How Can Matter Be BOTH Liquid AND Gas?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 3. 05. 2024
  • To Learn More Languages Check Out: speakly.app.link/Speakly
    PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to:to.pbs.org/DonateSPACE
    Sign Up on Patreon to get access to the Space Time Discord!
    / pbsspacetime
    Supercritical Fluids are one the strangest states of matter and yet they are found everywhere from Decaf Coffee, to dry cleaning, to the atmosphere of Jupiter. When we think of an exotic state of matter we tend to think of the really weird things that matter can do in extreme circumstances - like how at very high temperatures we get the plasma that the sun is made of, or at extreme densities we get the nuclear matter of neutron stars. But there’s one state of matter - supercritical fluid - that’s not solid, liquid or gas, but is also not confined to extreme or rare environments. In fact, there are planets in our solar system completely covered with oceans of the stuff, and you’ve often been the beneficiary of its powers without even knowing it.
    Special Thanks to Nigel Braun. Check out his episodes on
    Supercritical Fluids: • Going supercritical.
    Making Aerogel: • Making aerogel
    Felix Flicker’s talk on quasi-magnetic monopoles
    • The Physics of Magneti...
    Latest paper on the detection of an active galaxy by Ice Cube
    arxiv.org/pdf/2211.09972.pdf
    Check out the Space Time Merch Store
    www.pbsspacetime.com/shop
    Sign up for the mailing list to get episode notifications and hear special announcements!
    mailchi.mp/1a6eb8f2717d/space...
    Search the Entire Space Time Library Here: search.pbsspacetime.com/
    Hosted by Matt O'Dowd
    Written by Fernando Franco Felix & Matt O'Dowd
    Post Production by Leonardo Scholzer, Yago Ballarini, Pedro Osinski, Caique Oliveira, Adriano Leal & Stephanie Faria
    Directed by Andrew Kornhaber
    Associate Producer: Bahar Gholipour
    Executive Producers: Eric Brown & Andrew Kornhaber
    Executive in Charge for PBS: Maribel Lopez
    Director of Programming for PBS: Gabrielle Ewing
    Assistant Director of Programming for PBS: John Campbell
    Spacetime is produced by Kornhaber Brown for PBS Digital Studios.
    This program is produced by Kornhaber Brown, which is solely responsible for its content.
    © 2022 PBS. All rights reserved.
    End Credits Music by J.R.S. Schattenberg: / multidroideka
    Special Thanks to Our Patreon Supporters
    Big Bang Supporters
    Tim O’Rourke
    Devin Wiley
    Ryan Salsamendi
    Steffen Bendel
    Gautam Shine
    Bryce Fort
    Peter Barrett
    David Neumann
    Leo Koguan
    Alexander Tamas
    Morgan Hough
    Amy Hickman
    Juan Benet
    Vinnie Falco
    Fabrice Eap
    Mark Rosenthal
    Quasar Supporters
    Glenn Sugden
    Alex Kern
    Ethan Cohen
    Stephen Wilcox
    Christina Oegren
    Mark Heising
    Hank S
    Hypernova
    Ankur Anand
    Ryan Moser
    David Giltinan
    Ivari Tölp
    Vyce Ailour
    Brandon Paddock
    Ken S
    Gregory Forfa
    Kirk Honour
    drollere
    Joe Moreira
    Bradley Voorhees
    Marc Armstrong
    Scott Gorlick
    Paul Stehr-Green
    Ben Delo
    Scott Gray
    Антон Кочков
    John R. Slavik
    Mathew
    David S. Cerutti
    Donal Botkin
    John Pollock
    Edmund Fokschaner
    Joseph Salomone
    chuck zegar
    Jordan Young
    John Hofmann
    Daniel Muzquiz
    Gamma Ray Burst Supporters
    Hypothasies
    Justin Lloyd
    Chuck Lukaszewski
    Edward Hodapp
    Kevin Tillery
    Cole
    Marc Forand
    D. Delair
    Walter Montalvo
    Andrea Galvagni
    Larka
    Jerry Thomas
    Nikhil Sharma
    Alexander Gruber
    Jonathan Cordovano
    John Anderson
    Scott Hannum
    Paul Widden
    Bradley Ulis
    Craig Falls
    Kane Holbrook
    Ross Story
    teng guo
    Mason Dillon
    Harsh Khandhadia
    Thomas Tarler
    Sean McCaul
    Susan Albee
    Frank Walker
    Matt Q
    MHL SHS
    Terje Vold
    James Trimmier
    Anatoliy Nagornyy
    comboy
    Andre Stechert
    Paul Wood
    Kent Durham
    jim bartosh
    Nubble
    Ramon Nogueira
    The Mad Mechanic
    Ellis Hall
    John H. Austin, Jr.
    Diana S
    Faraz Khan
    Almog Cohen
    Alex Edwards
    Ádám Kettinger
    MD3
    Endre Pech
    Daniel Jennings
    Cameron Sampson
    Geoffrey Clarion
    Russ Creech
    Jeremy Reed
    Eric Webster
    David Johnston
    Web Browser
    Michael Barton
    Mr T
    Andrew Mann
    Isaac Suttell
    Devon Rosenthal
    Oliver Flanagan
    Bleys Goodson
    Robert Walter
    Mirik Gogri
    Mark Delagasse
    Mark Daniel Cohen
    Nickolas Andrew Freeman
    Shane Calimlim
    Tybie Fitzhugh
    Robert Ilardi
    Eric Kiebler
    Craig Stonaha
    Graydon Goss
    Frederic Simon
    Tonyface
    John Robinson
    Jim Hudson
    A G
    David Neal
    justahat
    John Funai
    Tristan
    Bradley Jenkins
    Daniel Stříbrný
    Luaan
    Cody
    Thomas Dougherty
    King Zeckendorff
    Dan Warren
    Patrick Sutton
    John Griffith
    DFaulk
    Sam Long

Komentáře • 1,2K

  • @pbsspacetime
    @pbsspacetime  Před rokem +436

    For those who skip the comments: there will be an end of year AMA on the channel on Monday, December 19th @ 4pm EST. We hope to see you there!

