Haunted Metaphors - A Russian Doll Season 1 Video Essay

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
  • So this one turned out pretty long. Also I didn't say it in the video but again, this show is up to interpretation so this is just my personal take and I'll probably be wrong about some stuff.
    Tumblr: / ladyknightthebrave
    Instagram: / ladyknightthebrave
    Letterboxd: letterboxd.com/lkthebrave/
    Patreon: / ladyknightthebrave
    Mastodon: mastodon.lol/@Ladyknightthebrave
    Music by Epidemic Sound: epidemicsound.com/
    Spanish (Latin America) subtitles by @darkmajokko on Twitter
    0:00 - Intro
    1:56 - Chapter 1: The Set Up
    5:35 - Chapter 2: Storytelling
    8:57 - Chapter 3: The F-Word
    15:00 - Chapter 4: Gotta Get Up
    18:55 - Chapter 5: This Show is Very Jewish
    24:47 - Chapter 6: Trauma
    31:42 - Chapter 7: Alone Again Or
    44:51 - Credits
    Sources:
    “How Netflix's 'Russian Doll' Music Supervisor Licensed Harry Nilsson's 'Gotta Get Up' -- Over a Dozen Times” by Tatiana Cirisano:
    www.billboard.com/articles/bu...
    “Emily of New Moon gets a star turn in Netflix hit Russian Doll” by Sara Fraser:
    www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince...
    “Netflix’s ‘Russian Doll’ Has Big Talmud Energy” by Rachel Klein:
    forward.com/schmooze/420004/n...
    “18 Things to Know About Natasha Lyonne” by Emily Burack:
    www.heyalma.com/18-things-to-...
    “Netflix’s ‘Russian Doll’ is Surprisingly, Deeply Jewish” By Emily Burack:
    www.heyalma.com/netflixs-russ...
    “'Russian Doll' Bosses on How That "Haunting" Finale Sets Up Season 2 (and Beyond)” by Jackie Strause:
    www.hollywoodreporter.com/liv...
    “‘Russian Doll’: Natasha Lyonne, Amy Poehler and Leslye Headland dissect their trippy Netflix comedy” by Meredith Blake:
    www.latimes.com/entertainment...
    “Nadia Dies. Nadia Lives. ‘Gotta Get Up’ Plays. Users Repeat.”:
    newsroom.spotify.com/2019-02-...
    “This is that brilliant song you keep hearing in Netflix’s ‘Russian Doll’” by Andrew Trendell:
    www.nme.com/news/tv/russian-d...
    “Natasha Lyonne On Being A 'Tough Guy' And Finding Herself Inside 'Russian Doll'” by Terry Gross:
    www.npr.org/2019/03/27/707104...
    “This Is That Song From ‘Russian Doll’” by Aisha Harris:
    www.nytimes.com/2019/02/01/ar...
    The One Big Frog theory:
    parsha.blogspot.com/2011/03/o...
    "L.A. Weirdos: On the glorious idiosyncrasies of three 70s West Coast singer-songwriters."
    pitchfork.com/features/unders...
    “Unpacking the video game twists of Russian Doll with co-creator Leslye Headland” by Karen Han
    www.polygon.com/interviews/20...
    “The Chosen Ones: An Interview With Natasha Lyonne” by Periel Aschenbrand:
    www.tabletmag.com/scroll/2125...
    “What the Ambiguous Ending of Netflix's 'Russian Doll' Means for the Show” by Esther Zuckerman:
    www.thrillist.com/entertainme...
    “‘American Pie’ star’s fight for life” - 2005 article on Natasha Lyonne’s Health Scare:
    www.today.com/popculture/amer...
    Jason Zinoman’s Twitter Theory on Russian Doll:
    / 1092448220482101248
    Daniel Handler’s Q&A with the quote about Judaism:
    • Daniel Handler Q&A
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 744

  • @quilespiritu
    @quilespiritu Před 4 lety +1750

    HOLY CRAP I didn't realize that all of those douchebag characters were played by the same actors!!!

    • @wowanothercookie
      @wowanothercookie Před 4 lety +60

      Me neither, I can't believe I didn't catch that!

    • @quilespiritu
      @quilespiritu Před 4 lety +72

      @@WarKeineAbsicht no, in one episode they were her coworkers, and in another they were EMTs. They were always douchebags though!

    • @funkymonkey7202
      @funkymonkey7202 Před 3 lety +33

      For anyone just scrolling thru comments its at 9:10

    • @withalittlehelpfrom3
      @withalittlehelpfrom3 Před 2 lety +3

      Wonder if they showed up in Season 2! I saw a couple times it could’ve been them.

    • @queengwendolyn333
      @queengwendolyn333 Před 2 lety +12

      @@withalittlehelpfrom3 I just finished watching season 2, and they were definitely there, without a single doubt, all 3 of them, exact same guys doing and saying the most ridiculous stuff 😹

  • @emilydurkee8664
    @emilydurkee8664 Před 4 lety +397

    "Underneath the surface we are all a little bit broken inside. Yet we live in a society that demands shame, in a way, for that very human experience."

