100 Honest One Sentence Kpop Opinions

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 9. 09. 2024
  • Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @planetminjae
    Read This!
    dotherightthin...
    Intro Song: Crush by MCND
    Outro Song: Cat Waltz by MCND
    planetminjae.c...
    Business Inquiries: minjaeplanet@gmail.com
    FAQ:
    Name: Juice
    Pronouns: He/Him
    Stan list
    Tier 1
    MCND
    Tier 2
    Weki Meki, Billlie, ITZY
    Tier 3
    CIX, The Boyz, Loona, (G)I-DLE, Blackpink, Twice, ONF, Hyolyn, Kang Daniel, Lucy, Everglow
    Tier 4
    Ladies' Code, IVE, WJSN, NCT, Ateez, Astro, Momoland, Oneus, Seventeen, DKZ
    Tier 5
    Verivery, Cravity, Jo Yuri, Enhypen, Purple Kiss, Stray Kids, Lesserafim, Pentagon, Lightsum
    Tags:
    Kpop kpop k-pop k pop BTS Blackpink Exo Brave Girls Momoland Chungha Sunmi IU Kim Woo Seok unpopular opinions kpop unpopular opinions reactions reaction HyunA Dawn Aespa Treasure Got7 Day6 NCT 127 NCT DREAM NCT U WayV Nu'est Pristin IOI I.O.I UP10TION woo ah GFRIEND Mamamoo SNSD Girls' Generation IZ*ONE Wanna One X1 Shinee Super Junior Vixx Jessi Orange Caramel Miss A Block B Oh My Girl APRIL BoA CLC Somi EXID TXT Tomorrow By Together Bighit JYP SM YG BigBang Winner vixxo Rocket Punch Everglow Weeekly (G)I-dle Gidle ab6ix StayC Chung Ha Kingdom Mnet ELRIS WOODZ SuperM 1THE9 Lucy TOO Golden Child WayV E'LAST T1419 seulgiology axiestan itztaeiltime Drippin BDC MCND Minjae SuperM Enhypen D-CRUNCH OnlyOneOf Bae173 UNB D1CE 1Team Pinkfantasy Survival Show Epex Lightsum Hot Issue Secret Number Xdinary Heroes review rookie group 4th gen groups 3rd gen VIVIZ NMIXX lesserafim queendom boys planet StayC underrated overrated ruined stage presence lipsync raps album rappers hate love MAMA mnet KBS girl teen crush debut disband comeback releases 2022 plagiarized title tracks bsides b-sides brutally honest stage performance o.o Starship WM Mystic Story Jellyfish Fantagio RBW Brave Entertainment Top Media DSP IST MLD Woolim c9 FNC Cube Brand New Rappers Vocals Live Prerecorded GWSN tier list tier ranking Up10tion Cignature Bvndit Spica Woo Jin Young Cherry Bullet Kep1er Monsta X Mirae Dreamcatcher Tri.be StayC Wei VAV To1 Oh My Girl Woo!Ah! AOA Fromis_9 CLC Everglow Pixy newjeans red velvet
    #kpop
    00:00 Intro

Komentáře • 803

  • @PlanetMinjae
    @PlanetMinjae  Před rokem +138

    Ur mad
    bit.ly/3eVux2e

    • @burninfire158
      @burninfire158 Před rokem +112

      is it just me or why does it translate to "horrible food" 😭😭

    • @parkpark6976
      @parkpark6976 Před rokem +3

      I'm aware of cause and effect on your channel. better than the channel xxooxx real trash
      And thanks for sharing your opinion.

    • @victjsofjsmdngor
      @victjsofjsmdngor Před rokem +5

      @@burninfire158 same 😭

    • @twinspinning
      @twinspinning Před rokem +2

      The video isn't available in my country😭😭

    • @klaire5720
      @klaire5720 Před rokem +28

      and ur views were getting low obviously. seulgi’s gonna eat. don’t hate

  • @ncteno
    @ncteno Před rokem +1296

    just my thoughts: clc had everything to succeed, except a good company. they had the talent, the hard work, and released a fair amount of bops. unfortunately, they didn't have the proper funding or promotions, so how were they supposed to afford even the basic necessities? they had to ask other idols for money to get plane tickets and funds for their mvs. they could have succeeded, if only they had a better company.

    • @rexharschang6737
      @rexharschang6737 Před rokem +56

      They are definitely one of the best group ever in Kpop, a whole package.

    • @mirnagamino2023
      @mirnagamino2023 Před rokem +4

      They asked other idols?

    • @ncteno
      @ncteno Před rokem +57

      @@mirnagamino2023 yeah, they were forced to ask some of their idol friends for like a spare 200 every once and then.

    • @pinkkam
      @pinkkam Před rokem +44

      having to ask other idols for stuff is so embarassing, i didnt know they did that omg 😭

    • @ncteno
      @ncteno Před rokem +61

      @@pinkkam they must have felt humiliated, god i hate that company for forcing them to do that.

  • @NoopyP
    @NoopyP Před rokem +733

    I don't know how you can have so many k-pop opinions, I honestly couldn't even think of one on the spot.

    • @honeymilk3815
      @honeymilk3815 Před rokem +71

      I was gonna say the same thing 🧍🏻‍♀️ , like hell i forget i even have opinions of my own sometimes 😭

    • @theycallmelanita
      @theycallmelanita Před rokem +1

      kpop stans like this have no jobs its not surprising

    • @JSAiKO
      @JSAiKO Před rokem +10

      It’s easy, you just say everything sucks and that counts as an informed opinion apparently. Haters gonna hate, and that gets clicks apparently.

    • @doram.a8475
      @doram.a8475 Před rokem

      @@JSAiKO wtf ithink you are a child

    • @incheonguy
      @incheonguy Před rokem

      because toxic people always find negative thoughts and things to say.. People who aren't toxic don't really formulate negative opinions and they don't make YT videos about shit they don't like. Only a toxic person does that. thankfully all the toxic ktube channels are losing subs as people have figured out subbing them and watching this shit is part of the problem. So just skip it, or give it a thumbs down and NO VIEW. Eventually they will get the message or wither away.