    • @thryce82
      @thryce82 Před rokem

      drunken barfight while defending your sister's honor???

    • @TheMemesofDestruction
      @TheMemesofDestruction Před rokem +3

      Danke! ^.^

    • @ZoranRavic
      @ZoranRavic Před rokem +4

      People who skip comments are probably the same people who don't watch the post credits scene in marvel movies

    • @celivalg
      @celivalg Před rokem

      you know, this is the one time I didn't skip them

    • @celivalg
      @celivalg Před rokem +2

      ​@@ZoranRavic actually I tried watching those but fell on 2 videos back to back where they weren't interesting, watched those now and I think I missed a lot of very interesting ones

  • @NemoK
    @NemoK Před rokem +468

    This really feels like an "It's not a bug, it's a feature" component of our universe

    • @gametalk3149
      @gametalk3149 Před rokem +4

      Yep

    • @berthulf
      @berthulf Před rokem +32

      I mean, technically and as far as we know, everything functions as intended and the only bugs we know of in our universe are the ones that crawl around on our planet...

    • @brianlink391
      @brianlink391 Před 6 měsíci +4

      LOL! Yeah, the universe surely has its own quirky way of saying, 'Trust me, I meant to do that.' Pretty wild, isn't it? Cool perspective!

  • @borttorbbq2556
    @borttorbbq2556 Před rokem +1445

    I'm really happy that he was willing to let you guys use his visuals because understanding it when actually seeing it happen is really interesting. His video was excellent and I loved how he actually went through the process multiple different times to try and go with which was really cool

    • @codymoore2886
      @codymoore2886 Před rokem +46

      Yeah, Nile does some cool stuff. I got interested in his videos when his video on turning disposable plastic gloves into hot sauce popped up in my suggested feed.

    • @nugboy420
      @nugboy420 Před rokem +8

      @@codymoore2886I thought that was who “he” was

    • @nugget0428
      @nugget0428 Před rokem +28

      When this video started talking about supercritical fluids I had Nigels video in mind hahaha

    • @Si-Al-Ti
      @Si-Al-Ti Před rokem +8

      Cody’s lab also made a nice vid on supercritical co2, showing the weirdness of it’s behavior even more, I think.

    • @IuliusPsicofactum
      @IuliusPsicofactum Před rokem +14

      Nil is the greatest. I am also always afraid for his physical health after each experiment 🙈

  • @Ryan6.022
    @Ryan6.022 Před rokem +680

    Worth mentioning while nilered shot that footage the device was provided by Ben over at applied science. He has an amazing CZcams channel where he discusses and explores all sorts of technical things. He built his own scanning electron microscope and made a liquid nitrogen generator.

    • @WestOfEarth
      @WestOfEarth Před rokem +52

      Ben is on an entirely different level than most humans, lol. What he's able to accomplish in his garage is astounding.

    • @vellexander4422
      @vellexander4422 Před rokem +8

      Came here to say exactly this - Ben's channel is amazing and I still reference his magnets video in my projects

    • @reidflemingworldstoughestm1394
      @reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 Před rokem +3

      I can't imagine how hard it would be to design an engine that ran on liquid N2.
      Ba dump tchss

    • @dynogunbattle
      @dynogunbattle Před rokem +5

      @@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 I bet you could get a Stirling engine to run on liquid nitrogen. Not to use as fuel, but to run on the temp difference between liquid no2 and ambient.

    • @Urgleflogue
      @Urgleflogue Před rokem +6

      I am seeing an increased cooperation between smart and famous youtubers, and I think that's great. 40+ years after it's conception the Internet finally starts to deliver fruits for us - regular, non-smart-but-curious folks. Now I can die happy.

  • @NiffirgkcaJ
    @NiffirgkcaJ Před rokem +304

    I really love it when scientific channels collaborate and let each other borrow each other's visuals to explain things much more easier.

  • @TheDaggwood
    @TheDaggwood Před rokem +248

    For those curious on triple points, a very tangible example is found in geology. The crystals andalusite, sillimanite, and kyanite are made of the same material. But the pressure and temperature experienced when cooling determines what crystal precipitates. A single chunk of rock can naturally have all 3 types forming alongside each other. It's beautiful.

    • @MushookieMan
      @MushookieMan Před rokem +15

      And material phase diagrams also explain why some stainless steels are non-ferromagnetic despite containing iron. The material phase austenite is the culprit.

    • @maudglazbrooke1287
      @maudglazbrooke1287 Před rokem +2

      oh! Huh. I know two out of the three of those, sillimanite being the oddball....

    • @christopherleubner6633
      @christopherleubner6633 Před rokem +5

      Yup a lot of gemstones especially emerald are originating from supercritical water. In fact it usually has a bizarre inclusion as a result. A crystal of magnetite, a bit of water, and a bubble of gas 🤓

    • @pyropulseIXXI
      @pyropulseIXXI Před rokem +1

      That isn't a triple point. A triple point is the state in which you can move to any other state, solid, liquid, or gas, directly from that 'triple point. Or are you trying to say that this rock is in a gas, liquid, and solid state?

