Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker [ Analysis ] - Part III
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 07. 2024
- Hello! Thanks for clicking on this video! This is the final installment of my three part review of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. The movie is bad and I want to break down why. If you've watched all three parts, thank you so much! If you enjoyed, please like, comment, and subscribe, and stay tuned for my future videos! If you didn't agree with what I said, please let me know, and discuss in the comments!
In this final installment to my review series, I finish the scene by scene analysis and move towards jumping from topic to topic individually. If you're interested in a specific topic, here is a time stamp list of the times I cover them. If you enjoyed, please subscribe and leave a comment!
Intro: (0:00)
Scene by Scene: (0:23)
Palpatine's Return & Why it's Nonsense: (33:41)
The Tragedy of Snoke the Lame: (41:25)
All in a Rey's Work: (43:15)
Rise and Fall of Kylo Ren: (49:44)
General Hux and General Hux V2: (50:48)
Stop and Sideline The Roses: (51:41)
No More Poe: (52:29)
Finn's Fruitless Finale: (53:18)
Inclusion of Leia: Good or Bad?: (55:19)
Goodbye, Luke Skywalker: (56:25)
Emotion Baiting = 10/10 Quality: (56:57)
The Parts That Didn't Make Me Want to Claw My Eyes Out: (57:42)
Final Thoughts on This Awful Trilogy: (59:06)
Conclusion: (1:02:15)
Link to playlist for this series:
• Chef's Star Wars: The ...
====================================
I used background music in this video as well that does not belong to me, here are the links to those songs.
Review Background Music:
[ No Copyright ] Coffee House Jazz | Calm Jazz Music | Relaxing Music | Relax Music Meditation
• Video
====================================
Copyright Disclaimer:
Clips from "Star Wars," "Marvel," or any other films are used throughout the video but are protected under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted.
All clips are used for the purpose of education and criticism. All “Star Wars," "Marvel," or any other film clips are owned by Disney, Lucas film, or their respective owners. I do not own any of this content. - Zábava
In this final installment to my review series, I finish the scene by scene analysis and move towards jumping from topic to topic individually. If you're interested in a specific topic, here is a time stamp list of the times I cover them. If you enjoyed, please subscribe and leave a comment!
Scene by Scene - 0:23
Palpatine's Return & Why it's Nonsense - 33:41
The Tragedy of Snoke the Lame - 41:25
All in a Rey's Work - 43:15
Rise and Fall of Kylo Ren - 49:44
General Hux and General Hux V2 - 50:48
Stop and Sideline The Roses - 51:41
No More Poe - 52:29
Finn's Fruitless Finale - 53:18
Inclusion of Leia: Good or Bad? - 55:19
Goodbye, Luke Skywalker - 56:25
Emotion Baiting = 10/10 Quality - 56:57
The Parts That Didn't Make Me Want to Claw My Eyes Out - 57:42
Final Thoughts on This Awful Trilogy - 59:06
Conclusion - 1:02:15
23.8 23
I hate to keep leaving basically the same comment, but yep. I agree with all of this. I still can't comprehend how they went into a new Star Wars trilogy without the plan to have Luke, Leia, and Han on screen together. I don't see how that's something you choose to *not* do. It literally makes no sense. Such wasted potential. As far as TROS is concerned, it barely even feels like a movie to me. It just feels like a mess of random, terribly executed, scenes. That's all it is to me.
Absolutely. Thank you for watching through all these videos!
I will never forgive Disney, KK, Bob Iger, RJ and JJ for not having a single scene of Luke, Leia, Han, Chewbacca and Lando; even Admiral Ackbar death was consequential and wasted.
I agree!
One of the few moments i actually cried on TLJ was when they said Ackbar was dead i had to pause the movie bc i couldn't believe it ._. They really did my boy so dirty
It’s no different than if they made Back to the Future 4 and Doc and Marty did not have one scene together either. Mind boggling.
