The Real SAM BAHADUR Reaction! | Brut India
Vložit
- čas přidán 20. 06. 2024
- Jaby and Achara raect to Brut India's "The MAN In Sam Manekshaw." The life and career of Sam Hormusji Framji Jamshedji Manekshaw was as illustrious as his name. Back in 2002, interviewed by his own grandson for a documentary, this is how he recounted his days of glory.
Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
____________________
Intro music by DAVIS
CZcams - bit.ly/30OK7RR
Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
Purchase a "I Got a Funny Feeling Tee" here!
unofficialdavismerch.myshopif...
___
Jamazing Patrons of June: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Riju Mahna and Daipayan Das!
Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
Original Upload Link:
• The MAN In Sam Manekshaw
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~CINEDESI~
CZcams: @CineDesi
Twitter: / thecinedesi
Instagram: / thecinedesi
~ACHARA~
Insta: @acharakirk
~MOOSA RAZA~
Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
Instagram: @syedraza7
Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
___________________________________________________
SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Intro song: Hudson Stanton
CZcams: / hudson12311
Insta: / hudsonstantonmusic - Komedie
As a Bangladeshi, i can guaranty you that Sir Sam Bahadu Manekshaw is the greatest Army chief in entire South Asia and also a great human being as a whole. You all should know more about this great man. And every defence cadet should study his life. Love and respect from Bangladesh.
And now 80% of Bangladeshi's are with Pakistan 💀. We can see a lot of Bangladeshi Muslims coming to India and went to Kashmir....
Stick to your Islam and pakistan bruh we all know your real colors
@@highfbi8188 why so salty ?? had a nightmare last night ?
Indeed.
This men saved Bengalis irrespective of Faith. Joy Bangla. From India.
“If a man says he is not afraid of dying, he is either lying or is a Gurkha.” Fiel Marshall Sam Manekshaw
Sikhs and Gurkhas were loyal to the "British Raj" during the 1857 War of Independence, which is why the British lionized them and later gave them "Martial race" status.
It was the Gurkhas of the Gurkha regiment who did the shooting during the "Jalianwala bhag" massacre. (along with part of the Baloch regiment - now in pakistan army).
So I strongly suggest you decolonize your mind.
@@odomangulati7079 I'm just quoting Sam Sir ,don't get so upset guy
@@indian9428 And I am just given you a history lesson, so you don't get so upset either.
@@odomangulati7079 Don't lay the blame for the tragedy on the soldiers. It is the ones giving the orders that should be blamed.
@@sgerardpandian That is exactly what the Nazi's said after they killed all the Jews.
They said they were just following orders.
"Respect the old man in the profession where men die young"
- Sam Manekshaw's Biographer
we'll see about it..thanks for ur concern
Game of thrones
Sir Sam Manekshaw is first Field Marshal of Indian Armed forces
It's wartime rank
5 star general
Currently the highest in Indian army is Chief of Defence Staff (CDS General - 4 stars) who commands all the chiefs of Three armed forces
He fearlessly served the nation since WWII
Proud son of mother India 🙏🇮🇳
bro kariappa was the first field marshal....not sam.
@@bibaswanmukherjee7237 check your information brother
Sir Manekshaw was promoted to field Marshal rank in 1973
And sir KM Cariappa was promoted to the rank in 1986
@@bibaswanmukherjee7237 Blatantly Incorrect.
@@bibaswanmukherjee7237 It's Sam Manekshaw, who was the first field Marshal of India. Gen Kariappa was 2nd.🧡🤍💚🇮🇳🇮🇳
The CDS does not command the Chiefs of the three armed forces. He is only "Chairman" to the Chief of Staff Committee, beside heading the Dept of Military Affairs.
Also since Lt Generals are eligible to be appointed to the post, he is clearly not senior to the Generals of the three forces.
His sense of humour and wit was really sharp. Once in a social gathering he quipped that - "I was never a heavy drinker, but both of my daughters are in to liquor, one is married to Baatliwala, another is Daroowala" 😂.
Baatliwala (bottle manufacturers) and Daroowala (liquor manufacturers) are last names in Parsi community.
Gujarati community*
@@sagar-fb2tm Nope, PARSI community.
@@odomangulati7079 Abe mai gujju hu hindu Muslim Jain South gujrat mai bohot sare logo k surname 'wala' hote hai especially ghanchi n gola community
@@sagar-fb2tm Baatliwala and Daroowala are BOTH PARSI surnames.
