Trying Terrible Stardew Valley Knock Offs!

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 30. 06. 2024
  • Today we're playing Rip offs of a rip off! As we go through and play a few games that were heavily "inspired" by Stardew Valley! Could any of these be the next big farming sim?
    Come Join The Discord!!! :D
    / discord
    Everything in this video was edited from my twitch livestreams. Join in the fun on Monday, Wednesday & Thursday @ 6:30pm NZT.
    Catch me live on twitch! :3
    / ninokito
    More stupid shenanigan's:
    • The Stardew Valley Mod...
    Follow me on these! :D
    Instagram: / ninokito_
    Twitch: / ninokito
    Twitter: / nino_kito
    Games:
    Sunset Valley:
    yuluohe.itch.io/sunset-valley
    Blossom Island:
    marikiwi.itch.io/blossom-isla...
    Haystack Village:
    jakegosche.itch.io/haystackvi...
    Im not giving the Wild Seasons Link
    Chapters:
    Intro: 0:00
    Sunset Valley: 0:25
    Blossom Island: 2:34
    Haystack Village: 5:20
    Wild Seasons: 8:14
  • Hry

Komentáře • 141

  • @Wwhdduendjdhhfmwosdn
    @Wwhdduendjdhhfmwosdn Před rokem +742

    the haystack village’s portraits would look really good for a horror stardew valley type game

    • @jakegosche2305
      @jakegosche2305 Před rokem +119

      Hi, this is the creator of Haystack Village! I'm very happy to read this, as there are actually a lot of horror elements in the game, although they don't show up until a little later in the story. 🙂

    • @strawbs8025
      @strawbs8025 Před rokem +7

      @@jakegosche2305 where can i find your game? id love to play :)

    • @jakegosche2305
      @jakegosche2305 Před rokem +32

      @@strawbs8025 I don’t think I can post a direct link on CZcams, but if you search itch for “Haystack Village” you should be able to find it, let me know if you can’t though!

    • @bianca1506
      @bianca1506 Před rokem +1

      Hey we have the same profile picture! :D

  • @jakegosche2305
    @jakegosche2305 Před rokem +1109

    Hey! I'm the dev of Haystack Village, I really appreciate you playing my game and hearing your thoughts! "Period dream" was hilarious. 🤣I know the game is very rough around the edges right now (I'm a terrible artist), but I'm working on making it significantly easier easier on the eyes, potentially through hiring a more competent artist. My goal with the game is to make a farming simulator with a large narrative focus and horror elements (many of the villagers can die depending on the player's choices), but it certainly has a long way to go.
    I loved this video, keep up the great work!

    • @NinoKito
      @NinoKito  Před rokem +371

      Oh wow it’s so nice of you to comment! I hope my comments never came across as harsh because I did have a lot of fun playing Haystack and can’t wait to see where your game develops too! Im a massive horror fan and have talked a lot with my community about how amazing it would be to have a horror Stardew game, even before playing Haystack village, so that sounds reallyyy exciting. Is there anywhere I can follow you for future updates about the game?

    • @jakegosche2305
      @jakegosche2305 Před rokem +219

      @@NinoKito I didn’t think you were too harsh at all, I thought your comments were really funny! Your comments at the end of the Haystack segment actually gave me a lot of motivation to keep working on the game.
      And I really appreciate your interest in the game! As far as updates, I think CZcams keeps deleting any mention of social media in my comments, but I’ll likely be starting a devlog on my itch page soon.

    • @orangejuice8881
      @orangejuice8881 Před rokem +11

      that'd be cool to see, can't wait when its done!

    • @alexandriadukes8137
      @alexandriadukes8137 Před rokem +9

      Yassss. Excited to see how it turns out! I love the concept

    • @livvyheartex
      @livvyheartex Před rokem +34

      Keep going my man, you have the potential of making the true "Evil Farming Game" the internet always wanted

  • @faimynth6030
    @faimynth6030 Před rokem +485

    I will say the whole "grandpa left a farm behind for you" isn't particularly a unique story line to Stardew it was used by the Harvest moon/Story of seasons developers long before Stardew came out so I wouldn't really consider it an aspect to be knocked off.

    • @DerMeres
      @DerMeres Před rokem +8

      I thought the same.

