2019 Acura MDX vs Lexus RX Comparison: Which Luxury Crossover Does a Better Job?
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 03. 2019
- The Acura MDX and Lexus RX are two of the OG luxury crossovers. The MDX debuted in 2001 and the RX just a few years earlier in 1999. They're mainstays in the hotly contested segment and have been kicking it before crossovers were cool. Both crossovers have become well known for offering stellar reliability and the soft, cushy comfort that luxury shoppers are looking for. Both CUVs are available as regular gas-powered models and hybrid versions, and although the MDX comes standard with a third row, the RX is now available in a long-wheelbase version that also offers an additional row of seats, so the two are even closer than ever.
Last year, the MDX sold 54,886 units in North America but the RX sold almost 118,000, which is a huge difference. Does the Lexus deserve to outsell the Acura by that much? We brought both CUVs together to find out.
Get a free price quote: quotes.autoguide.com/
Please show your support and subscribe!
czcams.com/users/subscription_c...
AutoGuide reviews the latest new cars with test drives, car comparisons and shootouts plus coverage of breaking auto industry news, auto shows, rumors, top 10 lists, and spy photos. Help shop for your new car with informative car buying tips and car recall news, and be entertained with feature stories, Top 10s and car review videos. - Auta a dopravní prostředky
This review has the worst conclusion as in the whole review they're complaining on Lexus RX but at the end crowns it the winner, WTF.
That said the engine runs better and rides better but picks the lexus because it special lol
I love Lexus I do, I do. Owed a Lexus Rx400h loved it. but, my Acura MDX is much better all around over the RX!
It's definitely a good idea to consider either and it's a tough choice really. Both the Acura MDX and the Lexus RX are great luxury crossovers that are very comfortable and great to drive. If you want more confort and quietness, the Lexus RX is the one for you, since that's the goal for Lexus products, isolating you from the real world. You'll still get that in the Acura MDX, but you can also drive it more aggressively and it's a lot more fun to drive. Plus, I think the tech is much more easy to use in the MDX, and it's very simplistic for anyone to get in and learn within minutes, whereas with the Lexus infortainment..... yeah, it's easy to see why you wanna just break the screen off of the car xD Either vehicle is a win for me though, but for me, I'd choose the MDX for more practicality and I just love Acura vehicles in general (even though some of their interiors may not be the best), and Acura and parent company Honda are pretty conservative with a lot of things, but I don't mind it.
I like the dashboard of the Lexus better, but I prefer the MDX in most other aspects, especially in A-Spec trim. The Lexus looks nice from most angles, except the front, which looks like Darth Vader. So I would pick the MDX in A-Spec trim.
Yeah but the front makes it look fierce and it makes it look more stronger
@@gayanekarapetyan8581 then look at the Toyota Avalon
I think most would be happy with either vehicles. Quality stuff from both brands. I recently compared the MDX and RX350 for purchase(amongst others). The RX rides better because of its more upscale interior, but the MDX drives so much better and has more interior space. I ultimately went with the Acura, but I would have been happy with the Lexus as well. Good luck to all those making the same comparison and buying decision.
The RX is miles ahead in terms of build and quality. The MDX really does feel like a nicer Honda Pilot. The Lexus is a real step above.
Facts!
You buy a Honda for the guts. Acuras are Honda bones on a slightly more expensive exterior. That’s what helps keep them under the costs of comparable Lexus, Volvo and BMW.
BCJDM so true and I can prove it. Objective or subjective, Lexus wins.
Lexus was the brand put German brands back to the drawing boards.
Seiko Watch too bad the LFA didn’t have the impacts on the exotics the way the NSX did.
@@MidnightAspec Actually total opposite. 2011 LFA track time is almost 30 seconds faster than NSX. That is a shame
Lol she said the Lexus RX will look old in few years! Really AutoGuide, you hired these two for reviews?
😂😂all I see is her nostril 🤦♀️🤦♀️😂😂
it true, this car will not age well
cheesun124 But even if its old, it will outlast your life, it doesn’t give up
This what you get when the US education system turns out more snowflakes who like to hear themselves talk (because they're all winners) than common sense young people. Flush out the socialist garbage who call themselves teachers and professors who are focused on indoctrinating innocent children and replace them with normal hard working adults who truly care about kids well being and preparing to be productive citizens in the real world.