@@odomangulati7079well he was from Gujarat… and yeh he was PARSI
My uncle was in 3rd Gurkha Rifles, veteran in '62, '71 war, Sam is simply a legend
My great grandfather was in the same war too.❤
@15:14 , You missed the context. It was not how many Bengalis you would kill but more like what is the minimum collateral and civilian loss you can manage in. When He said 100 then his response meant anyways 1000's are dying if at the loss of 100 peace can be restored than it better anyways. Also there are a lot more videos of him with lots more stories
Correct
Yeah. Hon'ble Field Marshall Manekshaw meant that if left unabated, thousands of Bengalis would die in the violence. If the army takes control, there might be a possibility of a hundred casualties in the action, but he could definitely restore a rudimentary peace and save the rest.
Calcutta Violence started by Muslim League rioters during Direct Action Day was stopped by counter rebellion organised by Gopal Patha. Read about him.
@@yushpi gopal patha story must be known by all....what a legend
They don't understand British English...
I am still amazed at how well spoken he was, the right mixture of chauvinism and chivalry.
you saw this first time?
@@Pk_1911 it's my 2nd time but first on Jaby's channel
He was trained by the British and when he joined the Indian army he could not even speak Hindi. Which is why you can see his british accent even in 2002.
Now I understand why he has this accent. I noticed this accent with lot of people born before the 50s @@odomangulati7079
So a well spoken guy is absolved of all sins
He was the man of the men. Watch is speech at Indian Military Academy passing out ceremony and his lecture on leadership at Saint Xaviers college. He was and is a great role model. Manley + charming + great sens of humour + very well spoken + extremely witty + man who commands respect and honour.
The man the myth the legend sam.The indian army field marshal🔥💯
Gurkha is the regiment he respect most.... He even said that once in his interview:
" Fear is a Natural Phenomenon, Like Hunger and Sex, Anyone who says he's not frightened, is a Liar, Except the Gorkhas. ⚔"
Every Single regiment and forces group did so much for this country that we have to make a movie on every one of them to educate our future generations. These people gave so much and today most of the people of this generation only know what gender they living in or what vape or drink they gonna take in evening with their friends.
Sikhs and Gurkhas were loyal to the "British Raj" during the 1857 War of Independence, which is why the British lionized them and later gave them "Martial race" status.
It was the Gurkhas of the Gurkha regiment who did the shooting during the "Jalianwala bhag" massacre. (along with part of the Baloch regiment - now in pakistan army).
Before 1857, the Army was mostly made up of Bengali Brahmins. The Regiment was called "1st Brahmins" and "3rd Brahmins". All the Native regiments was dismissed after the 1857 war and the army was filled with Sikhs and Gurkahs and Baloch and Pathans who remained loyal to the British.
@@odomangulati7079you're so true my friend
@@odomangulati7079I wish more people know this
@@odomangulati7079The Bengal Sepoys didn't have all Bengali Brahmins, majority of them were Bihari Brahmins and they opposed the British instead of joining them in 1857 which is why they disbanded 1st Brahmans Regiment later.
Good to see that you are checking Sir Sam Manekshaw's media interviews available on CZcams. Now you are well equipped with information to compare the movie and Vicky Kaushal's acting and the movie.
From addressing the Pakistan infiltration into Kashmir (genocide of Hindus in Kashmir) during a crucial time to handling West Pakistan (now Pakistan) atrocities (read massacre of Bengali intellectuals, social activists, and students from both Hindu and Muslim communities) in East Pakistan (now Bangladesh), stand against China against all atrocities ... Manekshaw is a legend who led operations that changed history.
🙄🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯😑🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 thanks for this reaction and thanks for your respects.
May Sir Bahadur resting peace and be a man of god watching over us.
Hope I can be some one like him . A better and greater guy. Like him.😑😑🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏.
Mad guy out.
Field marshal is a post for life, never retires.
I am so glad that the world will know Sam Manekshaw. I have heard so many stories from my dad, as my granddad was from the army and he passed before I was born. I always thought the world should know about such great personalities, and hardly any of the young ones do today.
Fun fact: they started conversing in their native 'Nepali' language at the 17:17 mark
Why did people born before the 70s have such a unique accent? I noticed this with actors like Dev Anand and Raj Kumar?