    • @TheDaggwood
      @TheDaggwood Před rokem +5

      ​@@pyropulseIXXI My example is a triple point in geologic terms, which is different from a thermodynamic triple point. A thermodynamic triple point pertains to 3 phases of matter existing at a single juncture, while a geologic triple point pertains to 3 different crystalline structures at a single juncture. Yes you are correct in that this video is the "classic" true definition of a triple point, I'm just providing another way of looking at it. A triple point in geology is also a point in which 3 tectonic plates intersect, but I'll leave that out to avoid further complication.
      They are called triple points because both scenarios involve a substance being 3 different unique phases/materials at equilibrium. Both are rare to find in nature!

  • @CaptainCuttlefish74
    @CaptainCuttlefish74 Před rokem +455

    I knew about supercritical fluids, but I never realized how important they are. It's honestly kind of wild that so many mundane things rely on such a weird state of matter.

    • @MrEiht
      @MrEiht Před rokem +3

      ? A squid that is doof AND Dr.? THAT is weird to me.

    • @unperrier5998
      @unperrier5998 Před rokem

      For me they're most important in trivia games :)

    • @MrEiht
      @MrEiht Před rokem

      @@unperrier5998 or if I want to scare off my wife when she demands sexy times...with ME!

    • @jonesyjones5408
      @jonesyjones5408 Před rokem +15

      They aren’t just important…………..
      they’re……………………..
      critical

    • @noiJadisCailleach
      @noiJadisCailleach Před rokem +11

      @@jonesyjones5408 They're not just critical, they're -----------------------------------
      Supercritical.

  • @WestOfEarth
    @WestOfEarth Před rokem +126

    Was hoping you'd mention Venus. This fact isn't widely shared, and to me it's one of the most fascinating aspects of Venus.

    • @jasonwilson7094
      @jasonwilson7094 Před rokem +1

      If you could make aerogel that would float on the superfluid then all you need is a satellite that floats on the super fluid that can build aerogel the whole planet are the right lab conditions to do it. It’s kind of a no-brainer.

    • @TlalocTemporal
      @TlalocTemporal Před rokem +18

      @@jasonwilson7094 -- That's just a dirigible in a fancy atmosphere. Venusian weather balloons are still a great idea, but you don't need superfluid to do a floating lab.

    • @PMA65537
      @PMA65537 Před rokem

      @@mikefuller9073 He was just annoyed at the effect of sulphuric acid on his dry cleaning.

    • @dalemosdeliverers9050
      @dalemosdeliverers9050 Před rokem +3

      So if you fired your thrusters when landing on Venus Falcon 9 style, would you still end up with a very clean-looking spacecraft (with all the soot washed off)?

    • @zimriel
      @zimriel Před rokem +4

      @@dalemosdeliverers9050 and all your flesh washed off. didn't we just read about the sulfuric-acid clouds?

  • @NATESOR
    @NATESOR Před rokem +22

    Dry cleaner here. Many of us are still using a chemical called Perc (Perchloroethylene) to dry clean. It's extremely non-polar so it is great for addressing oil stains. Under ideal conditions, basically all of it is distilled off and reused. If anyone is worried about it sticking to clothes, they should know that it evaporates very readily and by the time you put it on it will be totally gone.

  • @sebastianelytron8450
    @sebastianelytron8450 Před rokem +348

    If there's one bad thing I can say about this video, it's that it ends.
    But that would be supercritical.

    • @INGIE32
      @INGIE32 Před rokem +8

      lol

    • @JorgetePanete
      @JorgetePanete Před rokem +8

      Keep it cool ❄️

    • @Numba003
      @Numba003 Před rokem +2

      This was excellent. Thank you. Merry Christmas! ✝️🎄

    • @debrachambers1304
      @debrachambers1304 Před rokem +2

      OOOOOOOOHHHHHHH!!!

    • @atk05003
      @atk05003 Před rokem +7

      If the many-worlds interpretation is correct, then there is a universe where Matt is still listing states of matter.😁

  • @vanderkarl3927
    @vanderkarl3927 Před rokem +57

    Yoooo happy to see NileRed's footage (with permission) in this video! It really is a great demonstration, he made some great videos on supercritical fluids.

    • @mfaizsyahmi
      @mfaizsyahmi Před rokem +2

      I'm watching this literally after watching another video where Nigel blow up an inflatable doll on a rooftop in Tokyo. So weird.

  • @ElliottCallum
    @ElliottCallum Před rokem +39

    Great vid - I’m a chemical engineer currently working on a carbon capture plant. We’re having issues with reverse flow relief scenarios with supercritical CO2 depressurising and causing dry ice to form in the relief valves due to JT cooling. Great relevant video for me.

    • @Sin526
      @Sin526 Před rokem +5

      What a fascinating problem to be working.

    • @Basement-Science
      @Basement-Science Před rokem +2

      Too bad carbon capture is completely pointless right now though.

    • @joaovfm
      @joaovfm Před rokem +2

      As a Chemical Engineer I wish I could work such interesting problems

    • @ElliottCallum
      @ElliottCallum Před rokem +3

      @@joaovfm it is a great project, most interesting I’ve been on since graduating in 2017. Great to be on energy transition projects.