    • @chr1_san704
      @chr1_san704 Před rokem +64

      Isn't Stardew Valley inspired by Harvest Moon though? Harvest moon came out really long time ago and when I first discovered Stardew Valley I thought of Harvest Moon.

    • @faimynth6030
      @faimynth6030 Před rokem +19

      @@chr1_san704 yes it ís that's another point to my comment

    • @lasmirandadennsiewillja9435
      @lasmirandadennsiewillja9435 Před rokem +32

      Stardew fanatics who didn't witness the pre-Playstation 2 area yell at every game that has pixel art, floorboards, and a pumpkin, apple, or turnip, "Stardew RipOff! CA should sue!"
      There's barely any indie pixel art game out there anymore, especially if it has some kind of management or simulation gameplay aspect, that's safe from the "RIP OFF RIP OFF!" downvotes, I'm honestly waiting for these people to attack videos about games from the SNES area.
      It's honestly annoying. I love Stardew, I played it since it came out and have over 3k hours on it. It's an excellent game and one of the best in the genre but let's be honest for a second, there are barely original aspects in the game. It's a really Harvest Moon-based game that took all the great stuff from HM, the decent stuff and improved it, and left out the annoying stuff/made it less annoying (even many of the characters are "knock-offs" of HM villagers). It's ridiculous when you see people whine under an indie game that it's a Stardew ripoff because it has pixel art and the inside of buildings has wood-coloured floorboards (no shit, saw that in a comment on Traveller's Rest).
      It's like someone bakes That Pizza - it's bigger, cheaper, with more cheese, and miraculously healthier but tastes even better than your favourite pizza that you've bought from the store in the past and people not only claim this pizza baker invented pizza, but accuse everyone who makes pizza or any kind of round-shaped food or food with similar ingredients ("Pasta?! This has wheat and cheese and tomatoes sauce, just like That Pizza!") of copying That Pizza.

    • @faimynth6030
      @faimynth6030 Před rokem +12

      @@lasmirandadennsiewillja9435 honestly calling games that are just trying to be games copy of other games exists in every community and is annoying
      "So excited for the Breath of the wild pokemon game!" In reference to sw/sh or SC/VI like people know BOTW didn't invent open world's right 😭

  • @NinoKito
    @NinoKito  Před rokem +243

    Since Stardew is a “rip off” of Harvest Moon, are these all rip offs of a rip off? 🤔
    If you wanna get involved in future videos feel free to follow me on twitch or join the discord!!
    Twitch.tv/ninokito
    discord.gg/NRfG6h2VX2

    • @pirozza01
      @pirozza01 Před rokem +25

      Stardew isn't a rip off, it's the "better version" of harvest moon

    • @midgelionhart
      @midgelionhart Před rokem +12

      @@pirozza01 i still prefer harvest moon

  • @bumblebeepalooza9087
    @bumblebeepalooza9087 Před rokem +93

    i think the art style for the portraits in Haystack Village are SUPER pretty!!! honestly, i would really love to see the game become its own unique thing

  • @MomotheToothless
    @MomotheToothless Před rokem +75

    Ok as an avid Stardew fan I will applaud it's laurels and all it has achieved, but people need to stop saying "ohhhh where have I heard this story before" when referencing Stardew's plot. Stardew is amazing yes, but not groundbreaking. It rebooted the genre, but harvest moon / story of seasons and rune factory walked so it could run.

  • @thekittyburger3175
    @thekittyburger3175 Před rokem +137

    I just need to know the lore from Haystack Village (why did the player get a period nightmare?!)

    • @NinoKito
      @NinoKito  Před rokem +54

      I was literally so intrigued I still have it installed to play it more lol

    • @froggy5748
      @froggy5748 Před rokem +7

      Sounds like me tbh

  • @deannaparker9900
    @deannaparker9900 Před rokem +47

    That last one is more of a Harvest Moon: Friends of Mineral Town rip off, like the farm has such a similar layout lmao

  • @kristinastone7838
    @kristinastone7838 Před rokem +13

    To be fair to Haystack Village and their grandpa story line, Stardew Valley took that plot line almost to the beat from Harvest Moon. So, these knockoffs using the grandfather’s farm storyline could just be copying the original farming simulator, Harvest Moon.

