Cooler Master NR200: Liquid vs Air Cooling Summary
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 09. 2024
- The Cooler Master NR200 is a very versatile case when it comes to cooling. After seeing how liquid AIOs and higher end air coolers perform, it's time to get some recommendations on the applicable user categories. I also show some testing with a higher end CPU and GPU.
Links for products mentioned- as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases:
The Case:
CoolerMaster NR200: amzn.to/2FxMqSU
Air Coolers:
Noctua NH-C14S: amzn.to/2Fhydtv
Scythe Fuma 2: amzn.to/3bGSLrf
Noctua NH-U12A CPU Cooler: amzn.to/34e2Gmo
Liquid AIO:
Corsair H100i Pro: amzn.to/3iDAuhh
NZXT Kraken X53: amzn.to/3c4CGf0
NZXT Kraken X63: amzn.to/33CafkS
CPUs:
AMD Ryzen 9 3900X: amzn.to/315dZex
AMD Ryzen 7 3700X: amzn.to/34fUp1a
GPU:
Gigabyte Nvidia 2070: amzn.to/3iDXAEv
Motherboards:
Gigabyte Aorus X570 ITX Motherboard: amzn.to/2Qe9yYB
Asus B450 ITX Motherboard: amzn.to/33zCFfh
Fans:
Arctic P12, 5-pack: amzn.to/3hTjVxj
Noctua NF-A12x25mm PWM fans: amzn.to/3h9mFGt
CoolerMaster should refund you the cost of the case for the great work you've done showcasing their product.
i agree, watching his builds inspired me so I ordered a new PC using his advise. love the nr200p
Yeah, inspired and challenged me to do my first ITX build in this case before the end of 2022. I'm kinda scared lol 😅
Dude this series has been so useful! You did an amazing job! Back in October I upgraded my PC to a 3900x and a 5700xt. However, things got so toasty in my Cougar QBX using the stock cooler and low profile fans that I started using an outside fan to cool my components and stop my PC from overheating and shutting down while gaming. I just recently got the NR200 and was looking for some information on good aftermarket coolers and case fans. I was considering liquid cooling but after watching your videos I decided to purchase the Noctua NH-C14S and 3 Noctua NF-A12x25's. I'm really looking forward to seeing how much cooler things are! Thanks a mil for making these videos man!
Glad I found this entire channel dedicated to the NR200! Best NR200 channel (maybe the only) on YT🤣
for my first SFF build i went the NR200 with an 240mm AIO and you were one of a few content providers out there to help me pick the right case. I'll be rewatching a couple more of the videos in regards to fans and configurations. Keep up the good work :)
so happy to find this video as I consider a build in this case. Thank you!
Glad it was helpful!
Many thanks for this great series on the NR200. Bravo!
Basically, there is no difference at all between a highend air cooler and a matching water cooler. That's the reason I prefer the Noctua, no danger of leaks.
My DAN A4 has caused me within 3 years the same problem twice. It is so tight, that the cables got a loose contact over time. At my search for a great replacement case I came accross your video series with the NR200. I bought it with the Noctua NH-U12A
Yep, my first build and I'm going SFF. Thanks for your excellent videos. I was planning on buying the Cooler Master Master NR200 and your vids have been very helpful.
Another great NR200 video! Building with 5600x and RTX 3070, wish you could re do this video with the latest components.
Still a valid case in 2022, and thanks for the testing.
My case arrived today! Great content and voice. Subbed!
All right! Enjoy the build and thanks for checking in!
Amazing! Hapy I found your content. I just committed to this case and have not built for almost 10 years. AIO was not really interesting for me since i’m a 1080p casual gamer. Subbed! Great content, thanks!
Welcome aboard!
I maybe late to the party, but thank you for all the nr200 videos, you really help me with my “research” for this case ☺️
thank you so much for a really knowledgeable explanation of air vs aio.
Really appreciate this series of videos on this case. I plan on building in one of these at some point in the future, and was thinking about sticking with air cooling. All of these in depth comparisons really help narrow down configurations to consider.
This deserved my like 👍🏽. If I could like it more than once i totally would, underrated content on this page!
Man, your videos are awesome! I wish you the best
On this case you can put the 280mm AIO on the side and have 2 fans on both sides and it somehow fits into this compact package, it's truly insanely good design
Thank you for these videos, I really want to challenge myself to do my first ITX air cooled build in this case. 😅
Great summary and good point made. These series definitely eliminated unnecessary trial and error approach for those who were uncertain about the cooling solution in this case. Let’s see how the new 3080 behave in this case now 🤓.
You got it! 3080... sigh... I tried, just like everyone else. We'll see how the next few days look!
Machines & More ohhh I know! No sweat! Whenever it’s possible. We r here waiting on your next videos 😃
Machines & More the major concern would be triple slotted cards as that might prevent installing bottom fans. I wonder if slim fans would work or just let the card itself pull the air from the bottom 🤷🏻♂️
Again, awesome detail review!
Glad you liked it!
