How did Neandertals smell?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 06. 2023
  • Pretty bad I bet, but how was their sense of smell?
    Produced by Complexly for PBS Digital Studios
    References:
    www.cell.com/i...
    phys.org/news/...
  • Věda a technologie

Komentáře • 2,4K

  • @eatenman1235
    @eatenman1235 Před rokem +8696

    I freaking love science. We will ask the most ridiculous questions, create different hypotheses, and go through so many complex trials just to learn how Neaderthals and Denisovans smell.

    • @melvinbrotherofthejoker436
      @melvinbrotherofthejoker436 Před rokem +157

      I FREAKING LOVE SCIENCE TOO OMG!!!!!!!!!

    • @magneto228
      @magneto228 Před rokem +53

      @@melvinbrotherofthejoker436 IKR OMGGGGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @safaiaryu12
      @safaiaryu12 Před rokem +119

      "We're going to grow scent receptors of extinct humans in a petri dish..."

    • @jimmyjasi-
      @jimmyjasi- Před rokem +11

      I'm curious if they Could they smell Carbón oxide?

    • @lmao.3661
      @lmao.3661 Před rokem +40

      oh my science!!!

  • @CriaVielen
    @CriaVielen Před rokem +868

    I can't be the only one freaking out over the fact we have the technology to recreate Neanderthal olfactory sensors using a fully sequenced genome.

    • @bumpersincapped
      @bumpersincapped Před 10 měsíci +11

      and then there's the self driving cars

    • @AffirmativeArtsOnTheRoad
      @AffirmativeArtsOnTheRoad Před 9 měsíci +22

      It sounds like something "cloning adjacent" has been done here...which
      suggests that we might need to make some decisions about how far we, as a
      global society...think we should/could/wisely ought to...take this
      "cloning" idea.

    • @noahjones1192
      @noahjones1192 Před 9 měsíci +8

      @@AffirmativeArtsOnTheRoad just look at Hwang Woo-suk and what he’s done

    • @jake-rg3fd
      @jake-rg3fd Před 9 měsíci +5

      ​@@noahjones1192what exactly? From his Wikipedia article it looks like he's cloned dogs, and *said he'd like to* clone mammoths and other extinct species.

    • @jorden9821
      @jorden9821 Před 9 měsíci +3

      ​@@AffirmativeArtsOnTheRoadyeah, nothing is stopping the path we're on lol

  • @WhoThisMonkey
    @WhoThisMonkey Před rokem +348

    My sense of smell has returned after 6 months smoke free.
    I can smell flowers again!

    • @100Creed
      @100Creed Před 10 měsíci +9

      I smoke for 12 years now and can smell everything just fine. And I qit smoking for 6 month once and yeah my taste and smell increased slightly but not that much. So you did smoke 3 packs a day or just big cap?!

    • @Dermaa
      @Dermaa Před 10 měsíci +14

      Congrats! 👏👏

    • @dillydally3051
      @dillydally3051 Před 9 měsíci +1

      oooh you want to smoke again oooh

    • @airacummins5076
      @airacummins5076 Před 8 měsíci +9

      Wait my parents have smoked my whole life, is that why I have a bad sense of smell

    • @hmmmm3094
      @hmmmm3094 Před 8 měsíci

      ​@@dillydally3051lmfaoo bro rlly trynna hypnotise him

  • @LadyRedAmber
    @LadyRedAmber Před rokem +97

    I love the idea of like a homo sapiens and a neanderthal haveing a conversation like
    Sapiens:"oh dear cousin do you smell the beautiful aroma of roses in the air?"
    Neanderthal:"my brother in Lucy i smell poison gas lets get out of here"

  • @rhoharane
    @rhoharane Před rokem +2163

    Does this imply that we're relatively more fruit-eaters compared to them?

    • @lwolfstar7618
      @lwolfstar7618 Před rokem +363

      That's actually a really solid point

    • @patrickbrand1319
      @patrickbrand1319 Před rokem +534

      It's been theorized Neanderthals were mostly carnivore. It was cold where they were from after all

    • @Nerobyrne
      @Nerobyrne Před rokem +712

      Modern humans have evolved the distinct ability to smell fertile soil.
      There's a certain smell called petrichor, which comes after rain on fertile soil.
      Our receptors to detect this are some of the most sensitive in the animal kingdom.
      So basically, we evolved to be farmers😮

    • @avarise5607
      @avarise5607 Před rokem +393

      ​@@NerobyrneWell farming is fricking op survival strat, no wonder early farmers got the bussy

    • @LanceBjornsson8888
      @LanceBjornsson8888 Před rokem +68

      Fruits weren’t as sweet or common back then.

  • @nemo-x
    @nemo-x Před rokem +253

    Also if they were super receptive to sulphury smells, that likely means that they wouldn't have tolerated stinking themselves.

    • @ryanbutler6387
      @ryanbutler6387 Před 10 měsíci

      Maybe they didnt have the intelligence to recognize that?…. Maybe?…. Idk.