  • @charmedblondie4
    @charmedblondie4 Před 4 lety +792

    Not sure if anyone's mentioned this but you referencing the door handle shaped like a gun at the end definitely made me think of Chekhov's gun and how that relates to all the "irrelevant" elements of the show (props, no name extras, etc) disappearing one by one until the central conflict is resolved.

    • @juhlsghouls
      @juhlsghouls Před 4 lety +19

      Kali Ellis if you put a gun in the first act you gotta use it in the third.

  • @castoputa
    @castoputa Před 4 lety +552

    She’s carrying a torch, I took it that she passed it to us...

  • @laotasurfs1110
    @laotasurfs1110 Před 4 lety +1894

    I just realized, if Russian Doll was your standard CBS show, the two mains would've met in episode one, which would be the origin story of how Nadya and Allen are living the same day over again, and the show would be about them searching New York for other people in time loops -- different people each week -- who they would break out with some kind of life coaching, in hopes of fixing some broken time-thing and finding a way out of their own loops.
    There would be no drugs or cigarettes, the personalities would be reversed because focus groups found Nadya unsympathetic for sleeping around and drinking (but found those traits made Allen _more_ sympathetic), Nadya would be played by a model and Allen would be white, and Ruth would be a blind, black man with all the wisdom of the universe, who is the only one outside the time loop who believes them because being black and blind makes him magic (but like, _main protaganist_ magic).

    • @candyisreading8813
      @candyisreading8813 Před 4 lety +121

      Oh...my God?

    • @SunburnCity
      @SunburnCity Před 4 lety +52

      @@candyisreading8813 Correct

    • @romancandleofthewild
      @romancandleofthewild Před 4 lety +204

      No one has ever nailed it as much as you have with this description. Well done. Down to the casting of the blind, black man who believes them. Brilliant.

    • @kirkserpes2574
      @kirkserpes2574 Před 4 lety +76

      Seriously fuck you for being this correct.

    • @angelkingsley5299
      @angelkingsley5299 Před 4 lety +12

      Laota Surfs honestly

  • @kathleenperazzo9654
    @kathleenperazzo9654 Před 3 lety +88

    Its the same outfits every time, for both of them - but in the last loop, both of their last loops, there was specific attention drawn to their change in outfits. Nadia with the pirate shirt from Maxine, and Alan with the good karma scarf. Those two versions are in separate loops, but when they march together in the final scene, Nadia is in the pirate shirt and Alan has the scarf - they are reunited to the same timeline

  • @camomiletea7357
    @camomiletea7357 Před 4 lety +254

    A theory I've seen for season 2 is that we will learn that Nadia's mother was in her own timeline, broken mirrors, choosing watermelon's because every other fruit was rotten to her, she died at the age of 36 and it was suggested that we would follow or learn this (there's a few other points but I can't remember them well), this leans in to both options and it just sounds ridiculously believable to me.

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 4 lety +44

      woah that would be a trip

    • @Annak773
      @Annak773 Před 3 lety +17

      that would make sense as to why nadia was the same age as she was when her mother “died”

    • @drflannelxd904
      @drflannelxd904 Před 2 lety +15

      That opens the door for so many explorations of generational trauma, especially if there's uncanny similarities with Nadia's loop.

    • @AlphaPizzadog
      @AlphaPizzadog Před 2 lety +4

      Do you think Nadia's mom broke out of the loop then? What could have caused them to stop?

    • @nataleynakata3687
      @nataleynakata3687 Před 2 lety +3

      Russian Doll Trailer for S2: Helloooo from the fuuuuutuuuureeeeer

  • @kthxbi
    @kthxbi Před 4 lety +502

    me- I wonder why Russian Doll feels so different and so much more authentically gut-wrenching about the way in which its female characters behave and process emotion and trauma
    ladyknightthebrave - all of the creators were women
    me- oh yeah, that'd do it

    • @nodiggity8746
      @nodiggity8746 Před 2 lety +5

      Yeah I've only realised now that the show feels fresh and genuine because the characters are not written by males lol

  • @xoda523
    @xoda523 Před 3 lety +81

    The "are you ready to let her die?" comment from baby Nadia absolutely does haunt me so mission accomplished

  • @alonsogonzalez7539
    @alonsogonzalez7539 Před 4 lety +603

    I don't know why the algorithm decided to give me this like 10 months after I watched Russian Doll, but regardless I'm so happy it did.Mandatory "you should have a lot more subscribers", but for real, this was quality like you rarely see on here, specially from a small channel.
    So much that can be said about Russian Doll, but for now, I'm just so happy it made me find this channel.

    • @Emidoki
      @Emidoki Před 4 lety +2

      Same!

