What are the roots of the campus protests? | Unreported World
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 04. 2024
- Unreported World meets the students divided by the conflict in Gaza who are fighting for their voices to be heard on campus.
Subscribe to our channel for more Unreported World episodes / unreportedworld .
Across universities in the United States a battle is raging over freedom of speech. At Columbia University two pro-Palestinian groups have been banned for holding unauthorised protests about Gaza, a move members say is about shutting down any criticism of Israel.
Amidst allegations of intimidation, antisemitism and Islamophobia, reporter Kiran Moodley follows a Palestinian student and Jewish-American student to see if he can find common ground.
Filmed, Produced & Directed by: Nick Blakemore
Series Producer: Andy Lee
Executive Producer: Ed Fraser
Production Company: Channel 4 News
We don't have to worry about "free Palestine" We now have to worry about "free USA"
Yes free USA from isNOTreal
From AIPAC
We free the USA from Israel, which contributes heavily to political campaigns here and it's a cheap investment on return for them. They just got US taxpayers for 92 billion in war funding.
Zionism has been entrenched in American politics for over one hundred years ! It also influences the religion, the culture the entertainment industry, and its education systems.
They're inseparable.
Amazing how different the people are here from their "representative" government.
It's just Woke Students with no knowledge about History
Mind Begs the Question:
- When Governed by Politicians
- Who justify Starvation,Death Camps,Gas Chambers/White Phosphorus,Ethnic Cleansing,etc
- Governed by Righteous or Satanic?
They aren’t even necessarily citizens
You will be amazed on how much differeing opinions the whole populace has. To claim one side represent "the true people" is a recipe for fascism.
@@exextrovert The majority are.
How can one possibly be pro-genocide? How can one possibly not be pro-peace?
Genocides tend to come with lots of excuses. The victims are dehumanized and seen as an entirely criminal population.
The natural law is tooth & claw.
By the following:
1. Saying hamas are freedom fighters
2. Chanting entifada
3 Saying from the river to the sea.
Hamas keeps refusing ceasefire ... you do know that, right? last time was a few days back. yeah they want israel to stop shooting, but unconditionally lloolll
If Israel stops fighting and protecting its people now, it will be a genocide of its entire population. If Hamas stops fighting now, there will be peace. I hope you understand this? Why do you think a country like Israel has to invest a fortune to protect its people? 1/5 of the citizens of Israel are Arab BTW.
I appreciate the communication between them, that is noble and that is the way out of this difficulty.
These two young men at the last session are giving the hope for the two entities Israel and Palestina to life together 🙏🙏
if criticizing Israel and it's policy is antisemetic, then
by this logic, u cant criticize Saudi or Iran because that is islamophobic.
No one is saying you can't protest or that it is anti-semitic unless perhaps you are calling for the destruction of Israel. But you can't make campuses threatening to other students. That is a completely different issue especially on private universities who can restrict what you do on their privately owned campus. Even the KKK marched peacefully in Skokie.
No.
Sorry bud but a public display of support for intifada and 'resistance at all costs' is in direct correlation to jews being blown to bits on busses.. so, criticize away, hell I criticize Israel myself non-stop, but the underlying meaning of all of this that was designed to fly over these students heads are the problem and nothing else
@@mdarrenu If there's a state committing tremendous evil, would it not be justified to call for its destruction, without harm to its people or civilians?
@@yasink331 That is pretty much all states since all commit tremendous evil. I just don't see that much evil with Israel. Some sure. People pick sides. I don't live in Israel or Gaza so I don't have all the facts or have an opinion that matters.
when somebody is telling you, you are not going to have freedom until i feel safe. you know that you do not have the equal rights.
Which governments, countries or entities involved here care about "freedom" and human rights? It's not Russia, Qatar, Iran, China, North Korea, the Houthis, Hezbollah or Hamas.
How does this quote or any Hamas laws over the past 18 years support any definition of freedom and equal rights? "We support the eradication of Israel through armed Jihad and struggle. This is our doctrine." - Sinwar
Open your mind to Palestinians like John Aziz, HowidyHamza and Ahmed Fouad Alkhatid.
In your weird understanding of the world...... it is very easy to fix this. Make them feel safe, right? Hahaha
@@MsBhappy When you leave people no choice they cling on to whatever they find. Years of oppression from Israel and years of blockade has gotten us to this point. The only way for a two state solution to even work is if israel gives up its sick fantasy that it's people are a chosen people and works with the UN to free the Palestinians it has prisoned in Gaza. All I see from Israel is death and destruction. They don't even let aid in. Whatever comes their way at this point is justified.
@@MsBhappy as a chinese, I can confirm that Chinese government doesn't care about human rights, at least not of ppl of china.
@@farsalami8605respect other people, give them equal rights. You will never be safe by practicing apartheid
protesting is a natural right, harassing is not. both sides need to live with that.
"Some Jewish students will say that they are also a minority. What do you say to that?" "Sorry, I have to go to class, goodbye."
That means she thinks J's are powerful and somehow opt out of any racial dynamics. Nevermind the "H" a couple of decades ago, all the nations that exiled and kept out of, still being the leading target of hate crime in current day, and literally being a minority...but some have whiter complexion, therefore it ceases to all exist.
My thoughts too. She cried loudly that she wants to protest for the minorities/victims like her, but when it's pointed out that the Jews are minorities too, she pleads the 5th
Not only are Jews one of the biggest minority's on the planet, Jews have also experienced the Holocaust in very recent history and ancient history. Let's also add that Israel's land and country size is 1000 times smaller than the surrounding Islamic countries. Who's the minority now? 🤷♂️
Sick
Jew hatred is easy. Its one of the smallest minorities that exists.
Can you still protest against war in the USA or not?
Yes, if you submit & get permit from City. Then protest peacefully. Abide by traffic Laws. Stand on sidewalk not in street. Pretty simple rules.