  • @BaronVonQuiply
    @BaronVonQuiply Před rokem +6

    20:35 Can confirm. I have several strobe lights flickering in each eye 24/7. Been like that since around 1996. It never stops.
    It also causes enlarged blind spots, which is a little weird because the brain fills in the missing area so things aren't hidden behind a wall of black, they're just deleted. eg, I walked into a step ladder one night because I couldn't see it, I ran my hand into a table saw because my hand was in a blind spot and I could not see it despite looking directly at the blade.

  • @Numba003
    @Numba003 Před rokem +24

    I suppose I hadn't ever really thought about how decaf coffee is made. This was fascinating! I didn't realize the lower reaches of the Venusian atmosphere were supercritical fluid. Thank you for this!
    Merry Christmas out there everybody! ✝️🎄

  • @zovisapphire
    @zovisapphire Před rokem +10

    I was JUST about to suggest you look up NileRed on this exact subject, but I didn't expect you guess literally use them in the video!
    I am glad you consider Nile as a source you can trust and add to your videos. I would love to see an official PBS Space x NileRed crossover episode in the future c:

  • @SonnyBubba
    @SonnyBubba Před rokem +15

    I learned more about supercritical fluids in this CZcams video than I did in the year I attempted a physics masters thesis on the stuff.
    The major professor had tried to record fluid flow patterns of a supercritical fluid, but his experimental setup left much to be desired.
    The heater was an old fashioned lightbulb, controlled by a laptop and a thermocouple.
    But instead of putting the bulb in a socket, he had me use a soldering iron to weld the wires to the bulb (?!) (yes, this is a physics experiment).
    I ended up doing a non-thesis masters.

    • @Gr3nadgr3gory
      @Gr3nadgr3gory Před rokem +4

      Your professor needs to take an engineering class or two.

    • @randomnobody660
      @randomnobody660 Před rokem +2

      @@Gr3nadgr3gory Just like how misunderstandings of physics are badges of honor for mathematicians, surely ignorance of engineering principles is a compliment for physicists?

    • @brianlink391
      @brianlink391 Před 6 měsíci +1

      LOL! Sounds like your major professor was auditioning for a spot on 'MacGyver: Physics Edition'. Soldering wires to a bulb for a supercritical fluid experiment? Talk about innovative (or, you know, bonkers)! It's no wonder you learned more from CZcams than in that lab. I'd be left scratching my head too. Sometimes reality is stranger than fiction!

  • @deathsyth8888
    @deathsyth8888 Před rokem +61

    Scientist: So are you a liquid or a gas?
    Supercritical fluid: Yes.

  • @jamesbarber5410
    @jamesbarber5410 Před rokem +10

    Super critical water gives us vulcanism and we didn’t realize this until very recently as far as science goes. I’m surprised that you gave that aspect of it so little screen time. The reason I mention this is because it’s the reason we get deposits of ore that we ultimately dig up to make the tools we use to explore our corner of Spacetime!

  • @valoisa
    @valoisa Před rokem +5

    This channel has been one of the most inspirational things in my life and I want to thank Matt for it. Thank you. I wasn't too good at physics when I was doing my engineer studies after high school but all this is very approachable and interesting and I really love this channel.

  • @RME76048
    @RME76048 Před rokem +20

    This has to be the most lucid and interesting depiction of supercritical fluids that I have ever seen. It takes you far, far away from simple phase diagrams and brings the viewer to a quick 'a-ha!' understanding. Thanks, Matt!

  • @bigyeticane
    @bigyeticane Před rokem +14

    Thanks everyone at Space Time and helpers! Thanks to Dr. Matt for his charisma. I learn a lot from you guys.

  • @claytonharting9899
    @claytonharting9899 Před rokem +5

    I’m so glad you guys made this video! I’ve been hearing a lot about supercritical fluids lately and I’ve never really understood… what they are. I can list facts about them, why we use them when we do, etc, but I never really understood what they actually are

  • @whereami8224
    @whereami8224 Před rokem +9

    @Applied Science also has a series of videos on supercritical CO2. He was probably the first CZcamsr to make it in a transparent chamber. And he decaffeinated his own coffee beans. Shockingly, that was 11 years ago.

  • @Pteromandias
    @Pteromandias Před rokem +1

    This is too cool. When you were talking about it being hard to visualize the supercritical liquid phase, I had an immediate recall of that NileRed video. Then you play it on here! I like the sort of convergence where my favorite non-intersecting CZcams channels suddenly cross streams.

  • @atarahashirazi1941
    @atarahashirazi1941 Před rokem +8

    For anyone who needs to see this if you stayed for the last comments in the video: this is especially true for nearsighted folks with extra strong prescriptions. The more flashes and floaters that you see (they aren't bacteria), if the number goes up a lot, get to the ophthalmologist. If you have a retinal tear, you might see a black 'sheet' fall across your vision or something like that. Again, get help immediately if you want to keep your eyesight. I had a scare once with an aural migrane where I could not see for the first time. It was terrifying, but fortunately temporary. I thought my retina tore because a doctor had warned me that with my prescription that could happen to me. Also, I'm not a doctor. FYI.

  • @NavarroRefugee
    @NavarroRefugee Před rokem +10

    I would love to have you as an astrophysicist on call at the hospital. I want to be able to call an astrophysics consult and get yelled at for not having the patient's neutrino exposure history ready in advance. It'd probably be faster than getting an ophthalmology consult booked for visual flashes too.

  • @JohnAlbertRigali
    @JohnAlbertRigali Před rokem +1

    I’d been fascinated by the supercritical fluid phase ever since I learned of it. I’d been hoping for a good and visually aided discourse of it, and this is it. Thank you and Nigel!

