale zombies aur un jaise bevkoofo ko…
Maximum viewers are Indian
We really appreciate your mentality and social reform work
He has a big Pakistani following as well. Not only Indian
India has been ruled by left ideology liberals for 60 years so naturally he's very appealing
nah bro , the anchor has not a developed thinking as it was required for the convo , he was acting like an Oobleck nothing else , on the other hand muzzamil is good , but biased .
@@peaceeoutt2875In actual I'm also talking about Muzammil not about anchor ,i watched this video just because of him
@@ayushnishad8339 ik but some of his statements are biased isn't it ?
It will be very difficult to find another Muzammil in Pakistan having such rational thinking. I am from India
I don’t think he’s a pessimist- The first time I saw Muzammil’s video I was blown away by his critical thinking, analysis on documented facts - I was personally inspired and his philosophy helped me in my personal and professional space as well - we need more and more ppl like Muzammil-
He's a pessimist, you just need to update your pessimistic definition.
i was bllown appart until unless you start hearing opposite side
@@balajzafarr respectfully, i disagree!!
If pessimist is helping us to change for better.would we say it passimist.@balaj zafar
You weren’t blown apart , you were blown away …..
unless you meant you actually exploded 😂
The way you talked about women's rights, and women having a sense of self. I can't believe men like this exist in this society. Thankyou for bringing this up. Men cannot even imagine the things women go through, of every single social class. Toxic masculinity is a plague which will eat us rotten
When I listen to Syed Muzammil, I rarely look at his face but my ears are always the same because his words are more important.
Hasn't he started becoming cheap? By cheap I mean even Naeem Sikandar can buy him. 😁
Is he kinda ugly?😏😉😎
@@suhaibsheikh6375 😁
best books are cheapest.. i bought leviathan by hobbes for just 250 rupees in lucknow
@@existentialbaby But repetition is boring. Sitting in different shows, repeating same thing everywhere sucks.
Muzammal has introduced the science of critical thinking among youth and I see people started listening to him in big numbers recently. He made a lot of sense and the logical explanation he do, I never listened to anyone like him who have modified my social and political perspectives in many ways. Such a brave and honest gem we have, who talks about the topics like Baluchistan and role of establishment in particular which is the main root cause of almost all the problems associated with Pakistan. I hope he continue to unleash them all and he has a long way to go. Naeem your authenticity in asking questions is worth mentioning and I listened to you here first time due to Muzammal as I follow his podcasts and you have earned a subscriber as well. Thank you for both of you!!
Kudos to Mr. Muzammil.. A down to earth critical thinker..
Thanks Sikandar Bhai for bringing him here. Really liked the way you put up questions and bring out what listener would like to know.
World need such passionate people to bring better change in the society. 👍🌹👍
There is so much one learns just by listening to Muzammil, he's just a terrific orator, a great synthesist of complex rationalist ideas. We need more rationalists/existentialists at the helm of political institutions like him to get our respective countries out of the grip of extremist ideologies. I'm certainly inspired to read more by this guy. Also, Muzammil it'll be amazing if you'd do a collab with any Indian Podcaster. Would love to hear a constructive progressive, realistic dialogue!
Haha...you dont learn anything from his BS.
@@ports0339 That's your personal choice mate! Make peace with it.
Just out of curiosity, do you guys do podcasts in lndia over these topics and others?
@@patricksavage242 Yeah, We do mate. I've seen a couple. Where you from?
@@Guessswhosback Please do suggest few youtuber. i listen ravish kumar and that deshbhakt guy. any one more interesting ? jo sirf pakistan ko bash karney k bajaye overall critically souchney pey baat karey.
I was helping my mother in kitchen chores, while listening it. I don't know how 2 hours went away.
Indian here. I was also making Sabji-Roti and listening this podcast. 💕🙌
Just out of curiosity, do you guys do podcasts in lndia over these topics and others?
@@patricksavage242 Watch Ranveer Allahabadia We have many podcastor
Muzamil!! Lots of Respect to your bravery & courage. Stay safe. Love from NYC
Sir you are such a big intellectual person with a good heart. Such a gem for your country. Your philosophical & psychological thinking & analysis is amazing with a such young age it’s amazing. Big Fan of you.
Such a rare man in Pakistani context. Genius. Dear neighbours, try to learn from this mind. Faida hi hoga.
