Fascism and Media in Contemporary Pakistan | Syed Muzammil Shah
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 08. 2022
- Syed Muzammil Shah is a broadcast journalist and talk show host currently associated with Capital TV. He is also a political scientist and a social critic. In this session of "Baat se Baat" he will share his observation on fascism & media in contemporary Pakistan.
It is a great change to hear someone sensible from Pakistan. Pity he has no hope of being in power.
I am from India and I must say that i have never heard such a nice talk. I am impressed that Pakistan is blessed with such intellectual people and we have hope that they will keep religion and politics separate. I will be happy to invite you to India into some literary festivals. You seems to be the best.....
Bro muzzamil is gem but people like him in pakistan are so less , that we can count them by a hand , India has thousands of gem like muzzamil , for example sushant sareen , abhijit iyer etc , again muzzamil doesn’t deserve a s*ithole like pakistan, come India and where minds like you’ll be appreciated
Haven't seen any auditorium so full ever in my life. Syed Muzammil has this magic!
Just brilliant! Erudite, sensitive and straightforward. Sweetest sovereignty of reason!
Dear Muzammil, it's extremely heartening to see this kind of quality content. Best wishes from an Indian.
india me tumhari kaum bhi kaha kam hai...hindu majority me hai isiliye musalman thik thak chal rahe hai varna india me pakistan vala hi haal hona tha agar musalman majority me hota...
@@workproductivity6223 Haan wo baat toh theek hai. Halaat aur sudhar jaate agar India ke musalmaan Hindus ki Tarah ho jaate, lekin ab Hindus Musalmaano ki Tarah hote jaa rahe hain.
بڑے عرصے بعد نہایت شاندار گفتگو سننے کو ملی ہے مزمل سید سلامت رہیں آپ جزاک اللہ۔
Sir pervaz hood & muzammil are our real heroes.Real assets of pakistan
Such people are real asset of all countries
Bhai ye achche log par inki koi nahi sunta
One of most finest intellectual of Pakistan ❤️❤️❤️
Top quality discussion. Thanks from India
Syed Muzamil should be heared more in Pakistan and India as well
Aji ghanta knowledge h isko
Tujhe bohot zyada hai?@@vikasduhan4067
Speechless.One of the best talks I've heard in my life.Wish I had been there in person.
Muzammil u r a real jouranlist i respect the most.happy to see u at "The black hole".
Respect! When reason speaks, this is how it sounds.
What an exceptional flawless Orator, i can imagine how much research and reading this guy must have put in in his absolute quest for truth! You’re ray of hope and an inspiration to our brain-dead, entertainment binging generation!
What a great thoughts
Superb superb superb
More power to you, brilliant sir Muzammil ♥️♥️💯💯💯
thought provoking
great great great
everyone ...... this needs to be share 🙏
His command over the subject is fantastic. Just marvelous.
He was happy today.. Great human being... Born in our era... 🎉🎉
Brilliant absolutely Brilliant SAVE THE HUMAN RACE FORUM ABSOLUTELY APPRECIATES THE MAN AT THIS INTELLECTUAL BRAVERY N INTELLECTUAL WRESTLING
Excellent session from Muzammi jil. I love hearing this guy
As an indian I must say this guy is so good
Excellent speech in simplistic ideas which explained in understandable understandable speech for the common people.
I have radically changed my interests in nowadays politics and media since I found that how they manipulate our minds for there ruthless popularity
Thanks sir to clear my thoughts❤. Now I'm free to think with my own understandings.
Muzzamil is always superb but the questions asked by students are also very good ..
Initiative by The black hole is really commendable
Very informative
مزمل سید صاحب کی عمدہ گفتگو
Pakistan needs such intellectual people
Nice to see Muzamil here. Talks sense, talks reason.
Brilliant 👏
Fantastic..I needd to read books.
People need to watch this.
Good talking muzamil Bahi good ☺
Totally intellectual talk
Very thoughtful speech
im proud to see such discussions in Pakistan, a country is failure without intellectuals... We need to nurture these minds and thinkers...
