Does the Quran Imply that the Prophet had a Concubine? | Concubines in Islam, part 10 | Shabir Ally
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 02. 2022
- Is there any indication in the Quran that the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) either had a concubine or had license to sleep with a slave woman, just by virtue of owning her without the need for marriage? Dr. Shabir Ally answers no. He explores Quran 33:50 and 52. He explains that the Quran maintains the distinction between free women who are married and captive women who are married for reasons pertaining to the nature of society at the time.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by visiting our website www.quranspeaks.com or sending an etransfer to igive@quranspeaks.com
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: czcams.com/users/subscription_...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
Why is he not sincere in giving an answer? He should know that sex slaves is already prescribed for believers (33:50) in reference to the women authorized by Allah for a Muslim man's sexual use. When a child or a woman is taken captive, they become slaves by the fact of capture, and the woman's previous marriage is immediately annulled. This is because having sex with married slaves is also permissible (4:24). The Quran clearly states that Muslim men have been given permission to have women prisoners of war as their sex slaves. It says:
“O Prophet! We have made lawful to thee thy wives to whom thou hast paid their dowers; and those (slaves) whom thy right hand possesses out of the prisoners of war whom Allah has assigned to thee"
This is just one of several personal-sounding verses "from Allah" narrated by Muhammad himself. In fact, there are several other verses in the Quran about the sex slaves. Muslim apologists often pretend that passages of the Quran which clash with modern sensibilities have a different meaning in the original language, even if this alternate meaning already seems to have eluded fourteen centuries worth of Arabic-Islamic scholars. Although Muslims often decide which parts to follow or ignore, the Quran (33:36) says that it is not fitting for a believer to choose for themselves (i.e., disregard) any matter already decided by Allah.
You have to free your war captives with or without Ransom
No if a woman capture her husband alive you can't take her as cucobbin. It's prohibited. She can't separate with her husband . Kind is most important thing in islam.
@@sarashifu6863 🤣🤣 which men were left alive so a lady cannot be a con . cubine?? Even kinana was k. illed and saffiya bint huyyay was taken by muhmad.. what are you talking about??
Very informative...
I have a 10 year daughter. and I am praying that my daughter will be as respectful and smart as yours. You are a blessed man.
Aamiin Allah humma aamiin
Great explanation
I'm glad to see her back
Instead of using " Right hand processed' should not we use the meaning 'processed by your oath'? If we do so, all the difficulties will go away.
English translation, English doesn't have the enough words to match with the number of words in Arabic, that's why at many places they have issues with using correct word or explanation from english.
It's the issue with number of words in English and Arabic, Arabic have way more words than English, hence at many places choosing the right word or explanation is difficult.
May Allah bless you, your just solve all of my difficulties. And made my Iman more strong.❤
Excellent👍💯
Thanks Dr.Shabir, that was very informative
The two groups of women mentioned in the verse the wives who were given dowries and the wives without dowries. The captive women or cousins ( the right hand possession)who might not ask for dowries or especially slave women will not require dowry to be married. I believe Quran made this distinction between those two groups of women but nonetheless they have to be married before sharing a bed.
No....sabir is lieing
@@Liabrarian Yes, do you think otherwise?
What constituted a legal marriage. I mean you are saying Wives with and Wives without Dowries, but what if there was some confusion at a later date about whether a slave woman was in fact married or not.
So what you are telling me is that I can capture a woman and marry her without giving her Mehr so now she is my slave?
u are sick in the head ,imagine it was u who were killed,, would u want ur wife to marry ur killer
In the last video, you gave a different meaning to the phrase "right hand possess"
That is exactly what I thought 🤔
I love this saying
I love dr Shabir but this question, he is refusing to understand the urf of ancient societies and trying to make them pG.
How come mo slept with safiyya the same night he killed her husband and father without waiting for the idda period?
She was too beautiful that’s why.
where did you even get this,in the full hadith it says when they traveled back to Makkah Safiyyah(ra) iddah or mencus had just finished and it's not that she (ra) was just beautiful,again in the Full Hadith The Prophet (saw) had no interest in safiyyah(ra) even after seeing her! It was only when a person told The Prophet (saw) she was the cheiftess of the tribe and so that's the reason The Prophet (saw) freed her and asked her if she wanted to go back to her relatives in the tribe and live them or marry him(saw) and that's when you realize her(ra) Husband literally Slapped her(ra) so your the one who is at fault here because again The Prophet (saw) had no interest even after seeing Saffiyah(ra) beauty because The Prophet (saw) only married her hoping t settle peace between the tribes.
With all due respect I think we should not try to prove Islam to fit in what modern society can accept. Allah is The All Wise and has infinite Knowledge on Everything. If the Sheick can only respond to my concern. What if his interpretation is wrong and that the Prophet has acted on that legislation? On what side will we find ourselves when debating those having evil thoughts about Islam?
