G466 vs 046! Clone vs Oem!!! Who makes more Power? Blue thunder?
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 01. 2023
- Just picked up one of these blue thunder saws. wanted to see how it stacks up against an oem 046.
for more product and service info visit the website.
worksaws.com
If I had these two saws on a job site I'd run the blue one just so I knew my backup saw would be a reliable machine 😅
That is a very solid plan
It's hard to run iffy products when you know you have a bad ass Stihl in the truck.
@@matthewotis3594 I'd hate to run a saw and only have a turd of questionable quality as a backup. I keep 7 saws + latest project in my van and work with others 80% of the time, 95% of the time within 45min of home so my original comment was more of a thought experiment.
@@7eis my guys bitch about having to load up 5 or 6 saws everyday when I usually only use 2, maybe 3 a day. I always saw it's better to have them and not need them than the other way around. Stay safe up there!
I do the same thing. Best the living snot out of the clone and have the OEMs as backup.
I bought the G466 just like that one. As Joe mentioned, I replaced the tensioner right out of the box, and since the recoil handles are known problems, tossed an OEM on. Ran a couple tanks of 25:1 and then leaned back to 32:1... then adjusted the carb - really livened it up.
I don't make a living with my saw, $1500 for a 76cc just doesn't fit the budget. $320 got me in the game, and I fully plan to use it as an educational tool as much as a saw.
Wow 25:1?? Is that a good thing to do to new saws?
Really liked the comparison and with the proper tinkering and tooling anything is possible.
Excellent review, as always, Joe!!! I can now get some understanding of why folks buy these saws for things like milling.
Buckin Billy put me on to you. Glad he did!!! Excellent and very informative. Happy days Dino!!!
Welcome aboard! Glad you enjoyed the video.
I used AM cylinders to learn how to do port work back in the mid 2000's when Baileys started selling the big bore kits. Did a couple, got gains, but not near as much as I could get from an OEM cylinder. They did serve a great purpose of being a cheap cylinder to practice grinding on.
I like seeing you play with clone saws.
Great honest advice. Cheers Joe.
My opinion on the aftermarket saws is they are great after you fix all the issues. Every one I have gotten has had little issues out of the box but after a few times out cutting things stop breaking and they become reliable.
Always a good day when Dyno Joe uploads a video!
Thank You! Hope you enjoy.
You bet!
Great video. Thanks for the good information.
I’d like to see the numbers once the blue saw is broke in. My g466 seemed to pull much better after 4 or 5 tanks run through it. I have a couple big trees that had to come down and I didn’t see the reason to spend the money on an oem saw that I wont use much. I haven’t had any issues so far with it but Ive only run about 10 tanks of fuel through it.
I always prefer oem saws even an older one. But for the price of the big saws even blown up you can get a clone for cheaper. Was looking for a 90 cc Husky. Found one in a box in pieces for $750 and I picked up a G288 for $400 delivered to my door. I only use it for big stumps and milling. Does the trick. Cheers
Keep showing us the progress of ol blue
I just picked up a farmmac 660 clone. Very impressed with the quality. The casting of the cylinder was much better than the farmertec saws I've had a part. Didn't run it stock to compare though.
love seeing the holzfforma saws on the dyno
Hey Joe nipped over from buckin to say hi.. a stay in Scotland. Been watching u for a wee bit. Your doing a great job fella. Keep it up. Harvy had nothing but good things to say about you. Keep Hur chappin.👍
I can't stand the Stihl flip caps. Screw caps are just better. Thanks for the video
I have the Holzfforma G372 Husky clone and it’s my go-to saw. Took awhile to get the carb dialed in and the chain tensioner is not the greatest. I had a Husky bar and chain lying around and got this saw already assembled for like 180 bucks with free delivery. Wish I’d gotten two. Don’t worry though. I have a Stihl 461 as a backup.
I would love to see you run about a dozen tanks of fuel through the blue saw and get the carb and air filter right. Then do the dyno. Bet it posts significant gains as my clone saw did. Great video. 👍
I have two of them I use them every day for logging they both work great
Great video! Would have loved to see you swap the mufflers and run them again. Also, it would be interesting to see inside the clone saw, timing numbers, port sizes, transfers, etc.
