Charlie Kirk DISMANTLES 'Apache' Who Demands Apology From White People
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 04. 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @the_perseverance
BECOME A PATRON: www.patreon.com/ThePerseveran...
Follow Us On TikTok: / theperseverance1
Follow Us On Instagram: thepersever...
Bringing smile to your face, by REACTING to music that you LOVE.😜
⚠ IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: IF you don't like any of my uploads for whatever reason, please don't make a scene - contact me here on CZcams by sending me a private message or send me an e-mail on: asmrsuperior@gmail.com & i will happily cooperate and take it down!
© Copyright Notice:
We make these videos to motivate people and inspirate them for better workout. We do not own the clips and music we use in most cases. Our understanding is that it is in correlation to Fair Right Use, however given that it is open to interpretation, if any owners of the content clips would like us to remove the video, we have no problem with that and will do so as fast as possible. Please email us if you have any concerns at laughchallengeme@gmail.com
FAIR-USE COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER
* Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
1)This video has no negative impact on the original works (It would actually be positive for them)
2)This video is also for teaching purposes.
3)It is positively transformative in nature.
4)I only used bits and pieces of videos to get the point across where necessary. - Zábava
Not a single group of people around the world owe an apology for the past. The entire world has committed atrocities towards another group. We live in the now.
should Germany apologize to the Jews?
Amen, my brother, amen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hould Germany apologize to the Jews?
@@maketaco6683 Germany has apologized to the Jewish people.
@@Red22762 but the thread starter said "Not a single group of people around the world owe an apology for the past. The entire world has committed atrocities towards another group. We live in the now."
I'm sick of all these fake victims😤
A victim could become a victor with an attitude & outlook change.
ISLAM IS FAKE ACTING VICTIMS, forever and the world eventually will fall for it in a big fall.
There is nothing fake about them. And even Charlie admitted that the conditions under which Native Americans live today have been caused by the US government.
Shut up, they are NOT "fake victims." They have been and still are victimized by the so called "liberals" and our government, who make it almost impossible for them to better themselves. Who do you think provides the drugs and alcohol, just like they did way back when? The U.S. government also, just a few years ago, tried to hand off diseased meat to the Natives, telling them it was safe. Their children, until fairly recently, were forced into "re-education schools," "Indian schools," to unlearn and reject their heritage and language. The children were forcibly removed from their families, taught English and had their hair cut. Many died from the abused suffered in those "schools." Mass graves have been found to attest to it. Today, their woman and children are kidnapped for trafficking. They live in America, strangers in their own land, second class citizens having been forced onto the most undesirable acres of dust, some without the basic necessities of life, like running water, sanitation or electricity. Medical assistance is often miles away. If you don't believe me, go visit a rez. Go to a Native American film festival. See the evidence in the documentaries. These were the prototypes for Dim. run cities and states being run into the ground by the Dims. today. The luckier tribes own casinos, and they do share the profits with other tribes, but it still isn't enough to pull most out of poverty and addiction. Hopefully, this will change over time. Aho.
@@CedarMountainsnow No! As only "white" on any other colour matters, as it is fake victimhood and oppression🤯
Native American tribes engaged in conflicts and wars with each other long before European colonization. These conflicts were often driven by competition over resources, territorial disputes, revenge, or cultural differences.
A lot of people think Native American tribes were all living together peacefully, singing Kumbaya and there was nothing but peace among them. Same thing with African tribes. Until the evil white man just came barging in creating chaos and confusion.
And sometimes they slaughtered and enslaved each other out of plain meanness!!!!!!!!
These things still occur in Africa today.
@@Red22762 They also did the White settlers the same way.
THERE ISN'T A NATIVE TRIBE THAT DID NOT HAVE PROBLEMS WITH OTHER TRIBES...Think The Black Hills always belong to the Lacota?? THEY LEFT Wisconsin/Minnesota because of the Oquiwa and they were pushed from Illinois, Indiana, Ect ect...Cherokee and Several tribes fought over land ect....Most captured other indains as slaves ect ect...Pretty sure the varouis tribes in southwest do not get along...just saying everyone needs to look in the mirror at the the person who is holding them back the most.