00:00 Highlights
1:15 Career choice and initial education
3:53 Landing to journalism and political science
5:17 Biological determinism for political science
7:17 Critical Self-reflection by Syed Muzammil Shah
10:44 Critical thinking, toxic optimism, and pessimism
13:26 Pessimism in journalism
15:12 No freedom for Media in Pakistan
16:10 Lack of reading and knowledge in the Media industry
19:43 Region-specific content in mainstream media
23:13 Not highlighting Baluchistan and Tribal Areas
24:36 Media channels by businessmen in Pakistan
26:36 Social media revolution and liberal audience
29:30 Controlled mainstream media
32:11 Establishment of Pakistan
33:45 State within the state
36:47 Hybrid democracy and dependent economy
40:20 Real estate model, no wealth creation
42:17 Promoting humanistic secular model to survive
43:35 Ties with Afghanistan
46:32 Dirty politics of Pakistan
49:01 Politics is an art of effectiveness
51:20 Imran Khan’s dangerous social vision
55:14 Minorities in Pakistan
58:08 Secularism, liberalism, and Islam in Pakistan
1:01:18 Left wing, right wing - then and now
1:02:45 Liberal leaders and parties in Pakistan
1:05:07 Literacy plays a crucial role in awareness
1:07:40 Progressive societies and forward-looking minds
1:09:50 Rights of women
1:16:00 Toxic masculinity
1:21:10 Institutional education vs self-taught life
1:23:11 The books that changed Muzamil’s life
1:24:56 Philosophy in life
1:29:35 Genre of reading books
1:31:12 Living a balanced life-social activities and entertainment
1:33:15 Sports and games
1:35:07 Books vs video content
1:37:37 Reason for initiating video content
1:39:29 Preparing for content
1:41:22 Money is not passion for Muzamil
1:44:12 Muzammil’s goals/purpose
1:47:36 Progress follows destruction
1:50:50 Thank you note and Contact details of Muzammil Shah
Thankss
Wow great yaar
Thank God I listened to this man myself bcz some Desi Desh Bhakt were telling me that he was also a "desh Darohi"....what a logical person who is speaking on the behalf of every person having some open sense.......
Power to the real journalists like Syed Muzammil who are fourth pillar of democracy ❤❤
I am an Indian and just here to develop my thoughts. He is a gem for us critical thinkers. Some times we are not clear that why we think some philosophical thoughts about self in such manner, but he usually give it a word, that's why I come here. To get words for my feelings.
This guy always blows my mind up, always. ❤❤❤
Syed Muzammil Bhai we love you and adore you here in India so much ❣
One of the best podcasts in my life expanding my thought process 💯💯
Silandar’s on fire hoodboy, faisal warraich and now muzammil. Keep up the great work👍🏼👍🏼💛
Syed Muzammil ভাই পাকিস্তানের আসল ইতিহাস জানানোর জন্য আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ 🇮🇳
What a revolutionry and honest mind this guy has, muzzamil is the only hope who can bring peace in this part of the world, I wish he was
Syed Muzammil is such a great person❤️
This is the real power. The way he expressed his opinion and put strong points forward seriously fabulous. Nothing can influence me except knowledge and education and that's what he has. Thank you so much sir...!!
Very intellectual person. We need more people like whose arguments are highly critical and fact based .
Indeed
Brilliant,logical,factual,reasonable analysis...great podcast...❤
Toxic positive psychology...critical thinking.
Thank you Muzammil bhai for highlighting & raising the issues of Gilgit Baltistan ❤
I heard you on the recent pod cast n I was very amazed to see such a fresh and critical mind in Pakistan. The overture of the conversation is very genuine and move to a fine genius young man. I bet who ever listened to you. learned a lot
After prof Hood hoy and now this man 💎 now you're approaching some good ones🥰
This podcast inspired me soooo much that i can't explain in words...he explain each issue on a logical based scenerio.... public should give a chance to such persons....but unfortunately, it is not possible as easy as i said...😢
Ambitious stuff is generally not easy but nothing is impossible. If there is a will there is a way. I believe in this and my whole life is based on it.
I agree. But the problem in this case we are dependent on institutes that hire and take the persons to screen. So it's difficult for a single person
After a long time found a young blood who is well read-
Well articulated and well self-taught.
I don't agree with many of his view points but it doesn't take away my interest in listening him.
The young lad putting up great questions and giving ample time to his guest to answer.
Thoroughly enjoyed it.
Muzammil is a saint of modern times.He may disagree,but his ideas are saintly .Thanks for this video.should have continued for another two hrs.
Muzammil saheb,
Our challenge is to discover 99 more persons like yourself.
Jazakallah.
A most engrossing interview. Was really blown away by the clarity of mind and vision of Mr Shah.
This is the only podcast that I have been able to listen from beginning to end despite it being 2 hours long, most podcasts fail to hold my attention at all.
I am familiar with Mr. Muzammil’s ideas. His analysis and self awareness is always inspiring and top notch.