    • @Kagomai15
      @Kagomai15 Před 3 lety +4

      I know this is like a year late but I would definitely recommend BREADSWORD as another film-centric video essayist if you haven't heard of him already. His essays have the same kind of politically and historically-aware, sincere and positive analyses and critiques as Lady Knight's 💚🖤💜
      (Edit: his channel is breadsword not broadsword my bad)

    • @levirichardosn9595
      @levirichardosn9595 Před 2 lety

      haha i’m in the same boat. i even tried to find long format essays after i finished it. really glad i came across this tho

  • @castoputa
    @castoputa Před 4 lety +277

    ALSO..... Don’t underestimate our appetite for the feature length analysis video hahaha

    • @scoutpark5230
      @scoutpark5230 Před 2 lety +1

      As a rabid contrapoints fan, I second this.

  • @sistergloomy2063
    @sistergloomy2063 Před 4 lety +131

    “and then sent him this gif of a miniature pony”

  • @CorbiniteVids
    @CorbiniteVids Před 4 lety +415

    I would honestly much rather have the next seasons turn it into an anthology show honestly, because I kind of don't want any other ending for these two. I love the idea of them just showing up in other people's timelines and helping like Horse did, because the writers won't have to explain if it's the same Nadia and Allen, or if it's another timeline, or if it's their ghosts, or if they're leaving impressions in another reality, or if it's all not literal. I'm the kind of person who always gets obsessed with unravling the material reality simulated in a work of fiction I want to understand how it all works and I've spoiled a lot of games and a lot of series for myself in doing so (I need to learn to stay away from wikis). But with Russian Doll it so effectively evokes this nebulous message with its plot and to me that message hinges on its vague uninterpretable nature, and I think answers would ruin that, and I think a continuation of their storylines would probably ruin it unless they did it in a really well-crafted way that continued to shun explanations and create more questions, or if each season was able to stand on its own as a show with only implied continuity but gained greater meaning when strung together. And I like the idea not that the writers are hiding some sort of answer to the whole thing, but that they simply don't have an nswer

    • @DanielkaElliott
      @DanielkaElliott Před 4 lety +7

      I totally agree but i felt that way about OA too untill i saw season 2

    • @yaelbenko548
      @yaelbenko548 Před rokem +3

      I don't know if you've watched season 2, but your theory of each season standing on it's own with only implied connection is spot on! It's crazy really, season 2 can definitely be a story of it's own where it has even a greater meaning when you put it together with season 1, what a great prediction!

    • @CorbiniteVids
      @CorbiniteVids Před rokem

      @@yaelbenko548 i haven't watched it yet (plan on it soon) but that's so cool to hear!

  • @vambuny
    @vambuny Před 4 lety +163

    this show deserves a lot more love and a lot more appreciation.
    my parents and i watched the show together, and i didn't find out until the very last episode that my dad had watched the show without us the night before. he told us the only reason he'd been able to keep up the facade of this being a new experience was because the show was so tightly written and jam packed with little details, that in almost every scene it was like seeing it for the first time because there was more and more he hadn't noticed or put together the first time around. to me, that is amazing praise, and that alone makes me recommend the show to friends.
    it helps that it's just fantastic all around, too lol. the acting, the cinematography, the sound design, the plot... it's an incredible experience to watch

  • @Wendy-je9zf
    @Wendy-je9zf Před 4 lety +176

    the first thing that struck me when I first watched through the show was how intense and beautiful the cinematography was
    just,,,,,wow!!!! this show did that

  • @TimeLady910
    @TimeLady910 Před 4 lety +289

    Criminally underviewed. Same with the Fleabag video!

  • @lulubeukes2296
    @lulubeukes2296 Před rokem +6

    Just commenting three years later to say the second season was fucking phenomenal. I watched this video when it came out and then kind of forgot about it, but recently I saw Russian Doll on Netflix, remembered this video, and binged both seasons in two days. I love this show more than Nadya loves Oatmeal.
    Please please please make a video on the second season.

  • @deviousxen
    @deviousxen Před 4 lety +147

    This is one of the best shows I've seen in YEARS including weird anime.

    • @heartsDmise
      @heartsDmise Před 3 lety

      Hans Hanzo boi, One punch man, violet everygarden, ronja the robbers daughter, mushishi, children of the whales, Tokyo magnitude 8.0, erased, princess tutu, kemono no souja erin, moribito, the promised neverland... shall I go on? I have millions of amazing anime recommendations with great storylines and writing! There are plenty of great ones, you just need to look past the generic ones

  • @neyann
    @neyann Před 5 lety +485

    Ummm... This is a masterpiece? Thank you for making this, loved every second of it. I'd be really into pt. 2 that explores those additional theories you've mentioned, just sayin'! 😉

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 5 lety +52

      Wow thanks so much! I don't know if there's more material for a part 2 lol? It would just be a lot of me pointing at different things like...did you see the mirrors here, here and here? Did you notice she's constantly being fed chicken by her friends and with Ruth and at one point chokes on it? Just a lot of that really. Thank you for watching I'm glad you liked it :)

    • @CamiCushing
      @CamiCushing Před 4 lety +28

      Ladyknightthebrave omg I would high-key watch a very long video about you bringing substantial meaning to every other scene, song, food item, all of the things. I absolutely adored every moment of this video. You have a new super fan. 💙

    • @thatonegirludontknow
      @thatonegirludontknow Před 4 lety +5

      @@Ladyknightthebrave What they said!!

