Is INDIAN RESERVATION System JUSTIFIED? | Ajeet Bharti's Take
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 08. 2024
- This is a clip from episode 147 of PG Radio with Ajeet Bharti @AjeetBharti
Watch the full episode here: • Ajeet Bharti addresses...
---------------------------------------------
To Become a Social Genius, Click Here: amzn.eu/d/6tvr8jQ
----------------------------------------------
The Art of Conversation-
Get better at talking to people here: thepravachan.c...
--------------------------------------------------
👉🏻SOCIALS
--------------------------------------------------
Find us on Instagram: / prakharkepravachan
Join Darbaar Discord-
/ discord
Connect with Prakhar Gupta
Twitter: / prvkhvr
Facebook: / prakharkepravachan
Mail: contact@thepravachan.com
--------------------------------------
What is PG Radio Clips
--------------------------------------
PG Radio is your one-stop intellectual cafe. Prakhar, the host, sincerely believes that there is much to be learned always and everywhere.
Follow Prakhar as he weaves sense into dialogue and monologue, conversations and research, science and art, comedy and tragedy, poetry and prose.
Prakhar Gupta, the host of this podcast, is a student of Economics and Psychology at Columbia University in the City of New York.
He has been a student of accountancy, finance, and corporate law. He shares an insatiable passion for politics, philosophy, psychology, and personal growth.
------------------------------------------------
Find our audio-only podcast
------------------------------------------------
Spotify: bit.ly/pgradio...
Apple Podcast: bit.ly/pgradio...
Google Podcast: bit.ly/pgradio...
===
Credits:
Produced by- Ansh Bhatnagar
Host- Prakhar Gupta
Reservation assumes all general ones have a luxurious life. 😂
Ya bhai you don't hesitate to tell your caste . and we hesitate a lot when somebody asks about our caste. And then people judge us according to our caste. This is an evil truth of our society ...
@@user-wd5ik2xg9f even with 100% reservations before 1950, doing centuries oppression on 95% population including your own women, having higher social status if u are still poor and uneducated guess who is the loser here.
@@adityanarayanazad6329kitna punish karoge humko ab😊
I'm from dalit community and i exactly agree with these points.
In schools n colleges none of my friend bothered about my caste. Happiest of Relationships.
Later when we all jumped in job prep. Me clearing all exams thru reservations and them being of same potential. There occurred a gap automatically.eg I'm 3 times net jrf holder and now in a govt job. They dont hv net yet and working in pvt.
There is clear disenchantment.
First time in my life due to reservation I'm losing respect among them. Im quite sound and able but that tag reserved has put more harm to me.
I really want reservation be limited to education and not jobs.
are to bhia mt le, apni jaat pe sharam h to terko, reservation is for representation. tere jese bina haddi ke logo k karan hi samaj pichhd jata h tumhra
To bhai vote ke time jai bheem walo ko kyun dete ho vote? Congress jo kehti hai ke aur badha denge quota, uska boycott karo. Tunhari community ko political pawn bna rakha hai. Aur general walo ke bache $uicide kar rhe hain
@@greatbathindian hum toh bjp ko hi dete hai. Baaki everyone has right to vote as they like. We can influence others that's the least we can do. Youngsters in my family give to bjp. Oldies stick to congress.
If you dont like this reservation then why did you filled your quota as reserved caste in competetive exams? Some of my close friends who are from backward classes themselves filled their quota as neutral category
thnx bhai
i don't have problem with reservation but it should be based on economic conditions not on mental and intellectual basis.
I have problem
60% seats reserved is no fair in any condition
You know how income certificate can be manipulate
Just go to tehsil and give some money to broker he will make your income certificate below 40k per annum that's a fact and you think economically weak person are getting the benefits of ews kota😊
Reservation koi garibi hatao yojana nahi hai, social discrimination se deal karne ke liya bana hai specially for Dalits.
I also have a problem with reservation. Bcoz of 70 years of this injustice, the sawarns have been discriminated against. So they need reservation now and sc,st reservation should end.
Economic se mullon ko mil jaye ga
Mea frnd obc uska dada gov job 2 bete gov job , sare pota poti gov job mei hai school fee bhi kam lagta tha , 1999 mein ford ikon car se school ata tha .
Being vegetarian doesn't means one have to eat poisoned fruits or vegetables too likewise being secularism doesn't mean we have to recognize islam /Cristianity ... we should reform our constitution which is written by invaders and mullah only... 🕉 🕉
Baat to sahi hai
Main bhi reserved hoon but due to some circumstances jis exam ko dene jarha hu usme reserved ni hoon!
But one's who doesn't know this will judge on their assumptions ki reservation mila hi hoga unless I clarify that myself.
bat shi h? mtlb kch bhi. muj aj tk koi reservation nhi mila lekar fr bhi bol skta in in logo ko bilkul andaja nhi h reality ka. reservation to sbko mil rha h ab brahmano ko bhi banio ko bhi lekin unka naam kyu nhi lia? pichhle 30 salo se obc jaat yadav gurjar sbko mil rha h reservation lekin unka naam lia nhi kyu? kyuki inki soch me h inke dharam me h. bachpan se hi yhi sikha h
CA exam mein reservation nhi h sab practical h isliye sab ki respect hoti h, sab caste cause sare mehnat se bante h
Reservation hona aur cutoff me big difference hona fark hota hai
Humare yaha teacher ki bharti me ScSt ka cutoff 12 out of 100 gaya tha
Jab ki General 81 gaya tha
Ab 12 lane wale bachho ko kya padhayenge? Fir bolte hain govt school me bachhe sirf mid-day meal khane jate hain
Let them be that way brother . Wo isliye bothered nahi ki tmhe reservation mil raha h wo isliye bothered ki unke liye kuch v nahi bs papa ka daulat h joh saalo se discriminate kr ke paaya h . Avi bhale discrimination ho raha tmhare saath but atleast tmhara economic conditions toh thik ho raha h na nahi toh wo v possible nahi ho pata . So agli baar koi kre discrimination toh try to feel good because wo discrimination krte h that's why reservation h not the other way around
@@skmishra8839 ni ni cut-off ka alag matter hai
Uska reservation se lena dena ni hota hai
Jis category mein jitne seats hote h unki akhri seat wala jitna marks layega wo cut-off declare hoga.
