We Tried 9 Different Black and White Cookie Recipes

In this special edition bake off, I'm doing a black and white cookie comparison in NYC! In this video, I review 9 popular black and white cookie recipes. Let me know in the comments which city I should do a bake off in next!
The full breakdown, including the data analysis and my top picks, will be live on my blog. Thank you to our sponsor, ‪@imperialsugar‬ for providing the high-quality pure cane sugar that powered all of these cookies!
Blog post: www.thepancakeprincess.com/20...
Instagram: / thepancakeprincess
Facebook: / pancakeprincessblog
Videography thanks to Michael Ma from Makin Media: / @makinmediastudios8479
Recipes (in order shown):
00:00​​​ Intro to the Black and White Cookie bake off
1:13 Ina Garten: barefootcontessa.com/recipes/...
2:13 Of Batter and Dough: ofbatteranddough.com/black-an...
3:08 New York Times: cooking.nytimes.com/recipes/1...
4:01 Epicurious: www.epicurious.com/recipes/fo...
4:53 Baked: www.karenskitchenstories.com/...
6:01 New York Cult Recipes: app.ckbk.com/recipe/newy12064...
6:53 King Arthur: www.kingarthurbaking.com/reci...
7:43 America's Test Kitchen
9:06 Junior's: www.food.com/recipe/copy-cat-...
9:52 Final verdict
10:34 Wrap up + finger guns!
In case you're new here, here's how a bake off works:
- I bake 9-12 different recipes in one day
- Samples of each recipe get distributed to a team of tasters
- Tasters rank each sample for flavor, texture and overall appeal
- We analyze the data and rank each recipe according to the scores!

[@janahavey1359]

Can’t wait to omit lemon from them all 🤣

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

LOL Jana. As long as I get to eat them!

[@nutcrackerdesserts6403]

Never had a black and white cookie but they sound soooo good

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

You must try, they're so delicious!!

[@carolc1818]

Your best video yet! Love the NY energy!

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Thanks Auntie Carol!!

[@shundajenkins4157]

Greenville SC

[@imperialsugar]

YUM!

[@WhippedFood]

Ther are looking so good 😍

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Thank you!!

[@isabelissimaa]

Also love seeing you with your fans and tasters. The bts of the tasting process was so fun!

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Aww thank you!! It was SO fun to meet everyone!! Glad you enjoyed the bts as much as me!!

[@catherineding3129]

Love your video! ! Could you please make a comparison of oatmeal raisin cookies?

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

On the list, hopefully one day soon!

[@Emily-kg6eh]

You gooooo pancake princess

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Thanks Emily!!!

[@YankeeFiddler13850]

Come to the Binghamton, NY area to try spiedies

[@500gulf]

Did the people you handed out the cookies to in the park rate or come up with a favorite? It would be curious to see what the consensus was if you did.

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Yes! They submitted rankings for all the cookies that were tasted. For these bake offs, I always do a full data analysis from the taster rankings and post the results (and favorite) in the blog post (which is coming soon!).

[@Tron7Thousand]

I totally confused with the title... I was expecting to see a Black and White woman cook off😁

[@omaryousef7616]

Came for the data, stayed for the finger guns. It is the Pancake Princess way.

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Lolol thank you Omar!

[@isabelissimaa]

YAS FINGER GUNS

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Hehe just for you!!

[@bostonboyz9935]

Where's the recipe

[@erikathepancakeprincess]

Recipes are now linked in the description!