    • @ChanceViola
      @ChanceViola Před 4 lety +5

      Ladyknightthebrave I third this I would watch the shit outta this hypothetical video

    • @alannahlouise6154
      @alannahlouise6154 Před 4 lety +3

      ​@@Ladyknightthebrave totally agree would love to see this video come to fruition

  • @lizd.2343
    @lizd.2343 Před 4 lety +313

    darn it...I didn't need to find another female video essayist that does awesome detailed videos that are almost a hour long. I also love Russian Doll, I feel like people sleep on this.

    • @candyisreading8813
      @candyisreading8813 Před 4 lety +5

      Omg please give me your recommendations

    • @lizd.2343
      @lizd.2343 Před 4 lety +25

      @@candyisreading8813 Lindsay Ellis (one women, loves the transformers and drinks her weight in red wine while talking about them) and the Take (mostly run by women, and they take a lot of girly movies and dissect them).

    • @iloveyourunclebob
      @iloveyourunclebob Před 4 lety +15

      @@candyisreading8813 Liz's fantastic recommendations because they are also my favorites. I'd also add in Jenny Nicholson for a much more sarcastic take on pop culture and even though she doesn't do movies, Contrapoints is also another fantastic video essayist for a dissection of life. Ms. Lola also has a great video essay on Lolita that I would recommend. Ms. Lola only has 4 videos so far for a heads up. She might have had a bunch more videos at some time and deleted them. Just right now she only has four. I found her recently with her video essay on Channel Awesome's The Wall parody.

    • @iloveyourunclebob
      @iloveyourunclebob Před 4 lety +9

      @@candyisreading8813 oh and my dumbass also forgot to recommend Sarah Z. More like Contrapoints in the dissection of life, but also pop culture topics including books and even fanfiction.

    • @amyreynolds7244
      @amyreynolds7244 Před 4 lety +9

      @@iloveyourunclebob Darn it I already follow all these people! They are AMAZING don't get me wrong, but, like, I need MORE.

  • @vikthya1711
    @vikthya1711 Před 3 lety +19

    the delivery of "Yeah okay DON" was when I had to pause to hit subscribe. what a gem.

  • @nalurossi6958
    @nalurossi6958 Před rokem +8

    i would love sooooo much to see a video like this about season 2 like, all almost seems like all the themes chosen for this video were the ones they explored in s2

  • @CorbiniteVids
    @CorbiniteVids Před 4 lety +96

    I've watched this a few times now and never noticed the same guys causing trouble in all the different costumes/characters

  • @Timmytamtam
    @Timmytamtam Před 2 lety +4

    I set „gotta get up“ as my alarm sound because I wanted it to be the intro of my every day

  • @Sofifi-tp6xz
    @Sofifi-tp6xz Před 4 lety +83

    never had a video essay bring me to tears before,,,

  • @madeniquevanwyk
    @madeniquevanwyk Před 4 lety +43

    If someone asked me to explain the ending to them, I wouldn't be able to do it, but it evoked such strong emotions in me - positive emotions - that I burst into tears upon seeing Nadya and Allen emerge from the parade. I really don't know, I just love it to death.

  • @wowflower
    @wowflower Před 4 lety +34

    this show struck a serious chord in my heart

  • @River_StGrey
    @River_StGrey Před 4 lety +581

    Arrived for the Russian Doll analysis, subscribed for the pro-feminist snark.

    • @thehorriblebright
      @thehorriblebright Před 4 lety +10

      Would have been the same for me, except I was already subscribing.

  • @wilddogspam
    @wilddogspam Před 4 lety +75

    Wow, I definitely didn't expect this show to have a second season. Looking forward to your next analysis if it does.

    • @moonlily1
      @moonlily1 Před 4 lety +17

      I don't think it should have one, but I'll be there to see what they'll do with it. I hope it won't be a disappointment. Russian Doll was perfect.

  • @adhedonia
    @adhedonia Před 5 lety +87

    You should consider placing your work as podcasts, you have great pronaunciation and you cover material you talk about fully. As I see algorithm has not caught up on you yet. Don't give up the good work :)

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 5 lety +19

      Thank you friend, I'm okay with a smaller audience. I don't know what I would do if my stuff got really big like Lindsay Ellis. Plus you have to pay to host podcasts but not to put videos on CZcams. Thank you for the advice tho, I'm glad you liked the video.