Cut-off upr niche hota rhta h Dsssb mein ST ka cut-off sbse high gaya tha kisi kisi round mein! general se v upr
Reservation based on caste in India has majorly 3 disastrous disadvantages: 1. Non-deserving people getting seat in college or any job. 2. Brain drain- some bright students if don't get into top colleges then they go to foreign for education and jobs. 3. Money drain- parents spent around 1 to 1.5 crores to send their child for foreign education. All of above leads to loss to indian economy.
That's what you think the reason behind brain drain? Then Why do you think IITians and Doctors are going abroad after educating themselves from government institutions on tax payers money? 😂 Stop giving this bull$h *t reasons. Also, people from general category can atleast afford to study abroad. Do you think that any tribal student or dalit student would even afford to study abroad?
Do kodi da tera brain drain😂
First and foremost what is non deserving ...
Most of the the exams are merit based or cutoff due to limited seats...
Ex - if there are 100 seats and 200 bright students and 1000 dull students , then only top 100 will get admitted..
But that doesn't mean that left 100 bright students were non deserving.. they were deserving ... It was government who couldn't full fill thier population needs...
Similarly brain drain is due to government lack of seats .. not due to reservation..
And thirdly people spend money outside india because they can't get good education facilities in india expect some iits or AIIMS.
Well Said... Ajeet Ji. Thank you for sharing this information with us
Castism ka main karan, manusmriti & sanatan dharm hai... Ajeet is always spread mis information.😂😂😂😂
Self respect emotions kaha se aagye beech mein?
Historically religion and wealth controlled by upper caste peoples!
Now what's problem if we bring equality in society with the help of reservation system?
Without equality ke compition kese possible hai?
What equality you want everyone has same rights to education . Are you trying to say that all lower caste people are helpless and all upper caste ones are super rich . Reservation is worst and lazy strategy to attain equality in society. You can help poor with education loan , study material, classes but giving them seat for just very few marks is very wrong
@@Peter-zj3gl then you have to redistribute wealth ! Upper caste people have farms and they hold religion institution!
In reservation sc / st people have only 2 seats!
If sc /st people will able to compete with other you can remove reservation no problem!
@@user-kr3pg7et5g Your problem is wealth then why didn't you ask for financial help or aid from the government instead of asking for a reservation.
All so called journalist are thinking from there point of view .
Dalito ki samasya shayad hi koi samaje jo dalit nahi hai.
Reservation is due to caste.
To vanish caste system only one solution is inter caste system.
And bharati should promote inter caste marriage instead of commenting other things.
@@ashishraj6757 i don't support reservation in government job either!
But in education reservations must needed ! Only for sc and st for those who really deserve it
Reservation is fine as long as all have to compete on the same quota. Like he said, You are indirectly saying that backward class people cant have the intellect to score higher marks hence the lower cutoff.
We have Johnny Depp discussing reservation before gta 6🗣️
Reservation ?
NEET, JEE -❎
other services -✅
Jati, Dharm -❎
economic conditions ✅
Very good administration ke andar to diversity of use hone bhi chahie Taki Koi society ka Banda bhi represent Karen Kyunki Jo Elite log Dete Hain
@@Shubham-pr9cq sabko upar uthane ka mouka milna chahiye
par docter aur scientist ya engineers best hone chahiye👍
@@SarveshKumar-zc7fw Administration Mein diversity honi chahie scientist mein kaun si diversity dhundhenge ham
and in another segment of nothing ever happens lol
nothing will change 70% of INDIA POPULATION IN OBC SC AND ST how do u think general can even compete for their rights now it is beyond over take the black pill
mai apne ek friend(SC) se baat kar raha tha reservation pe, vaise to wo bahut samajhdaar hai achhe school mei padha hai achhi upbringing huyi hai lekin reservation ki baat jab bhi aati hai toh bilkul anpado ki tarah defend karta hai, wo logically sunna hi nhi chahta kuch reservation ke baare mei usko bas itna pata hai ki reservation chahiye. kyu chahiye aur actual mei kise chahiye iss se usko koi farak nhi, uske sath kabhi castism nhi hua phir bhi kehta hai ki castism band karo
Reservation as a system is a total heck , alternate thing could be done is by providing them materials to study , provide them with a house space , and necessary conditions and let them compete but no baba baba baba baba .
And irony is then they cry ohh my friends in my final year mbbs didn't talk to me much and said iska toh ho he jayega I mean( example ) 1k seats ,550 reserved and rest 45k students will co Pete for 450 seats !!!! And we should provide you more beneficiaries by providing study materials like you're going to come and feed my family after getting selected in pg , idiotic havoc .
Bhai log face, skin colour, surname dekhke hi samjhjate hai ab lower caste se ho... reservation ho na ho discrimination rah ta hi hai...
Ye he bhraman log bhar west mai jake reservation lete hai ki hmay toh angrezo ne sataya hai 😂😂
A sc category teacher is selected for seat of teacher and he scored 40% marks in exam but being a general category student i need atleast 80% to clear the exam then how could such teacher teach me😢
Reservation was introduced to increase representation in services and society in general as there was a discrimination based on caste.
The question which we need to ask ourselves is,
Is there enough representation or not and if not why ?
Unless and until we will not address this problem reservation will be there
I have given jee this year. I scored very bad and secured around 193000 rank and so was not Qualified enough to sit for Jee Advanced Exam, i accept that. But one of my friend who is financial good background is an SC and has scored 6.5 lack rank, but he is Qualified to Sit for Jee Advanced.
Now, what does the Govt. trying to prove here.
And A Bigger Moron like Rahul Gandhi comes up and Says He is Day-Dreaming to Increase Reservation from already 50% to even more.
