China's secret internment camps
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 05. 2019
- ...and the internet detectives working to find them.
Become a Video Lab member! bit.ly/video-lab
China has been quietly detaining its population of Uighurs, the country’s Muslim minority, in internment camps. First-hand accounts from inside the camps paint a brutal picture of torture and political indoctrination. At first, China denied the existence of these camps and tried to cover them up. But as a network of academics and activists uncovered evidence of the camps' locations, and the reality of what’s going on inside, China changed its story.
Read more about about China’s crackdown on Muslims from Sigal Samuel on Vox: www.vox.com/future-perfect/20...
Further reading:
China’s brutal crackdown on the Uighur Muslim minority, explained
www.vox.com/2018/8/15/1768422...
China’s final solution in Xinjiang
www.hoover.org/research/china...
Migration and inequality in Xinjiang
geog.ucla.edu/sites/default/f...
www.wsj.com/articles/SB124811...
Tracking China’s Muslim Gulag
www.reuters.com/investigates/...
List of re-education camps in Xinjiang
/ list-of-re-education-c...
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what’s really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com.
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o
Or Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
Stop calling them "internment camps" call them by their actual name, concentration camps
C. B. Really?! Can they even do that?
@@c.b.7172 hey dummie its already banned in china
J Mach geez sry I don’t live there so I can’t know 😭🙄🙄
Kendrik MacDonald Same in America people call native prisoner of war camps = reservations but the US government has labeled each reservation a POW camp example Pine Ridge POW camp #334
Magdalena Queen It’s amazing how many people are blind to the world. When evidence is presented people just look the other way. If it doesn’t directly affect them, it’s none of their business.
WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT THIS
They are this is old
Because there is a lot of money to be made in China. It's the same reason people can't talk about Taiwan, Tibet, or Hong Kong.
Coz of islamophobia n China's growing power
eek yeah prove it
Safir how
The worst part is there is actually a majority of people in the internet denying the existence of this camps.
The wumaos of course
hmm
basted
it's a mintority, everyone has known about the huge list of crimes the CCP has committed the last several decades but nobody is doing anything against it because these Westerners pockets run deep thanks to the CCP. Freedom died in the year 1989 when the Tiananmen Square protest was obliterated.
The “Wolf Warriors” from China
What frustrates me is this was a big thing among most of the world, but then everyone just forgot about it after a few weeks.
Not everyone forgot, it's just that China is very intermixed with the global economy, making actions against it slow and difficult to implement. But in January, Joe Biden signed into law the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act, banning all exports from Xinjiang to the US. This is huge because cotton from Xinjiang alone made up 20% of the entire global cotton supply, and more countries are following suit.
Also this month the US and Germany have been pushing for the release of a UN report on the treatment of Uyghurs, which is set to come out very soon, and will then allow a motion for an investigation with unrestricted access to be performed by UN investigators. The movement for help is slower than anyone would like, but at least it's remaining steady, and hopefully soon it'll be enough return the rightful freedom to the Uyghurs, and safeguard their culture.
People need to understand that this is exactly what happened to the Jewish before ww2 started
Its inevitable
History does repeat itself, this can happen to any one of us in the future
I think us nowadays, we are informed of what happened during WW2 n all the things that happened during them, like concentration camps. We are taught that they are super bad, and yes they are, but when we hear concentration camps we think of WW2. I think what China is doing is covering it with that, that's why no one is talking about its because people don't realize that this is as bad as what happened during WW2.
so u mean that ww3 is coming..
and now it's also happening in China and Palestine
This is what journalism is supposed to be, to uncover truth
this is the type of stuff vice used to do, now they rank flavors of mountain dew. at least Vox is here
@黃杰禮 LOL, I think you have been hypnotized by Propoganda. Just because a few people out of 1 billion people commit a crime, it does not mean that 1 billion people commit the same thing.
@黃杰禮 hello there. Do you know how many Muslims on this Earth? If they are like what you described, no one is alive right now. I live in Malaysia. A Muslim Country with multi racial citizen. More than 70% people here are Muslims. No one here go around killing people or suicide bombing using the name of religion. I have been around them for 30 years and never felt myself in danger 🤣. Stop spreading false rumors you greedy people!
@黃杰禮 Besides, why you want we take them out from their own land? If you don't like them so much, give back their land and move on.
Wow Chinese are doing same thing what white people did in America killing culture .
200 BC - Great Wall of China
2000 AD - Great Camp of China
miss
Great firewall of China 2000
This for Just Turkic .
@Rabies 2.0 lol no
@Rabies 2.0 China literally controls Pakistan's economy they don't have a choice
China: "No long beards"
Confucian: am I a joke to u?
confucius*
😂😂😂😂🤭
no one know real confucius face
Lol they even ban Confucianism, Dalai Lama, Christianity, Buddhism, like basically every religion
@@cat3784 he’s not a god though, they acknowledge that. He was a human
modern concentration camps.... Where is the U.N.?
Most countries are afraid of China. A better question is why Middle eastern countries remain silent. With the way they treat Israel/Palestine you'd expect them to remain consistent.
@@ericdunn9001 Was thinking the same thing. Where are the middle eastern countries on this? Even neighboring countries like Kyrgyzstan not saying anything?
News flash! China is a permanent member of the UN Security Council
qwerty 100 Not just Saudi-Arabia but, Qatar, Emirates also north african countries Egypt, Morocco, Tunis, Algeria and Middle-eastern nuclear powerhouse Iran.
是不是傻，什么话都信！去新疆看看不就知道了吗！
Never take your freedoms for granted.
Sometimes freedom is not always the right way to solve everything. The recent Sri Lanka bombing for example, that kind of terrorist event will never ever happen in China.