    • @kristinastone7838
      @kristinastone7838 Před rokem +3

      One of the originals, I should say. Not trying to leave out any of the others, I just referenced Harvest Moon because that’s the one I grew up with.

  • @Junkuza
    @Junkuza Před rokem +81

    I like that he keeps saying 'where have I heard that before' at legit tropes of the genre. Stardew didn't make that storyline bud lol.

  • @arnand6636
    @arnand6636 Před rokem +30

    This one's for my Therapist.
    0:39
    Male Robin : Welcome! Are you new?
    I'm Barry, the (i think) lumberjack of this village!
    Buy seeds
    How do i cut wood?
    How do i use seeds?
    Go back.
    0:59
    Female Gus : Hello! I am Marie, the (bruh what) eggplantist and the owner!
    1:16
    Pierre but he is a million years old : Welcome to the village ! I am Henry, the general store owner, i sell anything you need!
    1:50
    Some random a**h*** : As you are new, i will authorise* you to use a part of my field.
    That same a**h*** : So you stealing from my farm? GET OUT!
    You're welcome.

    • @MM-jf1me
      @MM-jf1me Před 11 měsíci +2

      Me: Thank you!

    • @naluzoniro
      @naluzoniro Před 5 měsíci +1

      the innkeeper, not eggplantist xD "auberge" is an inn, "aubergine" is an eggplant :') otherwise, all good !

  • @Rikrobat
    @Rikrobat Před rokem +39

    The agony in your voice during all of the intro scenes had me flashing back to watching my friend beat Metal Gear Solid 4. It was eventually 3am, and we were begging the cutscenes to stop so we could be done. Stardew's story elements and character stuff might be on the simple side, but at least you can interact. XD
    Thank you for another fun video, Nino!

  • @YumikoMayamine
    @YumikoMayamine Před rokem +40

    When you're french your gameplay of the first one is hilarious! I still don't want to play this game. Also you should know that Stardew Valley wasn't available in french for 2/3 years and a team of fan did a patch so french people who didn't not understand english could play and they weren't paid. Maybe out of frustration we got our own game lol

    • @ellie5780
      @ellie5780 Před 15 dny +1

      i speak polish and we still don't have our version (and never will have ig) but there's a mod that adds it at least

  • @Itsrainingsimmies
    @Itsrainingsimmies Před rokem +8

    No but I actually really love the art style for some of the portraits in Haystack Village. It's unique.

  • @Vic_Coco
    @Vic_Coco Před rokem +11

    I remember when Wild Seasons was so hyped up and then they gave up on it. It was a massive flop

  • @hannnix4913
    @hannnix4913 Před rokem +17

    inspired by this u should create ur own version or ripoff of stardew valley using scratch (a coding thing) or something

  • @laurieb3703
    @laurieb3703 Před 15 dny +1

    "are we sickeling in a cathedral??" 😂😂😂

  • @elydragonfly
    @elydragonfly Před rokem +1

    That's so cute when you try to read french (I'm french) lol You really made me laugh for the last few days, when I discovered your channel ! I can't wait to see what's next :D

  • @yopi_yopi
    @yopi_yopi Před rokem +7

    I'm french, this was so funny 😭 Sors pronounced as sauce 😆 "SAUCE!!"

    • @bl4mmed
      @bl4mmed Před rokem +2

      the cheese is under the sors

  • @bug8992
    @bug8992 Před rokem +7

    Sunset valley is a town in the sims so they also stole the name

  • @dianaferrel1702
    @dianaferrel1702 Před rokem +45

    You are adorable and so fun to watch

  • @samurailevi49
    @samurailevi49 Před rokem +5

    Technically, Stardew Valley is a Harvest Moon knock off. Both games are great though.

