Deputy Conservative leader and NDP finance critic discuss federal budget | CTV Question Period
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 05. 2024
- Deputy Conservative leader Melissa Lantsman and NDP Finance Critic Don Davies react to the federal budget.
Subscribe to CTV News to watch more videos: / ctvnews
Connect with CTV News:
For live updates and latest headlines visit: www.ctvnews.ca/
For breaking news, fast, download the CTV News App: www.ctvnews.ca/app
Must-watch stories and full programs at www.ctvnews.ca/video
CTV News on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/discover/CTV-News
CTV News on X (formerly Twitter): / ctvnews
CTV News on Reddit: / ctvnews
CTV News on LinkedIn: / ctv-news
---
CTV News is Canada's most-watched news organization both locally and nationally, and has a network of national, international, and local news operations.
The only reason the NDP is voting for the budget is because they know the conservatives will win otherwise.
its like you think they would prefer a con government to a liberal one.
NDP will vote with Trudeau
There's the pension too. They won't have it if they lose their seats before October 2025.
And they haven’t yet earned their pensions ….
Would it not be grand if jag is due feb 25th pension he calls for non confidence vote march 1st
Jack Layton would be rolling in his grave if he could see the state of the NDP under jags leadership and I don’t think he’d be too happy with the back bench NDP MPs.
Agreed!!!
Jack Layton would have been one guy who could bring a country together. Justin just fragmented it more.
The NDP keeping their “word”……what a joke!
Russian bot.
@@Liberal_From_Prairies689Chinese bot
@@Liberal_From_Prairies689you are the most braindead cultist in history.
conservatives not serving canadian but care more about their corporate interests/masters. We would only know about their policies until next election.😮 see you in next election 😂
@@hameedkhorami1485 you might be there next election but Jugmeat won’t 😆
The day that Trudeau is kicked out of office must be called a National holiday to celebrate
Our independence day
The NDP will vote for the budget because they want their pensions next year. They know they're politically dead anyway. Their only hope to comeback is to get rid of Jagmeet and get a real leader who stands for the working class.
This all about the pension now it’s beyond Trudeau control,he’s lost the leadership to money, I wonder how it feels for him to loose the leadership trust
LOL, these bot accounts will say anything...
With Charlie Angus leaving, that party is d.o.a.
@@mrkang4080what makes that a bot account? Everything he said is right.
Just because your little brain doesn’t agree with it doesn’t make him a bot. Makes you a fool
And saying "corporate greed" over and over again while supporting the Liberals. Hopefully his political career is finished after the next election.
NDP is an absolute clown show propping up this incompetent government. They should be ashamed of themselves
They have no shame
Oh ya let's replace them with a government who literally doesn't have policy! An actual do nothing government!
@PengWinCZcams election is Oct 2025. They don't need any now. Anyone else.announce.their policies
But, but, but ... who'll look after their Pensions! Jiggy won't be able to afford another Rolex!
@@PengWinCZcamsthe conservatives have been clear about their plans. You just haven’t been paying attention.
The Liberals are the “do nothing” party.
NDP will support budget because Singh is holding out for his pension.
NDP don't care about Canadians only about there pensions. If you vote NDP you might as well vote Liberal.
Pierre Poilievre qualified for pension at the age of 31
So what Con policy will fix the problem? I will wait.
@@thrillhouse7867 What's your point?
@@martinzarathustra8604 Which problem are you referring to? The budget?
@@martinzarathustra8604 At least they will be tough on crime and bring order in the immigration system.
The NDP are holding Canadians Hostage. They Don't Deserve to be anywhere near Ottawa, and I certainly hope that the Canadian voters make that abundantly clear in the next election. I have NEVER, and I mean NEVER, seen anything like what they have done in all my years, and I truly hope that I NEVER have to witness something like this ever again. The NDP are the Absolute WORST - And as far as I am concerned what they have done with this so called Coalition should be illegal... PERIOD.