@@Rich-yj4ubyou sound like you live in moscow. in this country, people have a right to free expression and the right to peaceably assemble. period. its in the bill of rights. no conditions, no permits. its definitely pretty simple
@@MattMajcan You are ignorant of the laws, then 🤣
@@MattMajcan Then why do they block traffic? Stand in the streets? Chant nasty vile hate 😤. Law abiding citizens won't stand for that. Never, never never...
@@Rich-yj4ubwould you have stood by germany in ww2 if people had blocked the streets speaking out against it?
At 6:40 the student is asked if he trusts Netanyahu and the Israeli govt. He says “I’m not sure if I trust him, but in times of war I have to”. Prior to Oct 7th, Netanyahu was facing opposition from many Israeli citizens. Makes me wonder how much Netanyahu benefited from the attack?
Benefited?
The attack absolutely played right into his hands. Before Oct 7 he couldn't even form a coalition government and he was wildly unpopular
One poll/survey from November 2023: "Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu also faced disapproval, with 73% of respondents expressing dissatisfaction with his performance."
However, there's also the saying "nothing unites like a common enemy" and that was shown to be the case with Arab Israelis and Jewish Israelis after October 7 (not for all but unity increased).
This is true for any and every country during war and its roots are in evolutionary psychology because of fight or flight, life or death, and community and societal preservation and uniting over shared values and national identity. 😮
One protest against the government last year had 200,000 attendees. There have been protests against Netanyahu all throughout this war. He won the 2022 election by less than 1% of the vote. People blame him for the failure to prevent October 7th so he'll be out of government with the next election.
@@joycelee1807 yea. He was close to being ousted and many of the population was unhappy with his rule prior to Oct 7th. After that he was given total command and got support amidst the chaos.
@@MsBhappy good points but don’t forget Israel was warned 3 days prior to the attack. But they were still caught by surprise. Are you telling me they’re that incompetent or was it on purpose?
Jews can "return to their lands" (while an Ashkenazi of the 21st century has no relation to a Hebrew of Antiquity) but Native Americans do not have the right to return to their sacred lands, strange...
And humans needing a relationship to long departed ghosts to sanctify where they are on the planet is even stranger.
That's what your terrorist friends told you?
Nice try. Dont pretend like you know what you are taking about. Le5s talk about Palestine that never existed as a country
@@HELLWARS101 All Arab countries had their independence except Palestine. The state of Israel is a promise of the British COLONIAL Empire. This is why the USA loves Israël : the two countries share the passion to kill and colonize the natives in the name of a religious book.
@@HELLWARS101 what is a country? Snap out of the colonial mindset then answer the question.
Literally at the same time, screaming "Intifada" and holding a "ceasefire now" sign 🙄
Well said, the absurdity here is insane.
@@SoMeBoDyThatUKnowUS It will take an Intifada to reclaim the land stolen from them over the past 80 years, and when the zionists leave, there will be peace, not absurd at all
schizophrenic
Dictionary
Definitions from Oxford Languages
in·ti·fa·da
/ˌin(t)əˈfädə/
noun
the Palestinian uprising against Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, beginning in 1987.
So you can't uprise against occupation and ask the occupation to stop killing you ?! Or do you just flinch at every Arabic work you don't understand and consider it to be a terror chant ?
....they are not the sharpest knives in the block. "...thick as rocks..."
The students need courses in Middle East history and Jewish history too. Many of them don’t know what they are chanting about.
There is. It teaches them not to hate either one. That's what the protest is about.
Why only Jewish history?
@@emberson7850but they hate Jews
Those students care nothing about justice. They're just supporting the intersectionist brand. Their tears for gaza civilians are crockadile tears.
@@emberson7850 ?? Then why are they bullying Jewish students? There is nothing peaceful about what we see and the violence of the protests around the world. Do you realize who is behind all this and that Iran, an oppresive regime, is behind all this from the beginning?
I’m enjoying this coverage. Thanks ❤
You know this is about racism and hypocrisy when you realise that critising Is real is promoted as anti Jewish whilst critising Saudi or Iran is not never ever labelled as anti muslim.
Yes it is , all the time! The difference is that being anti Islam is rational and even compulsory for those of us who believe in the triumph of civilation over the savage. Count me among them
Muslims don't consider Iran Muslim
@@jennydawson6952you’re just sad lol
Yes, people are hypocrites when they won't condemn Muslims & Islamic countries for beheading journalists, flogging bloggers, issuing fatwas against critics, throwing gay men off rooftops, female genital mutilation, throwing acid in women's faces, prohibiting women from driving, moving freely about, or getting an education, & countless others ways they oppress non-Muslims, & women & gay people. Theocracies are not good places to live if you are not a member of that religion. It's interesting that people who claim to be pro-Democracy & progressive want to see Israel, the only Democratic, progressive country in the Middle East, wiped off the map, while they support brutal Islamic theocracies or kingdoms where minorities & women have no human rights. Why aren't all these women protesting wearing burkas? They support a religion that, once gaining control of a state, forces women to wear black from head to toe in the scorching sun. Tell you what... Go protest or march for gay rights in Iran & see how long you last. Yes, if you chant, "From the river to the sea," you are supporting the genocide of Jews throughout the Middle East. Israel is the only place where Jews, Christians, & Muslims live side by side w/ equal rights & in peace. Arabs in Israel can vote & they hold offices in the legislative branch & the Judiciary. And you want to destroy them. That's what "From the river to the sea" means. No Israel. So, yes, you are anti-Semitic. And don't ever call yourself progressive, pro-woman, pro-human rights, or pro-Democracy. [ETA: One thing you CAN say you are is pro-terrorism because October 7 was a terrorist attack on Israeli women & children, which was like Timothy McVeigh bombing the building in Oklahoma City or like the ISLAMIC terrorists who murdered innocent people on 9/11/2001. Hamas is a terrorist organization who have stated that their goal is to destroy Israel. They are not interested in peace, a 2-state solution (they've refused repeated offers), negotiations, or ceasefires (they've broken those again & again). Their goal is to terrorize & kill all the Jews in the Middle East. Do you think suicide bombers & fanatics who fly planes into buildings would hesitate to use Palestinian people as their human shields so they can launch rockets on Israel under the protection of being located in a hospital or a school? Do you think that religious fanatics who believe they will be rewarded in the afterlife for killing Jews, and who killed Muslims & people from Arab countries who were in the World Trade Center on 9/11 care about the Palestinians either? You are pro-terrorism when you support Hamas. Israel wants to stop Hamas, not commit genocide on all Palestinians. Hamas is killing Palestinians by using them as human shields in their single-minded quest to rid the Middle East of Jews.]
women don’t have equal rights in those countries.
lol notice how the Palestinian guy wouldn’t say he doesn’t support Hamas
For a lot of those people they have personal friends/family that have died and 100% view them as freedom fighters. That may not be what we feel, but what would you think if you were him? What if you entire family was blown up on their way to see you? You need to have empathy for these people and what the history of that region is.