Great breakdown series. There really is something wrong in almost every scene, never mind the overall series problems you detailed. The Last Jedi was a mess but Rise of Skywalker felt like it just gave up on making the Star Wars universe interesting. Also, I did write a screenplay for an alternate episode 9. So if you have the time or interest, the video is uploaded on my CZcams, a text version pdf is in the video description.
Oh wow, that sounds cool! I'll have to check that out. Thanks for watching the video! It means a lot to me when viewers leave comments like this. Would you consider subscribing? We've got lots of more videos coming!
Yeah with Palpatine not stopping the lightning, Count Dooku was far more intelligent. He shot a bit at Obi won but he deflected it easily, so Dooku just up and beats his ass
19:18 I can forgive the similarities between the Lando ship-reveal scene and the portal scene in Endgame because the whole trope of the battle seeing lost but help arriving is a common thing in storytelling.
That said, "I am all the Sith...and I am all the Jedi" is one of the worst moments in any film I have ever seen.
@Kaos It does my heart good to learn more reasons why that terrible scene is terrible lol
Ey. Do not compare the ending of VI with this movie. It is not fare. Even having still to face the rest of the empire, destroying the superweapon again, with the Emperor, Vader and a portion of their fleet is something worldly of celebration in an universe with some logic where actions mattered.
Not like this. Here they celebrate their forced victory over a copy/paste fleet that came from the ass of a Palpatine that shouldn't be there, while the First Order, already hiperpowerful for no reason, fall prey for a sudden, script induced, rebellion, that remembers the death of Poochie in The Simpson.
35:00
What do you mean no buildup? Didn't you watch the Fortnite special event where Palps tells everyone his galaxy takeover plan?
In all seriousness, I haven't seen the film I've just watched the takedowns. I had no respect left for the sequel series just by watching IX's opening crawl alone.
I have Star Wars fan friends who say "this movie felt like star wars..." and I wholly disagree. Star Wars HAD CAUSE AND EFFECT. Star Wars MADE SENSE. Good analysis.
Star Wars didn't have the plot of a videogame where you need to do that to get that and oh look something that will help you
Did you disown them?
This is one of the most embarrassing movies I have ever seen. Ridiculous to levels I could not imagine. I laugh at almost every scene. I almost like the movie just for that.
Well Rae could fly by then. Maybe she could just float her way off the island 😁
... or to the death star ruins
Your suffering is over my friend
Yes 😭
Great analysis, thank you sir. As someone who’s been a Star Wars fan since young childhood, I enjoyed the sense of catharsis I get from hearing in detail just how terrible this movie is. The Disney trilogy as a whole is a huge slap in the face.
Agreed. If you sub to the channel you will get to watch my upcoming analysis of Return of the Jedi 👀👀
@@TheDigitalSaloon I subscribed 👌. Return of the Jedi has some nonsense parts but damn it’s still good 😂. Looking forward to it
At the risk of sounding cliche, I now look forward to seeing that review video on TLJ you keep talking about lol
31:12 aparently the visual dictionary says that Lando's daughter was abducted by the first order, so had they put that in the movie, the interaction between him and Jana would have made sense...lol
It still wouldn't have made sense cause there are thousands of First Order troops. Why would he assume she was his daughter? It came across more like he was flirting the first time I saw it lol.
@@jayhartRIC I think because I heard the daughter rumors I already had that in mind, since it didn't sound flirty to me 🤷♂️
My guess is, since he knew Luke and Leia well, he probably just figured that's how it worked. Runs into random black woman who would be in the general age of his daughter, so it's like "I must have randomly run into my long-lost daughter" lol
53:40 It's a cool idea, but I think they wrote themselves into a corner trying to put it in the main trilogy. They want to be able to treat the stormtroopers as faceless mooks so that we can cheer about killing them, but that's fundamentally at odds with trying to make them captured children. Even as early as TFA this started causing story friction, like Finn cheerfully shooting his fellow abductees in the escape.
I think the right way to handle it would be to give it to someone as a side story. Like I hated TLJ, but imagine if Rian was given the "former stormtrooper perspective" movie. Then all the more subversive stuff would fit far better. It would be an appropriate place to mention the arms dealers selling to both sides. Or it could mention things like all the people they killed by blowing up the death star. Maybe they could even say like the rebels "caused" some of it, because the remnants of the empire needed to replace all the manpower somehow.