Great video series! I am planning to move my system from a Fractal Define C Mini case to this one and changing the Noctua tower cooler i have now for a Kraken X53. Im planning also to use my 2x120mm Noctuas as bottom intake for my oc’d Radeon 5700 and the Sickleflow fans as top exhaust fans, as the only model available in Finland is the 200p version :) I also have 2x140mm Noctuas that i will re-use from my Fractal case instead of the Kraken’s regular fans. Hopefully it will be a cool SFF build :)
I love air cooling and your work has helped me a lot Thank you!
Great analysis.
Really love your detailed review and suggestions, one question I would like to ask is if I use the noctua C14S, will I still be able to mount a 3.5 inch drive? Thanks!
Yes- on the rad panel, however you only have two screws of space to tighten it down, unless you drill more holes.
Absolutely brilliant. Thank you! Subscribed :)
Great analysis, I’d love to see a similar video going over tempered glass thermals and what is the best air cooler we can fit into that configuration. I can’t find something reliable about what is the best cooler to fit in that situation
That is coming right up! Will also be doing a budget tower cooler roundup as well.
@@MachinesMore Awesome!
@@MachinesMore you’re so helpful! I’ll have to wait until I see that TG video since I have my hand on the trigger looking for the best air cooler that will easily fit.
Great analysis, thanks for the effort
Great job! Very thorough.
Thanks for the video! In the end I went for a Kraken X63 for this one. Never had an AIO so I honestly wanted to tinker with it and just experiment a little, plus I would like to undergo some overclocking on my i7 10700k and I felt safer with more cooling headroom. Having said that, I'm not against air cooling, and if things don't go as I like, I may just go back to it :)
Cheers, OC’d 10700K is pretty much what I’d consider a AIO use case. How are you liking it?
What gpu are you running?
@@MachinesMore I'm enjoying it so far. Pretty much silent until it gets really hot. For now I'm happy with it, although I honestly see nothing bad in general with aircooling
@@saucyg6371 heh, wish I could've bought a 3080 to put in this baby, sadly, didn't make it for the reasons you all know! Actually I'm rocking a rtx 2070 borrowed from a friend of mine
I love my NR200. I wish it has more clearance on the right side panel for cable management.
Thank you very much. Another great video. :) Everything I want is presently in stock. Mentioned before. My parts are way overkill. But, no wife, no kids, no pets, no exes, no mortgage. And I'll only overclock - a bit. Oh, my MB is Asus ROG Crosshair VIII Impact Mini DTX. :)
I'm building a 4K editing PC with 3900XT, RTX 3070, B550I Aorus pro ax in NR200 (no OC). Could you please tell me the best CPU cooler that you recommend? Appreciate your effort in helping out PC builders and thank you for your amazing videos.
If you’re using the vented panel then with that setup a Noctua C14S would be very good. You could also do the Noctua U12A.
The Artic 240 or 280 AIO is really a good option. Not pretty, but great performance and great price. Perfect for this case in my opinion.
I have heard good things about these!
I was also considering this, but since the tubes come straight out of the pump head, combined with the extra thickness of the radiator, it makes a very tight fit and sharp angle for the tubes. Illustrated in this picture: imgur.com/a/q8JV2Vy
@@holojam3403 put it via sidemount
@@holojam3403 he should not have put his tubes like that, many have said to lay the tubes over the top of the power supply. that setup gives me anxiety lol
Yeah, that tubing pressure would keep me up at night... Not sure if it’s yours but personally I would have attempted to rotate the unit so that the barbs are on the PSU side.
You forgot AMD vs AMD in the intro...
Very disappointing.
Seriously though, this series is fantastic. You've done an amazing job, and all of the tech community owes you one!
Ah, AMD vs AMD... my favorite discussion. :) Judging by the market trends lately, that might just become the prominent discussion in the near future. Let's just hope that competition keeps things interesting and the market healthy for consumers. Glad you enjoyed and thanks for checking in!
I’m back! I finally took the time to transplant my PC parts from a Lian li Tu150 to a NR200P with vented panel.
I disassembled everything while managing to keep the CPU cooler (Scythe Ninja 5) on my motherboard (Aorus Z490i ultra) but I immediately ran into a big issue. Because the NR200 cannot accommodate a 120mm at the back and because the exhaust fan of the cooler does need to stay flush with the back of the case, it doesn’t fit. I’ve rewatched all your videos as well as a few others and I had completely missed that detail. None of the tower coolers you covered actually require having a fan flush with the back of the case, hence them fitting. I found a guy on Reddit who managed to fit a Ninja 5 in a NR200 but he only managed to do it because his motherboard doesn’t have a heatsink and so he was able to bring the back fan lower than the top of the IO shield.
I wish I had noticed it earlier but now I understand why the NR200 ships with a 90mm fan!
All medium/high performance coolers seem to have sone sort of clearance issue, either with the top fans, the side bracket or the PSU mount. Should cooler master had made this case 3-5mm wider, it would have been one of - if not the most - versatile sff case. As is though and leaks potencial apart, I feel that this case is far better suited for water cooling.
It’s disappointing but I am considering re-transplanting everything back to the Lian li Tu150 which I believe is a better suited case for air cooling.