  • @sevenkashtan
    @sevenkashtan Před rokem

    i just wanted to say i have seen all your videos a few times each and i appreciate all the hard work you guys put into thiem. Thank you

  • @KeithCooper-Albuquerque
    @KeithCooper-Albuquerque Před rokem +5

    Thanks Matt and team for another great video!

  • @asmithgames5926
    @asmithgames5926 Před rokem +8

    One time I was explaining the Triple Point to my parents - matter being a solid, a liquid, and a gas, all at the same time. To which, my step mom replies, "Is that like when you use the bathroom? It's a solid, a liquid, and a gas." The three of us couldn't stop laughing for the next 30 minutes. 😂😂

  • @claireplume11
    @claireplume11 Před rokem

    Thank you for this video, it confirmed a lot of intuitions I had about this subject. It’s not always easy to find answers to your questions when you don’t have enough knowledge to formulate those questions adequately.

  • @mellow-jello
    @mellow-jello Před rokem

    Thanks for bringing me back to my first thermodynamics lecture taken a quarter of a century ago for me. Almost anticipating you to mention the term reservoir, a favourite term used by my professor.

  • @nemethdaniel6384
    @nemethdaniel6384 Před rokem +3

    This was actually nice! Phase transitions are quite interesting. There is for example some sub-phases inside liquid, where viscosity or surface tension changes at some temperature/pressure.
    But now that we looked at the phases on the "right side" of the Einstein equations, maybe the next video could be about phases on the other side! (phases of geometry/ gravity)

  • @patrickmchargue7122
    @patrickmchargue7122 Před rokem +4

    Thank you for a very clear explanation. (and to the other contributor you referenced)

  • @CyrilleParis
    @CyrilleParis Před rokem +1

    This is so refreshing to hear you speak about classical physics at the edge of our knowledge (or our understanding as laymen) rather than almost speculative knowledge at he edge of our fondamental non clasical knowledge (even if I love that too!). Continue spicing your more extreme things about space time (which are great!), with sometimes (just sometimes) a detour to more classical physical mysteries : the three bodies problem, the Navier-Stoke equations, chaos theory, matterial physics on the macroscopic scale (properties of solids : physical, electrical, chemical, magnetic, etc.).
    Don't lose the space-time trend : just spice it with videos like that which are very educational and interesting when you present them this way, with your talent.
    Go on doing it in your own very subtle way, your serialized way, to fascinate the non geeks who are afraid of equations and the very geeks who want highly complex physics without them. I think I'm a fan because I'm a bit of both.
    Thank you!

  • @zharul8716
    @zharul8716 Před rokem +2

    Another add up about Super Critical Fluid in my feed thanks to PBS Spacetime and Scienceclic. Very awesome.

  • @rubensandstrom6824
    @rubensandstrom6824 Před rokem +4

    At final someone who explained supercritical fluids in plain English unlike the professor in my HVAC class

  • @treyschisler384
    @treyschisler384 Před rokem +12

    I love how AppliedScience's project keeps popping up on my favorite creator's videos. Giving it to Nile was a really kind and smart move for everyone!

    • @Basement-Science
      @Basement-Science Před rokem +1

      Yeah I bet a ton of teachers will have used that footage in lectures as well. It's an awesome demonstration.

  • @FleurDeFire
    @FleurDeFire Před 3 měsíci

    I first learned about Supercritical Fluids on NileRed's channel. Loved seeing you use his footage and shout him out while discussing this!!

  • @AmikLanfranco
    @AmikLanfranco Před rokem +1

    I remember learning about this topic in my organic chemistry lectures many years ago; and back then I found it very difficult to visualise these different phases. Thanks to your video, I can finally understand what I was trying so hard to understand back then.

  • @jonathankunjummen9901
    @jonathankunjummen9901 Před rokem +12

    What a fascinating and unique episode!

  • @ritamdutta5860
    @ritamdutta5860 Před rokem +63

    Last time I was this early, En Passant wasn't forced!

  • @omarlasheen5218
    @omarlasheen5218 Před rokem

    The pacing and sequencing of his explanation excites me dude. Like he said “I’m gonna show you” (3:38) and I’m audibly saying “SHOW ME.”

  • @matthewlawrence2395
    @matthewlawrence2395 Před rokem

    All the information all the time. Thank you PBS for helping on my path of growth.

  • @garystewart3110
    @garystewart3110 Před rokem +3

    Oh nice, I remember learning about this in my first Chemistry class in College. Sadly, college I never got to do or complete. Had I done things right maybe i'd have a PhD too, instead only GED. :\ I love that state diagram @1:56 the way it's graphical instead of just lines really makes it pop. :)

  • @Tigtone_85
    @Tigtone_85 Před rokem +39

    Saw a vid years back from NileRed where he went into this stuff while trying to create aerogel. He had a pressure chamber where he was making liquid co2 go supercritical during a part of the process was pretty interesting.
    Edit: comment was made after I paused this vid 2min in 😂

    • @thekronianserpent6523
      @thekronianserpent6523 Před rokem +3

      All fun and games until you find out they covered some of that in this video.

    • @evilotis01
      @evilotis01 Před rokem +1

      ha i came to say the same thing until i saw yr comment :)

    • @Tigtone_85
      @Tigtone_85 Před rokem +4

      @@thekronianserpent6523 Lol didn't see a NileRed shoutout coming I admit. Def waiting till the end from now on and check out Nigels channel if yall haven't already. Dude does tons of crazy chemistry experiments.

