Rabbi Tovia Singer and Carlton McDonald Powerful Debate: Is Jesus the Promised Jewish Messiah?
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 08. 2024
- Watch Rabbi Tovia Singer's latest debate with Carlton McDonald (2019), and learn what the Jewish views on Jesus is.
Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2)
outreachjudais...
outreachjudais... www.toviasinger...
Sponsored by Yiboneh
Check out Yiboneh's archives for other great speakers:
www.yiboneh.com...
Rabbi, I came out of Mormonism at 22 years of age, and now at 39 years and 2 weeks I’m 100% out of Christianity after listening to this. I’m coming home. Baruch haba b’shem Adonai.
It's been 4 months - do you enjoy buddhism?
My friend just bless everybody never curse love your creator . only with Jesus you can get to the destination which is God.JESUS came to break the protocols so we able to win heaven.He brought Holy spirit whom is teaching us how to mature and build character . my brother have your mind on devils tricks to win your soul. Only throught Jesus.
@@andrie4384 you are lost bro learn hard
I left Mormonism at age 59 and I also left any idea of any religion being the answer, it was the hardest and best decision I ever made. I believe that their maybe a God but he or she has nothing to do with dogma or religion.
@@andrie4384 how did the holy spirit guide Ravi?
No laptop required by Rabbi Tovia Singer, just a few notes.
When the Rabbi speaks, I wakeup and my mind becomes clear.
Thank you Rabbi, it’s always a pleasure listening to you.
Are you Dutch?
It's good for the audience to keep track of all the quotes.
Yes he is eloquent, but to bad he is on the opposite side, but if you believe in the New Testament, it has been all predicted, shalom!
He's not a pastor, but he is a Rabbi, he knows a lot more than a pastor! A pastor is someone that is a charlatan, that trying to push his Goods, but a rabbi knows the true word of God
@@damirramic1154 can't believe the new testament. The tanach proves it completely false from 1000 different angles. We couldn't believe in the new testament even if we wanted to or tried. There is a reason we are still jewish and still not interested in christianity at all
I heard the first guy for like 5 minutes and I knew immediately that he was going to get schooled.
LOL
Gotta love how confident he came in though!
If I believed in something like modalism I'd say that Tovia himself is an expression of God's wrath.
When he argued that baptism and anointment are the same thing I about lost it.
😂🤣… easy there… 😂😅
After being a "Christian" for 27 years, I am being converted. The separation has not been an easy one but I can't turn back.
keep goin'
Stupid I will remain Christian, lol to tovey singer is still a boy
Good riddance
I love you Rabbi Singer. You are amazing!!! You have strengthened my faith. I always listen to you and i feel at peace.
I may be three years late but this is true and profound information I feel blessed to have received. Thank you.
What is true.. The man who is fluent in Hebrew quoting Hebrew Scripture. Or the preacher who just totally had no idea, no clue of the Hebrew scriptures
My answer is Rabbi Tovia Singer. I never seen anybody that is so knowledgeable on the bible and nobody is better than him on debating this topic.
I am an atheist and came here from Derek (MythVision), but this Rabbi is amazing and profoundly educated and articulate. I learned many things from him. Thank you Rabbi.
@@alfredmawuntu842 you are in the wrong place to campaign for your buddy jesus. I am not interested in jesus at all or in god for that matter. But the Rabbi is intelligent and I enjoyed his talks although I do no share the faith or beliefs.
Fellow atheist here who loves Rabbi Singer for the same reason. With his help, we can lead these poor people out into the light... away from religion.
Na. Tovia is not so great. The Hebrew Scriptures are amazing. I am thankful Rabbi Singer studied Hebrew and Torah and prophets for hours and hours a week for 52 weeks of the common calendar of Rome since before he started kindergarten through Yeshiva. Then throughout his entire life.
I've never seen a Christian come close to winning a debate with Rabbi Tovia and I'm not even Jewish.
He certainly didn't win this debate especially just quoting false scriptures
I agree. And I'm a firebrand atheist.
The Christian never won anything,he just read English translations & mistranslations of the bible
You may be right about that, the same way no one wins the debate against Muslims. But any one who seeks to win debates outside of the truth, is misleading himself.
But the Rabi, needs to read Romans 11. 25. Maybe it can help anyone who reads it.
We once had a problem with Pastors who must have met with people like Rabi, who denied Jesus.
When they came back, they abandoned faith in Jesus. And became drunkards, crying for the time they praised Jesus while denied in His land.
They never read Romans 11 25, if they did, they would never sought truth about Jesus from Jews.
@@zukied4817 you can not handle the truth even if it faced you that's why God created confusion for all yr denominations
He started his words with
“ I have watched rabbi Tovia before I came to debate “
I wonder why he didn’t leave Christianity yet ????
I thought the exact same thing, and I don't understand why he brought up tens of issues which Rabbi Singer already discussed in other videos. I guess he had nothing better to offer.
Leo Wise
Exactly
If he had really seen Rabbi Singer in any of his debates, why would he bring up the same old claims that every other Christian had brought up, and for which Rabbi Singer had already given the answer? It was either hubris on the part of Carlton, that because HE said it, finally Rabbi Singer would have to admit it must be true, or Carlton lied about seeing any of Rabbi Singer's other debates.
Matt Tillman @ because missionaries have not any new claim or any claim.
Matt Tillman
Because They have no any other knowledge
Besides claiming the same thing repeatedly as the previous Christian scholars did ... these people are betrayed and keep believing in Christianity blindly
The pastor seems like a very sweet man, but these people are no match for Rabbi Tuvia’s knowledge and logic in these matters.
