Story of the Subcontinent - Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed | Abbas Haidar | ViewPoint
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 09. 2024
- Today, the 9th of November, 2021, marks the 144th Birthday of Allama Dr. Iqbal, the thinker of Pakistan. So, today, let's revisit the Complete Story of the Subcontinent with Award-Winning Writer and Political Scientist, Dr. @Billumian47.
Along with 'ViewPoint with Abbas', we have another series named 'Abbas Narrates', where we deconstruct thoughts and ideas.
Please have a look: www.youtube.co....
Wanna know Abbas personally? He writes his heart out on Instagram. Follow here: / abbashaidar09
You can connect with us:
Email | abbasnarrates@gmail.com
Dr. Ishtiaq is my mentor in history, he has great energy to narrate his research and knowledge. I pray to God he may live long !
Pakistan is non democratic country.
Pak. Avam. अपना. Sach. Itehas. ही. Jan. ले. Pak. महान. नंगे. होंगे. हथियार. के
कमीशन. तो. मिलता. मगर. जंग. 48..65. 71. 99. से. कितना. पेसे. हथियार. खरीदे. होंगे.
अवाम. मरो. कम्यूनिस्ट. सत्ता. मे. डालर. बनाओ. पाक. अवाम
which god ur abhramic god createdby abbasi or eternal hindu common read sachwala
Professor Ahmad"s vast knowledge and clarity of thoughts is really impressive...
@@vinodmishra2888
Dear Vinod Mishra, I cannot read Hindi.
*“Nobody died for Pakistan but millions of died because of Pakistan ”*
Sharp, lucid, analytical, diligent, and meticulous, respectful and humble. Ishtiaq Ahmed is an exemplary role model for the subcontinent.
Totally agree Sir
I'll second that.
This is content for a complete audio book. As an Indian this is one Pakistani who has taught me so much about my own nation.
Hindutva is only a reaction. It’s a defensive and a belated refusal to put up with bigotry. No one in India wants to overturn the secular nature of the state. The proportion of Muslims in India has risen from 10 to 15%. Any comparison with what Pakistan has done to its minorities is false equivalence.
himangshu bhai not true we want to discover our hindu roots just to see if original was secular or not ... if not at least we need to find writings of charvaks and other atheists and other lost works like aryabhat's second text which is lost
@@einsteinwallah2 we have a lot of dalit writings and if they started reacting the same way hindutva does and call it " their reactionary or defensary action" then they will start frowning. Anyways that's not a defense that's an excuse to be radical.
Just like recently right-wing groups stormed into a convent school in Madhya Pradesh and pelted stones at the building over claims of conversion of students to Christianity. The incident took place at St Joseph School in Ganj Basoda on Monday even as students were taking an exam, which had to be stopped because of the incident.
Sure those students will grow up loving hindutvawadis. And here's a fun fact, convent school have hindu student majority because of obvious 80% vs 2.3%.
"no one change the secular nature"
Who are demanding hindu rasta"?
Very very good information by
Dr, sahib thanks to Abbas bhai,you have dugout
The history. Good suggestions by Dr sb.
Keep it up 👍
Haha 😂 you are so funny
@@einsteinwallah2 research of past literature and society is good things. Finding out ancient knowledge is also good. But County, people and society which we have today should be based on present value which respect human rights and humanity. Because democracy was not present in old times in India. Secularism is required for a Democratic country work.
I have always admired and respected Dr. ISHTIYAK AHMED, he is a learned, experienced, unprejudiced and very seasoned historian. He is very broad-based and unflinchingly hard hitting when it comes to facing and dealing with indisputable truth. How many people across the world have this integrity and character ?
Jinnah literally created Pakistan out of thin air. He made sure Muslim have a safe Islamic country for themselves.
Meanwhile what did Gandhi achieved? Hindus are still struggling in India? Do Hindus have a safe Hindu country for themselves?
Right now, Muslim have 2 countries, Pakistan, Bangladesh. Hindus have no State in the world and Hindu population is declining. Who is loosing?
He speaks the truth based on hard facts that's the reason why he is respected a lot in India, but not much in Pakistan.
People who speak truth are never Respected in Pakistan.
