'Democratic superhero': Russian journalist reveals letter Alexei Navalny sent days before death
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 02. 2024
- Mikhail Zygar, founding editor of the exiled independent Russian media outlet TV Rain, joins Chris Hayes in the wake of the death of Alexei Navalny.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#AlexeiNavalny #Russia #Putin
The most courageous man in Russia. He will be remembered forever and his words will be heard by generations. RIP ALEXEI
It's so crazy that when I heard this, I cried like I knew him!! Idk why I just sat, looked at my husband and tears.. This man was pure bravery.. He will be remembered in history books for all to remember.. ❤
@@newworlddisorder776 Who??
@@newworlddisorder776а МИ -6 ни причем.Скрипали перед выборами Путина в 2018 году, отравление Навального перед выборами в Гос.Думу. И снова выборы президента, маятник надо раскачивать.
@@Swnsasy Navalny
Кто его будет помнить? Не как он воровал лес в промышленных масштабах, помнить конечно будут. А как политик он ноль. Его знать ни кто не знает. Он за 10 лет не написал политической программы. 2 раза был осужден за воровство до начала политической карьеры)))
Navalny was an incredibly courageous man. He knew taking a stand against Putin would cost him his life. That's the ultimate commitment.
Навальный был глупым предателем.😂
Whats the use he gave for his country?? Only rise childrens for propest!
Sing katyusha
But saying international law is nothing and he not support Ukraine against russian dictatorship regime, but in Ukraine living many russian who support Ukraine in NATO and EU, but he not . Now russian die in Ukraine and he die for nothing. People not go for resist against putin dictatorship regime becouse he supporte xenophobia in russia and he not unfortunately unite people...
He knowingly martyred himself
This man never broke
He broke now
@@KD-nk3htNavalny was and is a hero. And heroes live forever. But perhaps it's beyond your understanding.
Navalny said Muslim "flies and cockroaches" should be exterminated. Then he mock shot one in the commercial. He was a extremist and hate mongering bigot.
@@Elfdustify Navalny said Muslim "flies and cockroaches" should be exterminated. Then he mock shot one in the commercial.
@@KD-nk3ht Putin soon too
“for when I am killed” He knew his fate ….brave.
Maybe he went back to Russia because his family were under threat
No his wife said he had the freedom to retire. His daughter is in California. But he loved his country @@MyMccarron
@@MyMccarron hahaha hollywood or bollwood which one you like more ``maybe`
Remember him.
Remember his works.
Never give up!.....
😂
Never give up. Never!
RIP Navalny. You live on in our hope, courage, and strength!
Free Texas!
@@ampm5899 Free Chechnya, Free Dagestan, Free Buryatia and so on.....!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Go find eggs Ivan
@@geeridWow! Find a home psychiatrist as soon as possible! And don’t get carried away with hallucinogenic mushrooms!😂😮
Amen I'm heartbroken
😂
He came back to his people that followed and supported him knowing he would die. A true leader rather than living comfortably in Germany. RIP
Thank you for your courage in standing up to Putin. Alexei Navalny RIP.
Standing against Putin for US
.
Очень неприятный тип этот навальный. Топил за западные ценности в России. Туда ему и дорога. Вообще не жалко что он умер
But Putin is the winner
@@user-es1xe6jh6ustanding against Putin for the Russia.
@@user-es1xe6jh6uwhat an asinine comment.
Navalny was everything Putin and Trump aren’t. Handsome, polished, well educated, intelligent and beloved by his family, friends, and supporters. He will be remembered as a hero, martyr who gave his life to be a moral example for Russian society and the world 🌍.
Navalny's wife smiled happily at the briefing about his death
Perhaps do some research on him. I think you might be somewhat embarrassed if you do
@@user-ml4dm5ji9f I have. You must be a Regime’s puppet.
I don't know of a braver person who willing walks into the lion's den, knowing what awaited him. Navalny is a true martyr. 😢
he knew this when he left Germany with a tube in his bladder
Even his family has been extremely brave for standing by his side and respecting his decision while being aware what would happen.