    • @totenfurwotan4478
      @totenfurwotan4478 Před 10 měsíci +10

      @@ryanbutler6387Neanderthals we’re very intelligent and had larger Brains then Homo sapiens

    • @draculastraphouse7863
      @draculastraphouse7863 Před 10 měsíci +7

      ​@@totenfurwotan4478larger brains but they were less efficient, they were still smart though

    • @totenfurwotan4478
      @totenfurwotan4478 Před 10 měsíci

      @@draculastraphouse7863 😂 yea dude if you say so

    • @c4onmylip
      @c4onmylip Před 10 měsíci

      ​@draculastraphouse7863 what proof do you have for that?

  • @jenmqkeeper
    @jenmqkeeper Před rokem +71

    I love the Neanderthal info, but I kept getting distracted by the adorable crocheted dino in the background with a pan pride flag! 💕💛💙🦖

    • @Neumannberg
      @Neumannberg Před 8 měsíci +1

      Do pansexual people have sex with frying pans

    • @Owlthathurt
      @Owlthathurt Před 7 měsíci +7

      Repent to Allah, please don’t fall for the devils satanic agenda.

    • @ommsterlitz1805
      @ommsterlitz1805 Před 7 měsíci

      a what flag ? science is irrefutable there is 2 genders and the purpose of life is reproduction

    • @tea5687
      @tea5687 Před 7 měsíci +10

      ​@@Owlthathurtmmm, nahhh

    • @magnesiumoxide6863
      @magnesiumoxide6863 Před 7 měsíci

      Me thinking it was columbia or romania

  • @piyali.6172
    @piyali.6172 Před rokem +4210

    That's interesting... but people really can't smell honey? It's very apparent after opening the jar

    • @aricalamari
      @aricalamari Před rokem +601

      Really? It has a strong odor to me.

    • @kyrab7914
      @kyrab7914 Před rokem +272

      It depends. I've found black&gold honey to have a strong scent,but golden honey not as much

    • @salt-emoji
      @salt-emoji Před rokem +222

      That's because you've only ever had ultra pasteurized micro filtered mass produced honey.

    • @matijafurac5149
      @matijafurac5149 Před rokem +555

      ​@@salt-emoji My grandfather is a beekeeper and you could not possibly be more wrong

    • @piyali.6172
      @piyali.6172 Před rokem +330

      @@salt-emoji brother, you're assuming I live in the states. I live in Bangladesh where most honey is cultivated from farms.

  • @SteveMND
    @SteveMND Před rokem +1194

    "How did Neanderthals smell?" With their noses!
    Happy Belated Father's Day!

    • @camarofish344
      @camarofish344 Před rokem +10

      God, I get that it’s a joke but I genuinely was confused for a sec of how someone wouldn’t know how they would be able to smell

    • @samuelmellars7855
      @samuelmellars7855 Před rokem +9

      That's where I thought the first bit was going!
      Good to see I'm not alone!

    • @MatthewFTabor
      @MatthewFTabor Před rokem +5

      The same comment I was going to post :p

    • @Havron
      @Havron Před rokem +6

      _"My dog's got no nose."_
      "How does he smell?"
      _"Terrible!"_

    • @jamesmcinnis208
      @jamesmcinnis208 Před rokem +1

      ​@@camarofish344"How" can also mean "how well," as in "How is his backhand?" or "How are you?"
      And, I think his name is Steve (not God).

  • @voilet-the-non-violet-vulpix

    I love the crocheted Dino!! Very cute! 🦖

    • @rubyrogers239
      @rubyrogers239 Před rokem +26

      The pan flag is adorable aswell. I want to learn how to crochet now

    • @bush6770
      @bush6770 Před rokem +10

      ​@@rubyrogers239The American Flag is also cute, and makes my freedom sense tingling

    • @mars_starz420
      @mars_starz420 Před 10 měsíci

      @@rubyrogers239sameee

    • @warmachine2772
      @warmachine2772 Před 8 měsíci +3

      ​@@bush6770that's definitely not an American flag bud, I like the patriotism though🇺🇸

    • @sherylisaweome
      @sherylisaweome Před 7 měsíci +1

      omg my name is violet too! (i think thats ur name cuz of ur username)

  • @ParagonChumba
    @ParagonChumba Před rokem +8

    "Somehow" : Neanderthal strapped to table in a government bunker somewhere being forced to smell bath & body works candles.

  • @___.51
    @___.51 Před rokem +548

    Sorry but there needs be an entire video about that throwaway line “they grew Neanderthal scent receptors in a lab”

    • @gillcaz
      @gillcaz Před rokem +30

      "somehow" the emperor is back

    • @RobertHouston-sf5fh
      @RobertHouston-sf5fh Před 11 měsíci +6

      C-c-c-c-clones.

    • @tellg0t090
      @tellg0t090 Před 10 měsíci +2

      Oh ya we've been able to do that for a while

    • @AffirmativeArtsOnTheRoad
      @AffirmativeArtsOnTheRoad Před 9 měsíci +1

      It sounds like something "cloning adjacent" has been done here...which
      suggests that we might need to make some decisions about how far we, as a
      global society...think we should/could/wisely ought to...take this
      "cloning" idea.

