I really love how in Trump, Payne just kind of loses relevance after the real killer takes the stand. He is kind of just coasting along, not understanding what the hell is even going on. This also kinda fits thematically when you consider the point of Apollo Justice.
1:24 Poor Payne. Phoenix's debut was so impressive that Payne made him his rival, but in the opposite direction, Payne made such a zero impression that Nick can't even remember facing him at all. Sums up Payne pretty well.
In Investigations 1, Winston stands outside the crime scene area and doesn't do anything, which can result in some players not being able to notice his presence. I did find it funny was actually being really nice to Edgeworth and Edgeworth not responding to his compliments and instead just inner monologes to himself that he has no clue who he's talking to. However, it does make sence Winston is so nice as both he and Edgeworth are prosecuters. In Investigations 2 however Winston has a much larger role. Yes, his niceness towards Edgeworth is again met with him being completely ignored, however when John Doe falls under suspision, Winston is appealing to the emotional side of players by demanding that Doe is imidiatly placed under arrest and later on he's used in order to ragg Swift onder the coals, which eventually results in Horace exiting the plane and attempting to hijack the investigation under orders from the president, only for Doe to then blow his own cover by holding Horace hostage.
@@DerpyHiro I saw some of my family members and friends play Investigations 1 and they completely missed Winston. In fact they were adement that they never saw him ontill I showed them playtrough.
Fun Winston Payne facts: 1. He is the only character (along with Gumshoe) to have a speaking appearance in every Ace Attorney game (including spinoffs) up to and including the release of Investigations 2 (since Phoenix and Maya do not speak in either Investigations game, and Edgeworth is absent from Apollo Justice). Payne appears in each of these games' first cases as well (including Investigations 1 and 2). 2. He appears in more cases in the original trilogy (5 cases: 1-1, 2-1, 3-1, 3-2, and 3-3) than Franziska von Karma (4 cases: 2-2, 2-3, 2-4, 3-5) and Godot (4 cases: 3-2, 3-3, 3-4 [as Diego Armando], 3-5). 2.5. Every case in Trials and Tribulations features Winston Payne OR Miles Edgeworth (but never both); Payne also appears in one more case than Edgeworth in the game (3 cases vs. 2). 3. In The First Turnabout, if you signal Larry to tell the truth about going to Cindy's apartment, he will say that he went but didn't see her. Winston Payne objects and says that he has a witness who can prove Larry is lying. Phoenix never objects before this point, which means that Payne's voice is the first one the player hears in the series. However, if you tell Larry to lie and say he never went, Payne never objects; he just calls Sahwit to the stand, where Phoenix's voice when he shouts either "Hold It!" or "Objection!" is the first one the player hears in the series. 4. In the credits of Trials and Tribulations, Winston Payne is the last character to shout "Objection!" This means that Payne's voice is guaranteed to be the last one the player hears in the original trilogy. 5. In Turnabout Memories, we learn that Winston Payne has a wife who is implied to be either really beautiful or really ugly (depending on your reading into what he says during Dahlia's testimony about how she met Phoenix). He also has a daughter.
Every Ace Attorney game? I know he's present in the original trilogy+Apollo Justice, but Gaspen Payne replaces him in Dual Destinies and Spirit of Justice, Phoenix vs. Layton replaces him with Flynch (who admittedly is a Payne knockoff), and The Great Ace Attorney uses Taketsuchi Auchi. Winston is still the most prominent Payne though. Gaspen and Taketsuchi only have 2 appearances so far vs. Winston's 4.
@@Teknanam You're right about Winston Payne not appearing in Dual Destinies, Spirit of Justice, Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright, and the Great Ace Attorney games, but what I meant in my comment was that Winston Payne appears in every game until Investigations 2. However, compared to each game in the original trilogy and Apollo Justice, where Winston acts as the primary prosecutor for their respective first cases, his roles in Turnabout Visitor and Turnabout Target, the first cases of Ace Attorney Investigations 1 and 2, respectively, are far more limited, as he has only cameos in those cases. Granted, while the model used in Turnabout Visitor is undoubtedly of Winston Payne, the nameplate of his textbox simply reads as "Prosecutor" (see czcams.com/video/KSufOGOFYy0/video.html). However, in Turnabout Target, all ambiguity as to his identity is thrown out the window, as he introduces himself as Winston Payne and his nameplate changes to reflect his identity (see czcams.com/video/D42Cexo75a0/video.html).