Very intellectual personality in Pakistan
Good initiative' the black hole'
Pakistani's, educated and rational people like Muzammil are your real heroes, not Imran Niazi type of fraud characters! More power to the youth of Pakistan, you can be the change! 🇮🇳
I opening for any individual.. good work muj...
Great !
Clapping wah wah Pakistani society is hoping better. Muzammil ko listen karne khoob public ki bheed.muzammil jese intelectuals.pakistan me bahut kam h. pakistan required more youth like s Muzammil.
Very nice
Vv rational person. Muzamil sb. I fully agree on his narrative.
Great keep it up
Excellent speech (Khalid Mojajirzada)
Just start saying the truth not quarrel a time will come everything will be on the right direction
great
Thank you youtube
How can I participate in these events?
💚❤
Name of the books he mentioned.
Sir Muzzamil as a girl apsy aik question hy Mera?I belong to a village..I Was 18 when I got married now I am 23 and mother of two kids.I was FS.c student when I got married..mene graduation or masters shadi ky bad kia.. Virtual uni sy online masters kia management me 3+ gpa sy or mery gaon me mein aik he lrki hun jis ki 16 years education hy...but Meri family allow ni kr Rahi private job..bank me allow ni hy..idhr koi company industry ni hy Jahan management ki job kr ky ski sekhun khud ko groom krun..ap css ki bat kr rahy k ye ni krna chahye lakin mjhy btaein mein kya krun..? Is Pakistan ny mjhy kya dia? Ghr wlay allow kr rahy job sirf Is shart py k government officer ki job ho tou thek wrna or koi kam ni krna hmari izzat kharab hoti hy...aik conservative sy gaon me rehty huy mein agy study continue he ni kr skti ku ky Yahan koi uni ni hy..tell me what should I have to do..? Ya phir idhr rehty huy or bchy paida krun or population me mzeed izafa krun...??
Guys like you need to grow. Then only your country will have future. But you need to multiply faster.
Aisa koi India me bhi ho to batao. Hume bhi Janna hai India ke probs ke bare me
2:00:12
1:38:25
There is no law for the mad person free thinker n king rest of all are the law giver or the followers
15:09
35:05
38:08
40:00
47:55
49:30
1:14:30
1:23:05
1:26:09
Zia was not first on to popularize Mohammed bin Qasim as a hero of Pakistan. Just listen to the song "Aao bacchon sair karayen tumko Pakistan ki" from the 1950s movie called Bedari.
In one Indian film, we had a song:
Aao bachchon tumhe dikhyen jhaanki Hindustan ki 😅
In the end he was speaking about Parvez ...some one. Who is it. Can some one spell his full name for searchign in google
Yeah its Pervez houdbouy.....
@28:18:27 zoom in and see the map of Pak, it appears like dog is trying to eat India. In reality also it it trying the same.
What you perceive as fascism is infact feudalism in new form in your country.
Qayamat ki sari nishaniyan shayed pakistan m he puri honi thy.. is liye ghreeb maray jaty hen
2:24:30 who is he praising? pravez .. who?
Parvez houdbouy
Propaganda did play a huge role in Nazi Germany, but that happened much later, after the Nazis were well established in the German parliament. Goebbels was made minister for propaganda in 1933 and started broadcasting Hitler's speeches on radio and organise the Nuremberg rallies which were spectacular visual propaganda events. However, the Nazis exploited racist ideas which were prevalent not only in Germany at the time, but even in European colonies and other countries like America and Japan, where racial superiority was taken as normal. Anti-semitism was deep rooted across Europe, and the Nazis simply encouraged it further. Hatred for Jews was already well established throughout Europe, hence when the Nazis targeted them, it was not met with the kind of resistance which is there in the West now, where Anti-semitism is a serious offence. Fascism always develops in societies where some form of extremism already exists and remains unchecked or unchallenged.
مزمل صاحب ایک سوشل بگ بینگ کر نا چاہتے ہیں ۔۔
KARKASH AWAZ.