  • @iexist8099
    @iexist8099 Před rokem +252

    Seulgi's solo did not suck one bit. Like it's so good 😭

    • @xourlovingbeautifulsoulx8165
    • @cam0987
      @cam0987 Před rokem +5

      I love it

    • @Poop-pd9tg
      @Poop-pd9tg Před rokem +3

      It is as artistic as Loona predebut songs + dance and vocals were crazy and on point, she mixed different singing techniques and styles + the growl is slowly becoming the SM trademark thanks to Winter.
      Honestly, the mainstream flock is boring and I guess EDM trash or strong beats are what they only want. They might as well just listen to NCS msuic

    • @tashasmithy5795
      @tashasmithy5795 Před rokem +2

      It’s an opinion

    • @twiceuuimida3847
      @twiceuuimida3847 Před rokem

      Ikr!

  • @martao332
    @martao332 Před rokem +509

    It's just my opinion but I think you shouldn't judge Seulgi's solo based on Wendy's and Joy's. She isn't releasing a ballad album or a remake one.

    • @donghye1004
      @donghye1004 Před rokem +19

      exactly!!

    • @JL-jg8tr
      @JL-jg8tr Před rokem +22

      Uh, don’t put the other two down just to bring up Seulgi. I’m sure she wouldn’t appreciate it. All three solos are unique and not for everyone, but you can’t deny the talent.

    • @lana89001
      @lana89001 Před rokem +75

      @@JL-jg8tr I don’t think they did…Joy did do a remake and Wendy did do a ballad…

    • @JL-jg8tr
      @JL-jg8tr Před rokem

      @@lana89001 yes, but isn’t that insinuating some kind of insult to those two?

    • @The_Rusalka
      @The_Rusalka Před rokem +52

      @@JL-jg8tr No, they’re just saying that they have different things.

  • @jaydenism2137
    @jaydenism2137 Před rokem +226

    for #87 i think that yunjin of lesserafim in the world is my oyster documentary speaking out about the racism she faced as a kid as well as AleXa on eric nam's podcast really is allowing idols to talk about their own issues.

  • @sleepyburrito6348
    @sleepyburrito6348 Před rokem +578

    For #50, I think it's important to separate how Soyeon is respected in the Korean industry vs. how international K-pop fans see her. International non-Nevies *hate* her, but from what I've seen from other writers, producers, directors, and the general public, Soyeon is actually one of the most well-respected artists in the industry right now, you'd just never know it from the way international K-pop fans (and especially K-pop Twitter) react to her doing literally anything. Look at how the entirety of international stan Twitter tried to discredit all of her work based on her writing 1 "bad" rap that was, by her own words, fairly basic English to make it easier for the Korean audience to follow.
    It just blows my mind how she can have one of the cleanest track records of writing, composing, and producing good music, having the respect of both her juniors and her seniors in the industry, getting praise left and right from the likes of songwriters like Ahn Ye-eun, and international stans will *still* try to rip her to shreds for any little thing that she does.
    Definitely agree on the Soojin thing though. As a Neverland, of course I miss her like crazy and think her situation was very poorly handled, but some of the Soojin solo stans are ridiculous. She went on hiatus a year and a half ago, was removed over a year ago, and her contract was terminated 7 months ago; it's time to move on.

    • @andtipidee
      @andtipidee Před rokem +35

      Love your answer! I thought it was really intriguing to see the opinions of Soyeon's domestic fanbase. She really deserves a ton of respect considering how much she's contributed to the industry.

    • @goodietwoshoes7238
      @goodietwoshoes7238 Před rokem +38

      the people who always appreciate her are the professionals. imo, I'd rather have professionals like me over mobs than the other way around

    • @Sammmm85
      @Sammmm85 Před rokem +2

      very well said👍

    • @Cloudkirb
      @Cloudkirb Před rokem +44

      The rap wasn't even bad though, it had a good meaning. Sure it could've been executed better but it wasn't as bad people make it to be

    • @sleepyburrito6348
      @sleepyburrito6348 Před rokem +34

      @@Cloudkirb Exactly, honestly I think a lot of international K-pop fans' reaction to the rap in Tomboy was 1) based on them not understanding that the rap was made for the Korean audience, not the Western one, so of course there's going to be nuance in it that a Western audience wouldn't understand culturally (e.g. "sometimes we swear without cigarettes"), and 2) only going based on the official broadcast version and not the uncensored CD version (so many people were pitching a fit about "I like to 'ehh' on drinking whiskey" without realizing what she's saying in the full version is "I like sex"). It wasn't a bad rap, but so many people were trying to paint her as a "bad rapper" as though she wasn't called the "Scary Unnie" on Unpretty Rapstar when she was younger than the rest of the contestants on that show, and like she hasn't written so many good raps throughout (G)I-DLE's entire discography and her solo work.

  • @gabrielnalom4930
    @gabrielnalom4930 Před rokem +128

    Soobin has the best blue hair of any idol ive ever seen. Like im not even exxagerating i genuinely think this.

  • @staysthetic
    @staysthetic Před rokem +538

    I agree so much with #11, Blue Flame and The Great Mermaid are on the next level

    • @thenerdoflife4302
      @thenerdoflife4302 Před rokem +10

      onda necks level

    • @Vtropicalmoon
      @Vtropicalmoon Před rokem +1

      my 2 favorites from le sserafim 💙🔥

    • @icy_memes5990
      @icy_memes5990 Před rokem +4

      @@thenerdoflife4302 if your making a joke about how winter says next level that's hilarious 😂

    • @Chrono_topher
      @Chrono_topher Před rokem +2

      Blue Flame and Sour Grapes for me
      But Great Mermaid is still very good

    • @thenerdoflife4302
      @thenerdoflife4302 Před rokem

      @@icy_memes5990 I didn't know she said it like that, lol. I just thought that people replacing the lyrics with other words was the meme in itself since I don't listen to aespa (since I'm keeping up with enough ggs I can handle for now, lol)

  • @bunbungabriel
    @bunbungabriel Před rokem +291

    42. I'm so ready for Mamamoo to have another hit, everything seems to be going well so far, rbw is actually putting effort into promoting the cb, they have had a bunch of appearances at festivals, have multiple tv appearances planned, moonbyul is about to win 'second world'
    Now all we need is a good song and the girls can take home a couple of wins 🤞

    • @lia_anh
      @lia_anh Před rokem +21

      The competition is going to be tough but the promotions have been pretty good so far and I have faith in the girls. Although in the latest video dropped on the Mamamoo channel they didn’t provide eng sub immediately so I was a bit disappointed, really hopes that they would change this…

    • @msnjs1939
      @msnjs1939 Před rokem +23

      @@lia_anh the English subtitles is a huge problem for their numbers. All the dang views go to the fan videos. So annoying

    • @lia_anh
      @lia_anh Před rokem +19

      @@msnjs1939 So annoying I know! What’s even worse is that during the whole year you’re so used to the solo content from the member’s channels who all have immediate eng sub, that when you open a OT4 video on the Mamamoo channel you remember: ‘Ah yes no eng sub…’ Why can’t they do this right?