@@CharlesLijt Forced Assimilation, imprisonment, torture and violation of human rights is NEVER a right way to solve anything
@@luit361 Yes it is. The problem is solved when all participants are "changed" or gone.
@@CharlesLijt Terrorist attacks only happen if the underlying population feels prosecuted for its existence. Torturing and maiming innocent civilians to prevent them from trying to separate from the country that marginalizes their identity does not necessarily mean you are preventing terror attacks. In fact, you are inflicting terror on a type of people just because who they are.
You want to protect against terrorism, there are plenty of good methods at doing that. Basically, what I am saying is you are a moron who also happens to be hypocritical and fallacious in your argument. Good job!
@@CharlesLijt I would prefer freedom over security any day. To say terrorist attacks don't happen in China is a bold statement. Do I need to remind you of Kunming in 2014, Urumqi in 2014, 2015 and 2016? Again, you are just an idiot. Good job!
Detains people for being extremist, also is keeping human beings in concentration camps. Hypocrisy at its finest.
I literially got an ad before this called “thank China”
Same
Ha ironic
😂😂😂
Xi Jin Ping is watching you
Thank them for removing Islamic radicalization.
All countries should do the same.
these camps seem awfully familiar idk why...
greetings from germany
WeirdChamp bring back old memories eh
@@LeviAckerman-iv9eq yeah the good old days :)
why the western world support the terrorist ?why the western world invade Syria and Iraq and Iran ?
@@tianlezheng6829 OK wumao
With all of these horrible things going on, I like your humorous spin on it. There's truth to it, at least.
Never trust anyone who talks about the necessity of 're-education'
Media can do anything. Right or not we cant judge from video only.
we are doing it in pre-education
As a Chinese, I think this video is just blackening China and talking nonsense. In Xinjiang, Han people lived in the Han Dynasty more than two thousand years ago, more than one thousand years earlier than Uygurs. And Uygurs are not Turks, they are Hui people. Another very clear fact is that the United States is the most active anti-Muslim country in the world. What qualifications do you have to say about China? Millions of people are in custody? Do you have any common sense? How many places do millions of people have to close down? Nonsense report, you may have deceived some people who do not know, but you can not deceive me. I have taught in Xinjiang, people live well, do not need your American care, want to evolve our country, sorry we do not need, first take good care of yourself, do not make trouble in other countries.
@@jack-sy2pl i think china is somewhat right or their cult never stops. See in Kashmir however it's being pushed by china and Pakistan but that's a whole diff issue.
Main issue is radicalized people.
Yeah, i mean the re-education of violent, poorly raised children is a terrible idea...
Germans: Hey! I’ve seen this one before.
Russia: Hey I’ve also seen it before
@@dexterjettster3683 gulag
@popular when
Every major power: hey! I’ve seen this one before.
@1450 green frog Native American "schools" , Japanese concentration camps at WW2.
The fact that China is on UN's human rights council demonstrates how much of a joke the UN is.
The 5 county UN power
USA , UK , France , Russia and China
If you look at it there's no South American or African countries
@@shweli4326 And you have 30% share for EU too! Reforms needed.
I think the UN is slowly going back to its old shadow...the League of Nations...
@@dimitrypetrenko3470 it has always been like that only. EU has 30% share in the security council, meanwhile Asia just has one representative ironically it is CHINA !. Africa & Latin America's doesn't even has any representative in security council it's like they don't have the power to take any decisions. It's polarised in the west and that's not a sustainable thing, in a multi-powered world.
They are one of the heads of the UN and that makes me mad
The world has said it would not allow these types of camps anymore and we continue to watch more and more country's commit these horrific attacks.
Jarid Gaming There isn't much the world can do
Be a bit more specific will you?
It’s because when it happens to Muslims people don’t care.
so happy it’s never happened in the US! sorry i mistyped that.
it’s terrifying to know that’s it’s happening all over the world, including the united states (look up immigrant “detention camps”
It’s not like the media has been focused on “AMERICAS HITLER WHITE SUPREMACY PIPELINE ALT RIGHT MUSLIM HATING BIGOT PRESIDENT” The media only cares about these camps now so they can war monger. Vox never cared about Muslims.
Irony dies a slow death everytime China speaks at World peace forums.
yash goenka lol
Can I retweet this?
@@husseinmohammed1431 yeah bro
I agree, but I could say the same for the U. S. though
No, irony is not only well and truly surviving, but is absolutely thriving thereby, more accurately....
Did that one guy just say “these are really just boarding schools”??? Boarding schools???!!
re-boarding (in the most literal sense of "boarding", if it were to be a verb) schools where the kids that are now adults don't return from.
More like Water boarding schools
Yep like the boarding schools for native american children that the US murdered this is happening not only in china but all major powers do this the only reason ur not finding much about the US doing this is because they pour in a lot of money to censor things that are against the US government
"China is violating human rights" well uh yeah they've been doing it for 80 years, where do you think North Korea got its ideas from?
We are repeating history how much more are we just gonna let slide
@Hernando Malinche Would prefer a world without it so we can start moving forward
@Hernando Malinche We prefer a world with less you.
leya mustapha I don’t know how else to put it other than some people who lack humanity will see torture and they will always try to defend that torture. What you give out comes back and I hope we can do enough good💜
@Hernando Malinche guess you don't even feel sorry for the jews you are sick how can you agree with all of this??
Hernando Malinche not every muslim is like that tough
The fact that there are some people supporting this makes me sick.
@Lukeftwny I need to be sent to the 're education camp' becuase I dont agree with torturing innocent people just becuase of their beliefs?
@@sulsur4151 I wanna know what kind brutality you have faced from Muslims?
@@sulsur4151 I'm muslim myself and what brutality?