@Rabbi Tovia Singer, thank you for being kind, genuine, and patient with these Christians. As a former Christian and now Orthodox Jewish convert, I can't help but think how many years I wasted in the "messianic" movement. If only I'd spoken with someone like you while I was trying to piece together the half truths and misinterpreted texts. Bezerat Hashem these sincere souls will become righteous Noahides and leave this nonsense. Keep up the good work.
Welcome home...
Yes, welcome home holy Brother or Sister.
How sad you turned on Jesus Christ the Lord of glory, for a dead religion. God will honor his Son. You will not dishonorm Him
@@kingjames5527 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂👻
@Love 4 Jesus why do you believe Jesus is God?
It's almost painful to listen to this guy. He might know some scripture, but sadly, he's grasping at straws at this point. Thank you for speaking truth, Rabbi Singer.
Jackie Betancourt I was just sitting here thinking OMG it’s painful to listen to him. Rabbi about to dispel all the teachings that he has explained in the wrong and doesn’t have understanding of
@mohammad khan You are a Conspiracy theorist.
Pastor: "Jesus was the messiah". Rabbi Singer: "Hold my beer and watch this"
Alpha Omega Hahahaha
@@adriansalinas7374LOL, yeah, for sure, bro 😂😄. Tovia knows his subject
More like “hold my manischevitch”
@Bible Addict background? Either jewish or not..
@StormNexus precisely 👍
I am a gentile, from Philippines... what an awesome and great explanation by Rabbi Tovia Singer. I learn many things from the Rabbi about their own History... More Blessings Rabbi.. . I am also waiting for your Messiah !!! May he speedily arrive in our times.
I am also a Gentile, going through the a Chasidic conversion. Peace be with you brother from another mother. Shalom/As salaam aliekum!
@@prestonjones1653 Welcome ✡️✡️
Amazing
Ha! Ha! Ha! Indeed, Tovia Singer's Messiah will be arriving in 2024. Thank God it's his Messiah, not the Messiah of the world.
In typical christian fashion, that christian was all over the place and really couldn't make his conclusions stick.
Embarrassing really.
I noticed. In fact, I commented as such in the above post.
I heard him reference Isaiah 7:14 as the "maiden" and Tovia covered that well. That would be enough right there to cause me not to want to present concluding remarks. He was confusing in his concluding statements. On the one hand he reiterated what he said about Daniel's weeks then with the other said he was confused and would talk with Tovia afterwards. That is good but ...
@@chaboi7 The Israelites didn't start out black. The blacks are from Ham.
@@akivatalansky
You can't be serious. 😂😂😂
Shalom Alcheim singer only debates ignorant Christians....he won’t debate messianic believers in Jesus
I'm sick, yet thankful for this debunking. It's clearing up a lot that has been so incomprehensible.
" I think I have a better understanding of how a mosquito feels in a nudist colony. He's saying to himself I don't know where to begin."
lol, love Rabbi Singer
This wasn’t even a debate. It was a schooling by rabbi tovia
I don’t know how any self respecting Christian would be able to logically hold on to their faith after such an intellectual onslaught lol
Carlton M Was Schooled as He Never imagined !
Keep up the Good work Rabbi Singer ✡️
They are like flatearthers. You can show them proof all day but they won’t budge.
Rabbi Tovia Singer is an amazing speaker, Rabbi and amazing debater. This video here is why Dr Michael Brown refuses to do live debates with him or unedited debates. Because R'Singer is amazing and nobody can prove any of his points wrong. While he easily takes Christian claims and dismantles them to show them false, myths, or Christian propaganda that has no place in Judaism.
May you live long Rabbi Singer and continue destroying these murderers of Jewish souls.
Exactly, and Brown thinks that no one sees through his charade. I know as a fact that Brown has not requested a debate with Rabbi Singer in 30 years. He knew very well that Rabbi Singer would want nothing to with him after Brown edited the debate, and personally attacked the Rabbi Singer in his books and on air, without allowing a response. To this day, Brown posts his edited debate, and posts attacks on the rabbi, without mentioning that the debate was heavily edited. Brown has quite a group of psych fans will to believe anything he tells them.
He knows his torah to the letter
Barbara Thomas,
The letter of the law kills the spirit of God.
There is nothing to add to what Rabbi Tovia ministered. It was perfect. May all the Christian messianics close the door to the N T Jesus and leave the Church and come home to HaShem.
Hello Genesis 3
There is enough evidence for me in the Old Testament to believe that Jesus is the Messiah, the only begotten Son of God.
The earthly sanctuary(temple) was an image of the original which is in heaven.
According to (Psalm 48:1-3 ; Isaiah 14:13-14) the throne of God is in the north. In the earthly sanctuary on the north side was the table of shewbread(the bread of his presence)(Exodus 25:30).
The table had two crown's and and there were two stags of bread.
In the law and the prophets we can see that there are two YHWH's.(e.g Genesis 19:24, Amos 4:10, Zechariah 3:1-2)
Read Psalm 45:7-8
At the beginning in Genesis we can read "Let us make man in our image after our likness". Two Humans were made. The first human was made and out of the first was taken the second Human.
Why did Abel, Noah, Job, Abraham, etc and afterwards Isreal sacrifice to God? Why does God need sacrifices? Why was Adam and Eve clothed with skin after they had sinned?
Greetings
@@earthenvessel7952 , you state "The earthly sanctuary(temple) was an image of the original which is in heaven."
My response, and what did the heavenly sanctuary look like? & prove it....
You state "According to (Psalm 48:1-3 ; Isaiah 14:13-14) the throne of God is in the north."
My response, you must be reading a Bible you invented because nothing of the sort is written in either of those passages. (though Psalm 48 does mention the northern side, but nothing there about the throne of God)
You state "In the earthly sanctuary on the north side was the table of shewbread(the bread of his presence)(Exodus 25:30)."
My response, actually the verse in psalms is a reference to the northern side of Altar. It has nothing to do with the Table.