Unfortunately if you do not respect the person who speaks truth, you end up losing a leader
True
@@hemalbhatt4055 you guys dnt respect Arundhati Roy
@@Zainab-jb7lr
You guys don't respect many Pakistani people like tareek fatah, Hussain Haqqani,
@@hemalbhatt4055 Hussain haqqani yes.Tariq Fatah.. no...he is a big lot with zero integrity
This guy is a very good interviewer. I dont know why this guy hasn't received the resources to do better production value to his program yet.
Great questions and great analytical approach.
Count me a fan of Abbas Haidar. More power to you.
Well since the discussion here was so frank I would like to say that Hinduism is an organic faith. For example: the sun gives us warmth and light, helps crops grow and at the same time has the power of parching the people and scorching the earth. Repsect and awe for the sun is very basal and similarly you can find the sun achieving a divine status in Hinduism. Same way, in the agrarian way of life, cattle is extremely important. From milk to ploughing it plays a vital role. Hence the bovine animals attained a status of respect and divinity. People may call this primitive and this is obviously open to argument, but I stand by this argument
The irony though is lost on the country that a foreign sport that involves a ball covered in slaughtered cow skin being thrown about, smashed with a stick, spat on, and rubbed on one's behind is so popular that it is considered a religion! Talking about cricket in case anyone was wondering. Not to mention the starving and abandoned bovine animals betrays the reality that the true intention behind the love for the bovine is really no more than an excuse for hate of certain segments of society.
@@imgn8r715 well, since you picked up the bovine issue, leather trade is allowed in India in the name of liberalism. And your discourse makes me feel like you are a liberal yourself. Stop leather trade tomorrow and the left will flood the streets with their own set of objections. So, what is your solution?
@@AdityaKumar-rj2uf Whether the left will protest the leather ban or not is speculation. I am more interested in knowing why Hindus who are against cow slaughter not protesting cricket where balls are wrapped in slaughtered cow skin?
@@imgn8r715 well there's a lot of things to protest for. Like the independence of Balochistan, creation of Pakhtunistan and of course, Sindhudesh as well. So of all the things on earth, you want to communalise and politicise cricket balls?
@@imgn8r715 In hindus cows are revered that means they are not supposed to be killed. We have already been wearing belts, using combs and jewelry and ornaments in ancient times were made of cow products. Obviously cows were not killed for making them but they were made from dead cows, this is just to prove you wrong that Hindus enjoy a free pass to hate anyone who kills cows. It's you who has a communal bigot and I can sense the deep poison in you to hate hindus but alas since you cont you tried to take a lame example to demean Hindus. Go and clean your own soul coz you never how many products are made of pork skin which you so much consider to be haram and would come on street with naked swords to kill anyone whoever mixes pork or pork related products in your daily lifestyle. Tch tch
If Mujibur was treacherous against Pakistan then why Mr jinnah was not treacherous of Indian national congress and united India
Mr jinnah was not treacherous of India as Mr savarkar was not treacherous of India
mujib separated east-west Pakistan on the basis of bangali race. 1972 separation
East-west pakistan was separated on the basis of religion from India. 1947 separation
now even bangali's suffer an identity crisis on the basis of 1947-1972 independence, which india can easily exploit.
kashmiri's also need to understand this, if they are with a 1947 separation it is on the basis of religion (which the indians can not easily revert), but if they separate on a 2021 basis, it will be due to kashmiri race, a decision the indians will easily revert in a couple of generations.
@@shehzadnoor9907 IDENTITY CRISIS STILL EXIST IN PAKISTAN.
@@sreekantcp
Bangladesh has two independence 1947 and 1972. They have an identity crisis.
Independence of Pakistan was on the basis of Two nation theory. What Kashmiri's should say is that they want independence according to 1947 then there is no identity crisis. Only Islam separates You cleanly from the indian's as no other force does.
@@shehzadnoor9907 WHY DON'T YOU MENTION BALUCH, SINDH, PAKHTUN IDENTITY CRISIS
After a long time I have heard so wonderful, informative, insightful, unbiased and objective an interview. Probably the best of 2021. Kudos to you Abbas ji and Dr. Ahmed ji.
