@@stanman6576I also saw it. It is good and certainly better than army of the dead. I rate it a 7.5 because I just wish there wad more time with the characters.
@@stanman6576 do not listen to the scores. It is a good movie. It is not excellent but it’s good. Far better than anything star-wars had put out in the last decade.
@@stanman6576 yeah I saw it. I liked it. I like when Zack does slow motion. However, I will say in this movie there’s a lot of slow motion probably too much ha. Even so, this movie is bad ass bro
Simply put. People these days have zero attention spans unless they can binge 3 seasons of one show on the spot. And for some reason people like that don't like watching movies that are that long. It makes no sense but that's how they think and it's just been something I've been trying to accept.
It's been years since I gave two shits about 'critics' scores. They hate what I love and apparently hate me too. I only ever pay attention to audience reviews. I find it interesting however, looking at the 'audience' scores, roughly four out of five scores give it a five star rating, sometimes a four. There are almost no twos and threes. However about one in five audience reviews score it with one star. Interestingly several of those one star reviews are accompanied by comments about how people are spamming reviews who haven't seen the movie yet, because it isn't out yet! Well if those idiots think that reviews are being spammed because they think people can't have seen the movie yet, what does it say about 'their' one star reviews?
Lol hack Snyder cultist. Hack Snyder cultist where targeting Taika waititi by flexing rt scores and critics reviews done by same critics. But now are crying it's fake. Dumb this are the same critics that reviewed thor4. If they are fake then that makes Thor 4 masterpiece 😂😂 Hack Snyder cultist will always play victim card for their master's movie.
The Star Wars influence is totally expected as it was originally penned as a Star Wars movie. I haven't actually seen the movie yet as I plan to watch both movies back to back like I always do with the Hellraiser 1&2 movies. However, I must admit I am a Snyder fan so I might be a little biased.
Not a Snyder fan here… why does this guy always have to have a directors cut even when he has complete control? It’s almost like he can’t create a concise and enjoyable movie without having hours and hours of your time.
Millennial buzz words: slow burn, pacing. Translation: impatient or ADHD. If your preferred "pacing" is an issue, youd better avoid the much longer directors cut he has verified will be released.
He didn't write the script by himself right? Didn't Shay Hatten(John wick 3 and 4) and Kurt Johnstad (300 rise, Atomic Blonde, Act of Valor) help write drafts as well?
You're 1 of a few who have anything positive to say about this movie. Everyone else is roasting it badly. I may or may not watch this it doesnt seem all that interesting to me.
Lol hack Snyder cultist will always play victim card. Man this cultist were targeting Taika waititi by flexing same Critics reviews but now are saying they just gave negative reviews due to being Snyder movie 😂 The critics that reviewed Thor 4 and Rebel moon are same. By your saying all the critics were joining on hate train while reviewing thor 4😂 Grow up and accept hack Snyder movies are either mid or garbage.
I really wanted to like this, the look is badass, the characters are okay-ish, the villain is blah. It really does feel like TEMU Star Wars 100%. If they would have gone more ....Firefly and just have fun but everyone is dead serious, everyone looks like a Greek god, everyone is shrouded in plot armor,everyone is the best fighter in the galaxy or absolute master at everything. The only way you'll have fun watching this is if somebody is giving you a $100,000 bucks as it's on screen.
Happy birthday mate! I knew absolutely nothing about this I was like oh that new Sci-Fi is dropped, watched it completely enjoyed it, knowing obviously it wasn't complete part 1 etc... then reading the reviews it's like wtf is wrong with critics these days. I'm no slouch, but seriously talk about a disconnect between audiences reactions and the demands of critics so obviously don't get enough air time and are just pretty miserable most of their lives I have to assume l😂 And I guess people just forget what an awful writer George Lucas was with respect to dialogue eh?