I quote Rashi "the joy of the entire earth: Now what is its joy? The north side, angles in French, angle, corner. Redak (Shorashim) also defines it as corners, and so in Ezekiel (46:21). The northern side of the altar [was] where sin offerings and guilt offerings were slaughtered, and whoever was grieved because of the sins he had committed would bring a sin offering or a guilt offering, and he would be forgiven. He would then emerge happy, and the sacrifices would benefit the entire world."
You state "In the law and the prophets we can see that there are two YHWH's.(e.g Genesis 19:24, Amos 4:10, Zechariah 3:1-2)"
My response, really? Please do show me where those verses say there are two YHWH's. You must still be reading the same bible you invented which has God's throne in the north. :-) In fact in all three cases God is speaking in third person. Not that there are two Gods. If you can't tell the difference I suggest you read Isaiah which makes it very clear there is but One God ALONE.
You state "Read Psalm 45:7-8"
My response, how does "You loved righteousness and you hated wickedness; therefore God, your God, anointed you with oil of joy from among your peers." equal two gods?
You state "At the beginning in Genesis we can read "Let us make man in our image after our likness"."
My response, but only God (singular) made man. & we are indeed made in the likeness of "us". "Us" being God, the angels, and the animals.
You ask "Why did Abel, Noah, Job, Abraham, etc and afterwards Isreal sacrifice to God?"
My response, Abel because he wished to thank God. Noach because he wished to thank God. Job because he thought his children may have sinned. Abraham because he wished to thank God. Israel mostly because they wished to thank God. (with on rare occasions for other various reasons, such as overcoming Tzaraas, having a baby etc...)
You ask "Why was Adam and Eve clothed with skin after they had sinned?"
My response, because they had lost fulfilling the commandment so they became naked. Skin kept them warm. God used the skin of the snake which had then been forced into molting in order to clothe them
@@earthenvessel7952 another means of securing forgiveness is with prayer. This is known from King Solomon's dedication prayer at the 1st Temple. He told them that when in the future they may be w/o the Temple they would implore Hashem with their prayers and He would hear them. It is with the heart that we are justified and with the mouth and right action that salvation is effected. The christian belief that it is only through blood that salvation and favor can be had is from paganism. I understand that sounds preposterous and like something from the devil but dear soul much loved of Hashem it is so and you may search it out yourself.
@@reddog9401 you are speaking of Rabbi Kaduri. It was proven to be a fraud. You may google it for the reasons. Better you do your own research. I spent more than a decade in it. Research and Scripture and Hebrew led me away from the false beliefs you proselytize. Isaiah 53:10 is not your savior. I'm very sorry you were not educated enough while growing up. I'm also very sorry you believe Jews are being punished for rejecting the christian savior. Best regards.
@@reddog9401, nowhere does it say that the Messiah will stand on the mount of olives.
There wasn't anybody rejected. In order to reject something it has to actually first be considered. jesus is considered to be the Messiah as much as the cat in the dumpster. Do you "reject" the cat in the dumpster as the Messiah? In other words, do you actually consider the possibility he is the Messiah and then you reject him?
jesus was killed as per the commandment in the Torah which states that one who entices others to idol worship must be killed. Do you reject God's laws that such must be done to the enticer?
Lambs blood doesn't save. & jesus was as far as I know not a lamb. If he was a lamb as you claim, lambs are not the Messiah as lambs are not even human. Perhaps indeed you believe the cat in the dumpster is the Messiah? After all, like a lamb, he too is an animal. By the way, did jesus eat grass? Did he make baa baa sounds? Just for your information, lambs don't talk. So if jesus was a lamb he never said anything.
One more thing, the only thing that saves is following God's commandments. You might want to actually read God's word rather than the new test and you will find the truth. :-) You will find verses such as those found in Ezekiel chapter 18 which clearly states what saves a person. (hint: it's not lambs blood)
I didn't realize I was going to be watching Rabbi Singer doing house chores!
I was hoping for a great and worthy debate instead, what I got was Rabbi Singer sweeping, mopping, vacuuming, AND polishing the floor with Carlton McDonald.
I just love Rabbi Singer, HaShem bless you! Baruch HaShem, HaShem bless Israel, and praise HaShem for the truth! I can't hardly wait for messiah to come and the Temple to be rebuilt!
@@reddog9401 You're delusional, like all of your kind.
Carlos Barron
Carlos Barron I know right. What was that guy thinking?
Hahahaha ❤️
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Rabbi Tovia is so amazing and knowledgeable. I can listen to him all day long.
im at minute 27:00 and i feel so bad for this preacher, he has no idea what he is talking about. calling Moshe Rabenu a murderer is not only totally ignorant but he should have known that he cant say something like this to a jewish audience.....
Ezra Adler
“Tell me-Moses slew men and Ahab slew men-is this in each case murder?
Assuredly not; for Moses slew the men to destroy idolatry and to preserve the worship of the true God, but Ahab slew the men to destroy the worship of the true God and to preserve idolatry.
Wherefore to Moses the slaying of men was converted into sacrifice, while to Ahab it was converted into sacrilege: insomuch that one and the same work produced these two contrary effects”
- Prophet Jesus in the Gospel of Barnabas - chapter 159
He doesn't have a clue and he's all over the place!I am at the pint of fast forwarding to Rabbi Singer's response....
Noah Goldsworthy
He also debated Hamza Myatt on the divinity of Jesus and was smashed there also. I feel bad for him, he has very awkward mannerisms and he seems to be sincere and have a good heart. I pray God shows him the difference between worshipping Creation and worshipping the Creator alone
@@zafster22 yes thats why i feel bad for him, he seems like a innocent guy. but why is he going to a debate bichlal? didnt he learn about the jewish position before he came?
Jolly Yeholiver
It was manslaughter. Moses simply struck him not realising his own strength and power.