If anyone in London, UK is interested in a white NR200P, let me know ;) This thing is heavy so I am not shipping it though!
Yikes! Have you tried it with just one fan? Might surprise you depending on what chip you’re cooling. Would hate to see you give up now and since I am still slowly testing through TU150 thermals, I am seeing results at least a few degrees worse, of course not apples to apples yet since I am not using the glass panel yet.
Machines & More The problem is really that rear 120mm fan. The cooler fits with the front fan only and a 90mm fan would fit at the back. However, I guess that cooling performance and noise would take a hit. Here are 3 images that ilustra-te the issue: imgur.com/gallery/lsaR7hA
I’ll wait for your comparison video with the TU150 before I make a decision though ;)
i like you man, bought an nr200 on a whim the other day, stumbled across your vid. You have the best content on this case, very well done.
i've got a tu150 build you might find interesting on my channel.
Dude, that is one sick TU150 build and can really appreciate how the lights highlight the NF-A12s! I've got my cooler setup exactly the same way (1x exhaust fan from the U12A on the rear) and am diving into detailed testing now. I'm guessing you have another NF-A12 as an intake? I've had the TU150 awhile and meant to jump on it a few months ago to get all the thermal testing done but got sidetracked with the NR200 testing. Enjoy the NR200!
Honestly for me it comes down to atheistics when choosing air or liquid cooling, now for my NR200 build I went air, simply because I had a spare L9x65 (Used on an i5 10400) laying around and the fact that you cannot see inside the system.
Just did a NR200 build: 3950X, 6800XT (triple slot!). Had water-cooling initially, but it was too cramped inside so I swapped it out for air. Managed to squeeze in a couple of 15mm fans under the GPU with literally a mm of clearance. Wifey using it for gaming so I don't think the 3950X will be pushed very hard, apart from a few cores, so I'm not too worried about temps. GPU temps are insanely good. I've really gone off water-cooling now.
cramped? AIO is much more compact than a aircooler. Unless its a smaller one.
@@craigshandworld I guess it was just the configuration of that particular case that worked better for air cooling. I managed to fill nearly the entire volume with hardware.
@Mike yeah, I'm leaning towards aircooling I think for nr200p. So lich back and forth info on air vs aio
Thanks for this review! I'd like to fit a 3080 in this bad boy
Oh it fits, problem is getting both lol :P
@@tmkongen got my nr200p incoming. Got the sf750w, 3080, still waiting 😭
@@sinetwo wow
Just finished my build in this with a 3080 FE, it fits just fine, plenty of space for the GPU. Gotta just cable manage like a boss to make it not a mess with an X52 in there along side the 6 fans and 3080 FE. Took me longer to get this case than it did the 3080, which I feel lucky for.
@@iceddz no one basically has the 3080fe, so you should consider yourself pretty lucky, despite it being the hottest in the series ☺
noice!! was divided to go with an AIO or AC for the NR200p...well seems like the AIO will be for my next build...
AC with the NR200p will be just fine I guess
I picked up an NR200 to replace my tired, old 2008 build with something small and powerful for 4k gaming in the living room. Your coverage, along with some others, made it an easy choice! Would a hybrid GPU, like the EVGA 3080 XC3 Hybrid be a good idea in this case?
Thank you for all the NR200 U12A coverage, It works out conveniently for me because thats what im working with. But i am planning on using my full ATX power supply which between that and the U12a will leave very little free room. I think ill be ok but you seem to be the man who knows most about this case. Would you recommend getting a SFX PSU?
Thanks for this!
its easy on those choices, dogs, batman, amd, amd and aircooling :D
I like your video and your t shirt as well
Thanks a lot for this great video! Your recommendations are solid and make sense I will most likely be building a mid range gaming machine with this case. If I get the scythe fuma 2 cooler for a AMD 3700xt or possible new Ryzen Gen 3 will the two stock fans fit at top or is the aircooler to big? Also you can rotate the power supply casing to be more in the front of the case, will this orientation work best for air cooled builds?
hey machines, great vid and detailed study, NR200P builder here want your opinion on a cooling setup : ( verified all component clearance with fittings and all)
cpu only cooling :
mini pump res combo : corsair XD3 RGB (mounted on PSU backplate) and any CPU waterblock (maybe corsair for tha sweet RGB)
left of the case : 92 mm 4,5 cm thick alphacool rad with a noctua black swap NF-A9 PWM (not sure of ex/intk with push/pull or not)
second cooling (still for cpu only) : bottom of the case 240 rad (slim) with no fans .....on top of it the GPU will be helping pass air throught the fins.
i think it could work with the top fan in exhaust making such a negative pressure than air will be pulled into the case and help cool the cpu even without the gpu fan working.
I imagine this setup configuration because it will offer the best overall visual of the components, while providing what i hope will more than enough to cool a 250 w cpu overclock ( at least 150 w dissipation for the thick boi 92 rad, then the lazy boi 240 only have to deal with the 100 w remaining....
also it will be all watercooled ready ( just add a GPU block and 2 fans on the 240 and it's done)
what do you think ?