    • @msnjs1939
      @msnjs1939 Před rokem +1

      @@lia_anh Right, so if they can do it how come the company can't do it?

    • @animecuredmydepression6700
      @animecuredmydepression6700 Před rokem

      Where to watch second world?

  • @YourPsychoanalyst
    @YourPsychoanalyst Před rokem +278

    I think that Seulgis solo album will be great because Seulgi is Seulgi, not to be confused with any other member of Red Velvet...

    • @riffgroove
      @riffgroove Před rokem +123

      SM has always done a great job of creating solos that suit the individual vibe of each member.
      Wendy loves smooth jazz and piano ballads above all else. She freely admits that Light Me Up is her favorite song out of RV's entire discography.
      So her solo album perfectly reflected that.
      Joy loves Trot music and retro radio songs, so her releasing an album of older cover songs she grew up listening to make perfect sense for her.
      If you're not into either of those things, you obviously aren't going to enjoy them as much as people who do.
      I'm sure Seulgi's solo will be no different. And from everything I've seen so far, it will suit her perfectly.

    • @demoniccharm8391
      @demoniccharm8391 Před rokem +27

      @@riffgroove you’re literally my favorite red velvet stan you always defend them

    • @andtipidee
      @andtipidee Před rokem +54

      @@riffgroove Exactly! They're doing what they love, so I love that for them than anything. They don't mind if the majority doesn't want it; they are creating music for themselves and the people who like that style. I personally find it cool that each member has their own underlying sense of uniqueness. Makes for a better debut for each member.

    • @riffgroove
      @riffgroove Před rokem +5

      @@andtipidee THIS!

    • @Be.my.chill.kill.127
      @Be.my.chill.kill.127 Před rokem +22

      @@riffgroove exactly! RV do concepts that mach the members personality the most, even their solos are versatile!

  • @oneout5143
    @oneout5143 Před rokem +77

    6. Xiumin’s debut made so much sense to me lol, considering his personality and the solo stages he’s had in the past, but I can definitely see how it must have been kind of shocking? for casual listeners with it deviating so much from the other members solo stuff. I feel like SM has actually done an incredible job at developing each member’s solo musical identity.

    • @northrnstar
      @northrnstar Před rokem +8

      it's such a fun and refreshing song and he embodies it so well. definitely on repeat

    • @akuhappy3246
      @akuhappy3246 Před rokem

      I always love sm's artist solo project in music release. They always has interesting concept and distinguish every member musical identity that suit them all

  • @seulgisthighs
    @seulgisthighs Před rokem +336

    Seulgi is gonna have the best solo album ever (and it's clearly different from joy and Wendy so don't understand you're concern but ok)
    Edit : I was right seulgis album is the best album ever there is nothing to skip she slayed everything she is the one and only ace

    • @klaire5720
      @klaire5720 Před rokem +57

      exactly. I don’t understand his concern tho. he’s not thinking logically

    • @alannguyen257
      @alannguyen257 Před rokem +12

      Teaser drop so crazy 🔥

    • @c7berrr344
      @c7berrr344 Před rokem +1

      Litteraly

    • @Be.my.chill.kill.127
      @Be.my.chill.kill.127 Před rokem +10

      Her solo looks very interesting

    • @mellow_doodle3998
      @mellow_doodle3998 Před rokem +20

      SM doesn't really take good effort for wendy and joy solo to be honest like water seems like Taeyeon rejected song and joy solo is mediocre it would be good if they give wendy R&B and for joy something classy or elegant. For selugi the concept and genre seems to be perfect so let's hope for the best.

  • @lia_anh
    @lia_anh Před rokem +131

    The last OT4 Mamamoo projects didn’t do really well cause they were mostly songs for the fans. Mumumuch was for their anniversary album, and WAW was a ballad released in the middle of the summer. I’d argue that all of their solos did extremely well actually, given the fact that they were solos, the members do have solid individual fandoms. However Mamamoo+ did fail to make waves and it somehow did worse than the members solos even though two of the members were there….
    I really hope that this comeback will attract the attention of many people and that they will snag a win despite the competition being so intense. Right now Mamamoo is a very fandom driven group so I hope that they can regain the attention of the international public!

    • @ezrahanif8531
      @ezrahanif8531 Před rokem +2

      mamamoo+ song Better is good though
      don't understand why it failed to attract the viewer

  • @gayperp
    @gayperp Před rokem +158

    I’d say Soyeon is so hated within the industry because she’s so talented. People feel threatened, especially because she’s a woman.

    • @ANONYMOUS-zy3cd
      @ANONYMOUS-zy3cd Před rokem +14

      Oh, I thought it was because of her controversies.

    • @harleyqueeen
      @harleyqueeen Před rokem +20

      Probably her personality and controversies.