Like what? Make big claim, you better back it up. Your anger is making you stupid.
I agree with you 100%
NEVER underestimate the stew-pidity of our fellow Canadians
How are they absolute worst? Conservatives created shared services, and they wanted to move away from housing at federal level so what 😅
The absolute worst indeed.
Horrendous!!!
Two medications does not a pharmacare program make
Jagmeet will vote yes for the budget to ensure he gets his full pension. Wake up Canada
25 seats doesn't have the power your r@cism does
Love this reporter hold everyone to be accountable to there policies. This is real journalism.
😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
🤣🤣🤣🤣 seriously? Every time Lantsman spoke, she turned on her deaf ear syndrome, and tried to say that she didn't say something. 🙄
Not really since bell owns these slaves
She is trying to make conservatives look bad and they are not even in power.
@@voltairedecent255 To your point she still pushed for a response. It's because its not the response you wanted it seem. There politician you know that right.
Provinces already have school food programs, and pharma care programs
And dental for low income as well as indigenous. It’s called Smiles Programs and includes dental surgery.
Overreach
Why would conservatives let the liberals know what their election promises will be. 10 dollar day care? A joke! The NDP have no power and get nothing but anger from Canadians for keeping the inept liberals in power. They will do worse that the liberals in the next election
Singh only concerned about his pension. NDP should be outcast from parliament
90% of parliament is doing this. It sucks but that's politics. It's just money.
Singh’s pension isn’t the only NDP’er that is due next year. There are a few others that are due their pensions.
And he’s doing this at the peril of his own party, as they will be in “non party status” territory next election.
If NDP supports this budget they are done
singh is more concerned about his golden pension he doesnt qualify until Feb 2025 we all know he will vote with the Liberals
They're already done, so they might as well just vote for it and collect their pensions next year.
They are done anyway.
@@egc04 Why would be care? Chances are he will win his riding if an election is called today. I have no idea what your point is. I think you need to read some books.
I wish the NDP voters would protest in the streets against this budget that the Liberals are bringing down. They are about as du... as the Trump supporters
If parents where not taxed to death they could feed there kids 6:57
Exactly!!
Yes, food is so expensive now
They cause a problem then want to fix it it’s a complete joke
NDP is full of crap
The budget didnt balance itself....obviously. He needs to understand monetary policy and the economy doesnt grow from the heart.
he just needs to go away
Really?
Pension pension pension pensions is all the criminal NDP care for
It sounds like they care about getting more affordable houses built and getting nutritious food into schools. Did you even listen to the interview?
Thanks Vassy for asking tough questions by all parliamentary
The NDP are using consultants to study the budget? Smfh.
that would be because not one of them is sm::::art enough to figure it out on therevown!!
Dental care and pharma care is a joke
Jag needs to go too
If anyone should know about greed, it is Jaghmeet Singh !
Both Jagmeet and Trudeau have pit a huge dent spending so much of our hard earned taxpayers money!
The NDP is such a joke
You can enroll as many ppl as you want to dental care but when dentists say no it’s all moot. These NDP ppl are delusional
It will just turn into another racket. Dentistry was going that way anyway. Unnecessary x-rays, cosmetic procedures and apparently everyone and their brother now grinds their teeth while sleeping.
Agreed, and with an outside insurance company handling claims, the dentists are worried they won't get paid! One more failure for the twits!
The ndp will absolutely support the liberal spending budget. They do not care about Canada’s future. More government, more spending and let the middle class be destroyed.
Stop deficit spending
How? You can type but ax the tax is silly ranting. Maybe cons show read the budget. Or write one already. Rhetoric doesn't get you anything. Cons province leader cut your wages housing and hiring lol not feds not the liberal. Ask missy why?.
Don Davis, the NDP has no a platform to cut spending. You have no idea how to fix the deficit.