  • @yannkjelsen4311
    @yannkjelsen4311 Před rokem +313

    I guess the honey smell depends on the flowers, and the quality of honey

    • @hollygonzales1439
      @hollygonzales1439 Před rokem +9

      Yeah, honey to me has a more floral smell

    • @jturtle5318
      @jturtle5318 Před rokem +16

      ​@@hollygonzales1439that depends on what it's made from. Manukka honey smells medicinal.

    • @snicksabea
      @snicksabea Před rokem +1

      Without pesticides, it was probably awesome.

    • @jworster1979
      @jworster1979 Před rokem +9

      Clove honey is most common in the US. But grandfather had bees ans would take them to orchards to pollinate the trees; love some apple honey and other varies of honey. But make sure to get your region raw honey to help against allergies!

    • @leekestner1554
      @leekestner1554 Před rokem +1

      @@jworster1979 Tupulo Honey is supposed to be the sweetest.

  • @petrichor3797
    @petrichor3797 Před rokem +13

    My father is a beekeeper and let me tell you natural honey straight from the woods or garden smells INTENSE. It smells so strongly that every time we remove it from the apiary the whole house STINKS of honey.... Lemme tell you, there's a good reason why many beekeepers rarely if ever eat honey 😅

  • @lupomorelli7669
    @lupomorelli7669 Před rokem +11

    Omg the pan flag

    • @clairepettie
      @clairepettie Před 9 měsíci +1

      I was really enjoying Pride Dino on the fridge.

    • @nicholasneyhart396
      @nicholasneyhart396 Před 8 měsíci +2

      Oh, I thought it was the flag of Döbern, Germany. I have been there before, and I know that is the town flag. Well, there is my fact of the day, thanks.

  • @Dr.BitchCraftt
    @Dr.BitchCraftt Před 11 měsíci +29

    Respectfully Blake is becoming a fullfledged silver daddy now 🥵

  • @thorium222
    @thorium222 Před rokem +550

    Ok, hold on a second, how can anyone not notice how honey smells?

    • @2ndbrain909
      @2ndbrain909 Před rokem +15

      I have only half a sense of smell so there’s that.

    • @daddyethan
      @daddyethan Před rokem +81

      Looks like you're part neanderthal, shalom brother

    • @thorium222
      @thorium222 Před rokem +19

      @@daddyethan Well, since I am not African this is pretty much a given

    • @gaminghunt5837
      @gaminghunt5837 Před rokem +1

      @@thorium222 wait, do Indians have Neanderthal DNA?

    • @thorium222
      @thorium222 Před rokem +9

      @@gaminghunt5837 yes

  • @derisory
    @derisory Před rokem +126

    I can't help but imagine a nose growing out of a petri dish. I refuse to be corrected.

    • @MiG2880
      @MiG2880 Před 9 měsíci +2

      I don't know who you are, but i'm proud of you.

  • @psltmtir
    @psltmtir Před rokem +1

    Hi, just came across your channel and thank you so much for crediting your work! It is such a refreshing thing in these new and unfamiliar times.

  • @jordont1495
    @jordont1495 Před rokem +2

    Bro this channel is amazing, every short is amazing. Love this

  • @lavenderoh
    @lavenderoh Před rokem +373

    As a modern human not only can I smell honey but if I smell hot honey I will even run.

    • @Ryquard1
      @Ryquard1 Před rokem +9

      May i ask why?

    • @lunarmothcat
      @lunarmothcat Před rokem +13

      Run? Is it an unpleasant smell? I don't even know how hot honey smells. I imagine it would be like a regular smell but more intense... which might make it unpleasant

    • @Noookkzggwhwu
      @Noookkzggwhwu Před rokem +35

      Im really sensitive to the honey scent if you somehow manage to burn it it just smells really sickeningly strong and is gross

    • @susanne5803
      @susanne5803 Před rokem +19

      Towards or away from?

    • @lwolfstar7618
      @lwolfstar7618 Před rokem +33

      I will personally run towards. Hot honey fragrance usually means something delicious is in progress!

  • @viridiantheforest1037
    @viridiantheforest1037 Před rokem +88

    Yesterday I went to a local botanical garden and it had just rained in the morning. The smells were incredible, I had been there several times before and never had the same experience

    • @jep9092
      @jep9092 Před 10 měsíci +1

      I love geosmin

  • @highlandergrog6041
    @highlandergrog6041 Před 10 měsíci +2

    Wow! This guys eye color is breathtaking!

  • @zedmelon
    @zedmelon Před rokem +2

    I'll take
    "Bizarre Questions I Didn't Realize Need Asking"
    for a thousand, Alex.

  • @Sophakingreal
    @Sophakingreal Před rokem +96

    I think it’s funny how peppers got spicy to try a prevent things like mammals from eating them. Yet that’s the main reason we eat them lol. But even tho it failed it still worked. People love spicy stuff so peppers are kind of protected.

    • @thalassaer4137
      @thalassaer4137 Před rokem +25

      And spread out so theyre not in risk of extinction heck we even cultivated new sub species, mission failed successfully

    • @kiki_ci3880
      @kiki_ci3880 Před 10 měsíci +7

      Just like onions. Which is why they make us cry

    • @Muralidharan001
      @Muralidharan001 Před 10 měsíci

      which pepper?