Hey! That’s an interesting idea. If you want it to work you’ll have to run every fan in exhaust- top, rear, all creating a vacuum to semi passively intake through the bottom. Additionally I would seal off every vent and the gaps on the top filter with tape, because those will all be more attractive locations for air intake- you’ll want the bottom rad to be the only option for intake (even seal off the gaps around the rad if there are any). If you’re OK with your GPU taking in hot rad exhaust then I think it’s worth a shot. For sure the 240 will still be the bigger source of heat exchange regardless of thickness. Two Noctua NF-A12s at 1200-1500 RPM at the top will do the trick.
Another thought is- since it’s CPU only, why not just ditch the 92mm rad, run the GPU vertically and put fans on the bottom rad? Then you could even go with a slightly thicker 40mm rad and 25mm fans, instead of what I’m assuming is the XSPC TX240... I think your system would be better cooled that way, only thing is you won’t see your CPU block.
Based on the TDP I’m guessing you’re cooling a 10700K or 10900K for an all-core OC so if you were to do your first option but with fans on the bottom, and loop in the GPU, with the 92mm rad you just might have enough headroom for a 200W GPU (not sure which you’re running).
@@MachinesMore hoa cool, two out of two answers man, really awesome.
ok : let's try the workaround to fool proof the build if it's good with you.
1 you sayin' the 92 mm rad should be a exhaust push/pull to maximize negative pressure inside the chassi --> Q : i'm concerned with the rad recycling hot air and loosing performances.. what do you think ??
2 for the top fan exhaust i plan on using the LIan li unifans, proven by Jayztwocents to have absolutly bonker air pressure...and beautifull rgb with the aura motherboard i already have purchased. what is your opinion on that ?
3 regarding your question for front mounted GPU... i plan on using an colorful vulcan 3080, with the screen on the side to check for temps and others systems info (vram, gpu, cpu, and maybe a little GIF animation in between to add bang, the plan is to allow maximum visibility of all the others components i will spend money on, ( cpu block, motherboard, royal ram etc ) so bottom gpu is a must. but i have plan, maybe for summer if it get too hot to allow an other config with vented side pannel and front facing GPU
4 for the total 450 w heat estimated, what do you think the temps will be ( i'm good until i see above 75/80 c for cpu and max 70/75 c gpu ) and i plan on allowing a dynamic overclock to not peg the CPU (10900k undervolted) at mac tdp constantly
5 as for my work scenari....i plan gaming at 2k high fram rate ( so cpu at 50/60% tdp max and gpu almost max ) work with video editing and illustartor / photoshop all that
i think the total tdp will be shared quite well in many usecases ..unless i want to be stupid and render a blender scene while gaming a very demanding game...
sorry for long answer time and maybe poor english i'm in france :) and needed to readproof my answer for bloodstains !
Can you do a review with the TG side panel
especially with what air cooler suits best with the TG side panel, i know a few folks who would appreciate that as the air cooling options with the mesh side panel was restricted in what was available, with the TG reducing this list further.
something you may not have considered with tall air coolers.. is to use shorter motherboard standoffs. I havent checked exactly. But i think the supplied ones are ~8-10mm and you can get 4mm ones which would give ~+4mm clearance to tall coolers : )
That’s a thought... but you’d need to grind off more metal for the rear I/O and shield to sit further out right?
Is it possible putting 12cm fan on rear using converter 92mm to 120mm? For maximum air cooling
awesome video.
Hey Machines and More-- I have a custom top mount radiator mod for the nr200 that I designed and 3d printed. Was wondering if I could send you the parts and have you test it out-- how do I get a hold of you to talk more? Love your stuff and all the focus on the NR200.
Since nVidia appearently had 10 founder edition cards to be split among 6 billion people, will you be doing a video on the best partner cards for optimal cooling in this case? Most of them won't even leave room for bottom fans it seems. Would also be great to find a card suitable for deshrouding in the NR200!
They all went to influencers they don't give a damn about their loyal customers.
I will go for NR200, ryzen 3 3100 stock cooler and my old gtx 980 as my 2nd pc.. thanks mate
the intro is really funny but there is no such question intel vs amd
How quickly things change 😮
I'm looking for an top down air cooler or heat sink that will modestly over clock but be available to use the tempered glass panel
looking to build in a nr200. thanks for this! still collecting info on what parts to buy
I really wanted to go asus b550i with c14s using 120mm mounted on the bottom so I can use the psu at the sfx spot and 2 exhaust top and 2 intake fans on the side. Do you know, is the retail package of the c14s provide the fan bracket for 120mm fan or is the provided 140mm fan usable with a12x25 fan? Using the 140mm fan on the pull side of c14s with the asus b550i/x570i will shift the psu to the front panel or the atx position so i want to avoid this if possible.
Hey! You'll have to request the clips from Noctua for a 120mm fan, just be prepared to provide purchase receipt for their confirmation. Just to note- you can use the A14 fan underneath if you route your cables elsewhere, and not in the gap between the motherboard and PSU. Then I'd just put a 120mm fan on the radiator panel. I did not see a meaningful change with two fans on the radiator panel. Too much intake is a bad thing also. Good luck!