@@sideskraft Um they sound Canadian.
Lexus will cost less in the long term because of resale value and reliability. Scotty kilmer approved!
The title should be "the worst auto reviewers on CZcams". OMG, who hired these two?
BTW, both are very good SUVs. It just come down to your personal preference.
First off, you guys wrongly evaluated the MDX and Acura as a whole. You guys kept comparing it to a Honda Pilot, which I'm sure it's based on in some capacity, however you stated that the outside gave you pilot vibes, which it DEFINITELY does not. I don't know if you've seen a Pilot, but it definitely isn't similar to the MDX. The inside of the MDX is much nicer than a pilot, and yes the MDX is due for a full refresh, the interior is still very nice and nothing like the Pilot's. They're not even the same size or platform! I feel like you both played into the stereotype or persona of a Lexus. A Lexus is a very nice car, but I feel that your verdict was solely because it was a Lexus. You didn't even talk about SH-AWD, the hybrid system on the MDX, A-Spec or really anything. For goodness sakes, your title is "Which luxury crossover does a better job?" Which you both agreed it was Acura. The Acura drove better, sounded better, had more space, and better useable features. If you weren't going to have the 3 row RX, you should have brought the RDX, which would have definitely handled this RX. Overall I feel the comparison was unfair and slated. Reviews and comparisons are subjective, but to just say the Lexus won, because when you pull up in a Lexus people notice? People notice Acuras too, more and more since their refreshed styling and new designs. As car reviewers, you all have the power to give Acura and other brands like it, the recognition it needs, and the people honest, unbiased opinions. Very disappointed in this review.
Brandon Banner I totally agree with you!
So true
Totally agree
The Acura’s interior is as kind of outdated compared to the Lexus tho
Lexus is the Japanese king of luxury. Acura is more of the fun/sporty car. I think Lexus definitely competes better with the German rivals. I hate how the Acura interiors aren’t more luxurious. They used to be nice but now are super out dated.
I hate the huge grill on the Lexus. Would chose the MDX any day.
Lexus/Toyota has the ugly cow-catcher grill. Although I own a used Toyota Avalon Hybrid, I can deal with it because when I’m sitting behind the wheel I can’t see the front end. 😉
This is a terribly done review. Totally painful to watch.
I found them so bratty. What the hell DO they like? Other cars might get their whistles blowing but they’re going to break down and cost a fortune to fix. What makes them the experts. She probably drives a yugo.
@@jamespikarski5610 no she probably drives a trabant
Really, really good job -- assuming automotive journalists still work for the consumer. I've driven both of those recently, and your observations, albeit slightly overdone here and there, are spot-on valid, the questions real buyers have. Your personalities play off each other well.
My dad owns the mdx and its soo comfy so ill take that mdx
The thing is the Lexus will last forever
Edmonton, Alberta is full of 2003-2016 MDXes! Those things are tanks.
The Acura will last just as long as the Lexus.
@@MidnightAspec No. I suggest you check out carcomplaints.com and compare the # of complaints vs. the # units sold. Despite selling only a fraction of the RX, the MDX has many times more complaints.
Nothing is forever DICKHEAD
No. Lexus used cheap parts. I had and still have an RX 350 AND I FIXED MY OWN CARS. Lexus used REALLY CHEAP PARTS compare to Acura. I fixed and replaced some OEM PARTS TWICE. Why? Bc they are cheaply made.And driving? Lexus IS not even close. And If they have the MDX HYBRID? The interior materials are upgraded from the regular MDX.
This was horrible. I feel sorry for lexus letting these two kids drive their car. They don't get it. She belongs in a Honda civic and he belongs in a Subaru forester. They don't understand why lexus does so well. You will never understand! Just stick to the civic and the Subaru, they are good cars, just don't try to review such a success of an suv. You're not doing anyone a favor.
TRIVIA: Did u know that the Lexus RX350 is the safest car so far? There are zero deaths since it was first introduced in the market. Knock on wood..... It's electronics and overall built are very reliable to keep its passengers safe on the roads.
Ayy you watch Scotty Kilmer?