    • @GLUBSCHI
      @GLUBSCHI Před 10 měsíci +1

      Task failed successfully

    • @cdm94
      @cdm94 Před 10 měsíci +4

      We also use the capsaicin for pepper spray, so I guess the pepper DID succeed...by proxy, lol

  • @morgansinclair6318
    @morgansinclair6318 Před rokem +88

    It's interesting to ponder how their cultures' cooking would differ on a basic level from our own, especially if they still survived to this day.

    • @blondbraid7986
      @blondbraid7986 Před rokem

      Neanderthals still live inside all of us. Literally, modern humans have neanderthal dna in their genome.

    • @JohnDoe-kh3ti
      @JohnDoe-kh3ti Před rokem +3

      Aren't all people from Europe and Asia partially descended from them?

    • @jakerockznoodles
      @jakerockznoodles Před rokem

      "Haha, that curry's not even that hot, bro!"

  • @prematuredgravy8033
    @prematuredgravy8033 Před rokem

    Growing odor receptors sounds like smth the Jurassic Park scientists did as a trial before they just made Dinosaurs LMAO

  • @tylerm8143
    @tylerm8143 Před rokem +3

    The Panannosaurus Rex is a nice touch

  • @toshaville
    @toshaville Před rokem +41

    You probably don't need to smell a fruit tree to know it's there, whereas the ability to smell a beehive from across a forest could be really handy. A colony of bees has a pretty strong odor anyway, so they could probably smell it for quite a ways. How interesting! Thanks!

  • @FuneralProcession
    @FuneralProcession Před rokem +17

    Modern human: Bro, are these eggs bad?
    Lab Neanderthal bro: yeah.. throw 'em out

  • @IHaveSeveralDiseases0
    @IHaveSeveralDiseases0 Před 10 měsíci +1

    With their noses. *Audience laughter sign starts blinking rapidly*

  • @squeaky1963
    @squeaky1963 Před 10 měsíci +4

    Imagine if Denisovans and Neanderthals still existed.
    Neanderthal cuisine would be extremely unpalatable except to the hardiest of hispanics and Denisovans could directly pinpoint and predict farts

  • @KimberlyGreen
    @KimberlyGreen Před rokem +61

    I wonder what evolutionary advantage better detection of sulphur had 🤔. Were those smells more prevalent in areas their remains have been found in?

    • @michaelblacktree
      @michaelblacktree Před rokem +32

      That's a good question. Maybe it helped them avoid volcanically active areas?

    • @kyrab7914
      @kyrab7914 Před rokem +18

      That is exactly what I was thinking. I dunno the denisova range tho. Another possibility could be food as well

    • @patreekotime4578
      @patreekotime4578 Před rokem +56

      To avoid rotten foods and bad water?

    • @thebird4654
      @thebird4654 Před rokem +44

      ​@@patreekotime4578 Yeah, I was thinking something along those lines, too. A lot of bad/rotten odors are sulphur-based/have sulfur in them, if I recall correctly. I'd imagine being able to detect those would be a huge evolutionary advantage.

    • @ItsAsparageese
      @ItsAsparageese Před rokem

      Sulphur is a component of the gases released by activity of many bacteria harmful to humans, from rotted food to skin infections

  • @lwolfstar7618
    @lwolfstar7618 Před rokem +27

    You didn't realise honey has a smell?!?!?!?!?! Its one of my favourite scents and flavours 😅 maybe I have those ancient genes going on

    • @Sophie-wf9zk
      @Sophie-wf9zk Před rokem

      most humans have denisovan and neanderthal DNA, so maybe? :)

  • @evanperez6686
    @evanperez6686 Před rokem +3

    I wonder if we could figure out the appetite of other extinct animals using this method

  • @burgernoodle7589
    @burgernoodle7589 Před rokem +21

    Awesome pan flag, also really interesting! 💪💪💪

    • @whats_Gaming
      @whats_Gaming Před rokem +2

      I didn't know people are in love with frying pans.

    • @BinroWasRight
      @BinroWasRight Před rokem +5

      @@whats_Gaming Insert tired old joke HERE.

    • @Schampu4000
      @Schampu4000 Před rokem +3

      ​@@whats_GamingDo you know cooking enthusiasts exist

    • @whats_Gaming
      @whats_Gaming Před rokem

      But I heard they're se xually attracted too frying pans, and they'll do anything too that poor frying pan to "enchant the taste"@@Schampu4000

  • @alanorcotch7822
    @alanorcotch7822 Před rokem +1065

    the dinosaur with the pan flag is everything
    (would you guys chill out in the replies)

    • @Merennulli
      @Merennulli Před rokem +78

      Thanks for explaining that. I was confused why it was holding a Döbern flag. I didn't realize pan had a flag.

    • @alanorcotch7822
      @alanorcotch7822 Před rokem +44

      ​@@Merennullithat pansexuality had a flag?

    • @Merennulli
      @Merennulli Před rokem +60

      @@alanorcotch7822 Yes. It's my first time seeing it.