    • @nickkorkodylas5005
      @nickkorkodylas5005 Před rokem +1

      Nile green is objectively superior.

    • @evilotis01
      @evilotis01 Před rokem +2

      @@nickkorkodylas5005 this is true

  • @semaj_5022
    @semaj_5022 Před rokem

    This was so cool! Loved the visual representation of the subject and I'm definitely gonna go watch NileRed's video after this. I adore the space/cosmology stuff and really enjoy hearing about the more high level astrophysics stuff, even if I don't understand it all. However, episodes like this; the more practical and comprehensible physics, they're always such a breath of fresh air. Thanks for always providing such great content you guys!

  • @matthewgordon3281
    @matthewgordon3281 Před rokem

    I love it when you blow my mind with stuff I hadn't heard before.

  • @ENDESGA
    @ENDESGA Před rokem +14

    IT’S SPACE TIME

  • @oliviasvahn4090
    @oliviasvahn4090 Před rokem +49

    How about when water gets compressed in exotic types of ice? I’ve read about ice x and xii being in the extreme parts of that same phase chart. That would be another interesting topic to cover! Love your videos ❤ I always learn a lot from them! Thanks 😘

    • @Relkond
      @Relkond Před rokem +8

      That _might_ lean into allotropes, which would be interesting by itself if it hasn’t already been detailed…

    • @cyrilio
      @cyrilio Před rokem

      Second this. Perhaps also ice states of ammonia and other ices?

    • @PandemoniumMeltDown
      @PandemoniumMeltDown Před rokem

      All this made me test the enthalpy of ice in a martini skaker... not all that exotic but... oh so yummy. Super critical to use right proportions 🥸

    • @cezarcatalin1406
      @cezarcatalin1406 Před rokem +1

      If we keep increasing the pressure in a supercritical liquid... do we get a supercritical solid ?

    • @johnnamkeh1290
      @johnnamkeh1290 Před rokem

      @@cezarcatalin1406 Different physics, high pressure for solids leads to stripping of electrons (and eventually fusion), though if you get to iron that also stops happening.

  • @mathematicacivilis
    @mathematicacivilis Před rokem +1

    Congratulations to the PBS Space Time team for creating all this amazing, informative and engaging Science Communication content. Thank you!

  • @lisajsch1338
    @lisajsch1338 Před rokem +1

    Thanks for the featuring! And big shout-out to my current and former colleagues of IceCube who put so much work into producing these newest IceCube results. (More work than I put into this paper, actually, so they should be featured here!)

  • @timebeforespace
    @timebeforespace Před rokem +7

    This is so cool! The actual footage of the CO2 really helped understand the phenomenon.

  • @Mike23443
    @Mike23443 Před rokem +10

    I learned about this from Science Clique first. Their video was pretty well done, as is every one of their videos. They're able to explain like I'm 5 things I never knew could be explained that simply. PBS does a great job but a lot of the equation physics stuff goes over my head.

    • @TlalocTemporal
      @TlalocTemporal Před rokem +1

      That's great! I like the smattering of more complex ideas, most other science communicators gloss over the details entirely.

    • @Mike23443
      @Mike23443 Před rokem +1

      @@TlalocTemporal wow, you're so smart and cool! ☝️🤓

  • @The_Viscount
    @The_Viscount Před rokem +1

    Amateur Naval Historian here:
    This video is great. I've always wondered about the difference between standard steam and supercritical steam. Prior to the invention of reliable diesel nuclear reactors, the largest ships used oil fired boilers. Spray oil into a firebox and ignite it to biol water moving through tubes. These boilers turn water to vapor steam and, due to thermal expansion, the steam increases in pressure and can be used to run steam pistons or turbines. Basically, it's an oil power plant or steam train being used to run a ship.
    Nuclear reactors run much hotter. The reactor is hot enough to increase the temperature and pressure enough to make the steam supercritical. If supercritical steam is incompressible, then you don't lose as much energy throwing it through the steam turbines. I think. Maybe. Maybe Matt can confirm or debunk? But that's my conjecture based off this.

  • @davidgrisez
    @davidgrisez Před rokem

    Before I retired I worked in generating stations that had boilers and turbine generator units. One generating station I worked at had two boilers that operated at 1800psi pressure and 1000 degree Fahrenheit temperature. And one unit at this station operated at a supercritical pressure of 3550psi and temperature of 1000 degrees Fahrenheit. So this generating station was another area where a supercritical fluid was used to generate electricity.

  • @brucepreston3927
    @brucepreston3927 Před rokem +13

    If you had an appropriate suit could you actually swim in a supercritical fluid? I wonder what that would feel like...I'm guessing probably not but it would be awesome if you could!

    • @garethdean6382
      @garethdean6382 Před rokem +7

      It would tend to be more like a submarine than a suit, but you could be buoyant in some fluids. Swimming would be an issue since such fluids aren't very viscous, it'd be a bit like trying to swim through air. A fan would be a more useful way to get about.

    • @Anonymous-df8it
      @Anonymous-df8it Před rokem +1

      @@garethdean6382 So it's like floating on air?

  • @KomradZX1989
    @KomradZX1989 Před rokem +3

    I was born in 1989 and have always loved science. Grew up watching Bill Nye and every physics based show Nat Geo or Discovery Science channel could throw at me. In my entire life no one has taught me more or helped me understand physics and our universe more than Matt Parker. His dedication to teaching and explaining physics is truly an inspiration to me and will always bring me back, eager to learn more new things. Thank you for all the great work you do!!!