As a middle class family of Canadian (at least I thought I was), I hardly benefits anything from the Pharmacare program or Childcare program during the past 10 days. In fact, all those so-called "benefits" annouced by the Libs meant very little to me and my family. Due to the family income level, there is close to nothing we can call "benefits" if you compare to the raise of living cost from the past 10 years. I am not bought by the "programs". In the end, how comfortable that Canadian feel about their living cost get to say everything, not what those politics like to say in front of a camera.
BALANCED BUDGETS ONLY
When is the last time a Conservative government ran a balanced budget?
Melissa is absolutely right, none of these programs are actually real.
The major driver of the cost of everything is Jagmeets greed.
Truth!
You mean Rolly Singh?
Bank of Canada is part to blame. They kept interest rates too low for too long.
They had too Trudeau was spending like a drunken sailor ,and it's now caught up with the Liberals
Those were the instructions from the bosses in DC
They absolutely did BUT they have been practicing a fair show of financial responsibility while the Liberal-NDP has only continued to add to debt and decrease economic output by way of the last 2 budgets preceding this.
B of C is not fully independent. It is heavily influenced by PM, and our PM wanted rates staying low as long as possible to. Rebate an illusion of economic growth and prosperity
It was their excessive money printing that was their part to blame
I’d say is is called Singh greed
Pensions Pensions Pensions period
Singh must go!!!
The NDP is a total waste of space.
Corporate greed well when corporate decides to leave Canada then where are we?
No dentists are participating
NDP are one and the same as the Liberals and have caused this insane hardship on CANADIANS
You are CON what do you care about hardship?
Pierre for PM the rest send them to manual labor since we have a shortage
Vassy, great job on behalf of yourself and Canadians, thank you.
Thank you Melissa
For not answering questions?!?
Pierre poilievre has got my vote
So you fell for his slogans and NO policies
Cons and Libs have been in power for the past 20 years and here we are.
Well his deputy is not that different from Freeland! She can’t say if they are for or against raising tax on capital gain ?!!
@@red149 and PP and the CONS have NO solutions just slogans, bumper stickers, and fearmongering
@@sergeikhripun Yes here we are I voted for Mulroney, even Mike Harris, and Harper and now see I WAS WRONG, The CONS are Cons
Hey, N.D.P voters clean the crap from your ears, think for yourselves. Stop supporting the doom the Liberal coalition is putting on Canadians..
The NDP had a leadership review this year and reaffirmed their support for Jagmeet.
5:06 Vassy's like, "no, that's incorrect" 🤣
Trudeau and the NDP are toast.
Big Spenders of our money! It is abhorrent how much they have spent on trips and how they are being hated abroad and shamed Canada!
Election now please Pierre for PM
What's the point if conservatives won't reverse the changes. They can't even say it.
@@epictetus3406because you don’t announce what your government platform is till around election time or the other parties could steal your ideas
I really don't understand how anyone can still support the NDP.
What happened to funding healthcare, we need Doctors in Canada and healthcare workers. Get rid of the beauracracy in healthcare.
ask the premieer smith and ford and moe then
Wow, what a great interviewer! This is what we need. An interviewer who doesn’t pander to anyone. She asked tough questions and challenged when they didn’t provide answers. I am so grateful for this type of interview. This country needs it. Thank you
Where are all of these interviewers when JT is "answering" questions? No one ever holds him accountable.
Here let's make this simple for ndp and liberal voters...
More spending / more immigration equals higher interest rates and fewer houses.
True but we need reassurance the Cons won't go back to their Jason Kenney playbook of bringing in immigrations to keep wages low... they haven't said they won't!
NDP finance critic? Isn’t that an oxymoron?
I like how the host owned both of these government clowns.
Jagmeet is talking about Corporate greed but he only cares about his pension so the ndp party should avoid him.
Jack Layton was the best leader the NDP had. Pierre Poilievre is a career politician, and gets a sizeable political pension, once he becomes 55.
