@@frankpiccione8571 i think he means to say it is a pre-cursor to modern ambient music like the later works of brian eno, certain works by aphex twin, william basinski, grouper, etc. while i don't know if it was a direct influence on any of those artists, the first piece in this video certainly seems to have stylistic similarities with them like the slow tempo, long-held chords that change slowly bit by bit, and the general absence of any instruments or notes with harsh attacks
I've listened to many versions of this piece but in my head I want the upper voice to have a greater presence on the first beat notes and a little slower and no one does it this way so I must be wrong ? Any one got any ideas why I hear this so differently from everyone else ? P?S I'm not a conductor just an amateur composer
@@jonaszszulik1728 Although curiously, this modal harmony(second movement i think C myxolidian for example) makes it consonant but doesn't sound to me at all "Old Style". I mean, nothing here sounded to me Bach, Mozart or Beethoven. Only the ground bass in the second movement can remind me "baroque". But apart from that, nothing else.
was born the signet of perfection call me by my starred complexion they believe me well endowed please relieve me fly too close and now i can barely see the sky before me vague inscriptions floating stardust one recompense do what i must but what fault should i grieve diadem and scepter they percieve me, the son of dawn i know its wrong to not listen turn away to eyes that glisten little cherub and the seraph thats enough that is all of me, the son of dawn
Except that the second movement sounds interesting, it's like Sibelius.Everything else are all a tune,it's no different with noises when listening a long time.
C’est ma version préférée, merci milles fois
0:00 - No.1
3:16 - No.2
5:29 - No.3
the first reminds me so much of arvo pärt cantus in memoriam of benjamin britten. It's so beautiful
Part's piece if from 1976, this one from 1963... Gorecki was the real inventor of the Holy MInimalism...
How wonderful to find new expression in material so old. "Old wine in new bottles"
I've only recently gotten into Gorecki but he's quickly becoming a favorite composer of mine. This is proto-ambient, to me
What is proto-ambien?
I mean what is proto -ambient? Can you be more clear?
@@frankpiccione8571 i think he means to say it is a pre-cursor to modern ambient music like the later works of brian eno, certain works by aphex twin, william basinski, grouper, etc. while i don't know if it was a direct influence on any of those artists, the first piece in this video certainly seems to have stylistic similarities with them like the slow tempo, long-held chords that change slowly bit by bit, and the general absence of any instruments or notes with harsh attacks
Mistrz Górecki!
Un lavoro emozionante!!! estremamente emozionante!!!
No.3 is masterpiece.
Beautiful
I've listened to many versions of this piece but in my head I want the upper voice to have a greater presence on the first beat notes and a little slower and no one does it this way so I must be wrong ? Any one got any ideas why I hear this so differently from everyone else ?
P?S I'm not a conductor just an amateur composer
fajne poleca 3 cześć
Could someone tell me what makes these pieces 'olden style'? Besides the 2nd movement featuring groud bass (of sorts) I'm at a loss.
Modal harmony
@@jonaszszulik1728 Although curiously, this modal harmony(second movement i think C myxolidian for example) makes it consonant but doesn't sound to me at all "Old Style". I mean, nothing here sounded to me Bach, Mozart or Beethoven. Only the ground bass in the second movement can remind me "baroque". But apart from that, nothing else.
Who knows, where is possible to buy score and parts of this music?
Chester music
He didn't happen to mention which old style he was referring to.
Probably in those days in avant-garde circles, this was old style. After all, Gorecki was an avant-garde composer.
Who is the conductor? What Orchestra?
According to the video description, Antoni Wit with Polish National Radio Symphony
was born the signet
of perfection
call me by my
starred complexion
they believe me
well endowed
please relieve me
fly too close and now
i can barely see
the sky before me
vague inscriptions
floating stardust
one recompense
do what i must
but what fault
should i grieve
diadem and
scepter they percieve
me, the son of dawn
i know its wrong
to not listen
turn away to
eyes that glisten
little cherub
and the seraph
thats enough
that is all of
me, the son of dawn
How it deserves to be executed
Except that the second movement sounds interesting, it's like Sibelius.Everything else are all a tune,it's no different with noises when listening a long time.
Disagree, the first movement is extremely moving and very atmospheric.
Don't do Sibelius like that! :P
after learning holberg suite this will be fkin booring
I hope you've changed your mind. Gorecki is a great composer.
this is so beautiful! I wish I could join such an orchestra