MR. Pigeon Sir the person who invented algerbra was muslim. Without algebra, maths wouldn’t be complete and most technology wouldn’tbe made. Please search for facts before attacking people.
@Lukeftwny you should go to back school. Your teacher taught you something wrong.
Great series guys! I hope you decide to update it regularly again.
Google Maps coordinates for these Camps: 43°23'02.1"N 88°17'11.7"E - Now in 2021 there are so many more buildings.
Thanks! Let’s call a UAV drone strike ! 💥🇺🇸let’s free those poor folks there
Liar 🤥
Hong kong: And that's why we don't join this mess of a country.
aren't they being forced to?
@@TmonsterExtreme They're being forced to, but only because that is what should be done. Hong Kong IS a part of China and there is no denying that. It's completely ignorant and illogical to claim that Hong Kong isn't part of China...
@@cdrl3170 That doesn't mean Hong Kongers should lie down while their basic human rights are stripped away. Can you really blame them for protesting?
@@124085 Explain how their basic human rights are being stripped away, with evidence please.
@@cdrl3170 Google is your friend.
How many people know this secret?
It is now information
Game of Thrones reference 😂
@@daigoaisabli 😂
It has taken a life of its own
Isaac there’s no reliable source for the information so I wouldn’t get your panties too wet concern troll
Got sucks now
This is really interesting and scary. I really hope things like this get out more. People needs to know that these people are being oppressed, and they need our help. Due to the Chinese censorship they won't ever get any but still.
Use your brain to think why Chinese government detain those people. Have you ever witnesses yourself?
Xinjiang is open, you can go there.
don't know if anyone's still watching this but an update 4 years later:
I went to xinjiang about 3-4 months after this video was posted in 2019, which you could say was the "peak" of these internment camps. My grandparents live there so I have a perspective somewhat, and from what I could gather they know nothing about the camps. In 2019, the security and EVERYTHING was just so tight, there were security checkpoints everywhere, and when we were in the first one, it almost felt like clearing security and customs at an international airport. we almost got denied entry because of my US passport, but luckily my parents are Chinese citizens so they let me through.
covid took a MASSIVE toll on all these measures, and i went back just a month ago. now, the security checkpoints are nonexistent. while in 2019 you had to go through a full patdown, manual luggage inspection, a whole 40 minute procedure, now you don't even have to get off the vehicle. the bus/taxi driver just goes up to an officer booth and are let through. my cousin just took the gaokao and is heading to college, yet he STILL doesn't know of the internment camps that are literally just a couple miles from his home.
china seems to be taking a different route with xinjiang now, which is tourism. on our flight from Beijing to urumqi, the capital of xinjiang, 80% of the passengers were tourists with tourist groups. my grandparents small town of 70k people has been completely transformed from a run-down small area to a almost bustling tourist hotspot. in just a couple years, luxury hotels, theme parks, full on nature walks (mind you xinjiang is in the middle of the desert), and things like that have rapidly been built. my uncle said it was "unbelievable" how fast all the infrastructure was built. we visited one of the tourist "attractions", which was basically a bustling square with a theme park (that wasn't open yet), a hotel, hundreds of small shops, and a show plaza where uighurs put on dancing shows during the evening. surprisingly the square was packed full of people, most tourists. the same is happening in many other towns.
It take at least 15 hours from urumqi to one of those camps with car
WHY is this not in the mainstream media, and WHY haven’t I heard of this yet
Because the mainstream media doesn't actually do anything except regurgitate BuzzFeed level "news."
that what China want..
@@kazardomain WTF ?Is china owen all world media ?im chinese muslim from xi an ,im totally agree with govement reeducate those people ,before they doing Al jihad in china or your county !
@@user-xm4bx9lk8b im not sure about the community history there wether in the past they have ever committed or involving in any terrorism bombing killing Chineese ppl..enlighten me on this..
@@kazardomain they did a lot bed things ,even we are muslim city ,but in our city we are not welcome those people .
They are CONCENTRATION CAMPS, not internment
Concentration, internment, detainment, they’re all the same
nah they're re-education camps
bbqbeef nope they are concentration camps what is there to re-educate? A person should have the right to follow a religion without anyone’s influence.
Neoniii 000 not very many countries do that... hence why America was a hotspot for immigrants we allow that legally... a lot do not
@lucid_poppin You're calling ME a china bot? What
it's really sad for me as Chinese. After the BCI incident (H&M, Nike and companies banned XinJiang cotton, which angers chinese people), basically all of chinese knows about world's accusation on Xinjiang camps. Yet 99% of the people believe China has no problem at all and all the camps were just made up by the opposite countries like USA or UK... Even with the evidence in their face. Only 1% of Chinese, who usually in the center of Beijing or Shanghai, know that the camps are real. But the government would censor it anyway.
那所谓的“集中营”里面是什么人你不知道？是个中国人你不知道之前昆明发生过什么吗？被关进去的每一个无辜的，都十成十的恐怖分子。
你要是个汉族人我真为你感到悲哀，回族人已经在中国的待遇够好了，哪个少数民族不凌驾汉族之上？你还说得出种族清洗这种话，那祝你以后哪天被极端伊斯兰教恐怖分子袭击吧。
扩建的学校工厂卫星图就是证据？被洗得很彻底
@Quare Lay no such thing as a School Factory. Sorry you been misled
@@AngelV1sionMusic What I meat is schools and factories, not school-factory. Sorry you are misled by CZcams’s poor translation.