Islam is the real problem of Pakistan. After the last popat first five khalifas were murdered in khanajungi. So khanajungi was past, is present & future of Pakistan. Islam like Christianity, Marxism and Fiat Currency like $ driven hedonistic consumerism ask converts to cut their roots of native spirituality, native languages, native culture and pride in achievements of native ancestors. With roots gone they become rootless parasites. Rootless parasites are easy cannon fodder to build evil enslaving empires like Roman, Khilafat, Mughlai, British colonial empire and Dollar's economic empire.
Mr. Haider, myself being a student of history cant thank you enough for this wonderful interview!
We feel very proud to recount that after partition , when Prime Minister Liaqat Ali Khan of newly created Pakistan had invited MH Premji father of Azim Premji ( of WIPRO ) to come to Pakistan where he was offered the post of Finance Minister of Pakistan . Well ,the senior Premji refused saying that he would not leave his Motherland India.
Mahindra And Mohammad ( now Mahindra And Mahindra )
The famous Indian vehicle ( jeep ) manufacturer Mahindra and Mahindra was originally ( before 1947 ) named Mahindra and Mohammad .Partner Sir Malik Ghulam Mohammad chose Pakistan and , to the best of our knowledge , became the first Finance Minister of Pakistan ( a Post which was declined by the then WIPRO Chairman )
MH Premji should have left.
@@petrolecinternational7435 In retrospect it was a good decision.
Look at the economies of present day India and Pakistan.
You'll get your answer.
But at the time Per Capita GDP of Pakistan was greater than that of India.
Azim Premji was quite Shrewd.
@@thebestevertherewas useless to feed sense into a "bhakt" (slang for bjp supporters). Azim is one of the top donors (financial donations) in india but his muslim background is enough to overshadow his achievements and good gestures.
@@akaj188 wow, thanks for the info. That would have been good see, but 😓.
Abbas Haider I am at 40 minutes right now and what an amazing interview...my hats off to you my man....I am searching for Professor Ishtiaq Ahmed's books now will try to read all his books. Well done Abbas Haider and Professor Ishatiaq Ahmed....👍👍👍👍👍
@@AbbasHaidar kush-amdaid bhai 😊 jeetay raho 😊
I admire the works of Dr Ahmed. Follow him thoroughly across numerous platforms. Great effort from Abbas Haidar saab.
It was a treat listening to Dr. Ishtiaq sb, loved the whole vlog, and kept me very much engaged. Great information added to my memory, thanks Abbas bhai.
RSS bjp on Reaction Not Action
Wonderful conversation. While Dr Ahmed is amazingly insightful, but full kudos to the interviewer Mr Haidar. This interview deserves to be watched by all Indians and Pakistanis
I like your style of interviews….. excellent… keep up the good work ❤️
It’s always a pleasure to listen to Prof and Mr. Abbas, you are such a fantastic host. Loved listening through the whole discussion. Thanks!
Jinnah literally created Pakistan out of thin air. He made sure Muslim have a safe Islamic country for themselves.
Meanwhile what did Gandhi achieved? Hindus are still struggling in India? Do Hindus have a safe Hindu country for themselves?
Right now, Muslim have 2 countries, Pakistan, Bangladesh. Hindus have no State in the world and Hindu population is declining. Who is loosing?
@@RP027 , ever heard of a country called Nepal ? It's a Hindu country you can live in if you're feel Hindus with 80% majority are struggling and are unsafe in India.
@@RP027 we are good being secular and we should feel proud being diversified nation, bcz it make everyone safe.. never think being hindu country bcz we couldn’t achieve something great from that, hindu - hindu mai bhi ladiya hoti hai- or jyda hi hoti hai…these are only political agendas to bring religion in politics to distract mass from asking questions regarding development. as a citizen of India we should work for country only. religion is good only at personal level not national level, it degrades international image bcz you have deal with everyone not hindus only..and in hindus are spreading in European country which never try to be Christian country that’s the one of reason they are progressing. so think about it.