Haven't watched the video yet but I originally installed a low profile noctua cpu cooler in the nr200 then decided to buy a 240mm aio and I hated it. The tubes bent too much and had too much pressure against everything. Then it was impossible to install on the top of the case so I went for the side but that made it annoying to open the case later. Mine also came with a bunch of rgb wires and cable management is hard enough so long story short I took it out and swapped it with what I had before. I just won't overclock my cpu. Then I added 7 slim noctua fans instead. Thing stays chilly
Great analysis! I am going for air cooler but will use CRYORIG h7-QL Quad Lumi RGB instead so that I can use the TG panel without hitting the glass. Also can enjoy the cool RGB effect. The cooling may not be as good as Noctua though.
W it really depends on the CPU you are using. I also going for the H7 Lumi in my NR200P build.
@@ChrisCroft77 I am using R5 3600 only. It is not a very hot CPU. :-)
Should be fine! 3600 is easy peasy to cool.
You bring up very good points,AIOs in my opinion are okay but if I were to water cool my PC I would rather go with a custom loop.The reason that I would go with a custom water cooling loop is because I tried a Corsair 120mm AIO and it failed,I had the option of sending it back to Corsair for a free replacement but I failed to send the 120mm AIO back to Corsair within the specified time.Custom water cooling loops while more expensive than AIO water cooling have the advantage of allowing the individual replacement of the parts where as AIOs do not allow for replacement of the individual parts because AIOs come sealed from the manufacturer.With custom water cooling loops the only things that can fail aside from the cooling fans are the water pumps and if quick connect fittings are used then it becomes possible to replace the water pump without losing all of the cooling fluid in the water cooling loop.In a small PC case like the one you are using in the video it would not pay to bother with a custom water cooling loop because the PC case is so constrained but in regular size PC cases custom water cooling loops are a good option is what I think.Custom water cooling loops can be moved to another PC case provided that the custom water cooling loop is connected with flexible tubing and the other PC case is large enough to accomodate the custom water cooling loop.Thank you for the video and God bless you and your family.
Will a Thermalright Silver Arrow 130 fit? It's said to be 130mm tall like it's title suggests. Dimension: L120 mm x W101 mm x H130 mm Also will dual 92mm fans fit in the rear of the case or 80mm or 70mm? I want to fit dual fans in the rear, what size will fit?
Thanks for all the work. Did you notice a difference between mounting the PSU on the front panel Vs the back panel? Do you ever run cinebench as a benchmarking tool?
OH, got it
Hi, I have a i5-11600k occked at 5.1ghz. The cpu is cooled by a DeepCool Caste 280 AIO (Max 81° in 30 min. Cinebench stress test)
The AIO has the stock fan (DeepCool TF140 S)............ what's best 140mm radiator fan I can mount on radiator to boost AIO performance?
I watched some comparison between Noctua, Phanateks and others and Phanateks seems the best, but thsi comparison are on 120mm version, and I'm looking for 140mm..........
Thank You for your appreciated advice.
Does the TDP include the boost clock? I wonder when I check the info about my cpu?
I just ordered a 5900x and hoping my NH-L12S with a top mounted NF-F12 and a NF-S12 side intake will suffice. There is a couple millimeter gap between the two fans. I have a Cougar QBX which is similar to the NR200, I was wondering if I am be able to fit a C14-S, or if anyone else has used my setup before.
GREAT vid!! I’m building with this case, an ASUS x570i, kraken x63 AIO, and 4 chassis fans. How did you allocate all 6 fans to the MB’s fan headers? I know space is limited in the NR200 and I want to avoid a fan hub. Thanks mate!
What's the best setup and cooler for this when using a Ryzen 9 5900x and a Gigabyte 3080 Vision? I plan to do some very light overclocking and I want to make sure my components are cool. I could go either air or water but I don't want to do a custom loop. Please help!!
Hi! If you're using the vented panel: Noctua C14S with an extra fan under the heatsink; Noctua U12A are all good choices for a Ryzen 9 and should give you enough for light overclocking.
AIO- the Arctic Liquid Freezer II 240 tested in quite nicely and will give you the most overhead for overclocking. All these come in at around the same cost of $100 US so it's really up to you if you want to deal with the extra tubes and size of the liquid cooler.
Interesting video content. Can I still use my 240mm AIO on the side panel if I will reuse my existing ATX PSU with a mounting bracket? I’m planning to upgrade only my mATX mobo to a mini ITX one.
HI
I have a dilema...
I got both coolers:
Kraken x63 and Noctua C14S
What should I choose for better temps & noise?
Thanks in advance
Great video. Is a low profile Scythe Shuriken 2 or Noctua L9x65 enough for my 12th gen i7? I have it in a 10 liter sandwich case.
When you’re testing the results at the last part it says one fan on the top right and the two at the bottom. Does that mean for the test you took out the stock fan on the rear?
Yes, with many coolers it does not fit.