Then swap the air filters, then the carburetors.
Have several of the blue saws, only failed part is clutch bearing. I like them for reason of there cheap and if they grow legs and walk off does not hurt as much as a oem. Do still have several oem Stihl and husky saws.
Close enough to me. Would love to see the results after break in period, hope U can make it happen!
Great video and comparison. It was nice to see facts and numbers. I’ve got a G660 that I’ve built from a parts kit and I did have a few issues, but once I got past those it’s been a great running saw though I suspect it won’t compare to an OEM. It’d be cool to see you revisit this after the blue saw is broke in.
How was your chain adjuster? Mine was absolutely unusable on my 440 kit…
@@gabe1254 just fine actually. I do plan to swap OE parts in eventually but no need right now.
Great video Joe!
Thanks!
As a cheap skate I love my G366 the MS360 clone. Starts quickly compared to many other chainsaws I have run before, cuts and hasn’t failed me yet after 25-30 tanks of fuel, I feel like the value I got at less than a 1/3 of the price of the OEM saw is off the charts.
My g111 top handle had a leaky cap out of the box too. $10 worth of oem caps, and it's been a great saw for the money. Really interested in the power after break in, and the same comparison between the G666 and a real 066.
thanks for the break down
I have a couple Holzfforma saws. They cut great. The chain adjusters and oil pumps are crap though. Easy fixes.
awesome video .peace an love from scotland .
I like them for learning how to port with. If you blow one up, it’s not going to brake the bank
I have a cline husky 365 i put a 372 cylinder kit inside, i haven't had any issues with the saw since i got it back in 2019.
I wish I had money to buy Stihl. But after tuning my G660 blue saw kicks butt.
Cool to see the difference in numbers. Could you dyno the saw without the filter to see if that's the restriction? That would really be interesting, IMHO.
Good vid Joe👍🏻
Thanks 👍
Cool comparison...you know how I feel about clones ..I mess with a bunch of them....hard to beat them for firewood saws🤙🏻😎
Would like to see the G466 after a week or 2 of break in. I know my oem husky didn't reach full potential until it had about 10 tanks though it.
@@ozdatman I agree..but it was close out of the box
Nice work.
I wonder if the carb is the limiting factor on the cloner saw?
Nice comparison Joe! I look forward to seeing what you build out of the G466. I own a pair of 046 Artic saws that my Dad logged with since new , I have put alot of hours on them since 2010, I would have to say that if one were to find a low hour 046 and maintain it well it would probably last their lifetime, and go up in value too, something to consider when comparing price. From the first MS460 with flippy caps to the current crop of Stihl pro saws with flippy caps that I own and cut timber with there has been a 100% guarantee: They have all leaked! Both the gas and oil. I wish Stihl would revise these, no matter how diligent I am with cleaning them out every day they have rewarded me with a leak. I have had Zero issues with the caps on my Husqvarna saws....
G'day DJ, I keep one at the farm if a branch falls over a fence I don't bother locking it up if someone takes it then they'll be yelling at it when it won't start hot and I'll be at peace 👍.
Hey Joe, I've had my g466 for two years. I totally notice that once after initial carb tune and about 4-5 tanks then retune one the carb the saw seemed to run like a beast and maybe an old saw thats been way broke in against one not is not really a good test. Not that I'm partial to the clone as I would grab a standard stihl any day of the week. However I would like to see the dyno test after the clone was broken in and at least 4-5 tanks and a tune on the carb after would give a better result and see how it compares. BTW Thanks for the video- lil late in seeing it but again it will give some one better judgment to understand dynamics of power in a saw.
Id love to see the conversion(direct bolt on) ps6400 to ps7900.the difference.
im very pleased with my 2 big blue saws. if not for this brand, me and my son couldn't have tried the chainsaw milling. they have worked excellent for this, when you bury a 42" bar and it just keep on keeping on , whats to complain about ,other than no excuse Not to do it lol. we even bumped up to a 52" bar when needed. mine have been affordable and dependable.
