What Actually Happened In 1971? | 056 | TBT

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 2. 07. 2024
  • International listeners can support TBT here: buy.stripe.com/14keVU54r5hQ55...
    In conversation with Farhat Hussein, this episode explores the tales of 1971 from a civilian’s perspective. What has he experienced during 1971 war? What happened during 1971? How long was he imprisoned in India? How Indian wardens treated them? Did his family know about his whereabouts? What he thinks of today’s Pakistan? What he thinks about Seth Abid? Did he work directly under him? Was he a smuggler? Did he really kidnap Benazir Bhutto? Tune in to know more on Pakistan’s future, textile industry and youth!
    #ThoughtBehindThings #muzamilhasan #1971war
    00:00 Farhat Hussein
    00:59 How his professional career started?
    04:41 What he experienced during 1971 war?
    17:52 How many years he lived in India?
    23:27 What happened after he got out of India?
    27:09 How Indian wardens treated them?
    28:32 Did his family know about his whereabouts?
    31:22 Where he worked after coming back to Pakistan?
    34:41 What he thinks of today’s Pakistan?
    38:31 Did he work directly under Seth Abid?
    40:01 Murder of Seth Abid’s son
    42:11 Did Seth Abid kidnapped Benazir Bhutto?
    45:03 Seth Abid: a smuggler?
    46:19 When he retired?
    46:57 What he thinks about Pakistan’s textile industry?
    47:53 Is he hopeful for Pakistan’s future?
    48:45 What he thinks of today’s youth?
    Don’t forget to subscribe and press the bell icon to catch on to some amazing conversations coming your way!
    Follow us on Instagram:
    • / thoughtbehindthings
    • / muzamilhasan
    Support our podcast:
    anchor.fm/syed-muzamil-hasan-...
    You can also audio stream our podcast on following platforms:
    • Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/0PnNhyI...
    • Google Podcast: podcasts.google.com/search/th...
    • Apple Podcast: podcasts.apple.com/pk/podcast...

Komentáře • 1,9K

  • @joyitadsuja2701
    @joyitadsuja2701 Před rokem +21

    I am a Bangladeshi girl. My father is a Muktibahini. I am very much proud of our freedom fighter. And thanks India for supporting us. জয় বাংলা, জয় বঙ্গবন্ধু।

  • @rktiwa
    @rktiwa Před rokem +148

    I am sorry that you suffered so much baba jee but when you said Indian army saved you I feel some satisfaction. It is pity that none in their comments mentioned this fact. What people, really!

    • @freethinker241
      @freethinker241 Před rokem +4

      True bro

    • @nimaykargeti8913
      @nimaykargeti8913 Před rokem +7

      Indian Army keeps our prisoners with dignity. Don’t even imagine what happens with Indian prisoners in Pakistani Jail.

    • @nimaykargeti8913
      @nimaykargeti8913 Před rokem +6

      @@Brokenhearted894 if Indian Army said that then your brother must have links with militants. Indian Army is one of the most professional armies in the world We have zero tolerance policy when it comes to terrorism because we have suffered. 26/11 , Uri, Pulwama etc. Lost a lot of lives of Army personals too. So your propaganda of defaming Indian army on social media is not going to work. You are definitely a radical muslim or Pakistani .

    • @Brokenhearted894
      @Brokenhearted894 Před rokem +1

      @@nimaykargeti8913 oh! hyderpora encounter says a lot about occupying army.millions of innocent kashmiris killed by occupiers .the inhumane Afspa has made thousands of kashmiris as scapegoats pellet guns made thousands of kashmiris blind.thousands kashmiris are missing who are taken by occupying army by saying they have to just visit camp and they never came back.more than 9 Lakh occupying army roaming in kashmir.#QUITKASHMIR

    • @nimaykargeti8913
      @nimaykargeti8913 Před rokem +5

      @@Brokenhearted894 Go to Indian Kashmir and see developments there and then see your Kashmir. You guys don’t even have food to eat. In Indian Kashmir people are using 5G network. There is Airport, 3 Central Universities and 9 state universities in Indian Kashmir. No Kashmiri is missing. All are happy except the ones on ISI payroll.I haven’t heard of any protest or use of Pellet guns anything since article 370 was removed in 2019. I just visited Kashmir 6 months back. Loved Tulip Garden by the way. Thanks to Indian Government for taking good care of our Kashmiri brothers and sisters.

  • @samadsyed7480
    @samadsyed7480 Před 2 lety +849

    As Pakistanis we shouldn’t forget or deny the atrocities committed by our government and army against the bengali community which resulted in the mess he went through. If we don’t learn from our mistakes we won’t progress as a nation

    • @shakirobaid2895
      @shakirobaid2895 Před 2 lety +24

      how our govt are dealing with TLP can result in a shitty future atrocities again

    • @MA-ol9pc
      @MA-ol9pc Před 2 lety +20

      Do you know who the mukhti bani are?

    • @chilled_beer821
      @chilled_beer821 Před 2 lety +7

      True indeed

    • @narayansaini719
      @narayansaini719 Před 2 lety +128

      @@MA-ol9pc Mukti bahini were the force of persecuted Bengali's Armed Force Which was trained by Indian Army to liberate their Motherland Bengal.
      As an Indian I am saying that we supported Mukti bahini. But the Creation of Mukti bahini was the result of Atrocities of Pakistani Army on Bengalis. By Tagging them as "Gande Kaale Bengali" Army Generals and Politicians of Pakistan were responsible for 1971 Bengal Genocide.

    • @tawseeftaher9109
      @tawseeftaher9109 Před 2 lety +34

      ​@@narayansaini719 true.
      and not giving the power to elected member sheikh mujib by yahia and bhutto was very very despicable.
      @mehendipur Baufal, not giving power to mujib was synonym of not giving power to east-pak. always trying to dominate the toxic panjabi west-pak ..the whole pak country as a whole.