Now, You judge how they are planning out the Future of your Country.
Even Modiji is not Talking about Removing Reservation.
Not only this, but even An AIR 100 Student isn't able to Get CSE in IIT Bombay but an SC is getting that same Branch and College at 500 or a 1000 Rank.
Now, what is the Govt. And IITs upto is beyond any sane person's understanding.
I'm not discriminating Bheem Wale, but they are snatching what they don't deserve.
The System is designed so as the rich and affluent has to go through the struggle of Running the Economy and pay taxes and then their children are rejected just because a Bheem wala has a Reservation done Already.
Economically Weaker Sectionsed People should have Reservation, and Fees waived off. But Caste based Reservation is just detailing a Great Country with Talented People
Nn
In the end we see most of the gen who eat obc sc st seats most of the govt sectors are filled with upper cast people.
Accha bhai .
Reservation was introduced by Ambedkar as a temporary thing which had a ceiling limit for a limited time, the politicians made it unlimited. But the real reason why reservation was introduced is to empower the Dalits (victims of Criminal Tribes Act by the British) so that they don't fall for evangelical poaching by Abrahamic missionaries. And for that I salute Ambedkar, he was truly a far-sighted man.
it would have been better if they became christian a solid to the upper caste brahmins and their limpwristed inability to preserve hinduism
limit ka jikar kidr hai bhai
Limit kidhar likha hai konsi speech me jara bata
@@rubinsingh9383limit hai .. 10 saal ke lie hi laya tha ambedkar ne reservation taaki us time uske jaat ke log aage badh paye.
Fir nehru ne time to time 10-10 saal ka time limit badhaya fir aage ke v sabhi PM badhate gaye fir ye vote bank politics ban gaya even abhi haal hi modi ne v renew kiya tha kuch saal pahle kyuki sab ko pata hai agar nahi kroge to log tumhe anti dalit bol ke narrative banayege or iska best example humne v dekha hai SC ne sirf ek IPC act ko remove kiya tha jo SC/ST se related tha uska galat tarike se pesh kar kitna bada danga karaya gaya pure desh me fir majburan sarkar ko Sansad me wo act ko wapas laana pada as a law.
@@apnahindpolitical reservation 10 years k lie tha , education and public employment ka limit nahi h 💀💀💀💀 ghonchu
One more thing if a "reserved" category student gets good marks then why his seat is converted to "general category" ,
Jis category ke seat pe admission n hota hai usko hi mopup round ya last round me open for all kiya jaata hy
Ye isliye kiye jaate hai kyonki seat vacant na reh jaaye
Reservation ka hona casteism ko kaise badhava de sakta hai? If someone is from sc,st community who are socially backward, educationally backward, economically weaker unhe self respect ka chapter padha ke ye kehna ki woh apne halaton se ladh kar unse compete kare Jo paise Wale hai(mostly), educationally privileged hai.
Aur jaha Tak baat Rahi ki reservation casteism ko badhava deta hai. to yeh statement casteist mentality ko promote karta hai. Casteism ko justify karta hai.
Both of these people in this video don't understand or maybe don't want to understand the reality of sc,st community in our country.there is reason why bjp,rss people don't want caste census in India.
lmao dude just look at any university, ppl from quotas are used as a laughing stock
politician will always use reservation as a lollipop to gather votes from your community
bhai harr samaaj/country mein gareeb hote hai, rather than sponsering their education
you are restricting more deserved people based on caste, it's just reserve casteism
and always remember, agar reservation uplift kar sakta toh 70 saalo mein hojata
Brother
If I'm in college at some good marks after doing a lot of hardwork
And I have someone having same privilage even at half of my marks
Ofcourse I will be discontented
Bhai tum log bolte ho castism khatam hona chahiye but in reality koi nahi chahta ki caste system khtam ho kyoki caste system ke khatam hone ke sath reservation bhi khatm ho jayega.... Problem reservation se nahi h problem h iske utilisation se agar ek IAS ya doctor ke bete ko bhi reservation se exam nikalna pad rha h to ye empowerment nahi mental incapability ko batata h...Rahi baat cast census ki to iski shuruwat Britishers ne ki thi 1881 me kyoki unka core principle hi Devide and Rule tha aur tum phir se wahi chahte ho ki sabko jatiyo ke adhar par devide kar Diya Jaye aur phir kuch salo baad brahmano ko dosh dena ki humare sath jativaad Kiya gya h..... aur tumhari information ke liye bta dun BIHAR me already kafi time pahle cast census ho chuka h lekin iske baad waha kitna improvement ho gya sabko pta h...
Jab jaati khatm ho jayengi aur sab community equally develop ho jayengi tab reservation bhi khatm ho jayega. @@kjn1992rko
Muft ki khaane waale Ambedkar ka har waqt chuste rahenge...
At last kisi ne to ye critical topic uthaya.... thankyou prakhar Bhai...u have balls😅
Nehru on ‘reservations’: “I dislike any kind of reservation, more particularly in services. I react strongly against anything which leads to inefficiency and second rate standards. I want my country to be a first-class country in everything. The moment we encourage the second-rate, we are lost.
The only real way to help the backward group is to give opportunities of good education, specially technical education. But if we go in for reservations on communal and caste basis, we swamp the bright and able people and remain second-rate or third-rate.
I am grieved to learn of how far this business of reservation has gone based on communal considerations. It has amazed me to learn that even promotions are based sometimes on communal and caste considerations. This way lays not only folly, but disaster. Let us help the backward groups by all means but never at the cost of efficiency."
- Oxford press, ‘Letters to chief ministers’
Jinke ancestors 2000 years tak reservations ka benefits utha chuke hai unse gyaan bilkul nhi lene ka😂
nothing will happen a collapse is necessary lol until then everything will go on as it is or more reservation take the black pill it is beyond over
@@sagarkumar-kq7dc Vishwamitra Muni - was ‘a kshtriya king’ before he became a great sage.
Vatsa - became a Rishi though born to ‘a Shudr’
Matanga was son of ‘Chandal’ but became ‘a Brahmin’
Nabhag, son of King Nedishtha became ‘Vaishy’.