I have a 2018 Husquavarna 372xp but considering selling it and buying a new Holtzforma, do you suggest it or not?
@@dentondunn4346keep the husky, these aren’t an upgrade just very very good for the price, youl get more longevity from genuine saws.
Awesome video as always from Joe! The Dyno factor certainly puts the “proof in the pudding” not only for comparison like this video but the best way to test port and pipe alterations. Hopefully will see a video of a ported rematch of these saws!!!
Yeah go though them both top to bottom replace what really matters and see the results that would be nice maybe a good challenge for him with the blue saw not saying he has to deal with the part's he doesn't want to work on but replace them and then , I would like seeing that as well.👍
That would be crazy if he does and they both put out the same power that would say a lot I believe as well, that sounds like a challenge right there ! 😂👍
👍 Thanks Joe
Hello Joe! Buckin sent me over 👍
.to stop the fuel cap from leaking tighten the cap and lube the ceil remember it been dry and doxed up for how long
Maybe run some tanks through the blue saw and another run? Then port the crap out of it see if it hold up? Great video old Stihl with what 500hrs still holding on strong.
Getting ready to port mine and drop the jug a bit just to see
The way prices are today, I think the clones for the average hobby farmer would definitely be worth looking into. If you got a few years out of one and only threw a few bucks at it how could you go wrong.
Would you recommend putting the recommended fuel/oil mixture and bar oil that Farmertec recommend?
You gotta give it credit for not having seated rings
Love them since you have the option to have a 70cc saw n don’t have to spend thousands of dollars on them, bought the 372 xp clone n haven’t had any problems w it 🤞🏼 n she runs n cuts very well imo , if a seal goes bad, leak here n there 🤷🏼♂️ I’ll fix it , just like I would w a name brand saw , n Ive seen ppl spend 1200$ bring it home n have problem after problem soooo imo there a great home owner saw for a good price 👌🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼 n they do have a warranty within 30 or 60 days , e-mail just have to show that you bought from them, n not a dealer of holzforma,if you bought from a dealer ya have to go thru them to get the part , I didn’t know you were in MI , where I’m at I’ll have to bring one of my saws some time n get ya to port it
Hey Joe I like your videos....Buckin sent me...I'm a fan.
Thanks for coming! Glad you enjoyed the video
If I was going to be falling timber full time I would buy oem. For cutting firewood or occasional use. The clone saw will get the work accomplished just fine
The other factor between these 2 saws tested. The 046 was broke in. The G466 was new.
My G660 set in at around 4, 4.5 gallons of fuel run through it. Noticable increase in power once it set in. Pulling 105 drivers of 3/8 full comp chisel chain.
You already know I like the china saws. IF IF IF you know how to tinker with them
Would love to See the New holzforma "pro" Version on your dyno! Great Video as always!
That would be interesting
@@dynojoemods2764 i could pay for it. You Do a Video on it and then send it to me. Do you think that would work?
Hey Joe, you have maybe some instruction for a muzzle 881 Stihl? Thanks! Love your Videos!!!
I have a G444 clone and a Stihl 462 c-m. Do I like the Stihl better? Of course. After the G444 broke in, and the carburetor was adjusted properly, it pulls hard. Is it as good as a Stihl 044? I don’t know. Never ran one. Hate to admit it, but they are a great value for the weekend warrior who cuts firewood.
Check the squish and do a base gasket delete. See if it changes the power
I think farmertec does a great job with the 372’s
Break in time also needs to be taken into account, the blue saw will gain as it breaks in
I have 2 g444. Seem good but i do have trouble with caps and handle and starter cord
Nice, honest evaluation Joe. It's easy to talk trash about the clone saws, but you kept it factual. Pretty impressive how wide the powerband is on the 046.
Thank you. Makes sense why people like them, nice useable powerband.
I wonder if the clone if tuned and broken in well would have power closer to the Stihl? Also I think if I was the average homeowner I would definitely save the extra couple hundred and get the blue thunder instead of a poulan or craftsman.
The Stihl OEM flippy caps are better than the Holzfforma caps on the G466, but the OEM flippy caps still leak just not as much!