Having said that, yes, that is a huge problem that a lot if their leaders support an organization we have fought as terrorist entity forever.
@@GraceCole-qy6ul Y'all invaded so many countries claiming they are terrorists or they have nuclear weapons, but later the world finds out y'all were just there to steal oil and enslave civilians. Sorry, but the world does not revolve around you.
@@GraceCole-qy6ul don't forget the rape/murder of teenagers at a music festival.
No one really wants to talk about how the Palestinians were treated directly before Oct 7th. The people in the West Bank are still suffering. How long are they supposed to be oppressed. The kingdom of Saudi Arabia with its trillions of dollars and oil is not interested in helping other Arabs. Jordan is concerned with being friends to the U.S. The Palestinians need a hero. South Africa tried, but the global police will not rise up.
FREE THE HOSTAGES
100 plus on one side and 6000 plus on the other. ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT ONE SIDE ONLY OR BOTH
FREE GAZA FROM ISRAELI OPPRESSION!
@@nadaissa1969 war isn’t fair. Sorry.
Yes!!!! Free the THOUSANDS OF PALESTINIAN HOSTAGES!!! Thank you for remembering this!
Hannibal Directive !!!
The questions asked to the Palestinian student were far more harsh compared to others.
Expecting the Palestinian to condemn, and justify, whilst ignoring such questions for other participants in the program.
can't agree more.
Why this is happening? I believed this is on going but school administration ignored and failed to check it.
you guys are so brave.
This is amazing reporting. Awesome! This is what we need more off. Just great journalism. 👏
What is happening in Nigeria is not genocide?
When they can't stop a genocide in gaza they can't stop genocide anywhere .
this is about a coalition between the "woke left" and islamists, the "woke left" (ultimately) want a world revolution, the islamists ultimately want to kill jews worldwide. It is not about the civilians in Gaza, they don´t care. The marches go on for there to be even more killed civilians. Without the support HAMAS think they have in the west, HAMAS would have made a deal with Israel to stop the war a long time ago.
It absolutely is, they just don't care.
What is happening in nigeria?
@@donelci9337 62,000 Christians and some moderate Muslims have been unalived by radical iss lame ists.
Over 400,000 killed in Yemen (ongoing), more than 600,000 killed in Ethiopia (ongoing), tens of thousands slaughtered in Sudan (ongoing), similarly in Nigeria (ongoing), and over 700,000 killed in Syria (ongoing). But for a generation educated by TikTok, Al Jazeera, and so-called "anti-Western imperialism" as espoused by their post-modern college professors, there's only one conflict worth getting off the sofa for.
Well, that makes israel OK to day that. 😂
At least we should stop sending our money to them
Think of it as the Gateway activism, some people start here and then expand their scope to the other injustices. Then to the greater global imperialistic colonial system that links all of these tragedies together.
the government is not blowing all of our money that they could use in our country and sending it to these wars THATS THE DIFFERENCE...... this is the united States not Israel these wars do not concern us we don't need to send 60billion dollars to goddamn Ukraine and Israel every month... lets these countries deal with their own problems. these students have the right to be mad because there using THEIR money for Israel.
@@thanos9820that's called hypocrisy of Islamic world.
It's different when your country is directly supporting it. You think these people support those conflicts? America is the bgigest genocider since the Nazis.
What wonderful young people
There's still hope in the world!!
THERE IS FAR FAR MORE OF US THAN THESE. BEST YEAR EVER FOR EXCITING VIDEOS. SO GLAD , HAPPY, HAPPY , HAPPY , HAPPINESS IS A WARM FEELING.
Great video
Now that Nuland and Clinton are the Columbia staff, I'm surprised anybody sends their kids there!!
Driving down the road I watched a woman deliberately pull her car over on a dangerous bridge with no sidewalk so that she could remove and deface Israeli Flags.
Your species can only lie, cheat, steal, and kill.
Not suprised, that flag has killed many kids elderly and women. It's killed many civilians. It is not a flag that anyone should be proud of because it is a flag that represent oppression and genocide.
People love to feel justified in external hatred to avoid facing themselves...
I now see the israeli flag as i see the swastika.symbol of mass murder and fascism. What was an israeli flag doing in the usa anyway?
what were those flags doing on the bridge?
As Jewish Americans we failed to force Israel Govt. to make Israel an open fair society with rights for all, every body. We needed to restrict our economic aid to force Israel to end the apparent apartheid and repression and settler violence, houses bulldozed and Palestinians pushed out and land grab in violation of UN resolutions. Our military aid cannot be used on civilians and our Senators must sue the U.S. govt. to withdraw military aid used against civilians, its illegal. Hamas was acting brutally but what was their motivation. We should have restrained Israel for years,
Which country in the mid-east has this 'open fair society with rights for all'?
Iran? Saudi? Egypt? Pakistan? Iraq? Libya? Lebanon? UEA? Qatar? Sudan? Syria?
Afghanistan? Jordan? And please say where you'd prefer to live?
@@PrivateWalker
You could have been an example of democracy to those countries with dictators, theocrats and kings but you preferred to be only for yourselves (although not for Jewish Arabs and Ethiopians Jews) and dehumanizing Palestinians and your neighboring countries! You have lost your moral compass. 😢
Israel is home to over 2 million Arab citizens who enjoy full rights. While the Palestinian Authority said they will never accept a single Jewish citizen.