They really missed a trick not naming his brother “Waylon Payne”. Also, you forget Gaspen’s line in Dual Destines where he refers to Phoenix as “Winston’s greatest rival” and Phoenix is all like “Oh, we were rivals?”.
Payne is even funnier in the great ace attorney, in which he goes by "Auchi" (get it, cause ouch). The first case against him ends with kazuma literally cutting off his hair samurai style and the second time we see him his hair has grown back but at the end of the case after he loses, he cuts his hair himself and everyone prays solemly as he slowly finishes the job with sad music in the background. It is actually hilarious and makes me like him so much even as a joke lmao
Payne is honestly a charming minor character and he only gets better when more prosecutors are introduced, not only does his rather normal presence make these other stand out that much more, but he also ends up one of the few prosecutor that doesn't have any blemishes on him either beyond losing a few times in court, for all purposes, Payne is the MODEL Prosecutor, it's just being a model prosecutor doesn't matter in a setting as wacky as this, he's kinda like Mr Satan from Dragonball Z in a way and I can't hate him at all, the series wouldn't be seen as wild as it is today if we didn't have someone like him here to set a standard.
For me, Trials & Tribulations Payne is the best in the entire series. As you said, in "Turnabout Memories" he is such a jerk for Mia and really feels tougher then his future version. But he is also very nice to Dahlia that adds a gentle side to his character. If you think, Winston is not only fair in his trials, but also he really care about his witnesses and trust them by heart, as you can see in Dahlia and Wellington cases. Well, also you miss some little cameos of Payne in T&T, but I think, they are also really important for this character. Trial of Luke Atmey was meaningful for AA gallery, and Payne almost nailed Ace Detective. Yeah, we know that Atmey wanted to escape his fault this way, but I think that trial rose Payne in others eyes. And don't forget how he defeated Xin Eohp by his own hands!!!
@DerpyHiro To be fair, Winston was first destroyed by Mia Fey. And after that he was never the same. Even up against Rookie Wright and Rookie Apollo. Same with Gaspen and Rookie Athena. And Wright won against him while suffering complete amnesia. Although to be fair, both Apollo and Athena had THE Ace Attorney there to mentor them. So maybe Kazuma's curse just happens should an Auichi ever oppose a Naruhodo or their mentee in court. Now I wonder what might happen should an Auichi actually become a mentor or mentre of a Naruhodo. But considering the long history of Prosecutor and Defense Attornies in each line respectively. Not likely.
I like winston He is actually fair at trials and can be funny at times I also love that he is not one-dimension character Gaspen is the worst Idk but I think there should be one case when he is involved(not as a prosecutor but a person,witness) would be interesting
@@DerpyHiro I disagree only because I love Gaspen's pettiness. Instead of going through introspective change and recognizing the error of his ways, dude left the country to prosecute in one that straight up despise defense attorneys lmao
Given that Gaspen Payne lost a case in Khura'in, being purged from prosecution in Japanifornia thanks to Edgeworth's clean-ups, and attempted to get Phoenix Wright killed via Khura'in's tyrannical laws, I'd like to see Winston Payne return for a future Phoenix Wright game's introductory case. Maybe we can have Athena go up against him?
I really like Payne and his role in the story plus how more comedic they make him as the games progress. I do think he fairly smart because of his experience and his title of rookie killer really shows his knowledge and ability to take on newbies which could also show his smarts in different ways like picking his cases with him wanting to take on some more simpler cases with seem a lot more open shut and while also facing less experienced attorneys. Would love to see more of cameos or more members of the Payne family
Sometimes i think Payne is kind of underrated, to be honest i'd love to see a flashback trial between him and Grossberg since both characters are kind of underused.
If you somehow didn't feel bad enough for him already, in the older Ace Attorney fangame Trials after Justice, he loses to Maya Fey who took over as the replacement attorney after Phenoix slept in.