    • @jessp.r.7181
      @jessp.r.7181 Před rokem

      @@harleyqueeen What part of her personality? And i thought all their controversies were resolved

    • @thundercloudss
      @thundercloudss Před rokem

      @@ANONYMOUS-zy3cd Can you elaborate what controversies shes involved? I didnt heard any
      The only controversy that was related to her is Soojins departure from idle

    • @nekame
      @nekame Před rokem

      true

  • @starscapers
    @starscapers Před rokem +28

    the more i think about #60 the more i agree with it like??? ten is SO multitalented he literally could have been one of the biggest idols in the industry if sm hadn’t locked him away after the 7th sense basically until wayv debuted

    • @leabaden5935
      @leabaden5935 Před rokem +3

      Exactly! And ten is such a good dancer one of the best in the whole Industrie for me even. But sadly I have the feeling after loocking him away and that weird hiatus situation with way v. That it still really affects the members especially ten bc in super m every one went crazy about teamin and Kai bc they are good dancers but ten often got overlooked. It's maybe an unpopular opinion but I like tens dancing way more than Kai and teamins. 🤷🏼‍♀️

  • @fogel5672
    @fogel5672 Před rokem +60

    To me Dreamcatcher has the best Discography. Title Tracks and B-sides

    • @jingl3ball
      @jingl3ball Před rokem

      Can you recommend me some bsides cause I’m tryna get into their music 👆👆

    • @hannispho
      @hannispho Před rokem +5

      @@jingl3ball hi fellow insomnia here!
      - locked inside a door
      - starlight
      - can’t get you out of my mind
      - whistle
      - poison love
      - and there was no one left
      - jazz bar
      - wonderland
      - silent night

    • @jingl3ball
      @jingl3ball Před rokem +1

      @@hannispho thank youu !! Will indeed listen to them

    • @Lemon-x-
      @Lemon-x- Před rokem +5

      @@jingl3ball in addition to what yunjinification suggested:
      - Red Sun
      - Black or White
      - July 7th
      - In the frozen
      Hope you find something you like!!

    • @jingl3ball
      @jingl3ball Před rokem +1

      @@Lemon-x- thank you ! I already love red sun so that’s a thumbs up

  • @AlM22
    @AlM22 Před rokem +69

    YES, I AGREE! Sour Grapes is my least replayed song on the album - TGM is my favourite yet soooooooooo underrated & Blue Flame is just perfection

    • @tpwk3321
      @tpwk3321 Před rokem +1

      I love sour grapes blue flames 🔥

  • @xourlovingbeautifulsoulx8165

    Seulgi's solo will slap

  • @shashou6912
    @shashou6912 Před rokem +67

    n° 79 about Oneus is hitting me hard. I'm afraid you're right, they probably have maybe one or two comebacks before Ravn's enlistment. The group will probably managed without him but with Seoho enlistment in 2024, it's gonna be hard. Keonhee is a great vocalist but it's mostly Seoho who is carrying the whole song (title track). I can see that Hwanwoong has been improving greatly in the last 2 or 3 comebacks, their company is probably training him to be more active as a vocalist. Let's just hope they won't have a hiatus and that Tomoons will still be here the next few years until they all completed their army duty 🤞🙏 A BG needs to be really popular and have a strong fanbase in order to survive after enlistment.

    • @ploryz
      @ploryz Před rokem

      Ravn ruins most of their songs so im.not worried

    • @xionlogy4496
      @xionlogy4496 Před rokem +6

      @@ploryz I hope that’s just a typo because he doesn’t ruin any songs..

    • @ploryz
      @ploryz Před rokem

      @@xionlogy4496 his rap is horrible, he ruins the songs. Example- to be or not to be.
      Lee do also is a horrible rapper who ruins songs but at least he can sing, ravn adds literally nothing to the group

    • @leabaden5935
      @leabaden5935 Před rokem +5

      @@ploryz well that's your taste and opinion I love ravns raps.

    • @shashou6912
      @shashou6912 Před rokem +3

      @@ploryz Well that's your opinion.
      Ravn rap is not very conventional. Not gonna lie, I wasn't really a fan of his rap until Lit but I never thought it ruined their songs. Now I like his flow and I think it fits very well with most of their songs.

  • @melodieimwindy
    @melodieimwindy Před rokem +84

    Im actually really excited for seulgis solo since she has a very different vibe from the other rv members and tbh her unit with irene had good songs so i kinda expect something like this

    • @leabaden5935
      @leabaden5935 Před rokem +2

      Same

    • @leabaden5935
      @leabaden5935 Před rokem +3

      @annayu for the doest time I watched it I thought so too. But now I'm absolutely obsessed. 😍

    • @luu_sama_
      @luu_sama_ Před rokem +3

      I will accept people not being in love with her title track, but all bsides on the album are so well produced and her vocals never disappoint. She rlly gave it her all 🙏

    • @jessp.r.7181
      @jessp.r.7181 Před rokem +2

      @annayu Yeah i always listen songs at least 3 times before i decide i don’t like them. Songs never reach the top when you just listen to them once because it’s something completely new for you. Sorry for butting in lol.

    • @aquelarre7616
      @aquelarre7616 Před rokem +1

      @annayuto you

  • @Felipe-rs2my
    @Felipe-rs2my Před rokem +39

    Seulgi's solo teaser is out and sounds amazing 😭

  • @angelkswi
    @angelkswi Před rokem +19

    SEULGI'S SOLO WAS SO GOOD

  • @pinutbutter5942
    @pinutbutter5942 Před rokem +4

    imagine ten was in 127,they would be much more popular than they're now

  • @ARandomHumanE
    @ARandomHumanE Před rokem +38

    With the jype opinion about what they're focusing on (71), nmixx really shocked me. Like their rapping is good, dancing is amazing, but they're best category is vocals with 4 vocalists being main vocal worthy. It shows a sort of change in the jype projectory and it makes me excited.

    • @youdonotknowwhoiamlol
      @youdonotknowwhoiamlol Před rokem +5

      I agree! I would have never expected a vocal-based girl group out of JYP, but here we are!

  • @jelly_beans1347
    @jelly_beans1347 Před rokem +128

    main vocals are mostly the underrated member (ningning, taeil, wendy, rosé, liz, keonhee, yedam) and main dancer material also (rosé, jihyo, ningning, heeseung)

    • @jamesfoster8654
      @jamesfoster8654 Před rokem +16

      Under-appreciated you can’t be underrated when your famous

    • @rubyjaneluvbot
      @rubyjaneluvbot Před rokem +42

      underappreciated not underrated. I personally disagree with ningning being main dancer material. winter is better than her but ningning has better stage presence.