Apartheid?
Regarding the security measures like walls and checkpoints, these were implemented after a series of terror attacks. Israel faced a difficult choice: either forcefully remove Palestinian Arabs or implement protective measures to prevent further attacks. You prefer the first option?
The US aid to Israel constitutes barely 1% of Israel's GDP. You think that without the US aid Israel will fall?!
UN resolutions? Did you ever see a list of UN resolutions? They almost never say anything against actual oppressive regimes, all they do year-long is one thing - Israel, Israel and Israel. Easy to bully a small country with a minority of 16 million people vs. 2 Billion Muslims. It's politics.
History shows that the Jewish people have endured challenges over time, while those who harbor hatred will ultimately fade into obscurity.
@@faniarethas2716 The Shah tried that you tool 🤣
I'm indigenous English & experience muslims & their culture on a daily basis. If forced to live in the mid-east then there's only Israel. How many hands & feet, arms & legs do they arbitrarily chop off? How many lashings? Stonings?
It's abundantly clear Israel is the dam holding back islamic fundamentalism - no wonder they don't like it!
Edit:- And you're unable & unwilling to answer - Where'd you'd rather live - but we all know that answer!
The leaders of the 'Palestinians' never wanted peace with the Jewish people even before the rebirth of Israel in 1948.
I really enjoyed this video. It showed both sides. I've been doing my best to try to understand both sides of the debate but mainstream AND alternative media makes it difficult to not be biased. There are definitely some bad actors on both sides that are making the divisiveness even worse.
I've attended my share of campus demonstrations, but nothing is more confusing than this issue. I ask numerous people to have an open conversation about what they are demonstrating for and get told to talk to their cell leaders and then they turn their back towards me. Really? You choose to take a side in a very serious debate yet you can't debate on your own understanding? So I go talk to their mommy and daddy and they tell me they have overwhelming support. From who? The community that you have lied to support your own hatred views. There is much more to this issue than we all think.
What do you want to know ?
free the hostages then talk about ceasefire
What about the thousands of Palestinians illegally imprisoned by isnotreal?
What about them? @@RichHandsome
@@RichHandsome Can you tell Hamas? first free hostage then ceasefire? If you don't want free hostage we will say no ceasefire
@@g.classens1284 80 hostages strong exscuse for 80 years oppression, fascism, currently a genocide. some very smart jews going about
I'm sorry but SO meny of you don't even know what you are talking about!!! There is NO reason that Hamas should not have done 7 Oct
"Jewish Voice for Peace" is a misnomer and antisemitic. period . the end.
"I plead the 5th" yeah, that about sums it up
Palestinian try to make term “intifada” is normal 😂 , just check what was happen in intifada and u will know what is it and then understand that palestinian protesters is calling that this will be “global” … no thanks
Learn to spk english first??
9:16 oh the classic “you’re asking me the wrong questions” 😂🤣
They know how to play on tankie’s emotions, but the minute you try actual logic with them their brain just malfunctions
This is propaganda period.. the lemmings will find there way here to say “free Palestine” anyway 🇺🇸 smooth brains
that part right there said it all
😂😂😂😂😂😂true
the most important part of communication is context, which u seemed to miss
There's no tankies to be seen here
Why can't the UN send peace keeping soldiers into Gaza to help distribute food. ( why is the UN so quite, they have sent peace keepers to various countries in the past. ( when it suits their motives I guess)
Because they don’t want to be shot by hamas.
The UN caused all this mess when they split up Palestine. They don't own the land. The UN has blood on their hands for causing this
UN is corrupt.
Cause you need UN Security Council’s approval and the USA will always vote it down.
These protesters are bullies.
Ir-an is funding these protests.
One side has offered peace one side has according to their own words and many many surveys conflict until they end up with everything.Case closed
I remember, when the NEWS broke out on the streets of Gaza, and terrified Jewish captors were dragged mercilessly into the covens of Hamas, the vast majority of Gazans were euphoriated shouting ALLOW-ARK-BARR!!!!
Today, the cry is ALLOW-US-BACK!!!!!
.......Jewish captives......
Shut up.
Stupidity has no limits.
Who is?
Talk about yourself?
@@fatbulousgurl_ Where are the Queers for Palestine? I miss those geniuses.
@@mentalminority i look myself cuz i'm not stupid.
So I'm sorry if i hurt your feelings when i called you stupid.
I really thought you already knew.
Keep talking.
I remember how Palestinians were celebrating after 9/11 attack on America, and how Israel was helping America to fight terrorism since they has a lot more experience with terrorism, in the Middle 'East. While Its easy to fool Genz;s who were not around when 9/11 happened, they will not fool older generation,..
I remember that too: I saw the planes on TV and after, when heroes were looking for survivors in New York, etc. But it looks like we did not teach those students well.
Clearly you don't remember the past century of colonialism in the Middle East and how y'all divided the people into arbitrary regions to make them hate each other while y'all exploited their resources, and then you complain when they fight back
do you remember the reason caused 911?
Mossad / CIA
You mean the dancing Isrseli's who were arrested and then later releasedback to Israel later? Don't flip it. Look it up.
Novara media and owen jones have been covering these issues in detail.
yes, they have en eccentric take on these issues that a lot of wokies seem to love
@@MiMiiViVi if you can stand his drooling dry voice, disengenious way of arguing beside the point by strawman, and sneaky, twisted, slow narrative, then yes, sure.
Covering it terribly
@@WUB0105wow! glad to know that your opinion is poor. 😃😂😂
@@okapi3202 I wonder why so many here like to post slogans. That speaks for itself.
AMP and two SJP chapters cohosted an event in May 2023 featuring Mohammad el-Mezain, who served time in prison for funding Hamas. Students for Justice in Palestine is a terrible organization.
What's worse ?? some of those in the Israeli government are known criminals
Take a look at who is in the Israeli Parliament
"KNOWN TERRORIST "
@@nadaissa1969Why don't you like Mansour Abbas?
Or are you referring to how both Iman Khatib-Yasin and Aida Touma-Sliman were rightfully sanctioned by the Knesset ethical committee?