@@quarelay2486其实集中营确实存在…也没必要否认，老胡很早以前还拿这事当作正面例子说过。只是我们都知道西方媒体喜欢在这事上做片面或者虚假的报道，我们自己人知道就行了。还有就是我觉得这个视频大部分还是对的，比如我们不在乎外界对新疆的评价😂国内本来就不怎么喜欢穆斯林，我也不想隐藏这个😅永远不会原谅他们曾经对汉族发动的这么多次恐怖袭击
One other detail to note: There is another Muslim ethnic group in China known as the Hui (回). The only difference is that the Hui are basically Han Chinese who converted to Islam. The Hui speak Mandarin Chinese and live both in Xinjiang and east of it, towards central China.
What China is doing with these internment camps is no different than what the U.S. and Canada did to the Native Americans in forcibly assimilating them. The only difference is that those North American countries acknowledge what happened and allow for free and open discussion of that history, whereas China tries to hide what it is doing.
This is how you create extremists not how you integrate people
I doubt the CCP really cares, they killed nearly 100 million of their own people during the great Leap Forward alone, so I doubt they'd worry too much about killing off the 11 million Uyghurs if they have to. Judging by the UN's track record in Africa and Yugoslavia with race wars and genocide I doubt they'll do anything to stop China.
Please imagine millions of Muslim inside your country and they’re not well-educated and easily get brainwashed by terrorism and extremism. Now how is to create extremists?
@@Heirenmusilin "Now how is to create extremists?" what?
@@Heirenmusilin im guessing you are chinese nationalist.
These is how you tackle extremists and future terrorists..
“These are... uhhh” *looks at paper* “ah, boarding schools.”
Seems legit.
@8:25
These people are so indoctrinated they cannot tell the difference between truth and lies. It would be so satisfying to call them out though.
THE so called schools are absolutely concentration camps. Still, they are not murdering people inside. That forces someone to lose their freedom, while at the same time cut the resource of terrorists. USA spent longer time in the middle east, doing worse.
Also, China took control of Xinjiang back in Han dynasty, about 2100 years ago, when Muslim didn't even exist. After the collapse of Han dynasty, China regained it in Tang and Qing dynasty, and ROC till today's PRC. So Historically, it's China's land, there's no reason that China shouldn't take control of it.
And in Qing, the place is controled by Mongolians, not Uyghurs. Uyghurs are the last people going there after Han, Mongolians and Hui and everyone else, then they claim "it's Uyghurs' land". LMAO.
@@lewismay5909 oh bullshit. That history so only does not matter today. The world and culture was a much different place than today. Today this is completely bullshit human rights violation. Genocide without guns is still the same. Let me guess you a han Chinese so why would you care other than these are fellow humans. You are are a terrible human being.
skel8484 sorry but you don’t realize that there are 1.4 billion Chinese in China. The majority, included Uyghurs, is against terrorism. There are other 55 races for Chinese government to take care of. Han is the one with the least protection in China. You are too ignorant to know anything. ;-)
Can we not ignore the Christians they're detaining as well?
ok if this is true, it's now a personal vendetta.
We shouldn't. These are atrocities commited by a dictatorship and the International community doesn't do anything to prevent this.
Atheists who rule the west are happy when they see Christians persecuted , they only care about muslim
Little to no Christians are being abducted here. Christianity is strong in China. Sit down.
@@wrldreem thanks Mao, always good to hear from you.
And hundreds of thousands of Christians aren't having church in the sewer systems either, huh?
Read a book.
Xinjiang is a massive region - the enforced labor camps can be seen on google earth and on satellites like shown in this video. They are strategically placed a 15 hour drive away from the tourist attractions.
The chinese news sources hire vloggers to go to big Xinjiang cities to show the good outward conditions, while obviously not showing the camps placed in to the faraway fields.
Literally one of these kinds of travel vlogs showed the same exact people following the vlogger around, even spying on the vlogger from outside windows while they visited a khazah home.
This is the sort of reporting that i love from vox bringing these issues that arent being covered enough by mainstream media.
Those are not news, ask BBC.
I kinda stopped watching the mainstream media a month ago. They brought out a bunch of pundits to debate about the Mueller Report; I got tired of it.
@@sahilhassan8538 i got tried of it two years ago lol, trump pooped 5 man panel, but ones he did samething they like bad whem it's bad, hooo he is so presidential ones he bombs Syria.
I've seen this quite a few times on my country's mainstream media (netherlands)
It almost feels like they have some bad news about China at least once every week
You should be critical of their reporting just as much as you are critical of hearing stuff from China. Vox isn't exactly unbiased.
Why does this seem like the beginning of the Holocaust. This is saddening
Kenny the killing already happened in 2009, by the Muslims, targeting the Hans, but I guess you care more about imaginary deaths than actual deaths
sichuang he So there should be mass detention of white christians then because of the Christchurch mosque shooter?
Kenny because it is?
@@sichuanghe8678 you're evil
Andrew Rapport yes, this world really disgusts me.
Very good journalism. May Allah have mercy on the uighurs.
Bismillah brother
Allah sleep
Freedom for Uighurs !
i feel so disgusted by some of the comments that ACTUALLY supporting this violence like where is humanity RIGHT NOW??
Are you kidding me right now. What did they say.
@@bazil4146 one of many comments read 'why is China doing this? It is thier golden age to learn how to make bombs.'
I support this violence because it's just logical and people like you only see the one side and not the full story. Just think about why.
@@anonwithamnesia explain why you support Muslim killings in china??
calledmaxi just because a rebel group that is trying to separate Xinjiang from the rest of china by is causing attacks in China Doesn’t other Muslims get to be punished just because of some group’s actions.
Its an open secret. Everyone knows but nobody says anything.
China can do anything they want really (atleast within China) and they're only getting started.
Sounds familiar....
Sounds familiar....
that is actual untrue as I lived in china for many years, and my aunt's family live in china as well, and there is alot of propaganda against Uighurs and if you where to get caught speaking out against the communist party you where arrested.