    • @dannimonai1733
      @dannimonai1733 Před rokem +73

      Yes! I love it

    • @EmilyWood1996
      @EmilyWood1996 Před rokem +132

      AND he’s In a kitchen? Sir, stay away from the cutlery 😉🥴

  • @nerdynanny
    @nerdynanny Před rokem +16

    The Ty-PAN-asaurus Rex in the background is a welcome sight this Pride.

  • @ursadabear2810
    @ursadabear2810 Před rokem +2

    I was today years old when I finally put two and two together on the words ‘balsam’ and ‘balsamic’. Balsam sap is what gives you that classic Christmas tree smell, but because ‘balsamic’ is usually followed by ‘vinegar’ I never connected that ‘balsamic’ also means ‘related to balsam’

  • @zoemccoy7799
    @zoemccoy7799 Před rokem +8

    cute dinosaur plush with the pansexual flag!

  • @Haeresiarchonte
    @Haeresiarchonte Před rokem +55

    I ain't no scientist but I'm pretty sure Neanderthals smelled with their noses.

  • @liyostr570
    @liyostr570 Před 13 dny

    Excellent intro 😂 i love floral smells and the smells of trees and stuff i cant imagine being even less sensitive to them than i currently am

  • @chillycanuck2566
    @chillycanuck2566 Před 10 měsíci +13

    Love the pan tyrannosaurus

  • @AkaedatheLogtoad
    @AkaedatheLogtoad Před rokem +11

    What about sight? This is really interesting

  • @bryanabbott6169
    @bryanabbott6169 Před rokem +20

    My high school biology teacher let us try out an experiment on ourselves, dealing with be able to detect a certain taste. We were given a pill with an ingredient (it's been a few decades, so I don't remember what it was) that a few people could detect (thanks to genes).
    I was one of the few who did in the class, but I'd reckon that how strongly you could taste it was also affected by your genes. Anyways, it was slightly bitter to me.

    • @wildliferox2
      @wildliferox2 Před rokem +3

      Just looking at Genomes doesn't give you the full picture. Despite the same genomes, Women more likely to be Supertasters, better sense of smell and hearing than men.

    • @bryanabbott6169
      @bryanabbott6169 Před rokem +5

      @@wildliferox2 It wasn't about being this 'Supertaster, champion of Tastopolis', but being able to detect a chemical by taste. There were only a few boys and girls who could detect the chemical, I was one of them.
      Taste is a sense that is highly dependent on another sense, smell, to function properly. I used to have a high level sense of smell, but I was stuck with cleaning up messes and the cat litter, so I had to suppress my sense of smell to do so. I also developed a deviated septum in my sinus cavity. My sense of smell and taste had dropped since then.

    • @eldritchyarnbeing3295
      @eldritchyarnbeing3295 Před rokem +6

      @@bryanabbott6169i remember doing this as well in biology class and it tasted so nasty😖 it was funny seeing some people yelling about "how can you not taste that!" because it was so bitter it made me gag

    • @cocobutter3175
      @cocobutter3175 Před rokem +2

      I remember something like this, but it was a strip of paper with a chemical, and most people could taste it. I was the only one without receptors to taste it. So I was the only one who didn't get a piece of candy to deal with the taste afterwards. Also the only diabetic in class. Which was a weird coincidence that makes me think about that moment to this day. Whatever this chemical was was acrid rather than bitter.

  • @MkJeezy2007
    @MkJeezy2007 Před 8 měsíci +3

    I NOTICED THE DINOSAUR HOLDING A PAN FLAG IN YOUR BACKGROUND OMFG I LOVE IT

  • @dclomg5
    @dclomg5 Před rokem +4

    I trust this guy. I'm not sure why? He just seems like he does nothing but spit facts.

  • @scottd.1700
    @scottd.1700 Před rokem +62

    Being able to smell sweet and woody scents really well might imply that they relied heavily on a tree foraging lifestyle.
    Nuts, termites, and honey might have been the main part of their diet.

    • @bluebeesmarple
      @bluebeesmarple Před rokem +8

      yes! they were very knowledgeable in medicinal plants and even had midwives to assisting in birthing, sulfur and honey are super useful in medicine!

    • @apeking7099
      @apeking7099 Před rokem +3

      There's also been found alot of starch on Neanderthal teeth in Spain

    • @ZoiusGM
      @ZoiusGM Před rokem +2

      ​@@bluebeesmarpleIf they were knowledgeable about medicinal plants, and if what the guy in the video says is true then that means that they were knowledgeable about something that they couldn't smell well.

  • @scottm2664
    @scottm2664 Před rokem +62

    Happy Pride. I have the same flag up outside…..

    • @MagicBaldMushroom
      @MagicBaldMushroom Před rokem +5

      Maybe pay attention to what he's actually saying in the vide instead of focusing on this man's sex life

    • @scottm2664
      @scottm2664 Před rokem +31

      @@MagicBaldMushroom or maybe do some research and discover that the flag is for PAN people which if you Google you’ll find HES PAN. So don’t speak out of turn unless you know your facts.

    • @willydilly9020
      @willydilly9020 Před rokem +22

      ​@@MagicBaldMushroomUnlike you, some people can do more than one thing at once.

