Life as Jewish settler in the West Bank | DW Documentary
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 09. 2020
- The West Bank: Chaya Tal is one of 430,000 Jewish settlers living among 2.7 million Palestinians. The young German is aware that her presence alone is a provocation for many Palestinians. But that does not deter her.
These days the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the Kingdom of Bahrain want to establish diplomatic relations with Israel, as the third and fourth Arab countries, after Egypt and Jordan. In return for the agreement, Israel wants to suspend the planned annexation of areas in the occupied West Bank, which the Palestinians claim for their own state.
"Personally, I don't see a problem in our living here", says Chaya Tal, "but rather how we live here." She believes that isolation is not the way out of the decades of confrontation in the region, but that it is by talking to each other. The Palestinian Abu Awwad also sees it this way - despite or perhaps because his brother was shot dead at an Israeli checkpoint. Together with Rabbi Hanan Schlesinger they have come up with an idea to ease the situation on the ground. A report by Theresa Breuer and Vanessa Schlesier.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch high-class documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
DW Documentary: / @dwdocumentary
DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو: (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
For more visit:
www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Instagram:
/ dwdocumentary
Facebook:
/ dw.stories
DW netiquette policy: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
Forcibly building your Home on someone's territory and then crying for peace... strange
never cried for the piece.Bombing the hell outta Palestine ever since
@@AshikJonathan that is the problem, power corrupts...
@@Asoka-great say that to mohmoud abbas. This war is not about Israel. Its about power. Abbas remaining in power without elections now he wants some reason to be reelected
America, UK, France, Portugal, Spain, all did this too. lmao
How about the millions of economic migrants coming to prosperous Europe? Oh, wait, they didn't even have to build homes, they got them for free
"And then he threw a rock at me for killing his uncle and burning down his house. Why are they so violent??
How many people have Arabs murdered in the last 1300+ years in the name of Allah?
As I'm learning more about "settlers", I'm starting to think that they need a new name. How about "thugs"? Or, "thieves"?
That, and they also all look like they're tripping. Completely disconnected.
They are thieves protected only the IOF and the guns they carry
armed illegal migrants?
There is a funny joke in there about calling them Jays and how the rest is redundant
How about “bugs”?
‘Personally I don’t see any problem in me occupying other people’s land, I find it problematic that they’re not peacefully letting me get away with it’
True 😂😂😂
The audacity 🤦♀️🤦♀️
She is so delusional 🤦🏽♀️
Her friendship with the Arab is laying the foundations for her to stab him in the back because he’s tired of living through conflict. She’s got nothing to lose and she knows it.
How about others occupy your land
It's hard being a coloniser😞😞
yeah
And even harder to be a refugee.
No kidding. Yesterday, the Palestinian family that we kicked out of their home kept yelling at us. Why are they so angry?
@@travis419 Last month, the family whose car I stole demanded that I return it to them. How deplorable of them. They had the audacity to ask for a car that my dad said should be mine to me.
Yeees how can they not understand that my fairy tale god gave me the right for their homes..
Imagine breaking into someones house, sitting on their couch, eating their food and watching their television and, when the rightful owners complain and attempt to drive you out, you complain about how rude they are being. How disconnected from reality are these "settlers"?
Imagine breaking into someone's house and killing everyone or forcing them to convert by swords
This is how all Islamic nations formed too
@@doctormanganate5814 I know that
@@doctormanganate5814 I'm from India. I can relate. everybody knows that dude, israel is better than hamas. They always want to stay in places where they are in minority
But if they become majority there won't be any rights for minority
@@doctormanganate5814 when uk 🇬🇧 involved in your history everything becomes confusing 😕it's common.
Last month, the family whose car I stole demanded that I return it to them. How deplorable of them. They had the audacity to ask for a car that my dad said should be mine.
Remember one thing the place you are living in was once someone else3
@@vlaythsh7880 stupid.
vlayth sh so all places in this world is
@@vlaythsh7880 give the place youre living now to previous owner, please
@@QweRty-dl1ev roman were their before jew they should have the land first
The settlers (squatters) talk about the Palestinians as if they're aliens. "Making contact," "reminder we're not alone," etc. Like WTF!
Yes, it's absolutely obscene!
Literal karen's walking around thinking the own everything and get free hand outs..
Why are they being painted as the "victims"?
Because that’s what the Pro Israel media does.
Because Jews have been expelled from over 300 countries throughout history, purged 3 times already, and haven't had their own Jewish state in thousands of years.
How quickly you forget your history when BuzzFeed keeps squeezing the sense out of your frontal lobe.
@@xBrownGirLinTheRingx 🤭🤭😍😍💕💕💕
Western media? Why you're so surprised?
Because deutsche welle and company still "expiate" for ww2. Pathetic
Would this lady speak about getting along if I moved into her house and refused to leave?
Perhaps Jacob ("If I don't steal your house someone else will") could shed some light on this.
by that logic dont ignore whose house it was 2000 years ago. easy game
@@iggyzootz1 2000 years ago? That’s your logic?
@@Katez9241 yep. like it or not jews are indigenous to that land, especially to judea and sameria/ west bank.
@@JudeanWarrior7 ok give Europe to Rome give back America to the native Americans ur logic is stupid it isn't their fault they were born there
Please stop calling them settlers! They are colonizers.