No they did say something but as soon as they did, they r taken away from their family, their friends and simply disappear from face of the earth. They surveillance and blocked anybody that talked abt it on the internet, so the masses wouldn’t know
“We didn’t know we were making memories, we were having fun” - Xi Jinping
isn't that a quote from Winnie the pooh
@@neraa.2165 you don’t get the joke
Hold up
@@UnKewledPenguin yes
💀
This is so saddening, and yet people deny that this is happening.
They're Concentration Camps. Calling them Internment Camps is just underselling what it is.
E X A C T L Y ! ! ! !
It's strange that no one in the video used the terms cultural cleansing or cultural genocide.
UTubeTulip they could be sued by chinese officials and face a tough backlash over such a claim even though we all agree on it
Because they’re not being killed at this point in time. Just “re-educated” and imprisoned.
Jillian Michelle Genocide, at least by the UN definition, doesn’t necessarily involve killing. Sterilization, forcible transfer of children, and creating conditions designed to cause at least partial destruction of the group (such as disease-ridden environments) are all examples of genocide under the Geneva Convention.
@@prettygirlrock444 well -cide denotes killing, though. Insecticides kill insects, it doesn't transfer them.
Turnip Society ‘Cultural genocide’ is a term interchangeable with ‘cultural cleansing’: you’re not the only person confused by it, as ‘cultural genocide’ is a proposed concept that has no accepted definition. The term was removed from 1990s drafts of UNDRIP for that exact reason, if I remember right.
I just curious about the selfie token by a man in handcuff. He still had the freedom to make it?
How do you see what goes on in the buildings from the satellite images that you can call them concentration camps?
History is repeating itself and everyone is silent
China will soon take over the world. We need to think optimistically
yup, im sure if these tortured people were americans the whole media would talk about this
There's a policy of a appeasment working here
Thats China's specialty. They cover up everything
The UN is a joke. Where was the UN in the Rwandan genocide, the Indonesian genocide, the Rohingya genocide, the Cambodian genocide, the DRC genocide, the Silent Holocaust, or any other genocide in a foreign country? The UN is just a validator for the dominant powers of the world.
they are trying to prevent extremism by creating extremism? flawless logic right there.
Until they get too powerful and it goes out of hand.
@Elric Newgate Are you living in a cave? You dont heard the news? China is infiltrating every country and spying and manipulating them. They will be the next USA.
Elric Newgate chinese extremism is better than islamic extremism. until these camps become extermination camps and we discover afterwards hardly any of those detained were extremists to begin with.
@@haleemashireen1923 that's such a brief explanation to sum up this video 👏👏
Elric Newgate ‘it stays in China’ the same thought everyone had over the Corona Virus.
As a Christian, it’d be wrong to not fight for these people.
You mean prisons. They are in prisons
Concentration camps*
They’re literally making Hitler V2 and everyone is like.
yep.. k, cool.
there is not only Uighurs, more than one million Kazakhs in prisons now.. Also many Kyrgyz and Mongolians..
Minus hard labor works, illegal medical experimentation, gas chambers, on site execution, and mass murders, it's different.
Dumbest comment
Guess what? It’s cuz they’re not white.
Chelle Castillo you have the same last name of me. Cool
Hm, a 'Boarding school'.
Out in the middle of the desert.
Twice the size of the nearby city.
Seems legit. 🙄😒
With high border walls and watch towers.
Steven Manning lol
It's Hogwarts!
Yes yes it is very good boarding school my daughter go there i recommend you send kid there!
That's actually how Chinese boarding schools look like.
As a Pakistani, I am really, really ashamed to see this and the fact that our government is not doing anything about it
(respectfully) your government isnt even a government. The country's ruled by the army. OfCourse they wont do anything.
Because all world governments are the same, they stand together for utilities not because of similarities
That's why people should see each other as humans and only that
Colony of China
-300,000,000,000 social credit 😱😱
This is horrendous. I didn't have any idea this was going on
mrglasgowswrinklyauldbawz me either
Same and i lived in China ?
According to the Chinese these are western lies?
You also have no idea that terrorism killed hundreds of innocents lives in this region because the western media will never report it
Seth Leoric it is only ok for US to fought wars and invaded middle eastern because they want revenge for 911, but when China trying to contain terrorism in its own country they blame no human rights
"Factories or even schools" you already know somethings wrong with the world when those two are considered visually similar
Yeah, school is basically a factory for kids these days
Schools are meant to be like factories, the modern idea of schools was actually developed to train factory workers.
@Logan Jones. Ugh, no, they technically aren’t. If they were, students wouldn’t be the vast majority of every major protest and social movement.
@Logan Jones. is that what made you justify dropping out?
read foucault
When you realise China is doing the same things as Germany in 1934
Nope they are not
@@That_GuyCZcams wdym??
@@user-vk6ve5ip9m China is not trying to start wars or occupy foreign land.
@@That_GuyCZcams they occupied Tibet.
And they want to occupy Taiwan.
@@davidmason8253 *occupate*
Anyways you are right
imagine doing this kind of reporting and then neglecting the very real fact that our government is consistently doing worse here in the US and in Guantanamo Bay
every large protest, especially for black rights, in the past four years have ended in police violence or tear gassing or some other form of aggression to stop peaceful protests.
we have to look at ourselves and our own functions before we can ever cast shame on others.
the US ripped families apart and cages children who are looking for a stable home.
the US incarcerated mass amounts of black folk for possession of marijuana, and used their cheap, basically free prison labor to build our public infrastructure (slavery)
it is astounding how deeply ingrained being anti-china is in this country, and it makes sense. this american country and economy was FOUNDED on abusing human rights (native americans, black slaves) how could we expect to be anything but that?
look inward and carry some self awareness before we ever try to spread our "greatness" to other countries who are actually taking care of their citizens better.
