Did Salam Plagiarise Glashow
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 06. 2024
- Dr. Taimur Rahman shows from the original papers and other sources that Dr. Abdus Salam did not copy Sheldon Glashow. In fact, in his 1979 acceptance speech of the Nobel Physics Prize, Sheldon Glashow himself acknowledged the unique and key contribution of Dr. Abdus Salam.
A person with Netherlands citizenship is misleading Pakistani youth, where Dr. Salam died as a proud Pakistani. Dr. Taimur, thanks for sharing your rational thoughts. ❤
Absolutely correct…mouthpiece of mullahs is the one who is spreading nonsensical controversies about Salam sahib..for this Netherland ka mullahs…ahmediya is not a Muslim,therefore this heartburn…
He gave up his Pakistani nationality for Netherlands. This shows how loyal these people are.
He is the most biased person on the internet, appealing to the anti-Ahmadi authority. All his content however is empty and devoid of any rationality.
Kon?
Would you like to share authentic reference?
Nobel prize committee is not Pakistani politics nor Pakistani judiciary, they do not make decision without any thorough consideration.
like Malala... 😂
Hahaha anyone with this weak level of knowledge shouldn't be allowed to comment😂
Go read, there're prominent examples of their failures where they r proven even worse than paki politics.
(And btw Muslims are not saying or exposing them, their own people r doing).
No the peace prize is awarded by the Norwegian nobel committee. All other Nobel prices are awarded by the Swedish science academy. Witch is among the oldest and most competent in the world.
آپ نے سچ کو آشکارا کردیا وَقُلْ جَاءَ الْحَقُّ وَزَهَقَ الْبَاطِلُ ۚ إِنَّ الْبَاطِلَ كَانَ زَهُوقًا
آپ کی پوری ویڈیو میں نے بھرپور توجہ سے دیکھی اور سنی ہے۔ ماشاء اللہ، بے حد مدلل اور سنجیدہ انداز اختیار کیا ہے۔ آپ اور ڈاکٹر رحمان کی ویڈیوز دیکھ کر دلی اطمینان ہوا کہ ہمارے (ماہنامہ گلوبل سائنس کے) بعد سائنس کا یہ کارواں آگے بڑھانے کے لیے سنجیدہ فکر احباب موجود ہیں۔
Thank you.
Sir ap Qaisser sahab ka bhi jawab dain unki video k comments main. Thanks
@@abraizahmedkyun dein jawab video KY comments mein? Jab poori video bana di hai to ab Raja NY jawab Dena hai
@@Taimur_Laal راجہ پِدّ ی
راجہ پِدّ ی 🐧
What a rebuttal.... Thank you for sharing this much needed video, Sir ❤
Thankyou Dr sahib for the rebuttals. It’s a brave effort. Unfortunately all sense is lost when we deal with hatred.. and prejudice.
زہرِ تعصبات نے اندھا ہی کر دیا
اپنے ہی جاۓ فخر کو بیگانہ کر دیا
مسمار کر کے رکھ دی عمارت ہی عدل کی
جو تھا وطن کی شان، جلا وطن کر دیا
لیکن یہ کیا غضب ہوا ، کیسی ہوا چلی
قدرت کا ہاتھ تم کو ہی مہجور کر گیا
تم تو وطن میں رہ کے بھی گمنام ہی رہے
وہ دور بیٹھ، وطن کو مشہور کر گیا
Apne jis channel ka bataya, us k liay thanks.. We need such people to be heard, they are the experts.
بہت بہت شکریہ سر آپ نے بہت ساری غلط فہمیاں جو پتہ نہیں کیوں پھیلائی جا رہی ہیں انہیں دور کیا۔ یہ کیسی عجیب و غریب ذہنیت اور یہ کیسی مخلوق ہے کہ جسے ساری دنیا مان رہی ہے لیکن اس مخلوق کا اصرار ہے کہ پاکستان کو یہ اعزاز نہیں چاہیے۔
Thank so much dr saab, is baar hum molviyun aur un ke front man ko nai choren ge
Thank you Dr. Taimur Rahman sahib. Perhaps out of spite towards Qaisar Raja, the Imperial College London organized a conference in honor of Dr. Abdus Salam. The video has been published on the official channel of the University just 2 days before. You may watch it on CZcams channel "Imperial College London". The host says:
"I'm continually amazed by the the strength of the ongoing research in theoretical physics here and the continued pursuit of the directions that Professor Salam set by one measure. Imperial ranks in the fifth most impactful University in the world in theoretical high energy physics and that is largely due to the tradition of Excellence which Professor Salam incorporated when he set up the group in the late 1950s."