Will America taake responsibility fooor death of Julian Assange?
Completely what a brave soul 😢
@@SD._we sure hope there are some developments for Assange soon! Strange that not much is being said....#42 & 44 have some explaining to do!!
Alexei Navalny is a HERO and will LIVE FOREVER ! 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹❤🌎
Alexei Navalny: "NOT TO GIVE UP" ! NEVER GIVE UP !
A tragic loss for Russia and democracy.
Russia people hardly have heard of him, no loss for Russia, he is used for West propaganda, poor fellow
A tragic loss for the world, for me, for his wife, for his daughter, for his son, for his supporters, and of course the Russian people.... We will see justice we will have justice
LONG LIVE NAVALNY ✊
talk specific what is democracy as well each time when you speake becausei v found myself being oporessed by both republicans and demcorats
@@homosexualbiologicalmaleexit Civil liberties and human rights. Sadly lacking pretty much everywhere.
which democracy you talking about uncle ..one you forcing around the planet that you do not keep in own place ..or maybe something new you come up with
I can’t stop crying
I have never met Alexei
But my heart is aching 😭
This is the reality of this horrible world
So sorry!
Прости нас 😭
Тоже самое чувствую…
Putin sees another dead body..
I agree I'm crying as well
Mine too. I find comfort finding out others feel as I do.
😆
He should be named the man of the year in times magazine
I thought the same!!! ++
Putin created a martyr... he really must be losing it. RIP Alexei, your courage and patriotism will not be forgotten.
In regards to the death of Nalvalny always look for motive ! Who benefits by his death and all the media attention?Just read this headline “U.S. president wants Congress to punish Russia by extending military aid for Ukraine “ just saying
I had hoped this moment would never come
Putin 2024 🇷🇺✌️🎉🎉🎉
I had just watched the documentary on Navalny a few days ago! I'm heartbroken. He was SO charismatic, smart and seemingly fearless. If I were a Russian, I would be COMPLETELY devastated. Putin just flat out murders any of his opponents. I'm so sorry for Alexei's wife, daughter and the rest of his family. Edited to add: I'm also so sorry for the people and future of Russia! 💔
putin treats Russia like its his personal property,and anyone that live in it belongs to him.putin your time is coming to an end you can't stifle and hold a people back your greed and evil God is watching pay back will be painful
Dear Alexei, we are devastated in Australia to hear about your "sudden death syndrome" ❤
We can't even comprehend what you have been through
Thank You for your ultimate sacrifice ❤ R I P
❤💕💜🧡💕❤💜💕❤🧡💕❤
You represented your country well Navalny. RIP Sir!
The Russian people are poorer for the loss of this man. I really hope one day there's no oligarchy Dictatorship , no king but real freedom.
Just give it some time and my conclusion will start to sink in ❤
Вам бы мозгов побольше. Нет в России диктатуры и мы не бедные. Россия свободная страна. У нас нет кварталов бомжей, наркоманов и психически больных людях. А Навальный для России никто и пустое место. Вы бы за Ассанжа переживали или Гонсало Лира. Вы вообще ничего о России не знаете. Вы обычный диванный эксперт. Навального посадили на 19 лет и никаких проблем от него не было.
😂
how old are you? 12-13?
Lol, obviously you do not know anyone about Russia. Most of oligarchs who got rich thanks to the fall of Soviet Union, the mafia barons and all those billionaires who only had interest of West in their mind, were removed, sent abroad or in prison for crimes. No Russia does not have an oligarchy dictatorship. It is a domocratcy with centralised power. This is how Russian prefer it, this is why Putin has 80% support. Can you accept it, or you need to push your vision of what works on others?
Keep protesting people, never stop
I don't know why I've been feeling sensitive lately, when I heard about his passing this morning, I literally cried like a baby, I cried as if I knew him personally. He may be gone in body, but he is not gone. My heart goes out to his wife and child and to the people of Russia that believed in him. I am so sorry, this is disgusting.