Also who gave ‘Ambedkar’ (originally last name ‘sakpal’) his last name & who gave him a scholarship to study abroad?
@@sagarkumar-kq7dc abe vo reservation nahi tha power rule tha tum logo me itne power nahi the ke yudh lad sako apna empire bana sako reservation ka matlab kamjoor mandbhudi ko aage badana hota hai par use time hum kamjoor mabdhudi nahi tum the
M I the only one thinking why Jonny Depp is speaking such good hindi?
😂❤
Joh mai smjha aapke video se ki sarkri school ke levels bahot acche hone chaiye . Aur aapko pata h h . Ki kitna accha h sarkari school. Aur jb Delhi ke school develope hota h . Aur fir aapki Gand jlti h . Aap clear stand pe ho he nahi . Aur aapke pass solution hai he nahi . Bs name ke liye bol de rahe h equal ground diya jana chaiye education me .
@Avsingh7875 ghotale pe bolna sahi h . But tm yeh v toh dekho ki phle debate me kavi v yeh topic nahi aata th school ke bare me but avi yeh mudda h . And it's because of AAP . Ab wo party ghotala kr rahi h yeh Mai Maan skta hun but tmhe yeh manna padega ki isse phle kavi v sarkari school hospital yeh sb kavi mudda nahi rhta th . So as a whole yeh better he h
Dehli mai bas 9-10 school acche hai, don't be fool
@@sameer-fk8oy 9-10 best h . Baki sb v theek thak h . Baki savi State se bahot jata better . Lol
My thoughts on this was exactly the same, education should be made even free for everyone till 12th, post that reservation should be given primarily based on marks and then economic conditions.
It's so unfair that 3-4 years back some guy who was all India first in one of the exams (post MBBS) was unable to get a seat in the college he wishes only because of reservations. This is just nonsense.
His idea of adding "reservation" tag to one's post was just great and should be implemented.
Equal opportunity does not mean we should always expect equal outcome. But still opportunity should be equal. Rich SC people taking reservation neither have self respect nor mercy on other poor SC people
Zara socho uss B.E.O ka jo uss "0" marks waale ko kaha appoint karwaayega ? Kaise appointment karega jab apni hi block ke bacche jinse kal milke, unki education ka haq dene ka wada karke aaya ho, unka future uss bande ko dega jisko "0" aaya hain
Me SC se hu lekin mene aaj tak schedule caste ka koi bhi scholarship nahi liya
Odisha me 0.75 mark me Biology High school teacher recruitment mila hai 2023 me... Disgusting
Rajasthan mai toh zero marking wala bhi teacher Bana hai😢
Jaab tak reservation system rehega tab tak revolution ka ummid chod dena chahiye ❤️
Two of my friends applied for CEE one of them was St and another was general.. St friend scored 83 and general frnd scored 109 but could not reached cut off marks. Now ST friend is studying in best engineering college of our state and my general frnd and i completed bsc. From gov. College.. That ST friend don't even know the full form of CEE at that time.
I feel this is Jonny Deep 😂😂
I was about to comment about zero mark securing aspirants are getting govt teacher job. In odisha. So its not Rajasthan alone.
I am from West Bengal. I never knew I am dalit untill North Indian news papers started writing about some incidents happening in our states. They make me realise that SC=Dalit. In West Bengal, even Khsatriyas can be listed as SC.
I being a kshatriya don't even hesitate if being called a dalit what's the big deal in that problem is they pacify a unreal argument to end reservation is to forget the cast I mean think for a while I belong to the family my ancestors had a bloodline of shivaji Maharaj how could I not be proud of it , if you search of a war Dalits held called bheema koregaon and almost every dalit is proud of it yaar can you say don't cherish that war and be proud of it , just think which man doesn't have a sympathy for the poor , sympathy is the easiest thing to sell off this reservation is firmly not available for the real deprived and rich Dalits are using it at par which is a nuisance instead govt would have provided facilities for those like study materials, house , basic necessities for preparation of the exam for those who are deprived or don't have any ancestral property and allowed to compete on their own hardship but no take advantage and freebie and call it samvidhan 👏👏
@@CrayLyfAnkita9477 Nothing wrong in being proud of our ancestors. But dalits are being treated as inferior human being, untouchables, impure etc. This is not acceptable. This is the reason I have problem with the word Dalit. The word Dalit is used as synonym of Untouchable.
@@unstoppableub if you go in the main comment section of the video you will find many comments where it's not a discrimination anymore unless 2 friends reach 10th standard and in further studies the general candidate has to look that due to reservation his friend got a seat and he didn't instead of reservation , search for the course called " forensic " Maharashtra has just one college in nagpur and just check for the reserved seats I would like to tell that general has 1-2 seats and that too for one who are studied 11-12 in same college at this point the youngster develops anguish for obc st sc , the govt would have allocated benefits like houses for those who don't have any ancestral property or without proper houses , free resources for preparation of exams this could have been removed the system of discrimination just look honestly are the really oprresed getting facilities? Aren't the situation what happened 300 years ago used as a victim card in today's generation where neither I have discriminated , nor you got discriminated, neither I studied for 3000 years neither you were stopped from studying it were the ancestors just imagine if reserved seats are for a class because of oppression for 3000 years then Kshatriyas should be also given reservation because their ancestors died defending the country ! Seems logical ? I am against this form reservation system directly employing seats where on one side OBC teachers like divyakriti says 3000 years with no education and today when allowed to compete people are using shortcuts for direct position so at that time also not studied well and today also instead what a person requires for an exam resources , a house , ration so govt and your politicians should provide it but no your politicians play politics on that imagine through the system I said their wouldn't be any creamy layer also , just one question do you think if a freebie is given to someone would it be taken back ? People would get on roads even after 75 years from now if reservation is cancelled this is the situation it's not like a limit decided that okay those who are opressed should take benefit within next 5 years , advocate and politicians show datas of how many OBC are at govt position do tell me is every OBC interested in studying? Many of them go for sports as carrer , artists , other courses so initially if they do not get succeeded they want their kids to get a govt job but again if he is least interested he will not opt for the same and the cycle continues and what it's shown OBC are still oppressed I am against the reservation but not against their upliftment provide them resources and let them fight .
