Plato | Symposium - Full audiobook with accompanying text (AudioEbook)
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 01. 2020
- #Symposium #Plato #Dialogues
Platonic Dialogues Playlist: • Platonic Dialogues
Alcibiades: • Plato | Alcibiades - F...
Gorgias: • Plato | Gorgias - Full...
Euthyphro: • Plato | Euthyphro - Fu...
Apology: • Plato | Apology - Full...
Crito: • Plato | Crito - Full a...
Phaedo: • Plato | Phaedo - Full ...
Cratylus: • Plato | Cratylus - Ful...
Theaetetus: • Plato | Theaetetus - F...
Sophist: • Plato | Sophist - Full...
Statesman: • Plato | Statesman - Fu...
Phaedrus: • Plato | Phaedrus - Ful...
Philebus: • Plato | Philebus - Ful...
PDF of the translation I use: fragmentsofragments.files.wor...
I’m getting my undergrad in philosophy and I have ADHD. This was very helpful. Naturally the dialogues are easier to read than other texts in general, but having this audio saved me a lot of time and helped me focus.
Thats awesome Clayton! I find having the audio and text together is the best and most intense way of focussing on the dialogues. Its super clear if you have lost attention and you can rewind and go back a bit. Happy to hear that this had helped you in your studies. :)
glad to see im not the only ADHDer that simply cant stand to read a book on its own! :D
Clayton, if you can read and understand Plato, even you have to read 100 times, you don't have ADHD. Majority of people can't understand Plato in depth. Those are much worse than ADHD problem. Paideia Society
I was doing my undergrad in Philosophy and I too suffer from ADHD, but after a semester in it, I decided to switch my major to Psychology and my minor to Philosophy.
Shut up
0:05 Introductory Dialogue
15:25 The Speech of Phaedrus
21:12 The Speech of Pausanias
37:27 The Speech of Eryximachus
47:36 The Speech of Aristophanes
1:03:09 The Speech of Agathon
1:15:48 Socrates Questions Agathon
1:21:49 Diotima Questions Socrates
1:26:21 The Speech of Diotima
1:51:43 Alcibiades' Entrance
1:59:59 The Speech of Alcibiades
2:20:53 Final Dialogue
Thanks. Great time stamps 👍
1:55 Setting of Socrates' dialogue on love
3:08 Apollodorus throwing shade on businessmen
15:25 Phaedrus initial speech about love: What is love? (Baby don't hurt me)
17:22 Phaedrus explains why a city/army of men who love one another would be the most powerful (they share shame/pride in one another)
21:20 Phaedrus states that love gets the highest honor
22:28 Common vs Heavenly love-- everything is either noble or shameful (including love). Depends on how it is performed
26:38 Athens and Sparta have simple understandings of the complex idea of love. Elis and Boeotia are inarticulate and lust-driven.
Iona and the Persian Empire ban Love, Sport, and Philosophy bc they are tyrannical states. This weakens the citizens (27:47)
31:12 Love is not inherently good/bad but depends solely on the behavior in its reaction
33:29 Honorable love is the only acceptable way of love, for the sake of wisdom and virtue
37:33 Eryximachus takes Aristophanes’ turn bc he has the hiccups lol
38:00 According to Eryximachus’ study of science, love is a diety that occurs in all forms of life, including plants and the Gods. Not just humans.
43:34 Synopsis of Eryximachus' speech: Love is the harmony from balancing good and bad, or opposites. Similar to yin and yang.