Whats discusting is 100 thousand dead people in Gaza
💜💙 it's been a wild few months with lots of overwhelming news and emotional things happening. Try to take care of yourself but also let the emotions out when you can. I am not a very outwardly expressive person but i also was super affected by the news today. We must embody the democratic fight and determination and persevere, united 💙
Да насрать нам на твои слёзы, хоть в штаны написай😂😂😂🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺💪✌
I feel the Same here in Germany.
I‘m soooo sad..I feel hopeless and anger. I‘m speechless.
I know it hurts so bad 😭😭😭😭
So sorry to lose Navalny!!
So sorry to lose Gonzalo Lira!!
Очередная собачья чушь!
Let’s make sure he is not lost?
Putin always wins
Just as he had been run over by a bus. He has been K I L L E D by Putler, can you understand that ?
Rest in peace, brave Alexei. I'm so, so sorry this was done to you. We'll never forget you. 😥💔
Putin 2024 🎉🎉🎉🇷🇺✌️
@@mera1379The ONLY Reason Poo Tin will win the Election is bcoz he has Every Opponent Murdered 🙄
This is a man whose last words no doubt would have been: I only regret, that I have but one life to lose for my country
Alexey was a true hero, they are not found in large quantities. it is sad and he will be missed.
we must honor his life, remember the struggle that killed him,
and the path he walked as a beacon to guide our vision.
It's strange how much the media cares about a Russian who gets killed but not a American Gonzalo Lira journalist who got murdered while in custody Ukraine prison 2 months ago. The American mainstream media is so full of it
Right ON! May he now R.I.P. and look down on Vlad the Satan. There is a Special Place for Alex and a 'different' place for Vlad the Impaler. I don't need to say where.
@@ridethecurve55🙏🏼
I hope his vision will guide you! His vision was to deport all Muslims from Moscow. He said Russia must keep Crimea, he called Ukrainians an ethnic slang- of lower grade Slavs, he called Georgians- rodents. He called for access to guns for everyone. In an advert for it, he showed Arabs and referred to them as cockroaches. He compared refugees to cavities.
It's so crazy that when I heard this, I cried like I knew him!! Idk why I just sat, looked at my husband and tears.. This man was pure bravery.. He will be remembered in history books for all to remember.. ❤
Same here
I cried too-I took myself by surprise!
Will America take responsibility fooor death of Julian Assange?
😂Насмешили в России он для всех предатель
In history by the West? Maybe. They should honour their creation indeed. 😂
Heartbreakingly sad. So sorry for his family and friends' loss... and the world's as well. :(
Surely Mr. Navalny knew this would be his eventual fate when he returned to Russia. May he rest in peace.
Huge loss for all the world but what a great example of resilience.
obviously sounds like you know more than enough about world politic ..of course except your own which you have no enough information or did not want to learn
Putin will Not be able to silence this GREAT VALIANT MAN!!!
As Americans, we always expect a happy ending where good triumphs over evil. We believe it inevitable good will triumph over evil. This world run by men just keeps getting darker.
😂
I expected it too... and I think it will happen but without the main character. In real life people don't have plot armor, unfortunately
Then Americans better make sure Trump does not get re-elected. Trump will copy parts of Putin’s reign
''When I look into Putins 👁 💀 👁 eyes I see the KGB.''
Republican Senator John McCain
Which does help explain why Mr Trump felt as he did about Mr McCain.
Looking at Putin is like looking at a reptile.
Что куришь? Это глюки .
When I look to putin I see devil 😈
RIP John McCain
I agree 'no'. I am gutted about Navalny's physical passing, about how he suffered. But, I know energertically, his spirit lives on through his legacy. Nothing is random; niether is his death. I am more than enraged by the fact that Russians have allowed this. Putin is weak; a sad excuse for a human being; his is a little man. I feel so much for Navalny's family and i will continue sending them love. But Navalny's death can and must instill hope for Russians to trasnmute their historically violent, corrupt past and begin living by a very different paradigm and Navalny - this one man who galvanized support across Russia, across the world - was instrumental in this process. You cannot let him down and you must never give up.