  • @lost_.gremlin
    @lost_.gremlin Před 12 dny

    a great day to be french HAHA hearing nino trying to read the dialogues from sunset valley was very much worth being a frenchie

  • @mayouwn3534
    @mayouwn3534 Před rokem +1

    I'm French and it was really funny seeing you translate and trying to speak, you are good tho I'm impressed 😁👍

  • @StarFenyx
    @StarFenyx Před rokem +3

    The first one looks like if stardew valley and the legend of zelda were mashed together XD
    also r u a new Zealander? I can hear the accent, dunno why it took me so long to realise

  • @casp1xVODS
    @casp1xVODS Před 2 měsíci

    the fact that i can meet you on the street, god bless nz :3

  • @tachythepizza
    @tachythepizza Před 2 měsíci

    The Last thing I was excepted to see in this video is someone talking in my langage and doing a french lesson xD

  • @sakusakiyoomi9246
    @sakusakiyoomi9246 Před rokem +7

    You should play harvest town I don't think it's a rip-off but I kinda actually enjoy it

  • @sovietbot6708
    @sovietbot6708 Před rokem +3

    If you're French, skip to 2:34 to preserve your sanity

  • @Jay_jax38
    @Jay_jax38 Před 4 dny

    I love his emo collar lol ❤

  • @garra123454
    @garra123454 Před rokem +2

    Moving from the big city to a small town has been around alot longer than stardew valley though harvest moon is alot older than stardew valley and thats also the plot of harvest moon

  • @bridgettawinchester3063
    @bridgettawinchester3063 Před 8 měsíci

    “I like it because it says boys” 😂

  • @alaisvalera5233
    @alaisvalera5233 Před rokem

    watching the first one as a french person was insanely frustrating

  • @cupcat-.
    @cupcat-. Před rokem +1

    i want u to try harvest town, its a free mobile game that kinda feels like stardew

  • @oliverhill149
    @oliverhill149 Před rokem +2

    I was about to go to bed but this is more important I swear

    • @1000-THR
      @1000-THR Před rokem +1

      I agree
      This is way more important than sleep

  • @Katzykeens
    @Katzykeens Před rokem +3

    You should play graveyard keeper o3o

  • @BrittneyThompsonFL
    @BrittneyThompsonFL Před měsícem

    Harvest town is a genuinely good mobile alternative to stardew, and there’s no mention of a grandpa owning the farm before you so it’s not haunted!

  • @billmitchell1433
    @billmitchell1433 Před rokem +1

    Hey Jimmy Urine I love your CZcams channel!

  • @Laureth-DK
    @Laureth-DK Před měsícem

    I fell for Nino speaking french that's way too cute T-T (and I'm french)

  • @wednesdaysleftshoe
    @wednesdaysleftshoe Před 2 měsíci

    I have a tv and on the main menu for the Tv there’s a knock off but you build the village and you just can’t talk to the villagers, I spent hourss on my village before I bought Stardew. And now I spend hours on my farm and Haley

  • @user-jq3yb8xr6y
    @user-jq3yb8xr6y Před 2 měsíci

    If you thought the last game had a long intro/tutorial, you haven't played Harvest Moon ToT/AP.

  • @faerinaa7186
    @faerinaa7186 Před rokem +2

    who r u and why r u now my new fave youtuber

  • @Liz-hf5ms
    @Liz-hf5ms Před 11 měsíci

    A game you should play that is inspired by stardew valley is called poket pioneers and it's really fun

  • @gehap
    @gehap Před rokem +7

    WHY DOESNT NINO HAVE ALOT OF VIEWS NOW GRR IM BOOSTING

  • @The_nonexistant_angel
    @The_nonexistant_angel Před rokem +6

    Ngl I thought you were gonna play harvest town lmao

    • @The_nonexistant_angel
      @The_nonexistant_angel Před rokem +3

      I actually have both Stardew valley and harvest town I personally like harvest town a lil more.

    • @shrub825
      @shrub825 Před rokem

      @@The_nonexistant_angel hey another harvest town player! :)

    • @madamebunbun3479
      @madamebunbun3479 Před rokem

      ayyyy i'm a harvest yown player!

  • @teo2102
    @teo2102 Před rokem

    i think most of them are people trying to make a mini game to practice coding

  • @stellabartleby1947
    @stellabartleby1947 Před 3 měsíci

    what about Coral island?? its like stardew valley except with full body anime portraits

  • @cookiesam321
    @cookiesam321 Před rokem

    technically, they’re also rip-offs of Harvest Moon-especially that last one, though!

  • @aquarium8650
    @aquarium8650 Před rokem

    Denis was actually saying that you are stealing from him and to get out

  • @imaghost2961
    @imaghost2961 Před rokem +1

    Wild Season actually looks really nice!! It’s a shame the intro is so long and the game is pretty broken.