This series has been fantastic! I'm going to be a first time builder in the upcoming months so I have a long winded question (S). I already have the NR200 waiting to be built in but I'm currently waiting to see what Zen 3 and Big Navi look like.. If there aren't meaningful gains over Zen 2 and what Nvidia came out with, AMD driver issues be damned. I'm more than likely going to go with a 3700X and an Asus Tuf 3080 with a c14S as my cooler for the CPU with eyes set on the Gigabyte B550i Auros Pro AX mother board. With the socket being set up higher on the Motherboard is one top fan for exhaust going to be enough to manage the airflow for say, 2 Slim noctuas on the bottom as intake and two noctuas on the side radiator panel as intake as well? Are the two slim noctuas going to inhibit airflow to the GPU that much?
Thanks!
Thanks! Yup, it's totally fine with one exhaust to the right. With the direction of air flow pushing towards the mobo, air is getting pushed out the top anyway, and while the exhaust would help, the C14S is pretty competitive already, as you can see. I don't know that you can run slim fans under the TUF 3080, it may be marginal. The Strix card I tried in there was only two mm thicker, and slim fans hit the GPU and would not spin. At any rate, even if you can clear it, if you're that close to the GPU you may encounter weird fan behavior since the case fans will be on their own cadence, and won't always be in sync with GPU fans.
With the A14 on top you won't be able to fit another fan between the cooler and the side panel, it's too tight. But you don't need to, you can just move the A14 fan onto the rad panel, and that was the best tested config if you use a pull fan under the heatsink. I'd be careful with two side intakes if you also run bottom fans. The reason is you want directed airflow at the heatsink, and two intake fans ended up being less effective in the case due to pressure build up in the case (4 intakes, 1 exhaust). Without bottom fans, the two intakes on the side should be fine.
@@MachinesMore thank you so much for the detailed response. Really appreciate it!
Will Corsair iCUE H115i RGB Pro XT fit?
I actually dont mind the NH-C14S like i said in your past video. I just don't know how well it would do if i were to change the case. I'm always thinking about a potential change in cases
I hear you- the moment you switch to something with a TG panel it will limit the cooler's potential. Then again, an AIO isn't a given, either, who knows how rad compatibility will be, and likewise for a tower cooler, the clearance is uncertain either in a future case. Probably the only thing more certain is if you stick with a lower profile top down cooler.
Great video, just be carefull with your mic it has an annoying sound at the end of each word
I've had the same aio for 6 years now. They seem to last long enough.
@Oliver Solheim Corsair H100 series can't even remember which one.
Hi, so I don’t know whether you are going to react on this. I love your series as I tend to get the nr200 myself. I’m going to get a i9 9900k with a 3070 when it’s available. I don’t really use that many cpu heavy tasks, so my gpu is the main thing that has to stay cool. The thing is: where I live, the C14s(109€) is more expensive than the U12a(98€). I don’t mind spending more money if it works better. So I also looked at your aio vids and found the nzxt kraken x63 and ther Corsair H115i. I’m a little worried that an aio in this case wil get malfunctions due to little space. What would you, or anyone else recommend? Have a nice day and thanks again for the series, you’ve helped me out tremendously
Hey, I was planning on using a Hyper 212 Black and two top exhaust fans with my NR200P. Do you think adding a 92mm rear exhaust fan would be necessary? The CPU is a Ryzen 3600.
Probably wouldn’t do much, but probably wouldn’t hurt either- unless it’s right up against the heatsink or the fan, in which case it would interfere. It’s not terribly loud but does add a little noise.
@@MachinesMore Thank you! I guess I'll test temps first before making a purchase.
Welcome- you should be fine either way since R5 3600 is pretty tame, cooling wise.
I found a good deal on one such CoolerMaster case, but I'm thinking about fitting an air cooler for the CPU if I do get said case, specifically the Dark Rock TF2. Any opinions? Currently running a Ryzen 2700x with a Dark Rock Pro 4 on it, inside a Define R4 case. Big case but a bit of a hot box especially during the hot summers ( think ambient temperatures of 37-41°C on a regular basis).
Your videos about this case in particular are very informative, kudos! 😎
Hey! The TF2 isn’t a very friendly ITX cooler, due to the position over the board/RAM and it’s not one I’d recommend. For a similar airflow setup with better compatibility I’d go for the Noctua C14S. Should handle the 2700X just fine!
@@MachinesMore Oh okay. I found this one dude that was using it in his build inside an NR200P and since I think the Dark Rock Pro 4 is doing a great job thought it would warrant an attempt. Though in his video I see to remember there was no room for the 92mm back exhaust fan and the upper exhaust fan that would sit above the tower cooler, purely because of the TF2's size.
Going with the C14S because I already have it (in a cheap Sharkoon QB1 case). Waiting for the NR200 to be in stock and new Ryzen processors to come out. Trying to decide between B550 Asus or ASRock motherboards (I want fans on top of the case). Thanks for the video!
Cheers- B550 ITX, I’d typically recommend Gigabyte in this case since the USB-C front header isn’t used, but the socket is seated high (just like on the X570 test board I use), which means no top fans over the C14S. I’d go Asrock if those are your two choices since the Asrock has better VRMs and also passively cools them, unlike the Strix which uses a fan- and yes you can hear these little fans when things are quiet. The noise pattern is very different from say a case fan.