  • @Rishi.N.Mathur
    @Rishi.N.Mathur Před rokem +125

    We can only imagine what our ancestors suffered during 47, 65 and 71 ...they are such brave people ...Respect to this gentleman from 🇮🇳

    • @betaalsbuddy1655
      @betaalsbuddy1655 Před rokem +1

      Stop d!ckriding paxtanis if you have a little bit of self respect potato face paj33t

    • @stone9126
      @stone9126 Před rokem +2

      Especially people from Bengal and Punjab.
      I'm from Bengal 🇮🇳

    • @Rishi.N.Mathur
      @Rishi.N.Mathur Před rokem +1

      @@stone9126 Yes

    • @piyushjaiswal9283
      @piyushjaiswal9283 Před rokem

      Suffered? He was in army that *aped millions of Hindu women in military camps

    • @sharad991
      @sharad991 Před 6 měsíci

      3000 soldiers of Indian army...martyred

  • @HunaidSohail
    @HunaidSohail Před 3 lety +227

    His memory is so good. He is telling situation 50 years back as a story that a person can imagine in his mind.

    • @aneeqaahmed115
      @aneeqaahmed115 Před 3 lety +14

      My Dado was about 5-6 yrs old at the time of Migration and literally she told us all the stories and things happened at that time She even can't remember what happened yesterday now but all the past events are still refresh in her mind🥺

    • @HunaidSohail
      @HunaidSohail Před 3 lety +16

      @@aneeqaahmed115 Its never easy to forget tough times in life.

    • @AbeerZahid47
      @AbeerZahid47 Před 3 lety +6

      Memory works by recalling your past moments, the more you recall a moment in your mind, the longer you can remember it even if it is 50 years old.

    • @qalabeabbas6114
      @qalabeabbas6114 Před 2 lety +3

      I reckon it's not easy to forget when something like happens to you.

    • @RajbirSingh-fl7zp
      @RajbirSingh-fl7zp Před rokem

      @@qalabeabbas6114 kķ

  • @sanjayshahare336
    @sanjayshahare336 Před rokem +180

    When this Babaji said"Indian army"saved them,I really fill proud of Indian army. Jay Jawan - Jay kisan - Jay Hind ki Sena ❤❤❤

    • @prashanthk8755
      @prashanthk8755 Před rokem +1

      Can u tell the exact time he says that

    • @Real_Not_Fictional
      @Real_Not_Fictional Před rokem +3

      @@prashanthk8755 approximately 11:40 ke arround

    • @jenifferbrown2297
      @jenifferbrown2297 Před rokem +1

      That is a fact. In many places indian forces did save non bengalese. But not as a generality. In thousands of other instances, the Indian army turned blind eyes to the genocide.

    • @bandhandas2796
      @bandhandas2796 Před rokem +2

      @@jenifferbrown2297 your source please

    • @tanveerahmed9639
      @tanveerahmed9639 Před rokem +6

      Bro , being a Muslim , I salute them for this act . Maneskshaw ❤

  • @jgel16116
    @jgel16116 Před rokem +15

    No matter who wins the war, it’s the common man who always suffers. When he talked about his children’s pictures while in camp, it brought tears to my eyes.

  • @haroon420
    @haroon420 Před rokem +12

    11:31 so the Indian army protected his life from the Bengali militias.
    Say what you want but in the last 75 years, the Indian Army has been about as professional as one can expect in such circumstances.

  • @engr_msj
    @engr_msj Před 3 lety +314

    Because of the so called generation gap we have lost the stories of struggle, hustle and survival of our elders. We do not know their journeys. We do not know what they have done for this country. Big thanks and thumbs up for Muzammil to bring this conversation for us. We seriously need these kind of journeys for our motivation.

    • @ammarahmad79
      @ammarahmad79 Před 2 lety +1

      True words Sir💖

    • @farhanathar2256
      @farhanathar2256 Před 2 lety +4

      True. 100%
      We have been missing these kinds of sessions in our main stream media. And that's why Our new generation really lack understanding of importance of this country and the struggles our ancestors have faced for this blessing known as Pakistan.
      Kudos to Muzammil for bringing this elderly man in the podcast

    • @uzmafakhar5660
      @uzmafakhar5660 Před 2 lety +3

      I used to sit with my father and my NANA , ask them multiple question and they share experiences. it worths spending time wth elders.

    • @anjaananjaan5107
      @anjaananjaan5107 Před rokem +2

      You should also try to know how and why problem happened? If a country starts a war and its citizens struggle, their country should get the blame

    • @ashiabbas7756
      @ashiabbas7756 Před rokem

      @@farhanathar2256 ok

  • @alirasheed3474
    @alirasheed3474 Před 3 lety +267

    Man you are going to change the dynamics of Pakistani youtube...hats off to you!!!

    • @vidhushekhar17
      @vidhushekhar17 Před rokem

      WE WILL CREATE KHALISTAN IN 😝🤗 C A N A D A. 😁😝
      SIKHS, MUSLIMS, CHRISTIANS, PARSIS AND JEWS, JAINS AND BUDDHISTS ARE H A P P Y IN INDIA AND ARE FLOURISHING. THEY BECOME MEGA-STARS, PRESIDENTS OF INDIA, CHIEF JUSTICE, LEADERS AND WHAT NOT. OF COURSE WE WILL PROVIDE ASSISTANCE TO THE BALOCH PEOPLE, TO THE PASHTUNS, TO THE KASHMIRIS OF THE PoK, THE SINDHI COMMUNITY OF PAKISTAN, THE UIGHUR MUSLIMS OF CHINA.

    • @KhalidKamalReasonbeforepassion
      @KhalidKamalReasonbeforepassion Před rokem

      It is typical of older adults, you can't remember what you had for breakfast, but stories from 30 years ago are detailed and clear.

  • @supersonicbasugmail
    @supersonicbasugmail Před 2 lety +15

    This has been a brilliant podcast. You usually get an "Indian" or a "Pakistani" perspective in books. But someone who lived through it, amazing man !