  • @AlexTheWormonastring
    @AlexTheWormonastring Před rokem +1

    maybe you should check the farm.

  • @god_of_gaming975
    @god_of_gaming975 Před 2 měsíci

    7:43 lol😂😂

  • @Alan_was_here_
    @Alan_was_here_ Před rokem +2

    C’était un bonne vidéo. :)

  • @MisterDaniel_1900
    @MisterDaniel_1900 Před 23 dny

    Fun fact: Sunset Valley is also stolen from The Sims 3.

  • @Monster_NopeNope
    @Monster_NopeNope Před rokem

    Welcome, your new
    Y name is Barry the village wood cutter

    • @Monster_NopeNope
      @Monster_NopeNope Před rokem

      Buy seeds
      How to cut wood
      How to plant seeds
      Back

    • @Monster_NopeNope
      @Monster_NopeNope Před rokem

      Her name is Marie,she is the innkeeper and owner

    • @Monster_NopeNope
      @Monster_NopeNope Před rokem

      My name is Henry, I sell everything you need

    • @Monster_NopeNope
      @Monster_NopeNope Před rokem

      Denis said “welcome to the village, I authorise you to use part of my field … BUT BEWARE, DONT STEAL MY VEGTABLES”

    • @Monster_NopeNope
      @Monster_NopeNope Před rokem

      Poor denis said “so like that you steal from me, you will no longer have access to part of my field”
      Rip

  • @dulainey9453
    @dulainey9453 Před rokem +1

    You mean Harvest Moon rip offs. Especially at the one made BEFORE stardew. HM came first.

  • @gehap
    @gehap Před rokem +2

    ive heard of sunset vallwy its so 😭😭

    • @NinoKito
      @NinoKito  Před rokem +1

      It was cute! Just French 🤮

  • @theblackwidower
    @theblackwidower Před měsícem

    How dare these devs rip off Stardew Valley, a 100% original game who's story and gameplay had never been done before.
    /s

  • @stephennr
    @stephennr Před rokem +1

    I NEED A HAIR TUT PLS 😭🔫 (I WILL STALK APL YOUR SOCIAL MEDIAS FOR IT)

    • @NinoKito
      @NinoKito  Před rokem +5

      LMAO I dont even like my hairstyle a lot of the time😅 This will be long because there arent a lot of good tuts on youtube so ill try be descriptive. SO my hair cut was just some choppy af homejob layering and then grown out. If you have thick hair then I recommend to NOT wash your hair that often, obv stay hygienic but you dont need to wash your hair every day! I wet my hair then ruffle it with a towel till damp, then go through with a tiny bit of wax to add some hold (otherwise my hair goes into a bowl cut shape). Then I get a hair dryer and a thermal hairbrush and roll the sides of my hair up in the hairbrush while blow drying close to the brush at a medium heat to get that curl up look, then after that a few spurts of sea salt spray and ruffle my hair with my hands!

    • @Mel_250
      @Mel_250 Před rokem

      @@NinoKito aw u are so kind 🤭🤭

    • @stephennr
      @stephennr Před rokem

      @@NinoKito THANK YOU

  • @CapyCara765
    @CapyCara765 Před 11 měsíci

    Try Harvest Town

  • @vaelegoro7782
    @vaelegoro7782 Před 9 měsíci

    So meny bad story of seasons (originally harvest moon) clones

  • @Human-Tessa
    @Human-Tessa Před 3 měsíci

    I’m French- SORS

  • @KatrinaHereTocausetrouble

    i'm sorry but the first one is french ???
    it time for me a french to watch a guy speaking french
    well trying i think

  • @TheRedeemed23
    @TheRedeemed23 Před rokem

    these are so bad it hurts

  • @enderkatze6129
    @enderkatze6129 Před rokem +1

    That's Not how you pronounce "Salut"

  • @YaoiFan22
    @YaoiFan22 Před rokem

    Sunset Valley looks much better than Stardew. A lot more detailed.

  • @cocoa-powder3476
    @cocoa-powder3476 Před rokem +1

    A suggestion for game makers, Do NOT make your introductions so long it’s excruciating

  • @chahdeddaou2494
    @chahdeddaou2494 Před 7 měsíci

    Sors=leave

  • @Micfurry
    @Micfurry Před rokem

    You so cute aa♡♡