It's hard to find people who say the truth
what I want to say is what u said,Im live inXingJIang,same situation like ur Guantanamo Bay.Ur minority one who have intellect in CZcams
internment camps is a sugar coating for concentration camps.........but the saddest part is that this time no one is going help them people
Tiny Blue Dot :(
@@Konstantinos1648 re-education camp is just a nice name for concentration camp (which itself was back then a nice sounding name)
believe me, as a German I'm kinda a natural expert on internment camps and genocide
hoping America hears the call to oil
dasyad00 someone’s bout to get “liberated”
12 UN representative has visited the camp. 9 muslim nation feel nothing wrong. That the mainstream media never report.
This topic is trending again thanks to Twitter hope more people know about this now
Wow Lizzy no matter how much it trends we can’t do anything about it unless you want another world warm
Last week tonight also picked this up
Stephen Saravia • 99 years ago I know this might not be the time to laugh but your comment made me cackle
But the problem is that Twitter is heavily liberal and will avoid the CCP and its problems. Even when there are several.
hope they know about a high school to keep up this myth of a genocide. whatever.
It sad to see no one talking about this anymore, while people are still suffering. It's sad to see people ignoring something this series and not trying to help. What a world we live in.
Imagine if this was Muslims doing this to people who weren't Muslims. There would've been international outrage (same for rohingya, no one cared really) and an invasion. Which Zeppelli is that? gyro?
It was the same in WWII, back during those… events. The people at the time pretended to not know what was going on, but believe me, they did.
Is there any solid evidence other than pieces of clips here and there provides in this video?
You literally have witnesses/victims narrating their experience and you're asking for proof?
@@blahblahblah5924 Problems is, this is hugely different from what I heard from my friend in Xinjiang. I asked them face to face. They do have their own dissatisfaction with the government, but those several witnesses/victims in this footage are just.... not on the same page.
“China is violating human rights” Ah yes the floor here is made out of floor
mao
@@gaoelnlaojehc8913 l mao
Did you know that if you share videos defending china on the internet they will be taken down by america and you will be arrested. And yet America says china does that.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Jets Flighter Literally the first right in America’s constitution says that you have the right of freedom of expression, speech included. Also the video highlights China arresting people who have different views
@@zeta4115 I will buy you a can of coke of you could verify such claim.
CZcams notify everyone this is something worth recommending
Darris Hawks where did you hear that? 🧐
Darris Hawks um no?
yes please!!
Evelyn Pichardo you know youtube is the first line of anti-China media
No it's not
thank you for covering this, we need more of this.
My friend’s friend spent 5 years in these camps. Witnessed organ harvesting and beatings.
proof?
Sadly China is too much of a lucrative trade partner for most countries to care doing something anything it.
Exactly. The Uyghurs are also very patient People and don’t deserve this.
Just like with Saudi-Arabia and their oil
Sad but true. And if a country or two should decide to "step up", there are still massive hurdles like trading embargos and a massive army...
Right
At least trump is doing something
The scary thing is that people living in china aren’t aware of these things. If i still lived there, i wouldn’t know so many things like this.
Edit: this blew up. Wow i didn’t think my random thought would invoke so many discussions.
And i must address: please be respectful on this platform. It’s great to have disagreements and exchange ideas, but please be respectful and open minded.
I lived in China when I was little 2007-2014, and i was certainly not into politics or social issues as a child. So many things i don’t know could be just me being an ignorant kid.
However, i do think that it’s wrong to ban social media platforms such as CZcams and search engines such as Google in an attempt to censor or prohibit knowledge. Freedom of uncensored knowledge is a human right, tho it’s not possible to have anything uncensored, there should be at least freedom of press in every country. People should be able to see every side of the story and decide for themselves. Censoring and denying acts of violence is wrong in itself, and it is not a problem only within China.
Ragnar Lothbrok most Chinese people couldn’t care less it’s the government not the people. China isn’t like USA where people vote for things. The government just does them
Ragnar Lothbrok no...as a Chinese I don’t think so, it’s impossible China will become Muslim country it’s a very small minority.
I searched on baidu, China’s relevant of google, and the only report I found says that these are all made up by western media. The majority of Chinese have no idea about this issue
Yonna zhong 当然了，我只是随便说说而已
Just like the ordinary German citizens about the concentration camps holding Jews
my GOD!
how can you judge someone as POTENTIAL criminal ?
But it's so unbelievable that what he said happened in where we live😐I never know that we live so painful
Too many countries depends on China, so they become invisible in a way.
The 1 million detainee figure is unreliable because it is only based on satellite images. No group other than the Chinese government know the real figure. Western media fail to mention that some of these detained Uyghur Muslims are religious extremists who preach Salafism and Wahhabism in Xinjiang. Salafism and Wahhabism are two extremely conservative ideologies based on the belief in returning to a purer Islam as practiced in the time of the Prophet Mohammed. These Muslims have caught the Chinese government’s attention as terrorist groups like ISIS and al Qaeda draw on elements of these teachings. They are different from the Muslims that live in the West who appreciate and abide by western liberal laws and values. Some Uyghurs that are not religious extremists are indeed sent to re-educational camps. These Uyghurs are poor and low educated farmers from Southern Xinjiang who don't speak much Chinese and only know how to farm. Most of these people live in poverty and feed themselves on growing wheat, raise cows and sheep on the oasis using the most traditional ways of agriculture. However, it is extremely vulnerable and sensitive to the harsh climate changes and water scarcity in Southern Xinjiang. Their food is purely based on the amount of water they get. If it is too hot in the summer and if you get little water from the mountains, you might end up with no food or no money.