Thanks Scotty
My grandfather ended up going off the road and hitting a tree head on in an MDX and he came out unscathed
The mdx is statistically and verifiably more safe in a crash so wdym?
Lexus any day of the week not only when compared to Acura but also when compared to the German Premium brands.
Lexus IS the Elite luxury brand.
Uhh no, not even close. German brands are better built cars, better interiors, worlds better infotainment, look better etc...We own an RX, my wife likes it, I miss her BMW X3. If I were choosing between these two I'd go MDX over RX.
Seiko Watch iiuiiibb
My Mazda CX5 drives better than the RX. The Mazda has a much sportier ride whereas the RX is soft and is boring. However, the Audi Q5 was better looking, the interior was nicer and it was very fun to drive.
The MDX is my choice for zippy and fun sport feel but the automatic transmission won’t hold up like the Lexus will. The Lexus IS a much more reliable and comfortable ride!
I got use to the radio if u dont touch it every 2 min ok .. steering wheel controls do the job also
The nerve of them to question lexus build quality. That's how you know they're hating in Lexus.
Still the MDX the #1 selling 3 row SUV. Can't wait to see what the redesign will look like.
Brandan honda Facts
Brandan honda The new MDX will come out in 2020 and will be sold as a 2021 model.
@@michaelfoulkes9502 yes I read
It seems like this guy just agrees with everything she says. There seems a lot of generic talk too. Idk
clealry they are boning
When you got frustrated manually typing in the address, does the Lexus not offer voice input??
How many time did this dude say "Whatever"? Such poor quality of a review
I care about exterior much more than interior thats why acura for me
And both are super reliable
Couldn’t finish watching this. All I hear is complaining 🙄
The MDX has proven very reliable for us
Great Candid Review 👍
Lexus RX all-day! King of reliability and that new RX is very smooth and a joy to drive.
Looking at people cringing about an "uncomfortable way to enter a 3rd row seat" or "using an infotaiment systems", makes me realize how freaking spoiled human beings can get.
I agree with the Acura/Honda statement. There is no reason to pay a premium for an Acura when a Honda is just as good with similar interior materials.
I drove the RX last year. What I took away from it was it was like driving an EV.
It was that smooth. A frictionless driving experience.
No one buys the F-Sport, so testing this one and using it to represent the RX is a big problem.
The regular one, once you drive it, you buy it for a reason. It is that good. The F-Sport, not so much.....
MDX all the way, no questions asked
Both are great but the MDX is better because it has 3 rows and IS the best selling 3 row luxury SUV. They should have used the RX-L
@Nezumi Speed Then that buyer wouldn't consider the MDX which makes the comparison a bit forced. Similar, a buyer who _needs_ the extra space would have already crossed the RX off their list.
This reveiw sucks. Don't hate on the Acura
The RX IS GARBAGE
Youngmoon Plays ok peasant. I own a 2018 Lexus RX and a 2019 Land Rover Range Rover and both are great cars. The Lexus IS far superior in quality when compared to the Acura which one of my friends own. Acura is shit because of there mediocre attempts at luxury and there shitty transmitions.
❤️
At 1:38 she says the RX “long wheelbase version” 3 row......The RX 3 row has the exact same wheelbase as the 2 row. The body is extended not the wheelbase. Someone needs to check your facts before you post video. Maybe I am nitpicking. Otherwise good review.
Steve Printy you are not
18:19 I see what you did there, #straightpipes reference lol... the famous visor test!
I've wondered what the Straight Pipes guys are testing with that...what are they looking at with the visor test?
The RX’s interior is so much better and when it comes to reliability these things live for ever. Lack of Apple and Android connectivity and horrible entertainment system really need to be addressed.
Thanks for your honest comparison 👍
I love my Lexus . Everyone in my family is driving lexus and Toyota which last forever. But i love how the MDX looks so nice and more space.b
In this specific comparison I'd take the Acura MDX easily any day over that Lexus RX.
And why.?
Until Honda and Acura's transmission problems kick in.....
I literally love the infotainment system on the Lexus. I find that fingerprints get stuck on touchscreen infotainments and dislike that. It's an easy to use system, and all around convenient, other than the navigation on the system.
"Changing the radio station makes me want to murder someone" that cracked me up!