    • @xourlovingbeautifulsoulx8165
      @xourlovingbeautifulsoulx8165 Před rokem +9

      Disagree with main dancer material part, having energy or stage presence to execute the movements doesn't equal a good technique or executing the movements the best, which is one of the main factors that make main dancers be main dancers, as the other comment said Winter has a better technique than Ningning, etc.

    • @_aiko020
      @_aiko020 Před rokem

      @@rubyjaneluvbot watch the illusion dance practice and try saying she's not main dancer material again 🙃

    • @_aiko020
      @_aiko020 Před rokem

      @@jamesfoster8654 ok and? Same thing.

  • @Lekta
    @Lekta Před rokem +8

    60. I could write a novel about how badly SM screwed up with Ten and WayV in general.

  • @maitreyikulkarni6045
    @maitreyikulkarni6045 Před rokem +32

    #30 SOMEBODY SEES IT, like i think that's also a reason why there's so little solo stan wars within carats (as if there's any war at all), bc all the members do get some sort of genuine recognition and have evenly distributed solo projects as well as lines. post 2018, the line distributions and different sub-unit bsides (like flower, light a flame, etc.) really show just how much potential each member has. and im here for it!

  • @faelotus
    @faelotus Před rokem +33

    With # 89, it would be so interesting to hear a full video essay on this opinion. I also had this suspicion as well but I could never explain why.

    • @diana-by2mt
      @diana-by2mt Před rokem +1

      I would like that too

    • @sweetmonster324
      @sweetmonster324 Před rokem

      Can u explain me about that opinion i didn't understand

    • @amorelockster1023
      @amorelockster1023 Před rokem

      Yes I’ve also heard about companies using idols dating relationship rumors to cover up scandals

  • @maitreyikulkarni6045
    @maitreyikulkarni6045 Před rokem +50

    #48, yeah i agree. i do have fingers crossed for yuju though, her discography is my most favorite post-gfriend release and i like how she debuted with such a solid, distinguishable sound, if you get what i mean.

  • @yvsypvsy
    @yvsypvsy Před rokem +58

    i love that planet minjae's opinions aren't just hating on the idols for no reason, and are actual fair opinions. we stan

  • @ChicaBuenosAires
    @ChicaBuenosAires Před rokem +19

    Also somebody needed to say that about Soojin. I get it, it was so unfair, but we need to move one if we wanna support the I-dle members. Sometimes it feels like their hard work is dimished bc something "would sound/be better with Soojin".

  • @Winnangh
    @Winnangh Před rokem +16

    I agree with your opinion on NFTs. A someone who has been closely following the gaming indistry and the developments/discourse on NFTs there... Having these things land in kpop is worrying.

    • @riggsmarkham922
      @riggsmarkham922 Před rokem +2

      NFTs are certainly nasty, but the whole market for them has utterly collapsed since their peak last winter, so I’m not too worried that they’re going to take over *any* industry at this point.
      They might still exist in kpop for a while, but I feel like they’re going to turn into nothing more than normal, boring collectibles - the “get-rich-quick” bubble around them has popped imo.
      At least I hope I’m right and they don’t come back with a vengeance.

  • @ayoidek6571
    @ayoidek6571 Před rokem +4

    4:58 bro you need to listen to Hope world if you think j-hope makes emo music, before jack in the box this man was literally known for bubbly and happy music

  • @prakharjyoti9033
    @prakharjyoti9033 Před rokem +20

    42. I'd argue that their past comebacks weren't impactful considering that all the ot4 music that they released last year was just for 'fans'! Their last proper comeback with promotions was Aya which actually did pretty well and they even performed in on MAMA.
    Now, talking about the solos which also did good considering the bare minimum promotion that they get. The clear example here is WheeIn and how her company actually pushed forward with the promotions, which even got her a win (when full fledged solo artist are unable to get one).
    Let's cheer on our girls this time ✨

  • @daisylee5410
    @daisylee5410 Před rokem +6

    FINALLY SOMEONE ELSE WHO ONLY COLLECTS THEIR ULTS ALBUMS 😭😭 and even with that, I only collect SOME of my ults and have different rules for each group for max affordability 💀💀

    • @daisylee5410
      @daisylee5410 Před rokem +2

      For example Dreamcatcher is one of my ults but I'd never collect them bcuz gurl- SO EXPENSIVEEE

  • @Em-nu2dt
    @Em-nu2dt Před rokem +8

    SEULGI SOLO DID NOT SUCK. Not sorry

  • @helengarcia6834
    @helengarcia6834 Před rokem +6

    can we have an update on your thought of seulgi's solo?

  • @eddiy335
    @eddiy335 Před rokem +10

    "Sour grapes"is a great song but "Great Mermaid" and" Blue flame" deserved so much more.

  • @maitreyikulkarni6045
    @maitreyikulkarni6045 Před rokem +6

    and yes, i need a dino solo too because my god is that man the definition of an ace.

  • @graceharding5072
    @graceharding5072 Před rokem +4

    Anyways 28 reasons is so good

  • @dylancowan2075
    @dylancowan2075 Před rokem +21

    seulgi's solo debut slayed 🤭

  • @GoHawksDoesMC
    @GoHawksDoesMC Před rokem +14

    127 put something in the 2 Baddies album... they covered so many sounds but did it all so seamlessly and it's so addictive (except for Tasty, I'm sorry it just didn't click for me)

    • @shmems96
      @shmems96 Před rokem +2

      Same here! I love every song except Tasty 😅. It’s a bit too cringe

  • @marianaorozco1411
    @marianaorozco1411 Před rokem +8

    Well the thumbnail aged horribly

  • @moonhwi3754
    @moonhwi3754 Před rokem +5

    love how u flopped on the seulgi solo prediction.. it absolutely slapsssss

  • @mbr_80085
    @mbr_80085 Před rokem +10

    Somewhat related to 9(and 50&51); I really think a collab between Soyeon, Yeonjun, and Hongjoong would be such a slay and go so hard, tbh I just want idols to collab on music more 😭😭

  • @statesofgracie
    @statesofgracie Před rokem +7

    it’s live >>>> studio choom
    studio choom is nice and all but I can get the same experience from any music show or dance video
    it’s live is close to the only time you’ll ever get to see idols perform with a full live band and the only time you’ll get to hear that exact rendition of a song

  • @burninfire158
    @burninfire158 Před rokem +5

    Xiumin 😭😭 EXO 😭😭😭 I AM SO HAPPY HEARING OF THEM AGAIN MY ULTSS MY HEARRRRT

  • @Kiki_248
    @Kiki_248 Před rokem +7

    I personally view "My satisfaction" as IVE's best song (after love dive haha), so interesting how tastes differ!