Ye video Dr Abdul Salam k khilaf Propaganda k Taboot me Akhri Keeeel hai. Jazakumullahu Khaira Taimur Sir. His belief is between him and GOD, that was his personal matter, who are we to comment or argue? We should be concerned with whatever he did for Pakistan and the International community, we should be proud of him as a Great Pakistani Scientist. If he had not been an Ahmadi and had been a Muslim like the rest, we would have focused on his contributions and achievements rather than giving importance to his beliefs. It's not like he was a religious leader or figure whose beliefs should concern us. That is a matter between him and his God
Excellent response bhaijan.
Very well articulated and expressed.
Stay blessed!
Well said Dr. Rehman. This is a sad reality of Pakistan keh jab tak yousaf youhana Muhammad yousaf nahin ban jata wo acha cricketer nahi hai.
I followed QAR on this issue and it wouldn't be wrong to say that QAR has been taken to the cleaners here. that's why its important to look at both sides of the picture.
No one is being taken to cleaners. Here, someone has put forth his point of view on the subject. You may agree with either of the two or even none.
Sir, excellent vlog
Respect and love for you
Thanks
fabulous video
I am muslim but I also admired dr abdul salam as human and also as a scientist
Ashtafirullah
The problem with religious bigotry is it makes you blind to any good from people you stand against. Only one Scientist worth of recognition Dr. Salam is being brought down just because his religious identity, precisely explains why Pakistan will never produce any Dr. Salam
Haha aj to tabahi macha di sir , great , very well articulated , I was not aware about the peer review of abdus slam , thanks for sharing this
Raja ka to Baja baj gaya hoga is video ke baad.
Chal atheist murtadeen aurat
thank u for doing this again Dr. Taimoor. May Allah Tala always bless u
افسوس۔ نفرت اور تعصب انسان کو کتنا اندھا کر سکتا ہے، اس کی تازہ مثال ہم آجکل دیکھ رہے ہیں۔ 😢
No only religion does that to everyone, all religions are man made garbage 🗑️ and anti humanity!
Nah Janai hmain kya hogya hai...
"Kisi Qoum ki Dushmani tumhain us pr zyadti pr majboor na krai"
That's why i never listen to any one who is in quest of finding Higgs Bosons in the Holy Quran.I just hate them for misusing our sacred book.God has given us minds with proper reasoning faculties and has commanded us to study understand and flourish ourselves.That's only truth we get From the Holy book.
Kia Faida ... Qaiser Raja ne phir yehi kehna h k ... "Well , i was expecting something academic" ... 😂
Gregg semenza faked his way through Nobel prize and now got ex#posed his papers were published meaning those who reviwed and the noble prize was given to a fraudster
What were you saying ?
Doctor sahib ye qaum munafiqat mein Bani Israel ko be maat dey chuki. No doubt Doctor Salam is one of the greatest scientists of the World and Pakistan should be proud of him and own him
Ahmadiyya fact check blog exposed Abdul Salam
I strongly disagree with most part of your views and ideas. But here you defended him rightly. He is Pakistani and deserves all the praise.
13:55 "meri theory ko age barhane me Salam ka kirdar tha" ofcourse but key word is "barhane me", Salam was developing and improving on someone else's work without citing that very person. This is grave in the world of the academics....
@@elprofesor8571 bhaiii aap ne nobel prize ki speech dekhi??? Us me credit diya na unho ne..
@@rjameel. Dr Salam didn't. Where did he?
@@rjameel. Dr Salam didn't give credit, do give time stamp if you think he did.
But why you disagree mostly? 😂
Is it because communism bites?
سر آپ گریٹ ہیں ۔اللہِ آپ کو اپنی امان میں رکھے
Such a shame that Qaisar sb is so biased and polarised about A Salam.
Everyone is biased dear. We just have to chose the side. Either I stand with ignorance or with knowledge and truth. In either cases I am biased.
Shouldnt use sb for him , he is a clown.