  • @madheeaafroz2920
    @madheeaafroz2920 Před 9 měsíci +1

    This podcast is close to my heart after Dada(grandfather) I listened this whole story in same accent and way that my Dada used to tell that how they struggled and migrated Karachi

  • @hamzaiqbal2163
    @hamzaiqbal2163 Před 3 lety +85

    Please make more podcasts like this. We need to preserve the history and only few people from that generation are left.

  • @fasihaimran8545
    @fasihaimran8545 Před 3 lety +56

    A refresher conversation. Today's life problems are far less than the hardships faced by our elders in those times.

  • @imranghafoor939
    @imranghafoor939 Před 2 lety +252

    My father was in Dhakka(East Pakistan) at the time of Dhakka fall. He was Lt. Col and after the Pakistani forces surrendered to India he was shifted to Agra jail where he remained captivated for 2 years. Afterwards he was shifted to Diolali where he remained for another 6 months before he along with thousands of Pakistani army forces were released in April 1974. I was born in 1972 and was almost 2 years old when I first saw my father. Now my father is in Lahore; is almost 94 years of age

    • @beforetest7211
      @beforetest7211 Před rokem +25

      tu mazak kar rha hai na 😂

    • @FashionSuggestions2
      @FashionSuggestions2 Před rokem +12

      I wonder why war veterans of '71 serving in East Pakistan never told their side of story. My uncle was in Chittagong in '71

    • @fuadahmed5501
      @fuadahmed5501 Před rokem

      Did your dad take part in war crimes against Bengalis?

    • @India-hc2hu
      @India-hc2hu Před rokem +53

      From hindustan
      Abbajan india jail me , bachcha ho gaya udhar Pakistan me .... Waah

    • @JeetuKumarYadav-ow8jq
      @JeetuKumarYadav-ow8jq Před rokem +49

      @@India-hc2hu Aisa mat bolo sb Allah (Maulana) ka Karishma hai😅

  • @AverageDriver180
    @AverageDriver180 Před rokem +6

    my eyes teared up when he said " Apny Mulq Ki Qadar Bahar Dhakky Khaany K Bad Ati Hai" hes truely a wonderful soul

  • @mehrshahzadkhan
    @mehrshahzadkhan Před 3 lety +410

    I want more podacsts like these. Bring people who have either witnessed the migration or known people who had and all those stories

    • @wasifalimughal8105
      @wasifalimughal8105 Před 3 lety

      Yes agree

    • @farhanathar2256
      @farhanathar2256 Před 2 lety +2

      These people are real gems who tell real stories of our history and help youth to understand what this country means.

    • @farhanathar2256
      @farhanathar2256 Před 2 lety +2

      Migration stories are really emotional if you hear, one can't help but go into deep love with this country. 🇵🇰
      Sacrifices didn't happen for nothing..

    • @umer.on.youtube
      @umer.on.youtube Před 2 lety

      @@farhanathar2256 True.

    • @MuhammadIrfan-nx5ii
      @MuhammadIrfan-nx5ii Před 2 lety

      desi informer

  • @farazmalik1940
    @farazmalik1940 Před 3 lety +114

    His line saying "Apny Mulq Ki Qadar Bahar Dhakky Khaany K Bad Ati Hai" made me realize how hard the situations would be for our labourers who're working outside Pakistan. May Allah SWT make things easier for them.

    • @Hamza-fr1gj
      @Hamza-fr1gj Před 3 lety +5

      Bro you never know how we feel about our Pakistan... not saying that I didnt love my country during the time I spent in country but mulk ki qada Pakistan se bahir ee hoti he...
      They say overseas earn a lot and maze ee maze hain but they never realise we earn by working our arses of here... if most of Pakistanis who rely on their family members outside worked back in Pakistan they would earn as much..

    • @farazmalik1940
      @farazmalik1940 Před 3 lety +2

      @@Hamza-fr1gj More power to you sirrrrrr

    • @aliakbar3983
      @aliakbar3983 Před 3 lety +1

      Ameen ❤️

    • @neepabanerjee17
      @neepabanerjee17 Před rokem

      Brother, please write the full form of SWT.

    • @firstsparkle5378
      @firstsparkle5378 Před rokem +4

      Bilkul.... Bangaliyo ne to pahle Dhakke v khaye, Fir Genocide v survive kiya, Fir Apna khud ka mulk bnaya

  • @krushnakulkarni
    @krushnakulkarni Před rokem +5

    What a sensible youtuber, never interrupting at wrong times, intervening when need, asking correct questions, great job Muzamil !

  • @Rishi.N.Mathur
    @Rishi.N.Mathur Před rokem +3

    Such a simple and beautiful human being ...Love from Delhi 🇮🇳

  • @hamzaiqbal2163
    @hamzaiqbal2163 Před 3 lety +52

    New generation should listen to this podcast. Just realise the blessing of your own land where you can proudly walk.

  • @shahnaseebb6175
    @shahnaseebb6175 Před 3 lety +20

    Thank you so much, Muzammil. I have met plenty of people who survived 1971, and their stories are extremely heartbreaking. I am so impressed and greatful to you to bring forward these stories; which goes against the proclaimed narrative of 1971 on the internet.

  • @wanderingfeather5789
    @wanderingfeather5789 Před 2 lety +13

    My father was also in prisoners when Dhaka fall happened, he was just new in army and they sent him to East Pakistan due to pre war situation. He been there for 3-4 years and when he got back, they not carried him in army for more tenure as it happened to all army prisoners.
    Thanks for this noble man for such amazing discussion.

    • @Maverick-zo4kc
      @Maverick-zo4kc Před rokem +1

      Pakistan army committed genocide of Bengalis, especially Bengali Hindus, in erstwhile East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) in 1971.....3 million Bengalis were brutally murdered by Pakistan army.....Shameful and outrageous

  • @abhisheksharma2036
    @abhisheksharma2036 Před rokem +10

    Huge respect to indian army who protect citizens from such brutal atrocities . As we say humanity always prevails .