  • @sylviapage61
    @sylviapage61 Před 4 lety +37

    Catch me rewatching this now! i forgot just how much I love it

  • @iSchmidty13
    @iSchmidty13 Před 3 lety +32

    When i was watching it, i didn't even get the slightest vibe of it being a "feminist show". It just felt so real and natural all the way through and i couldn't place exactly why!
    Really a testiment to how well it was written

  • @katchie2888
    @katchie2888 Před 4 lety +22

    The analysis of the music choice is so cool. I only watched this movie once a good while back, but I think I was too mesmerized by the shot composition and surrealism to really notice how haunting the music is. Rewatching some of the scenes, it for sure sets a lot of the unsettled feeling that comes through.

  • @TactownGirl
    @TactownGirl Před 5 lety +54

    I am floored! This video is fantastic! I frick'n love it! I've watched like a million videos about Russian doll and none of them are half as good as this! FANTASTIC WORK HOW DO YOU NOT HAVE MORE SUBS?!

  • @kyajohnson8223
    @kyajohnson8223 Před 4 lety +38

    Girl. Who are yooouuuu? I love your mind and I'm glad I found this challenge

  • @kleerude
    @kleerude Před 4 lety +180

    I was just thinking about how sick to death I am of long-form video essays by men. Thank you so much for adding your voice.

    • @superyoism
      @superyoism Před 4 lety +7

      easy just do not click on them theres plenty of female creators why be sick of different people creating?

    • @Dorian_sapiens
      @Dorian_sapiens Před 4 lety

      I can't see who else you subscribe to, so maybe you already know about these channels, but some of my favorite long-form essayists are Laura Crone, The People's Bayonet, Mad Blender, and Popular C/C (she hasn't uploaded in a while and might be done, but her existing videos are outstanding).

    • @Me1le
      @Me1le Před 4 lety +3

      That's a bit harsh. Though if you're looking for more, Lindsey Ellis has some of the best video essays on CZcams.

    • @DeadpoolAli
      @DeadpoolAli Před 4 lety +1

      @@Me1le also the Take is good too.

  • @TheNumnutRandomness
    @TheNumnutRandomness Před 4 lety +106

    Algorithm did something good for once. Your video is so polished and detailed, how do you only have a few thousand subs?? Awesome video on an awesome show!

  • @CanonShot
    @CanonShot Před 2 lety +4

    9:05 never picked up on the fact that those were the same 3 actors. Wow lol.

  • @shiivainu9442
    @shiivainu9442 Před 4 lety +35

    Beautifully done. I'm a bit of a homebody, with minimal female relationships throughout my life and it has always been harder for me to see the differences between male and female influences in media. You really opened up my mind, here, and I'm grateful for it. This show is undeniably amazing and your analysis fits like a glove!

  • @debramurphy3139
    @debramurphy3139 Před 4 lety +44

    Thank you for making this video,I loved watching Russian doll and this helped me unravel a lot of the stuff that I couldn’t wade through alone,we are all broken but together we can make it through this life..thank you once again...❤️

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 4 lety +2

      Thanks so much I'm so glad you enjoyed this and the Fleabag video! (Also I accidentally hit the thumbs down button, if you get a notice about that just ignore it.)

  • @alexandragabitto2573
    @alexandragabitto2573 Před 4 lety +34

    I love this show and I love your analysis, but I can’t help but feel like failing to mention the Nihilistic symbols inherent in the work is like saying Bojack Horseman is really about Catholicism.
    tw:suicide, depression
    You probably already know this, but for the people in the back the premise is exactly like The Myth of Sisyphus by Camus, enacting the same meaningless task over and over again for eternity. Camus provides two answers to this dilemma: 1) commit suicide and 2) rebel and find happiness by giving it meaning anyway (the latter of which being the option he preferred.)
    The whole horse bit is a reference to Turin’s Horse, an incident that many believed marked Neitzche’s (the philosopher who created Nihilism) descent into severe depression/mental illness. He witnesses a horse tied to a carriage collapse from exhaustion and its master whips the hell out of this poor animal until a sobbing Neitzche stops him whilst having a panic attack.
    Alan = Suicide Option
    Nadia = Rebellious Option
    Horse = A really tired, overworked, depressed animal who caused a famous philosopher’s life to spiral out of control
    Have I mentioned how much I love this show to bits?

  • @monikyrodrigues5267
    @monikyrodrigues5267 Před rokem +2

    Damn. That essay holds up to the standard of the object analysed. ALSO, if there's a video essay award out there, this one should be awarded FOR SURE.

  • @sophiesullivan4888
    @sophiesullivan4888 Před 4 lety +27

    This was legitimately the best show I've EVER seen.