I can tell you where exactly where he has stole EVERY idea for this show. Unbelievably predictable, hackish and lacking originality. I have to admit, The Magnificent 7/The Seven Samurai/ Battle Beyond the Stars in space is an interesting concept, but it is just executed poorly here. Very disappointing. Now I know why Lucas Films turned this screenplay down.
Zach seems to have forgotten the cardinal rule of film making, "SHOW! DON"'T TELL!" It was very boring. You have to grab your audience within the first 30 seconds to one minute mark. Something has to happen within that time frame and nothing did. I love Zach, but I just don't think he has the writing chops.
Ok thank you Chris my expectations for this film is neutral I'm just going in on a neutral level I'll still check it out and get my final verdict on it
The writing. Here we are again with Snyder's achilles heel. Trying to forge a new IP. For a start KUDOS to him for trying to do so, new IP's are desperately needed. To do that though you've got to have the right people at the top of their game. The world buiding, how you handle the exposition, characterisation work. It's HARD haha. Is Snyder the right person to take that beast on? I don't know man haha. Good review. Objective review.
he had the john wick writer work on this. My thing is snyder knows how to film something; He just needs to take a break and get a lot of people to review his scripts before he decideds to shoot anything.
I can see that. this is the problem with film today. Story, dialogue and characters are mid, but the visuals are outstanding. I much prefer dialogue and story now. ZS gave me 300 tho and I am forever grateful.
I feel like they shot themselves in the foot with the Netflix cut. Like I know 2 hour films do better on the platform, but bad word of mouth isn't going to help anything. But not sure if the director's cut can overcome all the excessive exposition
@landonweldy5468 obviously NOT. Statistics demands we take the larger sample size, not the smaller sample size. For every single field you can name. Here is an assignment for you: find a case where a smaller sample size was preferred over a larger sample size, all things being equal.
@@nosuchthing8 But all things are NOT equal. For a streaming movie, audiences don't even have to prove they've seen the movie. And you'll get people giving it a 10 for no reason other than it being a Snyder film, and you'll get people giving it a 0 for the same reason. We live in the age of the review bomb, for good or for bad. The one thing I will say in favor of audience scores is that they CAN be more representative of the actual consumer-- reviewers don't necessarily want to see the film, whereas the audience doesn't see it unless they do. At the end of the day I just don't care about the score itself. Say a film has a 90% score, but you look closer and everyone gave it a 6/10. Not a very good movie in my book. Mass appeal, sure. But that's still an F. Don't get me wrong, I want to like this movie. But when every review says it looks good but is like watching an encyclopedia entry, I don't get excited.
@landonweldy5468 you made some good points. But you have to consider human nature. Suppose the movie in question was a saw like movie. If I HAD to review it, I would give it low marks. Because I don't like that type of movie. People tend to be siloed. Some don't like animation, or sexy, or world war two, etc movies. My concern with listening to the critics is that it's very possible mant don't like the genre. And give a bad review for that reason. Ignoring the people that never saw RM, at least most of them made a conscious effort to see the movie. They had an expectation to enjoy the genre. Which speaks volumes.
Best not to mention the rumor of an alternate cut when it comes to a Snyder movie. I can forgive you for not being aware but It just becomes this whole thing. Ha. Just having some fun. I appreciate the honest review. A little disappointing as it seems most reviews say similar.
Snyder - exposition and then we should feel something about it, what a good director would do in interaction and dialogue with the characters but hey it looks good if you like the look of his movie full of blurred stuff and an unfocused background and overuse of slow-motion. So it is again the worst of Snyder and if you don't love even what he is good at - pictures then a definite no. No thanks another trash.
"i had a lot of fun with it" and "but the story" you lack consistency here buddy. if you enjoyed the movie the story held up. when a movie fails due to story that is not a comedy then you will not have fun.
No, he has egged on his toxic fan base. I don't feel sorry for him because of that. I do feel sorry for him because of what happened to his child, but not because of his hack film director career.
This movie was epic! I cannot wait for part 2!