This is a very cool analysis. I admit, I came here expecting some sort of explanation detailing how smart he was, but this is much much better. I've always loved how funny, fun and hateable Payne was, and I think this analysis makes up for the people who overlook him. Nice video, in other words!
I like Winston Payne he is a great character but he needs more love he is too underrated so i decided to make a fan game called: Ace Attorney Winston Payne Because he needs more love
I don't really care about him, but I respect him for being the most normal prosectutor. He was good in his role in 1-1, kinda dissapeared mid trial in 2-1, but I really enjoeyed him in 3-1!
Gotta admit, any time there is a new PW, AJ, or GAA game, Im always curious as to what the "Payne" character is going to be. Hilarious writing. He's always talking smack and cant back it up, and makes the hugest threats lmao. I always get a good laugh w the Payne characters. I hope they always keep a version of Winston around lol.
Here are some video ideas for you since In really want more Ace Attorney content- 1) Take about the Future of the series. Will we get a new game and what are your hopes for it? 2) Idea for an Ace Attorney full reboot with Phoenix Wright. 3) Ranking the shock moments throughout the series
Definitely want to do the first idea at some point. Probably won't do the second idea just because I personally don't care for a reboot. The third one is a neat idea! I think I'll do a video like that. Maybe some time later this year but we will see
I have some questions if you dont mind Will you rank characters from all the games at some point? Do you recommend Professor Layton games if Im a AA fan? what is the next game you will make review on? Also idk If I heard correctly but you would review turnabout serenade at some point
Will you rank characters from all the games at some point?: Yes I've been thinking about that. I'll probably do one video like that for each game. Do you recommend Professor Layton games if Im a AA fan?: Yes I think a lot of AA fans end up liking Professor Layton. That being said, they are quite different. Professor Layton is about solving puzzles so it's quite different gameplay wise. Some AA fans do not like the stories in the Layton games but I would still give it a shot. Just go into it blind with no expectations what is the next game you will make review on?: Trials and Tribulations Also idk If I heard correctly but you would review turnabout serenade at some point: That was only if a lot of people asked for it. You're the first person who brought it up so far so I probably will not make that in advance since it looks like the demand is not there. Still, I am also trying to cover Apollo Justice late this year so I'll make the Turnabout Serenade video once it's time to review that game.
Honestly, let him actually be a major factor for once. And no, the Furio-case does not count, that guy has less than 3 braincells and also intentionally lost. 3:32 Tbh, I think it would be funnier if Phoenix never saw Winston again after 2-1 and just remembers that many years later. We technically have a deus ex machina for the inconsistency too, the headbonk. Who said Phoenix got all his memories back? He just knows he got most of them.
I really love how in Trump, Payne just kind of loses relevance after the real killer takes the stand. He is kind of just coasting along, not understanding what the hell is even going on. This also kinda fits thematically when you consider the point of Apollo Justice.
yea the entire scenario and Payne's reaction to it is quite funny
The Judge is the one that comes up with counter-points in that one, it's pretty funny
What about Biden?
1:24 Poor Payne. Phoenix's debut was so impressive that Payne made him his rival, but in the opposite direction, Payne made such a zero impression that Nick can't even remember facing him at all. Sums up Payne pretty well.
:(
In Investigations 1, Winston stands outside the crime scene area and doesn't do anything, which can result in some players not being able to notice his presence. I did find it funny was actually being really nice to Edgeworth and Edgeworth not responding to his compliments and instead just inner monologes to himself that he has no clue who he's talking to. However, it does make sence Winston is so nice as both he and Edgeworth are prosecuters.
In Investigations 2 however Winston has a much larger role. Yes, his niceness towards Edgeworth is again met with him being completely ignored, however when John Doe falls under suspision, Winston is appealing to the emotional side of players by demanding that Doe is imidiatly placed under arrest and later on he's used in order to ragg Swift onder the coals, which eventually results in Horace exiting the plane and attempting to hijack the investigation under orders from the president, only for Doe to then blow his own cover by holding Horace hostage.