    • @abhisheksharma2036
      @abhisheksharma2036 Před rokem

      @user-be6pi9vb5p ye apne pak army wala chij hm pr na thopo jhan government hi army chalati hai aur elected pm ko hata ke jail me dal diy a jata hai koi pm ka nam btao pak ka jisne hal filhal me apna full term complete kiya ho indian army is great and always be 🙌

    • @fouziamaqbool8959
      @fouziamaqbool8959 Před 10 měsíci

      And now your army is brutal to the citizins of india

  • @tahreemfatima5015
    @tahreemfatima5015 Před 3 lety +29

    Mere dada bhi esa hi andaaz e bayaan rakhte the. Un ki yaad agayi💔l

    • @ghausvlogs5553
      @ghausvlogs5553 Před 3 lety

      hey if you love vlogs then have a look on my content as well.

  • @kimstarlet1114
    @kimstarlet1114 Před 3 lety +28

    It's an honour to be able to witness and listen to someone who survived 1971 war and how things were back then. We read in history but having someone who experienced all of it is just phenomenal and extraordinary in itself. Thank you for doing this. This has been the most precious and golden podcast. Allah Pak may bestow him with the best of health and happiness. He is our true hero to survive such harsh conditions and stay hopeful till the very end. Such remarkable journey it was. Thanks alot for sharing this with the world.

  • @Rishi.N.Mathur
    @Rishi.N.Mathur Před rokem +19

    As an 🇮🇳 I can only appreciate your efforts to bring such people and stories to us ...God bless you

    • @samitmathur007
      @samitmathur007 Před rokem

      Whatever comes out of this oldies mouth is bs... Yet another wave of good times coming their way....
      Enjoy... Because you are worth shit and nothing else!!

  • @khalidabbasi5292
    @khalidabbasi5292 Před rokem +6

    My father was also prisoner of war in India after 71. He was also kept in Meerut Camp. I wonder if they were together.. Most fascinating interview.

    • @danish5244
      @danish5244 Před 11 měsíci

      How did Indians treat him in the camp

  • @coldshlder
    @coldshlder Před 3 lety +35

    Incredible witness accounts of the horrible atrocities within South Asia. Younger south asian generations should listen to the painful history and try not to repeat these events.

  • @ars1an891
    @ars1an891 Před 3 lety +7

    This was moving. Thank you Muzamil for being a great host, not interrupting and keeping everything in a natural flow.

  • @ravikumarsribhashyam8846
    @ravikumarsribhashyam8846 Před rokem +10

    Two points I noticed particularly. One, at the verge of being massacred by Mukthi Bahini, the Indian Army saved this man. The second this man has noticed trunk loads of money with some Pakistan army jawans. Just see the difference now and realize and respect other religions followers, other country people of different language and culture.

  • @hammadali9627
    @hammadali9627 Před 3 lety +71

    My family Migrated from Nawab shah (Mashriqi Pakistan) in 1971, losing everything they had .. and now when I listen people saying to me why you guys came to Pakistan you are bengali's , you guys aren't true Pakistani etc etc , it really hurts ...My great grand parents spent their Half of life here( In maghribi Pakistan, present Pakistan) my Grand parents spent their youth here my father and mother were born here, I was born here (in Pakistan) and still people say we aren't really Pakistanis ..

    • @xyz-fq5nm
      @xyz-fq5nm Před 3 lety +21

      U r more Pakistani then all of us.

    • @hammadali9627
      @hammadali9627 Před 3 lety +7

      @@xyz-fq5nm Thanks a lot ❤️

    • @xyz-fq5nm
      @xyz-fq5nm Před 3 lety +11

      @@hammadali9627 u aren't supposed to thank for it. Honestly as a nation we had made way too many mistakes. I really apologize for any such thing that you or your family had to grow through.. We really need to teach the real history to our people. We have to learn from our mistakes that's the only way.

    • @hindukushkhankhan5724
      @hindukushkhankhan5724 Před 2 lety +4

      We love u. You r true Pakistani

    • @maeoxys9336
      @maeoxys9336 Před 2 lety +1

      Aisay logon ko L pay charra

  • @Danielbuffon
    @Danielbuffon Před 3 lety +26

    literally, his story gave me shivers, imagining how hard the situation was. we are glad to hear this story. keep it up muzamil.

    • @narayansaini719
      @narayansaini719 Před 2 lety +4

      They were given Proper Barracks, Good Food and Regular Money by Indian Army.
      Can you Admire That Treatment given by Indian Army to Your POW's

    • @hassantech1862
      @hassantech1862 Před rokem +1

      @@narayansaini719 f*** India and there Army We love our Country Pakistan

  • @sariakhan9011
    @sariakhan9011 Před 3 lety +27

    Historical Conversation.Please invite more personalities to discuss about history which is great asset of our country.

    • @ghausvlogs5553
      @ghausvlogs5553 Před 3 lety

      hey if you love vlogs then have a look on my content as well.

    • @amita8526
      @amita8526 Před 3 lety +1

      ur history is nort more than 70 years LMAOO

    • @XtremeFun
      @XtremeFun Před 3 lety +8

      @@amita8526 please spread this dirt under indian videos. RSS terrorists in the comment section will not be appreciated

    • @amita8526
      @amita8526 Před 3 lety

      @@XtremeFun thats why u guys are stipped naked at airport lmaooo

    • @mubeeniqbal2455
      @mubeeniqbal2455 Před 2 lety

      @@XtremeFun 😂😂😂

  • @user-by7kl6dm3q
    @user-by7kl6dm3q Před rokem +4

    मैं हमेशा से यह आंखो देखें हालात सुनना चाहता था।
    धन्यवाद।। जय हिन्द।।

  • @nilofer60
    @nilofer60 Před 3 lety +6

    I've said this before and I'll say it again....you have the best guests on your podcast. Loved hearing his story. Please bring more people like him. We all need to hear these stories first hand. Thank you once again.