@@stanman6576I also saw it. It is good and certainly better than army of the dead. I rate it a 7.5 because I just wish there wad more time with the characters.
@@stanman6576 do not listen to the scores. It is a good movie. It is not excellent but it’s good. Far better than anything star-wars had put out in the last decade.
@@stanman6576 yeah I saw it. I liked it. I like when Zack does slow motion. However, I will say in this movie there’s a lot of slow motion probably too much ha. Even so, this movie is bad ass bro
1 out of 4 reviewers liked it. Some REALLY liked it. Maybe you will too.@@stanman6576
@@gyaweroissah7960lol no, its very bad😂
Love the review, love all the vlogs! What an epic time we had - so great to finally meet and get to know each other properly. Until next time mate 💙
I'm going to wait to watch this on Christmas day. I always love watching a new movie on Christmas and I think this is the perfect choice.
I just wish he released the extended cut now. Like why release a shortened cut when it's not even going to theatres
They don’t call him Hack for nothing.
Because Netflix told him long movies don't get top views on the platform
It is going to be in some theaters
Simply put. People these days have zero attention spans unless they can binge 3 seasons of one show on the spot. And for some reason people like that don't like watching movies that are that long. It makes no sense but that's how they think and it's just been something I've been trying to accept.
@@Booty_Crum people saw Oppenheimer John wick 4 and end game lol.
It's been years since I gave two shits about 'critics' scores. They hate what I love and apparently hate me too. I only ever pay attention to audience reviews.
I find it interesting however, looking at the 'audience' scores, roughly four out of five scores give it a five star rating, sometimes a four. There are almost no twos and threes. However about one in five audience reviews score it with one star. Interestingly several of those one star reviews are accompanied by comments about how people are spamming reviews who haven't seen the movie yet, because it isn't out yet!
Well if those idiots think that reviews are being spammed because they think people can't have seen the movie yet, what does it say about 'their' one star reviews?
Lol hack Snyder cultist.
Hack Snyder cultist where targeting Taika waititi by flexing rt scores and critics reviews done by same critics. But now are crying it's fake. Dumb this are the same critics that reviewed thor4. If they are fake then that makes Thor 4 masterpiece 😂😂
Hack Snyder cultist will always play victim card for their master's movie.
The Star Wars influence is totally expected as it was originally penned as a Star Wars movie. I haven't actually seen the movie yet as I plan to watch both movies back to back like I always do with the Hellraiser 1&2 movies. However, I must admit I am a Snyder fan so I might be a little biased.
REBEL MOON 1 week 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Not a Snyder fan here… why does this guy always have to have a directors cut even when he has complete control? It’s almost like he can’t create a concise and enjoyable movie without having hours and hours of your time.
Millennial buzz words: slow burn, pacing. Translation: impatient or ADHD.
If your preferred "pacing" is an issue, youd better avoid the much longer directors cut he has verified will be released.
He didn't write the script by himself right? Didn't Shay Hatten(John wick 3 and 4) and Kurt Johnstad (300 rise, Atomic Blonde, Act of Valor) help write drafts as well?
You're 1 of a few who have anything positive to say about this movie. Everyone else is roasting it badly. I may or may not watch this it doesnt seem all that interesting to me.
to be fair star wars isnt original eather was inspired by john carter , dune , flash gorden and western and samurai films
Also the Valerian and Laureline comics by Pierre Christin.
And? It's more iconic 😂
@@user-bt9yh8jn1qdoesnt make it original. You sound like columbus right now
@@BLACKSTA361 and? Star Wars more iconic
And its way different than what Lucas originally wrote
Children of Fire, Chaos Born is a title by Drew Karpyshyn. ZS should get with Drew. They would rock it.
Thank you for a respectful review; and for not just jumping on the hate train.
Lol hack Snyder cultist will always play victim card.