The so called Apache needs to check on what the Comanches did to the Apache.
But the Comanches aren't white. Therefore, they are angelic beings and anything they did in the past was just fine.
He should apologize for those sunglasses.
The so called apache didn't argue. He said and asked what he wanted to. And said thanks.
Muslims should not apologize for 9/11
They want people who’s family never owned slaves to pay people who’s family we’re never slaves. This is insane
And in California where there never were any slave owners or slaves.
And some slave owners in the USA were free blacks.
I want people who attacked and killed early settlers moving west to pay the family's of those settlers for the loss of their family members. Makes as much sense as others demands.
@@jameswest9261 Those early "settlers" were stealing land and murdering its original owners. The thing is, he abuse still continues in this day and age, i.e., in the now.
Natives are not asking for that. Blacks are.
You should check how the Mexicans treated the Apache tribes. Perhaps they should be asked to apologize, too.
That’s true. It was all a big mess. The Mexicans, which were half white Spaniard” mistreated, and killed other Indian tribes” Then, when the Mexicans? which were half Spaniards got strong enough, they went to war against their ancestors” the Spanish” to try to kick them out of Mexico” lol.
The Apache have the good land in the SW because they overpowered the other NA's that were there before them, there is no real point to this argument.
The white man is somehow the “daddy” of all other groups, and whites are supposed to provide for them and ensure their success, and kiss all their boo-boos too.
Apache's were slaughtered in Northern US/Southern Canada and driven South by other tribes. Do those tribes owe the Apaches an apology? When the Apache migrated South, they colonized the land of other tribes and slaughtered their people - do they need to apologize? No, only white people need to apologize for existing.
Yeah, they only want to blame whites!!!!!!!!!!!!
I want reparations from the Romans who slaughtered and took the ancestral lands from my ancestors in Saxony
Perhaps the Romans can get reparations for things the Vikings did as well. Lets just all be victims, so we don't have to pay reparations to anyone.
And I want reparations from everyone who enslaved my Slavic ancestors for over 900 years... By the way, the term slave actually is derived from the name of the Slavic peoples
Perhaps Britain should demand war reparations from Italy, because Rome invaded in the 40's A.D.
@@carriertaiyo2694.. And the Irish demand reparations from the Brits who enslaved 350,000. 😝
@@Tijuanabill What if we all gave another person $1.00. Wouldn't that settle it? Give a dollar, maybe you receive a dollar. No more victims.
He's about as Indian as Warren.
They're first cousins.
DNA showed she does have native american ancestry
@@maketaco6683 Yup, as much as you or me. I suppose you think Biden isn't racist as well. czcams.com/video/2TJpnGCHtnA/video.html
Pocahontas Warren is 1\1024 Native American!! Doesn't that mean anything??😜
@@spaceace1006 Ace ... 'Shock Me' is even more Native American than the dude and more Chinese than Pocahontas is Native American .. Ace & Alex Van H are also first cousins from their Chinese side (does that really mean anything?)
Are the tribes going to apologize for enslaving other Native Americans and Black people?
The Creek Nation people owned Black slaves up until slavery was outlawed after the Civil War.
“Buffalo soldiers” were some of the fiercest and effective killers of Indian tribes. Does the Black community owe this man an apology? Of course not! And neither do I…..
Pompey Factor MOH recipient never featured.
Natives owned black slaves first,also stop trying blame everything on blacks
Horse crap.
It was the Hispanic/Mexicans that colonized the area of North America where the Apache were located. The is didn't gain the area until 1846, and the Apache were one of the most violent and dangerous tribes in the Americas at the time. They had been fighting the Mexicans for generations, and continued to attack and fight the US settlers when they tried to come into the area. The US retaliated and so there was conflict with them for the next 40 years, or so.
Yeah, this myth of Natives living here in peace, with no wars, just being one with nature, is a premise so utterly stupid, that it hurts the brain to even consider it. I'm so over wealthy white people going around in search of victims everywhere, so they can crown themselves as their savior.
Same as slavery, you want those who never had slaves or anything to do with it to apologize or give money then you’re the one with the issues.
Plus, the victim mentality traps people in failure and poverty.