@@MachinesMore Are you able to have a top front fan? does the PSU get in the way?
As long as you use the SFX power supply there's rarely any interference between any cooling options and that top/front position. SFX-L mounts higher, and the PSU plug would possibly interfere with the fan clearance.
I'm still trying to get the cooling system situation... ugh! I have the case come this week but my setup is going to be, ( I can't believe I spent this much)!? Basically, I'm going to be running a 5950x w/ 32GB (TBD but Trident Z is the front runner), 3080 as it stands. I'm considering an AIO but would be fine with a good fan that will fit. Anything is going to be than what I'm working with at this point.
wait so for the power gamer/super quiet user, the AIO is better than a air cooler?
Amazing dedication to NR200 , great job : )
I just built my new nr200p build with tg panel, where im using 3700x and stock amd cooler. I assume i can't fit in fuma 2 and noctua u12a so it would have to be c14s. What fan would you recommend to swap that brown noctua with?
Cheers! Well, I think the Fuma 2 is worth a shot, I know it's spec'd at 155mm, CM's limit on the NR200P is 153mm, so if we're talking about 2-3mm of tolerance, it might work. Anecdotally I've been seeing user builds with the Fuma 2 fit in. I would tend to shy away from the C14S in a TG case since it's intaking pretty close to the solid panel, but there is an open rear next to it so it may not be all bad. Still though, I think a tower would be better with the TG. As for fans, Noctua does make a "Chromax" or black A14, so that would be the natural swap.
im so glad i found you, your vid are amazing but dafuq is that keyboarddd
Hi...do you know if the raijintek Morpheus will fit this case?
Do those tower coolers fit with the TG panel?
Bro.. can you test it with ryzen stock cooler? How good is cpu temp?
My Wraith Prism wasn't overly loud, and it would peak out at 65 degrees. But my 280mm radiator AIO tops out at 44 degrees, and it's almost completely silent.
I’ve been debating a custom loop vs air cooling for a few weeks now while I was waiting for a sf750. (Got it finally!) I really want to use the TG so... While I’m still waiting for a 3080, if I go with the Fuma 2 for 3900x (x570i aorus) should I intake from the rear or exhaust? And is it worth switching the scythe fans for Noctua A12x25?
Woohoo! If you’re running or planning on a 3080, I would definitely run a rear intake. The recommendation to run the cooler as an exhaust is really for moderate TDP GPUs, and the 3080 is squarely out of that category. Stock fans are OK at stock clocks. All core OC on the 3900X is definitely fan upgrade territory. The issue isn’t so much that the fans are bad, they’re just capped at 1200RPM. Arctic P12, Noctua’s P12 Redux, are all good lower cost alternatives that should work fine. A12x25 is the best but come at a cost.
Over been subscribed since you're first nr200 video. I'm planning on a build with fill size atx seasonic 850 watt psu, s14s. Any advice? Do you think that c14s would also got in ncase m1? I have both cases and I am absolutely hell bent I'm using a full sugar atx psu no matter what.
ATX PSUs will fit, just be aware of GPU limitations since they sit low. If you can 3D print CM has also made a bracket model available. The C14S isn’t as good in the NCase compared to the NR200, since it has a top fan limitation. Also the NR200 top fan adjacent to the C14S helps it too. The 240 AIO in the M1 is by far the better choice if needed.
What's the biggest side-exhaust aircooler that fits side bracket? I need to use it but so far I could not find any, even 212 doesn't seem compatible.
There’s a couple of solutions. A few folks have modded the side panel by widening the holes to accommodate the heatpipes on a tall tower, otherwise a short tower like a 92mm or short Cryorig H7 would be a good solution for using the panel.
Is it possible to fit two top exhaust fans, if you go wit the NOCTUA NH-C14S? Im planning to build a setup in this case. I've got a Asus 3080 TUF on its way, and from what I can tell there's not room for any buttom intake fans - or maybe with low profile? I was planning a single intake on the side alongside the NH-14S and then two exhaust on the top.
If you have a board with low cpu socket, I reckon you could easily get a slim fan over it.
Will you be getting an Nvidia 3000 series card to test in the NR200? The unique airflow of the 3000 series cards prompt these questions: I'd be interested if bottom fans will still help, or whether bottom fans could interfere with the airflow dynamics of air entering the underside of the 3000 series FE card. For instance, if a bottom fan delivers air either slower or faster than the 3080 ideally wants air to enter itself, could that produce turbulence? I wonder if it would be better for the 3000 series card to suck in ambient air i.e. no bottom fans. I also wonder if the larger size of the 3080 will interfere with AIO cables, influencing the decision between a 240mm or 280mm AIO. I also wonder if the Noctua U12A can cope with the 3000 series cards. (Unfortunately, I can't get the C14S at the local store that will do my build).