@@unstoppableub what is the full form of OBC then ? It's given by babasaheb himself I had written a long reply but see the algorithm here ,even that got deleted after posting the comment still would write a brief
2) even supreme court said creamy layer must be removed didn't babasaheb or anyone think of this before and it took 75 years to understand the issue ? People who really need the facilities are deprived so is this the responsibility of your politicians or general category to amend things ?
3) my opposition is not for the upliftment of really deprived people my opposition is by the illogical explanations of reservation one of them being explained by divyakriti that 3000 years of education was deprived and just 75 years of reservation is irritating them , so acc to this their is no inflation!
Acc to him what ancestors suffered inreal people will be liable of their facilities so Kshatriyas must avail the facility too because our ancestors sacrificed to save this country in wars!
Reservation as a scheme is another blunder to create more discrimination just look up for schemes like mhada and sra have you heard people bullying the govt or the poor people who once lived in slums now live in a better society , no because it's a realistic and logical scheme which has certain limitations that your slum was demolished the govt through pvt builders gave flats to people in slums and builder can sell rest flats and earn his wage , govt had the option to do so for obc and st too they could have given necessary benefit like free education, a basic house for living , ration etc so this was a limited facility and supports equality for all no tension of creamy layer and all that shit 3000 years without education was the problem na so study now and compete but no we need direct reserved seats , secondly not every OBC or sc student goes for govt and private jobs many go for sports , arts, other activities so after that a data is made by an ayog which tells still obc and sc st are not in above positions I mean then what's our fault bc many of them might not study even hindu upper caste has chapris and so do obc and sc st have ( only to be precise or fuck this upper lower shit ) so do the ayog want every OBC and sc to be on top at a time then this thing will end ? Is that even logical to be like that orelse the necessary benefits for obc as I mentioned for students who want to study for govt exams and pvt exams must be provided by your politicians which is more rational , this is just my logical question to you .
@@unstoppableub no one uses that word more than your own ministers and politicians dear , in a city like area no one cares of caste and all I didn't care for it uptill my 11th college registration when I got to know a st guy got a top college even after his parents were a teacher in a college hatred in new generation starts from here
Thanks Amazing . Thank you Jhonny depp. Reservation is destroying sc and st also .
Me toh pehle doctor ka jati check karta hun
Sorry to say that but
ScSt doctor ko dikhane se dar lagta hai😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂true
with reservation summing upto 85 percent it's really difficult for us
Passing out mark from a medical college is same for every body. Your attitude already showed why reservation is necessary.
@@prashant-bm4fp passing out mark same but but but getting a government job also have reservations so it again the same thing give exam get lowerer cutoff and take government job
He said it right if you think reservations is your right then write dr.abcdefgh md (reserve) in your prescription
@@prashant-bm4fp and what about pg entrance? what about government job recruitment?
1. सेल्फ respect = गालियां देना और सब को
Thank you Ajeet bharti ji.
Agree with you 🙏🚩🚩
If you are saying that people should write reserved under their names … you basically proved that the upper caste people are surviving on the basis of their castes right? You are good at targeting the minorities but ever thought of the minorities? Do they really want reservation? No. What they want is equal respect which upper caste carry by birth. I can see his frustration. Just understand one fact , sc/st people spend their life to prove their credibility
Bro is right somehow...
🔴I don't have Problem with Indian Caste System but it should be based on Economic Criteria.
जितने Log 8 लाख से ऊपर कमाते हैं वो ब्राह्मण 4 लाख से कम वाले दलित 😂
अगर सब कुछ पैसे से ही तय हो रहा हैं तो जाति भी पैसे से ही तय होनी चाहिए।😂
Jo zero mark leke select hua hai uska koi nam to hoga uske details bhi batao jra
rajasthan me 1 st grade math ka exam hua sc st walo ka zero hi nhi neg me no aaye par unko select kiya m from rajasthan so m janta hu ho skta h ye tumhe jhooth lge
I dont know who is is he but almost everything he said is wrong. May be he has reservation phobia 😂😂😂 but he said wrong
Iam sorry but this comment system itself proof of why reservation is necessary, I agree Resources should be provided to everybody and see how they excell. But we should also state and admitt the fact that the descrimination according to caste is still happening not just in jobs also in every aspect there are many rural areas where people are still denying to let a SC or ST person to buy land, even in citiea there are people who ask you caste before giving house for rent and denying if the person or famiy is of lower caste. As a perspective of varna system why not remove tge caste system itself entirely and provide educational and constitutional rights to everybody equally. This will become a controversy because many people of so called higher caste wont see this happen.
Not disagreeing with your views but a just question.
What do you think about the conditions of the blacks in the US compared to Indian
SC/STs? Why did they improve their social status and now are on equal terms with the whites?
And why the same thing cannot happen in India?
@@Roseviell yes there are many blacks who raised there standards to be equal with the whites yet there is alot of racism towards them too, and there are a lot of blacks who didn't raise to the standards and still doing illegal things in u.s, similarly there are a lot of people from SC and ST who raised their standards and made a living by gaining knowledge and jobs and any child of gov employee is not eligible for reservation according to their income. Even though our constitution has divided the reservation to 50-50 that is 50% to general category and 50% to OBC, SC, ST at the ground level the implementation is being played by the politicians and people hating the reservation system. Which will always oppress the communities. There are cases in the recent times when the lower caste people demanded for the equal rights they were killed many people wont agree that this is happening but this is the harsh reality. People are not coming out of their caste bubbles to look at each other as humans. Until the day the caste system is removed officially by our judiciary system there will be a need for reservation and still people will fight with each other on the basis of religion.
@@reddysai1197 thankyou, i really do wish that happens.