  • @hoanhuynh7059
    @hoanhuynh7059 Před rokem +3

    JHope already released the kind of happy vibe songs you like, it's called Hope World. You should check it out. Thank goodness, BTS don't repeat the same concept. I am tired of kpop groups who keep releasing similar concepts repeatedly.

  • @flvrdust
    @flvrdust Před rokem +9

    seulgi’s solo was tew good y’all are just haters. the only thing i didn’t like about it is that i got a bts cookie add before it

  • @midnightshutdown
    @midnightshutdown Před rokem +13

    I am extremely excited for Mamamoo's comeback. From the teasers it sounds like the title track AND the album is going to be full of bangers, no "b-side sounding" b-sides here. I absolutely think this is their time to shine.
    I also honestly feel like their solo releases are doing well for the minimum promotion their company gives them. And although I would love for them to be recognized, I'm mostly just excited about the sheer quality of their solo music lately. Like have you heard moonbyul's shutdown or hwasa's bless U? Some of the best music to come out of kpop recently.

  • @Swastiii1103
    @Swastiii1103 Před rokem +6

    Well present here and seulgi's song didnt suck.

  • @seulgisz
    @seulgisz Před rokem +2

    my satisfaction by ive sounds like a dreamcatcher song

  • @igballehasani9910
    @igballehasani9910 Před rokem +20

    for opinion 14, my satisfaction is my favorite ive bside 😭lolll, i love the low notes they sing

  • @arnolacosta6093
    @arnolacosta6093 Před rokem +7

    seulgi KILLED IT

  • @caitlinmahsoeung
    @caitlinmahsoeung Před rokem +4

    I would like to say that I absolutley hate those "Its Live" channels cause theyre not even singing live, it annoys me so much becuse I just wanna hear them sing (even if it's shaky) but it's prerecorded or there's backing vocals which really dissapoints me- I just wanna hear them sing- like they do it to everyone but like even to stayc, wendy and somi as well (I don't even folloe them but geez), THEY CAN LITERALLY SING SO WELL WHY NOT LET THEM (it makes me honestly this upset cause they literally promote it as its live when its not T-T)

    • @reecegraham6921
      @reecegraham6921 Před rokem +3

      Ikr. It always irks me when kpop fans brag abt their idols singing based on those so called ‘live’ videos. Those are def not reliable videos to judge their live singing

  • @Bambabababambam
    @Bambabababambam Před rokem +8

    Mamamoo's solo releases always perform well, all members get wins except for Moonbyul but Moonbyul sells the most albums

  • @juliasalomonsson2287
    @juliasalomonsson2287 Před rokem +12

    The Hybe family show was so much fun, I agree. I would also love to see more shows like that. TBZ x ATEEZ could probably get pretty chaotic but it would still be fun. The first thing that popped up in my head was a show similar to 'Show me the mwm' but with more than one group, either more RBW groups or other groups. I've been wishing for a Oneus x Onewe season of this since the first season ended but I wonder if it's ever going to happen.
    Ailee and Sojung are both great vocalists, but I personally don't think they sound that similar. Or at least it's not something I think about. But now I'm thinking about how my dad said something like "if you made someone listen to this without context, you could probably trick them into thinking this is the original" when referring to Ailee's cover of 'I will always love you". That's kind of off topic but oh well.
    People getting mad at idols for smoking has always sounded a bit weird to me, even as someone who can't stand the smell of cigarette smoke. Like...many idols probably deal with a lot of stress so it's not that surprising. Do I think it would be better if they didn't smoke? Yes. But I'm not even going to pretend like I can tell idols what to do and what not to do. It's none of my business.
    Hating on "older" idols solely because of their age is something I will never understand. Like sure, younger fans might find younger idols more relatable but still. Unless they say or do something inappropriate I really don't see the problem. I honestly wouldn't complain if a group with members who are 60 years or older debuted, it could actually be fun. What's the problem?
    It's not like talent disappears with age. Maybe you don't find "older" idols attractive, but in my opinion that's not a reason to hate on them. With that being said, I also think there should be an age limit for debuting as a Kpop idol. I feel like it's never going to happen but oh well.

  • @bellatourigny4047
    @bellatourigny4047 Před rokem +7

    How u feelin now. Seulgi has in my opinion the best comeback of any female idols from a group.

    • @dgls127
      @dgls127 Před rokem

      The awnser is in the thumbnail

  • @ohnoits
    @ohnoits Před rokem +3

    4:06 Flashbacks to Yuna sneezing on camera and saying “bless me” 😂

  • @cocoatwist
    @cocoatwist Před rokem +19

    idc, ill never stop talking about the mistreatment of soojin as someone who has ulted her and gidle for years. the way she was ripped out of her beloved group for false reasons left so many people, including me, with a bad taste in their mouths and until she gets proper justice im not going to stop talking about it!

  • @seherozdemir463
    @seherozdemir463 Před rokem +3

    79.
    last night i was thinking when Ravn will be enlisted then i stopped calculating so i wouldn't cry 😢😔

  • @gabrielnalom4930
    @gabrielnalom4930 Před rokem +14

    Cravity rlly released two of the best title tracks of the year, and kpop stans STILL dont acknowledge them for it

  • @emirose3308
    @emirose3308 Před rokem +6

    I just wanna say on that one about wishing idols can be more open about their mental health. The one idol I know who is quite open about it is BangChan of Stray kids and while its great, all it’s done is have people tell him to k word himself and use it against him in stupid fanwars on twt. So i’m not surprised if Idols wouldn’t want to be open about it even if they could be

  • @NihilLucis
    @NihilLucis Před rokem +3

    most of the time, it's gg fans that bring up bg in their discussions...