It was NOT murder, it was manslaughter and accidental - Moses repented immediately and God forgave him
Moses did not ‘murder’ anyone - God forbid
Watching Christians debate scripture is like watching a child try to argue with an elder
I can tell Tovia was so excited about this... Easy day at work for him, lol
@@jesusdeity2010 Nope.
@@jesusdeity2010 if God can only be found in Jesus, well that's not God
@@jesusdeity2010 talking about casted out demon. no big deal bro. the sharman from my village can perform that. in fact thosands of sharman can do that. so do you mean these sharmans are gods?
God walked this earth in Christ doesn't even make sense. Christ the Greek word for saviour to r messiah is not God. God has promised to send us a messiah which we eagerly await. Try say a sentence that makes sense next time
The audience looks so bored 😐 listening to McDonald speak. I’m so glad they didn’t get up and leave. I probably would’ve fallen asleep 😴 or left. Just listening to him now has the same effect on me.
I feel like going out to buy Macdonalds Halal chicken burger as i watch him speak..
Wait.. IS there such a thing??
Were you there? I was on the end....it was really good. Rabbi was so good.
😂😂 that's what happened with me , when i was in church every time sleeping 😴! i am Jewish out of church control and no more sleeping anymore, because i read Torah and Tanah 😊!
😂
As usual the debate made points and in the end Rabbi Singer shed light on Tanach .Baruch Hashem. !!Toda raba Rabbi Singer.
This Pastor's explanation is very shallow. Waste of time.
Sad to know that people like this pastor are “leaders” in the church and are supposed to guide masses to salvation
😭
It's hard to stand up to authority, isn't it?!
Christian r mix up with paganism. Muslims believe Abraham. Noah. Moses. Jesus they were prophet of god. Read the quran
Baruch HaShem! Rabbi Tovia Singer! May HaShem guard you in all your comings and goings, and in all your ways, from now and forever!
Baruch HaShem! Thank you Rabbi! Another victory against Christian missionaries!
Christian's want to change the definitions in the Torah. Temple is a physical place where G-d presence dwells. Our body is a vessel for our holy human soul. Islam is far closer to Judaism than Christianity. Christianity is far closer to the Greek and Roman's of Jesus time. So sad they don't even know who G-d really is except for pagan versions of Him.
Agree Bro.
I like this Rabbi. He doesn't mince his words.
I want more, many more Rabbis preaching like this. Rabbi Michael Skobac is also a wonderful speaker.
Thank you Rabbi Tovia Singer
A major reason the New Testament authors were so dreadfully unsuccessful in preaching to Jews is the following:
Moshe Rabbeinu taught us there will be men coming to speak in the Name of G-d.
Moshe Rabbeinu taught us to check and see if that person can perform a sign. If confirmed, “treat him”, I repeat, “treat him” as a prophet.
Moshe Rabbeinu taught us to now listen to this mans message. If it contradicts anything G-d has spoken at Mt. Sinai/Torah he’s a false prophet.
Now let’s apply the formula to Yoshke.
Along comes a man named Yoske claiming to have a message from G-d. Ok, according to Moshe that’s the first checkmark.
Yoshke performs a miracle(s) That’s the next checkmark.
Now what’s the message? The message Yoshke says is that Moshe is no longer valid. It’s no longer up to date.
CONCLUSION: Yoshke undercuts his own authority which tells us to even grant him our attention at the moment and strike three, this heretic is out.
REASON: If Moshe is out of date, then the authority and parameters by which to rule who is a prophet and who isn’t must therefore also be out of date.
No further discussion necessary.
Yeshua NEVER said the Torah (i.e. Moshe) had been replaced. Indeed, in Matthew 5:18, he's saying that not even the smallest stroke of the Law will ever be changed until EVERYTHING has been fulfilled. Since we still don't have the Kingdom - everything has certainly not been fulfilled. The only book in the Brit Chadeshah that implies that the Law has been done away with - for, it says, something 'better' - is 'Hebrews' - which lacks authentication and smells of Gnosticism. (I think it's a bit of leaven that someone didn't get rid of.) In the rest of the Brit Chadeshah the translators have used the same word 'law' to refer to both 'Torah' and 'customs' - so confusion reigns. Yeshua upheld Torah. So did Shaul/Paul. Here's a quote from Shaul/Paul. "Do we then make void the Law/Torah through faith? God forbid!!! Yea, we uphold/champion the Law/Torah!" Romans 3:31.
Fiona So is that why Christians worship a human being? Is that why Christians don’t put on Tefillen everyday? Is that why Christians don’t circumcise their sons? Is that why Christians don’t sanctify the new moon? Is that why Christians don’t wear tzitzit? Is that why Christians eat Chametz on Pesach? Is that why Christians violate Shabbat? Is that why Christians murder? Is that why Christians steal? Is that why Christians commit adultery? Is that why Christians eat pork? Is that why Christians wear a mixture of wool and linen? Is that why Christians don’t have peot and shave their beards with a razor? I can go on and on if you want. There’s so many laws in the Torah that Christians don’t keep at all! They don’t keep even 1% of the Torah.
To say the NT authors were all for the Torah and didn’t abolish it is shear nonsense as even Luke criticizes Paul for teaching Jews in exile not to circumcise their children any more.
No one is confused or has ever been between Jews and Christians. You never encounter a Christian on the street and confuse them for an Orthodox Jew. Never. But follow the same book? What is this a joke?
Your entire life is based on NOT following Torah.
If you come and say well the Jews added to the Torah. That’s also nonsense. You are just hopelessly ignorant of the teachings of the sages. They had orders of magnitude greater intelligence than we do and may have used ten steps of logic to form a conclusion for a certain ritual, practice or ruling. All derived from the text.