راجہ پِدّ ی 😋
This video is better than the previous one; specially the analogy of Yousuf Yuhana to Muhammad Yousuf. 👍🏻👏🏻❤🎉
I have disagreed with most of your videos and opinions, but you have defended Abdus Salam rightly. To level accusations like plagiarism are unwarranted without strong evidence like that guy did. You were right not to name him. I'm an academic, like you, so I understand the peculiarities of recommendations, peer-review, conference and journal publications
Well. Thank you for your value edition in the on going issue. Dr. Rehman made an excellent response. But I love your simple language. It makes things very clear for non-technical person. Love you ho gya Bhai g.
if you are referring to Qaisar raja (reaction queen) .... then dont worry. He was former taxi driver in UK (start posting this question to him on all his videos). And I dont know on which intellectual capacity he is black painting Dr Salam. We should celebrate his achievements (including Nobel prize) , and should not bother on his faith which is his personal matter and part of his own spiritual journey.
Most of these overseas pakistani are
I have seen people selling Islam for CZcams views, not more than QAR. He absolutely pushes his nose everywhere.
Salam was man of big heart , irrespective of pakistan's wrong treatment with Salam becoz of his religious beliefs still he claims himself Pakistani.if ever he would have born in India he would have definitely received honors like APJ kalam who became president of india but unfortunately for pakistan
Giving him medals and awards was one thing and then Giving him big authorities was another. If this is bad treatment with him then Idk what do u think is right
Raja sab k shikwa number 1: Peer review siraj ul haq , zia ul haq aor qaisar raja se kyo nai krwya.
2. Raja bhi like : me nai manta ye Glashow ki original speech ha . Ye seculars ki chal ha unho ne script Change ki thi salam didn't deserve nobel prize
Raja ki baja bajate rahe. thank a lot for debunking desi motivational speaker
13:55 "meri theory ko age barhane me Salam ka kirdar tha" ofcourse but key word is "barhane me",.... Salam was developing and improving on someone else's work without citing that very person. This is grave in the world of the academics.
Nothing motivating…only misleading gullible youths….he himself is a citizen of Netherland,but wants sharia in pak….haha
@@elprofesor8571 Science is all about progress, scientist suggest their theories and future scientists work on them, nobody can wake up with a full paper on gravitational force or a high res image of black hole, scientists collaborate and find better explanations.
@@mustafaasif4719 gaslow was alive at the time, a co winner of the Nobel prize, Salam was accused of plagiarism. And the evidence supports the accusation. Not citing is a form of plagiarising and this is grave in the world of the academics. Dr rahman himself made this clear in the previous video and if you disagree I don't know what to say to you.
Regarding the specific citation practices in scientific papers, it's important to note the following:Independent Research Contributions: Nobel Prizes often recognize independent contributions that, when combined, lead to significant advancements in a field. Salam's work was based on his own independent research, even though it was related to the work of Glashow and Weinberg.Citation Norms: The norms for citing previous work can vary. In some cases, researchers might not cite contemporaneous work if they developed their theories independently. It's also possible that Salam's work was sufficiently distinct in its approach or findings to warrant separate publication without citation.Peer Review and Recognition: The peer review process and the recognition by the Nobel Committee are thorough. If there had been a significant oversight or ethical issue with Salam's paper, it would have been noted during the review and award process.
Thank Dr taimur for explaining how scientific society operate
Dr Abdul Salam was a great scientist
Itna great nahi west ne banaya he by planning
@@AamirKhan-bh7bwI am curious...west ko kya faida hua banane ka
@@AamirKhan-bh7bw west ne q bnaya tha?? es se tou west ki mazeed be izzati hoti hai k aik aisa gareeb country se aik aam sa larka utha aur itna azeem scientist bn gya .... tum log bs unkey Ahmadi honey ki wajah se jal rahay ho aur sochtey ho k yeh nobel prize tou sirf Dr. Abdul Qadir Khan ko milna chiye tha...
@@Angel_of_Peace_93 jalta woh hai jisko ghanta farak padta hai
Tu rakh paas apni science Tera fraud science har din debunk hota hai phir tu bolega bhai yehi toh hai we are not sure but we try to knowledge that betters
Smartphone kaise kaam karta hai woh toh tumko pata nahi theory bana ke rakhi hai hai kuch
Andhere mei teer Maro uar bas bak do
13:55 "meri theory ko age barhane me Salam ka kirdar tha" ofcourse but key word is "barhane me", Salam was developing and improving on someone else's work without citing that very person. This is grave in the world of the academics......
Great analysis Dr. Sahab. You are always an inspiration.