Most land has changed hands many times, but only Jews are condemned for it
squatters and thieves
@@suzannenobel3994that would be the Palestinians
They're Settlers. They just want to coexist and celebrate diversity. Multiculturalism is our strength.
@@jonnyknight8001your delulu amaze me
How do settlers live with themselves? How can they justify stealing other people home and lands?
Because they are fed by religion which makes them blind
Somebody told them they are "chosen one"
They are not stealing anything. They buy the land and homes. The Palestinian don’t own anything.
Because they feel they're God's chosen people.
They are simply reclaiming the land that was stolen from them
"If I don't steal your house, someone else will"
-Yakob, 2021
Hah, it's still Jacob. The J sounds like a Y in Hebrew.
@@alsofrightened1 What does steal sound like?
@@KentonJoseph No different than it does in English.
he was renting the place from somebody else. He was sayng that is not with him that she should argue
My dude I've been seeing you on every video. That's dedication.
The fact that a rabbi says that belong to them because they were there 2000 years ago makes no sense to me
It would make sense if you knew how Romans expelled original settlers in the 2nd century CE
@@EdArmGuitarI still don't understand how this justifies kicking natives out of their homes.
@@EdArmGuitar and then??? Are they can prove their legitimate reason beside their religion like their ancestry? They fleed from jerman and became refugee in Palestina but they want to claim it as their own after they been accepted.
It’s like saying my great great great great great great great great great great great great great great grandpa lived on this land so it’s my land. Your land is where ‘you’ were born, simple as that.
@@Kevs_a_dawg you should add word "probably" inside that narative too😭🤌
"For many people here, this is their first contact with an Arab". Sounds very much like Apartheid.
sorry to say but if u r really a hindu as i presumed from ur name i must say your common sense is the best among others(HINDU) i've come across in the comment section of fb,youtube.
it is worse than apartheid
@@idrishmeahchy1897 Right wing Hindus have bad images of islam because of our neighbor Country and what is happening in indian politics
@@idrishmeahchy1897 Our neighbor country are Islamic Republic & also they are our enemy country. We already have fought 4 wars with them. When our peaceful neighbor country realised that they can't win war with india, they started using Proxy war against india. Sending state sponsored terriost is one example of proxy war.
Here we got very bad image of Islamic Republic despite of more than 205 millions Muslims are already living in india.
Bc there is segregation. There are mostly segregated palestinian towns/homes and segregated jewish communities and the ones close by are protected /supervised by israeli military who constantly opress palestinians and make them go through check points every day.
You move from Germany to someone else's land and then say you want peace
"someone else's land"
@@polishrepublic5055 I am pretty sure I can not just travel over to Poland and occupy a land illegally
@@aadeyemi5767 you dont have any justify
@@polishrepublic5055 So I can't claim the land of my ancestors from 2000 years ago?
@@aadeyemi5767 Ancestors of Jews arent from 2000 y ago.
My ancestors were in Germany 2,000 years ago. Can I go claim land there?
According to Israelis, you can and you must
You can if you have power enough.The same thing as Red indian(Cherokee Mohok Apa che) Inca Maori Aborigin ect.
@@prakorngirodkunkid7877yeah. by the 16th-17th century way of thinking.
I win the wars I draw the map bud, crying won't help you .
@@PhysicsViolator But it's illegal to just go to someone's country and squat and then start a war when they are unhappy about it.
So if that’s the case, let’s all go to other countries and take their lands and homes. It’s absolutely justifiable according to these people.
lol, Exactly :) I wonder if they would agree with that argumentation if we should bring up the fact that jews got their homes stolen by the nazis in Germany , I mean same thing. But oh lets forget that little detail.
Exactly
Palestinians are descendants of Arab colonizers.
@@blessing5173 aren’t many people ancestors of colonisers, very flawed ideology as to why they should be kicked out their own homeland
@@H.Rvenice The point is. It isn't their homeland.
If I don't steal it, somebody else will - "Yacub, Israeli Settlers - 2021"
Allah Hu Akbar
@Prophet Netanyahu Spare no one. Kill men and women, children and infants, oxen and sheep, camels and donkeys - 1 Samuel 15:3
‼
I think he meant he was renting the place
@Anas Mirza Indian hiding behind a Muslim name. Did India get O2 from Saudi yet?
It's really hard to show any empathy for the settlers. Most of them come from advanced western countries with tons of social benefits and every tool available to have a good life (except for the US which has no free healthcare, college etc.).
Almost like you're being programmed to not have any empathy for them, because of the constant propaganda you're being fed of "israel bad, settler violence is a real thing"
settlers = evil thieves
you're just jealous hahahahaha
@@MTC008 who on earth would be jealous of genocidal monsters?
I agree with you. I myself come from a Western country and decided to move to a rural part of south america. I made sure though that the land I bought doesnt have any ancestral claim by the indigenous communities as some do, and I also accept that if something were to happen, I would have no option but to back off. It is a privilege to be there, not a right even if the state gave me a piece of paper to show that I can be there. I really don't like these people's attitudes
She calls herself religious but Which part of Jewish law allows nightclub
Hypocrisy of the highest order
She is simply lying
This was a party at a neighbour's house. Watching comprehension
@@archiefeld5801 watching comprehension lacking. it's a neighbour's party. watch again
@Prophet Netanyahu crawl back to dirty ganges
"Israelis," one of them is a German, the other an American from New York...