@@ThatGuy-sd3zl I am saying that Yeshua and Shaul upheld the Torah and that the 'church' that we now have is corrupted.
Here's a brief (very simplified) outline of history - the early Christians were made out to be enemies of Rome because they saw Yeshua as a king. These people then went into hiding. Finally, Constantine pretended to 'see the light'. He then mixed Christianity with paganism. Those who didn't accept his way were persecuted. Those who followed his 'mix' had access to the Scriptures and corrupted them. The top ones in this 'church' told those wanting to follow the truth that Christians should kill the Jews. etc.
We are STILL under this corruption . Protestantism started to come out, but then stopped too soon.
With regard to Jews 'adding'. .. I have (admittedly, only very briefly) read on practical Judaism. It tells me I MUST pray when I see my first apple, or my first flower or this or that or that or this. What this is, is like a nagging spouse. When we get married we have some duties and it's really nice if we go the extra mile voluntarily, to which we say, "thank you". But, if your spouse keeps saying, "And do this.. and do that .. and don't do this and don't do that... and don't forget this... etc" you eventually throw your hands up and in the air and cry, "I can't take it anymore!"
What Yeshua nd Shaul were saying was, "Keep it simple. Be nice and be happy. God has said what he wants. He's your husband. Just do what he wants, please. What everyone else is saying isn't important."
In the end … God loves us.
Fiona, you've got to stop relying upon tbe New Testament or "BH" as you call it. Enough already, Its not true, and no way is it the word is Hashem, so much manipulation of the Jewish scriptures. Why have you fallen for this "yeshua" nonsense? Peer pressure, too much at stake? Fear of going to "hell"? Afraid of what your family and friends with think? Too many powerful experiences at whatever "messianic temple" you may attend? Do you understand Hebrew fluently? Do you understand Greek mythology?
Fiona, live a simple life, follow the 7 laws of Noah, drop the idol yeshua worship. To see the relationship Jews have with Hashem as nagging the root of your confusion. Orthodox Jews see their obligations as precious and sweet, but your false Paul had said he's got an easier way, you totally miss the point of why Orthodox Jews follow the commandments given to them, as if they are an inconvenience, that's a bad attitude to have, and youve sadly fallen for the messianic Christian way, because it appears so attractive.
Where can study with Rabbi Tovia Singer?
Jewish wisdom is well over 3000 years old. Hundred of generations and scholars, not only the tanach, but commentary in the gemmorah, midrash. Genius talmudic scholars, ancient Kabbalist wisdom. Then one guy gets up, “well in John blah blah blah it says blah blah blah” Therefore Jesus is the messiah.” I mean how insulting and short sighted can one be.
why is he shaking his body like that? it must have been very tiring for him....Tovia just swallowed him up like catfood!
It was so annoying and he was so uneffective I fast forwarded thru it.
Jews sway while we pray. It is in reference to the verse in Psalms (35), "All my bones will declare Your praise." Incidentally, this was the Psalm recited in benediction at the opening of the Constitutional Convention.
Achdus5774 you shall tremble before the Lord.
The word of G-d has that effect on all of us.
@@timothya.olmeda7299, I don't do that, and I'm a believer in Jesus Christ.
Did the disciples tremble? I know the word says the demons do.
@@jamesmccluskey391
Wrong!
To fear God is to understand the power of His hand and might.
We have all sinned.
And fear the judgements of God.
But, God gave us a way in which we can overcome evil, and master over it.
This way is not from a human blood sacrifice (which happens to be an abomination to HA’SHEM your God) but the only way to salvation and the mercy of God is to return to HA’SHEM [God] and repent.
How do we know this?
Ever since the destruction of the Second Temple, the only way to salvation is through repentance.
Again, how do we know?
This is explicitly explained by God in Ezekiel 18:21-24 and Ezekiel 33:11-16.
I guess you Christians didn’t get the memo?
There is no other besides HA’SHEM [God].
There is no such thing as a Jesus (Christ).
There is no such thing as a dying Messiah.
Nor an only begotten dying son of God.
Because none of these things exist in the Jewish Scriptures.
Your beliefs are nothing but a progressive revelation designed by the Church throughout the centuries.
And the time to realize this, is now.
Shalom
This was not a debate.
It was a fantastic teaching by Rabbi Singer
I think the preacher is going to repent and desist from Trinitarianism after this '' lecture '' from Tovia..
I agree!
@@fidelcatsro6948 hope
Iam a Nigerian,after listening to vario Rabbi I believed in God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob .every other gods I don’t believe and nobody’s can convince me no more shalom.the Jews are the chosen ones the world will listen to them and Jerusalem is the capital of Israel and everyone will go back home even though iam black i will go back home that is the promised land .presently i leave in Brazil God bless
Carlton's strategy is to put you to sleep
I almost forgot... TEAM TOVIA! ✡️☝🏾
calling Moses "a murderer" twice how dare you
Hansina Dam, was he not?
@@sternwheeler No... if you ever learned the Oral torah you would understand this story. But Christians are elementary in these subjects.
Carlos A.N, not a Christian. Tell me more.
@@sternwheeler Moses is the reincarnation of Abels soul. Cain's soul reincarnated into two bodies, the Egyptian that attacked the hebrew and Jethro. When Moses killed the Egyptian he fulfilled part of the wrong that was committed to him in the past life. When Jethro gave Moses his daughter Zipporah, Jethro was paying for the jealousy he had for his brother in his past life. Cain was jealous of Abel for being born with 2 wives and his jealous led to his offerings not being accepted by God and eventually he killed Abel.
Carlos A.N, was the Egyptian or Moses cognizant of these facts?
Rabbi Singer speaks the true original verses Great job .Keep up your work
Satans tongue
@@rickpederson1219 christians have such a warped view of Satan too.
@@rickpederson1219jesus was a satan .