Man this cultist were targeting Taika waititi by flexing same Critics reviews but now are saying they just gave negative reviews due to being Snyder movie 😂
The critics that reviewed Thor 4 and Rebel moon are same. By your saying all the critics were joining on hate train while reviewing thor 4😂
Grow up and accept hack Snyder movies are either mid or garbage.
I really wanted to like this, the look is badass, the characters are okay-ish, the villain is blah.
It really does feel like TEMU Star Wars 100%.
If they would have gone more ....Firefly and just have fun but everyone is dead serious, everyone looks like a Greek god, everyone is shrouded in plot armor,everyone is the best fighter in the galaxy or absolute master at everything.
The only way you'll have fun watching this is if somebody is giving you a $100,000 bucks as it's on screen.
Happy birthday mate! I knew absolutely nothing about this I was like oh that new Sci-Fi is dropped, watched it completely enjoyed it, knowing obviously it wasn't complete part 1 etc... then reading the reviews it's like wtf is wrong with critics these days. I'm no slouch, but seriously talk about a disconnect between audiences reactions and the demands of critics so obviously don't get enough air time and are just pretty miserable most of their lives I have to assume l😂
And I guess people just forget what an awful writer George Lucas was with respect to dialogue eh?
I can tell you where exactly where he has stole EVERY idea for this show. Unbelievably predictable, hackish and lacking originality. I have to admit, The Magnificent 7/The Seven Samurai/ Battle Beyond the Stars in space is an interesting concept, but it is just executed poorly here. Very disappointing. Now I know why Lucas Films turned this screenplay down.
Chris, Thank you! I always appreciate a honest review. I don't trust someone who loved everything. No bathtub review?😂
any idea why snyder doesn't have a writing partner after all this time?
Kurt Johnstad Shay Hatten.
They are the Co Writers of this Movie
Zach seems to have forgotten the cardinal rule of film making, "SHOW! DON"'T TELL!" It was very boring. You have to grab your audience within the first 30 seconds to one minute mark. Something has to happen within that time frame and nothing did. I love Zach, but I just don't think he has the writing chops.
great review!!
Your Batman cosplays Been epic wanna say first am normally a Spider-Man cosplayer working on my own Batman cosplay and yeah rebel Moon looks amazing
Ok thank you Chris my expectations for this film is neutral I'm just going in on a neutral level I'll still check it out and get my final verdict on it
The writing. Here we are again with Snyder's achilles heel. Trying to forge a new IP. For a start KUDOS to him for trying to do so, new IP's are desperately needed. To do that though you've got to have the right people at the top of their game. The world buiding, how you handle the exposition, characterisation work. It's HARD haha. Is Snyder the right person to take that beast on? I don't know man haha. Good review. Objective review.
he had the john wick writer work on this. My thing is snyder knows how to film something; He just needs to take a break and get a lot of people to review his scripts before he decideds to shoot anything.
Loved it. Third time watching it. Fave scene with the droid and the girl. Touching. I've heard it compared to a bugs life lmao
I saw it in a theater in Austin. It was incredible
I honestly feel like Snyder is at his worst when he does original movies and writers the story of said movie.
Why they released a bad cut is beyond me it’s Napoleon all over again lol.
It’s not the worst thing I’ve seen.
I think it will be released in a few theaters in the USA.
I can see that. this is the problem with film today. Story, dialogue and characters are mid, but the visuals are outstanding. I much prefer dialogue and story now. ZS gave me 300 tho and I am forever grateful.
Dont forget movies are visual media.zack likes to use visual story telling and people mostly dont get that
@@bigben9056 Nah it's not people that are the problem. A lot of movies use "show don't tell" exceptionally.
He just doesn't know how to go about it.
When he said the fight scenes aren't really brutal I knew this movie is a waste of time. A wasted opportunity, shame on you Netflix.