May be you are on the benefited side
@@Peter-zj3gl thats the tricky part im not on the benefitted side my father struggled to get a gov job in the circumstances where they are treated as untouchables and not worthy to study. As my father got a gov job he struggled a lot to get promotions and I have witnessed all his struggles and he told me never take the advantage of the caste system but to take responsibility of my own career, i failed to acquire a medical seat even after trying twice later I got into Physiotherapy completed my ug with the eligibility without using caste, now I am pursuing my masters on my own in bangalore and the college offered me to either be as assisstant professor or a junior research fellow my caste didnt play any role in all these. But i still find it difficult to get a house coz people ask me for caste, and when I go to my village recently i witnessed sc's drinking water as a person poured water into their hands bcoz of the caste they couldnt drink in a tumbler. If u think I am benefitted by the reservation I cant help it.
रघुपति राघव राजा राम पता न पावे सियाराम 😂वर्जिन mary कुंती 😂अली बजरंगबली 😂
Bilkul sahe hai, education or health care se to om s km reservation ht na chahea
Is mandir reservation justified?
Now the narrative is... Reservation according to population... Just like separate electorate system... Seat according to caste nd class
I don’t care whether there is reservation or not. If it is there that is the only unfair advantage that we have if it’s not then that’s okay. The unreserved people have lot of generational education and wealth which was earned by oppressing lower caste and they will use it to the max to achieve whatever they want.
I as SC candidate could have got decent college in general ranking but got admission in IIT. I’m not top1%ile but top 4%ile. We get into aukaat ke bahr ka college. We tackle the syllabus which is beyond our capacity along with all these taunts, inferiority, guilty, unworthiness and if we still win then we deserve some respect. I work in private now.
The way this guy is mentioning it’s like “general people will definitely discriminate tum reservation Kyu nahi chor dete”.
These kind of people want to solve casteism problem by making people forget about their origins but reality is people won’t forget their origin as long as their caste/religion gives them motivation. Ex we are Marathas we are warriors, we are marwadi we r great businessmen,etc.
we are dalits…… what are we?
Annihilation of discrimination by caste is needed u can’t remove caste as concept now.
If gender discrimination exists u can’t remove the ways to identify gender. U can’t ask people to have unisex look.
The reservation problem will be automatically solved when more and more people will try to get the same job from same community the cut off will rise and it will match that of gen.
Reservation is incomplete if general people are not welcoming towards dalits.
Only general people can stop discrimination who are at top of social hierarchy and hence the reservations. Peace
You tell me how the condition of SC ST will improve. Do You know the cutoff of government teachers in Bihar. What are they teaching in the school who got jobs through reservation and the facts is that most of the students who studied in government school are of SC ST category. What are they teaching to those students. How's the condition improve you tell me now.
Instead of asking for a reservation why you can't ask for financial help from the government. Why not????
Do a caste census of coaching institutes in Kota. Let see the ratio of general to lower caste. That will give you an idea of how resources are distributed across the country. Most upper caste people have generational wealth which ancestors of lower caste people were denied of (ofcourse this does not apply to everyone and there are exceptions). Reservation is not about lower caste people being inferior in competitive exams. It's more about the fact that lot of lower caste people don't have the resources to prepare for competitive exams that other people have. Competitive exams are definitely a race but it's not an equal race because not everyone is starting from the same starting point.
If you are good at studies goverment in every state is giving scholasrahip to lower caste . Lower fees of exams , scholarships in coaching institutions, scholarship for books in colleges . I am not saying that lower caste are on same level but the existing system has failed to put them on the same level and will continue to be a failure to do so . And according to ypur commemnt a student whose parents are earning and have benfitted from reservation , irrespective of which caste they belong , they should not be given reservation too because they can afford basics .
I agree some people are not financially Strong so u can give them financially push by govt schemes. Rather than 56 is equals to 87 ye kha ka justice h ye to lolipop de diya bhai chlo reservation k basis p iit neet college mil bhi gya phir placements m dekha kro ki reserve category wale piche kaise rhte h
Who told you that the majority of my OBC friends are more wealthy than me. And what about rich SC ST still some family getting reservation not all.
What do you want say that half knowledge person will be doctor enginner... civil services...
Also do a research how many uc people are being rejected while we are at it .
Reservation should be based on economic conditions...I m medical Student in my Class I have 10 people management category out of which 5 people belong to SC ST category...even SC ST category people are so poor than how can they give 90 lakes as a donation nd including 8lakhs yearly fees...nd In class a vegetable seller kid general category worked hard his dad sold lands to pay fees....So yes Reservations is worst Thing of India...compete on basis of Merit ...
Is dono pr comment Krna bekaar hai.😂!!
He is talking everything in such an idealistic sense. 90% of students cannot crack a competitive exam like JEE,NEET if they are not given coaching which is expensive. You live in a fool's paradise if you think preparing for boards and the quality of teaching at that level is same at coaching and the difference can be overcome by government by just 'training' some teachers . Moreover, if you speak of economic background reservation- it is more difficult as the criteria for EWS makes most of the general EWS. The fact that a farmer with good harvest season is above BPL for one seasons and not for another season with poor harvest. Caste and handicap reservation can be objectively more identified and if NCL is applied on that reservation automatically reservation system seems more valid.
to vahi to bola financial support do reservation hata ke
he is absolutely wrong. this is not the way of explaining, Seriously🤣🤣🤣 aarakshan ke prati nafrat dikh araha hai kuchh jayada hi
1:45 TRUTH
You can have reservations but atleast put some quota that you can only avail reservation 2-3 times in life or cap by economic conditions on reserved castes. Finally do not hire teachers, doctors, engineers based on reservation. Its ok to be a clerk based on reservation or a manager, but jobs cannot have math teacher with 0 marks
अजीत जी से मैं सहमत हूँ comptition में रिज़र्वेशन नही होनी चाहिए
This one clip shows the clarity of thought compared to the constant propaganda casteist nonsense spewed daily by left wing.