I’m watching Israel annihilate Gaza tonight and then I saw this and it made me angry. The people of Gaza are literally liked caged rats and have nowhere to go except, possibly, here in the West Bank. These settlers have all of Israel and yet they take what is not theirs to take. It is disgusting to hear these people say that “the whole land is theirs.” It is not. There were legal agreements made and signed and agreed to. Respect the laws you yourselves agreed to!
I agree.This is a disgusting behaviour honestly
@@SpikeShnoopsthere nothing significant about giving true inhabitants in your illegal colony all those privileges it’s the least you do, the best you do is either gtfo go to Europe where most of yall belong your not true hebrews or have two state solution
@@SpikeShnoops No they didn't "elect" Hamas. There was no competition - do or don't situation
you are right! the USoA should give the land back to native Americans! and the Arabs should give the land back to greeks and others
Come now, palestinian settlers also grabbed quite a bit of jewish land on the west bank of the Jordan river in the forties, fifties and sixties. It’s a mess.
Free palestine. Zero sympathy for colonizers.
“I got my principles”, meanwhile stealing somebody’s land. So far for principles
you stole the Senkaku islands from China. Give them back
7:53 it blows my mind that a faith leader such a rabbi is essentially saying that for decades he had not acknowledged the humanity of Palestinian people he lives amongst
Right? it's not like the guy comes from absolute poverty and never had internet access or a million resources available.
Ikr! And he said they'd worked in the house. Even without knowing their stories could he not see them as human beings?
Fun fact: you'll never get a story from Palestinian side from a Palestinian on this channel
Oh they had Ali Abunimah on from Electronic Intifada, but they cut him off when he started telling the truth about Germoney's involvement on the side of Apartheid and Genocide.
It is actually harder to find stories from Israeli perspective. West media blame Israel all the time, but I can see this topic is much more complicated
@Alexander Rummel I don’t think they get their assed kicked by media, opposite actually. But they get ignored from UN and world leaders and that’s the problem. It was British who gave Palestine to Israel and we can’t blame Israel for it. It was just after 2nd world war. Poor Palestinians lost their lands and rights and this continues to these days because world leaders don’t have balls to decide where will be the borderline and to make Palestine sovereign country. And I can’t defend Palestine either because it is Hamas who is bombing Israel and who is responsible for all terrorist attacks in region and I will not defend terrorists. I am not defending Israeli government for steeling Palestine’s land. I am just saying it is an extremely difficult topic and nothing is simply black and white here.
can't get a story from someone that is illiterate (wait a minute that sounds familiar.....)
yes its complicated. but come on. idf vs beseaged Palestians with rocks. Palestians are not HAMAS. Hamas is one of many governments in Palestine. Palestians are peaceful and simply want to live in Peace. Stop this Genocide occurring in Gaza now.
“You take my water, burn my olive trees, destroy my house, take my job, steal my land, imprison my father, kill my mother, bombard my country, starve us all, humiliate us all, but I am to blame: I shot a rocket back.” - Chomsky
The blame should be laid squarely on European imperialism and colonisation in the world. America foreign policy for their own selfish interest is also a chunk part of the problem.
@@kassimsaeed789 No, the blame should be put on the arabs for spending generations playing the perpetual victim instead of doing literally anything to improve their situation, and the arab world for coordinating to make sure the palestinians remain in perpetual limbo, passing refugee status down through generations instead of either emigrating elsewhere, or living peacefully among their neighbors. They chose rockets, and death, over prosperity and life.
Perfect summation of the conflict.
It's more like:
“I shot a rocket. You take my water, burn my olive trees, destroy my house, take my job, steal my land, imprison my father, kill my mother, bombard my country, starve us all, humiliate us all, but I am to blame”
@@mithulahiri4105 it's a perfect summation if you're completely historically illiterate and choose to believe blatant fabrications and propaganda instead of documented historical fact.
She didn't migrate to Israel, she went occupying palestina
It's called Judea. Google is your friend.
Jews = we were here 2000 years ago.
Palestinian = we lived here since 2000 years ago.
@Samuel Johnson Dont be stupid and act like USA didnt help Isreal at alllll
@Samuel Johnson
You got help of the whole west
@Samuel Johnson you making a case for Nazi Germany or Israel, o right same shit.
@@ld.2979 In 1948 Israel was armed only by the Czechs not America. The Arab Legion in that war was officered and armed by the UK. Later the USSR armed the Arab armies and the USA armed Israel. However there were never any US military involved.
@@hassanlabyad4082 Nonsense, in 1948 the UK supported the Arab Legion and the US refised to sell arms to either side. It was only the Czechs - who were not in the West at that time - who armed Israel.
So, a german jew moves there, can't speak a word of hebrew i assume and then says "i see no reason why i can't live here."
I'm not sure if that's german arrogance or jewish delusion... Probably both...
@Samuel Johnson they shouldn't be there either
@Samuel Johnson yes. I always stand on the side of truth.
@Samuel Johnson they care about I think as much as they care about what you think, dumb ass mouth breather
She does speak Hebrew.