    • @MagicBaldMushroom
      @MagicBaldMushroom Před 11 měsíci +2

      This is hilarious, people getting so offended by a little opinion

    • @coltonmartin5057
      @coltonmartin5057 Před 11 měsíci

      ​@@MagicBaldMushroomno one brought up his sex life. Only you did. Stop thinking about how this person has sex you weirdo!

  • @Splattercat_art
    @Splattercat_art Před rokem +2

    That’s such an interesting way to figure out what an extinct species ate! I would have never thought about sense of smell as a factor

  • @redandblue1013
    @redandblue1013 Před 11 měsíci +4

    It’s insane that we can analyse the smelling abilities of an extinct species of humans tens of thousands of years ago

  • @LeopardMask12
    @LeopardMask12 Před rokem +9

    Bit of a tangent, but what happened to the H in Neanderthal? I've noticed people pronouncing it differently for a while but this is the first time I've noticed it spelled without the H as well. Is it a cultural/language thing related to the language we created the word from?

    • @jturtle5318
      @jturtle5318 Před rokem +11

      The German name for the valley in Germany where they were discovered is pronounced without the H".
      It had been Anglicized for many years, but that's the original.

  • @EmonWBKstudios
    @EmonWBKstudios Před rokem +32

    Better than an anime convention smelled like.

  • @stxdude830
    @stxdude830 Před rokem +1

    Sulfur for rotting meat? Wood sense for foraging? Etc

  • @m3alw0rmss
    @m3alw0rmss Před rokem +1

    "honey i got you a rose"
    "tf do I do with this"

    • @Hood_mf
      @Hood_mf Před 2 měsíci

      They can still like how it looks Ur not going up to the rose u got and smelling it constantly

  • @thomashughes_teh
    @thomashughes_teh Před rokem +16

    When I was a kid if the windows were open I always knew when the neighbor was putting honey in her tea. The smell is different than when it goes on toast or the lid is left off the jar.

    • @NighttimeDaydreams
      @NighttimeDaydreams Před 9 měsíci +2

      Yes, it's like... The scent of honey, carried by steam plus the smell of chamomile or whatever

  • @juliocasim4330
    @juliocasim4330 Před rokem +4

    I really love watching PBS-eons i learn a lot about science

  • @divalea
    @divalea Před rokem +1

    The Giles to our Scooby Gang.

  • @murphmanin
    @murphmanin Před rokem +2

    Living in the wild heightens all the senses that are needed for survival. They probably had better eye sight especially at night too. Prob for that reason and the fact they didn’t have all this man made light either

  • @brynadoodle
    @brynadoodle Před rokem +10

    No wayyy pan pride flag behind!!! Hell yeah ❤ the short is fantastic as well of course!!

    • @trogo3402
      @trogo3402 Před rokem +7

      Yes. He is in a kitchen. There are pans there

  • @sapphodyl
    @sapphodyl Před rokem +6

    Awh, the second source link is broken 😢
    Love this vid!! Thanks for sharing cool science news.

  • @FuneralProcession
    @FuneralProcession Před 9 měsíci +1

    Smells neanderthal arm pit: Hmm.. its earthy.. what the heck!..
    Neanderthal: Now smell my finger 😅

  • @anderssicker2651
    @anderssicker2651 Před rokem +6

    i love the t-rex with pan pride, so cute, also great video

  • @Burn_Angel
    @Burn_Angel Před rokem +11

    Does that mean Neanderthals relied less on foraging than us, thus implying they had a mostly carnivorous diet?

    • @bluebeesmarple
      @bluebeesmarple Před rokem +1

      no, they knew and foraged a wider variety of plants and medicinal herbs actually

  • @chubbydinosaur9148
    @chubbydinosaur9148 Před rokem +36

    Dude... I was fine a minute ago and now I have like a good dozen of questions!

    • @darkblonde4791
      @darkblonde4791 Před rokem +1

      The whole receptor? The whole sensory organ? The whole...

    • @duckqueak
      @duckqueak Před rokem

      Thats science for you!

  • @nondisclosureable
    @nondisclosureable Před rokem +1

    The scent Balsamic being referenced is that of Balsam Pine not Balsamic vineger.

  • @_Thorfinn_karlsefni_
    @_Thorfinn_karlsefni_ Před rokem +1

    Those receptors also allowed them to know what not to eat and if predators were coming I think they reacted more to sulfur because well it's not edible and honey because while it is nutritious they would have to deal with bees so knowing when honey is around is also knowing when danger is around

  • @godlessqueertheywarnedyouabout

    Shout out to the pansexual T-Rex

    • @MagicBaldMushroom
      @MagicBaldMushroom Před rokem +3

      Just pay attention to the video and stop focusing on this poor t-rex's sex life

    • @taylorblazi1580
      @taylorblazi1580 Před rokem +27

      ​@HairlessLittleLass bold of you to assume people can't focus on both. Even bolder to tell various people in this comment section what they SHOULD be focusing on (as if it really matters). If the Pan flag aspect isn't the point of the video as you insist on reminding everyone here, then why are YOU so focused on it?