And what about the black slave owners, including the black man that started black chattel slavery in America? Will they receive a check or will they have to pay, and how will we know difference? They have no response for that.
And give money to people who were NEVER slaves!
One-third of slave owners were black and at least 2000 slave owners were American Indians. Are those seeking reparations demanding their descendants pay up?
Gotta pull blacks in it,even when it's not about tht.
I learned in school many years ago how the native American tribes were treated 200 years ago. It is not looked over. However, I have nothing to feel guilty about.
People asking for apologies always cracks me up 😂😂😂
I’m offended, you owe me an apology! 😂🤣
Thank You... I, myself; have some percentage of Native American Blood, running through MY veins... Plus, a whole bunch of English, Irish, German, Lithuanian AND Polish Blood... I'm "a True, Heinz 57- American"!!! A product of "The Melting Pot"... I don't owe anybody ANYTHING (since I finally "clawed my way outta DEBT, a few years back) and I refuse to allow ANY disgruntled individuals with "a Victim Mentality"; to put ME on some kind of "a guilt trip"; because my WRAPPER ,(skin and hair) is "so light"... Yesterday is dead and gone; tomorrow's outta sight... Let's just try to get along... We MIGHT JUST "make it through tonight!"
You having Native and Irish blood, I'm just gonna say this as a Native American, you put both your bloodlines to shame. Natives and Irish have gone through the same thing when it comes to colonization, racism, discrimination. The only European people that I can recall that ever stood for Natives, were Irish. I know quite a few Irish people myself who advocate for Native Americans. I'm just at that point in my life where I believe the United States should just be for the Native Americans, AAPI Americans, and Irish Americans (at least the ones who advocate for Natives)
@@hailoweenhailoween5264 You don't know me, hailoweenhailoween5264... If you did, you wouldn't make such a presumptive and "BULLYING", erroneous statement, like "(I) put both (my) bloodlines to shame"... AGAIN: I don't OWE anybody squat... That doesn't mean that I haven't spent the time to become educated about history, $upported various Native American "CAUSES"; and that, as, if'n when the opportunity arrizes, fully intend to BE supportive of Native American CAUSES (NOT the ones that are directed towards further "feeding the monsters" of addiction and dependency) in the future... My Great GREAT GRANDFATHER, had married a woman, who's Father was a French "Voyager" and who's Mother was either a Cherokee, CAPTURED by the Miami (or Maumee), or who was, indeed a Miami (or Maumee)... Her name was Myrtle Serrette, who gave birth to my Grandfather, Chester Hastings, who was treated like people in the late 1800's and early 20th Century TREATED "1/2- Breeds"!!!!!! Now Chester picked up a .30-06 Enfield and WALKED and CRAWLED across France, with that thing and for YOU, who's 99% ignorant oy MY personal history, have no standing to try and put shame on me! I don't OWE YOU or ANYBODY the time'o day... You ain't about to put ME on some kind of a "guilt trip" maybe YOU "oughta be ashamed of YOURSELF"... Have a nice day!
Can't change the history of something none of us are responsible for. Get over yourself and live life to the fullest before taking on somebody else's guilt or crimes which there's plenty on every side
@@hailoweenhailoween5264. I’m Native American and Scottish/Norwegian, but your claim isn’t true - the Scottish have also had long ties with the Native American community.
@@hailoweenhailoween5264 Out of curiosity. What could/should be done to suffice everyone enough to take those feelings away? Even those who didn't live through any of it....what would be enough? What can suffice everyone enough to be like "okay debt is paid, we have what we want or needed to comfort our feelings and now we can just move forward."
I think every member of the dominant African-American society should apologize for the mayhem Their culture has caused this country.
The excuse will be that it's because of systemic racism keeping them down is why every other minority group and/or immigrants are able to succeed in the US except them.
Why are you talking about blacks when this man is talking about natives.
@@bootnazz1786 were going by emotions like this kid.
@@HANKHILLFORTXGOVERNOR kid spoke logic
Charlie Kirk kicks arse😜
Do they owe aplogies to the descendents of the people they killed during their raids?