@@mohit6941 India will be a Muslim majority by 2100.then cowards like you will flee the country like other Hindus did in 1947
عباس بھائی بہت اعلی مزہ آ گیا سن کے دونوں لوگوں نے بنا کسی نفرت یا تعصب کے صحیح تاریخ بیان کی ۔
پاکستان میں ایسی باتیں کرنا بہت ہی مشکل یہاں لوگ سچی بات برداشت ہی نہیں کرتے ۔ پاکستان کسی ساری تاریخ جھوٹی اور من گھڑت ہیے جو ہمیں سکول کالجز میں پڑھائی گی
Mr. Abbas , there was a superb discussion. In 1947 we did not get freedom, what we got was a manufactured freedom. Britain outplayed the Indian politicians. Muslim league was predominantly made up of feudal and nawab who were very much a collaborator of the British. The real reason for the British leaving India was their precarious financial situation after second world war and huge sacrifice of the azad Hind Fauj of subhas Chandra Bose. It was a INA trial that led to uprising of the Indian armed forces.
Very much informative discussion. Look forward further discussion.
Nothing better could be narrated so well, simply and unbiased. Thanks Abbas Haidar.
@@AbbasHaidar yes dear, already done both.
I am surprised that how Pakistani will digest the true narratives of Prof. ISHTIAQ AHMED.
Great reseacher and a historian who can speak truth in a highly rediclised and fed with wrong
history. My salute to a great man.
Dr. Istiaq Ahmed' s realistic views on partion is logical and the most authentic one.
Zabardast! it was so interesting to listen him talking
Dr Ishtiaque is the only person who is not suffering from Stolkholm syndrome even though he lives in Stolkholm
Ironically, the late converts from Hinduism to Islam like Iqbal, Jinnah and Bhutto were responsible for the first partition of India based on the religion of the population, for the first time in Indian history.
Good and logical analysis and research
Hi, Mr. Abbas Haider, congratulations for hosting a wonderful program with Mr. Istiaq Ahmed Sir. One of the few remaining political scientist having such a indepth & candid oral and written analysis on Indo-Pak history.
As an Indian, I must be great full to our towering leaders who charted such a diverse country India to a democratic, pularistic and progressive nation, having its true role in world affairs.
Hats on to you guys, be lately there is a introspection about Pakistan.
Wishing you good luck on your endeavor.
@Abbas Haider I just finished the whole interview....I am very, very, very pleasantly surprised at such a wonderful thought process of such a great scholar Professor Ishtiaq Ahmed. Brilliantly done!!! May I suggest that you interview him about his books in the next series, like a book review kind of thing and ask him questions about why he wrote such and such thing and try to figure out what happened in the past? Do think about it and please do let me know thank you 😊
@@AbbasHaidar geetay raho kush raho 😊
What a wonderfully enlightening conversation. Lovely; thank you for speaking the truth.
It is a fact that God is only perfect. Please listen to wisdom of this historian.
Unite with love with a basis of human values and not islam
Excellent work Abbas Sahib
عباس حیدر صاحب ھم سب آپ کے لیے دعا گو ہیں کہ اس مسخ شدہ تاریخ کے بیانیے کے ھوتے ھوئے آپ سچائی کے بیانیے کو لیکر ھم جیسے جوھلا کو حقائق بتانے نکلے ھیں اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو ثابت قدم رکھے اور بےشمار کامیابیوں سے نوازے سچ بات کھنا افضل ترین عمل ہے خاص طور پر جھوٹ اور منافقت کے دور میں مالک کائنات آپ کا حامی و ناصر رھے
Excellent Objective analysis by Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed
What an enlightening discussion! Pakistan should immediately stop conflict with India. India has moved on from pain of partition. We too want peaceful, happy & developed Pakistan. Best of luck! 💐❤
Dr Ishtiaq sir is gem of sub continent 🔥🔥🔥
awesome video loaded with lots of information and hope. Thanks to abbas, and special thanks to ghalib kamal for introducing us to this channel. 🙏
Being an Indian Muslim, it becomes imperative to understand the realities, dimensions and political discourses of Pakistan movement to renounce the hindutva agenda of BJP. Both Pakistan movement & hindutva agenda has lot in similar.
🃏 Urdu me likh lo,aap kuchh samjha hi nahi sunkar bhi ... Dusri baar sun lo......
Yep, the hindu equivalent (i.e hindutva) wanted the same for india, a country based on religious lines but congress (thankfully) aimed for secularism. Unlike rss who rejected tricolor for years.
@@dennisthemenace4288 Allah ki gaand me lulli aur anguthachaap jahil gando Nabi laudakhor tattikhor Muhammad ki Tarah har rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool Muslim hijdo ki Islamist gaandallah me lulla 😂😂😂😂
Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed is a true Punjabi - very open, and fearless.