    • @swordinthestone313
      @swordinthestone313 Před 11 měsíci +3

      ​@HairlessLittleLass Sex life? Tf you sexualizing him for? Super sus, dude

    • @cletusmcfetus
      @cletusmcfetus Před 11 měsíci +1

      ​@@swordinthestone313maybe the flag that represents a sexuality idk though

    • @swordinthestone313
      @swordinthestone313 Před 11 měsíci +5

      @@cletusmcfetus You can literally be asexual and pansexual at the same time. Romance doesn't equal sex. You're being weird.

  • @babs_babs
    @babs_babs Před rokem +23

    the world for sure smelled different back then. car fumes weren’t everywhere

    • @revearain7692
      @revearain7692 Před rokem

      Same as Neanderthal ass and feet and bo
      Lots of methane lots of it.

  • @IberianCraftsman
    @IberianCraftsman Před rokem +2

    so its like a polar bear vs a grizzly bear, we are the grizzlies with more fruit in our diet while they probably were more meat oriented.

  • @Sophie-wf9zk
    @Sophie-wf9zk Před rokem +1

    i imagine they reconstructed the receptors based on the analogous gene coding regions to our receptors, cell culture is pretty cool and can do some crazy stuff if your scientists are talented enough

  • @limerence8365
    @limerence8365 Před rokem +13

    Sulfur is a weird smell cuz it smells like rotten eggs and when I went on holidays to Iceland I smelt it a lot but it didn't smell bad. I actually kind of liked it. This must be a me problem cuz I also find the smell of fish and cow pats comforting cuz they remind of my childhood holidays home which makes sense on paper but they're still bad smells.

    • @DiscoDevil197
      @DiscoDevil197 Před rokem +3

      Its not the smell thats weird, you are

    • @SteveMND
      @SteveMND Před rokem +9

      Oddly, I feel the same way about the smell of chlorine. When I was a kid, my parents owned a little beachside motel, and one of my earliest chores was checking the chlorine levels of the motel pool, and as such, it has stuck as a reminder of happy childhood summers, even 40 years later.

    • @nealjroberts4050
      @nealjroberts4050 Před rokem +13

      Smell is strongly associated with emotional memories.

    • @ghoo283
      @ghoo283 Před rokem +1

      Fish odours let me gag, funny how we all differ. I can eat fish only if it is prepared by someone else.

    • @sinephase
      @sinephase Před rokem +2

      sulfur is in a lot of things you wouldn't consider "bad" smelling though and is an integral part of how they smell and taste

  • @megansfo
    @megansfo Před rokem +4

    It's astounding to me that scientists can even know this! Amazing.

  • @medical_muscle_greg
    @medical_muscle_greg Před 9 měsíci

    Love this channel! Keep up this great content

  • @rachel_Cochran
    @rachel_Cochran Před rokem +4

    WHYYYY CAN'T I WORK IN THIS FIELD??? being a nurse sucks man, this is all so much more interesting

    • @mihaitavraciu2248
      @mihaitavraciu2248 Před 9 měsíci

      Blame that on past you who wanted to work in the medical field ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

  • @ramieyon995
    @ramieyon995 Před rokem +6

    Too all the folks who can't snell honey...
    Y'all are missing out.

    • @megansfo
      @megansfo Před rokem +1

      I don't really like the taste or smell of honey, and certainly not the sticky texture. 🐝

    • @ramieyon995
      @ramieyon995 Před rokem

      @@megansfo Ohhhh

  • @RetroHoo
    @RetroHoo Před rokem +3

    This is so interesting! I would love to learn more about this (sense analysis based of genome analysis)

  • @RisqueRique
    @RisqueRique Před 10 měsíci +1

    They grew their olfactory receptors?? Science is awesome man

  • @metalman7825
    @metalman7825 Před rokem

    TLDR; we outcompeted out extinct cousins because of our superior flower smelling skillz.

  • @meribor
    @meribor Před rokem +34

    Loving the Pan Pride flag in the background!

    • @MagicBaldMushroom
      @MagicBaldMushroom Před rokem

      This dude is saying really cool stuff about Neanderthals and the only thing you noticed is his sex life?

    • @joshuadoty4682
      @joshuadoty4682 Před rokem +8

      @@MagicBaldMushroomyou are obsessed dude

    • @rivviegobrr714
      @rivviegobrr714 Před rokem +1

      ​@@MagicBaldMushroombro you literally stalked the comments to be homophobic get a life 💀💀💀

  • @kevincronk7981
    @kevincronk7981 Před rokem +5

    Wait they can grow parts of neanderthals and denisovans? I'd imagine growing an entire organism is a whole different ball game, but does that mean they could individually grow each part of the body of a neanderthal or denisovan? We could learn so much about them from that

    • @garethhughes7430
      @garethhughes7430 Před rokem

      Growing an organism has been done before... Would a homo sapiens egg implanted with caveman DNA take? We shouldn't, but we totally should, should we?

  • @hannahbonanza1075
    @hannahbonanza1075 Před rokem +1

    How different were the floral smells & flowers, before people started cross breeding and changing them too I wonder?