The MDX would be the one I'd choose but it's still not a compelling package considering the dated console. But the upcoming precision cockpit though ... MDX 2020
I’ve always find her annoying and not a good reviewer just my opinion 🤷🏾♂️
annoying is an understatement
I agree! Like I could barely get through the video.
@@2001COUPE You got thru the whole video? at 4 minutes, I went to the comments to see if it was just me that felt this way. Confirmed.
I totally agree when she goes bing bing bing bing....
She is annoying so bratty like probably was when she was a kid.
Lexus All the way
Seems like Acura made a good decision by not sending the top of the line hybrid vehicle. I wonder how a regular RX350 (no F-sport) with the 18" rims would compare vs the MDX that was received. Most of the criticism in the driving dynamics of the RX is due to its F-sport package which comes with the 20" rims. a slightly stiffer suspension and add the Hybrid on top of that. Sometimes simple is best and Acura played their cards right to please Autoguide. The RX isl the better luxury SUV.
sub310 Great point. My sister was a Lexus general manager, and she told me do not buy the 20” wheels, it just looks nice, but not comfortable to drive
I have owned both RX and MDX. RX definitely better materials. Both infotainment systems stink, but RX really stinks. Where MDX leave the RX in the dust is on the road. MDX is stable and really holds the road; RX eh. Fun factor in driving MDX wins hands down. I really can’t stand Lexus’ grills. They do look like something from DarthbVader.
Let’s start here. Personally I like Subarus, but if i weren’t to have a Subaru, I’d most likely have a 09 MDX. My mom has one and i’ve driven it about 3 times, and it’s awesome. I have a Subaru Outback and I would definitely say whenever my outback goes, i’m definitely going for a MDX. It’s reliable, safe, and it’s really good in the snow. I feel like the older ones like the 2010 ones have the same entertainment system as the pilot, which it does. I’m just so in love with the MDX and I would for sure buy it in the future.
Thank god they gave it a touchscreen for 2020
Lexus for the interior
Acura for the styling body ANYDAY!!!!
Definitely looking forward to get an Acura mdx my favorite!
My dad was looking at both of these and went for a q7. I still love these phenomenal cars
Just remember journalists are not owners.They do not understand how to truly utilize multimedia systems.the RX mouse control is for fine tuning the system. the talk switch is the convenience button to put in addresses (while you're driving), radio stations, temperature. The 2020 RX will knock it out of the park!
I find this girl unbearable.
Waheed Khan it’s obvious that her parents never whooped her..
She mostly trashes on the RX but picks it over MDX 🙄 smh
Omg her nostril 😂😂😂
Some fact checks:
1. The Lexus RX-L in most markets will sticker for less than the RX F-Sport Hyrbid you are testing. So, stating that the RX-L would be "much more expensive" than an MDX is simply false.
2. You can change a radio with the simple switch of a button on the steering wheel. You can also customize the remote touch control to be less "jumpy" and you can silence the "ding" sound if you find it annoying all in the setup portion of the vehicle.
3. For SAFETY reasons, you cannot enter an address manually while the car is moving. You can only use voice commands while the car is in motion.
I could only watch 4 minutes of this before jumping down here in the comments because so much was wrong. If you're going to "review" a car, do your research first, friends!
Thanks for watching and for your feedback!
MDX definitely looks better these two are nuts.
Which has better smoother ride quality? I mean, I did test drove Lexus RX and the ride quality wasn't that good.
Give me that Lexus
I don't understand. You spent the entire video criticizing the Lexus, but it wins because your neighbors will turn their heads when you drive home in it? Based on your review I was sure you were going to pick the MDX. That's my pick.
The "reviewers" know nothing about cars.
Thanks for the 2014 review
Even if it's not hybrid I prefer the Acura MDX one for me please
Milko Vasilev me too, lol I love the sporty look of the MDX
What about Lexus?
Acura’s are hideous
I own a 2018 Lexus RX with same infotainment system and for most of its use, it’s not bad once you get used to it. But I will agree with the reviewers that having to type in addresses for navigation is pretty awful. But the voice recognition for adding full addresses works well, and that’s m only method of entering an address. Lexus is using a larger track pad on their 2019 ES, LS, NX, models which is infinitely better than the RX current mouse. Still not as good as others, but better than their current mouse.