The re-education camps teach these poor Uyghur farmers the national law, Chinese language and new skills (modern farming and manufacturing labour skills) so that they can move out of poverty and move to Northern Xinjiang where there are more opportunities. Western media are lumping the Uyghurs farmers and religious extremists together as if they learn in the same camp/schools, when they're not. They all indeed go to re-education camps because they're there to learn. However, farmers can go home, the religious extremists cannot.
The religious extremists are sent to re-educational camps and not prison because they haven't done anything severely wrong, just been caught preaching/practicing Salafism and Wahhabism. Salafism and Wahhabism is extremely backward interpretation of Islam and we should not be supporting these people. These conservative Islam ideologies are flourishing in many Muslim-majority areas of China because Chinese ISIS fighters have returned to Xinjiang to recruit new members. They are recruiting poor low educated Uyghurs farmers because they can be easily radicalized.
yes
揭穿美國雙重標準：警察暴力鎮壓「佔領華爾街」運動
czcams.com/video/eCPfd6xm8YM/video.html
#新疆事件
@@sparkworks4401 What would you think if you were forced to eat dogs? Or abandon your beliefs (whatever they are) just because someone who is nothing like you will torture you if you don't? And we don't know what's all going on in the camps. For all we know they're committing genocide on a scale not seen since the holocaust.
Yes, we have no way of knowing the exact number of people in these camps, but that doesn't mean Vox is over-estimating. For all we know, they may actually be under-estimating! And as I said, only the Chinese government and their victims know what's going on in those camps. Look at what Hitler managed to get away with for years. For all we know the Chinese may be doing something just as bad, if not worse. And the fact that they're doing this to a religious minority CLEARLY has parallels to the holocaust.
Though honestly, with how China's becoming more and more brazen, it may not be long until war breaks out and we do find out everything. I mean, they HAVE been covertly taking over Africa, and of course there's their actions in the south China sea. Oh, and they've been antagonizing Taiwan and India for a year or two now. They're obviously looking to pick a fight with SOMEONE. Who will win, of course, is anyone's guess.
This is a minor point, but the video initially refers to the Uyghurs as "China's Muslim minority", but there are other Muslims in China too. The Hui people are also traditionally Muslim. The main difference here is geographic location (The Hui are located more in the central interior, along the Gobi desert, iirc), and ethnicity/language (the Hui are sometimes considered "Han-ified", or a subset of the wider Han-category.). This isn't to take away from the video, just to add a bit of nuance, and to stress that this is less about religion (which Western audiences might assume), and more about the Chinese government wanting to secure strategic areas and industries from a population they consider potentially "illoyal" due to several different factors (and the video does go on to highlight this very well).
True i wanted to raise this point as well.
Also Kazakhs
@@Andy-vc7eo "They are different from the Muslims that live in the West who appreciate and abide by western liberal laws and values." Most Han Chinese are different from people who live in the west too. "Most of these people live in poverty and feed themselves on growing wheat, raise cows and sheep on the oasis using the most traditional ways of agriculture." Many Han Chinese are farmers and/or live in poverty too. That doesn't make it OK to put them in "re-education centers".
There are big procent of Hui people in Xinjang, they preferred to live with us because of the religion. East Turkestan is the home of all muslims in China: Uighurs, Hui or Dungan Chinese, Kazakh, Kirgiz, Tadzhik people. All these ethnic groups are haunted. But the most important thing is that in Kazakhstan or Kirgizstan governments prefer to do nothing, because they have a money flow from China. That's why they pretend blind while our(mid asian) people are tortured and murdered. Disgrace.
@@YaohanChen Are these Han Chinese susceptible to radicalization by Islamic terrorist groups in an area that will soon become a hub of trade and commerce?
Can you give the longitude and latitude number of these camp location， so I can take some ground image and post online plz
Yeah those are definitely Concentration Camps trust me An old man from Argentina told me "Ja" when i asked him
It's pretty alarming that this isn't bigger news. Events like these shouldn't be allowed to happen at this day and age.
North Korea also has camps like this.
People in Palestine think so.
@@bigmike9128 So does Chechnya
too bad politicians around the world see China's authoritarianism as the "Ideal" governemnt perfect for ruling over all of Mankind
JαmëŽǎɏe And America
Eerie... This is reminiscent of the way the Nazis tried to hide their concentration camps when they first started building them...
Seems more like Native American reservations to me.
This time no one will blame China because they will just say it is internal matter,U.S is imperialistic and world will just node.
@@davidulanovsky8943 in what way?
It's like both.
@@leonleon2021 Maybe it's closer to Soviet labor camps?
Can we get more details?
What an evil government
"When you think Hitler's 6 million is high, remember there's always an Asian better than you."
- Mao Zedong
@@sbaeneg4738 it was war and war is war but my people love
@@sbaeneg4738 USSR was the worst
@@sbaeneg4738 Less of what happened in WW2, but more of what happened in the gulag camps and the collectivization of Kulak agriculture land.
Sbaeneg the sad part is my families had to deal with these atrocities
Mao Zedong only killed own compatriots
The most sad thing to me is that the our Pakistani media never tells us that of torture on Muslims in China ever!
The enemy isn’t Washington it’s Beijing
X i the enemy is every superpower
@@xi7837 what if they're both enemies?
@@sittingbackandwatchingital3845 Very ironic username you Have. :P
@@nisargayer3222 I'm from india and government says they're trying to cut all trade from china but still depends on them. That's what the media says .
You can’t just show people a random building and call it a concentration camp🙄️🙄️🙄️
yet they still call us terrorists 😐
“ They sort of look like factories or even schools.” That says something about our educational system.
That we give every child $100k in schooling?
@@yazansakran3326 I don't know about you, but I would have done much better with the cash.
*from a satellite image.