48:25 Aristophanes begins his speech, explaining that there was a 3rd gender, which was a combo of male and female (androgynous)
53:03 According to Aristophanes, humans reproduce with one another because our love derives from us wanting to be in our natural state, combined together. The womb, genitals, navel, etc are all reminders of our separation which was a punishment by Zeus
58:06 Love is our pursuit to be whole/complete with someone else
1:03:20 Agathon begins his speech
1:06:25 Love is the youngest/most energetic of the Gods. It also is the most powerful, over-powering pleasures and passions, which makes it moderate
1:11:00 Agathon views love like Christians view Jesus, a "savior". Source of all positive and drains negativity
1:20:02 Socrates proves that love can't always be good and beautiful because it is what it desires
1:21:50 Socrates begins his speech which is one he heard from Diotima
1:23:00 Philosopher's mean
1:29:02 Explanation of the lovers of wisdom*
1:33:04 According to Diotima- Love is the desire to possess anything good. Not just a companion but sport, philosophy, etc
1:36:52 Love is eternal. It is the reproduction (pregnancy) of desiring beautiful/good. This is the immortality of mortal things
1:41:58 *Important monologue* Diotima explains the differences of pregnancy in body vs. soul
1:52:50 The correct way to show up to a party 😂
2:00:00 Alcibiades begins his speech- a praise (and critique) of Socrates
😀👍
I teared up at Alcibiades speech. He's just so hapless and genuine. Like everybody else gives these ordered, almost rehearsed orations (to the point where their overly pure ideals of love almost seem fake) then he brashly tumbles in and spills his guts about how much pain he's in because Socrates doesn't love him back. Its just kinda moving. Like it is beautiful, sad and funny.
Wow, just discovered this, I’m blown away. No wonder these are classics.
Enjoy working your way through all of the dialogues on the channel in the Plato playlist 👍
Many thanks to Mr. Lewis Kirt for posting these Plato's classical Dialogue. This is a treasure of teaching far beyond than many could imagine, a lifetime study and training for humanity and many others. Paideia Society
I can feel how passionate you are as you read. Thank you for your devotion
You’re welcome. I’m glad it comes through. 😀
Starting this book 11/28/23 6:36 PM EST
Finished! 12/19/23 10:35 PM EST
Enjoy 👍
starting my For the love of wisdom class next week and listening to this is going to be gruesome! Taking the clas because I have to....keep me in yor prayers!
I can’t help being a fan of the Alexander and Paul translation, and I can’t help but commend your reading of my most favorite plato. Thank you
😀🙏
Glad you enjoyed the reading.
Beautifully read. Thank you Mr. Kirk!
You are most welcome. Just to let you know, we will begin a study of Plato’s Republic over on my other channel Book Club today. Here is the link:
czcams.com/channels/9L6KBc0AKe2mL5Yli0AtyQ.html
I remember going to school in West London with kids who would speak weLL like that with the double L sounds. It's nice to hear local accents sometimes.
Where abouts in West London? I grew up in North West London. A place called Harrow, or Arra to speak in the local dialect. 😉
You just saved me on assignment I had to do thank you omg I was last minute on my assignment and didn’t have the book thank you 🙏🏻
You are welcome. Happy to help.
Good luck with your philosophy studies, and I’m always here if you want to discuss. 🙏
This is excellent. I am a PhD student in London, working on Plato at the moment, and finding these very useful. Thank you. Do you plan on recording the Laches and Alcibiades Part II with accompanying texts as well? It will be very helpful.
Hey, happy to hear that you are finding the Platonic dialogues helpful! I do plan to get round to all of the dialogues at some stage. Thanks for the comment, and good luck in your studies!
God bless you for making this!
Thanks!!
God bless you for watching it! You're very welcome. 🙏
❤ This was amazing. Thank you
😀🙏
I really enjoyed your reading, thank you for making this video :) Keep it up!
Thanks Christine. Happy to hear that you enjoyed it! 🙏
This is my favorite nightly listen! 🙏🏼 ty
Glad to hear that. You are very welcome 🙏
Same lol
Jesus! this was good 😉 thank you
You're very welcome! Glad you enjoyed it! 🙏
Wow Symposium is beautiful. Thank you so so much my brother. 🎉🎉🎉
🙏❤️
Very thankful for the audiobook with text! My English is weak so this is super helpful.
Your welcome. I feel that even for people with English as a first language, having the audio and text together is the best way to take in the information.
Thank you so much for making this!
You're welcome!
If you enjoyed the Symposium then be sure to check out the Platonic Dialogue playlist to find many more of Plato's works!
Thank you very much :) well read and nice voice
You're welcome! I'm glad you like it. 🙏
thank you soooo much friend lewis!
You are very welcome! 🙏
This is very well read.
Thanks. Appreciate it! 🙏
Great reading... Thanks Brother 👌👌
It’s my pleasure, you are welcome 🙏
Thank you for making these. I listened to your theaetetus, sophist and statesman. I'm going back through several of Plato's works and audio with text is great. how many of these are you planing on making? are you planing on doing Parmenides?