I think it was because of the British english influence that was still in the country after they left (coz hardly anyone had any exposure to US english back then)! You might notice that generation didn't use to have any "fillers" when they were speaking. They used to speak in sentences and most importantly - to the point, unlike today where we care more about the flow and don't want to take a break in between the sentences.
Proper British accent.
So it's officially that The Gurkha Mr. Harka Bahadur Gurung gave him the name Sam Bahadur. To be honest he was fascinated by Gurkha regiment. He believed in Gurkhas even more than his own Indian armies.
Gurkha are indian armies
Few Armymen are from nepal but majority of Gurkha regiment members are Indian. And after service most of Nepalese always take indian citizenship and stay in India, so in short they are all indians.
What kind of idiotic comment is that ? He was initially commanding the frontier force which went to pakistan after partition. So He was later put in charge of the Gurkha regiment of the Indian Army.
From there is rose up to the rank of General and then Field Marshal of the Indian Army in which there are 7 Grukha Regiments.
LoL that's very stupid thing to say 😂
@bro gurkhas are nepali who work in different countries including india😊
He's an absolute legend! My father would tell me stories on how Sam Manekshaw was pivotal in winning the Bangladesh and other wars!!
I've been in the audience listening to his leadership lecture in the Academy. He was a legend and a great orator.
In the movie trailer Vicky's character address PM Indira as "Madam" which Sam never did... instead he used "Prime Minister" which you can hear in this interview.... so once after a bureaucrat's complaint to Cabinet Secretary pointing it to be disrespecful, the Cabinet Secretary mentioned this in Sam’s presence at a meeting of the Committee of Secretaries, he got a reply that left him speechless. Sam said and I quote “I hope you know that the term "Madam" is reserved for certain ladies who are in charge of houses of ill fame.” (Savage😮)
Only Field Marshal who call Prime Minister of Country as "Sweetie"
That too someone like Indira gandhi, that's just damn
There are some quotes of him which are still taught in the army to the young officers.
He once showed a minister his place. The minister said " hey you can you draw the curtains there?" Or something like this to one of the soldiers. Sam Bahadur was there and he said"Minister, he has a name and a rank in the Indian army... address him by his rank" So the minister obliged...
He always stood for his soldiers and never bowed down to any pressures internal or external.
He was loved! Not just by his men, but by the people!
He was a big name. Brave and humane. ❤
My father shook hands with the General as a very young officer, and he describes it as if he shook hands with a steel bar.
So true...my uncle met him too..strength as in character aura persona and himself..
I have watched literally all videos available on him! He’s my favorite hero! It’s always captivating just listening to him although he was quite old!
Showed gallantry in WW2 against the brutal Japanese, got injured during serving didn't know whether he was gonna live or not, served in 4 different wars across 4 decades, was instrumental in creating a new country while simultaneously leading his own towards victory. That's our Field Marshal Sam "Bahadur" Manekshaw for you.
His lecture on leadership is something you can keep on listening too 😍
Watching the reaction of you two together is just ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
" If a man said he isn't afraid of death either he is lying or he is Gurkha "- Sam Manekshaw.
“Beware of an old man in a profession where men usually die young”
Suits very well with the Late Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw
Thanku for this …it was much needed for everyone
Glad you experienced Sam Bahadur. He is still one of the widely respected leaders, not only among the men in uniform but also civilians. I hope Vicky Kaushal does justice with the role, it's a huge ask from him.
I'm just blown away by the charm of this man!!
Hi Jaby and achara it's a pleasur discovering new content along with you and all the group, it was so interesting this video put sparkles in my eyes and a smile to my face, I'm not Indian and didn't know who Sam bahadur was but it was relaxing hear this gentleman tell his stories, history is so interesting, i also felt like I could have listened to him for one hour , now that i know a movie is coming out of it, I'll gladly watch it, have a wonderful day.
Now that's a great reaction 🎉
Pls find lots of stuff like this n react ❤
As a cadet of NCC...from 1999 to 2001 and as one of the final candidates for Rashityra Indian military college (RIMC) Dehradun in the year 2000..i really assure that exposure to Indian Army training teaches you a lot of things...No1. Nation first no matter what..No2. People of India first..No.3 familyand friends first...No.4 Yourself first..
It was unfortunatey an unfinished dream of my late father...who wanted me to be a part of the Indian army and contribute my part. Even though i was partly a part of paramilitary through Assam Rifles under (Retd.)Major K.K.Ghosh. thank you mother India.. জই আই অসম ❤
This man literally change the Map of world and created a new country when super powers were standing against him, as is said , Bandey ne duniya ka naksha badel ke rakh diya😎
before the annoncement of this movie, i knew about sam bahadur. As a Bangladeshi whenever i read about our struggle for indepence...i always remember sam ji....