The sheer courage of Alexei Navalny and his family puts the MAGS GOP to shame. Oh wait . . . the MAGA GOP has no shame.
On a serious note, Yulia Navalnaya and her daughter will be next on Putin's hit list. They must be protected.
Why?
He wasn’t an American, not our business.
@@MSNBCult Commie Donnie is unAmerican; not our business.
When the entire GOP is bowing down to Putin, yes, it is our problem. @@MSNBCult
Kara Murza is sweating Novochok and Plutonium. God protect him, we wont.
May he rest in power, A hero for all time.
When there was nothing left to do but to sacrifice his own body in the pursuit of democracy, facing that possibility of death everyday, yet remaining a cheerful symbol of hope, he absolutely gave everything to bring change to Russia… and he has planted the seed to change it.
Navalnyi true leader of Russia. Even after his death he is bigger than putin will ever be
👏👏👏👏👏👏 🎉
This is an amazing interview. Well done, and God rest your beautiful soul, Alexei 🕊️
He was a traitor to his people he was killed by Ukranian & American
😂
@@d-rzarkocubrinoski
💤🚽👍🏻
Вечная память... Прости нас, и покойся с миром, Алексей. Ты настоящий патриот и герой России❤
I don't know if this mans wife will ever read this but I offer my sincere condolences for the loss of your husband! Democracy has lost a strong defender and that is a crime against us all! I again say how sorry I am for your loss but I'm sure you are comforted by knowing what kind of honorable man you married! Take care Mrs. Navalny!!
As Navalny said, we won’t give up. Russia will be free.
Just finished watching the CNN doc on HBO and I was sobbing by the end.
If anyone came close getting exalted to the messiah status it's this courageous man. Such a rare being, such an extraordinary man. For you mr Navalny i bow with deep respect. May your incredible deep love for humanity infect our hearts and open open people eyes, hearts and teach us being courageous in deeply loving eachother, your offer is not an offer for Russia and their people, your offer is for mankind! To your family I'd like to say a part of him just became a part of so many people on this planet in a certain way he's still alive within us. He's waiting for you in heaven where you'll be reunited again. ❤
I remember when he said he was going back to Russia. I screamed at the TV noooooo!! He will be remembered for his ultimate sacrifice for democracy. RIP Mr. Navalny ❤ and condolences to his family. I hope they're being protected ❤
He was what we call in America a true patriot.
Как Джулиан Ассанж?
Amen. I have seen it for years.
Why didn't you take him to America, because he is a product of American propaganda, which was aimed at rocking Russia through this mouthpiece. It would be better if Americans were so worried about the death of their journalist, who was killed in prison in Ukraine.
Yes, he was a coward lying traitor an MI5 spy!!!LOL!
Extremely saddened by this news.
We will never forget. We will never forgive. Rest in peace Alexey Navalny.
Live Free or Die , nvr knew Navalny, felt like a close friend died , sad day for the world !
💯
Cia puppet
Thank you for so good words!!! Good luck to you and your family! Alexei is extremely good , brave and greater person,! He was in the panishment cell underground for 1.5 years, with very little amount of water and food... Really sad he is not with us anymore... Very sad... Can't write this without crying 😢😢😢
AMEN
🤣🤣🤣🤡
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
🎉🎉🎉😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉
“Strike me down Darth, and I will become more powerful than you can possibly imagine”
- Obi-Wan Kenobi
You know who controls you if you know who you can not criticise.
Chris you are an American hero with your fair reporting sir! Thank you so much from down here in Texas sir!
RIP Alexis…..You will never be forgotten your bravery your love for FREEDOM!!! DEMOCRACY is worth fighting for. 💙🇺🇸⚖️💙
Let's name American towns and streets Navalny.
Alexa what a brave wonderful man who loved his country and his people RIP
NOBODY likes a coward traitor a MI5 spy!