I haven't tackled the Parmenides myself yet, and will be leaving that till last, but yes, I will be doing more. Philebus is coming next. I'm really glad you find them valuable. Thanks for letting me know.
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️✨🎄Good job
Thank you so much
You're welcome! I'm glad youike it! 👍
1:03:16 Agathon's Speech time marker
1:15:27
#180degreetheseries brought me here😊 #เส้นลองจิจูดที่180องศาลากผ่านเรา such a real masterpiece
Thank you
You're most welcome
Very good reading, what is you personal favorite Plato dialogues? I would like to read it next
I would say the Phaedo. Glad you are enjoying the Platonic Dialogues 😀👍
1:26:22 The Speech of Diotima
Auidomark - 1:26:22
Really nice video! Could you maybe re-upload the pdf of this translation?
Send me an email and I will forward it on to you 👍
I have autism and this helps me emote during class
Glad to hear that, and happy to help 🙏
25:25 to move quickly to someone else. As a matter of fact 181d
33:32 that is subjugation for the sake of virtue 184c
I’m just making bookmarks to help me finish reading the book. I’m learning this passage in my university.
Thank you for your great recital.
Gracias, merci, adios.
34:43 Only in this case 184e
41:00 Indeed, this may have been just what Heraclitus had in mind, though his mode of expression certainly leaves much to be desired 187a p325
27:03 beginning of page 12
1:15:54 Socrates Questions Agathon
Which translation are you reading from?
It's the Hackett complete works translation.
The Hackett Symposium is translated by Nehamas and Woodruff. It's a lively translation. And this is an excellent reading.
Thanks. Glad you enjoyed it! 🙏
1:20:00
Man. I knew these guys were gay but I was not prepared for just how gay.
48:25 Aristophanes speech
😀🙏
11:40
1:21:52 Diotima Questions Socrates
How many pages is this book? I feel like i couldn’t read this in 24hrs because thats what it feels like when I try to read a 100 pages
There are 49 pages in the dialogue Symposium. But the text is very small and compacted. It's quite a long dialogue, so maybe you could try breaking down into manageable chunks, say 30/40 minutes.
@@lewiskirk8289 thankyou!
You're welcome! 👍
37:34
37:33
40:00
Um i was just looking for info on the androgynous race. Is there something some treasure here?
38.05
25:19
thanks for hearting my timestamp :)
Anyone that hearts Plato, has a place in my heart. 🙏
I want to listen to this but this is so boring. How do people read these books? Any tips?
Go slow and be consistent. It’s not fun, or entertaining. See it like going to the gym for your mind.
This is my first time listening to this, it is reqllt beautiful. Also i did not realize that the ancients had such devoloped thoughts on lgbtq issues.
18:15
48:36
1:00:39
1:19:30
1:39:06
Someone please tell me if I heard this wrong but..... did this man just tell everyone that loving young boys (Children) is ok? 🤨😟 umm... no.
You should check out the bock saga...you are in for quite the shock if you ever leave the US.....there is a ton of shit about young boys in here, think elecromagnetically.....think of young or fresh as potent and pure. A literal interpretation sells it short.
Not all of platos works are authentic. There’s some corruption and people have added stuff in that isn’t authentic and the word of Socrates. It’s like any document that over 2000 years old. It’s not entirely authentic most of is but they’re a defiantly some corruption.
Athenians had a different conception of love, and homosexuality in the way that it is currently conceived (being an identity)would not be socially acceptable. They were certainly pederasts, but to them it was, in addition to a sexual relationship, a way of tutoring a young man, as the older man took the boy under his wing and trained him in the various duties and arts of civic duty and warfare. As far as historical accounts go this wasn't apparently a universal thing, but a phenomenon that was mainly prolific in Athens. Though in time, considering that Athens was a central focal point of Greek culture, the practice spread.
Man gahhh damn 🙄
THIS SUUUUUUUUUCCCCCKKKSSSS
æ
Kinda gay...
Sorry but Phaedrus was a batty man. 😂 talking bout himself
anyone got a discord invite
There is a patreon link. Come and join.
Why do they always go on about pederasts and gayness?
1:21:50
1:40:00
15:22
1:21:50
1:06:40
1:55:09
37:33
37:33
1:15:51
1:51:44
37:32
1:36:43
36:18
1:12:12
1:45:21