😂😂
@@user-kj2sh4gu3b why are you laughing man. Oh i see you didn't understand what i say. Don't worry i will give free tutions. I give free tutions to madrassa chaps like you. Agar madrase ki jaga school gaye hothe to yeh nobat na athi.
@@AzizKhan-yt4xc I m laughing at your ignorance. 😂😂
Why do you think seminary people cannot do much? Curious to know!
@@user-kj2sh4gu3b you are putting a world renowned scientist in trash because of his religion and you called me an ignorant. Wow
السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ سب کو
تیمور صاحب زندہ باد آپ نے تفصیلی مضمون کا حق ادا کر دیا قادرٕ مطلق آپ سمیت ھم سب کو بہترین جزا دیں آمین
Thank you for making this. Great job 👍👍👍
SIr, Kya baat hai. Amazing talk with facts and the closing statement was too Good. Raja nu litter Pheru.
Dr Tamur. ... You dont need to make videos and defending Salam. Some people are extremely biased in their views and would make every effort to be little Dr. Salam and other non Muslims. Dr. Salam was a great scientist and proud son of Pakistan.
Food for thought, you must stop teaching Socarate in your academic life and start teaching Pakistani born Socarate (Mr QR aka Pindi boy)
Keep it up sir g we are with you you are my ideal❤
Muhammad Yousuf.. ❤ he accepted Islam and started to break national and international records . After that . His performance increased significantly and he stated that reverting to Islam is the reason for his success.. ❤
Zombie 😅
Then why he was dropped in t20 world cups despite having better avg than younis khan in both test and odi
And why he was retired earlier, he could have become the first pakistani batsman to make high runs in total.
That ia the method Pakistanis treat to newly convert muslims
@@personalentertainment3294 friend.. he could have been simply dropped because of injustice as that has happened with thousands of Muslim cricketers too.. I'm not comparing him with any one but his world records were made once he converted to Islam and no body can deny that. And he completely loved it ❤️
@@personalentertainment3294 and yes his career ended earlier because of politics and satta mafia as that has happened with few other great Muslim cricketers..
@@user-go9uj6qq3i
After accepting Islam is liye records bany kuein ke us ka mental pressure ease ho gaya.
Pakistan mein minorities ke saath kia hota ha. Woh to ab media ki waja sy highlight hota ha warna pehle bi church ko aag lagai jati thi aur christians ko bi.
Woh pressure ease ho gaya. After conersion to Islam.
Warna jo record tendulkar aur jaques kalis aur Brian Lara ke hein woh to Muslim nai.
MahshaAllah Sir Taimoor we need people like you .
Dr. Abdus Salaam does not deserve the Nobel Prize for his contribution in Physics. Rather, it was Khadim Hussain Rizvi and qaisar Ahmad Raja who deserved it. Qaisar Ahmad Raja, a famous Biologist, Chemist, Physicist, Astronaut, Mathematician, and famous Teacher, truly earned such recognition. It was a Jewish lobby that prevented these two significant brains from receiving the Nobel Prize. It's a shame for the world that these two deserving individuals have not been honored.😭😭
Sub West ka propaganda hai bhai.
Don't weep. India still weeps at the Great Division of 1947. 😃😃
Hahaha
Haha…well researched peer review by you….He deserves Noble prize for for finding flaws in atheism, democracy,secularism,humanism and proving how flawless sharia law is….
@@babaali7050 😭متفق۔۔
Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩❤❤❤ Prof. Abdus Salaam Sahib...
The real hero..
جزاکم اللہ ڈاکٹر تیمور صاحب۔۔۔ ڈاکٹر عبدالسلام ہمیشہ پاکستان کا فخر رہیں گے انشاہ اللہ ❤
Bohot aala Dr saab❤
Behtareen video hy sir.
Behtareen ❤
We love Salam.
Raja exposed
13:55 "meri theory ko age barhane me Salam ka kirdar tha" ofcourse but key word is "barhane me", Salam was developing and improving on someone else's work without citing..... that very person. This is grave in the world of the academics.
@@elprofesor8571 Science Mai is tarha Kam hota hai yeh baat tu khud raja ne apni video Mai boli hai
Thanks Taimur for the crisp n acute refutation to almost all the false accusations by AQR❤
I am thankful to Qaisar Raja. Without his bullshit, all these brilliant sane minded people might not have made these vlogs and so many people would not have known in depth about how amazing were Salam's contributions.