Nice comparison. The blue saw should have a warranty. Also it looks brand new and is not broken in yet. Do you think the numbers will improve while the rings seat. I think they will. I think Tinman recently checked timing numbers from several aftermarket cylinders and compared to a stock Husqvarna cylinder. The Holtzforma had the closest numbers and was nearly identical to OEM. The quality of the Holtzforma cylinder is unknown how long it will last.
I know mine came with 6 month home warranty 3 month commercial
Its important to incorporate the dino and the carb tune, if you want to compare apple to apple.
If the carb isn't tuned right it will give a false result, so you should use the dino to tune the carb, especially the H which is the working high speed dial.
Lol!
Excellent video. Thank you for sharing. I am curious if you adjusted the carburetor on the clone saw prior to the dyno the run.
Yes, I adjusted the saw to a normal work tune, as if I were going to go cutting.
@@dynojoemods2764 ok great! Thanks for clarifying Joe!
I'd like to see more on this stuff. I'm still unsure of purchasing one. Floppy caps are junk in mt opinion
My new huskies have the flippy caps and I like them
Basically you can buy a low cost new saw, or a high cost used saw and still have to buy parts and work on them.
Thank s!!
First time here, subscribed. Bucking Billie Ray Smith sent me, when he vouches for someone it is good enough for me. Ty for your time and effort on the videos. like what i see... from SE Texas Bear
The more the merrier to watch Dyno Joe do his voodoo to saws
046 all day, have you ever worked on the Stihl 051 and what is your opinion? Thank you
i have a g444 thats been an animal up until recently... scored the piston and cylinder pretty bad. Got a hyway titanickel 460 big bore kit coming to fix it with... Gonna do a 483 light build
A little Taryl putty on that gas tank should fix that leak...
they both have the same compression (more or less) and the 046 is used for a long time and the 466 is brand spanking new. I bet in a tank or 5-10 that 466 will overpower that 046 by a mile.
I have a G466 it’s the Oring on the fuel caps
Ran a 044 vs a G444 sharpened both 044 with a 28 G444 with a 32 G444 cut faster 044 needed a carb tuning but ran the same other than lots of vibration compared to the stihl.
Lots of guys like those blue saws....Im not one of them! Great video though!
Have a jonsred 920 that I think is a 5 cubic inch saw that will run a 40 inch bar faster than a 660 or 066
If it cuts wood it’s good in my book , but I only cut fire wood once a year so the blue would be for me
I did find my blue saw 272 was a bit rich out of the box
You do good work Joe! very fair review. I’m still trying to figure out how I do feel about these clone saws. I love OEM stuff. I guess it’s the consistency for me. My one big sore spot is the fact that original manufactures can’t produce those souls anymore because they don’t meet EPA standards, but China can build them and sell them here all day long and they’re not held to the same standard. Can I get a amen.
Exactly!
The flippy caps are defo more prone to user error. After using them for a year, I quite like them
Mine snapped the plastic rivet in the centre and it fell apart. I had bought a new one in preparation of breaking one on the woods.
@@GWAYGWAY1 yes, I went to put my fuel cap on and it wouldn’t go, it felt like it was twisting in half, I finally got it on, but ridiculous, Stihl oem.
How do you find engine rebuild for this model g444?
Had the blue saw been fully broken in?
Gotta break old blue in before the dyno makes a difference
I got the g660 pro clone with meteor cylinder. Runs very well. I mill with it
test joncutter g7500 75cc
please
thanks
i wanna see a g444 vs 440/044. Those are some screamers.
Not a big fan, but people like em
Those saws are like the harbor freight of saws
Like em!
we want more...
On the flippy caps, after 15 years I've not had a problem with em. Easier to operate I'd suggest.
Like your channel, Buckin sent me for a look.
Please test Dolmar 5105
Up bore port and polish
I'd like to see a video comparing clone quality think there's 3 different ones are the ones claiming pro grade really any different?
Also I really would like to see one built for racing who cares if it blows. Some of the coolest videos is building up to failure to see just how much power you can make. A race car isn't reliable. A nascar engine runs one race, top fuel only a few they never run a whole season there not made for that.