And as a bonus, that would leave the main trilogy free to be proper hero's journey for Rey, instead of making the worst middle-of-a-trilogy movie ever. (Hopefully even the TLJ apologists can see that, even if they like the movie on its own, it's unambiguously bad *as a middle*.)
I loved this series gotta come back and watch The Last Jedi series thank you for yor hard work and showing why this trilogy SUCKS 😂🤘
The force ghosts don't bother me because we never see them do anything crazy off of the one planet that is canonically like super mega Force place.
I loved these analysis very still have yet to watch Your Last Jedi analysis but I will. Are you planning to do other films like WW84 for example?
Probably not haha
@@TheDigitalSaloon Too bad I really liked these and your LJ videos as well. if you are still doing videos maybe we could collab sometime?
Great Vids man!
I've really enjoyed your in-depth analysis/post mortem of this disgraceful film. Your effort is appreciated!
Thank you!
At least Palpatine's return in the EU was handled well, and it served to explore and expand on Luke's character and powers. I've heard that Lucas decided to let the writers use him instead, when he refused to allow them to bring back Vader.
Here, though, it was nothing but a lazy plot contrivance and nostalgia bait, very clumsily handled.
P.S. How the F do you "jam a speeder"?
30:09 I wouldn't say the celebrations and implication that the empire is defeated at the end of Return of the Jedi is a flaw. They didn't just destroy the Death Star. They destroyed the Death Star AND the emperor (or so we all thought...) AND Darth Vader AND probably many other imperial leaders. The empire formed with Palpatine; it's not like he was a king with kids and relatives to suceed him.
And in the OT, there was only one empire, not two empires (Palpatine's secret regime and also the First Order).
Communist regimes in real life have been overthrown with less destruction than what happened to the empire. Given that there had been a Republic within the lifetimes of most living adults at the time, and the Senate had even still existed until shortly before the events of Star Wars, setting up a Republic again would have been very feasible.
I’m glad holdo died... that character was dumb
True
Executive Summary: This film was offensively stupid.
But the entertainment it has given me listening to youtubers ripping it apart has been copious.
I couldn't agree more
Seeing all 3 videos.. thank you ..you're so right ..it was the worst trilogy I've ever seen.. Just holes all through the story smh .. I enjoyed your videos more than the actual movie
Thank you! I'm so glad you enjoyed. Subscribe if you're interested in more enjoyable content haha
An enjoyable watch. You have a criminally low amount of subs and views for the quality of content. But you've gained one at least.
Thank you so much! Definitely check out our other content. Personally, my videos have improved greatly since this one! - Chef
This whole Sequel Star Wars Trilogy was complete waste of potential.
Couldn't agree more. Thank you for watching and leaving a comment, it's much appreciated! Please consider subscribing if you haven't already 😁
The alleged explanation for Force ghosts interacting physically is supposed to do with Ach-To being the site of the 1st Jedi temple and therefore enhancing the ghosts' connection to the Force. But it's still bullshyt...
john boyega is hot...that is all. wished his character had actually gotten do diligence!
They should have just had Janna instead of finn
unrelated question, why can't Jedi fly? If they can push and pull and throw stuff around, well then you should be able to fly around too
I guess for most Jedi it just takes too much effort and intense Concentration.
Not everyone is on the Level of an Anakin Skywalker or a Yoda.
I think they could, but it wouldn't be worth the effort at all
Using force on your own self and other objects is different, I guess.
AYEEE
Thank you for watching! Would you consider subscribing to stay up to date with our new videos?
54:09
You believe that crap lie by Abrams? Sinking in sand about to die so you decide then to tell someone that is sinking in the sand & about to die with you, that you are force sensitive? I don't think so. Get your head out of your ass. JJ Abrams lied to you all. He was going to tell Rey he loves her. Why do you think Finn was always screaming her name and running after her?