Listening to Carlton is so painful, also watching him flick through the bible like a takeaway menu is ridiculous
Keep it up tovia.thank you for such a fine teaching
man...the expression on Tovia's face in the beginning says it all....poor guy.
You need to express yourself better than this. I do not feel sorry for Tovia one MITE, for he SLAUGHTERED Carlton McDonald's argument.
I love Rabbi Singer
Sharp as always, i love your lectures and debate even from years ago ❤. Thanks
I love you Rabbi Tovia, please continue your good work of true God of Israel, I love you.
I can't believe the Christian guy is telling what jews are and aren't...in front of some of them. He is hard to follow too and could have been more organized. Haven't listened to Tovia's rebuttle yet, but I know it will be great.
Well done. Thank you.
I am so bored listening to this preacher
I thought he was rather engaging
Brother To via Singer if you ever need anything in this life I will help you as you have taught me so much.
I have waited to see this debate!! Thanks rabbi :)
thank you rabbi for the video
As an atheist, who listens to debates like these to learn the views of others, I NEVER expected to hear a Christian cite the Koran in a debate with a Rabbi.
Citing the qu'ran is to show Jesus, the knowledge of God spreading throughout the world, selah
Christians (especially some american evangelical "christians") just should stop with this "judeochristian" nonsense (= "judeochristian" culture, "judeochristian" heritage, "judeochristian" values etc)
Judaism (monotheism) and christianity (polytheism) are two oppossing religions.
@James Gray "Please demonstrate anywhere the traditional Christian faith , or the new testament teaches polytheism.."
Challenge accepted.
In the gospels, Jesus wanders off into the wilderness and has a conversation with the Devil.
This Devil is later (or earlier, depending on if you use the timeline of the stories or the timeline of when the epistles and then the gospels were written) called "the god of this world." The Christian pantheon doesn't have a trinity, for to Christians, Jesus, his father, and the ghost are all one and the same monster, like a three-headed hydra. Rather, the Christian pantheon has a God of Good in Heaven, and a god of Evil in Hell who is also lord of the Earth. That's a form of polytheism called dualism.
BTW, even if Christians DID think there was a trinity, the rabbis say that what Christians explain is actually "partnership" (Hebrew: 'shittuf'), which is still forbidden, but not idolatry.
@@matttillman7430 make light go through a prisma and you will see several color, so the light is white or several colors? that's how the personalities of God work, is the same entity.
The water turns solid, liquid and vapor, same water right? that's how God transformed.
You Jews see God in a flat plain, but God is tri-dimensional.
God creator would never touch sin, that's way the form of the son came to work fulfilling his covenant. The Holly spirit, lives in us after Jesus left, Holly Spirit is not just the conscience.
@@mariorrodriguez535 According to the Bible, God is unchanging. Transform means to transition or change from one form to another. God has no form. Therefore, God doesn't transform. God didn't become Jesus, nor did Jesus become God.
@@matttillman7430 In that case how you explain God talking to Moses through the firing bush?
Christian's at least the ones who study are not idolatrous, like a Catholic can be. And Jewish should learn too that their good deeds are not surprising God because God is omniscient so He knows everything, but God only see us for a good repentance heart and that happens only trough Jesuschrist who is what God made for us as per promised to Abraham.
Lastly, God is on top of any religion, not God is.encapsulated in a only one religion like you guys spected.
I hope some day you can see the tridimensional power of God
@@matttillman7430 please tell me when the religion was initiated?
It hurts my ears listening to this British guy! The only thing I like about him is his friendly demeanor and accent
yes he seems like a very nice man with some lost beliefs ..
He couldn't even defend his belief at Speakers corner London let alone in a big platform such as this. It's beyond me he took this challenge. Check his debates with Muslim speakers at Speakers corner.
@@TAJi677 lol In his opening statement he says he watches the rabbis videos. How on earth does he even have the courage to confront him lol!
@@DjIsaacsOfficialSite I agree with you. He is not up to the task but tries very hard to appear so. No knowledgeable speaker or debater should consider this guy. He failed in so many debates in London. Check out Hamza Myatt EFdawah
I think they know their accents are appealing, it’s like they know! Lol
Crowd seemed a bit rude to the Christian 😂 still the Christian was not ready for any of this energy.. man is talking about Muslims for some reason 😵💫😂🤯
I was there, but I have to be honest that if you call Moshe Rabbeinu a murderer then you deserve no honor.
Thanks Rabbi for expose the falsehood of christianity
There are many falsehoods in Christianity, but Jesus isnt false. While many people experience being reborn by Jesus and live fulfilled life full of love others are still waiting for the Messiah as pride and ego keeps them from the real Messiah.
@@rskrks Is there any prophecy about Jesus , from the jewish scripture?
@@solomonaugustus5988
Too many
@@ronahijau3749 Too many? Name a few...
Please wake up.Jesus is your salvation.without Him throught Holy spirit you can not defeat devil.wake up.
Rabbi singer is the best!!!
I was in the Christian hell all the time this preacher would speak cause I was nashing my teeth all through his speach, but when rabbi tovia spoke I was brought back to heaven.
I'm at 21:00 in and Carlton McDonald so far is basing everything he says on the New Testament and it's books. He misrepresented Jews Anointing and he constantly references Paul and John and other Pagans. This guy has never debated clearly. He should have attempted to use only Torah, and references to attempt to construct his platform from Torah. Instead he uses full NT to create ideas of a prophecy being fulfilled.... :/ So basically Carlton should be a Morman because now Joseph Smith claims to have part 3 and if Mormons can point and reference their book then it makes as much sense as Carlton references only NT.
24:22 He brings up Jebus talking about the Commandments, but Jebus broke them nonstop in the Gospel. Jebus openly sins and breaks Shabbat on several occassions, In Matthew he gives a speech about how he is for upholding the Law and then he spends the full chapter rewritting the sins and laws on divorce, and several other issues. This is madness.