How about Iqbal?
@@PS-ej2xn which Iqbal?
@@rajeevverma1604 Were there many famous Punjabi Iqbals?
@@PS-ej2xn I know of 100’s of iqbals. At least 10’s of them live in NYC.
@@rajeevverma1604 Aren't you more qualified to discuss the history and politics of NYC than of India Pak?
Jinnah wore his religion on his sleeve. He was the most un pious human being!!
The fervour of 1st generation Hindu convert to Shia Islam.
His father converted to Shia Islam after being born Hindu. Grandfather was a Hindu bania,Gujrati speaking.🙂
@@muralimurahari4038 everyone are converted in Indian subcontinent except Hindus.
Jinnah literally created Pakistan out of thin air. He made sure Muslim have a safe Islamic country for themselves.
Meanwhile what did Gandhi achieved? Hindus are still struggling in India? Do Hindus have a safe Hindu country for themselves?
You are a Deka, you know what is happening in Assam. In 30 years Assam will be Muslim majority.
@@RP027 Do you even have a stand what are you trying to say. Listen you fool, Hindus are secular breed we don't have a sick concept of having isolated hindu majority like you people have and basis on that fundamental you created a nonsensical Islamic country and look at the difference between Hindustan and Pakistan in 75 years. Haha Hindus are struggling, okay if Hindus are struggling then who's winning? you.? lol.. you worry about Pakistan which is going to be broken into 4 pieces at anytime soon rather than worrying over Assam where BJP has already declared NRC to save its tribe.
I'll definitely try to watch the full video, but am apprehensive whether I will be able to follow the entire discourse on account of the language barrier. If everything is in Urdu, which is a very sweet language without doubt, viewership could be restricted to Pakistan and parts of India where Urdu is the dominant language. So, can we have at least some discourses in English, as well, which is understood by millions across the two countries? Thank you 🙏
Do Muslims know that Jinnah was a Khoja Muslim and his ancestors were Hindus who became followers of Aga Khan?
Great Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed zindabad
As Bangladeshis we are happy that we kicked out Pakistan from our country. Thank god !
@@AbbasHaidar what you abbas read his comments
@Ziaul but what Pakistan was doing with you, ur doing same with Hindus, same on you people
It is the superiority complex of the ex ruling Ashraf or elite, who feared being out of power under the Hindus. The wrong idea that "Hindus and Muslims cannot live together, meant that Muslims cannot be ruled by Hindus. Muslims (meaning elite Muslims) could always rule India for 800 years if they were in power and had the freedom to eliminate Hindus wherever required. Do Qaumi nazariya only meant Muslims cannot live under Hindu rulers.
This is so so amazing. thank God I found this. enlighten by this talk. thanks for doing this.
BTW and excellent interview.
Professor comes out as a great scholar, researcher and gives his unbiased opinion.
My father (1905-1987) was a matriculate. He always asserted that Pakistan was created by the British as a buffer state.
Dr Ilahi Baksh got himself alloted a huge property on Lawerence road to establish a hospital where poor will get free treatment.
This never happened. According to his will he was buried in that estate to maintain family’s possession. It took govt almost 50 years of litigation to recover the property. I
Hats off. Totally intellectually unbiased & honest. Indian journalism is unfortunately not that honest.
I salute to Prof. Ahmed for being truthful and courageous in bringing facts about partition of India and correcting history of Pakistan, which will help Pakistan to be a peaceful and better nation.
i really appreciate your opinion
Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed ji, you are wonderful. Today I learned a lot from you. I love history.
Being keen and curious student of history and plotics I always enjoyed listening Dr Ishtiaq Ahmad....thank you.. during the conversation brief talk came of Hindu hardline or rightwing...I would like to share my experience...I m came from Catholic background but now admire and follow Sanatan dharma or Hindu way of life...I grew in Allahabad UP then Mumbai...sand lived near Muslim dominant area in Allahabad ... every Hindu festival we used to have Riot and curfew ...and even in between..I have seen my own eyes how Muslim religious leader from local mosque use to protect all the mischievous teenager from cops and traffic police when they get caught wrong doing. .. and argument use to be go catch big ppl..why poor ppl...and these kids use to always upto mischievous act... and point came when Hindu started reacting..