    • @zimriel
      @zimriel Před rokem +1

      "always loved science. Grew up watching Bill Nye..."
      Ugh. The sex junk guy.

  • @tahseen.q
    @tahseen.q Před rokem

    As a chemical engineering student, this was a super awesome video. Really cleared up some of my basic conceptions. Loved it!

  • @afefasfe
    @afefasfe Před rokem

    Best intuitive explanation about supercritical fluids so far at least to me.

  • @eeveebrosstudios1896
    @eeveebrosstudios1896 Před rokem +10

    Sooooo… could particles that are usually considered metallic stay as such in the supercritical fluid phase, like say mercury, iron, lithium, copper just to name a few, and how would their properties typically associated with metals change, would they still be electively conductive, could they still be magnetically attracted in some manner?

    • @kylejf2108
      @kylejf2108 Před rokem +2

      Nice.

    • @ericdiederik3732
      @ericdiederik3732 Před rokem +3

      Interestingly, metals exhibit what is considered to be in plain terms 'metallic' behavior' exactly because the the properties they have when solid. The nuclei of metals can easily part with one or more of their outer electrons which allows them a degree of freedom in a crystal lattice. This is what makes solid metals conduct electricity. To answer your question: Metals techinically do not conduct electricity in both critical and non-critical gas forms. They are however readily ionized allowing a current to flow through a path of plasma, in what is called an arc discharge.

    • @michaelsommers2356
      @michaelsommers2356 Před rokem

      Remember that everything heavier than helium is a metal.

    • @eeveebrosstudios1896
      @eeveebrosstudios1896 Před rokem +2

      @@michaelsommers2356 so carbon, oxygen, and fluoride are metals despite not having the typical qualities of what is considered a metal?

    • @eeveebrosstudios1896
      @eeveebrosstudios1896 Před rokem +1

      @@ericdiederik3732 ok, so most typical metals at room temperature and atmospheric pressure, when undergoing super-criticality, behave closer to gases than they do as liquids or solids? That’s what I thought, but I could never find any research, resources, or references to check if that idea was the case or if something else was going on. I knew that the comparatively higher density solids combined with the fact that most of the metallic elements easily loss or give away electrons was the main reason that they could conduct electricity (very over simplified, but you get the point) and I was wondering if the density would be high enough for supercritical fluid “metals” to conduct electricity in a similar fashion to solid or liquid metals. Thanks for the comment, I’m going to continue to search for information on this very subject

  • @catchphase
    @catchphase Před rokem +4

    So happy that you guys collaborated with NileRed, I love both of your videos

  • @misterlau5246
    @misterlau5246 Před rokem

    Great presentation professor. The animation makes it very easy to understand.
    Gracias!

  • @UtopyDream
    @UtopyDream Před rokem +2

    You should also do a video about fluidized beds! They are used in quite a lot of industrial processes, even in oil refineries. In a way, the dispersed phase behaves like it belongs to another state of matter.

  • @msytdc1577
    @msytdc1577 Před rokem +3

    Matt's front tooth appears to have partially changed states of matter from solid to gas since the last video, face do be lookin' kinda pirate in this one, Arrr Matey!

    • @arcan762
      @arcan762 Před rokem +2

      why so few people mentioning this lol

  • @DERIVATIVES-mh6ej
    @DERIVATIVES-mh6ej Před rokem +3

    Can you do a video on how the zeta function is used in quantum mechanics?

  • @goreobsessed2308
    @goreobsessed2308 Před rokem +1

    Ah I've seen that Nile video nice I'm so glad yall used it

  • @meikamo
    @meikamo Před rokem

    So great to see two of my favorite YT channels collide like this

  • @HansStrijker
    @HansStrijker Před rokem +3

    It's all fun and games when co2 and water go supercritical, but when plutonium does it, suddenly everyone's immediately offended and turning their backs to it...

  • @BassNinja
    @BassNinja Před rokem +3

    Notification squad

  • @jaggonjaggon7695
    @jaggonjaggon7695 Před rokem

    Awesome to see some of my favorite CZcams channels working together!

  • @fehmeh6292
    @fehmeh6292 Před rokem

    The Nile red guy has a wonderful and insightful rant about the term "sublimation" that I love.

  • @Scribe13013
    @Scribe13013 Před rokem +3

    (obligatory potty joke)

  • @charles2395
    @charles2395 Před rokem +21

    With everything going on right now, the best decision to be on any creative man's heart is having a profitable investment strategy.

    • @nissan38p69
      @nissan38p69 Před rokem

      Even with the current dip in the market I'm still glad can smile back at my portfolio of $32,500 built from my weekly trade, all thanks to my advisor fergus Waylen

    • @vaztrevorknox4203
      @vaztrevorknox4203 Před rokem

      I definitely agree this current DIP is a huge opportunity to buy the DIP and also high volatility to yield more profit for day traders

    • @Kristenshwan
      @Kristenshwan Před rokem

      @Willis Braden The fluctuations of the market only affect those that hodl coins, but traders makes money on both sides, when it's bearish they go short when it's bullish they go long... The best strategy to use in trading crypto is to trade with a professional, like Fergus waylen he understand the market quite well, that way maximum profits are guaranteed.