  • @aleemriaz709
    @aleemriaz709 Před 3 lety +8

    i have been following you for as long as i can remember, and you have always felt like a elder brother i never had. I had to leave instagram due to some personal reasons and i was really sad about not being able to follow you. I was extreamely overjoyed to hear about this podcast. It was everything i ever wanted. i have been watching and hearing every podcast since. And thoroughly loved each and every second of it.
    This is my first comment on it, because i wanted to emphasize how amazing this was. i cried through out the podcast and loved every second of it. and THIS IS WHAT WE WANT. The heroes that dont get the followers or likes but deserve something more then that, our admiration.
    JazakAllah khairan kaseerah for existing akhi. May the Almighty always protect you.

  • @sadabmuntasir9535
    @sadabmuntasir9535 Před 3 lety +124

    I'm Bangladeshi. I don't know actually what happened that time, this story true or false and even I not gonna judge any of you. A very famous Bangladeshi writer name Syed Mujtaba Ali wrote in his book 'Bangladesh' after this incident ('71) "Everyone has their own story, A man, woman, boy-girl military man, Aam Aadmi, even 2years old babies also, everyone's". everyone wants to tell but they couldn't. And I personally love to listen to this kind of conversation. Their stories journey, struggle, hustle, and survival. Thank you Farhad Sahab make it happen, and also Muzamil Hasan sir. Huge respect to both of you.

    • @tanikhan1821
      @tanikhan1821 Před 3 lety +17

      Thank you for being open-minded and listening to a different perspective instead of falling for Indian propaganda only

    • @comefly101
      @comefly101 Před 3 lety

      True

    • @gamecinema3606
      @gamecinema3606 Před 3 lety

      ❤️ Right bro

    • @TheSoulja99boy
      @TheSoulja99boy Před 3 lety +33

      ​@@tanikhan1821 Stop Pakistani propaganda then expect us to believe you lmao

    • @olkia4
      @olkia4 Před 2 lety +7

      salam brother, we might not be present at that time but one thing we can do is pray Allah to give us "baseerat" the insight and use common sense as well as facts instead of hate and prejudice, I, as a Pakistani curse and disconnect myself from any general, politician or bureaucrat who was responsible for a single atrocity against any civilian. There were only 35000 Pakistani soldiers in east Pakistan surrounded by 5 crore Bengalis and Indian army, how on earth can 35000 Pakistanis do what Indian/Bengali media claim

  • @prakash7255
    @prakash7255 Před rokem +79

    After 2 year I'm watching this podcast, as an Indian it is interesting to listen him, first time I knew that apart from 90000 soldies there were some civilion also who were hostage.

    • @gamingwithsmilyt
      @gamingwithsmilyt Před rokem +9

      No the army was only 20000 others were policemen, guards and workers from west pakistan and bihar who were taken as pows

    • @cricket5179
      @cricket5179 Před rokem +19

      @@gamingwithsmilyt 🙂 at least 20000 teas in 1971 itself 🙂...fantastic hai na ..hai na..

    • @mikhan5191
      @mikhan5191 Před rokem

      The Pakistan army in East Pakistan, which later became Bangladesh, numbered 31,000 and they had NO Air cover and they could NOT be reinforced, so they had NO help from anybody - not even West Pakistan could help them.
      They were alone and fought bravely against 4 countries:
      Indian Army =450,000
      Bengali mukti bahini - trained & paid by India = 83,000
      USSR Soviet Union = Trained the terrorists & provided arms +ammunition +heavy weapons.
      Israel = provided India with weapons & missiles.
      So it was actually just 31,000 Pakistani Soldiers against an enemy numbering 600,000!!
      The 93K Pakistani prisoners of war included about 50k non army ppl such as police, railway workers, Bank staff, large group of West Pakistani business ppl who had moved to E. Pakistan & setup factories + families etc. Instead of sending them back separately, India included all them with the 30 K Soldiers.
      India should be ashamed of calling this a victory!
      Taking women & children & civilians as POWs then pretending they were all soldiers!!
      Above info compiled from various sources inc. Lt Gen Amjad Shuaib.

    • @laulaksiddique6160
      @laulaksiddique6160 Před rokem

      After 700 years the Hindus one a war with the help of Bengalis and the Soviets

    • @Ms-a_1
      @Ms-a_1 Před rokem +23

      ​@@gamingwithsmilytnot 20000. Army was 54000 airforce 833 navy 1386 and paramilitary 16000 and police 8000 and rest government employees and civilians. This is accepted by hamodour rahman commision. In 1972

  • @WajahatAK
    @WajahatAK Před 2 lety +3

    We have great stories but we can't make a single film on it. This man is a survivor and he is still standing still. Respect

  • @talhaiftikhar2725
    @talhaiftikhar2725 Před 3 lety +20

    Allah uncle ko sehat aur afiyat de.

  • @mmaryammehmood1062
    @mmaryammehmood1062 Před 3 lety +6

    Reminds me of my Dada abu May Allah grant him jannah. Yahi andaze bayan rakhty thy wo esy he waqiyt sunaty thy hmin. ❤️ This man is a true inspiration literally his words "apny mulk ka pata chalta he" makes me reminds our blessings.

  • @inshrahawan3882
    @inshrahawan3882 Před 3 lety +8

    Please make more podcasts like this one. This is history in its true essence. So much respect for Farhat Sahab and everyone else who endured hardships with him.

  • @hasnainabbasdilawar8832
    @hasnainabbasdilawar8832 Před 3 lety +29

    I love the diversity of topics covered here. Great job man!

    • @TBTGO
      @TBTGO  Před 3 lety +4

      Thank you sir

  • @TalalJaved
    @TalalJaved Před 3 lety +13

    He looks like my Nana Abu, I saw the whole podcast as if I'm watching him speaking once again as he used to tell same stories. May his soul Rest in Peace. More power to you to bring this podcast for us.