@@MsBhappyIsreal is a Nazi State..
I don't hear Israelis incite violence like the Palestinian people or the Hamas people
Did you not hear is ra hell leaders inciting violence over and over again. Are you deaf or blind...Thank God for social media. The world See is ra hell for exactly who and what they are, and the g....d is PALESTINIANS day life
Daily
@@azizahsattar444 Name one place in middle east where a muslim has the same rights that a muslim-arab has in state of israel?? I dare you to find anything remote to that level of rights and equality. ( And i mean from a mainstream islamic sect of that country... not shia in saudie... or sunni in iran.... or non-hanafi in afghanistan etc etc ) Just a regular muslim.
Name one country where they have that level of rights.
I'm actually from middle east and reside and travel mostly there. For me, writing something on internet..... i use 100 tricks to hide my identity. Do you know that in every muslim country you can go to jail for years... just because of a instagram post.... follow someone... or even like something?
Let these girls go to Gaza and see how they like it ( without the war ). see how Hamas ideology is.
Unfortunately for westerners.... you have imported this mentality to the west. Just a few days ago 16 year old stabbed a christian priest 7 times in the chest during his sermon in australia..... come on let's get real.
@@farsalami8605 And how is this relevant? Are you saying because they are Muslim it is acceptable to slaughter 13,000 plus children? Are you saying because they are muslim it is acceptable to commit war crimes against them?
Right... maybe you are wearing eyes covering and earplugs
The last 30 seconds gives me hope! This is what the administration should be doing, creating constructive places for dialogue, instead they are sending the NYPd after children.
Maybe these overgrown babies should stop rioting.
@@noco7243 maybe you fascists should stop the genocide
1970 palestinians 🇵🇸 Vs jordanians🇪🇭 30,000 deads womans and kids included
Yeah but nobody cares about that. If you are of a certain religion you can't do that lol
They don't teach about Black September in college campuses. In fact, they don't cover any conflict in which the religion of peace kill their own, like the massacre of 300,000 in Syria. There is an obsession with only one country.
Because the Palestinians were radicals that tried to take over Jordan! Jordan asked Pakistan to assist them repel the Palestinians and they laid waste to the Palestinian terrorists!
That is how dictatorships are maintained. This is why the West keeps them propped up. Democracy would be a huge problem for Israel and the West.
@@mathieufaltys so you are saying that these nations are actually democrats... but the west keeps them under dictatorship? lol
I love the idea of a place to be able to come and have organic discussion in a respectful manner. I will say that I thought this lady was onto something until she said that if you can't prove intent that it would be considered crimes against humanity. If you look at the details of the International law the things that Hamas are doing makes the accusation completely wrong.
If you encourage your children to fight your wars, including having them murder themselves so that they can also murder Jews at the same time, I'm sorry, that is not ever going to work. I promise you that Gaza would have been their own state long ago had they not used only violence to get their way.
If these kids there are Palestinian, then they have been lied to. They believe things that are absolutely not true then.
And their hate has produced only violence.
I mean you can't just occupy someone's land and not expect some sort of retaliation or violence, no country in the world would ever do that lol. Can you imagine what would happen if Iran tried to occupy the US? Do you think America would just stand by and do nothing? This is time and time again where Palestine tried to appease the UN to be recognized as a member only to be rejected time and time again by the West. So it's clear to me that Israel and the US are not interested in a 2 state solution, only in the complete destruction of Palestine.
lol, your definition of international meaning US and Israel, how graciously rasism, orientalist, and xenophobic of you! even US allies are condemning Biden administration and Zionism. You are living in delusion.
@cnn @msnbc this is what you call more objective journalism. You report on BOTH sides, not just the pro Israeli side.
Funny cause from my point of view msnbc is pro Palestinian.
check out how U of Chicago handles this! lessons to be learned.
Why are non Muslim students wear the Kaffiya? It's a religious symbol, and the colors mean the Haj.
It's not and can't be the symbol of Palestinian struggle since many Muslims in Israel were slaughtered in October 7th. Some Muslims are still kept captive by Hammas!
Badauin (Muslims) helped rescue people from the music festival, and many serve in the IDF.
This is not a religious war, it shouldn't be, and dangerous people want it to be that
They wear in support of Palestinians
But whoever has the power to speak will allow the truth.
its a piece of fabric, calm down.
@@Naomadtingz@Naomadtingz, they are culture-appropriating. I thought progressives stood against that?
You are right in that it is not a religious war, never has been. It is a colonial war, always has been.
The reporter seems biased and asks leading questions that seem to have obvious answers.
For the students, you need to face your studies and not meddle into what you do not really understand. If you need purpose in life, relocate to Sudan or Somalia or Yemen and you'll find millions who need your 'voice and passion for humanity'. In this case though 1,000+ citizens of one single country were brutally killed and it was televised. What you think doesn't matter to be honest. After September 11, the US didn't really care about what anyone thought. They crossed borders and went into Iraq and Afghanistan. Number of civilian deaths in the thousands? Number of aid workers and reporters killed? Well do the maths and consider if you're being hypocritical in this current case.
Imagine if all voices condemned Hamas since October 8? Would thousands of civilians not be spared today? But by wasting time criticizing a Government for being responsible for its citizens' lives, you are emboldening Hamas and not going to (ever) achieve anything with Israel because they are more than justified in their response.
Yh n when they do it. Its fine. Destroying a person's life n job for asking countries to stop this genocide. So who's the criminals
such a disappointment, i am in college and we've had our share but thankfully it's under control… this on the other hand💀
This situation is terrible but the reality is that when you mix two different cultures/religions with different worldviews then you're going to bring conflict one way or the other without a permanent peaceful resolution. The only realistic way to resolve this is for the complete capitulation of one side, that's how wars and conflicts usually resolve themselves whether you like it or not. So either Israel loses (which in terms of military strength is very unlikely to happen if you're going with loss on the battlefield) or Gaza falls completely under Israeli control, that's it
This is not about cultures mixing. Israel is home to a large Arab population within its borders. The Israeli Arabs make up about 20 % of the population. They have full citizenship and equal rights, and generally, the large majority of them, live good lives there, have careers, choose their life. The culture is not the issue.