  • @AlienZizi
    @AlienZizi Před 4 lety +44

    "im not saying a man couldn't have written this" i am. no man could, because no man would.

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 4 lety +15

      I will be forgiving in the sense that some female characters I love have been written by men and some women do also write men badly but like...Yeah. This show would probably not be the same if it was by a man.

  • @danny_devitoes5814
    @danny_devitoes5814 Před 3 lety +10

    As a teenage guy that wants to go into film making when I’m older, I just hope I can create something as amazing as this brilliant show

  • @joeyclemenza7339
    @joeyclemenza7339 Před 4 lety +54

    the only thing that would ruin this show is a second season.... keep it a mini series!!! it was flawless in nearly every way, and that cap at the end ties it all up beautifully.
    if they DO do a second season, i really hope it's with different characters and a completely different arch.

    • @lillianmeng5974
      @lillianmeng5974 Před 2 lety

      You’re about to be real disappointed on Wednesday

    • @babymilksnatcher
      @babymilksnatcher Před 2 lety +2

      you'll be surprised about how great it is. they finally had time to unpack Alan and Nadia's generational trauma!

  • @k_a_y_l_e_e
    @k_a_y_l_e_e Před 4 lety +28

    i watched this show in one night. i literally could not stop watching.

  • @sirenesque
    @sirenesque Před 4 lety +22

    Looking forward to seeing your channel blow up! This is seriously quality content.

  • @lionhartd138
    @lionhartd138 Před 4 lety +64

    "Written and directed entirely by women" - well, this explains why it loses me at times. AND it explains why I liked it so much.

    • @lionhartd138
      @lionhartd138 Před 4 lety +1

      11 likes!?! nobody likes my comments that much! Well it's a first anyway. Alright, who liked this comment 7 minutes ago while I was out making coffee? ( Damn, they always hit like when I'm not looking ). One way or another, I'm gna find out who likes what I say sometimes. ( don't make me go back to stalking... )

  • @louispescheux8736
    @louispescheux8736 Před 4 lety +14

    The only essential criticism of this show

  • @Kiannka
    @Kiannka Před rokem +3

    I also love how they picked up the gold piece of Nadias Necklace in Season 2, making the seasons flow into each other smoothly

  • @asariarchie5734
    @asariarchie5734 Před 4 lety +7

    I'm so glad I discovered this channel. The time and effort you put into your videos really shows, and this video will stay with me a while.

  • @YsabelGamache
    @YsabelGamache Před 4 lety +32

    I would not mind a feature length of this.

  • @fakesroyalty
    @fakesroyalty Před 4 lety +4

    This is literally one of the best videos I've ever watched. The level of thought, detail, and production you put into this is astonishing

  • @Konayo_
    @Konayo_ Před 2 lety +6

    I acquired this habit of watching video essays about series' I recently finished during the last few years. And so far, I think this one is the best I've seen. Very nice!

  • @MaverickMario
    @MaverickMario Před 5 lety +10

    You're really fantastic! Your videos keep getting better and more thoughtful. I loved this show when I saw it but I can't believe how much I missed. Thank you so much for sharing all of this research, this is seriously one of the best video essays I've seen on CZcams and I'm really glad I found your channel

  • @yael9455
    @yael9455 Před 4 lety +4

    It's November, and this is only getting recommended to me now.... Amazing job. Your point about the show being so densely packed with story was made cleared cos I could have sworn there were already 2 seasons out of it.

  • @51stcenturygirl
    @51stcenturygirl Před 2 lety +3

    One of things about trauma is feeling/effect of like being in the time loop. If not dealt with and instead suppressed, same feelings and conditions are subconsciously caused in present over and over, stunting growth, enjoyment and life itself. This series represented this remarkably well. In miniature, it is represented in deadly staircase. She dies several times when she tries to escape her repeated party (symbolism of her trying to escape facing her trauma). She manages to delay death by going down fire escape (changing her pattern). And then she manages to get down the stairs when she accepts her birthday party and help from her friend:-) BTW excellent video essay of this great series, I agree with everything 💜

  • @SimplyMayaBeauty
    @SimplyMayaBeauty Před 4 lety +75

    As an Israeli Jew, thank you for the appreciative and respectful coverage of the Jewish themes in the show.

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 4 lety +24

      Hey friend, as an American Jew I'm glad you enjoyed it. Shalom!

  • @worland102688
    @worland102688 Před rokem +1

    I am so glad I found your channel with this video. I love watching in depth video essays on good shows and this one was amazing. I am happy to see you have so many others as well! i can't wait to dive in. Keep up the amazing work.