  • @ethanlackey8048
    @ethanlackey8048 Před rokem +7

    I can’t even really smell flowers, they just smell like sickly wet is the best I can describe.

  • @Eatingguy
    @Eatingguy Před rokem +7

    I never thought of that question but this is interesting

  • @sarmadhabibkhan3036
    @sarmadhabibkhan3036 Před 7 měsíci

    Learning the type of scents they were popular too also gives us an idea for what type of foods they preferred compared to us. If Neanderthals had more sensitive smell receptors for honey, that means that honey was probably a popular food source for them. Meanwhile, our adaptation to greens, floral and spicy scents probably means that we preferred going after fruits and vegetables as a popular food source.

  • @mushroomdude6893
    @mushroomdude6893 Před rokem +1

    This is really cool as someone who lost their sense of smell early on in life. I wonder if these ancient civilizations had a better sense of smell then we do now.

  • @Mohotashi
    @Mohotashi Před rokem +4

    Pansexual Tyrannosaurus 😊

  • @Aztesticals
    @Aztesticals Před rokem +3

    Wernt denisovians frequently found along eastern siberia, southeast asia and indonesia. There are many heavily active volcanic systems in kamchatka indonesia the Phillipines, many volcanoc islands and much of the coastal areas are near at least 1 volcano. Coulf sulfur sensitivity allowed people to avoid living near active systems

  • @FUBARGunpla
    @FUBARGunpla Před rokem +1

    That sulfur would i assume mean better distinguishing of rotten meats and foods along side those other smells

  • @melohsparks313
    @melohsparks313 Před rokem +2

    Why does the balsamic part make so much sense lol

  • @ganonsbaker3026
    @ganonsbaker3026 Před rokem +35

    So they partially resurrected an ancient guy and had him sniff some stuff

  • @marghiecanas9744
    @marghiecanas9744 Před rokem +77

    ultra thank you for the pan flag detail, it made me love your channel ever MORE omg :_)

    • @PizzaManager101
      @PizzaManager101 Před rokem +18

      Right? Love subtle details that show theyre *at least* an ally

    • @MagicBaldMushroom
      @MagicBaldMushroom Před rokem +13

      Why is this man's sexuality making you more fond of him and his channel? What should his sexuality have to do with anything? It certainly shouldn't taint your perception of him, whether it's positive or negative, because a person's sexuality doesn't make up who they are and you definitely shouldn't judge them based off of it AT ALL

    • @joshuadoty4682
      @joshuadoty4682 Před rokem +1

      @@MagicBaldMushroomoh nvm you’re just a homophobe

    • @MrGoldfish8
      @MrGoldfish8 Před rokem +31

      ​@@MagicBaldMushroomIt's not about the sexuality, it's the solidarity in the face of marginalisation you pretend doesn't happen.

    • @ShawnUhlenhake
      @ShawnUhlenhake Před rokem +6

      this comment made me want to dig my eyes out with a fishing hook

  • @digitalharmony26
    @digitalharmony26 Před rokem +1

    Science is fascinating, answering all the questions I never thought I wanted answered. Also love the pan Dino in the background!

  • @csmac3144a
    @csmac3144a Před rokem +1

    That's fascinating -- ingenious science.

  • @Robynhoodlum
    @Robynhoodlum Před rokem +21

    I think they mean balsamic as in balsa wood, not vinegary like the dressing.

  • @snpdrg0n
    @snpdrg0n Před rokem +12

    I am also a pan dino lol 💗💛💙

  • @justanotheropinion5832
    @justanotheropinion5832 Před rokem +3

    Cool! Now do sight. Did they see the same blue as we see it?

    • @BinroWasRight
      @BinroWasRight Před rokem +1

      Probably not. Even modern humans have been slow to recognize blue as a distinct color. Various tribal societies have had their vision tested and see blues as greens (and they have a much wider palette of green hues than we do). In The Oddssey, Homer described the ocean as oînops póntos, or "wine-dark." Implying the ancient Greeks saw the sea in reddish hues, probably. Science and linguistics are so cool 🙂.

    • @Hood_mf
      @Hood_mf Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@BinroWasRightthey don't tho

    • @Hood_mf
      @Hood_mf Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@BinroWasRightnobody on the planet sees the blue in Ur pfp as green 💚💙 look pretty different to me

    • @Hood_mf
      @Hood_mf Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@BinroWasRightyh and I bet they saw purples as red too 😂

  • @gunnerdavidson7287
    @gunnerdavidson7287 Před 10 měsíci +3

    With their noses

  • @LandkreuzerPRatte-ov1rc
    @LandkreuzerPRatte-ov1rc Před rokem +3

    All these years and a small piece of our extinct relatives came back

  • @DaveTexas
    @DaveTexas Před rokem +2

    Can we grow me some smell receptors? I lost my sense of smell (well, most of it) in childhood after a number of sinus surgeries left me with scar tissue lining my nasal passages. I can detect odors if they’re really powerful, but that’s about it. Has science finally advanced to the point where I could be able to determine if milk has gone bad without tasting it?

    • @jturtle5318
      @jturtle5318 Před rokem

      Yes.
      Add some of the milk to hot coffee. If it's bad it will curdle.