Asset of Pakistan
The boy himself doesn’t know what exactly needs to be done in Pakistan. No doubt he possess great knowledge on history and political issues. His critique is good but would that lead to sensible solution ? It’s the same thing we have been doing. Bitching.
Hahahah so true.
446 view usme bhi lagta hai 400 indian honge
fun fact is maximum views on these type of videos which are meant for pakistani public gets from India😂
Populism isn’t fascism sir. And I strongly urge you to visit india and find it out for yourself.
It is just look at bjp politics essentially the same traits at a smaller extent but in future there might be someone else who can exploit it even further.
@@Bengalifirst speak facts.not assumptions
@@saym4gunthapally192 it is an fact. Bjp politics divide nation . Which in turn creates problem .
Modi, BJP , RSS are not only fascist but also shamelessly imitate them with pride.
@PavitShokeen well I am an hindu but you seems to be a dull headed bhakt . Gali galuz as only option make sense can not expect more than that from rss cowards .
Love from INDIA❤
Map dekha hai?
@@vipint3694 then what?..map to government banati hai wahi dikhana hota hai..iska matlab wo ilaka unka hua aisa thodi hai?..andhbhakt mat bano..nahi to India ki halat bhi pakistan jaisi ho jayegi...jo sikhne ko milta hai wo sikh le yaha se..
अपने देश में हिंदूत्व बढ रहा है
@@vipint3694 ignore map...doesn't matter unless they spoke wrongly!
@@INSPIREWITH_WORDS may be but one should always ask for correct map
Aapane To Bata rahe ho aapko lagta hai aapke jahil log Sidhe Raste per chal Payenge jo jo chij Bata rahe ho Inko aapke Jai Lava Mein Kar Payenge ya karne Denge aapke jail Mulla Hamen To Nahin Lagta ki ine Logon Ko Sidhe Raste per chalne Denge Kyon 75 Salon se Sidhe Raste per chalne Nahin Diye to Abhi kya Sidhe Raste per chalne Degi Inko Jo Nafrat Hai Jo kam Hona Chahta Hai kam Hona chahie tha vah to Jyada Badh Raha Hai vah to Jyada bada hai aapke Mulla Aur Hai railiyan nikal Nikal Ke Nafrat Bhar Rahe unko lag raha hai ki Nafrat kam Rai Karke fir se Badka rahe hain railiyan nikal nikal kar ine log Chhod Denge Hamen To Nahin Lagta ki yah Nafrat Ki Dukaan Hai yah log Chhodenge main aapke Jayal Mulayam ko chhodane Denge aap bhi Ek media Ho media wale ho na aapke aur badhiya hai ham log Sidhe Raste per chalne Denge Agar Inam ko Sidhe Raste per chalne dete to utna Din Se Kyon jail banaa kar rakhen Stri ko chhupana Jhuthe Kitab Likhna kitabon Mein Nafrat bharna Jitna hansane baat kar rahe ho na utna Aasan Nahin Hai very easy Nafrat Ki Karan se aapke Mulla hone badhate Baat To Roe Milenge Jannat Milegi ghar ghar ke yah aatankwadi Banna kam ho jaaye aapke Desh Mein aatankwadi Banna kam ho jaenge Hamen Nahin Lagta aap kya Bam ke dimag aur Soch Dekhkar na Hamen Nahin Lagta ki yah log Badal Lenge 75 Salon se lo Badal Nahin Paye to Abhi Kya Kaha badlenge han Hamen Nahin Lagta hai ki mahilaon Ne log ko yah mindset badalne Denge Aisa Na Ho ki aapko bhi Utha Kar Lekar jakar Gayab kar de Kyunki Unka Jagah bharna Band Ho Jaega na yah to sahi direction Mein Lekar Jaega Karke aapko Kahana Utha Na Le Jaaye Gayab Na Kar De aapko Kisi aapki Jaan Bulane Video dekh liya aapane Jo video banaya tha Usi Tarah na Karen aapko bhi aapki Jaan Bulao ne thoda Bach Ke Rahana aapke Jaan bol raha hun use
This dude is a very intellectual sounding person but cant just close my eyes and agree to everything he says
I live in america and the 1st person pointed to very serious and focused american issues.Why did you not let the first person who raised a very sane question about the issues in american society or hyper capitalism?why do use logical answers on everyother topic but use whataboutism when it comes to hypercapitalism and america? Why cant u listen to one thing agaist them?