@@WUB0105 Whether or not they have benefits does not change their cultural/religious worldviews. Someone can be enjoying all of those benefits and still desire the downfall of the nation they're living in or bordering because fundamentally their cultures conflict with one another. Historically Israel has a fair claim to the region because they were the first to settle there amongst the two of them. However, the Muslim people have their fair claim as well for having inhabited the region for a longer period of time after the fact. The region is culturally important for both of them and neither side will back down as a result. So yes, it's both of these cultures mixing in an area that they each say is theirs by right that is causing the issue
@@kabura8742 I´m saying: Inside Israel, generally, those Arabs that are Israeli, are happy to be so. When asked, 90 % + want to go on as Israeli Arabs living in Israel. The Arabs in Gaza and the West Bank (that Israel won from Jordan in the 1967-war) is what is the issue. As the Arabs in Israel, and the Arabs in Gaza and the West bank shared history until 1948, I don´t believe that the explanation is due to different cultures. The fact is, that the Israeli Arabs living in Israel (ie not those living in Gaza, not those living in West Bank) live happy lives, generally, and does not want a Palestine to live in. Many people in Israel support a Palestinian state, but they don´t want to live there. Not even the Arab Israelis want to go live in that potential new state. In my mind, that is fact, not opinion.
@@WUB0105 Then in your opinion what would be your solution to bring peace between the two sides? As I cannot see a path forward between the two that leaves both sides satisfied because of their differing ideologies
@@kabura8742 I think that will be a long, long road, and that Israel hopefully have learnt a lesson from oct 7th, painful as it obviously is.
I learned a lot from YT-podcasts on the subject. I would recommend Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Douglas Murray, Dan Scheuftan (on Quilette), and others.
Strangely they are silent for Afghan women, Iranian women and other !slamic @trocities on other religion like in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Africa
calm down. Those woman probably live a better life than you. Just worry about your own affairs.
They aren't though?
Well it's not in the news and you can't directly blame "capitalism" for it...
So it's not fitting their world view of "good" vs "bad"
@@gerri577 False. They most definitely do not.
@@Knight766 meh
Go freedom of speech❤
Free speech should never include hate speech, intimidation of a minority, incitement of violence, prejudice or treason.
The people exercising it every week continue to take it for granted. They're simultaneously hating and denouncing the country that gives them liberties, human rights and freedoms that Hamas, Hezbollah, Yemen (Houthis), the Islamic Republic of Iran, North Korea, Russia, Qatar, China who they now support are all against and who deny their citizens/civilians the same...
Protests are not allowed if violent look at the constitution which the pro palistine ones are almost always violent
" Genocide "
Section 1091 of Title 18, United States Code, prohibits genocide whether committed in time of peace or time of war. Genocide is defined in § 1091 and includes violent attacks with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. There is Federal jurisdiction if the offense is committed within the United States. There is also Federal extraterritorial jurisdiction when the offender is a national of the United States.
How about Anti Human that more Dangerous..not only for one ethnic that same like racism to other when you just concerned for one group of people.
Excellent report and perspectives ! We truly need to dialogue and more PEACE-BUILDING classes .´
Why does he believe he can change the rules of a University
They come and sharia follows
He is Muslim
@@80siddsooo stupid..
@@80sidd Oh, sorry that is ridiculous, but thanks for playing.
Because students change universities all the time! I’m an alumnus of Columbia and can tell you that 20 years ago I along with a group of students, changed Columbia ✊🏾🙌🏾 so best believe he can and we will change it again.
Who started the entifada
The oppresssed.
@mandelmon no Israel didn't start the entifada. Peaceful muslims did.
The Intifada was a reaction of the Palestinians to the offer of a state for Palestine, because they were angry that they did not get Israel. This is the main reason why there is no Palestinian state, they wanted everything and they prefer to make war than to work on their state.
You started watching the news on october 7th I see!@sarahhumphreys3980
@@sarahhumphreys3980Isreal colonized Palestinian territory and continue to spread out into more Palestinian territory, them colonizing Palestine makes them the ones that started this entire conflict. Isreal started all this, Palestinians are defending themselves from an occupier and an oppressor
“If one has to refer to any of the parties as a terrorist state, one might refer to the Israeli government, because they are the people who are slaughtering defenseless and innocent Arabs in the occupied [Palestinian] territories, and we don’t regard that as acceptable.” (1990) - Nelson Mandela
They should let Palestinian refugees into SA to guarantee complete downfall of sa and turn it islamic too
does anyone understand 'cause and effect'?
I never go down to US from my sweet old Canada
you have it worse, dear
You're talking about the Old Canada of 15 years ago, it doesn't exist anymore. We live in clown world now.
Canada is a s hit hole. hopefully we get rid of trudo next election.
have you been to canada? lol
Good. Stay there.
Hamas - So who abducted the 200+ people at a Festival October 7th that started this particular uprising and conflict???
Hamas.. they started the war. Now, they use as many human shields as possible.
Israel did
@nowayangelo Read a history book and become educated, then you can have a informed and educated decision
@@captpain1 lol, all the history books tell us that israel stole the land and persecuted the Palestinians ever since.
Nope, the 76+ years of land theft, murder, and occupation was started by Isreal
Advice to the American government: These students do not find jobs after graduation. The reason is that the American government pays the state budget to support Israel and does not support to the creation of jobs for graduating students.
Why doesn't the reporter ask the Jewish student about OCCUPATION AND GENOCIDE!!!!??? Palestinians have HUMAN RIGHTS AND A RIGHT TO SELF DETERMINATION
I remember how Palestinians were celebrating after 9/11 attack on America, and how Israel was helping America to fight terrorism since they has a lot more experience with terrorism, in the Middle 'East. While Its easy to fool Genz;s who were not around when 9/11 happened, they will not fool older generation,..