  • @chromatilla
    @chromatilla Před 4 lety +1

    FLIPPIN EXCELLENT CHANNEL seriously so much work goes into these insightful, badass in depth essays. thank you so much for writing them, they've reignited my love for many films and shows

  • @You-th3cn
    @You-th3cn Před 4 lety +10

    man this video is amazing, it really said almost everything i felt and it brought up so many good points! you’re very smart & well articulated and i love this video a lot, not a moment wasted in russian doll or your video :D (also ive seen all the interviews you referenced omg) thank you for taking the time 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖

  • @cellobabe
    @cellobabe Před 4 lety +1

    This has been one of the best, most in depth, well researched and properly annotated analysis ive watched/ listened to. Subscribed

  • @not_them
    @not_them Před 11 měsíci +1

    Suddenly had the desire to work my way through your videos again starting here. I really love your opinions and your work

  • @angervana
    @angervana Před 4 lety +2

    This is absolutely fantastic!! Thank you so much for making this video and the Fleabag one 👏🏼 I'm looking forward to more videos!!

  • @Kagomai15
    @Kagomai15 Před 4 lety +7

    I loved this show so, so much, and this essay was so good, I got emotional all over again. It's well written, well produced, poignant, and beautiful, and thank you so much for sharing it. Wow. I need to watch this show again!

  • @masondanger522
    @masondanger522 Před 4 lety +4

    ok so like, why is there only 190 subscribers here!? YOU DESERVE WAY MORE! Especially when it's so clear that you put much effort into each video! Criminally underrated, now I'm going to go preach the ways of ladyknightthebrave

  • @carolmay8108
    @carolmay8108 Před 2 lety +9

    So, I started watching this show solely because I knew you made a video essay on that, so thanks for introducing me to it. Something I wanted to share is my own take on why (spoilers incoming) Nadia turned around. Mike decided to explain Alan's actions towards the pair all night. He called Alan crazy, a completely obsessed maniac. What is Nadia told over and over again? "Crazy is not a word we use in this house" said Ruth in so many timelines. It's probably something Nadia has been told many times as she grew up. And after this complete stranger saved her life, she couldn't sleep with some whatever douche call him crazy, nor could she leave that stranger who knew so much about her and seemed to care. It's obviously not as much growth as experienced by the Nadia who's died so many times, but it's still a glimmer, much like with the Alan who hasn't experienced all those deaths. Anyway, lovely video! Have a nice day.

  • @rvnlcks
    @rvnlcks Před rokem +1

    This is just such a beautiful essay. I love this show so much, and I hope we get to hear your thoughts on the second season!

  • @elgoz13
    @elgoz13 Před 4 lety +1

    This show has been haunting me in the best way. I can't forget it and I never want to. Thank you for taking the time to appreciate it in such a well-produced video essay!

  • @arden.in.the.garden
    @arden.in.the.garden Před 2 lety +6

    We’re only 5 or so days out from season 2 and I am so ready to see what comes next.

    • @arden.in.the.garden
      @arden.in.the.garden Před 2 lety +1

      I personally absolutely adored season 2. Is it as good, I’m not sure, but I know that I adore it. I hope you make some sort of video one day about season 2, I love your analysis and how you word your videos. Thank you for introducing me to this show LK. ❤️❤️

    • @somewittyfella5118
      @somewittyfella5118 Před rokem +1

      @@arden.in.the.garden Months out and several rewatchings later, I too can't decide. What I am sure of is that I think the show can end where it did. Starting staring into a bathroom mirror, ending staring into a bathroom mirror.

  • @lauriechrisy1784
    @lauriechrisy1784 Před 4 lety +1

    Thank you for making and sharing this video- this has so much work and beauty to it. Thank you.

  • @eveecco
    @eveecco Před rokem +1

    Quickly wanted to say thank you for making this video. Since this was one of the things you’ve talked about I didn’t know about, and it seemed interesting, I decided to hold off on watch your video essay to watch the series. And god damn it’s amazing and I’m forever thankful that I found it! So thank you for this! 💜

  • @Hellooo134
    @Hellooo134 Před 4 lety +14

    This show is one of, if not my number one, favorite shows.

  • @sequoyachu98
    @sequoyachu98 Před 4 lety +4

    ive never even heard of this show but i took a chance with the youtube algorithm recommending me this and i certainly enjoyed hearing your take on such an interesting series

  • @Artemisio987
    @Artemisio987 Před 4 lety +20

    also, can i have "YEAH OK DON" as a soundbyte? i may need it as quick response to many an argument

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 4 lety +6

      Please use that to your hearts content. If thats how I become a meme thats delightful

  • @emmottbot1645
    @emmottbot1645 Před 3 lety +1

    This video is so well done. Months after finishing the show for the second time and I keep coming back to watch this video over and over. Captivating, and brilliantly executed.

  • @chairisma6055
    @chairisma6055 Před 3 lety

    this is such an incredible analysis, I learned so much and my appreciation for the show has grown even more!! thank u for putting this together

  • @castoputa
    @castoputa Před 4 lety +4

    Your channel is INCREDIBLE, incidentally. Thank you for your hard and glorious work. You’re criminally undersubbed here!!!