2. "Nature was unfair to women". "The birth pill was the greatest feminist in the world" is that not demining to a woman to say that nature can only be fair to woman if it gave them same economic oppertunity? Quoting someone like hirary when it comes to standing for women?
The end to most of the solutions and how to achieve them that u offered can only be achieved if u comoletely destroy the islamic family system. That is basic unit of any society that islam has to offer. Andrew tate offered a better solution pointing out the loopholes in western societies because if u kick the family system out, then its these hyper capitalist companies that run u and thats not good enough either as evident in the west
Hearing such things in Pakistan, it seems that the heirs of Taxila University are alive
Ohh now I got that Anti-Modi attitude also sells in Pakistan 🇵🇰, Mr. Muzammil Shah Modi isn’t Just a ‘Populist’ Leader, He served 12 yrs as an CM of Gujrat, Govern his state as an Complete Statesman & debated & expressed his opinion’s on each & every possible Topics On National Course only after then in a Diverse parliamentary Democracy he got elected by Voter’s of India.
Please don’t try to put him in the same room of Stalin, Hitler or Your Backyard boy Imran Khan.
Modi ko gali deke agar Pakistan me jinda rehne ki permission milta hain tab bolte raho..barna yea admi jo baat karta hain bohot jald mulle isko thok denge..
More of anti imran khan rather than original thoughts
Kab kaha hai Imran Khan ne ke woh anti West ya anti America hai woh to kehta hai ke hum sab see ache taaluqat chahtee hain .In fact ap apnee pas see baateen Imran Khan ki taraf mansoob kar ke apni taqrir suna rahee hain jo ke intellectual dishonesty hai
Hahaha. From all this at least you learned a word 'intellectual dishonesty'. Baqi kuch palle nahen Para lagta hai
@@Squishipie Haha ke Maamee would you please elaborate what you have learned from his biased and one sided speech
@@javedbutt6222 islamic touch
@@talashegumshuda5791 To tumhara kea kheal hai ke kea Hindustan mein politics ko Hindutwi touch aur anti muslim touch nahin diya jata.Aur kea America sameet puree west mein Isai aur anti muslim touch nahin diya jata?It is completely alright as long as you don't incite violence or hatred against anyone.
@javedbutt6222 o butt sab i m butt pakistani and Muslim too. Imran khan sahib sey jab china k vigar muslims k baray mai pucha gaya tha to unho ney kaha tha k china ka ye internal matter ha. Un ki isi mantaq k mutabik india or america ka internal matter ha.
Mujay apnay or Pakistani baio k rights ki fikr honi chahiye we r not a fkin super power jo kisi pr roob daal skay. Larkiyo k sath hamaray yaha jo salook ho raha ha wo akeli ghar sey nahi nikal sakti. America mai larki raat k 12 bajay akeli b niklay to usay or us k ghar walo ko pata hota ha k wapis pohnch jaye gi yaha din k 12 bajay b niklay to sath mai kisi ko jana parta ha kahi ko janwar na par jaye. We r Pakistanis hamay apnay rights in imran or nawaz sey manganay ha na k in ki gulami krni ha. Inho ney hamay serve krna ha hum ney inhay nahi.
Bhutto was a perfect example of a fascist leader. Like Hitler he used populist slogans to get himself elected. How ironical that the blue collar workers became Bhutto's biggest fans knowing fully well that he represented the feudal class. After becoming prime minister he used fascist tactics and kicked out all labor union leaders from his fascist PPP party.
I am sorry to say but I don’t agree with most of the things he is saying.
OR MUZLUM BUN KUR RO RAHY HO
False. This guy is partially correct.
Yeh laadeen hai
50:58 Sleeping beauty wake up. 1:51:01 Honey dont' fall into trap. This guy is full of rutta and bookish.