@@HELLWARS101since they murdered loads of British by terrorism before the creation of the state of Israel??? Is this what u mean lol
@@Naomadtingz do not try to change the subject. Israel was always our friend - the only democracy in the middle east. Lets talk about Iran who is financing all the anti Israel propaganda
.
Universities have always been a hotbed for political activism, just look at the anti Vietnam war protests or the anti Iraq war protests spearheaded by students, students always stood up against injustice
yes well this time they are on the wrong side they are on the side of terrorists they are not for the gazan people if they were they would say free gaza from Hamas
Not all student protests are comparable to Vietnamese war where student were drafted.
I remember how Palestinians were celebrating after 9/11 attack on America, and how Israel was helping America to fight terrorism since they has a lot more experience with terrorism, in the Middle 'East. While Its easy to fool Genz;s who were not around when 9/11 happened, they will not fool older generation,..
@@HELLWARS101troll detected.
Yea you troll
US uni is not torn apart, its actually the faculty are split into two. How can a school where voices should be heard, was accused of being negative? Its not a violence protest, yet the faculty ascalate things by throwing fear and poke those who voice out with punishment with baseless acusation of incitement.
The system creates this mess
I see only Mslm sowing division wherever they go again
that's funny, cuz the only thing i see muslims do in my area is eat falafel and shawarma.
@@chillmegachill Thats funny cuz I see them eat falafel and shawarma too
🤡💩
@@Burningman_1 tbh u seem like someone that sows division. moving on.
@@chillmegachill you seem like someone wilfully blind. Moved on.
They can protest all they want Israel is going to do what is best for their country and their citizens
spoken like a true coloniser 😂
Israel is a client state and relies on American approval. The total collapse of support from young americans puts a ticking clock, externally, on Israel's plans for the region.
State....country is Palestine!!!
and how is that? if someone neighbouring attacks America, or case be the asia regions and europe regionds, every sovereign country will first and foremost look for the interest of itself and their citizens.. if someone kidnapped your peope, you will beg your government to bring them back, you will look for your interest.. no one really will give two fcks on innocents at the other side, which there is none i believe, but israel is too kind stilll... so whats the meaning of coloniser in the current state of war? so are you dumb?
How can you feel threatened by someone saying words, while your gov acts in ways that kill people!?
The word intifada means struggle, resistance.
"while your gov acts in ways that kill people!" same can be said about the palestinians their government attacked israel chanting these same phrases.
Damn
Every dean of a divided campus must be sacked.
Unity must be enforced!!!
(that doesn't sound scary or fascist at all 🙄)
Why?
@@Amp497 LOL 🤣🤣
Because they did this?
You can’t come to america and said you want to change Palestine
Uhmmmmmmmm yes you can!
That's literally the definition of Free Speech written in our constitution.
Whatever our religion, whether Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu or Buddhist, we definitely oppose human rights crimes. We as human beings definitely want the brotherhood and democratization of fellow human beings to work well. There are no cruelties and crimes on human rights. Come, with a spirit of brotherhood, I urge you to oppose crimes against humanity against Gaza. And let's uphold human rights and build brotherhood. Let's make our respective governments aware in our respective countries. And let's support the students at the University of Colombia, America by taking action in our respective countries. Let's raise our opposition to crimes against humanity in Gaza and other parts of the world and we will cultivate the brotherhood of fellow human beings in the world with compassion for fellow human beings. Columbia University Student Life United States.
The Palestinian young man seems very well educated and articulated.
To the zionist man, this didn't start on Oct 7th, 2023 and if he understood the Holocaust, he wouldn't appear to be pro genocide. I cannot comprehend his train of thought.
how quickly NYC forgot 9-11
I remember how Palestinians were celebrating after 9/11 attack on America, and how Israel was helping America to fight terrorism since they has a lot more experience with terrorism, in the Middle 'East. While Its easy to fool Genz;s who were not around when 9/11 happened, they will not fool older generation,..
@@HELLWARS101 You remember Palestinians celebrating 9-11 so 3 million people deserve to be imprisoned and live under a blockade? Why don't you just say you hate muslims and be open about it? Say you support a genocide because you think these people are evil because they don't believe in the same thing you do. Say that you want them dead, embrace your barbaric nature.
Lol what does 9/11 have to do with Palestinians? How does 9-11 have anything to do with a genocide going on in Gaza? So a building gets knocked down and 3k people die so 3 million civilians deserve to perish? What is wrong with you?
@@HELLWARS101lol nice brainwashing the USA military trained al Quida we shouldn’t ever been there never again certainly not for Israel
Mossad/CIA
Americans have long forgotten 9/11,,,, the Palestinians were the ones dancing and celebrating in the streets!!!!!!!!!!!
No, they were not.
Mossad is good at creating incident.
Remember when the Palestinians blew up the Hindenburg? Or that time they killed Archduke Ferdinand?
So murder their innocent women and children?
It was not A-rabs who demolished the world trade center with explosives.
I completely agree with the truck guy, they have to be recognizable, not under masks!
This is real news, and is actually very human. This is the real story.
I can't believe The Governor of NY and The Mayor are allowing this . These fools are puttimg my hometown of NYC in danger once again. I mean how can you allow this in NYC of all places.
7th October is not the beginning of this problem and it will not be the end. One has to go back at why and by whom Israel was created. Antisemitism is fuelled by Israel's behaviour towards the Palestinians around the world. It should not be about pro-Palestine or pro-Israel. It should be about pro-Justice
It's about HAMAS,,, wake up you all.
@@JustMe-gs9xi Are you freely allowed to move in your own country??
@@Streetfussball what is your point?
@@JustMe-gs9xi I mean I have seen videos where they have lots of checkpoints in Israel and Palestinians are limited to certain areas. I was wondering if you are facing the same in your own country?
Anti-semitism is intertwined with those who take the teachings of Mohammed seriously. The Arabs rejected the rebirth of Israel before that rebirth. Haj Amin Al-Husseini stated that he would succeed where the Nazis failed and thus rejected the two states.
Makes me genuinely happy that i rejected applications to the USA colleges,they look like colleges less and political instituitons more.