If you are so keen of history,please dont take a small sample like only one city. Consider all the riots between hindus and muslims in India after partitionon and then come up with the results and see who has suffered more in life and property
@@gurdipsingh606 I have and doing it regularly. ..and still getting stronger in my view after every reserch of base....though current time it's lots of aggression coming from majority and that was bound to happen.
The entire of Manauri ( outside Allahabad) left to karachi but for 3 families.
@@gurdipsingh606 i google major hindu-muslim riots post-independence and damn results are one sided. Even the delhi riot that was blamed on muslims. Just google official victim names by delhi police in delhi 2020 riots. I mean how can have more muslim dead bodies if they are the one who attacked first on an unprepared citizens.
Its resultent behaviour of minority that is quickely to be judged and labelled uncivilised. But in contrast, in developed world, it is now rather treated as majority's responsibility to be blamed for themselves. Because numerically they use more resources for own betterment (education, economy, health etc.), and minority is left with systematic repression to be suffered. Under the circumstances their fear of loss turned them hyper reactionary especially in less developed world..
Didn't expect I'd watch it full, but spent whole 2 hours watching this. Professor sa'ab is very clear headed and sane. May his tribe increase.
Dr Ishtiak Ahmed my sincere appreciation to u for such balanced views and narrating history with all its bumps, warts etc. The way u hv narrated it is just wonderful. Kudos to Haider too for the way he has conducted the interview.
Thanks for this, it was very informative and engaging the way Dr. Ishtiaq Sir spoke.
Jinnah was from a family which converted to Islam only three generations back.
Jinnah's family was a lohana (a trading community) in Hindu ,gujarati family.
Their ancestoral home is still in Gonadal ,Rajkot ,Gujarat.
Thanks for presenting an excellent account of our history; camouflaged and twisted for all the decades.
Jinnah was so right .... look at what's happening in kashmir and to the Muslims in India as a whole... I'm glad I'm born in a Islamic country and God creates those circumstances with me ....
What a great discussion
I'm lucky to have found this channel.
In somequarters of India too self introspection is also going on in d intellectual field.
Though it is very difficult to counter both Hindu & muslim fanatics ,I hope ultimately ,we will be successful in bringing peace -harmony -respecting one another cultures .
Our parents also had to run for life from Pakistan.
Jinnah literally created Pakistan out of thin air. He made sure Muslim have a safe Islamic country for themselves.
Meanwhile what did Gandhi achieved? Hindus are still struggling in India? Do Hindus have a safe Hindu country for themselves?
Right now, Muslim have 2 countries, Pakistan, Bangladesh. Hindus have no State in the world and Hindu population is declining. Who is loosing?
ھندوستانی زبان ہی درست بات تھی. کاش کہ وہی بات اگر اپنائی جاتی. ہم نے بھی دیوناگری پڑھی ہوتی. تو سارے ھندوستان کا لٹریچر ہماری بھی دسترس میں ہوتا. المیے ہی المیے.. ہیں جو یہاں سننے کو ملے ہیں.. مگر معاملات اب بھی ویسے ہی الجھے ہوئے ہیں. جیسے کہ بنتے وقت تھے. زبردست سوالات کیے گئے ہیں زبردست انفارمیشن دی گئی ہے..
I really wish you were an indian. Your knowledge and oratory is illuminating
I wish to thank both of you for this nice discussion and request Dr saheb for his books in Hindi .
Thought-provoking approach regarding the whole scenario that has happened in this part of the world. Just can't off your eyes from start to finish. Thanks 🙏
Ishitaq sir
Aap ki bat Pakistani man Jaye tau
Pakistan tarakki kar jae.
Respect from India
The majestic narration of unvarnished truth from the mouth of an unbiased humanist without any frontiers ... I could safely say that I rode through a tangible history highway ...
Ishtiaq is right in saying that India was very secular and did not want any religious state. Unfortunately over the years due to Pakistans consistence enmity towards india now most of the Indian population thinks that Pakistan is terrorism factory (I do not think this is true.). A good portion of Hindus who were tolerant have developed thought that Islam has some fundamental issues (I do believe that it needs reforms badly at least in this subcontinent). The truth is somewhere in between. Also the Pakistani rhetoric regarding modi is not helping because there is hardly any truth to it.