This guy is totally in the friend zone! He is such a nice guy and so agreeable… He only gives her positive emotions… He is totally in the friend zone!
Except the rx L isn't a long wheelbase version. It's the same wheelbase across the board.
Because Toyota quality control is better than Honda quality control
The Acura MDX Number One
That Acura interior is brutal.
Surprise K “Brutal”
They did a great job reviewing. What are their names. Guy is goodloking.
Sebastien you really need to work on your hosting skills like Jodi
One phrase SH-AWD !! Reason why i would get the MDX
Aaronix4 i have lexus RX 350 with AWD
Me too.. Handle like a champ.. Actually I bought an rdx.. Fun cuv
@@TrapBoutBizness Which is not anywhere near the SH-AWD
....to me as a person that uses plenty of electronic devices, I have never found any of the Lexus systems to be difficult to use...there are steering wheel buttons to control everything so it always makes me cringe when they complain about the joystick. Not to mention they always make it seem like the UI and its controls are like such a major component on a vehicle when virtually everyone only uses it for music, text message readouts & navigation...and unless you're a pizza delivery driver or have a horrendous memory, how often are you really using the navigation..? They always love to trash on the Lexus UI and call BMW and Mercedes input methods amazing but I always fail to see what one needs to be controlling with these "amazing UIs" while you're supposed to be driving...cars, especially luxury ones, have become so inundated with stupid shit that have nothing to do with driving on top of people expecting to be spoonfed everything. I hate hearing about headunit systems on cars, they take up so much in car reviews when in reality they ALL suck anyways compared to my smart phone and computer...
The RX just looks so sharp love the sculpted body. Definitely the looker. Love the interior too.
Living for 4 years with a MDX I have to say that its mostly a good car, but some of the quality issues are to consider. I have no clue about Lexus' quality because it's not sold in Mexico, but now I wonder why. Anyways, I can confirm that the driving dynamics with the SH-AWD are really good tho. But it feels like it needs a new generation asap, but we'll have to wait another year.
SDRYC my 2014 randomly makes a loud buzzing noise from the engine bay
@@lamshao Never had engine problems... Just electrical. A LED died from the rear night lamp (the one in the trunk with the reverse light). And the center storage from the front is a little loose and squeaks
I like the dual screen, the gear shift mechanism and the awd system in the Acura. Regarding Toyota v Lexus comparison. There are similarities with the Highlander and RX including the engine and transmission. Most of the criticisms are really subjective in this review. These reviewers need a lot of work to improve.
Y’all really don’t like Acura, y’all did I the same thing with the RDX y’all were like the only reviews to bad mouth that suv. Jodi needs to be fire and Greg needs a raise
Jodi is the boss of Autoguide.
10:52 all I see is complaining. The mdx is a great car!
Who ever really says ' hey, you're the most least liked person so go to the 3rd row seat please'
Brutal reviews....just brutal
I can’t deal with the new Lexus styling in and out. Plus our local Lexus dealers are terrible. MDX for me please.
Why can’t you?
gayane karapetyan I know it is a matter of personal preference, but I really hate the size of the new spindle grill.
I love the masculine looks on the MDX. I think it's much more beautiful than the Lexus.
Wait I’m confused. You don’t like the RX because it drives car like ? Wtf let me see you complain about that in a BMW. LOVE the looks of the Lexus in its F Sport trim. Looks edgy and cool.
The Acura to me just comes off like a minivan. Pass. Just get a Honda van.
Toyota4Life The Lexus Enform system is so bad that’s enough not to even consider it
Her whiny voice makes my ears hurt
I’m not a fan of Honda after having two of them and having the new Accord as a loaner car. I’d go with Lexus personally. I don’t think these two vehicles are in the same category.
I have had several Acura's I presently have a MDX. the dealer service and support from Acura has gone to He**, almost non existent compared to what it once was, year ago. No more Acura's for me because of this. Findlay Acura of Las Vegas is a total joke. When I bought my Acura they gave me several free oil changes and when I went to use them Findlay would not honer them. Told me some employees had stolen some and they won't honor them, this comes after making a service appointment with them for the oil change Needless to say, I left and have never been back, after being refused to be able to talk to the manger. They covered for him, said he was busy to see me and in a meeting. yeah right! I wrote Acura Corp and told them of my experience they refereed me back to the dealer and I have never heard from either one to this day. I took new deliver of one at Jody Wilkinson in SLC they left the car so it would get hard water makes from there sprinkler system on my Black MDX when I went to pick it up. they said I will have the wash boy take care of it and he scratch the He** out of brand new car and had to send it our to be buffed only to return it with swirl marks from the buffer. like I say No competent service and support from Acura. Byers be ware.