So it goes with missionaries. Circular arguments, begging the question and assuming the point they’re trying to make is all they have as ammunition. Which is about as useful as blowing bubbles against the hover damn.
Law is for you, you are not for law.
If you know this then you know Jesus works in Sabbath
@Paula Wallace true
@@benabraham8607 jebus breaks shabbat at least 2 times. He sins through the gospels. He steals corn he steals pigs and kills them and he steals a donkey later. He demands a Jewish man carry his bed in public to his house and several speeches are heretical and he attempts to change the Law.
@@TzionBarlev
Lol, It is not Sin if God servant eat food in sabbath
Ex : David & Priest of Temples
Jesus is more than them to have such right
Tovia you are a light to the world👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼I love your passion for God
And the prophecies of the Torah that Hashem blessed is He, will bring all His children back. I am a witness to the truth of Torah. My ancestors were Sephardic Jews murdered by the Inquisition of Spain. I grew up not knowing Torah or the prophecies of Hashem blessed is He, about bringing us back to Him. I didn't know the Hebrew Holy Name of the merciful G-d of Israel because the Catholic Church did not allow us to read the Torah of Moshe. But I was praying one day and ask the Almighty God blessed is He, to teach me His laws and statutes. I received an answer, He brought me to His Holy Temple in the wilderness in a dream and there He showed me His precious Holy Name in Hebrew when I didn't know what those symbols meant. I saw the Holy of Holies when I didn't know what this place was or where I was. Thirty years later I found out when someone introduced me to the Bible. Ever since then Hashem blessed is He, has been leading me to my Jewish people, my family. The prophecy of us all the disperse around the world will be returning. I see it is happening, I am one of them. I also see how Hashem is working amongst His people. My Jewish family is not afraid anymore to teach those who are lost from the tribes Torah. No body can stop them ever again, because Hashem blessed is He, is the One working these wonders. I suggest to all my dear family, my Jewish people don't give up on your G-d. He is with us around the world. B"H
Lol did he just admit that xianity's history is stained with blood?
Rut Brea bbvv O
It's so comfortable to say that Jesus will accomplish everything on a second coming!!! 😂
I love Rabbi Tovia Singer, keep preaching truth. ❤
I almost felt bad for this guy until he started saying as Jews we owe the Church wow I don't even think he understands what he said.
@ADISA AJIBADE Is that what you think the United States didn't come to the aid of the Jewish people until 1973 and even then it wasn't what you think it was so obviously you need to go back and do your homework buddy the United States never helped Israel until 1973 so remember that the 1st Western country to actually help the state of Israel was France they gave a few planes and that's not the church that was Richard M Nixon
Mr. McDonald will soon find the reality of Hashem blessed is He. He is seeking, the truth of the Hebrew God, will be revealed to him.
Thank you Rabbi Tovia
Bs"D
Congratulations rab tovia...! Thanks to Hashem for you and your work. For helping us and protect us from missionaries.
Stay in touch, Meir
@Ramees Raja As far back as the 2 century CE the Church father Origen addressed Isaiah's 53 and the unanimous agreement that Jews always referenced it as themselves. That destroys the belief of Isa 7:14's son by a virgin. Because Isa 53 is Israel there is no son of a virgin needed to redeem the world even if want to think they're lying about the word almah. The case made that christianity is wrong is overwhelmingly correct.
@Ramees Raja I'm sorry I said you are parroting. I thought I deleted that. I don't want to disrespect you. Please understand that we do not want to be either.
@Ramees Raja I hope you are going to grasp that quoting your XT [christian testament] carries no authority with me or anyone else. I hope you will at some point consider mine and others excellent XT literacy and quoting it will go nowhere. Peace be with you.
@@debrapaulino918 There is no word virgin (betulah) in Isaiah anywhere. The word he uses is alma (young woman) not betulah.,
Was anyone else confused when the Christian quoted the Quran and starts talking about Islam?
I was there. Everybody really put on a face of, "what is this guy doing?"
Rabbi Singer, you are definitely called by HaShem! You are so awesome! No offense, to my Black brother( minister) I advice you NOT to debate Rabbi Singer, but please become a student of his… Shalom
The religion of love and mercy.... Hhhhh , we felt your love and mercy for the last 2,000 years ...
Yes, everyone across the globe, every nation/country has felt the results/“love” of the empires/countries that were christian-led..
Did you read history ? Are you serious ?
@@incorruptibleword4513 wrong. Judisim was given BY G-D to say it's flawed is arrogant of you. You think you're better than Hashem? 😂 😂 😂 😂
@@daviedood2503 Judaism wasn't given by God torah was, learn the difference. Just because something icludes torah doesn't mean the whole thing came from God. Hashem isnt Judaism he is the most high don't be ignorant study in more detail.
Blaq Inkz ... I do, that’s why my comment was in the same tone 🤣🤷🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Rabbi Tovia's parts: 0:36:04 -1:06:15, 1:21:39 - 1:30:52
Thanks. This is one of the most useful comments on youtube.
@@leeannep.7652why not listen to both men speak?
@@purplepill5345 Because I want to retain whatever brain cells I have left.
The pastor was wrecked so badly that he had to quote from scriptures he never believe in like the Quran and Sikh scriptures, while rejecting Jewish Torah which his religion is based on.
The way he dismissed the killing of the Jews by the Christian by simply saying that Christians also killed Christians is hillarious. They could never admit they had been killing to spread their version of Christianity. Ever.