@@averegeyoutuber9133 😑 I live In NRW And I didn't even need Caption for Her Statements cause it Duestch
😃Will She Gonna Claim that Land for Duestchland ? She is a German after all
This documentary completely disregarded settler violence.
I disregard your mom
They completely disregarded Palestinian terrorism that started decades before the first settlement in the West Bank had appeared. And Palestinian terrorism continues to this day.
@@user-ey4os4hw6w the only people calling them terrorists are the Jews. Ya know, the same people actually called terrorists when they come the King David Hotel to solidify their nation.
And the world is just watching and does nothing against it.
thats sad. billion people who have brain and heart cannot do anything. few people have power and sadly supporting the oppressors
And so is Allah Allmighty :)
What can they do when the Palestinian-Israeli issue is more complicated beyond this video. They have their own minor wars they are fighting in their countries. Israel and Palestine should find a common ground for peace.
OSINACHI i think the root of the issue itself doesn’t make sense that’s how it will be hard to find justice and fairness for Palestine. cause Palestine never done anything, israel came to Palestine land and ask for some. After UN divided Palestine into two for both Palestine and israel, israel still seizing up their land till today even. and now see how it’s getting worse, israel gets more brutal and no shame, they won’t stop till they take whole Palestine, cause US as the most powerful country with special rights, will always support israel, israel have a big backup
Actually it did, US will send Israel more weapons to protect Jacob's right to steal Palestinian houses
For me, what I heard was the Israeli’s sense of entitlement and that their Arab “friends” should be somehow grateful for living on “their” land. It was subtle, but the language used by the Israelis did indicate superiority. The Palestinians men appeared to be more genuine and at a loss at the situation.
Peace is possible but they need to now live together in a democratic land and also go to the same schools where kids will get used to each other and that will eventually bring permanent peace.
@@democracyforall That's literally America. Not sure we've established a permanent peace here...
@@billymadison8574and so does Singapore and every ethnic group here are living in peace. Maybe there is something wrong with your procedure when trying to archive it?
Israelis truly think they are ''God's chosen people".
@@democracyforall
You’re joking right.
I read a book that there was bones of my ancestors being discovered in Europe that means I shall move to Europe now.
I'm going to use Mexican license plate on my car since California did belong to Mexico before it was invaded and stolen.
@@aprettymonotheismsfamilyof2380 Mexico ceded that territory, which included modern-day California, Nevada, Utah, and parts of other states, in 1848 after it was defeated by the United States in the Mexican-American War.
@@sahtzhen_o4392 what you're saying is a lie because I'm replying and CZcams keeps deleting it
@@aprettymonotheismsfamilyof2380 Well, what's your narrative about it?
@Shafigh Khalili The Mexicans of 1800s were mostly a mix of native Americans and Spaniards and some were full Spanish like Vallejo or Arguello....
Zero sympathy. Maybe a better documentary would be what it is like to be the ones being occupied and the world doing nothing about it.
They should stop looking for external help and start forming up a real leadership. .. but they cant. They are all divided, corrupt, and stuck in their oldschool ways. Time for them to change FROM THE INSIDE.
@John Smith Did he ask for sympathy? You're assuming what his position on British colonization is and trying to condemn him on that basis. Your error is the strawman fallacy.
@John Smith As for your 'breakdown' of history. The Palestinians were there at the same time as well. Palestine was colonized by the Ottomans, then the British, and now the Israelis after the British handed them most of the land. As for the onset of violence, the head of state for Israel at the time admitted that they preemptively attacked their Arab neighbours. Also, before Israel was 'recreated', the territory of British Palestine was in chaos as both the actual locals and the Jewish refugees were basically in revolt.
It's easy to paint the story as entirely one sided as you did, by leaving out more than half of the details.
@John Smith I see you're attempt to look for an escape hatch, and rate it a 1/5. Still a strawman argument, followed by a historical myopia.
@John Smith Well since you own 95% of the politicians in the usa, maybe you can answer your own question !!
The Romans conquered Britain over 2000 years ago, if an Italian came back now to England and claimed the right to land once occupied by the Romans.....we'd think he was joking.
@Bettina MN yea, you're talking about Israel right?
It's not as simple as that. The Jews have had a continuous presence in the land of Israel for the past 3,300 years. However, over the last 2,000 years they have not had political control over the land - but they have always been present there.
They were likely still a majority of between 200,000 to 300,000 under Roman and Byzantine rule and then afterwards their presence was concentrated in the main holy cities (Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias, Hebron, ...) . Remember Jews pray towards the city of Jerusalem every day (similar to muslims who pray towards Mecca) . Throughout the middle ages, there are many account of famous Rabbis who moved to the Land of Israel (Maimonides, Nachmanides, Rabbi Yehuda Ha levi, Rabbi Yosef Karo, Rabbi Chaim ben Attar ).
When the Ottoman empire took charge in the 16th century, conditions were more favorable for the Jews to return and many of the small communities began to grow (especially Safed!). By the end of the 19th century, over 60 per cent of Jerusalem's population was Jewish.
When the UN approved the partition of the land in 1947, there were about 630,000 Jews which was 32% of the population - they were more or less granted the areas that had a high Jewish population (they were also given the dry Negev desert for some reason !) . They accepted the plan and established the first Jewish political rule over the land for a long time.