I think every educated Banglaadeshi should know about manik ji, and his role towards our independence. I think he was not only a great army man but also a very good human beings who respected even his enemys.....what a great personality....i feel myself lucky to know about himself from a freedom fighter of Our country,who went to india to take training for the war......Rest in peace manik jii......❤
Your countrymen have a different atitude now..thank you ❤
India’s pride! Glad you guys picked his interview for your video!
Thanks for bringing in this video it's very informative..we don't get to study or read this stuff in our academic history..ty it was worth every second.
Sam was a TRUE legend! One of the top soldiers India ever produced. Btw, he was fr the Parsi community ( people who originally came to India as refugees fr Iran/Persia) ...some of the best leaders in every sector, whether industrialists, teachers, scientists, lawyers, sportsmen, actors are from that wonderful bunch of people!
"What we won in the war.....we lost on the table"......the 1971 war
This has become so rare these now. Nice to see you doing video together.
There is no better actor than Jim Sarbh to play this character.
We all are his fans
He is the personification for what indian army exactly represents ❤❤
The reason we all love you Jaby and Achara so much is because of the earnestly with which you watched this whole interview so patiently, knowing so little about the man going into it. Your honesty in your work comes through and yes, Sam Manekshaw is a charismatic person to listen to, that always helps.
Sir. Manekshaw, I remember that he and he was the only Army personal who had shut PM on face and in a non confronted manner...
We have heard 2 ppls Sir and R&AW first chief...
Vicky is the perfect cast for Sam. Can't think anyone else fitting even remotely in that role.
I just hope jaby is okay....he's feeling a bit down.❤ and we had a full chapter on Sir manekshaw when I was in school and used to go panchayat Paredes.
Thank u guys for making reaction on Sir Sam Manek Shaw,its our glory to have sam bahadur in our side, such a legendary Human being with so much extra ordinary powers , so much to learn from him for life and for your responsibility to the work u do and to your role towards society
I never knew this video even existed...wudve wished it to be longer....but thanks for this reaction
Best person in talking, in leading his troops.........❤
Man, his mannerisms and gentlemanly conduct remind me so much of my (now passed away) grandfather. The just don't make them like this anymore! Truly the type of men to admire and aspire to emulate!
Same here I can keep listening Sir Sam Maneckshaw. A legend in a Professional Indian Army........
Wow lovely video thanks jaby achara for that ❤❤
He has more such interviews but this was a good one to sneak peek into the persona of the great man.
So glad to see you back Achara !!!!
❤
I would love to just listen his life's every minute narrated by him❤
Clocking up to 74 years, He is technically the longest continuously serving soldier in the indian army, or probably any army in the world!
And now that it's available on OTT I request Jaby and Achara to make a reaction video on that movie, ASAP.
Loved this
Indian and Bangladeshi army men are the kindest and most chill army men in the world.❤❤❤❤❤ Love from Bangladesh.
He was a rare gem.
There will always be Respect and Love for Manekshaw sir in our hearts, but a special respect for Jaby and Achara who decided to watch this video and understand the Legend instead of just watching the movie and get entertained❤ One of the best channels for a reason
You should see the full interview! Brut has only shown portions of it.
FM sam manikshaw's last words were "I AM OK "
His memory was so sharp. He could remember the name of his Sentry, Harka Bahadur Gurung, from 1947. I don't even remember what I did last week.
A heartfelt thanks to Jaby for highlighting this. 🇮🇳🙏
These were the real Generals of the Army. The army of Today really misses him..he could really stand up to any authority and speak this mind..it takes guts which sadly the generals of today's Indian army do not have.
Every Indian can go to war with a general like him. But now there's no one like him forget better than him.
Sam Bahadur is available on OTT on Zee5 platform.
My hero Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw
Legend never Dies 🏁
Live on our Hearts 🙏
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Thank you ❤ for doing this !
15:17 One wrong decision changes demographics
Nope, it Cowardice that changes demographics.
How about some Bollywood horror since Halloweens round the corner, my suggestions would be stree and pari(2018)❤😊
13B and 404 error best
They've seen stree I believe.
BTW bulbul is best
1920
@@user-sq2hv4ks1n😂
Raaz
Salute to field Marshall General Sam manekshaw in this age also a reacting like young. I am very happy to watch Gl. Manekshaw.