  • @SuperTipu10
    @SuperTipu10 Před 3 lety +23

    This man said the truth we Pakistanis refuse to accept. It was our injustice that made the Bengalis hate us and deserved to throw us out of your homeland. And India only helped them in the process.

    • @itsmee6663
      @itsmee6663 Před 3 lety +2

      Muhktibani ne bihari or westpakistanis k sath bi bhot zulm kya tha ye ek civil war thi

    • @Mira-pm3ni
      @Mira-pm3ni Před rokem +5

      ​@@itsmee6663 civil war tha but kyun tha yeh bhi toh socho .

    • @Faiz_Editz123
      @Faiz_Editz123 Před 8 měsíci

      Tf yiu saying? There is limited proof of the ridiculous exaggerated claims by bengakis and indians.

    • @godseguy
      @godseguy Před 4 měsíci

      @@itsmee6663 Don't be a blind. Muktibahini was formed in march 1971 when Pakistan Army started "The Operation Searchlight." The atrocities that the Pakistan Army and West Pakistani politicians committed from 47 to 71 worked as a fuel to form Muktibahini.

  • @mohammadminhaj3446
    @mohammadminhaj3446 Před 3 lety +2

    This was wonderful to watch. Thank you for inviting him and please do invite more people like him who have witnessed our past. This is needed.

  • @sehrishali7458
    @sehrishali7458 Před 2 lety +21

    i cried with him :((( what a wonderful podcast it was. need more like these!!

    • @VivekYadav-uw5ls
      @VivekYadav-uw5ls Před rokem

      Same happen to us in kashmir

    • @Loading........Dr.
      @Loading........Dr. Před rokem

      @@VivekYadav-uw5ls what happened

    • @VivekYadav-uw5ls
      @VivekYadav-uw5ls Před rokem

      @@Loading........Dr. horrors of seeing killing of relatives. when get targeted. Cursed .Not able to protect your family. Life becomes a misery.

    • @VivekYadav-uw5ls
      @VivekYadav-uw5ls Před rokem

      @@Loading........Dr. you just want to leave that place

    • @piyushjaiswal9283
      @piyushjaiswal9283 Před rokem

      Cry for the millions of Bengali women they *aped for years in military camps.

  • @honeybee5740
    @honeybee5740 Před 3 lety +16

    Literally , this is the first podcast that i listened with full interest 😊🇵🇰💚

  • @adeeelamasood6946
    @adeeelamasood6946 Před 3 lety +39

    Hi muzammil bhai . I just want to thank you. Honestly you are like an elder brother who through his podcasts has taught so many important lessons and you have changed my perspective of life. Same goes for Humna api's podcasts. I don't have elder siblings but honestly you both are playing that role by guiding teenagers like me through your podcasts and giving our confused minds a direction .My mom and I listen to your and hamna api's podcasts on our commute to college. I know you don't have the number of subscribers which you actually deserve but please never stop making quality podcasts like this. You have set a benchmark for other Pakistani podcast makers. Thank you so much. May Allah bless you.Keep producing amazing content and keep bringing amazing people to your podcasts.
    -Regards,
    A teenager who will one day owe Muzammil bhai the credit of her success.

    • @ayeshashah5256
      @ayeshashah5256 Před 3 lety +3

      Love tjem both to bits💯💯🥺❤️❤️ my favourite part of the day is watching their stories on ig😍❤️

  • @prasannachitnis892
    @prasannachitnis892 Před rokem +5

    One of my relations retd.Late Brig.Wadke ( Maratha Light Infantry) was in Sylhet sector during the 1971 war.Proud of our Indian Army.🇮🇳👍🇮🇳👍🇮🇳👍🇮🇳👍🇮🇳

  • @pravatsingh2819
    @pravatsingh2819 Před rokem +10

    Good episode, nice guest and anchor. Sam Manekshaw the General of Indian Army assured the Prisoners of War and instructed his officers to deal with them in proper manner. So he was loved by Pakistan soldiers at that time. Even during Kargil war one Capt of Pak Army was honoured when One Indian Army officer told his counter part to honour him for his bravery.

    • @irshadmdkhan9384
      @irshadmdkhan9384 Před rokem +2

      In Quran almighty all told,if you deliver justice you will be remain,if you deny justice you will be finished,Bengali Muslim having majority if they are given thier right as prime minister whole Pakistan will exist,but West Pakistani be minority in parliament feel superior Bangla muslim inferior to him this is main reason Pakistan split new Bangla Desh appear, Is there Punjabi sindhi,pakhtoon and baluch are superior muslim to Bengali Muslim?pak Army responsible for destroying Pakistan.

  • @Rustyeze
    @Rustyeze Před 3 lety +6

    This episode of podcast is golden, history and struggle and much more , recommended everyone to watch and learn how country is important and what true independence meant

  • @RakshitSharma207
    @RakshitSharma207 Před rokem +51

    Proud of #INDIAN ARMY… ❤. we fight for Truth we fight for Humanity irrespective of caste creed colour and which religion you follow….❤ MAZHAB NAHI SIKHATA APAS MA BEER RAKHNA HINDI HA HAM VATAN HA SARE JHA SE ACHA HINDUSTA HMARA… jai hind….

    • @akhtarshahbaz6951
      @akhtarshahbaz6951 Před rokem

      Indians are voltures
      Dont forget muslims ruled india for 700 years .
      Hindu has no history of being worriors or fighters .

    • @healthylife1112
      @healthylife1112 Před rokem +1

      Vande mataram

    • @fouziamaqbool8959
      @fouziamaqbool8959 Před 10 měsíci

      And what do you think about crimes in kashmir and naga land by your army ?

  • @law99channel
    @law99channel Před rokem +1

    Chacha Ji may you blessed with Good health....🙏

  • @mominatanvir9122
    @mominatanvir9122 Před 3 lety +16

    What an incredible story.
    Your selection of guests and questions are fantastic, Muzammil. Great work, team TBT! 👌

    • @TBTGO
      @TBTGO  Před 3 lety +3

      Thank you so much!