So there was always some Jewish population there, but it was the first time in 2,000 years that Jews had political authority over some part of the land .
and if he defeated Britain and all of their allies, he would be the owner of some cold, rainy islands formerly known as the United Kingdom
@@gj6126 .... Muslims also in Spain In Smaller Community since 14century You Got My Back for Emirate of Cordoba ?
When will you guys Done with Jokes
We accept Jews Who are Middle Eastern and Those 3% who Were they're before You guys Start coming from Europe like a Gold Russ Happened
Romans DID NOT originate from england, they were NOT indigenous, they came as conquerers spreading Christianity
Jews ORIGINATED from israel, their language, religion ORIGINATED there…..
I fail to see the similarity…….
They came to west bank from Russia Germany, Argentina and in title on land and Israel passport... Local Palestinians dehumanized just because of the nationality: ( Shame of the world!
what west bank would that be the 1's the arabs are occupying
since when palestinian people exist?
@@arjakezhaz4951 your name is literally arjake
stfu
The world will face its punishment
@@arjakezhaz4951 Palestine has been settled continuously since 4000 bc. Palestine derives its name from the Philistines who arrived in what was then Canaan in the fourteenth century bce, and eventually occupied the Mediterranean coastal plain from Jaffa to the Sinai. The Jews moved into Palestine from Egypt c.2000 bc but were subjects of the Philistines until 1020 bc, when Saul, David, and Solomon established Hebrew kingdoms. The region was then under Assyrian and, later, Persian control before coming under Roman rule in 63 bc. Palestinians are a mix of both indigenous pre-Israelite populations and later groups that settled in Palestine. The Arab conquest did not even result in a large transfusion of Arabs. Therefore ever since the philistines the region has been called Palestine and respectively, the native people where called Palestinians. Learn some history then you can make political claims.
“You can't have occupation and human rights.”
― Christopher Hitchens
He hated religions but hitchens was on point in this issue
I will go stay in my neighbor's sofa without permission and when they ask me to leave I'll just convince them that we should just talk about it :)
A sofa that used to belong to the ancient isrealites...
@@yurichtube1162
What is the relatioship of this japethian ashkenazi khazar to the anciant israelites
The anciant israelites are the very so called palastinians whose ancestors converted and got arabized and whom falsely you have named palastinians like the romans did to their ancestors
You were banished to exile you don't have any land, but time will come it's ok.
Amnoum N yes because ashkenazi are the majority in the jewish state.
You expelled and displaced Mizrahim and Sefardim jews living in Arab and North African lands and they have no place to go but Israel.
Moroccan jews are the largest jews in Israel.
@@francishallare204
Yez for mizrahim. Nope for sephardim.
The only descendants of jacob among the talmudics so calling themselves jews are the mizrahi of the levant, irak, iran.
Yemenite are arab converts from hemiar tribe in history
The sephardics are ethnically hametic amazighs descendants of berber tribes who converted in history to talmudism and their place is north africa
A squatter from brooklyn, paris or sm distant place in europe is entitled to live in Palestine while the original inhabitants do not have any such right...Israeli logic.
a rich squatter. thats the point, rich jews from west are RICH, thats why brits decided to sold them this land back in 1948
@@Nickxxx85and the Brits didn’t own the land either, they also took it, so saw no problem with this method.
These people who hate and think they have the right to kick out Arabs/Palestinians have ancestors who went through horrific genocide and were persecuted yet instead of using their own pain to prevent such things happening again, it’s almost like they feel entitled to hurt others because they have been hurt. whatever you do to someone will in some way cycle back to you..
[ These people who hate and think they have the right to kick out Arabs/Palestinians ]
Who were kicked out? Nobody was kicked out in the construction of that specific settlement. That was unused land.
(1) This was disputed territory.
(2) No individual owns the land.
(3) The land is unused.
(4) Building structures on that land is illegal according to international law AND Israeli law. That's the only one I can agree with from the anti-Israel talking points.
(5) That's it.
(6) Some family was kicked out. Nope.
(7) Some house was taken over. Nope. This was unused land.
(8) Some individual's land got grabbed. Nope. While this land should be Palestinian territory, no individual Palestinian actually has title to the land. This was just unused land.
(9) While 6 to 8 do happen, it did not happen in this specific settlement. This would be more common in Jerusalem today or during 1948.
Do not mix up your talking points. Learn to differentiate SPECIFIC settlements.
When those who are oppressed haven’t inwardly resolved their feelings of oppression they will oppress..much the same as the Palestinians…and their supporters …both have been oppressed and oppressors and until there is a letting go of this mindset ( takes work, self honesty and humility), then the suffering will go on and on …each side and their supporters defending, attacking and justifying….
Well said 👏🏽
FACTS
@@dancheng3014 Bro, come on. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians have been forcefully displaced in recent decades. Even the documentary mentioned the settlement was illegal according to the UN. Why don't you read some of those UN condemnations?
"If I don't steal your house, someone else will"
Jacob, 2021
I dont believe this dude was there 2000 years ago
It's Ridiculous
Doesn't matter... God promised him the land.
You sure do not know about archaeology and history, eh?