If this guy says he’s part Mexican? Then he should denounce the white Spaniards that through the Roman Empire Catholicism conquest” conquered Mexico, which was lands of Indians to begin with? And they did it in a very brutal way where hundreds and thousands of Indians died in the way they conquered the Indian lands that we now know as Mexico? So if he knows that history? Then he should help pay back to the 100% Indians for what his white Spaniard European ancestors did to the Indians in Mexico??
What about the Aztec Empire? They brutally exploited other tribes
@@oncho1960 That’s true! All the Indian tribes that were here in these territories were at war with each other at one point or another.
@@user-jq4tb7yr8m. True, and some of them were cannibals.
Well then there's the Aztecs. Do Aztecs owe anything to the other indigenous they conquered? No. What a silly "western" concept.
You seem like you also need a history lesson.
I guess no one wants to address the modern exploitation of people by "Native Americans" with casinos.
Listen to this guy - he honestly thinks he's got Charlie over a barrel!
Listen to his swagger, he thinks he's got an unassailable accusation of racism, and that Charlie and everyone else will just bow down and kiss his backside.
I'm GLAD Charlie did not bow down to this guy.
Should have asked him if he was going to pay reperations for slavery? The Apache many ithers an in fact all of the five civilized tribes practiced slavery.
West Africa is the only one who needs to pay black americans. They sold them in the first place. Nice try
White guy says he's part Apache and part Mexican😂😂😂
Looks a bit Jewish to me. 🤷♀️🤷♀️
In the 1800 both sides were vicious. It’s called survival of the fittest.
Thank you, sir for showing this. You are right. The only thing we can do about history is learn from it, and move on. Well said!
What does this Apache think this land mass would be like if Caucasians did not come here? Roads, bridges, farms, railroads, electricity, running water, etc. would NOT be here.
Hitler would have come here,5 machine guns and there are no more indians or casinos..
they would have advanced still just not as fast as the US did.
@@viperdemonz-jenkins they don't have the smarts to advance. They'd still be wearing animals and using bow and arrows.
@@viperdemonz-jenkins it would have become part of spain.
Damm straight I don’t anyone apologize
Well spoken by Charlie Kirk. God bless.
This touched me so much i sent him a buy one get one free at Arbys.
I am from Rome and I don't apologize to anyone for what my ancestors did 😊
NEVER IN HISTORY HAS SO MUCH BEEN ASKED FOR FROM SO LITTLE PEOPLE FOR DOING NOTHING
The bureau of Indian affairs was the first federal government bureaucracy. Look how well it worked out for the Indians.
Reparations can only be given to the person wronged, not to any relatives or future generations either.
If that guys Apache ancestors weren't so weak, they wouldn't have been conquered. Nobody owes him an apology.
Exactly! They weren't more virtuous, they just fking lost. Be proud your people won
Acknowledging the wrongs of the past doesn't mean one has to apologize for something they didn't do. Plain and simple.
I am so sick of all these people playing the victim card. 🙄😒 Grow a set people.
How do we even know if this guy is Apache/Mexican ,just because he says he is. How do know he isn’t from the same tribe as Senator Warren ? 😂
You were conquered, get over it
..
It's not over yet. America today is paying for what happened. That's why America has a president who can't even remember anything, a bad economy, gas and food prices going through the roof, closer to going to war with Russia, China, the Middle East, woke politics. It just makes me happy to see you Americans get all mad of what's happening to your country.
Let's agree on that!
BUT! America unfortunately, is being conquered right now, GET OVER IT?
@@hailoweenhailoween5264. Bull. The USA has been taken over by globalists whose mission is to crash western society, and indeed societal structures all across the globe, to bring in the “great reset.” Everything happening is intentional and being orchestrated from within. The joy you take in anyone’s suffering only speaks volumes to your moral decay - and the reset is coming to you and everyone else, wherever you are. You won’t be happy long.
@@jesse-zp6ko There's a difference. in one situation, the war has been over for over a century. in the other situation, the one you are refereeing to, the war is happening. you fight while it's happening, when its over is when it's time to let it go. Unfortunately, the left has done a great job in schools at getting kids to hate their country, and if you are white, to hate your race, so it's a difficult fight to try and correct the brainwashing and to few are fighting it like Charlie is. it may be a losing battle, but it's a battle you have to fight while you can.