I need to say Zack Snyder like you say Zack Snyder…by saying Snoidahh
I'm a Syfy junky, and all I want from every Syfy is a good movie. to say and compare it to other movies., so what
I cannot wait
Audience score is at 73%
The story and the dialogue are the problem but I had fun looking at lights flickering on the screen lol
You Coming in Different Accounts and Putting comments against Snyder 😂😂😂😂
man , You have a Lot of Freetime
I would love to see Zack be someone elses cinematographer.
Lets GO!!!!!!!
I feel like they shot themselves in the foot with the Netflix cut. Like I know 2 hour films do better on the platform, but bad word of mouth isn't going to help anything. But not sure if the director's cut can overcome all the excessive exposition
80% on rt is bad word of mouth? 😂
@@nosuchthing8 Audience score on RT is almost as meaningless as critic score
@landonweldy5468 obviously NOT. Statistics demands we take the larger sample size, not the smaller sample size.
For every single field you can name.
Here is an assignment for you: find a case where a smaller sample size was preferred over a larger sample size, all things being equal.
@@nosuchthing8 But all things are NOT equal. For a streaming movie, audiences don't even have to prove they've seen the movie. And you'll get people giving it a 10 for no reason other than it being a Snyder film, and you'll get people giving it a 0 for the same reason. We live in the age of the review bomb, for good or for bad.
The one thing I will say in favor of audience scores is that they CAN be more representative of the actual consumer-- reviewers don't necessarily want to see the film, whereas the audience doesn't see it unless they do.
At the end of the day I just don't care about the score itself. Say a film has a 90% score, but you look closer and everyone gave it a 6/10. Not a very good movie in my book. Mass appeal, sure. But that's still an F.
Don't get me wrong, I want to like this movie. But when every review says it looks good but is like watching an encyclopedia entry, I don't get excited.
@landonweldy5468 you made some good points. But you have to consider human nature.
Suppose the movie in question was a saw like movie. If I HAD to review it, I would give it low marks. Because I don't like that type of movie.
People tend to be siloed. Some don't like animation, or sexy, or world war two, etc movies.
My concern with listening to the critics is that it's very possible mant don't like the genre. And give a bad review for that reason.
Ignoring the people that never saw RM, at least most of them made a conscious effort to see the movie. They had an expectation to enjoy the genre. Which speaks volumes.
Best not to mention the rumor of an alternate cut when it comes to a Snyder movie. I can forgive you for not being aware but It just becomes this whole thing.
Ha. Just having some fun. I appreciate the honest review. A little disappointing as it seems most reviews say similar.
Solid review
Disney must be really, really worried. Plenty of Disney Dollars trues to sink the film, that's going to back fire.
Snyder - exposition and then we should feel something about it, what a good director would do in interaction and dialogue with the characters but hey it looks good if you like the look of his movie full of blurred stuff and an unfocused background and overuse of slow-motion.
So it is again the worst of Snyder and if you don't love even what he is good at - pictures then a definite no. No thanks another trash.
"i had a lot of fun with it" and "but the story" you lack consistency here buddy. if you enjoyed the movie the story held up. when a movie fails due to story that is not a comedy then you will not have fun.
No, he has egged on his toxic fan base. I don't feel sorry for him because of that. I do feel sorry for him because of what happened to his child, but not because of his hack film director career.
he did also direct watchmen which is the best comic book film ever
He didn't egg on anybody. His film Career has been great.
@@thewitcherking937 exactly there’s no point hiding from admitting he knows how to make great films, he’s just lost his way a bit
Just saw it… had to walk out like 30 min in. Dialogue was too cringey for me. Super derivative
😂😂😂😂😂😂
We Believe you 😂😂😂😂
Now Go Cry to Bed 😂
FYI : Cry Again Nazi , Trump is not going to win 2024😂😂😂
Look kids, a 2000-era Sci Fi Channel movie…oh wow. 😐
boring
What's his ridiculous accent? Australian? Hurts my ears.
What's your ridiculous comment? It hurts my IQ