Cause school develop synthetics
@@yazansakran3326 In most of Northern Europe it is indeed given to you, in America you need to pay it back.
I don’t see anyone taking about this anymore....
*To "Funky Town" melody*
TALKAboutit TalkAboutIt TalkAboutIt TalkAboutIttt...
because internet has a short memory and everything fades in three seconds
Cuz people rather do tik toks and track news on celebrities
Corona virus conveniently happened making everyone forget about this, Hong Kong, Tibet and other freedom and human right issues in China. I'm sure it's just a coincidence.
keep talking my friend
This was posted 2 years ago and at this point, I won't be surprised if this is still going on. Heck, I won't be surprised if one day we discover they have their own gas, or basic torture chambers. With all their lying, we can only expect the worst.
It is still going on. You can go see it in google maps
@@andrewdoesyt7787 I'm looking for it, can you give me the coordinates?
I wonder how many people can live in a camp like this in 8.54? There's not many buildings and so many open areas. 1000? Then you will need at least 1000 camps like this for 1 million people. Does it make any sense?
Thanks for covering an issue that the mainstream media isn’t covering, Vox. And this is coming from a conservative! Keep it up!
Im ut 99th like
Why does it matter that you are conservative? This video didn’t have any American political bias. It’s about China.
Owen_newO Vox often has political bias, but this topic isn’t being covered by the mainstream media and I was thanking Vox for that. If you have a problem with me giving thanks, then I don’t know how to help you.
@@owen551 Left leaning media outlets tend to try and turn a blind eye to China's crimes.
Not because they think it's morally right necessarily, but because it would make pushing their agenda harder.
Can't keep on shouting "big government" when the biggest government in the world is disappearing people into concentration camps, just because of their religious beliefs or segregating immigrants and minorities from the system that only benefits the Han Chinese, constantly violating human rights and freedoms that you would guaranteed in any other country.
And they'll only leave alone the Han Chinese that don't badmouth the government, too.
I can assure you, being 100% Han Chinese is not going to get you anywhere if you dare mention Tiananmen Square.
That will get you at the very least fired and evicted, if not exiled.
If they come to the conclusion that extradition is way too much trouble they WILL send you to a camp, where they most likely will try to break you. If they don't decide that killing you is the fastest way of getting rid of the problem.
"Long live Xi Jinping."
Yep. Definitely not a dictator.
Signs of not a dictator,
Need to chant his name everywhere
His pictures are everywhere
Loves to build “camps”
@Alex Mercer unless he dies; he is quite fat.
"Long live Xi Jinping." is fake news.I am Han Chinese.I swear I never say this words.And I adivise you that you can try to search ''detention camps USA'' on youtube.you can see what VOX can not report.Because VOX is USA's dog.
It’s so fake that I’m 100% sure whoever made this “long live Xi” up is not even Chinese.
@@ewgegkeugrwug1739 America don't need camp they use media to brainwash people. No wonder why America culture so shallow.
cant germany just copyright claim them?
China oppressing Uighurs yet hand guns to uighurs and having them as police officer? 4:57
@Joe Guajardo oppressed people don’t usually got hired as police and given gun?
KEEP POSTING ABOUT THIS PLEASE
Im a muslim from china ,the govement is doing the right thing .
@@user-xm4bx9lk8b 🤨
WTF what do you mean
أمين
@@liluzi_9mm78 There is a fundamental problem in Islam.
According to Islamic law apostasy is identified by a list of actions such as conversion to another religion, denying the existence of God, rejecting the prophets, mocking God or the prophets, idol worship, rejecting the sharia, or permitting behavior that is forbidden by the sharia, such as adultery or the eating of forbidden foods or drinking of alcoholic beverages. The majority of Muslim scholars hold to the traditional view that apostasy is punishable by death or imprisonment until repentance, at least for adult men of sound mind.
Laws prohibiting religious conversion run contrary to Article 18 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which states that "[e]veryone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance."
The English historian C. E. Bosworth suggests the traditional view of apostasy hampered the development of Islamic learning, arguing that while the organizational form of the Christian university allowed them to develop and flourish into the modern university, "the Muslim ones remained constricted by the doctrine of waqf alone, with their physical plant often deteriorating hopelessly and their curricula narrowed by the exclusion of the non-traditional religious sciences like philosophy and natural science," out of fear that these could evolve into potential toe-holds for kufr, those people who reject God."
And to remind, the biggest fuss leading Islam to the current xenophobic situation, is because there are no working of progression. Take ISIS, they justify Islamic teaching about enslaving women, destruction of scientific researches and somehow 10% Muslims in the world agree with it.
看得爽么？小朋友？
So is nobody going to do anything against this are we just going to sleep on it????
The sad problem is no one cares because these people are Muslim.
@@444_taziri what are we gonna do then? Start a war? WW3?
juntingiee yes so everyone can start care about other people’s lives✨
Pineapple Pizza Productions I know but I mean the media literally doesn’t show it:(
Trump is doing some things about China. Some presidents are now banning some Chinese apps. Tensions will elevate in coming months. What's terrifying is that Joe Biden defended China multiple times. If he wins, the CCP wins.
This is so sickening.
they seem to be getting concentrated to one area, I wonder what their gonna do next.
huh, I feel like i've seen this before
Seems very similar doesn't it
Can't put my finger on it
Oh dam here we go again
History repeats itself doesn’t it ....
Hamza Khan Mandela effect?!?
Who’s here from the eyelash tutorial
nomthi mkhwebu HAHAAHHAHA
me
nomthi mkhwebu me, i’m so confused
Me
nomthi mkhwebu how you know
Why did i get an ad promoting xinjiang and directly saying that these 'rumours' about xinjiang are wrong at the end of this video 🤔
Disgusting, shameful behaviour.