There is some fishy about this channel. They Do not follow the salaf -as-salih. May Allah guide them and us
I think a proper answer should be there for the attack of non muslim on these topic !
Only a jahil would resort to this mystical thinking. We need this knowledge for scholarly purposes. Even the Prophet himself was uncomfortable with things that God said to him. It's part of life to come to terms with uncomfortable truths. Every generation has had some kind of problem with the seerah, and sticking your head in the sand isn't going to make it go away.
Certain things were permissible for prophets but not for general people. Same as lot of responsibilities were obligated for the prophets but not for general peoples
That makes a lot of sense! Jumah Mubarak Dr Shabir
That's great explanation Dr. Shabir 👍🏽 & is there any proof if Hadeeth or Hayathus Sahaba that they had concubines that they never got married to?
Jzakla Khair
I love dr shabir explaination of each topic he's the perfect mentor......
You love, because you are a certified donkey. Read and think yourself. Sabir is lieing
@@mansurhallaj8568 are you a muslim?
@@zahinelahi2655 yes, pukka
@@mansurhallaj8568 lol, being a muslim and calling other muslims donkey. You are an embarassment
@@zahinelahi2655 a donkey doesn’t differentiae between lie and truth. Sabir Ali misinterpreted the verses of quran, and sadly donkeies don't realise this. Oh fools please read quran yourself, try to understand the meanings. Allah SWT has given brain to use it, not to make soup out of it.
To sleep with a concubine meant marriage. I think the confusion is because we are thinking of marriage as the formalisation or procedure we are commonly familiar with in later times. There were many ways to "marry' at that that time. Nikah doesn't always mean aqd al Nikah in the Qur'an. It sometimes means both or one or the other.
would u be ok with a man killing ur family and the same night the man who killed ur family marrying ur wife
Prophet Is a pros...
@@iankennedy1441would you be okay withs a nikah and not a marriage
Concubines were slaves, not wives. They don't have any rights like wives do. Concubines were limited to one man the same way that wives were however, in order to ensure paternity of offspring.
How do you interpret the “what your right hand possesses sura ? Does this imply that wives are possessions? This would make sense as the husband is able to divorce his wife with just three utterances.
no
watch part 7. the plural masculine form of "spouse" is used
According to the standard islamic narrative (SIN); at a young age, muhammad worked as a shepherd, later he allegedly took part, successfully with large profit for his employer, the merchant widow khadija, in two trips of trade caravans to the north. Muhammad was then entrusted with her affairs, and khadija, proposed marriage to muhammad when he was 25 years old, and she was 40? years old. Muhammad hesitated to accept because he had no money to support her. And it is not unreasonable to think that muhammad, an orphan who contracted an unequal marriage, would suffer a certain social stigmatisation. But with the help of his first wife, muhammad gained his financial independence and social security and gave him some social recognition - a turning point in his life. Two meccan verses of the quran refers directly to this time: 93:6 did he not find you an orphan and give [you] refuge?, 93:7 And he found you lost and guided [you].
It seems that muhammad married a total of fifteen women, excluding four concubines. He had eleven wives at one time.
very nice
In Muslims two things are not followed by muslims No debate for each other's religions we should say "your religion is for you my religion is for me" next muslims have no right to call anyone kafir .
15 minutes off nonsens
Imagine being a woman and being captured after watching ur whole family slaughtered and then ur to marry the man who killed ur family ,, husband brother father ect all murdered . Imagine ha ving to marry the man who killed them , Sorry but this and other reasons 4_34 ect is why I could never become a muslim.. take Sophia the daughter of the Jewish tribe who after battle had to marry Muhammad 2dsys after watching muhammad and his army kill her husband father brother .imagine how fearful stressed ect she must of felt . How can anyone think this was ok . Shabir so as long as I marry the woman it makes it all happy fluffy and hugs sure which woman could resist the romantic way in which u captured her, sorry but this is laughable
And the worrying thing is that people agree with this , If this is what islam does to ur Brain , then Islam is not for me
Hey! With safiya (ra) permission prophet (pbuh) married her... Not forcefully
@@aishaameen105 could u answer my ? Or is u natural gut telling u what Muhammad done is disgusting and wrong . Please answer my ?
@@iankennedy1441 Muhammed(pbuh) he didn't killed anyone... They started war for their freedom to live.. Muhammed born in Mecca n Mecca people's started attacking them then they leave from there to Madinah... After that Mecca enemies started to attack from there also...... At that moment they started war.... Our prophet(pbuh) he suffered alot only because he told his God is unique... His dearest friends n family killed by enemies... He showed his good character to slavery women's... He didn't sell them as a product... He just married them and give priority as his wife... With her permission he married her.. He asked her I will free u Or i will marry u? Her answer to marry him......
Hey u just think.... If safiya ( ra) married prophet (pbuh) by fearing him or she hate him... After marrying him she can do anything harmful to him... But she lived with him happily by obeying Islam... She has no problem with prophet (pbuh) then y u?