@@ianhomerpura8937 Archeology and Zionism are not friends. There's very little archeological evidence. No 'First Temple'. No proof of a 'David' or Solomon'. Hardly a thing at all. As for history: there's 2000 years of hardly any Jews being in Palestine before the white European colonist arrived with their plan.
@@ianhomerpura8937 even 2000 years ago,its not israel live in palestine. Its the prophetic lineage. Its not israel now. Its palestinian that live here.
The Palestinian Arab was not allowed to enter without an ID.
He could go to a Palestinian mall instead.
@@_Viking lol
@@_Viking Well the joke is that this is a mall in Palestinian territory, so yes, he was going to a Palestinian Mall
@@mohammedabobakr6549 you're wrong. It's Israel. It has _never_ been a Palestine in Israel. You got Trans-Jordan when "Palestine" was divided between Jews and arabs after WW2. But that wasn't enough, you wanted half of Israel's part too. Even that's not enough, since most arabs don't want there to be an Israel at all. "From the river to the sea, isn't that what you usually say?
Jews have three thousand-year-old history in the middle east, yet you claim that a 1500-year-old cult has more right to the land? Strange logic, if you ask me.
BTW, why do arab men run to Europe? Don't you have balls enough to stay and protect your family and your land? It seems like all you do is crying and complaining.
White suppremacist at his finest !!
These people are completely out of their minds, this is beyond insane, it's criminal
I'm sure the German woman is nice on a personal level, but at the end of the day she's willfully ignoring the way she's participating in and perpetuating an obvious system of oppression. It's a difficult thing to fully acknowledge and on a certain level I don't really blame her, but still. Own your shit lady lol.
During the 2nd world war most Germans did not see any wrong in Nazism. These settlers are Nazis.
Its easy to see and acknowledge, but she ignores it as it doesnt suit her. Its quite german of her to feel that getting to know a native elevates her in a self riteous way.
@Sonny BBC, CNN etc... criticise China for no free press, but these channel are bias in there review of the world, when they are simply not lying or bluntly omitting the truth... For example if these channels criticise Israel it will always be a very much lighter version from the truth of the story, which interestingly B'tselem, and Israeli human rights group, shows in there videos on CZcams with few people watching and subscribing to there channel.
I'm sure nazis were nice on a personal level and so were afrikaners. It still doesn't mean shit, they're still willingly supporting opression and settler-colonialism
I'll pick nazis over Hamas terrorists, atleast they're organized
I'd like to point out that the difference between this and illegal immigration is the amount of funding.
GOOD POINT! speech sir! couldnt have said it better
Honestly
Yes, for migrants coming from Central America to the United States, they have to pay thousands in the hope of a new life. To immigrate to Palestine, they will pay you to risk your life on the front lines of an illegal occupation.
I laughed so hard at 00:39, imagine someone taking your land and claiming that direct contact is the real road to peace .
But contact between Arabs and Jews and open mindedness is the way to peace…where children mix together, eventually there is acceptance, whatever their initial stance was from their indoctrinating families ….and so you do get peace. Otherwise each believe in an image of the other and that image tends to be a fictitious monster.
Yeah.. But atleast she is better than the others who try to kill Palestine out of existence
Haha and with the serious music on top it seems like a crazy man narrating with no touch to reality. In 20 years people will ask themselves how could such a horrific thing have happened?! With a lunatic media like this!
Who told you it is their land?
@@ChayaT your mum.
Settler ? That's colonisation
The Rabbi was surprised to discover that Palestiians were humans who thought they were being occupied.....which planet has he been living on ??
My heart goes out to these poor fascists :(
🤣🤣🤣
A bit overblown.
@@ems7623 not at the slightest fascist.
I can't imagine receiving resistance while colonizing someone , that's horrible
It,s too deficult to be a colinizer
"If I don't steal it, someone else will"
“If I don’t steal it someone else is going to steal it” - Jewish Extremist settler proverb
This video was published 3 years ago. Not after Oct 7th.
Well spotted lol
"Life as Jewish settler in the West Bank"
Translation: Life as a white European colonialist in any given place except Europe.
“Older men declare war. But it is youth that must fight and die.”
― Herbert Hoover
ধন্যবাদ...
thanks
That's 20th century. Wake up- it's 21st!
@@AA-pe9yy It's always been that way from thousands of years ago.
What the Israelis are doing to Palestinians in their own land is just cruel but of course it is more convenient for the world to look the other way.
You have got to be kidding me. Your comment comes on the day when Gaza sent bombs to southern Israel, it literally happened today!! Israel got every right to defend itself against a hostile group who wants death, not co existence.
@@czystekurestwo Agreed it's their Government that is at fault
@Traveller Blame the Government for not coming to the table for negotiations. Also spending money on weapons instead of their people !
@@carolkline5843 Hasbara troll;)))
It's my land now , cry me a river
She wants peace but she’s also a settler 😭 how clown!
“We were here 2000 years ago”………. That says it all 🤣🤣🤣
When your God's into real estate.
Q'uran states that whenever your land gets stolen, you can kill those who stole it to get it back.
@@SnafuWT qu’ran also recognizes judea and Samaria as the land of the jews ;)
@@joaocoelho8320 btw the quran doesn't or wven the bible don't support land theft. In the west bank there are four thousand illegal jewish homes that r built on private palestinean property. Y is it ok to trespass on another person's land?