کی محمد سے وفا تو نے تو ہم تیرے ہیں
یہ جہاں چیز ہے کیا لوح و قلم تیرے ہیں
Concrete evidence,strong arguments.. kiya bat h.. maza aya
بہت اچھے سے آپ نے وضاحت کی ڈاکٹر صاحب ۔
I was in the same theoretical physics group at Imperial as Salam in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
Salam was also a faculty colleague of my father after their PhDs. My father did his PhD in astrophysics at Imperial College in 1949 while Abdus Salam finished his PhD at Cambridge in 1952.
I therefore knew all of Salam's colleagues, including Tom Kibble who really was responsible for local symmetry breaking in his 1967 paper and according to Weinberg. Not his own work of 1964 or that of Higgs and others in 19t4.
The real breakthrough that led to Steven Weinrberg and Salam's 1967/68 paper was Tom Kibble's paper on local symmetry breaking in 1967. Weinberg credits Tom Kibble's paper as the conceptual breakthrough, and not the simpler 1964 papers of Kibble, Peter Higgs and others.
At Imperial College therefore the Higgs boson is known as Higgs-Kibble. Weinberg is clear that it was Kibble's 1967 paper that was the real breakthrough.
Now Kibble had his office a few yards from Salam's. And every theoretical physics professor at Imperial told me Salam gave the seminar which resulted in his 1968 paper. There was 0 doubt in anybody's mind.
Norman Dombey, the professor who casts doubt was not at Imperial. He was at the University of Sussex. Despite doing a PhD under Feynman at Caltech, for some reason Norman Dombey didn't land a position at either Caltech or Imperial. Maybe be is driven by profession rivalry.
Gell-Mann is on record on CZcams as saying that even apart from electroweak Salam could have won the Nobel for at least 2 other contributions. He mentions Salam and Ward as having made outstanding contributions to theoretical particle physics. Salam was known for several contributions, while Ward is known to every researcher in Quantum Field Theory as Ward identities.
And Weinberg and many others say Tom Kibble should have won a Nobel.too.
Now I attended seminars and courses by Tom Kibble. And also David Olive and Chris Isham. And many other extremely highly regarded world class theoretical physicists. They had all been colleagues of Salam. And no one ever dubbed doubted him.
And here's more. Even amongst that group, he was looked up to. It's like the best tennis players look up to Roger Federer.
The last time I attended a seminar given by him was on the 5th floor theoretical physics common room at Imperial. It was on Chern Simons theory. There wasn't a single question because none were at his level. Even in 1990.
Gell-Mann is clear in his CZcams videos that Salam would have won the Nobel for a few other pieces of work.
By the way, I have many stories of not just Salam, but my father, and their interactions in the 1950s. Salam also told Shahid Javed Burki that if my father hadn't left academia he would have won the Nobel in his area way before he himself he did.
Incredible. Thank you for all that information
Well explained ❤
Sir love u ho gya😊
Evidence based analysis
Salam left Pakistan as he didn't comprised on this religious beliefs
and we are here defending his science work excluding his religious views... what a shame
@19:47 Frank close says in his book "The Infinity Puzzle". Salam only pushed a door that was already open.
Good 👍
It is better to add the links of Dr Rahman's videos in description and comments section, to make it more accessible
Thank you very much for your response and educated response for Intellectually dishonest Qaisar Ahmadi Raja kind of maqqar.
Great Abdul Salam ❤❤
I talked to Glashow at Harvard and he told me that Salam was the most mathematical scientist he ever met,he never indicated any discomfort about Salam,after 50 yrs,he became a turncoat?
...Prof.Dr.Nasir Fazal gold medalist Cambridge USA.
please make a video about dr abdul qadeer too
Just debate eachother man
Professor, just a quick note: you accidentally referred to physiology as psychology in your this video lecture three time at 21:03, 21:58 and 22:28. Easy mistake, but thought I'd point it out for clarity. Your lectures are always insightful, looking forward to more!
Oh right. My mistake. Thanks.
@@Taimur_Laal13:55 "meri theory ko age barhane me Salam ka kirdar tha" ofcourse but key word is "barhane me", Salam was developing and improving on someone else's work without citing that very person. This is grave in the world of the academics....
Oay yar itnay ke khair hoti hai... mera bhe hasa nikal gya tha sun k wase tu...mujh say physiology aur psychology still likhnay main mistake ho jati hai. Ab mainay likhna he chor dia. 😂
@@elprofesor8571 raised a good point. Dr. Rehman has explained the issue of citation is much detail. Please watch his video.