In short even if there was not ill will among hindus it has developed now. I do think that India is stable as long as Muslims are minority. Its not that my friend Ali is bad, its just that when the clergy takes over its over. I know this is not a reasonable fear at least in my lifetime but it exists.
For that matter I have seen time when my dads best friend was a muslim. We used to go to Muharram as kids and enjoy it. All the village kids used to play cricket. There was hardly concern that there are two communities. That was just 20 years back. But the difference now is actually visible. Internet has not helped either.
exceptions are not rule. see what they do when they are in majority
@@ritesharora6032 Yes and no. Do not express such opinion without explaining reasoning for such thought.
Islam was meant to be for the time when world was chaotic and extremely violent. The core issue of Islam is that it fundamentally divides world in believers and non believers and tell believers that you are superior. You can kill non believers or tax them! The idea that Islam is perfect and the ultimate truth doesn’t help either! It’s total brainwashing. Yes there is truth to it in its essence but a man who is not capable of anything can not understand what is truth just because he read Quran. When actually we don’t even know if Quran was actually written or told by mohommad.
Sorry to my Muslim friends. I don’t hate you but Islam is not innocent. Most Muslims are innocent but the ideology is something else.
Islam gives too much power to the religious believers and the leadership and power corrupts. No wonder the moment Islam is in majority others are screwed.
@@nacpatil *Islam is a cursed religion*
Good to watch as both of them have read a lot and are knowledgeable. Very good to listen and learn
Truth will prevail. I hope Pakistani will learn a lot from this on their distorted history.
I just wanted to compliment Dr sahib for keeping the record straight.
Outstanding discussion. He is one of my favorites.
Excellent content. The questions were very mature and had depth. Pakistan people should think from view point of Indians sometimes too. Most of the Indian population don't want any fight with Pak. We are forward looking people who want the country to achieve new highs in science technology and in every field. Also we would like to see Pakistan progress as well because that would add to Indian progress as well. A progressive neighbor is always better than one who thinks of one as an enemy and creates problems.
Candid, honest and convincing. Thank you Abbas Haider.
mr jinnah grand father was hindu lohana he left his village to porbander to start fishing business and he make lots of money and return to his village and village people told him that you make money by selling meat and you not allow to stay in the village then he left to karachi.thats why he colorbred with british to teach hindu a lesson
History is unpredictable prediction of past and future which may be Right or wrong but every historian give opinion on the basis of what they observe and experience .it is the horizon of possibilities.....what is happening now for tomorrow it's history.so many of us write it in their own prospective...
Very enlightening. Thanks to Dr. Ishtiaq for the education.
Thanks for posting such an insightful interview. Prof Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed's talk is very unbiased. It was a pleasure watching this video.
Wonderful and valuable interview.
Pakistan 🇵🇰and India 🇮🇳 can learn a lot to improve our relationships for mutual benefit provided we stop serving tools ⚒️ of super power
Professor Sahib top most intellectual, historian and political personality. There is so much to learn from him.
The reasons behind the historical animosity between India and Pakistan - and its continuation for last seven decades - is not simply due to a territorial dispute in Kashmir.
It runs much deeper than that… and is seeped in the religious ideology of Pakistan which was the pivot for their separation from British India in 1947 where Hindus were in majority.
Muslim separatism was at the heart of the partition of British India… and Pakistan continues to foster Muslim separatism within India to dismember India further. They are not content to just stop with Kashmir seperatism. It is an endless endeavour which will continue for as long as Pakistan exists!
Goo job Abbas. I learnt a lot from Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed and you. I hope Pakistan grows and develops it's economic, education and governance might.I can see or would like to see Indian subcontinent like European Union(EU) at some point in future but it is a dream. Could you imagine the economic might of the complete subcontinent as a union...
Dr. Istiphaq Ahmad is great historian . salute to u sir from India. Very knowledgeable person always talking about true history.
Great show
Dr. Ahmed is a wonderful historian.
I hope one day India and Pakistan would again unite. It would be possible only after education and Science enable us to keep religion out of public places and keep our religion within our home.