  • @kainightshade5033
    @kainightshade5033 Před rokem +12

    42. I LITERALLY CANNOT WAIT FOR MAMAMOO'S COMEBACK!! I will admit I'm a bit nervous though. They need another serious hit like Hip and AYA. If they drop the ball...idk...😬 but I have every faith in them and won't even think about that! They have a lot of momentum right now with appearances, their solo activities, etc. Although I would say that only Moonbyul and Hwasa have the star power to stay relevant in the industry for many more years, I don't believe this will be Mamamoo's final comeback. I guess only time will tell. I'm excited about the ladies' future 😊

  • @aakritibansal4451
    @aakritibansal4451 Před rokem +5

    yujin is so charming like she has a personality while other female idols look like duplicates of each other like they dont have any individuality i swear 2022 awards could be interesting only if they dont give all the awards to BTS and BLACKPINK i had literally forgotten about showterview after jessi left

  • @mello4524
    @mello4524 Před rokem +5

    i wonder how tired irene is of people mentioning her age every 0,5 seconds

  • @KS-di4bn
    @KS-di4bn Před rokem +3

    I'm sorry I literally can't deal with Shut Down. Like they totally could've played the original La Campanella in the background as opposed to cutting it and repeating the same 4 bars over and over again/

    • @luisab3079
      @luisab3079 Před rokem

      Same, I do like the 4 bars they're playing, but after the tenth repetition I was so bored and annoyed by it.

  • @wimdmaster
    @wimdmaster Před rokem +7

    Xiumin's solo makes a lot of sense for exo-ls 💙

  • @nemo5288
    @nemo5288 Před rokem +4

    THANK YOU for mentioning (and having an opinion on) the sexism girl groups face with twitter posts such as the one you pointed out. Posts like the one shown mentioning bgs having little impact that years suggests the only reason why ggs are doing so well is a lack of male success or presence. As if the ggs would not do well if bgs were at the top of their game

  • @espressopicasso
    @espressopicasso Před rokem +12

    No but like 100% agree with #8. That Weekly Idol episode with Twice, GFriend, GOT7 and BTOB was honestly one of the best episodes ever

  • @DianaMartinez-fl1pj
    @DianaMartinez-fl1pj Před rokem +7

    About opinion 23: I agree so much with that! TWICE, for example, have A LOT of videos of them sneezing and I love it lol. They're my ult group, and it's very normal for me to see them sneezing or doing normal stuff like that, so I always thought it was common for idols to sneeze on camera, but I guess it's not (???)

  • @starzies
    @starzies Před rokem +30

    I was expecting Xiumin's debut to be in the same vein as Exo-cbx blooming day, but i was pleasantly surprised by the refreshing and really bright concept he took on!!
    And yessss Yunjin nation rise up. 🙏🙏🙏

    • @melody3629
      @melody3629 Před rokem

      i knoww! Im so happy his solo is being recieved well

  • @aeriwinter
    @aeriwinter Před rokem +10

    Bestie I asked you pink venom or shut down in your most recent live and you said idk when did u get so obsessed 😂

  • @sfukuda512
    @sfukuda512 Před rokem +5

    The Rocket Punch opinion hit me hard. All I can say is that it took them this long to find their sound. They still have hard core fans, myself included. The real problem is that Woolim is being that kind of company. They disappointed me with their lack of care for Lovelyz, and they are becoming Cube 2.0 with respect to their boy groups.
    They really need to bring in more Japanese and Chinese fans, but it seems that Le Sserafim is dominant in those markets.

  • @sarahslibrary
    @sarahslibrary Před rokem +4

    #60 This. Ten has everything that would make him such a popular idol like he has the talent, the charisma and he is an artist at heart, but he was (and still is) promoted so poorly that his talent can not be recognized. Maybe things can change once Super M picks up again, but that’s hard because he would more lines and with the Lucas situation who knows how long it will take for them to have a comeback. If anything, they should actually debut him as a solo artist instead of just letting his songs live on station. Idk, I have hope for him but it’s hard seeing him go unrecognized when he lives and breathes art.

  • @Bambabababambam
    @Bambabababambam Před rokem +2

    Soojin outsold

  • @niraxlevi9930
    @niraxlevi9930 Před rokem +3

    I agree shut down is a masterpiece everything about it screams unique to me i love the cross between classical amd hip-hop music

  • @dil8166
    @dil8166 Před rokem +8

    I'm not even into Dark and red velvet concept, but Seulgi' Debut just chief kiss. Even me, as non fans are hooked into her whole album.

  • @avril_moomoo760
    @avril_moomoo760 Před rokem +6

    42. Im excited for MAMAMOO cb. Although I really hope they get promoted good. It's not they haven't been doing good since their last proper release Aya did well. Its just the fact they haven't gotten any proper promotion since the company said they wanted to focus on their other groups :(

  • @ericacella1180
    @ericacella1180 Před rokem +3

    Seulgi got one of the best solo albums of the year.if you don't like anywhere but home and dead man running you don't deserve to have an opinion hahahahaha
    28reasons ate.

  • @allinonechrista
    @allinonechrista Před rokem +8

    Oh my goodness, I am so surprised you think that My Satisfaction is IVE's worst song - it's actually my favorite song from them and I wish more Kpop songs sounded like that!
    And I am extremely surprised that you think that Shut Down is Blackpink's best song! I prefer Pretty Savage, Boombayah, Playing with Fire, Kill This Love, Lovesick Girls, See You Later, Pink Venom, As If It's Your Last, Hope Not, See U Later, Forever Young, D4, How You Like That, Love to Hate Me, and Stay over Shut Down! Shut Down is a good song, but I am surprised that people love it SOOO much. I think the instrumental is a bit too repetitive. There's not enough variation within the song for me. It's good, but a little underwhelming and repetitive for my taste. The classical sample is very nice, but I wish they wouldn't have used it throughout the whole song. Using it in the intro, both verses, and the chorus was a bit too much in my opinion. The verses should've had a different sound and then went back to the classical sample in the chorus. That would've made the song better for me. I think this song has the opposite problem that Pink Venom does. Pink Venom has way too many different sound changes, but Shut Down doesn't have enough variation in the sound. Again, this is just my subjective opinion. Shut Down is still a good song!
    I do agree that the ageism is horrible. I can't believe there are people who say that being 20 is too old to debut. Not everyone is meant to achieve everything in their 20s. And not everyone has the privilege to be able to do what they want to do in their 20s, sometimes people have to prioritize other things (like making money) and then maybe, once they are in their 30s and have more stability in life, they can focus on doing what they want to do. One of my favorite CZcamsrs is in her 50s and she and her husband are living a happier and more successful life than a lot of 20 year olds! So what's to say that a 25 or 36 year old can't be a successful singer? I want to see more Kpop artists that debut at 25 or older! I want them to prove that it's not too late to do whatever you want to do!
    And I agree with what you said about how are some Kpop fans going to deal with things in the real world if they can't handle constructive criticism about their favorite groups. The real world and the world of work is unfortunately very harsh and they need to figure out how to not take things personally and not let what other people say bother them. If they don't figure that out, then it will be hard for them to handle everything they will have to face in life.
    I don't like Y2K genre of music and I hope that it doesn't become a trend either! And I agree that Hobgoblin would've made CLC a success if they debuted this year, I love that song so much!! As for the whole people who make mashups aren't music producers thing, that might be true, but some of the fan remixes are better than the original and I think that if you can make a song sound better than the original, then you ARE a music producer, even if you haven't made an original song yet.
    Thank you for making this video! I hope you are happy and healthy!❤️