Well put.
@@ahmada7333 lol yes it does! And this is not land theft , unless you’re accusing the arabs of being the settlers, sorry pal but even your own book says so ..
Those will only increase get used to it, that land was never yours
Title is wrong, should be life as an illegal Jewish immigrant in Palestine
@@arielnitzav2181 racism much
At 7:40 "on the question of whom the land belongs to, there are no easy answers...." Its an ILLEGAL settlement in an occupied territory, whats so difficult to understand?
Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere....UN should think about it .
Speace and justice is not the same. UN is an organization for speace not justice, plus we all know the UN cannot over right a nation wish, they can only offer a table for speace talk
But that's not allowed to happen, it's a violation of international laws, but Israel can do everything they want and won't be punished in any term, USA will protect them, Europe will protect them.
I understand that DW has a lot of German guilt, but seriously... don't praise these colonizers and apartheid lovers.
...praise???
@@DWDocumentary Yes as you using
very diplomatic words to save own image so no one call you anti semantic
mention the UN Law but not calling them what they are
They are killer occupier
Without any law grabbing the land on gun point
IAF intentionally killed young boys or paralyze them by killing on lower parts
After all of this West including US
just do paper work in UN and physically EU and US fully support them
People of Palestine nothing to do with
World war two but they still suffering
Palestine people did not occupied land they are victims of your hypocrite behaviour
God will do justice at the end of day
@@DWDocumentary "The young German is aware that her presence alone is a provocation for many Palestinians." oh, its good to know blatant land theft recognized as illegal under international law "provokes" only "some" of the lands original inhabitants.
imagine a media source saying rape only hurts "some" of its victims. that's your bias, @DW Documentary
Thank you for another insightful documentary DW. But I still fell that the Israelis should give the land back to the Palestinian people because it belongs to them
Jerry Ventura
Most of the people who fought that war are dead. The issue now are the people of today. The regimes on both sides are preventing peace.
Jerry Ventura did you miss the fact that before 1948 non of you guys were there. Now go back to Europe
jordan was created on 78 percent of Palestine!!!! Al that is left is 22%
@@jangodarkblade3360 same as palestinian. Most of them are jordanians and some are egyptians. Many native now live in chile. I think it's better both of them ( fake palestinians and israelis) give their land back to the native.
@Patricia Palmer Less than 1/3 of the world's Jews live in Israel. The rest live happily in every corner of the globe. Netanyahu keeps trying to recruit them to Israel but they're not interested. In fact, there has been an exodus of sorts of young Israelis leaving Israel www.abc.net.au/news/2018-08-28/berlin-becomes-a-haven-for-jewish-migrants/10164330.
Russia has a Jewish autonomous region. One of the largest Jewish communities outside of Israel is in Iran. There are Jews in Europe, Asia, the Americas, Africa, Australia. Seven million people would be easily absorbed by the world. Don't worry. They've got plenty of places to go.
occupants!!! my country was occupied by ruzzia and we hated it but could not do anything just silent resistance until we got our freedom back., Freedom to Palestine
Most of these settlers have grown up in America, Germany wherever just go back!
They came and settled there just because their religion originated there
(Just because the place where you lived didnt accept you and tortured you, you should not go to other place and torture others)
its disgusting that humans so easily see others as less human than themselves. wake up and realise that every human is human and that means they have human experiences and feelings and thoughts and should have human rights just as yourself, its not a difficult concept and should be basic logic for everyone
Jango Dark Blade
I think J is talking about the same people that you are.
Robustus your 100% right
It's not that they don't see them as humans, but are driven by their own survival.
Since when is Israeli court rulings above international law?????
Ever since national law is the relevant law for a country. Check out other countries' law systems you'll be surprised
You shouldn't even be there. End colonialism!
You should have said she is living in an illegal statement in West bank!!
I agree with your settlement!!!
Occupying other peoples land is normally illegal. But it seems to be permitted if you steal Palestinian land.
Please look at maps from directly after WWII and now. Palestine has been torn to pieces and most of it now "belongs" to the occupants. And it gets worse by the day. Don't forget to look at the maps!!
You move out of the lands your forefathers stole and you occupy first then tell us we cannot return to our ancestral home land hypocrite European.
Why only look back from after ww2? Since you're already going back in time, at least go all the way back when it belonged to the jews over 2000 years ago.
Also, you guys have land stretching from Pacific Ocean to the Indian Ocean. Stop giving me this bs about yoir land being devoured. You make up the vast majority of rulers & owners of the Middle East!
@@Denis-on2jk exactly
@@Denis-on2jk It always was Palestinian land, first stolzen by Great Britain. Thanks for reminding us that there are a lot of occupiers of Palestine.
She sees no problem with how she feels and where she lives. "They just need to understand that I am right". She certainly sounds very German, if nothing else.
🤣
Pretty racist of you.
Lebensraum 2.0
I mean- Germany, if you feel so bad towards them, why not give them a piece of your land?