If dentists haven’t signed up by now they won’t do it. That’s NDPs irresponsible projections
Fantasy projects and plans with no tangible foundation!
It's concerning that Lantsman won't say they'll claw back the capital gains tax. Really troubling.
It’s smart actually, it’s the liberals trying to set a trap.
I am a huge supporter of the Cons for the next government but yes, Lantsman was flat footed and sounded more like a Liberal in question period. Shame on her.
Do you show your cards before the bet?
She will tell it on campaign time. She is like i don't wanns say anything yet. Of course they wil claw it back.
@@lordfogg9728fair point
This reporter just exposes how bad our politicians are! They never have a straight answer
That's a problem that exists across party lines. It's infuriating.
@@Alex-js5lg
Im scared Pierre will be another Trudeau if elected … i hope not tho
@@Shiro642definitely not , he's going to help Canada get out of this serious danger Canada is in 😢
@@donnarocha4043 by... picking on trans kids and catering to oil companies?
@@Alex-js5lg Picking on? Since when stop spreading misinformation
Vash your not getting a policy until an election is called, come on you should no this ......
i wish governments would promote small business and reduce waste in government.
If only reporters would push the liberals to answer questions as hard as they push conservatives.
He says we are here for Canadians 🤣🤣🤦🏻♀️!! The NDP is finished! They will get decimated in the next election because they’ve done EVERYTHING but act in the best interest of Canadians! The Liberal/NDP coalition NEEDS TO GO !!!!!
Yes, agree 100%
Vassy rocks! This is how quality interviewers do their job.
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
She was on point and doing her job because there were no Liberals present for her to kiss up to.
The NDP is the biggest part of the problem offering free this and that which every Canadian would love however not on borrowed money which is counter intuitive ,costing Canadians more in inflation spending and borrowing costs
cut the gov't completely sack 60% of emplyees and most services.
The economy is shrinking but government is growing. Totally disconnected to reality.
YES!
This guy from the MVP must be living in the clouds or something
What's the MVP?
Pierre P will present his economic program going into the elections, and at the present moment Conservatives will keep taking apart Liberal and NDP’s incompetence
That is exactly what the job of the opposition is. To point out the shortcomings of the current government.
About time! Enough of NDP/Liberal pact
Gagmeet is just one big laughing stock of an NDP leader .... What an excuse for someone who wants to help Canadians ..... Yet he doesn't
Hot air…lol
Why did she keep dodging the question?
because they will axe the tax, especially the ones that effect the rich
She is wise to not reveal too much conservative platform before an election campaign. It keeps the NDP or Liberals from stealing their policies!
and give the liberals and ndp a heads up and ideas to take? kinda silly. that would be like the NFL swapping play books....
Libs call an election and we will expect an official position from Conservatives on cap gains inclusion rate hike….
Because conservative logic is illogical
Please define "fair share". I am sick and tired of politicians using this stupid sentence. How about every single person in Canada pay the same percentage? Those who are on welfare and financial support who are fit and able be given a time period and cut off date for that support so they are forced to become positive contributors to the country.
new comers included
My DEFINITION OF A FAIR SHARE for risk entrepreneurial takers: All Individuals or corporations that fund loans to (or buy shares in) profit-oriented business ventures deserve a risk based return on their investment that exceeds the after-tax yield they receive on risk-free government bonds or CDIC insured Guaranteed Investment Certificates.
@@egc04nope we need way less newcomers!! .there a huge part of this problem!!
I guarantee NDP support the budget
The NDP are a stain on Canada.
No, Jagmeet, the astronomical cost of living in Canada is not caused by corporate greed. It caused by astronomical housing bubble that sucks all disposable income, and the lack of competition being the result of Governmental policies.
The increase in capital gains tax will do one thing for sure. It will help that hesitant doctor to finally make the decision to leave Canada, all at a time when we want more doctors.