  • @user-gq9ub7tb1z
    @user-gq9ub7tb1z Před rokem +4

    what a funny thing to judge Seulgi's solo based on the 2. from what I see...SM has done way more for her solo than the other 2...which is a shame but it makes me so excited for it

  • @dgls127
    @dgls127 Před rokem +2

    Does anyone here remember how was the thumbnail before? "Seulgi's solo will suck"?

  • @tensmitten
    @tensmitten Před rokem +2

    #60 opinion heartbreaking 🥺 genuinely praying for the best in ten lee's career and hope that ten karma would hit sm like a ton of bricks 🥺

  • @KK-lm2up
    @KK-lm2up Před rokem +5

    OH DID SEULGI PROVE YOU WRONG !! Her solo was 🔥🔥🔥

  • @anastasiagraham2418
    @anastasiagraham2418 Před rokem +2

    For number 49, idk man I still feel like ggs do have more unnecessary/shoehorned/bad raps than bgs. It’s not just the rap itself but how they deliver it. I think it boils down to how most gg members are not as well-trained as bg members to be rappers which is kinda understandable cause not many ggs do hiphop/rap-inspired music.

  • @Shashapartytime120
    @Shashapartytime120 Před rokem +4

    😐😐 Seulgi deserves an apology😐😐

  • @honeymilk3815
    @honeymilk3815 Před rokem +5

    #92 YES SLAY!!!!! I WANTED TO TALK ABOUT THIS. I came to know most people don't stan A.C.E cause they're "old" when they're not even 30 wtf. Y'all plain weird. A.C.E has one of the BEST and flawless Discographies EVER. AND they are cute asfff

    • @leabaden5935
      @leabaden5935 Před rokem +1

      I love "older" groups. When a group in their mid twenties to 30s debut which is kinda rare on this time period. They have soo many plus points. Groups getting younger and I'm older 😭🥲

  • @dajab.7331
    @dajab.7331 Před rokem +7

    I totally agree with the Sunmi's Showterview comment. I recently watched her interview with Ateez and although it was alright, the guys had more chemistry, fun and looked more relaxed with Jessi than her. Sunmi is amazing and charming, yes, but I genuinely think that there's something in Jessi that helps people feel free, safe and comfortable around her, and that's why her show was so cool. I don't really watch either Showterview, but Jessi's had more impact and iconic moments and I miss her a lot.

  • @caseywiththehat9018
    @caseywiththehat9018 Před rokem +3

    I always worry that opinion vids on kpop yt, the opinions will bash certain idols or groups (namely Stray Kids and other "hated" groups), so this video was genuinely a breath of fresh air

  • @tangerindream
    @tangerindream Před rokem +6

    #95 the way I smiled when I saw SHINee haha i feel like i've never seen that channel ever mention them so I was surprised to see the background lol. but yeah, older idols having opened some doors doesn't mean the whole system on which kpop is based has changed. Pop music (so, kpop too) is fresh, marketable, and often catered to younger audiences, so companies and labels will always prefer having younger and fresher faces to sell said music, and that no matter how many older acts manage to achieve longevity or set new standards for themselves.
    That said, seeing this video has been pretty funny for me because, as a 2nd gen kpop enthusiast, a lot of those things mentioned are stuff I stopped caring about so long ago. I also don't know or care about so many of the groups featured here, so this makes my experience watching this even more amusing, somehow.

  • @brandoncrenshaw5027
    @brandoncrenshaw5027 Před rokem +5

    I respect your opinion and just like you said I'm giving my opinion like bro where have you been when it comes to EXO they are the group that can do any genre they've been doing it since debut that's why they're so famous for that each member has their own sound. And like xiumin said he's a '90s kid so that's the sound he was going for 90s and early 2000s. So I don't understand what's so confusing it's a fun upbeat song with amazing choreography and it's really special to us EXO-L it's a gift from him. And his debut album is getting so much praise from producers and artists and fans all around the world his album and song is all over the charts with 147.000 copies sold so far already going gold in China we're happy for you my brother

  • @jojopark07
    @jojopark07 Před rokem +4

    1:47 I hope Hybe's gonna make it a yearly thing because I really love idol interaction. I love seeing idols being friends with idols outside their group.

  • @shaemarcelin3306
    @shaemarcelin3306 Před rokem +3

    I am that girl whining about Soojin even tho I'm not a stan. I don't care. I love watching their MVs solely for Soojin

  • @virtual_angel_.x
    @virtual_angel_.x Před rokem +1

    #60
    I never thought about it, but Ten in 127 sounds so good imo

  • @gabrielnalom4930
    @gabrielnalom4930 Před rokem +10

    Can we normalize reacting normally to survival shows and not act like xxx contestant wants to cut xxx contestant's limbs off when all of the judges make this face "😯" and not start literal wars from people (WHO HAVENT DEBUTED YET???). Thank you🥰

  • @paparapapaimlovinit4168
    @paparapapaimlovinit4168 Před rokem +2

    an ateez x the boyz series would heal the world yes.