Modi is not populist leader it's propaganda by some media outlets of India and abroad.
Modi served 15 years as chief minister with close majority. He became famous because he made Gujarat no.1 state on economy, industry and social standard.
Bjp lacked prime minister candidate after atal bihari vajpayee's retirement due to ill health. Lal krishna advani and Rajnath Singh were not doing well in politics. Modi and Amit Saha name was proposed by RSS. Rest is history
He is a very fluent speaker but not an intellectual. Jus quoting some western writers doesn't make you an intellectual.
Then who is an intellectual?
Bhikaristan
Shame bhai 😢 I hope you be a better person.
@@Bengalifirst True...
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ very sensible boy in Pakistan first time in my life . I hope more kids could come out like him. Pls beta try to be safe . U r like my son . I am worried about you . I wish he becomes the prime minister of Pakistan . Pakistan will become a normal country and progress… USA
According to muzzamil mental,being nation we should do nothing.
Every thing is fine until I see the map
Muzammal is still too immature to lead a society because he doesn't know how to balance in between different classes, sects, gender, economy, culture, power etc. Whereas Molana Mododi gives total solution up to in between economy, culture, gender, power. Total solution!
Read Molana Mododi for the betterment of society, family as well as your own self.
Molana Mododi, Great scholar delibratey neglected by Pakistani"s for being local and Muslim. And Pakistani"s like imported things, English things and things they don't understand!
What a tragedy !
Very true
Id he is considered an intellectual in Pakistan then no wonder Pakistan is going down the drain 😀
Aapane To Bata rahe ho aapko lagta hai aapke jahil log Sidhe Raste per chal Payenge jo jo chij Bata rahe ho Inko aapke Jai Lava Mein Kar Payenge ya karne Denge aapke jail Mulla Hamen To Nahin Lagta ki ine Logon Ko Sidhe Raste per chalne Denge Kyon 75 Salon se Sidhe Raste per chalne Nahin Diye to Abhi kya Sidhe Raste per chalne Degi Inko Jo Nafrat Hai Jo kam Hona Chahta Hai kam Hona chahie tha vah to Jyada Badh Raha Hai vah to Jyada bada hai aapke Mulla Aur Hai railiyan nikal Nikal Ke Nafrat Bhar Rahe unko lag raha hai ki Nafrat kam Rai Karke fir se Badka rahe hain railiyan nikal nikal kar ine log Chhod Denge Hamen To Nahin Lagta ki yah Nafrat Ki Dukaan Hai yah log Chhodenge main aapke Jayal Mulayam ko chhodane Denge aap bhi Ek media Ho media wale ho na aapke aur badhiya hai ham log Sidhe Raste per chalne Denge Agar Inam ko Sidhe Raste per chalne dete to utna Din Se Kyon jail banaa kar rakhen Stri ko chhupana Jhuthe Kitab Likhna kitabon Mein Nafrat bharna Jitna hansane baat kar rahe ho na utna Aasan Nahin Hai very easy Nafrat Ki Karan se aapke Mulla hone badhate Baat To Roe Milenge Jannat Milegi ghar ghar ke yah aatankwadi Banna kam ho jaaye aapke Desh Mein aatankwadi Banna kam ho jaenge Hamen Nahin Lagta aap kya Bam ke dimag aur Soch Dekhkar na Hamen Nahin Lagta ki yah log Badal Lenge 75 Salon se lo Badal Nahin Paye to Abhi Kya Kaha badlenge han Hamen Nahin Lagta hai ki mahilaon Ne log ko yah mindset badalne Denge Aisa Na Ho ki aapko bhi Utha Kar Lekar jakar Gayab kar de Kyunki Unka Jagah bharna Band Ho Jaega na yah to sahi direction Mein Lekar Jaega Karke aapko Kahana Utha Na Le Jaaye Gayab Na Kar De aapko Kisi aapki Jaan Bulane Video dekh liya aapane Jo video banaya tha Usi Tarah na Karen aapko bhi aapki Jaan Bulao ne thoda Bach Ke Rahana aapke Jaan bol raha hun use