“ Carlton brought nothing to an argument “‘I kind of feel sorry for him, how much he does not know “‘
He is a person who takes religion very serious, but he is unfortunately brainwashed. I've talked to him after the debate and he just lacked so much information. But you should have seen the Bible that he carried with him. Full with notes, bookmarkers and lighted marks. Very impressive to see how hard he worked on it. But he was no match for Rabbi Singer שליט"א and rightly so. Because what argument can a Christian possibly put forward that is not refuted?
The christian guy has no business being in any debates, he just cost christianity a few members.
😂
This guy is.essentially incomprehensible...after a short while it was clear that he needed salvation...for his speech to fish.
May all missionaries be a ineffective as him.
.
Shalom Rabbi. I always learn so much from you
I love rabbi Tovia, he has opened my eyes to the truth. Judaism is the only truth. Shalom
as a christian i would never dare call magnificent moses a murderer what a wrong headed way to start a debate although i remain a christian for personal and unmistakable evidences of answered prayer it is clear this poor man was no match for rabbi singer whose blazing sincerity forbids me to ever speak ill of him what we all can agree upon is this hashem knows those who are his own as a father knows his children and all those who name the name of the lord avoid every form of wrong
I would love to see Tovia debate against Amir Tsarfatii he is a Jew and a Thora reader and a Christian
Carlton must have people whom he trusts and who are close to him. They should sit him down and say to him: "honey, we know how much you love this public speaking thing but... it's not working out. Maybe you should do something else". Lol
The rabbi destroyed his worshipers of the idolatrous Trinity
Rabbi Singer at the moment I am just lost for words so all I can say is Blessing to you at all times Amen
Why does Carlton McDonald cite the Quran in a debate about Judaism and Christianity to make an argument?
I’m a Muslim Alhumdulillah
But the Christian has no clue what he’s talking about
I cringe every time I watched these Christian pastors try to make any sense defending their corrupt book especially when face to face with Tovia. I’m also surprised they don’t give up, concede and convert on the spot.
Rabbi Tovia is genius.
i came to see my uni lecturer say dumb shit.
i left satisfied.
Allah swt never gave the book to the Christians
ISA pbh was a Jew
He was sent to jews
ISA pbh was the injeel ( Gospel ) good news
Bible was written by Paul
Christians are lost pagans
Thank you Rabbi from the dephts of my heart for teaching us to understand the hebrew bible and the true jewish faith!
I grew up in a fundamental christian family. Though I have a jewish grandma, it's a shame that this had no impact. So my father is theoretical also jewish, but he infact became a pastor, also my brother.
When I reflect on the christian teachings I have heard, it actually made no sense to me, but it's natural to believe what you hear over and over again. I also loved to read Tanakh, but had difficulties to read the gospels, because the mix of merciful and merciless is absolutely confusing. It was also clear to me that the christian faith is not in any way rational, logical or consistent. But I was taught that this is faith about, not to fully comprehend. Astonishingly I always hated Paul.
All my life I was attracted to the jewish people. But it took me long to research why they don't accept Jesus. In fact there is not one argument from Tanakh that justifies Jesus!
Now I am starting my conversion process, what is very difficult here in Germany. I feel like having a jewish soul and I want to be a witness of the One and Only True G-D.
What I want to tell you is that it is more than painfull for a christian to discover that there is no salvation in Jesus. I could not leave the couch for one week, when I found out. The fake connection to Jesus is very strong, because of all that "love" preachings and also Jesus movies. To be aware of having built all your life on a lie is so devastating. It is also a horrible feeling to see your family and friends continuing believing in that lie. They panic when you reject Jesus and accept jewish faith. Meanwhile I feel desperate to watch them. They consider me as a rebel. They are freaking out when I am telling them the reasons why christianity is an error, not able to listen, breaking up the conversation. Some of them argue that faith is dependent of your heart (feelings) and not your thinking. Paul was so clever claiming, that "the letter kills". His expression was constructing the way of how christians believe, that a single hebrew word is not exactly meaningfull anymore. In combination with "the new covenant" the hebrew bible appears obsolete to christians. I am sad, that christianity is a religion based on jealousy, aiming to take away from the jewish people, what G-D consideres them to be. When HE says HIS chosen people are HIS eyeball, HE reveals that they are a very part of HIMSELF. Gentiles cannot stand and accept this, often uncounsciously. They are angry and hurt. Some say I am dangerous.
And those who are willing to listen are not able to respond, saying "whatever you tell me, I won't change my faith". I feel deeply sorry for them, also for the preacher in this debate.
I am glad for any response on my comment. Actually I don't have anyone who shares my experiences...
A messanger appeared as a man and has God's name, this is in the Tanahk. Explain this please?
Thank you so much for this comment. You soeak nothingnbut truth to what many ex Christians are realising. We have been deceived by the jealous greko-romans about a Christ who was never the messiah of anyone out of their jealousy for the jews and their claims. It goes to show that Christianity is the real threat to the jews and God by adding text ( the new testament) to the jewish scriptures. Jealosuy, envy, and h @tred for the jews has led mainly the Europeans to form a religion where they can also feel important and included by stealing and even demonising the jews. It's very disheartening that I too can never say the truth in front of family and friends cause they defend their Christianity to the the d£ath of it without looking into history and hearing it from the jews. Accusing the jews of being confused and h@ting God by not accepting a Messiah that was never a Messiah to begin with... Jeremiah 16 vs 19
As a Christian I have a powerful relationship with the living God..and we built the Western/modern world, "You shall know them by their fruits"..what do we have to be jealous of? If it were only because of jealousy, we wouldn't have a true relationship with God, we wouldn't be experiencing the miracles we are.
You are brilliant!
This was painful to watch. I think Rabbi Singer has converted more Christians than he has brought Jews back to Judaism.
I still don't know what the christian guy was trying to explain or prove to the audience lol
my advice to him he should never engage in any debate...;)
night and day it's just simply that clear Christianity is dead religion
John Francis
Indeed - and there will be no resurrection after 3 days