"Jinnah never did anything to help my father's practice."

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 5. 10. 2010
  • Reflecting on his father's association with Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Iqbal Chagla said that his father's opinion was that Jinnah was known to be a fine advocate but not good at law. "He was a cold hearted man." When M.C. Chagla joined Jinnah's chambers, he had no income or money to speak of. Despite knowing this, Jinnah never did anything to help. When a solicitor would come and ask him which junior he would like, Jinnah would reply saying there were so many juniors at the Bar and any one of them would do. The solicitor then approached Mr. Velinker in the next chamber, who promptly suggested that his junior be briefed.
    Iqbal Chagla also recounted the story of Sir F.E. Smith, the noted early 20th century British lawyer and his senior. When his senior, who was on a holiday in Europe, was contacted for a matter, he said that he would be unable to come back. When asked for suggestions about whom the brief should be given to, he suggested that they engage "FE". That was the start of Sir F.E. Smith's career. When this appeared in a newspaper, M.C. Chagla dutifully cut it out and left it on Jinnah's desk for him to read. Jinnah read it, scoffed, and threw it into the waste paper basket. "He never helped him at all", Iqbal Chagla said.

Komentáře • 40

  • @sidsinha123
    @sidsinha123 Před 10 lety +28

    The book 'Roses in December' (Justice MC Chagla's Autobiography) should be a compulsory read in Indian schools. Only Indian Autobiography worth reading

    • @CAP753
      @CAP753 Před 4 lety +1

      I agree.It is an honest biography of a no-nonsense man.Enjoyed it many decades ago.

    • @garima5430
      @garima5430 Před 3 lety

      i have read the novel. the book absolutely amazing 👍

  • @MrTMrT007
    @MrTMrT007 Před 5 měsíci +3

    Jinnah was a TOP man. Hands Down.

  • @sunilkrishnani7001
    @sunilkrishnani7001 Před 9 lety +7

    I totally agree with Siddhartha Sinha, I am currently reading the book. I am enjoying ever written word. the simplicity and clarity of mind and body. I believe that it is one of my finest book

  • @banksy2870
    @banksy2870 Před 3 lety +2

    Jinnah was a rather arrogant man. And yes he did not really have any part to play in developing the career of FE Smith.

  • @arshadhussainabdulsattar2844

    Jinnah just shared Hamburgers, Ham-Sandwiches and gave company to MC Chagla for drinks. 😉😊😄😆🤣

  • @attorneyumarghazalli
    @attorneyumarghazalli Před 4 lety +10

    Jinnah is the greatest leader of last 300 years' political history. But today's Pakistani leadership is a shame on his name.

    • @mullahdopiazza817
      @mullahdopiazza817 Před 4 lety +6

      It was Nehru and Patel who decided to get rid of Gandoo Jinnah. Gandhi was against division of India and was willing to accept Jinnah as a first governor General. so don't come here and lecture us. What fuck is 'ghazalli'? what's your heritage, you fake bastard.

    • @attorneyumarghazalli
      @attorneyumarghazalli Před 2 lety +1

      @Vaishnav M N LOL. A peaceful struggle and amongst Hitler etc? How come?

    • @randomdosing7535
      @randomdosing7535 Před 2 lety

      @@attorneyumarghazalli kudos to you for your peaceful rebuttals to their ramblings

    • @attorneyumarghazalli
      @attorneyumarghazalli Před 2 lety

      @@mullahdopiazza817 Well I know who I am. And you from "Mulla "2" piaza". I didn't say anything. You said that.

    • @attorneyumarghazalli
      @attorneyumarghazalli Před 2 lety

      @@randomdosing7535 Thanks.

  • @ViewsNewsChannel
    @ViewsNewsChannel Před 4 měsíci +1

    To become Pakistan's Founder, Jinnah assisted the British in dividing India, disregarding the division of Muslims into 3 parts.
    Watch documentary czcams.com/video/iPO99tofR5s/video.html
    "The British Chessboard: Jinnah, Gandhi, and the Strategic Divide of India"
    czcams.com/video/L59B0amqJS0/video.html

    • @thinkagain2229
      @thinkagain2229 Před 4 měsíci

      Jis channel ka link diya hai , us bhenchod k total 60 subscribers hain

  • @611amir
    @611amir Před 4 lety +11

    Muhammad Ali jinah was great leader who pridicted today's India back in 1940s

    • @phantom11746
      @phantom11746 Před 4 lety +9

      Did he predict India would be this far ahead of Pakistan? Did he also predict that Pakistan would become an illiterate terrorist country. Jinnah was an arrogant idiot who lived in fool’s paradise.

    • @usmanali81
      @usmanali81 Před 4 lety +4

      @Bhakt Slayer Due to Jinnah, hatred flourished among muslims, hindus and sikhs. What Modi is doing as a blood thirsty arrogant, Jinnah and Nehru already did it specially since 1945 till 1948 approx.

    • @RajnishKumar-tr8xz
      @RajnishKumar-tr8xz Před 3 lety

      @prananshu bhuyan great brother

    • @saivalisetty
      @saivalisetty Před rokem

      @@usmanali81 well said

    • @pranavdubey7883
      @pranavdubey7883 Před rokem

      @@usmanali81 Amen