Oh do some people not notice Winston? I thought he would pretty noticeable just because he's a character we know from the past
@@DerpyHiro I saw some of my family members and friends play Investigations 1 and they completely missed Winston. In fact they were adement that they never saw him ontill I showed them playtrough.
@@spouwnerring I mean I have barely watched ace attorney games and... I immediately spotted him.
The fact that the Payne legacy is recurring is just so amazing
It really is. The Payne lore just builds with every new game
Fun Winston Payne facts:
1. He is the only character (along with Gumshoe) to have a speaking appearance in every Ace Attorney game (including spinoffs) up to and including the release of Investigations 2 (since Phoenix and Maya do not speak in either Investigations game, and Edgeworth is absent from Apollo Justice). Payne appears in each of these games' first cases as well (including Investigations 1 and 2).
2. He appears in more cases in the original trilogy (5 cases: 1-1, 2-1, 3-1, 3-2, and 3-3) than Franziska von Karma (4 cases: 2-2, 2-3, 2-4, 3-5) and Godot (4 cases: 3-2, 3-3, 3-4 [as Diego Armando], 3-5).
2.5. Every case in Trials and Tribulations features Winston Payne OR Miles Edgeworth (but never both); Payne also appears in one more case than Edgeworth in the game (3 cases vs. 2).
3. In The First Turnabout, if you signal Larry to tell the truth about going to Cindy's apartment, he will say that he went but didn't see her. Winston Payne objects and says that he has a witness who can prove Larry is lying. Phoenix never objects before this point, which means that Payne's voice is the first one the player hears in the series. However, if you tell Larry to lie and say he never went, Payne never objects; he just calls Sahwit to the stand, where Phoenix's voice when he shouts either "Hold It!" or "Objection!" is the first one the player hears in the series.
4. In the credits of Trials and Tribulations, Winston Payne is the last character to shout "Objection!" This means that Payne's voice is guaranteed to be the last one the player hears in the original trilogy.
5. In Turnabout Memories, we learn that Winston Payne has a wife who is implied to be either really beautiful or really ugly (depending on your reading into what he says during Dahlia's testimony about how she met Phoenix). He also has a daughter.
Every Ace Attorney game? I know he's present in the original trilogy+Apollo Justice, but Gaspen Payne replaces him in Dual Destinies and Spirit of Justice, Phoenix vs. Layton replaces him with Flynch (who admittedly is a Payne knockoff), and The Great Ace Attorney uses Taketsuchi Auchi. Winston is still the most prominent Payne though. Gaspen and Taketsuchi only have 2 appearances so far vs. Winston's 4.
@@Teknanam You're right about Winston Payne not appearing in Dual Destinies, Spirit of Justice, Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright, and the Great Ace Attorney games, but what I meant in my comment was that Winston Payne appears in every game until Investigations 2. However, compared to each game in the original trilogy and Apollo Justice, where Winston acts as the primary prosecutor for their respective first cases, his roles in Turnabout Visitor and Turnabout Target, the first cases of Ace Attorney Investigations 1 and 2, respectively, are far more limited, as he has only cameos in those cases.
Granted, while the model used in Turnabout Visitor is undoubtedly of Winston Payne, the nameplate of his textbox simply reads as "Prosecutor" (see czcams.com/video/KSufOGOFYy0/video.html). However, in Turnabout Target, all ambiguity as to his identity is thrown out the window, as he introduces himself as Winston Payne and his nameplate changes to reflect his identity (see czcams.com/video/D42Cexo75a0/video.html).
he also has a longer win record than both miles AND franziska
They really missed a trick not naming his brother “Waylon Payne”.