@@elprofesor8571 you have misunderstood what I am trying to convey. Salam 1964 was not directly responding to Glashow. He was solving the problem where Glashow and others had gotten stuck. That was the state of the physics at that time. Salam advanced it.
ماشاءاللہ ڈاکٹر صاحب
اللہ آپ کو جزا دے۔
Qaiser Raja ny booht depressed kr rakha Desi socialist or seculars ko
Dumb people are always depressing and toxic. You are right 😂😂😂😂
Thanks for the clarifications.
Dr Sahib kindly share your views about bigotry and shallow thoughts in people claiming themselves as believers.
This Abdus Salam Nobal Saga has proved 2 things.
1) He was a great scientist
2) he was a great administrator and lobbyist
Taimur sahab, thank you for making this video informing us about this topic accurately❤❤❤ , i wonder why do some people feel in our country feel so insecure of a non Muslim Pakistani to be appreciated for his contribution to Pakistan and Science ?
سر یہ تینوں پیپر ہمیں کہاں سے مل سکتے ہیں
Just google.
@@Taimur_Laal thanks sir
Dr salaam zinada baad ❤️❤️
Thanks to this controversy...we get sufficiently educated about Salam's work
Thank you Dr shahib . Your Details Article.
sir Pakistani neo 5g molvi science ko islamise karna chahty hain. wo islam ko pure religion nhi manty wo islam ko science, politics, economy, history, har jeez main dalna chahty.
A little correction:
At 22:27 you said psychology, it is actually physiology!
Yes. My mistake.
Very good SIR
Great job exposing Qaiser 👏 who's intellectually dishonest. Qaiser Raja thinks that by being intellectually dishonest he's doing islam a service. Far from it. He does superficial research with an agenda. He doesn't follow proper research methodology.
very nice saen....
Bilkul
Sorry to say sir ...these "shenanigans" were already stated by donbey and glashow endorsed it that slaam made sure tha he was mentioned everytime with Weinberg .
The question was where is that peer reviewed article of salam ?
Nobody eversaid that salam was not a theoratical physicist .
FURTHERMORE, IF 1964 PAPER WAS SUCH A BIG BREAKTHROUGH WHY DIDNT WARD WAS AWARDED WITH NOBEL ALONG WITH SALAM AS BOTH WERE THE AUTHORS OF 1964 PAPER ?
Good job brother
Excellent, like it.
Well said excellent
@13:36 glashow also only suspects that salam had read his 1961 paper, he is not sure. There is also no external evidence that salam had read glashows 1961 paper when he and ward were writing their 1964 paper.
The same is believed by the writer of "The Infinity Puzzle" frank close.
Did the people of punjab deserve that a person like Dr Abdus Salaam should be born in there area of intently, just think if he would have born in Hyderabad sindh, Gawadar Bit Shah , or khuzdar what respect would he have bagged and after his death the size of tomb would be the answer is respect,, i will not ever say that he was born in shameless people as i know that Baba bulay shah, baba farid,, gru nanank, Faiz ahmed faiz and you are born in them , what else can i day except to see Punjab hate will bring organ people back to stone age,, and than all punjabies will say that melt down if country was not the fault of educated punjabies but few fools in army who p put poets teaches in jail like farhad shah and treat him as a terrorist and price him as a terrorist by court of session judge level for this I'll say shame in the silence of rest of judges
what else can i say that it was the Bengals which paid the price and for freedom my question is how we as a Punjabi get freedom from our rotten biased society of injustice and grading of humans sure to there Belive
Pakistan "nation" was imposed on the life of people of this region. Sheer imposition!!
I commend you for not calling Economics a real award.
Nobel in Economics promotes capitalism --even under the garb of Institutionalism v. Individualism.
@@mohinderkumar7298 The economics nobel is a participation trophy. Nobody in science takes them seriously.
12:32 kya ye wala part quote hai ya phir dr taimur ki interpretation?
Psychology and Medicine nahin Taimur Sahab, Physiology and Medicine.
Yes. My mistake.
Thanks for defending Salam. Salam was such a giant that he could have got the Nobel prize alone in physics. However, it is not true that Nobel in science is not controversial.
You said that Dr salam corrected the glashow model so question is still there that why Dr Salam not cited the glashow. Bcoz in research upon correction we still cite the previous work!
Because he arrived at the point through an independent and different line of reasoning. I explained this in my video.