Jag highest expense mp other than the PM
So basically the NDP will pass it
Great job by the host of pressing both guests and attempting to extract concrete answers. The evasionary tactics were disappointing, Canadians deserve to have the strategies more clearly communicated. I feel like I learned nothing from this exchange, despite the best efforts of the host.
This budget can’t go through not with the ridiculous capital gains tax increase
If you earn $250k on a year through labour, you pay literally 3x as much tax as someone who earns $250k in profit from selling real estate or stocks.
Only Canadians signed up but no dentist. Dentists are not doing it. It’s like organizing a birthday party but the birthday person was not invited
So true! 😂
October 2025 becomes closer as each month passes.
Lantsman was given three minutes and four opportunities to say "yes" or "no" to whether the cons would keep or reverse the capital gains tax increase and dodged it on every opportunity. What an embarrassment. At least Davies had some sort of substance in his answer, even though I have no doubt they'll support the budget to keep their pensions.
There’s no dentist and child care centers are closing as they are not receiving money and pharma care sucks whooo hooo birth control and diabetes meds. All this sucks NDP
"Free dental care", that is not true. The dentist said that. Patients need to pay anyway.
I wish the conservatives would give more ideas of what they will do.
They will be on the next election platform. It won't serve them if they disclose it now.
They will when the election is called , they are not going to share that before
Wait for the election then they will give you an answer
They will roll out their platform when the time is right. Smart Canadians in that party .
@donnarocha4043 When the time is right? The CPC contradicts themselves. What are they going to do about issues that are worldwide? No Canadian government will be able to rectify matters that are worldwide.
Of course Jag will support it. If he doesnt, no pension for him
Unlike the Conservatives who raised the old age pension age to 67 when they were in power. That works out to about $28,000 out of every couples pocket between the age of 65-67. all they had to do was raise the premiums ever so slightly when they got elected but they did nothing about it for 10 years. Everybody knew the baby boomers were retiring except the cons.
5 mins in and neither of them have answered a single question 😂
The truth is that the government resourcing funds from the citizen's taxes. The government should learn how to invest and earn money, not from taxes only.
If NDP support this budget they will decimate their chances as a party in ever getting any members in parliament after the next election is over
Just whom do we, as Canadians, paid the interest too? Who receives the interest payments.
Bond holders and bankers
@hexxlaxx2992 do the bankers have an endless supply of cash? Where does all the currency come from for the bankers to lend? Who are the bond holders?
It's not endless supply of money
@@lloydkuepfer1599 Who has 32 trillion to lend to the USA as an example?
Not Canada's problem
They criticized the liberals for not answering questions, I am voting PC but they better do better interviews then this. Seemed very unprepared.
Solid interviewer. Pointing out holes in both guests parties instead of just one or the other.
We pay tax on income then buy our home then when we sell we have pay again!
Basset….don’t change. You are the best interviewer in a long time..
Jagmeet is not very bright. NDP are concerned about one thing. Pensions.
"5. **Interventionism**: One of Mises's critical lessons is the problematic nature of government intervention in the economy. He argued that such interventions, while often well-intended, lead to unintended consequences that can disrupt and distort the market, leading to inefficiencies and economic decline."
Today is day 113 of 2024 . If the liberal-NDP want to build 3.9 million homes by 2031 they would need to have built 170,856 by midnight today. That's 63 houses per HOUR 24/7. 270% increase on the average construction of home.
How did they pass school when they cant even answer questions 😆
I was a serious NDPer years ago i wouldnt vote NDP or Liberal if my life depended on it come on Pierre
Me too , I love Canada 🇨🇦 ❤
Alberta already sends more money to support other Provinces but none want to support the development of this LNG, oil and gas products except the Conservatives.
Exactly, drill baby drill get Canada out of this disaster 😢
Canada needs to be broken up. It's a complete joke!
Ask these idiots how they are giving medicine for free; where does the government get the money from?
How about slow down immigration, we cant handle these levels, I don't recognize Canada anymore!!!!
so when canadians dont wanna immrant jobs