100 years this"apache" would be scalped as a white man lol
At least the guy didn’t try to double down and blame everyone else. Props to him
It's the exact same here in Australia regarding the Aboriginal/First Nations people.
In fact, National Reconciliation Week is coming up.
I am descended from Spanish who intermarried with Jacarilla Apache, Comanche, Hopi and Tiwa. It is a complicated history. I am mixed ethnicity with all these tribes and also other Europeans. I too do not expect to give or receive an apology for something done by those hundreds of years ago. It is wrong to suppress and destroy another person, but without the intermarriage i would not be alive today. I agree with Charlie that everyting the government touches goes to hell. I applaud all the tribes who are taking control of their destiny and thriving. All tribes should be allowed to do the same.
How about what the aztecs did the apache chiene iroquoi maians, incas, the number of tribes that did far worse, shouldn't they apologise.
The native Americans were also slavers, buying their own African slaves as well.
@@qetoun and their own, other tribes, etc.
I have a good question: why are all Reservations littered with broken down cars and trucks?? It Looks like a junk yard, and Most Natives have turned to alcohol and drugs. When you get a "free government check every month, and have no drive or goals, You will try and fill the emptiness inside with other destructive things.
At least both sides were respectful and didn’t scream at each other.
Charlie Kirk might have added that Native Americans can go to college at a huge discount, compared to others, by virtue of being Indians.
What about White people that their family wasn't even here in this Country during those times. It crazy to say they owe someone for the color of their skin.
Let Native Americans on the reservations borrow against the land! Get government out of the way!
As A Native American myself: RoseBud Sioux (Lakota) The White People do owe us more than just an apolgoy.
As someone who carries Crow and Cherokee blood. I know nothing about the heritage of the blood I carry, so I won't be entitled enough to think of making demands of people who had nothing to do with the past.
Even if I did know, I'd rather make better strides to do what's best for my people to make peace with ourselves and other people, rather than making demands of apology of another people's descendants, in which, most of them would more than likely be my friends.
Why make enemies of people by forcing them to apologize and make reparations for something they had nothing to do with, when you can make friends to find prosperity and fortune for ourselves and future generations?
Is tell him to sit on that “apology”
Yes sir, you are right. Let’s move on.
They called them savages back then but the savagery was what was perpetrated upon the native Americans sick and sad 😢
Yo, my man. I applaud what you do. I do not know your background but you represent the mentality that everyone living in the USofA should have. You respect the country and understand how important and precious she is. I am a refugee that is now an American citizen and can say that i love America and it's the greatest country there is, even with flaws. It breaks my heart to see what the Left has done and continue to do.
Also, i went back to a video you made 2 yrs ago and your English is much better now...keep up the good fight.
A bunch of beggars who think there's just enough popular support that they can finally cash in
Mescalero Apache here born and raised in Besonhurst Brooklyn NY. Wanna say that to my face? We don’t ask anything from anyone! This dude doesn’t speak for anyone. We do fine all by ourselves and the ones that don’t wish to assimilate, it’s there right and they can stay on the reservation. No one begs for shit!
They guy asked for an acknowledgement, not an apology.
I agree a million percent with Charlie. I will apologize for my own personal wrongdoing to anyone, but I will NEVER apologize to anyone for something I didn't do. I will most certainly NEVER apologize to anyone because I'm white.
Furthermore, if this guy wants whites to apologize for the wrongs committed against his people, the Apache, what about him apologizing for all the heinous things the Apache did to white settlers and other Indian Tribes/Nations? Back in the day, the Apache were some scary, if not terrifying, people.