  • @peacechickification
    @peacechickification Před 4 lety +5

    I haven’t been so present and enamoured for a CZcams video in ages. Thank you for creating this brilliant, thoughtful nuanced piece about a piece of work that is equally brilliant, thoughtful and nuanced.

  • @kira-lilym6363
    @kira-lilym6363 Před 3 lety +2

    This is absolutely one of the best video essays I've seen! You clearly have a great eye for this and I can see that you've really done your research. Thanks for raising the bar! Really enjoyed watching this, consider me a new fan of yours

  • @MoorRoot
    @MoorRoot Před 4 lety +7

    I was interested in this show, but the fact it includes mentions of Emily of New Moon in it just put it on the top of my list!
    It’s one of my favorite book series growing up (and I still visit it from time to time to this day) and I’m also in the camp that has it as my favorite over the Anne of Green Gables series.
    Thanks for making this!

  • @jessica71921
    @jessica71921 Před 4 lety +3

    I love this. I watched the show and then came back once again, there's something about rewatching with a new perspective that kind of reminds me of the show. Thank you for making this, and the Atlantis video, and the fleabag video. I love it, I love such creative writers such as you.

  • @libelulaojo
    @libelulaojo Před 2 lety +4

    I hope we can look forward to a Russain Doll season 2 video essay from you.

  • @Kagomai15
    @Kagomai15 Před 3 lety +4

    All of your essays make me cry oh my god x'D This time it happened during the Trauma portion of this video, so thanks. I have other things I'd like to say but I can't word them right now lol

  • @mashabudryte5171
    @mashabudryte5171 Před 2 lety +2

    Just watched season 2 and rewatched season 1 and came across this essay - thank you for such a high quality analysis. I have learned a lot and and got answers for the questions I had

  • @stephenievee1126
    @stephenievee1126 Před měsícem

    This is absolutely one of the best reviews on the show if not the best! Totally fan of yours now!

  • @liamcoakley1822
    @liamcoakley1822 Před rokem +5

    “I do not know how to unpack the holocaust”
    Oh Lady Knight, you were so young

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před rokem +5

      Congratulations. This might be the funniest comment I've ever received

  • @jakejereza19
    @jakejereza19 Před 4 lety

    These deep dives are amazing! Super love your insights and your delivery! ❤️✨

  • @eduardocampos5739
    @eduardocampos5739 Před 4 lety +5

    I haven’t reach the middle of the video and I already subscribed! Thank you!

  • @shinniehildebrand
    @shinniehildebrand Před 4 lety +2

    I don't know what made you decide to make these video essays but please, please, please keep doing them. Both this one and Fleabag made me tear up and feel all the feels. Thank you!

  • @moonymilquetoast
    @moonymilquetoast Před 4 lety +1

    Another brilliant video, I hope you keep making them! Russian Doll, Fleabag and The Adventure Zone are the three things that have helped me through the rough patches of 2019, I'm loving these deep dives into story, theme, context, characters and so much more. I'm going to link this to my mom who I showed Russian Doll to last time I visited home as I'm sure she'll love it as much as I did. I hope you keep making videos 😊

  • @margaretmaguire8012
    @margaretmaguire8012 Před 4 lety

    this is such an incredible analysis, i’ve been looking for something involving russian doll that touches on a lot of these pieces and this was so comprehensive and informative!

  • @chelseariley-starr9085

    This channel is amazing. Loving every video I have binged.

  • @Tremeishere
    @Tremeishere Před 4 lety +28

    Came here after seeing your video on Fleabag. I really liked this vid and especially the Judaism section. Being a gentile there were many many things I didn't notice while watching RD. So thanks for that! 😊 PS: now this is how you do a video essay! A LOT of people doing them on CZcams (cough cough most of them men cough cough) shoudl take a cue from you.

    • @Ladyknightthebrave
      @Ladyknightthebrave  Před 4 lety +8

      Aw thanks I appreciate that. Although I will say I am by no means reinventing the wheel when it comes to video essays. If you want to see more essays by women I highly recommend Jenny Nicholson or Lindsay Ellis

  • @fravels9903
    @fravels9903 Před 2 lety +3

    Cant wait for you to review the 2nd season 💕💕💕

  • @ellieroder7315
    @ellieroder7315 Před 3 lety

    every part of this analysis is just so mindblowingly good, i'm so impressed! and wow there is so much i did not understand or even think about (even after 3 watches of the show!) that you explained so well, thank you

  • @charisleighmusic
    @charisleighmusic Před 3 lety

    I love your lengthy analysis videos! I love commentary and always wish yours were longer. Keep. It. Up.

  • @Chloe-ox7hd
    @Chloe-ox7hd Před 3 lety

    I love love how all the scenes you used. It explains the characters perfectly

  • @TheKoalaclub
    @TheKoalaclub Před 4 lety +3

    OMG I-was addicted from the beginning . Loved it!!!!