That "khanna ..loija " sounded like my father❤️
5:41 I'd heard that Bangladeshis were enraged and demanded that Pakistani military officers be put on trial in front of the people. The Pakistani military was afraid that the people of Bangladesh would kill their forces if they were left behind. In order to spare their lives, Sam Manekshaw accepted them as prisoners of war. Because of this decision, the victims and their families of Bangladesh genocide believe that India protected the war criminals.
Yeah but look at these shameless Bangladeshis now! Their local population is still ready to support Pakistan over India anyday. They now believe it was solely Bangladeshis who liberated Bangladesh and India did nothing that big there😂
Jai Bharat...✊
Jai Jagannath...!🙏🙏🙏
❤Thanks💞 to Both of you for ... u know what I want to say... 🙏🙏
I don't know what happend to me, what I'm thinking or feeling ri8 now but, My Heart waned to say Thank to you both after see this 1 so I...
Ok Bye....👍
Jai Jagannath...🙏🙏🙏
The irony is that India released their 93,000 POW (prisoners of war) but failed to get 54 Indians whose fate is not known. The reality is that their case was taken up half-heartedly. The government does not only ignore their sacrifices but also the tears of their families who still hope that they will return alive one day.
Blame the people who voted for the CONgress back then. Its too late for the Modi govt. to do anything about it.
@@odomangulati7079
Modi cant even get 93,000 PoW
Lot of Indians would have loved that if he had Overturned the Govt & become the PM, This Man Absolute Legend Chad 😂😂❤.
hitting like button, coz jaby kept his mouth shut for the better part of the reaction. thanks achara
He was a legend. He was very brave and charming.
This is the amazing documentary
Thank you Jaby and Achara for not disappearing the screen in between.
Not that's what Goosebumps are made of!!!!
When we war sam sir always my brother always talk about then I.following them sir great person for country.
You must watch more of his interview. That's why we indian respect sir sam bahadur
He wasn't just in those pivotal moments. He made those moments pivotal 🔥
“Sab ka Banda hai yeh ❤ Rab ka Banda hai yeh" aur kuch nahi hai bolney ko, Sam. Bahadur is Sam Bahadur...... ❤❤❤
Some people are born with rare qualities ..for SIR..am very small to even say sainething ..legend beyond words
He was not just an ordinary man he was legend
Thank you for sharing this... Our army has been following these values and classic discipline ... We had been groomed under apt leadership.. So unfortunate we have started behaving like the rest of the neighbours just because we pretend to be superior nation... We have lost the cause of "वासुदेव कुटुम्बकम"
to clean the dirt, you have to get your hands dirty.....and we dont celebrate the 'dirt' anymore
@@MohitKumar-nj8ms To clean dirt, wear gloves or use machines like any civilized and developed country would do. In other words, law should be the guideline, law enforcement should be the tool not the politician or brainless mob. We have seen enough countries trying such shortcuts and finally ending up in "dirt"
sorry for going off topic but it seems that Jaby being quiet in the intro and outro of the video is in reaction to the comments from the KICK movie reaction.
4:17 Lol. He only asked her to postpone it. The invasion happened 10 months later I think.
When US AND British sent their naval armada including aircraft carriers some reporters asked him are you scared that the Americans are joining the fight? He smiled and said he is happy that he will be the first general to defeat the Americans in a war …
Can you tell where you got this quote? I wanna read that article or video. But still the Americans didn’t intervened and 3 years later Vietnam would defeat America and brace the first to do it in a global stage.
He spoke so many languages ❤
20:01 American soldiers get PTSD after just 2 years of deployment, meanwhile Indian soldiers and generals are relatively peaceful ✌️
Between 100 and 140 Indan army soldiers have died ever year of “suicide/self-inclicted injuries”. This, when there is No war being fought for the last 20 years.
@odomangulati7079 What is the total number of soldiers across the army? And how significant is this number in that term. Mind you, the percentage is very much higher in Western countries.
Majority of American soldiers who fought in Vietnam were young men 18-19 year old who didnt even want to be there in the first place
@spilltea4241 No one here is talking about Vietnam. Look at the original comment. "2 years of deployment." They still get deployed around the world and have the highest number of Homelessness and drug affected ones
Permanent roommates season 3 is out ! Waiting for the watchalong
Yes yes yes yes yes yes million times thank youuu