I am OBC and I tale admissions through open or general category. I don't like reservation system at all. It's flawed at it's core.
Did u apply in OBC category first and then score high marks (cleared gen cutoff) or first hanly apply in gen category?
Rote raho reservation kabhi nahi hatega. Har General category pe mereko hasi ati hai😅
Banda bol to bilkul sahi raha hai. Par school mein baccho ko pata nhi hota kise reservation milta hai aur kise nhi. Unhe surname se hi pata chal jaata hai. Fark nhi padta reservation milta hai ki nhi milta hai, caste discrimination hamesha hota rahega...kahi pe zyada dikhne ko milega aur khi pr kam. And guess what..baccho ko surname ke basis pe discriminate karna seekhata bhi kon hai? School mein to nhi sikhata...to bachta ghar hai. Parents baccho ko galat sikhayega aur zeher daalega regarding caste to wohi leke aage badhega. To yhi matlab banta hai ki abhi tak upper caste log lower caste ko usi gandi nazar se dekhta hai. Reservation to bas bahana hai inka uss hate ko reason aur justification dene ke liye. Reservation hatt jayega to koi doosra reason dhoond lega waise bhi. So the points why reservation should be removed is valid and right, but caste discrimination can never be changed. Moreover any discrimination is form of strong dominating over weak. Anyone who possess power(money,fame, connections) can do discrimination. I believe its necessary to work on that mentality. The upper castes who believe themselves to be superior should first learn to know humility. They should understand that all humans are equal. The lower caste people need to come out of their inferior mentality and they need to be taught that they have same potential as everyone. These should start from home and school. Raising awareness is the only solution to do these things right. But who is willing to take this challenge? Change starts from home. If we can raise awareness among next 1-2 generation, there will be no reason for any reservation or anything else. Blaming each other will not solve anything. If we change the way we look the world, we can do wonders.
Reservation according income I think that should be applied ❤
Aap ki is asahaniya peeda ko ham samajhte hain 😁
Ye bate koi nhi samjhata 🥲
Q-Ye thought process kb aayegi india mein......
A-Kbhi nahi
Pure casteist mans 👼
Bhai ekk baat h mai St catogery se hun . Mujhe pata h sarkari school kitne acche h . And phle se tm jaise log discriminate krte ho . Ab reservation ke baad kroge . But diffrence kya h ab mai acche ghar me hun acche kha pi raha hun sarkari Naukri h mast life h . Aur tm log se respect aur equality chaiye v nahi . Jai baba saheb
To social equality to ati hi nhi. Bas financial fayda mil gya tumhe. To fir jab reservation khatm karne ko bat ati hai to ye kyun kehte ho ke jab tak social equality nhi ati tab tak chalni chahiye?
Badk 😅kha aur hag 💩yahi kar 😂....
Whi to baat hai na...acha job kro... paise kamao...usko baad bhi reservation ka fayada loge ...to jo log financially weak h unke taane to sunana pdega na
Achi life mil gayi hai mtlb tumhe
Iska mtlb ab tumhare bachon ko reservation ki zaroorat nhi hai
vhi to keh diya video mein .. swabhimaan ki kami hai
Reservation should only be based upon family financial condition and if required in some state based on female too.......
Some change in current policy is required atleast don't give benefits to those from where atleast one member of the family has already taken advantage of it ...
In my pov reservation should be completely removed and govt should provide extra help and support to make weak section of society strong enough to compete and achieve their goals .
The most funny thing about Reservation is, among 35 crores of SC ST OBC
They will get few thousand Government Reserved seats including all college and Government jobs yearly. Let's assume it's 100k
Now let's assume 10cr out of 35 cr are youth and compeding for it
10cr/100k = 1000 yrs it will take to uplift every SC ST Socio-economic condition
For the sake of the Argument let's assume reserved seats are 1 M 😂
10cr/1 M = Atleast 100 yrs
These are very high estimates in reality itne seats nahi hote
-Now include 2 factors into it
1) Successive Generations->
Now assume a 1st Generation SC/ST becomes a Doctor. He is financially well off, could easily send his children to quality schools and Tuitions. Now his 2nd gen will get the same facility his father has got along with financial privilage. He is more probable to get the seat. Now assume there are 1000s of such SC ST family whose 1st generation got the benefits and now there 2nd generation is Double privileged. Eventually It will cause Saturation where only the Rich section of SC will reap the benefits out of it and rest 80% will be left out.
2) Bhai Government Colleges aur Government jobs ke exams dene keliye bhi tou Minimum qualification chahiye 10th pass 12th pass etc. 80% SC ST ke pass itni bhi qualification nahi hain aur Reservation ka fayda lena tou dur baat hain pahle qualify tou ho.
Samjh ayaa tou balle balle warna Jai Bhim 💙🐦
Jitne bhi farzi daleele de lo jab tak casteism poori tarah khatam nhi hoti tab tak reservation rahegi. I hope you got it. Ab yeh mat bola ki casteism toh hoti hi nhi hai ya casteism is british construct. 😭🤣
Btw Meritdhaaris who can't even clear sc/st cutoff give huge gyan against reservation. 🤦♂️Then start begging for EWS reservation or also fake SC certificates. 🤷♂️
Samajh aaya toh dhinka chika warna Jai Shree Golf flag 🚩🦜🧡
@@manaspratimdas707 Jati alag chiz hoti aur Varna alag.
Caste = Jati
Jatiwaad isiliye hain kyun ke samajh mai jo mainstream Economy aur society ka part nahi baan paye woh pichdi Jati ka hogaya.
Varna Hindu Dharam ka ek Samajik system hain jiska Caste ke saath koi lena dena nahi hain.
Arthik vikas karo apne aap Jaatiwaad khatam ho jayega.
Secondly Casteism 1947 mai hhi khatam hogaya tha jab Desh mai Sambhidhan huwe tha. Constitution mai ye likha hain issh desh mai kisi bhi aur tarah ki Kanuni kitaab ya vibastha ajj sse illegitimate hain.