Moreover, Great questions by Mr. Sikandar. Each one of them very intelligently presented.
Great work! 👏🏽
wonderful conversation !
Lets take a moment and appreciate Naeem Bhai for inviting the guests like Hoodbhoy, Muzammil, Faysal Warriach ❤ loved all those episodes❤❤
One of the few personalities that I admire is Syed Muzammil shah who has inspired and enlightened my thinking. God bless you
Watched the whole podcast in one sitting. I've been listening, following you, since you visit QAU. Your ideas and thoughts are based on facts. Intellectually criticizing the problems. Pleased to hear and understand things from you. Be brave and courageous always. More power to you Syed Muzammil.
This man has adeptly encapsulated Pakistan's past 75 years and projected the next 75 years within a single episode. It's striking to note the somber and dark undertones that permeate the narrative, offering a thought-provoking perspective on the nation's journey.
Awesome starting..
Most awaited podcast ❤
as an indian syed muzammil hi banda mujhe ek educated gentleman lagta hai jise dkhne or sunne pr lagta hai ki mne time waste nahi kia...
india me aisey bandey nahi hai? why do you obsess over our intellectuals?
Man i also want to know if someone else is like him in India???
@@ali19231 bro i am not obsessed but there are the rare chances when someone from pakistan actual talk about the real problems rather than always talk about islam...
even highschool student in india is more intelligent then the pakistani inteellectual...
Ill tell u the reason if i am wrong then correct me ...
1. In indian school books like Social studies there is not even mention about anything wrong about pakistan they just mentions about the rivers only.. but in pakistan studies book {sindh studies} there is a saying about hindu or yahoodis are kaafir .. wow
2. not even a single time in india there is military coup but there is 3 times military dictatorship in pakistan...
not even a single time pakistan pm complete their 5 year tenure why ??? even then you says than there is democracy in pakistan ???
everything is not about nuclear power.. nuclear weapons cant give you food you have to develop also...
3.Not even a single time there is loadshedding or electricity cut in indias city like mumbai or delhi and now compare your karachi or islamabad how many times there is loadshedding
4.How can a Army Cheif{Bajwa} become so rich and start living in foreign country with his own house ?? now show me a single major or military cheif of india... cant you see he steals your {pakistans} tax money to full fill his needs ..try to see many other things than islam islam islam ...
5.Why the minority levels decrease in pakistan ... you can compare it with india its not decrease but it increase also..
Thankyou for listening me .. think about it with neutral mind set and correct me if i am wrong...
@@nitishvashisht914 your comment proves literally the opposite what you're saying.
1. that is literally false and stop taking your news from Republic TV and Whatsapp ppt. this literally shows how much you indians live in a bubble of yours. pretty sure you are the same guy who believes muslim guys in india are given sex training to lure in hindu women. grow up. "highschool student in india is more intelligent then the pakistani inteellectual" acha bakwas band kr. pakistan has a nobel prize in physics. india has zero. agya sukoon?
2. that's not a bad thing. spain, argentina, portugal, all had dictatorships that turned them into first world countries. don't understand the point you have. democracy is a scam anyway, esp where there is low literacy.
3. that loadsheeding thing is literally a thing of the last decade. like I said, stop taking your news from Whatsapp. loadshedding rarely happens.
4. true. we need to fix that.
5. minority percentage is decreasing because the majority is increasing. simple math. if you are saying about hindus, before 71 majority of hindus were in east pakistan. anyone with basic stat knowledge knows that comparison is invalid.
@@ali19231ur intellectual?? He is your property or what?? There are so many intellectuals in India in different fields but apparently they don't do podcast or CZcams videos.
Great podcast ..host asked very different questions from what we see people asking him👏👏
Waiting for this man on ur show
It’s always a pleasure to listen to Muzammil Shah. From what I’ve seen of Pakistani news media, I like the kind of coverage Dunja News do. Their think tank shows are really good and they’re fairly critical of politicians regardless of which side they belong.
Muzamil shb, I have been listening to so many public figures, but nobody like you comes across as so thoughtful in Pakistan. It is pleasure that asset like you is in Pakistan. Keep up the great work. More power to you brother ❤
From a guy who is unable to just finish a few-minute video to watching 2 hours long podcasts attentively, the credit goes to this man, hats off...
Syed Muzammil 😍❤️🥰✌️✌️
It’s because of Syed Muzzamil that I am passionate about philosophy and society today. And looking inwards.
Such a valuable conversation. Your best podcast guest so far.
This is the longest I've listened to any Podcast.
Absolute worthwhile :)
i can't stop listening to this guy he is amazing best podcast so far Naeem he is so rational we still have some hope i have gone to his channel and seen all videos.