Also, you forget Gaspen’s line in Dual Destines where he refers to Phoenix as “Winston’s greatest rival” and Phoenix is all like “Oh, we were rivals?”.
haha that's a pretty funny name. And yea I don't remember that line from Dual Destinies, but that's really funny
Payne is even funnier in the great ace attorney, in which he goes by "Auchi" (get it, cause ouch). The first case against him ends with kazuma literally cutting off his hair samurai style and the second time we see him his hair has grown back but at the end of the case after he loses, he cuts his hair himself and everyone prays solemly as he slowly finishes the job with sad music in the background. It is actually hilarious and makes me like him so much even as a joke lmao
Yea that scene with Auchi in the second game is hands down one of the funniest moments in the series. Comedy gold
Auchi Is actually Payne's name in the Japanese script
Payne is honestly a charming minor character and he only gets better when more prosecutors are introduced, not only does his rather normal presence make these other stand out that much more, but he also ends up one of the few prosecutor that doesn't have any blemishes on him either beyond losing a few times in court, for all purposes, Payne is the MODEL Prosecutor, it's just being a model prosecutor doesn't matter in a setting as wacky as this, he's kinda like Mr Satan from Dragonball Z in a way and I can't hate him at all, the series wouldn't be seen as wild as it is today if we didn't have someone like him here to set a standard.
For me, Trials & Tribulations Payne is the best in the entire series.
As you said, in "Turnabout Memories" he is such a jerk for Mia and really feels tougher then his future version. But he is also very nice to Dahlia that adds a gentle side to his character.
If you think, Winston is not only fair in his trials, but also he really care about his witnesses and trust them by heart, as you can see in Dahlia and Wellington cases.
Well, also you miss some little cameos of Payne in T&T, but I think, they are also really important for this character.
Trial of Luke Atmey was meaningful for AA gallery, and Payne almost nailed Ace Detective. Yeah, we know that Atmey wanted to escape his fault this way, but I think that trial rose Payne in others eyes.
And don't forget how he defeated Xin Eohp by his own hands!!!
His cameos are pretty funny!
I hope the Paynes make a comeback honestly. Neil N. Payne for the next series maybe?
Payne's are always there. The only time they aren't is like the crossover. Neil N. Payne is an awesome name
@@DerpyHiroand while there was no Payne in the crossover, they still had Flynch, who was pretty much a Payne in everything but name
"A thousand generations may pass, and still the Auchi Clan shall never measure up to the Naruhodo clan!"
Kazuma cursed an entire bloodline
@DerpyHiro To be fair, Winston was first destroyed by Mia Fey. And after that he was never the same. Even up against Rookie Wright and Rookie Apollo. Same with Gaspen and Rookie Athena.
And Wright won against him while suffering complete amnesia.
Although to be fair, both Apollo and Athena had THE Ace Attorney there to mentor them. So maybe Kazuma's curse just happens should an Auichi ever oppose a Naruhodo or their mentee in court.
Now I wonder what might happen should an Auichi actually become a mentor or mentre of a Naruhodo. But considering the long history of Prosecutor and Defense Attornies in each line respectively. Not likely.
I like winston
He is actually fair at trials and can be funny at times
I also love that he is not one-dimension character
Gaspen is the worst
Idk but I think there should be one case when he is involved(not as a prosecutor but a person,witness) would be interesting
I would love to see Winston in a non prosecutor role! And I agree Winston >>>>> Gaspen
@@DerpyHiro I disagree only because I love Gaspen's pettiness. Instead of going through introspective change and recognizing the error of his ways, dude left the country to prosecute in one that straight up despise defense attorneys lmao
@@ivan_ivankovich I mean
I did not say that I HATE gaspen
He is a good prosecutor
I just prefer Winston, he is more interesting than typical scumbag
Given that Gaspen Payne lost a case in Khura'in, being purged from prosecution in Japanifornia thanks to Edgeworth's clean-ups, and attempted to get Phoenix Wright killed via Khura'in's tyrannical laws, I'd like to see Winston Payne return for a future Phoenix Wright game's introductory case. Maybe we can have Athena go up against him?
I really like Payne and his role in the story plus how more comedic they make him as the games progress. I do think he fairly smart because of his experience and his title of rookie killer really shows his knowledge and ability to take on newbies which could also show his smarts in different ways like picking his cases with him wanting to take on some more simpler cases with seem a lot more open shut and while also facing less experienced attorneys. Would love to see more of cameos or more members of the Payne family
Sometimes i think Payne is kind of underrated, to be honest i'd love to see a flashback trial between him and Grossberg since both characters are kind of underused.
A flashback trial between those two would honestly be quite fun to see!