Lastly Reservation ne Niche jaati ke logo ko kya Literacy aur Wealth de diya ??? 70 saal se Reservation hain Abhi taak tou Reservation ki wajah sse abhi taak SC ST waalo ko atleast 50% Literacy mili hain ???
@@saikatghosh9073 jaati aur varna alag chiz hoti hai?? Haa
Lekin Jatiwaad varna vyavastha se juda hua hai. Jaati ke anusaar varna nishchit hoti hai.
Doosra caste system judiciary taur pe toh khatm ho gya tha par aaj bhi usse mana jaata hai kai Hinduo dwara illegally. Kai ucch jaati hindu toh constitution change karwake isse dubara lagu karwana chahte hai legally taki jatiwaad kar sake dubara.
Teesra, niche jaatiyo ka utthan kyu nhi ho saka kyuki wohi ucchi jaati ne woh ne jatiwaad ko jaari rakha aur niche jaatiyo ko kabhi bhi uthne nhi diya.
@@manaspratimdas707 Nahi Varna and Caste Same nahi hain
Manusmriti mai kahi nahi likha Shudra ko aap chu nahi sakte, yafir Khana nahi khila sakte etc
Manusmriti mai yea clearly likha hain agar koi Brahmin Vedic Rituals follow nahi karega tou apni Brahmin status kho dega aur woh sudra ho jayega. Brahmin agar crime kare tou usse zyada Punishment milti hain whereas Shudra ko kam. Brahmin no ko Kama ke khane ki ijazat nahi hain tujhe pata hain ?? unhe bhikh maang ke khane ko bola hain whereas Shudra ko Handicrafts ya agriculture ka dayatwa hain.
Varna Birth based tai hoti hain lekin Usme specifically Kahi uchi ya nichi jaat mentioned nahi hain.
Aur Jaat hoti hain jaise Rajput, Yadav,Jaat,Gujjar etc jo ke alag alag tribe hain. Inme sse jo tribe Raja ya ameer banne woh logo ne Manusmriti ka istemaal karke tod matod ke khud ko uchi Jati ka boldiya aur baakiyo ko neechi
2) Dusri tune khud likha hain illegally practice karte hain, tou law enforcement ki galati hain. Law enforcement thik hogi tou yea bhi ghat jayega. Murder illegal hain lekin log tou karte hain, tou yea tohri hain harkoi roz murder kar raha hain ???
3) Maine sidha bola ke bhai Reservation agar itni asar dar hain tou SC ST samjh mai atleast 50% laa paya ??? Agar nahi tou yea SC ST waalo kaise subidha deti hain jab 90% SC ST inse wanchit rehte hain ??
@@manaspratimdas707czcams.com/video/MOEluq3jUic/video.htmlsi=cb0DyrsE6NACN3Zh
reservation must be for education and health not for job
and also what about the corruption ,in job if reservation system is gone , it is even most
3:22
Chlo beta tumhara doodh bhaat hai😂
😂😂😂 ha kyoki wo weak hain 😂
Ek baar vikas divaykirti sir ki reservation par video dekho lo , no nonsense talking
Divyakirti talked about the emotional aspect of reservation but this guy is talking about the effects of reservation which is much more concrete and real.
Reservation se Dalits ko nuksaan hi horha hai and more importantly India ka nuksaan horha hai.
+ Divyakirti ne mere hisab se service exams ki baat kahi thi, naaki college admissions
@@Rosevielltrue
REVERSE CASTEISM
Are we going to condem the change of Maharaja Agrasen from Kshatriya to Vaishya
😠First tell me how many SC/ST people who are self sufficient in taking care of themselves leave the quota for other fellow SC/ST brothers. There are many people in India who are taking reservation benefits for 4th generation too. Rule should be made Govt should provide aid in ration, health services, admission fees etc till 21 years. Later babu tumhare kisi bhi peedi ko aarakshan nahi. And why doesn't SC/ST complain to Muslims who purposefully create many kids and also eat Govt facilities for generations. Why they don't question 40 lakh Bangladeshi and Rohingya immigrants who are eating their jobs and facilities....they just chant like Zombies....Brahmanavaad 🧟♂️🧟♀️🧟♂️🧟♀️🧟♂️🧟♀️
@@Shubham-pr9cq does it matter? khatriya or vaishya, Brahmin or shudra, it's all a title for what someone used to do. it really doesn't matter nowadays.
yes I am really proud to be born in his Lineage, the direct lineage from prabhu ram, being the first set of kings that had to fight the invaders in form of tuglak, and I do offer my pranam to him as his son and admirer, yet still these things are meaningless, what is meaningful is the tapasya, bhagwan Krishna preaches agresen maharaj in the battlefield of kurukshetra, what matters is his tapasya of shiva on ganga ghat and of ma mahalakshmi in gujrat (sorry I don't remember the river he offered his prayers), this tapasya, service and selflessness is what Aggrawals should be proud to inherit.
siya ram 🙏🏽
@@Yagvendra_duutdas Do you care about the lineage of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj or your proud of him because he fight for youMirza Raja Jaisingh you are proud of him who fought against you
Ambedkar or so called Periyar Was hate being Shudra Now if you hate the work of Shudra then the 75% of the society will be unemployed
@@Shubham-pr9cq see I respect shivaji Maharaj as a devout Hindu, I can't be proud of his Lineage because I don't belong to that.
history will be full of instances like you mentioned, like maharaj jaisingh, he was a close friend of Akbar, and he did fought Maharana Pratap ji with him but that would be a political debate, my statement was that no one needs to identify with a "caste" as it is a foreign concept, if you let go of kings (because yes they did have a vertical transfer of power), all "varnas" were earned by gurukul.
I never said I hate the job or anything, we need plumbers and we need pilots, I don't know how you inferring this.
siya ram.
Tum asali baat nahi kar rahe ho tum logo ke agende se saf saf pata chalta hai niyati kya h
A sc category teacher is selected for seat of teacher and he scored 40% marks in exam but being a general category student i need atleast 80% to clear the exam then how could such teacher can teach me😢