    • @lea5898
      @lea5898 Před rokem

      I'm honestly surprised that this name is being mentioned here, I stumbled upon one of his clients testimony last two months in CNBC world news and decided to try him out...I'm Expecting my third cashout in 2days

    • @jackfinnva2409
      @jackfinnva2409 Před rokem

      I have also been trading with him and the profits are secured and over a 100% return on investment directly sent to your wallet.
      Lack of trade discipline is the primary reason for in day trade losses. It is estimated that nearly 80-85% of day traders end up losing money in the stock market

  • @guardyangel
    @guardyangel Před rokem

    Amazing video! Thank you so much for this content!

  • @dcbaars
    @dcbaars Před rokem

    His videos really remind me of my physics teacher on school. He also could explain the most difficult concept with a beautiful example or experiment. He sparked my interest for physics, chemistry and astro physics

  • @rsc4577
    @rsc4577 Před rokem +3

    First

    • @rsc4577
      @rsc4577 Před rokem +1

      Finally 😎. Anyway, let's watch the video and then comment again.

  • @mgold7503
    @mgold7503 Před rokem

    I really liked the video clip. I can now see an example and understand the concept.

  • @Aochso
    @Aochso Před rokem

    We did this in physical chemistry class in university at the beginning of this semester and now finally i understand it fully. Our prof never explained it this clear, always had some parts of it which i didnt understand fully, so thank you. Also whats mildly interesting: in the solid phase at higher pressure there are different variations of solid matter, (if i translate it correctly from german) its called superionic ice. For example there is ice II, III, IV, V, XI and some others. Video about that would be great.

  • @deleted-something
    @deleted-something Před rokem

    This explanation of that graph makes so much sense

  • @srbelnap
    @srbelnap Před rokem +1

    I always look forward to how you're going to get "spacetime" into the ending monologue!

  • @valiantstallion
    @valiantstallion Před rokem

    17 years ago, in a skyscraper near a river..
    I was supposed to be working on the 33rd floor but I was exploring around whatever floors my keycard gave me access too. I soon found myself on the roof on an outdated observation deck. It was really cold, like -20°. I noticed that I was eye level with the fog coming off of the river and the surface was reacting like the surface of a body of water. There was fog waves. Man I miss those days.

  • @lewismassie
    @lewismassie Před rokem +2

    I was going to share both NileRed's video and the Venus atmosphere fact, but you got both ahead of me. Glad I didn't comment as soon as I arrived. Great stuff

  • @OldFartGrows
    @OldFartGrows Před rokem

    I remember researching this subject when I was a mmj chemist. I ended up developing brand new extraction tech. Loved making pressure containers with windows in them so I could see what was going on at different temps & pressure. Science can pay huge dividends

  • @objective_psychology
    @objective_psychology Před rokem

    As soon as you said you were going to show us what it looks like, I just KNEW you'd use Nile's vid! Great to see two of my favorite creators come together

  • @diomedesabcmnxyz7299
    @diomedesabcmnxyz7299 Před rokem +1

    ~ I attribute the properties of a supercritical fluid to convection, which affects only liquids & gases, along with additional interesting control conditions that can be explained by radiation in a vacuum.
    ~ Thermal conveyors = conduction (solids), convection (liquids/gases), radiation (vacuum).
    ~ A plasma condition is the intermediation between an inert gas & a vacuum borderline transformation, caused by radiation.

  • @therichieboy
    @therichieboy Před rokem +2

    I *knew* Nile Red would come into this! Really amazing video.

  • @AlanTheBeast100
    @AlanTheBeast100 Před rokem +1

    Best explanation of supercritical fluids I've ever heard.

  • @scudder991
    @scudder991 Před rokem

    Great video, especially the awesome House reference. I miss that show. And I would totally buy the series dvd set just to see your cameo, Matt.

  • @taubrow4973
    @taubrow4973 Před rokem

    In the first 5 minutes, I said to myself, "this is like that NileRed video" and lo and behold, it shows up. It really is one of the best visual examples of substance going supercritical

  • @casual_sky2
    @casual_sky2 Před rokem

    Hey! That was me! Thank you so much for the super detailed response! You guys are the best!

  • @robbabcock_
    @robbabcock_ Před rokem

    Wonderful video, verging on kind of understandable/practical science!

  • @mrwinemaker
    @mrwinemaker Před rokem +2

    Supercritical CO2 is also used for removing the possibility of cork taint in wine. If you treat the corks with it, the Tri-chloroanisol that causes cork taint gets dissolved and killed. Useful stuff

  • @MnJiman
    @MnJiman Před 11 měsíci +1

    "Ok, thats enough blah blah pressure blah blah.."
    That made me too happy.

  • @shaider1982
    @shaider1982 Před rokem

    It's a breather when Matt disucsses topics inside the relatively simer classical physics that's used in engineering. Helps the mind relax before we delve more into modern physics.

  • @WhiterunGuard11998
    @WhiterunGuard11998 Před rokem

    Matt knocked it out of the park again. Another flawless victory!

  • @ditrixgenesis781
    @ditrixgenesis781 Před rokem +1

    I've been super interested in the expanded phase diagram, and lots of places just don't cover it well.

  • @gavinthomas87
    @gavinthomas87 Před rokem

    That was ace - thank you Matt!

  • @caleschley
    @caleschley Před rokem +1

    There's a company in the city I live called Vitalis. They manufacture and sell equipment that uses super-critical CO2 to extract essences out of plant matter. I think their primary clientele are those in the cannabis industry but I believe there are other applications.

  • @maleusgaryn8227
    @maleusgaryn8227 Před rokem

    I was just talking about sublimation of water ice on Mars, using dry ice here as an example, 2 days ago. Perfect video to share with them. They're fans of Nile Red too, so bonus!