The vehicles are nice, but Jodi’s watch steals the show.
You surely are anti toyota and prohonda channel, no doubt about that, wonder why more and more channels are getting more of a promotional channels rather than being neutral, surely money makes the mare go. Shameful
I think the mouse is simple and intuitive after using it for a while.
I don’t like either of them . Love my 07 mdx
I owned a 2nd gen RX and now have an RDX. The infotainment system would keep me out of the current RX.
we have one this generation and have 0 problems with the system. reviewers have it for 1 week and don't customize it and then complain. it takes a few weeks to get used to, and it is super intuitive then. anyway, it is being redone for 2020.
I agree on the infotainment system. The only thing I really don't like about my 2015 Lexus RX350. I mostly use my phone to stream something, but no Apple CarPlay in mine. Little quirks... haha. I didn't get the Nav in mine because for $2k? WTF....my phone screen is almost bigger than the display.
Aside from the MDX having more space than the RX, the Lexus just looks so much more modern than the Acura even the Lexus was redesigned just two years after the MDX. I'm a Honda person, but I would definitely the Rx over the MDX. The Acura needs a redesign as the RDX had.
I just traded in 2019 rx to get mdx 2020 fwd technology package have to say wow when fisrt time rx owner like me drove mdx wooooo so cool strong sporty drive easy to use infotainment, bonus 3rd row for my daughter 8yrs old she is happy and love it. We went up hill 9k feet wow much better than rx.
The Lexus is no doubt a great car, but unfortunately the front end styling looks like it was done by a committee that previously designed the Pontiac Aztec and the Ford Edsel with the final approval of Helen Keller.
Both nice SUV"d but Lexus looks more aggresiver en bigger 👌
Dheeradj Lachman MDX is better
How the hell is the lexus bigger when the MDX has 3 rows
I own a 2012 TL and 2012 MDX...both bought new. Still own and drive them. I've been a loyal Honda customer since my 1988 Accord. I've influenced family members to buy Honda. But after the 2012 MDX...
I WILL NEVER BUY A HONDA PRODUCT AGAIN.
Honda motors tells me that my 2012 MDX is within manufacturing specifications to burn 1 quart of oil per 1000 miles. They manufactured the engines with a defect and now, instead of standing behind their products, have invented specifications that they call "acceptable" to turn their back on the customer.
I paid $48000 for a vehicle that began to burn oil at the 60000 mile mark. Every service has been done by Acura dealerships. I've had the complaint checked multiple times. There's now a recall. Guess what? Honda/Acura still refuses to admit that my vehicle has a manufacturing defect. I have a crappy Ram pickup truck that doesn't burn that much oil.
So in conclusion, your review is worthless. Interior materials really don't matter when the engine is manufactured with a defect that the manufacturer won't stand behind.
WOW!! THAT SUCKS!! I THINK I WLD.CRASH IT N THE BUILDING WHERE U GOT IT R CRASH IT UP THEIR A..I WLD.B PISSED 2..DAMN!! THAT'S SAD..SO SORRY 4 UR TROUBLES..THAT'S WHAT U GET 4 BEING A WONDERFUL CUSTOMER..JUST WOW!!!!!
I wonder why Lexus has yet to fix their infotainment after countless complaints from literally everyone
Lexus has implemented 2 really intuitive infotainment systems in the time that other companies took to hash out one, mediocre offering. Fact. These reviewers don't live with the product and were never trained how to use them how the manufacturer intened. Simply put its a case of a market not fully grasping innovation.
Craig Smith if you have to be trained to use an infotainment system you might as well look at something else
Come 2020 it will be touch screen
Cover Ontario plate driving on public road not being caught, good luck.
However, all prices are shown for US market.
Good job.. was useful.. thanks!
I feel like these really aren't competing with each other.....