Great discussion
I saw a video on CZcams where an interviewer asked German youth about Hitler. Everyone said he was a villain. The interviewer then asked if they felt ashamed and would apologize for Hitler's atrocities. They replied why should they because they weren't even born then. The problem with Muzammils and Ghias's of this world is that they want the youth of Pakistan to not only criticize the blunders of their ancestors, but feel equally responsible, apologize on their behalf and then adopt monasticism out of shame.
😂😂
Yes because they show youth a mirror of society in which people still celebrate dictators like Zia ul Haq who destroyed an entire generation through propaganda and religious extremism. The difference between german youth and pakistani youth is that they condemn actions of their ancestors and we don’t. They have learned from the history and moved on, we haven’t and are still stuck in past trying to restore so called glory of the Muslims.
@@Modicdeutsch In Pakistan, nobody blames the Bangladeshis for 1971. The two major thought groups are whether the army was responsible or Bhutto who lost miserably to Sheikh Mujib, but refused to accept his mandate after blaming rigging without proofs like the Imrans and Nawaz's of today.
@@ibratnak tou kia Bengalis ko blaim karain....🤔🤔
@@al-warisbuilders7034 o bhai main keh raha hu k Pakistan mein sab Pakistan ko he zimedar theratay hain 1971 ka, tou phir ye Muzammil waghera us baat pe already sharminda qom ko aur sharminda q kartay hain? Siasatdan aur generals jo 1971 k zimedar the Muzammil aur Ghias ko kisi khatay mein nai daltay, aur ye inko b pata hai k inki zyada tar audience middle class ki hai. Un ko ye sab btanay ka maqsad? Sharmindigi se khudkushi kar len wo?
Great discussion. Nice to listen to some one who is very realistic and convincing. I feel these are my ideas and thoughts that I have always believed in. May almighty bless Pakistan with enlightened society. Ameen
Pakistan’s best treasure ❤️❤️
Excellent talk. I hardly miss watching Muzammil’s interview on CZcams. One of the best podcasts I watched. Host is smart and he doesn’t interrupt guest a lot. He only poses questions and let guest speak his/her heart. Good luck! Next one I’m going to watch of Hoodbhouy and Faisal Warraich. I personally like reading books and always recommend people to read books.
Good subject being discussed.
I am from India,i am Hindu. i like your ideology sir
watched it continuously for 1 hr 51 mins... aaj tak kbi itni lmbi podcast ni suni with so much attention... man spitting facts. keep going!
I went through some shorts and felt that I should really hear his podcast. There are few people in Pakistan like you Muzammil who can talk broadly on facts.Kudos❤
The host is a humble person & asked really good questions.
I'm here just for Syed Muzamil Hussain
You're blessed
Appreciate the clarity of thoughts.
Syed bhai very active nowadays, podcasts, instagram , but i want him to be more active on his own youtube channel and make frequent videos , i just love him watching in vidoes foe hours❤
we need more people like him
Love the set Naeem!
Wow what an intellectual. We need more critical, rational and logical people all over Pakistan. We Pakistanis should extract as much knowledge from him and learn from him to strengthen ourselves. Only when the individuals of a society have adopted a growth mindset, can Pakistan develop. Love from Lahore, Punjab 🇵🇰
Absolutely brother
Very Well done Naeem, you asked many questions which I personally always wanted to know.
Huge admirer of Muzammil from India!!
its always nice to see Syed Muzammil and his analysis on the current affairs and history as well. he is a man of words
Truly loved it.
It's the thinking pattern that makes your journey❤
May ALLAH bless you Muzammil
There is no allah
This conversation enlightened my thinking. ❤
Very balanced podcast
very informative
I just love this man.
big fan of muzammil but hats off to the podcast host as well, its been a while since i saw someone so well put together in terms of interviewing someone
Outstanding Podcast ❤
Very rare people like him today. God bless him God protected him . I don't miss his video and do learn something new and get enlightened.
The personality which every student need as teacher 😊
Love and respect from FATA Bajaur 👍
Ab Bajaur aik district nahi?
The purpose is not to follow me its to follow yourself great said! real man.👍
Such a rich content in country like Pakistan...truly amazing
Outstanding
Muzumil you are very brutal True Pakistani in depth you are right my brother
Brilliant Analysis
Yar kamal hay yea banda. It's the hard reality of Pakistan, a hard pill to take.
I totally agree with the mindset of this man ❤
This Man is Inspiration! ❤
Intellectual and quality responses by Syed Muzammil to below par questions and interviewer.
This man is a gem 👏👏👏
informative
Well formed questions by Naeem sikandar
Mr muzamil you are great critical thinker.