Excellent response and the man appreciated it, all these comments are unnecessary. As human beings we should help each other in the here and now. The past can't be changed and nobody alive is responsible for it. My Great grandfather was Irish, My Great grandmother was Cherokee. My Great Grandfather was a Judge and argued cases before the SCOTUS of the State he lived in. When he died, his wife a native American, was forced to marry a white man to retain her joint property, a substantial amount of land, etc. She had 1 year to do this or lose everything. She married a man who turned out to be a drunk and would often beat her. My Grandfather about 17 years old stabbed him in the hand, during one of the beatings, as no law enforcement would intervene on behalf of a native American wife. As a native American Male he would have been jailed if not hung. He ran away and went to California with his best friend, Tom Mix, they worked on a ranch together as cowboys. As a result, when his mother passed away, all the property and wealth went to his family. My Sister went to the town and verified all of this. Do I think the people who live on this land now or the ancestors of the man who beat her owe me anything. No, they are innocent and had nothing to do with it. Why punish them for the deeds of another. I choose to take the high road. If not for this incident, my grandfather, never would have met my grandmother and I wouldn't even be here. There are families, children, buildings with businesses on that land. Should I emulate those responsible for injustice and invoke injustice upon others merely for the color of their skin. No. I am not a victim. I prefer we do everything we can to help anyone in this country lift themselves up. Love thy neighbor as you love yourself, do unto others as you would have them do unto you. No interest loans with easy payments for education including trade schools, etc. Tax breaks for the first 5 years for all citizens who are impoverished when they start businesses. These types of breaks cost taxpayers nothing as employees and customers pay sales taxes, etc. they actually add to the tax base of local economies where the business is located because they spend money in other local business. Return mineral rights to landowners instead of allowing government corruption to sell them off to large corporations. These types of reforms lift all, and harm none.
96% white. 4% apache. Thinks he's apache. lmao
My great-great grandmother was full blooded Cherokee. What our forefathers did to the native Americans was terrible but there isn’t a single person alive today that was personally involved in what happened then. We as white individuals owe no apologies to the native Americans. Our government made the decision to treat them brutally and it is to blame.
Never owned any Slaves
Never killed any Indians.
Wasn't even here at the time.
we all didn't have that honour and privilege unfortunately.
I'm part Cherokee and part white, the answer to your question is no!
There is a case for a mother apologising for her elder son punching another child,, but you would not expect the younger brother to have to apologise..
Thank you for this excellent video, and keep up the good work.
First and foremost NOBODY is going to make me apologize because they demand it.
he Jews should apologize for Howie Mandel and Pauly Shore
My Great Great Grandparents were slaughtered by the Apache. There is not an Apache alive today who owes my family reparations. As my family or myself owes not any American Indian reparations!! I am greatful to the Spainish family who found my Great Grandfather and raised him. This also reminds me of a young man from the Southwest who said "We should have another Pueblo Revolt" A friend of mine told him to give back our horses ,the line that brings electricity, our vehicles and our phones. He changed his mind 😂
Why would you WANT an apology that you have to ask for?
Just subscribed great channel thank you ❤
¿Are you "The Man In The Jar"!?!!!
The oldest skeleton found in north america was found to be 13,000 years old and they found out when they did a DNA test it had 25% european DNA so.... (and the most races that have the most problem with alcohol are north american indians/Eskimos/and the austraslian aborigine because they never invented it themselves and have not had it for thousands of years to a just too it )
Apache were WARRIORS, I doubt very much they were roaming the frontier in need of an apology. Grow a pair Tonto
No one owns a apology for something that happen before they were even born
Meanwhile, he cuturally appropriated Bono...
Inuk chuk!!!
Since time began and human beings appeared, there has been interbreeding among us. 23 and Me has become popular, almost a game with some, serious business for others. Imagine the surprise when my own report came back with 3% Subsaharan African. I was told all my life that my family were English, French, a little Irish for spice, and a great big helping of Native American. Nothing was ever mentioned about Subsahran Africa, nothing said about eastern European, but the report said that was somehow in the majority, with something like 9% undetermined origin. For that many elements in one DNA sample, it becomes very hard for someone to point a finger and tell me, or you, that you owe apologies. Nobody owes apologies. One side of my family is from England after the New World was found, came here as endentured, worked a period of years before they could claim a single cent their work earned. I just found out last month that contrary to Elizabeth Warren, my 19 times great grandmother actually WAS Pocahontas, with Kokoum as her husband, before she was taken to England where she had her other life. And that puts my bloodline on this continent before the very first settlers after the Vikings. Maybe pre-Mayflower, maybe about the same time. We ALL came from a common ancestor, we owe each other nothing but the respect of one human for another. And I don't care what shade your skin is, we ALL had our crosses to bear, and it's time to lay down the grudges and be the family that we actually are instead of being each other's enemy. It's time to lay that particular burden to rest.