Trying on the FE but the retail launch has been a bit of a mess! I'm hesitant on AIBs but at this point few of us are getting anything yet from the regular retail outlets. The reason I'm hesitant is because those heatsinks are ginormous, which precludes any bottom fans, also if you are limited for airflow at the bottom, it's going to be choked for air. Also, a lot of the cards are long, which, despite being compatible with the case, will really limit cable management and space efficiency in the case. A hybrid card would be ideal for this case.
@@MachinesMore I’ll be looking forward to your conclusions about FE vs AIB. The review by Techtesters said that the MSI and ASIS were cooler and quieter than the FE, because the larger heatsink made them run cooler and quieter. I speculate that if the AIB cards inherently run cooler and quieter than the FE, then that might compensate for not having extra bottom fans in the NR200?
Also, in terms of fluid dynamics of the airflow, I imagine that, to avoid air turbulence, the airflow of the bottom fans would somehow have to ‘match’ the airflow that the GPU fans desire. I’m speculating here, but is it possible that if the bottom case-fans are either too slow or too fast, relative to the GPU fans, it could cause problems of turbulence? It makes me wonder whether it’s best to let the GPU fans just suck in air at the rate that’s best for their fans, rather than adding bottom case-fans to the NR200. It’s akin to the situation of the airflow from the 92mm side case-fan having to be “in harmony” with the fans of the CPU aircooler.
Another issue I’m curious about is whether the GPU supports, that are supplied with some of the larger AIB cards, will fit in the small space where the bottom fans would be. I suspect these support arms may not fit in the NR200, but it’d be good to get confirmation.
The AIBs didn't radically redesign coolers, just really really upped the mass of the heatsink to compensate for the higher TDP. The reason I was hesitating on the AIB cards was that most of them were really long, or really thick, which is just a brute force approach. The FE design was more elegant but who knows when we'll see one in hand. You're absolutely right that the fans are going to be a problem though for AIBs since the fans will be interfering with each other unless they are synced. This is why deshrouding often works well in a small space, essentially you can just use one set of powerful fans to do double duty of case ventilation and heat exchange off of the GPU heatsink.
I'm going for absolute quietest possible | 10700k / Z490-i
1 - NF-A14 fan mounted on the NH-C14S radiator
2 - 4 NF-A12x25 PWM for both intake at bottom, and exhaust out the top? Can you please clarify for me. Why not 140mm fans, won't that help it be more quiet too?
Thanks!
My personal build 👍
140mm won’t fit at the bottom or top, only on the side panel. For the heatsink- the reason is when noise normalized, the NF-A12x25 actually meets and beats the A14’s performance, with a more pleasing noise pattern. As a case fan, RPMs are low enough that it isn’t a huge difference.
If only this case fit a U12A with the tempered glass panel.
I want a chopped down NZXT H210, no psu shroud, SFX psu only, no 3.5" bays, 3 slot gpu clearance
Since you mentioned about getting an asetek AIO for longetivity, is a three year-old Evga CLC 280 with 5th gen asetek pump still considered better than The latest ML240L V2?
Well, by virtue of being three years old and still running, as well as you knowing its history, absolutely. If it hasn't failed thus far, chances are it will keep on going. It's still too early to get a long term feel for the ML240L V2, but it is certainly a unit that's priced well.
i ended up buying a corsair h100i pro xt with Cool IT pump as it was on sale for about as much as the ML240L v2, but thanks anyway
The case seems really modular. Mounting an AIO in the bottom is bad (see GamersNexus video about it), but could you switch the top and bottom panels? Maybe the front IO gets in the way, maybe they can be removed and modded to fit on the other side?
It is really modular and very flexible, however the bottom fits in differently than the top. There is a catch for the bottom, whereas the top just snaps in. On the mesh version you could simply mount it on the side panel- for the NR200P (TG panel) you are stuck with bottom mounting, and yes, I agree that's a bad idea, however there are different AIOs, and I'll share one that might work better in a future video.
@@MachinesMore Ah shame, maybe it's a small improvement for Cooler Master to make for the next iteration, since I suspect it would be a pretty good layout for side-mounted graphics with the window. Looking forward to the next video, keep up the good work.
With today's reports that the new AMD 5900X will be around 150 Watts, i.e. 50% more Watts than the AMD 3900X, do you think it points to definitely going with AIO rather than air cooling? Or do you think the air cooling can cope with a 150 Watt CPU? I'm aiming for the new 5900X and 3080.
That ultimately depends on a lot of things, not just the TDP. The quality of the thermal dissipation matters too, how consistently the thermal output is also matters. If it’s bursty in how it is attaining the higher clocks, then Liquid cooling does give you an advantage here, since water has a higher specific heat and is slower to react to burst loads and slower to hit equilibrium. I don’t think 150W TDP is out of air cooling territory, it does rule out the smaller coolers for sure. Noctua D15 is above a 240 AIO so I don’t think there’s anything an AIO can do that a bigger air cooler can’t (well, leak) Certainly 10900K in PL2 is well over that 150W. In an SFF case, especially where a D15 won’t fit, you are best off with a 240 AIO. In the NR200 and NCase M1 you have the advantage of being GPU agnostic. The exhaust direction of GPUs have little effect on an intaking radiator.