Trump must be jealous he can’t do the same to his opponents
THIS is great proof why a President should NEVER have full immunity
@rowanmorrigan9358= SCUM BOT
Yep, and all his supporters including the republicans in congress re pro-Putin. It’s disgusting.
Not yet
You are absolutely right - but what could it have resulted in, in the worst case?@@pauljcross2289
Putin may have just made Navalny even stronger by having him murdered in prison. We will see how this plays out. I’m heartbroken for Alexei’s wife as well as the millions of Russian people who looked to him for hope. He was just made a martyr and that may make him even more dangerous to Putin.
so smart and loaded with information's you sounds like ...question is are those info correct or adjusted as usual you getting on your tv and radio station
Navalny was and will always be LOVED, He stood for truth and democracy. He was sent to the most brutal prison in the absolute coldest temperatures that can affect one’s health and that was done on purpose! He was an exceptional person and may he be long remembered in history way past Putin like Ghandhi over his assassin.
You should Google Alexei Navalny white nationalist history. He was very ultra right-wing.
cruel and unusal stuf ....then u go after family ...and ruin relationships ....put him in noise bubble ...and hide everything and claim u stand for democracy or helping ppl .....or money ..
Well said.👍
200 rubles for you comrade.
try to time it ..(account suspended)@@brianwalsh1131
Alexei Navalny is one of the best human being in Russia and the world! We will miss you and remember you as one of the greatest hero of this world!
❤Boetin, 4 juni 1976 - Charp, 16 februari 2024) 🙏
They need to form the Navalny Democratic Party in his memory. Condolences to his family 🙏
As you wish. anything for your money
Создавать Вы будете? Не надорвитесь.
This is the country that Tuckero Rose would have the rest of the world believe is a great place - better even than the nation he was born to.
Tuckyo Rose Carlson is a real piece of it.
Lord Haw Haw reborn
@@TobiasC-mg4zkthankyou, that's what I call tuck tuck 👍
Well, I lived there until 1997 and I'd rather die than go back. A lot of attitudes there are straight up medieval, no independent thinking.
Will America takee responsibility for death of Julian Assange?
@SD._ Assange is alive, in case you don't know.
So sorry
The biggest loss to Russia in years! I wish him strength in heaven 🙏
Rip ❤
RIP ❤
Thank you, thank you, thank you!
We all know that politics in America are headshaking whacked out, but in Russia, the opposition is just taken out!
Какая опозиция??? Navalny is a real traitor to Russia, a CIA agent
Democratic superhero is right. Navalny had balls of steel. Maybe Russians will react now. But it is doubtful given the level of oppression.
RIP😢
спасибо за все и прости нас😢
he would’ve been better to stay in Germany with his family and campaign from there.
He knew that.
He would of been dead earlier cause he was a stooge for nato and America
I never understood why he went back
He was brave. His wife said he could have retired or gone to California where his daughter is.
But she said he loved his motherland. He loved Russia
@@deannatow5003😂
I had so hoped Navalny would make it out of prison alive. I’m sad for the Russian people and for the world at his loss. RIP Alexei Navalny.💕🙏💕🙏💕
So so sad
Navalny: Truly worthy of the world's respect.
Heartbroken...
Let’s make sure we get Biden elected again in honor of Nalvany.
Only if you promise to change the sheets 😂
It's strange how much the media cares about a Russian who gets killed but not a American Gonzalo Lira journalist who got murdered while in custody Ukraine prison 2 months ago. The American mainstream media is so full of it
@@mera1379 he poops on himself every 5 min
Putin has endorsed Biden for reelection.
@@breakfast00club..11 this is funny to say while supporting the diaper don.......projection as usual
I am so sorry for Russias loss.
We are strong. I also must say that this segment by Chris Hayes was the best of all the coverage I saw on the various news shows.
Guy was a baller - when asked why he would risk going back to Russia and not stay safe in Germany after they tried to poison him he said “I wouldn’t give Putin such a gift” man was a straight gangster RIP!