I agree that the occupation in the west bank is unjust.
Also many of the men, women and babies that were slaughtered in October 7th agreed with that, many of them protesting against the government and\or assisting people from Gaza to gain access to better life, work and health.
Hammas wasn't killing people at a music festival because of the occupation, it did so in order to sabotage the peace talks between Israel and the Saudis, and did so under the directions of Iran,
Palestinians were given at least 4 opportunities by Israel, USA and the UN throughout history, to settle for a 2 states solution. But hawkish parties like Hammas preferred to continue the struggle in a hope to a "from the river to the sea" Palestinian state, which means destroying Israel and killing all the jews in it.
The reason why Gaza is a free Palestinian territory, to begin with, is that Israel gave Gaza unconditionally in a hope to find a settlement for the conflict.
Gaza could have been a hub of technology and culture, like a Singapore of the middle east, if not for Hammas taking over in 2007, launching thousands of rocket into Israel, instead of developing the place.
Anyone who dreams of a Palestinian land must choose between two options:
1. Dream of "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free", meaning, fighting Israel in a neverending war in the middle east.
2. Accept Israel, (blame the British for it, if you must) and dream of a future where Israel is a partner, and not the enemy.
Again, love your content.
Keep up the good work and let's make a better future together!
'Many of them protesting against the government and assisting people of Gaza.' Lol did you come up with that joke yourself? They were literally having a party next to a concentration camp... they were complicit.
Gaza is under a total blockade even before oct 7th. The coasts has been blocked off for much longer with even fishermen not being able to leave the coast. How do you expect a region to be prosperous like Singapore if they can’t even exit their shores or even allowed an airport to bring others from other countries within the borders?
@@Sg133
When Israel gave it freely to the Palestinians in 2005, it was open and free.
The blockade by both Egypt and Israel started after Hammas took over in, 2006 and killed all democratic opposition in 2007.
Hamas has lived among the Palestinians in Gaza for years, and they were well aware of it. They want to eliminate the Jews and take a land that does not belong to them. They are just as responsible for this war as Hamas is. God bless and protect Israel 🇮🇱
Tell something about settlers living in west bank
Protests blocked an ambulance with a sick child that ended up dying but that’s okay
I'd like to see British News companies covering news in Britain for once.
I'm an Israeli, I grew up in Israel during the first and second intifada, I survived a terror attack of a suicide bomber in my city's mall when I was only 11 years old (2001 Hasharon Mall suicide bombing). 6 were killd, including 2 female teenagers, and over 50 were injured, amongst them little children. The terrorists target EVERYBODY - women, children, all kinds of reiligions, ethnicities, races - they don't care, because intifada is about terror and chaos, at least that what it was in Israel in these times. When you get out of the nice theories, terminology and books, and come into the reality - it is not so nice anymore. The ones shouting to globalize the intifada are either stupid, don't know what it means in reality, or simply do not care about humanity at all. They are not protesting for the benefit of Palestinians, they are protesting for the destruction of Israelis and Jews. Someone who truly cares about humanity, justice and peace, would uphold these values, for ALL people.
You are absolutely right.
European Jews are not Semitic people and are not entitled to any Semitic land.
6 were killed, how laughable. 85,902 palestinians massacred by zionists since 1948 and you are just simply blind to it? who doesn't care about humanity is you, living on stolen land in stolen houses, stepping atop of corpses of civilians, and expect no consequences. Truely laughable.
Where did your grandparents come from? They should of stayed there rather than colonise
@@ayyo6997Oh 😂 that is why people like you are so ignorant. My family has lived here in Israel for seven generations, since the Ottoman empire rule! My family lived here long before a lot of arabs and palestinians...please educate yourself so that you won't make a clown of yourself next time.
Why do we see mostly children supporting terrorists, who or what has taught them to support terrorists
Tic tok , instagram, schools , peer pressure and the chance to get a new status when posting on media
The West throughout history has viewed liberation movements against slavery, apartheid, and colonialism as terrorism. Whether it's the Haitian Revolution, the independence of Algeria or the end of apartheid, the same, tired arguments have been used to justify continuing to repress racialized people under repressive systems of racial domination.
Do you call the people of Palestine, who resist the Israeli occupiers, terrorists? It's like calling the French resistance movement to the German occupiers in World War II terrorists.
SO Sad! And yet SO True!!@@Some826
Why does the IDF kill so many children?
I wish people could just get along
They can't because of women.
11:15 oh Eva there’s no difference between the men [& women] responsible for these deaths.
Both tribes are operating on fear, anger and hatred. They’re both responsible for indiscriminate murder. The only difference here are the weapons being used, the damage being inflicted, and the number of casualties.
I wonder if these protests are only on prestigious campuses. Other colleges might have better control when protests get out of hand and students end up threatened.
As someone who goes to a community college in NYC. I can say this is mainly on the Ivy League level. We had a small protest at Borough Manhattan Community College with couple of students showing up, but nothing this huge as Columbia University . Keep in mind my college is the biggest community college in the city, but I'll will whats happening in Gaza had made politics kinda uneasy on campus.
It’s politics plain and simple.
The larger the college the more heated it gets, draws in news cameras becomes a public issue makes it to national news networks, protests grow bigger due to having a larger platform.
@@Michael-du2fv exactly! Thats my beef with this BS. Half these people wouldn’t even be here if it weren’t for the attention
The Gulf Petrol monarchies donate heavily to elite US universities, esp Middle East Studies departments. They are determined to spread their 7th century barbarism and Islamo-fascists cult across the globe.
Free Israel from Hammas.
The Gaza belongs to Israel. 🇮🇱
Which you stole and still stealing 👹🐷
this is also genocidal statement
@@roc7880 it's a fact. Look at any map of Israel online.
To put it into perspective, one needs to consider the story of Noah and the Ark. Noah and his sons spent all their time shoveling the waste created by all those animals onboard, over the side of the Ark. Eventually, the flood waters receded and exposed a huge pile of ** in the middle of nowhere. Many years later, Columbus discovered it.
But it’s really great to see her some intelligent people talking to each other …