    • @Maverick-zo4kc
      @Maverick-zo4kc Před rokem +1

      Pakistan army committed genocide of Bengalis, especially Bengali Hindus, in erstwhile East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) in 1971.....3 million Bengalis were brutally murdered by Pakistan army.....Shameful and outrageous

  • @RazV6
    @RazV6 Před 3 lety +10

    Bless him. He mentioned Thandi Sarak in Hyderabad and that place made me remember my childhood. Thanks for this podcast, emotions were high in this one

  • @hamzainayatbarlas1918
    @hamzainayatbarlas1918 Před 3 lety +4

    This guy is full of positivity and gratitude

  • @saimakhalid8156
    @saimakhalid8156 Před 3 lety +15

    Aoa, Muzammil one of our uncle experienced the partition. He came from India. If u are interested . You can call him and he can share precious moments and history of Pakistan.

    • @Maverick-zo4kc
      @Maverick-zo4kc Před rokem +2

      Pakistan army committed genocide of Bengalis, especially Bengali Hindus, in erstwhile East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) in 1971.....3 million Bengalis were brutally murdered by Pakistan army.....Shameful and outrageous

  • @faizahmed6068
    @faizahmed6068 Před 2 lety +3

    Everybody is talking about how insightful the words of the guest are; but nobody seems to have noticed how attentively is Muzammil listens to his guests without interrupting them. We should all aspire to be like Muzammil. Kudos bro!

  • @adilali5334
    @adilali5334 Před 3 lety +7

    Farhat Hussein you are an inspiration.

  • @ahmad-masroor
    @ahmad-masroor Před 3 lety +14

    30:14 :'( made me cry

  • @aleexious2466
    @aleexious2466 Před 2 lety +4

    Such a decent selection of guests.
    Hats off to you Sir Muzamil.
    We can't thank you for what you are giving us.

  • @harismoin3433
    @harismoin3433 Před 3 lety +6

    I always enjoy the company of old people, there's always so much to learn from their experiences. Looking forward to more podcasts like this.

  • @hinanazli7264
    @hinanazli7264 Před 3 lety +5

    My Dada Abu used to tell stories like this... Ya dahkte Hoye Laga Jase vohi behte hon...
    Sub say achi baat Kay Unko baat Kehne Ka Pora Moqa Diya...Host nay Bhut ache say suna... Interruption nahi aii baat may👍👍👍...
    Make more podcast like this...

  • @WaleedRajput1
    @WaleedRajput1 Před 3 lety +24

    your respect getting higher .. love from Hyderabad

  • @khalidhussain8584
    @khalidhussain8584 Před rokem +2

    This Baba ji has very good memory, he relayed his experience to us so wonderfully, what a great man! Subhaan Allah!

  • @abdullahanwer3075
    @abdullahanwer3075 Před 3 lety +7

    I can't explain the impact of this episode. It's awesome.
    Keep em coming 😁

  • @furqan8000
    @furqan8000 Před 3 lety +15

    Muzamil bhai you need to get someone who experienced 1947 partition. They are very few now and we should preserve their stories. Btw amazing work, i eagerly follow your content

  • @emanguftar2761
    @emanguftar2761 Před 3 lety +71

    I literally cried while listening to this podcast!! Every episode of these podcasts always teaches us something new! Muzamil Sir what you are doing is highly commendable! Just Wow! Keep making such content Sir ! May Allah bless you Ameen.

    • @TBTGO
      @TBTGO  Před 3 lety +13

      Thank you so much ma’am!

    • @Maverick-zo4kc
      @Maverick-zo4kc Před rokem +7

      Pakistan army committed genocide of Bengalis, especially Bengali Hindus, in erstwhile East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) in 1971.....3 million Bengalis were brutally murdered by Pakistan army.....Shameful and outrageous

    • @adityashah1353
      @adityashah1353 Před rokem

      Yeah you should cry because you (pakistani) are the perpetrators here.

    • @rajvanshsingh8165
      @rajvanshsingh8165 Před 11 měsíci

      Kash un lakho Bengali aurto ka rape inke sathiyo ne kiya uske bat bhi karta ye bhudda agar mere galat lag rahe ho to me sabut deta hu... Tumhari army...army nahi ha ek cartel ha jo apne khud se mtlb rakte ha

  • @mohammadshamsi548
    @mohammadshamsi548 Před rokem +1

    Excellent interview which drove me down back in 70s. This is a live history. My beloved Farhat Hussain has faced lots of problems but he showed nothing against the players behind this episode. It is his greatness. May Allah (swt) grant him maximum reward of his patience against all his difficulties and pains he faced. Ameen

  • @AshishSharma-sd8fn
    @AshishSharma-sd8fn Před rokem +4

    That's why everyone loves our Indian Army💕❤. Enemies praise Indian army.

  • @tauqeerhassan8091
    @tauqeerhassan8091 Před 2 lety +4

    I loved this one particularly. I think there can be a whole series on history with seniors like him.

  • @tayabairfan7449
    @tayabairfan7449 Před 2 lety +6

    The best podcast till now. Plz invite more guests like him. ❣️❣️❣️

  • @muhammadnouman3990
    @muhammadnouman3990 Před 2 lety +10

    This literally reminded me of my grand father :( , He fought 1965 & 1971 , and I don't know why but this respected person is telling story exactly like my grandfather, I'm feeling that this is my grandfather sitting in front of me :( , Alas! We ruined our country :'(

    • @Maverick-zo4kc
      @Maverick-zo4kc Před rokem +7

      Pakistan army committed genocide of Bengalis, especially Bengali Hindus, in erstwhile East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) in 1971.....3 million Bengalis were brutally murdered by Pakistan army.....Shameful and outrageous

    • @smilefaceofbengal
      @smilefaceofbengal Před rokem

      yes , Pakistan army destroyed Pakistan.

  • @shariqbawa4643
    @shariqbawa4643 Před 2 lety +2

    Muzammil bhai we are so proud to have you! May Allah always keep you and your loved ones happy. Ameen

  • @adilali5334
    @adilali5334 Před 3 lety +4

    Love & Respect for Sir Farhat Hussein.