No less than a blessing to know truth in our Life. Thanks Prof and Abbas
Partition of India was the greatest blunder in human history. It resulted in muslims in India feeling insecure , in the killing of millions of people both muslim and hindus in 1947 and in 1971 which would not have happened if India had been united . The condition of the minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh would not have been what it is today. Mr Abbas I urge you to read Maulana Azad's book India wins freedom. Its a first hand account of what transpired during the freedom struggle and how events unfolded which lead to Partition
Don't he crazy. Glad India got rid of those nutcases. Yes, we also lost a few gems like Dr Ahmed but on balance, this was one of the best things that happened to India, at a huge cost, but still the best.
Hello. Abbas sir I recently found your channel on CZcams and I want to let you know that you are doing very good work. I watched few of your episodes and I liked them. ❤️❤️
What a teacher! What a speaker! What a fantastic perspective he gives to history which is so cluttered and conflicted! Spares noone as a researcher-Nehru Jinnah alike. Respect !!
وہ مسلمان جو اللّٰہ اور اسکے رسول اطاعت کرتے ہیں انکی ھیبت ھوتی ھے ۔
Abbas Haider get Parvez Hoodbhoi, Hussain Haqqani, Anis Farooqui and the likes of these brilliant people in your future programmes and debates.
- that was a well invested 1 and a half hours of my time - very informative
-a great interviewer and a very informative interviewee
- am subscribing :)
What a shame that we will not find such nuanced and fact-based discussion on Televised media.
Partition proved a blessing for Hindues because by now United India would have become Muslim majority country.
پاکستان کا مستقبل:
قوم سے ملّت
وفاق سے یونین
Great interview, great questions, one of the most insightful discussions that I've listened on all these complex issues (Indo-Pak rivalry, Idea of Pakistan, Jinnah, Nehru, Gandhi, Pakistan as rogue state etc.). I've read biographies of Gandhi, Nehru & am an avid reader of Indian Subcontinent's History & the GeoPolitics. I agree with much of Dr. Ishtiaq's views & insights. Really good, mostly rational except when he talks about Islam Religion. However, I do not agree to (1) that Nehru was a visionary leader (may have been better than Jinnah, who I agree was worse) Nehru by kicking out SC Bose & making selfish blunders like Muslim League, warming to Soviets pre-1947 etc enabled if not caused the Partition, when he should have stopped it. (2) Dr. Ishtiaq is right that now that Pakistan is there (although he agrees it's creation was a mistake), grow it, but he is very unrealistic in saying that Pakistan can become a LIBERAL RELIGIOUS state! What in the world does that even mean? It seems he's talking like Jinnah there. One can not radicalize the state in the NAME OF RELIGION for 73 years (as Dr. Ishtiaq also says many times) & then expect some magical twist. (3) Pakistan will not survive unless it figures out a way to distance the state from ISLAM RELIGION & ISI/ ARMY. The Irony/ issue there is that, Pakistan would not survive int he 1st place WITHOUT Islam & ISI. Hence, this is a contradictory statement, its a FANTASY of Dr. Ishtiaq just like Jinnah. Pakistan will ultimately crumble, may take 5-10-30 years & India wont have to do anything either, Pakistan will implode. Consequences will be bad, very bad for everyone, but this IDEA OF PAKISTAN from Jinnah, will not end well for anyone. Sad but true.
This interview is of last year. See the condition today. What will be the view Dr. Ishtiaq sir today. Totally unpredictable country.
One of the best videos by Abbas Haider
I think it is important to remember that Dr. Ishtiaq was born after the division of India. He has not experienced how the minorities of India felt in pre-partition days. He also has spent most of his life in Sweden where secularism is practiced. He needs to talk to Muslims of India including Kashmir, investigate the situation Dalits are in, and discuss minority issues faced by Sikhs. Dr. Ishtiaq will always be liked by the Hindus of India and praised for his voice criticizing Muhammad Ali Jinnah's Two Nation Theory. Many people have made their name in criticizing Jinnah and I am sure Dr. Ishtiaq will be a darling for that group. As we progress the rest of the world will follow. Most of us would not have achieved academic distinctions in United India, just look at education statistics pre-partition. Dr. Ishtiaq will always be popular among the naysayers of Pakistan and Hindus of India.
Agree 💯percent 👍
your knowledge about dalit ,sikh , muslim's of india very limited, and what's your literacy rate after partition??