If you somehow didn't feel bad enough for him already, in the older Ace Attorney fangame Trials after Justice, he loses to Maya Fey who took over as the replacement attorney after Phenoix slept in.
Oh yea
The chess case
I remember this case
It was a good case
Where's this fan case and what's it called??
@@D14MBK phoenix wright trial after justice
Even more in T&T, the Atmey trial’s prosecutor was Payne, as well as the first trial for the murder of Glen Elg
Yea he appeared a lot in T&T surprisingly
This is a very cool analysis. I admit, I came here expecting some sort of explanation detailing how smart he was, but this is much much better. I've always loved how funny, fun and hateable Payne was, and I think this analysis makes up for the people who overlook him. Nice video, in other words!
Thanks! Glad you got some enjoyment out of it
You are awesome bro. So happy to find ace Attorney CZcamsrs who are still active.
Thanks!
any ace attorney without Winston would not be ace attorney he just gotta be there
I like Winston Payne he is a great character but he needs more love he is too underrated so i decided to make a fan game called:
Ace Attorney Winston Payne
Because he needs more love
I don't really care about him, but I respect him for being the most normal prosectutor. He was good in his role in 1-1, kinda dissapeared mid trial in 2-1, but I really enjoeyed him in 3-1!
XD I like how Payne is the only who takes really unwinnable cases, really shows how Reckless he is.
“Ah, Winston Payne. He’s a pain in the *butt* but he’s no Larry *Butz.*
No way dude just roasted 2 characters in just 13 words.
Payne🥰🥰🥰
On of the favorite characters❤
HA!
anyway correct this man is one of my favorite tutorial elements in a game
Gotta admit, any time there is a new PW, AJ, or GAA game, Im always curious as to what the "Payne" character is going to be. Hilarious writing. He's always talking smack and cant back it up, and makes the hugest threats lmao. I always get a good laugh w the Payne characters. I hope they always keep a version of Winston around lol.
Here are some video ideas for you since In really want more Ace Attorney content-
1) Take about the Future of the series. Will we get a new game and what are your hopes for it?
2) Idea for an Ace Attorney full reboot with Phoenix Wright.
3) Ranking the shock moments throughout the series
Definitely want to do the first idea at some point. Probably won't do the second idea just because I personally don't care for a reboot. The third one is a neat idea! I think I'll do a video like that. Maybe some time later this year but we will see
"Let's see what you've learned since last time." So, did he just break the fourth wall?
I have some questions if you dont mind
Will you rank characters from all the games at some point?
Do you recommend Professor Layton games if Im a AA fan?
what is the next game you will make review on?
Also idk If I heard correctly but you would review turnabout serenade at some point
Will you rank characters from all the games at some point?:
Yes I've been thinking about that. I'll probably do one video like that for each game.
Do you recommend Professor Layton games if Im a AA fan?:
Yes I think a lot of AA fans end up liking Professor Layton. That being said, they are quite different. Professor Layton is about solving puzzles so it's quite different gameplay wise. Some AA fans do not like the stories in the Layton games but I would still give it a shot. Just go into it blind with no expectations
what is the next game you will make review on?:
Trials and Tribulations
Also idk If I heard correctly but you would review turnabout serenade at some point:
That was only if a lot of people asked for it. You're the first person who brought it up so far so I probably will not make that in advance since it looks like the demand is not there. Still, I am also trying to cover Apollo Justice late this year so I'll make the Turnabout Serenade video once it's time to review that game.
Ok
Thanks for reply
I will at some point play Professor Layton
Honestly, let him actually be a major factor for once. And no, the Furio-case does not count, that guy has less than 3 braincells and also intentionally lost.
3:32 Tbh, I think it would be funnier if Phoenix never saw Winston again after 2-1 and just remembers that many years later. We technically have a deus ex machina for the inconsistency too, the headbonk. Who said Phoenix got all his memories back? He just knows he got most of them.
Payne is actually a really good character (minus his objection voice cough cough)
his objection voice makes him even better
@@DerpyHiro fair point, i have to give you that.
he's cute
Doesnt he also appear in soj?
Does he? Which case was he in?