Last week I was walking down a road, I saw a big mansion owned by an old couple, I asked them if I could stay at their house and they were very happy to let me stay temporarily, as time passed they became more and more exhausted by my stay and I became more and more infatuated with their house. I even began to invite my friends to come and squat there, until we finally said one day this house is ours and locked them outside. I am an Israeli and that old couple is a Palestinian one. This is exactly what is happening in Israel and it’s how it will stay sadly.
Excellent allegory you summed it up beautifully.
They want us to feel sorry for them for stealing Palestinian land and not enjoying leaving there ?
The oppressors have special place in hell
FR€€ PAL€STIN€! 🙏🏽❤
She’s a criminal
It’s so weird how they want to live in poverty when they can freely go anywhere but Palestinians can’t
They can. You just need ID.
2000 years old 😂 at least they are talking. Its like having a guest who never leaves your house. As a semite myself i never claimed that part as my homeland. Poor palestinians i hope they get thier land back ❤❤❤
My god! Yournot brainwashed! Let's be friends 💜
I guess you have another one Reem lucky you we havent had it for a long time
That's pretty interesting to understand, how background sound is used in to fuel, emotional connection that how much these colonisers are suffering after occupying other's home, farm land and even their peace!
Criminals. The settlers are trespassing and not wanted there. You can't just kick people out of their homes. You'd think the people who suffered pogroms for centuries would have empathy and not see the hypocrisy, but you'd think wrong.
I live in Germany and I am shocked that a women who recived good eduvation in germany thinkt like that. I know that everyone has an opinion and an opinion can not be good or bad but her opinion is beyond bad.
Eh, she's Russian.
Oh know they're settlers. No. They're occupiers.
Soldiers are occupiers, civilians are settlers.
@@dionysus8967 actually they whould be colonists, not settlers, since settlers implies the land is unowned.
Validating two thousand year-old land titles certainly complicates things, just imagine if some native american tribe living in Honduras claimed Texas or if some aboriginal people living in Papua New Guinea claimed Australia that is how this whole thing must have felt in 1948.
Well and if they came back and claimed it what would you say?
“If I don’t steal your house someone else will.” -Yacob, 2021
“War does not determine who is right - only who is left.”
― Anonymous
Also War determines who is gonna rule the land and control the spoils, this is how Israel been created and this is why we have 4 Palestinian out of Palestine , and this is why Palestinians who still live in Palestine are second glass citizens, and this is why they can't prevent Israel from taking over their land and homes , therefore this is why Israelis enjoy much more resources than their opponents, let's not lie to ourselves, without the Israeli army , Israel would never be exist
@@jeffjeff5719 Without Israel Palestine would not be there .They supply water .They invent most things also they cultivated that land .Blame the Palestinian Government for the peoples problems.
Well, 'Anonymous' you are very wise !
@@carolkline5843 If we were neighbors and I decided you weren't using your property to it's full potential so I planted my garden in your yard, would you be to blame or would I just be a greedy land grabber?
@@rollingthunder1751 Dont reply with stupid comments like this one !
British colonised India and some "rulers" made friend with locals But, British remained colonial masters and Indians remained "subjects"
This is same story in Apartheid Israel , where Israelis are Colonial Masters and Arabs are 3rd class citizens.
From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.
from the river to the sea palestine will never be free as long as hamass and plo are in power
From the river to the sea, Palestine will be FREE
🇮🇳🇮🇱🇮🇳🇮🇱🇮🇳
🤣nice dream
Won't happen
We were here 2000 years ago 😂😂 😂 😂😂
Leaving Germany for that 😂🤦♂️
yea and she was born and grew up in different countries and cultures so its not like thats her original home and she missed it so much.. guess its the free land and all the perks that they get that makes them make the move to that like she explained herself
Her mere existence there is causing oppression on others.
Yeah could not believe it either !!!
I guess being trailer trash is acceptable if you are the chosen ones !!!!!
I know 😂
They are agents or atleast the ring leader and the rest are sheep that follow the leader.
The narrator said anyone caught talking with the other side is punished, apart from its only the Palestinians being punished and arrested and the settlers can do what they like. Arrested by the IDF not even Palestinian forces. They don't want Palestinian's talking to the settlers because the settlers will then see how wrong they are.
"If I don't steal your house, someone else will"
Jacob, Illegal Israel Settler, 2021
True, I rebuilt my fence and pushed the fence over into my neighbors taking some land in the process. Now, they're suing me in court asking for their yard back. How preposterous of them
They should just leave they arent wanted there
You don't specify who should leave.
The Israelis? Or the Palestinians?
@@Thor.Jorgensen ikr i meant jews should leave
@@user-fq5dt6to2h .... and the Jews think Palestinians should leave as they are not wanted there, either.
@cdpgbc 1966 but the ENTIRE middle east want jews out not just palestinians
go back to Africa where all human race came from
Religious madness is the problem
That has nothing to do with Religious, it has to do with people who come to this country to not live with people side by side but dominate them.
Must be very cheap to live on someone else’s land !
Not all Jews left palestine. Many stayed there alongside christians and later on alongside muslims. And many jews later on converted to Christianity or Islam. There is no way to distinguish now who owned these lands 2000 years ago.
Imagine if someone comes to egypt and says "I am descendend of pharaoh because I say so. Now give me my land back."
Should this be an acceptable cause?
Absolutely appalling. How could anyone steal a person’s home and not be morally bankrupt.