He can't be native American. None of the people ask for apologies. Just be treated fairly. He must be too lazy.
If he's half mexican and half Apache he's gonna have one helluva conversation with himself later. The Apache and Mexicans fought one another.
But as for what Charlie said? Spot on, none of us alive today owe an apology for stuff that happened long before we were born. And I'm only responsible for whay i do or say, or how i react to what someone else says or does. Nothing more
Every Independence Day we celebrate our Founding Fathers who had the courage to go against the British monarch and create their own government. They had a vision for a government controlled by the people where every citizen had the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. They also knew the decision to break away from the British empire was bold and would come with a price. But they had faith that freedom would prevail.
You have the freedom of choice because we all have different interests and desires; therefore, no one can tell another person what to do with their life or how to live it! In order for society as a whole to not only survive but thrive, it needs a diversity of views and opinions on issues such as religion, politics, economics, etc.
Even an ‘idiot’ has basic rights in the constitution to freedom of conscience, religion, opinion, thought and belief. Even ‘idiots’ have the right to freedom of expression as well as the right to the protection of inherent dignity. Every person has the right to freedom of conscience, religion, thought, belief and opinion.
This simply means that nobody has the right to interfere with anyone’s freedom to think they way they want, to hold the beliefs that they want and to formulate and have their opinions.
Even idiots have the right to be an idiot and to have that right respected.
As soon as you say colonists I no longer give a shit about what you think.
Fyi, if Jackson hadn't moved those Indians then they would have been wiped out by the Americans.
I accept no responsibility for anything that I personally did not do, what my ancestors did has nothing to do with me.
Move forward- leave the past alone except to learn from it and do good today.
In Canada the Prime Minister formally apologized to the native people.
Wasn't good enough.
The Governor General apologized.
Wasn't good enough.
The Queen of England apologized on behalf of all English people. Not good enough.
What is an apology from me going to accomplish? What is an apology from Charlie going to accomplish?
I'm so sick of this APOLOGY BULLSHIT "Let him who is without sin among you be the first to throw a stone at her" GET OVER IT ALREADY
I agree with him; but what the hay does he mean by "Abraham Lincoln was no hero"?
Lmfao “Apache-Mexican” dude looks like he was in U2
I’m mixed race Native American, my grandfather was born on a Reservation and I will say that I tend to agree with Charlie Kirk’s premise of not needing to apologize for anything that you didn’t have a hand in however I will also point out that people have this false idea that the things that happened to the Native Americans were generally more than a century ago and that couldn’t be further from the truth other than yeah it started centuries ago. I’m going to point out some more recent examples.
Church Rock Nuclear Disaster, after WWII the government came to the tribes in the 4 Corners region wanting to prospect for Uranium and the Navajo Nation agreed to let them mine in exchange for some improvements made to the Reservation to make it better for the people but the improvements were never fully completed and also the dangers were not explained, this is a tribe that even today not everyone has modern household conveniences like electricity and indoor plumbing so they definitely didn’t understand nuclear dangers. What do you think happened, a giant tailings pond was created at the mine and was left long after the mine closed and when a storm breached that tailings pond it poisoned the entire area killing livestock making water unusable causing cancer in large numbers of people in that area and decades after the first breach it’s still not fixed, they clean it up the way a kid cleans up their room tossing everything under the bed or in the closet, of course with nuclear contamination that kind of cleanup doesn’t work but it’s only a bunch of poor Indians so who cares about repeated breaches.
Next is the Government Funded Boarding Schools, the ones in Canada that were all over the news a couple years ago because they found hundreds of unmarked graves of children, well America had those Boarding Schools too and ours were just as bad. Kids taken from their families sent out of state forced to learn how to live like a White Man because they could save the Soul if they killed the Savage out of the kids. Basically if you talked in your language they would physically beat you sometimes to death and the same if they caught you practicing anything else from your culture. Sexual abuse was not an uncommon occurrence for the girls. Also this Boarding School practice kept going through the 1960’s.