  • @Ans_aka_Inzi1073
    @Ans_aka_Inzi1073 Před rokem +4

    Truly a special episode... Such versions of history are always rare to find 💯

  • @farooqazam9124
    @farooqazam9124 Před 3 lety +4

    We want more podcasts like these, Loved it! 👌🏼❤️

  • @sheikhumer7873
    @sheikhumer7873 Před 3 lety +31

    Pakistan is blessings with all negatives we have to work for the improvement of the society. We need to unite the country 🇵🇰❤️
    I cried while watching it. 💔

    • @farhanathar2256
      @farhanathar2256 Před 2 lety +1

      Great. That you got the gist of the program. I hope our other young ones also get the same feeling after listening to this brilliant podcast

  • @yamnafarrukh2815
    @yamnafarrukh2815 Před 3 lety +6

    MashAllah MashAllah❤️ DADA ABU Allah pak aap ko sehat, tandrusti dain or aap ka saaya hum sab par yunhien salaatmat rakheien.
    AMEEN

  • @XtremeFun
    @XtremeFun Před 3 lety +6

    Such a great podcast, no words. It would be extra ordinary if you could get any military person during the war in a podcast

  • @muhammadamjadqasim7505

    بہترین انٹرویو پروگرام 👌👍
    یہ autoplay پر چینل خود ہی play ہو گیا
    میں یہ skip کرنے ہی والا تھا
    لیکن 2 منٹ، انٹرویو سُن لیا تو بہت انٹرسٹنگ لگا
    رات 3:30 بھے سے یہ پروگرام پورا سنا/دیکھا
    تایا صاحب کی سچی کھری باتیں بہت ہی بہترین لگیں ♥️
    اللہ تعالیٰ، اِنکو لمبی اور صحت والی زندگی عطا فرمائے آمین

  • @ianonymous8753
    @ianonymous8753 Před 2 lety +5

    Please bring more stories like this. You are doing a wonderful job my friend. 🙌

  • @victordashmohapatra3546
    @victordashmohapatra3546 Před rokem +5

    as an Indian we seek forgiveness for inconvenience and hardship of civilians who got struck between two armies, our intentions were to save lives be it Indian, Bangladeshi or Pakistani

    • @trilokyamohanchakra6351
      @trilokyamohanchakra6351 Před 5 měsíci

      Wtf? Have some shame before asking for forgiveness for a favor we did to them for the sale of humanity

  • @shahsaljan
    @shahsaljan Před rokem +1

    What a beautiful thing I have listened on the start of the New Year, can't thank you enough for putting up this gem, I always search for the real side of the story. Thank you so much for finding such a beautiful person. Love to see another sitting with him, I am sure he has many wonderful experiences to share if someone scratches his memory. He got so much to deliver to the youth that we need. I again Thank you for this.

  • @ehsanullah3931
    @ehsanullah3931 Před 2 lety +2

    Such a raw story. uncensored story, directly from bottom of heart to someone of experienced it at first hand.

  • @hafsakhan6912
    @hafsakhan6912 Před 3 lety +5

    Such an informative podcast 👍
    Also, The way you were respectful, towards him and his views, deserves appreciation.
    Both of you are assets to the country 🖤

  • @smiles4you142
    @smiles4you142 Před 3 lety +3

    Mujhe ahsaas ho rha hai ke hum apne mulk ko kitna for granted lete hai! Azaadi bohat bari naimat hai! Allah humare mulk ko taraqi de aur Humain iss mulk ki behtari ke liye kuch Acha karne ki tofeeq de! 💓

  • @kailasphanashikar8587
    @kailasphanashikar8587 Před rokem +1

    Loved simplicity in presentation. No flashy lights, effects, music etc. still effective.
    Each human being has some story to tell. I think Muzamil has done a great job recording one of such stories.

  • @fatoomaiqbal5159
    @fatoomaiqbal5159 Před 3 lety +8

    He is a legend ♥️♥️ loved every bit of this podcast.

  • @zainaliamin3491
    @zainaliamin3491 Před 3 lety +4

    This was the best podcast on your channel, Loved it!

  • @nuhankhan2394
    @nuhankhan2394 Před rokem +3

    Being a Bangladeshi, it also reminded us of the struggles of civilians during a war..... wonderful story .....

    • @devildevil8304
      @devildevil8304 Před rokem

      Being a Bangladeshi your mom was fucked by this Abbuu…

  • @usmanazam4662
    @usmanazam4662 Před 2 lety +2

    At the time it aired,, didn't really hear it through but today got the opportunity to listen it thoroughly and it was quite enlightening, inspiring yet horrifying listening to the struggles he had to go throughout his life and how they coped with it all. Also, the point he raised about realizing the importance of living in a free independent country.

  • @ishratbinteshams2445
    @ishratbinteshams2445 Před rokem +2

    Look how good is Indian army. Give them ration. Salute Indian army from Bangladesh

  • @islooboyrashid5927
    @islooboyrashid5927 Před 3 lety +4

    This is the best Pod you've ever done Muzamil. should do such pods more often

  • @abrarahmad1733
    @abrarahmad1733 Před 3 lety +5

    Loved it. Your podcasts are miles ahead of other CZcamsrs

  • @foxtrotalpha58
    @foxtrotalpha58 Před 2 lety +2

    This was a good effort. Really appreciate it.
    May I suggest more such interviews of elders who survived partition, wars.

  • @sabasiddiqui429
    @sabasiddiqui429 Před 2 lety +4

    It was really amazing to hear someone's experience of the 1971 war. But it's so surprising that even though Seth Abid kidnapped Benazir Bhutto and smuggled gold Farhat sir addresses him as a 'nek aadmi'.

  • @deputation006
    @deputation006 Před 3 lety +4

    I literally cried and realized we have seen nothing, especially young generation. Muzamil do call people who can share such stories.