Authoritarianism always makes me think of the queen song ‘I want to break free’
Thank-you, great words, here, some one in Russia needs to step up. HUMAN RIGHTS
Thx for this....
Its time the world stand up and unite . Honesty, truthful, charismatic powerful, .He never gave up. He should go down in history for his Bravery. Strength to fight for his people justice. ❤❤❤ All are praying for his family. God protect them . 🙏 Om
Thanks from Russia for showing information about his death.
This is what trump wants complete SUBMISSION!! Vote blue 💙💙 to save AMERICA!!!!😅
Putin politically prosecutes opponents, Democrats politically prosecuting Trump. 👀
@@MSNBCultIt's not political, Trump is a proven criminal. You'll get over your obsession with him soon, you'll see
Know this: Trump is an agent of Putin and the GOP are directed by Trump. To save our country VOTE BLUE 💙
@@MSNBCult you have orange on your lips
@@MSNBCult Only in your dreams. Trump has been a criminal all his life, and justice is finally catching up to him.
RIP
A great loss for all the decent Russians who were hoping for democracy and the downfall of Putin.
Не дождетесь , нормальных людей больше , чем навальнят , Путин ВВ наш президент и не вашими языками ,оскорблять его
All 12 decent Russians. The whole world is at risk because Russians can't leave their vodka and remove Putin. The worst cowards on the planet.
Кто-нибудь спрашивал порядочных россиян? Порядочные россияне за Россию и нам плевать на ваше мнение! Мы жили, живём и будем жить! Умойтесь!!!
It's strange how much the media cares about a Russian who gets killed but not a American Gonzalo Lira journalist who got murdered while in custody Ukraine prison 2 months ago. The American mainstream media is so full of it😊
@@user-lx1rj1vy5x It's strange how much the media cares about a Russian who gets killed but not a American Gonzalo Lira journalist who got murdered while in custody Ukraine prison 2 months ago. The American mainstream media is so full of it
Sad, so very sad.😭
We cannot consent to these horrible crimes against humanity.
This should be a valuable lesson to all americans why this coming election is vital. No one person with any common sense should elect a man or woman who has shown tendencies to follow an autocratic figure.
Putin war carimnal
His Nelson Mandela God bless his soul may he rest in peace protect his family. ❤❤❤
Putin is going to his mirror mirror on the wall and it's telling him that he's not as beloved as Navalny
Exactly!
Sad day and the world let putin live....sad too
Rip Alexei..🙏
Such incredible brave people in Russia.. my heart goes out to them...Respect from Holland to you all.
R.I.P. Navalnyj, you are a true hero and legend ❤
Trump called to congratulate Putin
Putin prefers Biden.
And to ask for a 500 million dollar loan.
Biden called to order diapers.
@@douglasreagan4979Biden ordered diapers for Trump.
Because he's a REAL Christian, and therefore, he provides for those who don't know shitenenuf to provide for themselves, no matter how rich they say they are! Catholics For Biden!
As a belarusian I begUnited States, NATO and EU to liberate us from Russia and integrate us in the free western world and Europe 😭😭😢😭
Imo, that's probably not going to happen, since its controversial, it would be like an empire by other means. If you learn anything from Alexy Nalvany, you should learn to take that freedom for yourselves. It would be the only way to legitimately free yourselves from tyranny.
Покойся с МИРОМ,Алексей.Сердце больше не болит за народ.А народ не должен волноваться.Борьбу за свободу продолжат Собчак и Ходорковский,Лазарева и Каспаров,Быков и Гозман.Вперед с новыми кумирами.
😂😂😂Насмешили всех предателей перечислили
Пройдёт немного времени и ты будешь вспоминать эти дни. Все вернётся бумерангом. В 37-ом ,было много таких как ты. А закончили они там же где их жертвы. От всей души желаю тебе, упокоится с миром.
@@alexz4422 больной человек я тебе желаю того же самого жди