That Indian Health Service that’s meant to be a we’re sorry thing from the government is not exactly so great. America has actually been investigated by the UN for Crimes Against Humanity for Involuntarily Sterilizing women who went to clinics for treatment like normal OBGYN care, yeah look it up. Oh yeah then there’s the doctors who liked their intimate partners to be on the very young side. Quite literally a DR would get reported for inappropriate behavior with proof even and the Indian Health Service would just move him to a different Reservation with a new victim pool to start abusing, almost seems like the Catholic Church doesn’t it. Now before you say that can’t possibly be true I assure you that it is but you can always go online and look at the PBS Newshour as they did a lengthy investigation of one such DR and he just got moved from reservation to reservation but finally after the PBS program got involved that DR did finally get investigated arrested and is in Federal Prison but he was just 1 predator in that corrupt system and that crap is still going on now so it’s not old history.
While the average American has absolutely nothing to apologize for involving those issues the government workers and the government itself obviously do because they were the ones participating in that stuff and I think acknowledging that would go a long way towards healing open wounds that still exist with people who were affected firsthand not a family member or distant family member. Also opening up the sites of those former Boarding Schools and letting scientists come in with GPR to locate the bodies of kids that never got to come back home.
Charlie Kirk hits this issue head on,with a reasoned response. The children are not responsible for the sins of the father.
And let’s not forget all the grueling deaths caused by the Apaches to the Comanches. A sincere apology is due.
Native Americans have rights which is more than I can say for indigenous Christian’s in the Middle East! Native Americans have given rights to people! They have reservations and respect! They don’t pay taxes and have opportunities to make their reservations better. Everything is on you as a person to make yourself better!
No! Apologize to your own people for not doing better!
I want reparations from anyone that is a descendent of a Barbary Pirate.
Beret man uses the term ‘colonist’ yet America has not been such a thing in 240+ years
He said the government has done a terrible job with establishment and use of the Bureau of Indian Affairs.
The government has done a terrible job with most everything it has Touched!
That's why we need smaller government! They spend Boatloads of money to do a Horrible job with pretty much everything!
When the indigenous People start taking Responsibility for their actions and DEMAND that their Leaders stop taking advantage of the People they are REPRESENTING, become ACCOUNTABLE People.... stop being victims with your hand out stretched., Contribute to Society.
Charlie Kirk spoke the truth in a way that needed to be told.
THANK YOU CHARLIE FOR EDUCATING THE IGNORANT
I’m responsible for my mistakes. Nobody else’s.
Love your channel man
What the hell is he gonna do with an apology?
Let's not forget what the Apache did to the Navajo, the Metis, and the native people who originally lived in the areas of Texas, NM, and AZ. The Apache slaughtered them to take all possessions and continued to do so for 80 years until a more violent people came and took what they wanted from the Apache, before the white man...the Comanche.
I'm Latino/Hispanic, Native- American, a little caucasian, No one owes me anything, it would be an insult to do so, really...
I went to school in an area consisting of a heavy Caucasian population, thank God !. But with the same balance of Mexican Americans, (as well as others.) And I just can't help but notice that in the areas not too far from us, l saw/see the results of kids who were educated in heavily Hispanic. Latino School zones.(as well as other non white balanced fully ethnic areas ) [of course Asian Areas excluded ], These folks are just not as articulate ( not all but most ). As well as other things which are painfully obviouse to me, but which they seem to have no clue about regarding. I've also seen Caucasians who within a few beats i can tell were definitely raised outside of Caucasian neighborhoods or grew up with kids of a heavy Ethnic influence, I shake my head & think how sad. Before you judge me i speak fluent Spanish, was and am immersed heavily in Mexican - Chicano Culture and intermix with all cultures, just the fact that i was lucky enough to growv up in, and around their periphery, ( Whites I mean ), I'm certain, makes me more open minded and embracing of other cultures and the world at large.I say and see this from experience in my elder age, I definately know this, and no one will ever take this understanding from me, its as true as the Sun sets and rises every day.
First, descendants of the Comanche should apologize to the Apache for committing genocide against them. Then the Chippewa should apologize the Sioux for chasing them out of Minnesota and colonizing their land, after which the Sioux should apologize to the Kiowa for colonizing their land.