*This is the full list of concubines of prophet Muhammed.*
Baraka
Berre binti Şerhabil
Cüveyriye binti Haris
Ebu Rafi'nin cariyesi
Ebi Cehil'in cariyesi
Ebi Ruhm
Esma binti Nu'mân
Esiye
Eslem
Etiye
Fadl
İnâb
İsmet
Gaziyye
Gifran
Hakim bin Hizam'ın cariyesi
Halime
Hafsa binti Ömer
İmâme
Kalka
Kays binti Sa'd
Leyla binti Hamîze
Leyla binti Kudame
Leyla binti Haris
Lübâbe binti Haris
Meymune
Medyune
Mîme binti Abdillah
Marhaba
Marya
Nâşiye
Nufeyse
Rabia
Remle
Ramlah binti Şevbe
Rihane
Reyyane
Rumaysa
Sebîne (veya Sabîne)
Sâfiyye binti Huyeyy
Safiyye binti Ebû Ubeyd
Sâfîne
Sahle
Sâra
Sâvîye
Süheyl binti Amr
Sümeyra
Şağalibe
Sâvite
Şeyma
Tufeyre
Tübâ
Ukbe binti Ömer
Umame binti Abdi'l-Muttalib:
Ummu Ammâr
Ümmü Eymen
Ümmü Gıris
Ummu Hakim
Ümmü Mısrâ
Ümmü Muhâcir
Ummu'l-Hüseyn
Ümmü Selem
Ummu Şuca
Ümmü Seleme
Vüheybe
Zeyneb binti Cahş
Zenibe
Zeyneb binti Güzeyle
Şuva binti Haris
Y u had shaved some part of bread
Pls tell me did prophet ( saw) had cucobbin or not.
The answer is - depends on if you believe the hadith that says he did are legitimate.
Ally already admits to not only s*x slavery but the slaves must 'consent'. Not sure why he doubts the hadith pertaining to Muhammed. He already enjoyed more wives than anyone else was supposed to have.
Yes hé did , he also owned slaves , his ONLY surviving son was from a slave
@@iankennedy1441Ibrahim died in infancy, he did not survive the Prophet or his mother Maria
Shabir Ali would you like someone do such a thing with your daughter?
It's not true!
would you want someone to enslave your daughter like jesus preaches?
If it is not available for Muhammad in Quran to have concqupine Than why he Did go against Allaha discussion and had Slept with Maria qubtia
Phrophet muhammad (saw) he will never go ALLAH 's command he is a Phrophet but really there are so many doubts about marria that can't confirm. Pls don't use words against Phrophet. We don't know what is true or false.
@@sarashifu6863 If u dont know whats true or false WHY are u a muslim?
It doesn't imply anything it is clearly stated that he did.
That's not the way a prophet should behave.
Did u even watched this Video? Here nothing inappropriate thing has been proved about prophet. So what behaviour thing u talking about? I think u r lindu.
@@mahedihassan7880 not everyone who questions is hindu. We muslims have BRAINS as well.
@@afia9641 he is. His user name proves. And what u r trying say by implying have brains?
@@afia9641 His name says that he is a lindu and a lindu person don't know any logic.
Surprising that Muslims think that morality is relative. What is immoral today has to be immoral in the time of Mohammed.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Excellent summary. Slavery n sex with concubines was the zeitgeist till time of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Quran textually phased out both through example of Prophet Muhammad PBUH.
What was practiced historically by Muslims in their civilisation is also something which cannot be denied in case of Slavery n concubinage but Quran is categorical in this context .
Jazak Allah.
Achchha ghumaya hai 😂
I see a good man trapped in an immoral religion.
christianity is immoral
This is the most common accusation on our prophet jazak Allahu Khair for making this video.and clearing the misconception against Islam.
An excellent explanation of “What the right hand possesses”. Thank you.
It is not lawful for you ˹O Prophet˺ to marry more women after this, nor can you replace any of your present wives with another, even if her beauty may attract you-except those ˹bondwomen˺ in your possession. And Allah is ever Watchful over all things.
es una gran contradiction decir que tenian permiso para casarse con ellas (the slave girls) para que eso no implicaba relaciones sexuales. Quien se cree eso?
A concubine is basically a girlfriend. Ma malekat aymanakum means what your oaths possess not right hands and that is someone you have a verbal agreement with. Ma malekat aymanakum means you don't have to give her dowry, alimony, or inheritance/insurance after death. The mulk Al yameen or wife must be muhsinat and It's hypocritical of Muslims say it's Haram to have a girlfriend but not have a concubine. The Quran doesn't talk much about marriage but rather about sexual relations. The word nikah means continuous sexual intercourse or sexual relations. Check Quran 4:25 which says men who cant afford the expensive sexual relations through marriage should do so through ma malekat aymanakum. The aqd or agreement is verbal via an oath.
@Rajib Hossain
Ya jahil, there is no girlfriend in islam, malakat aymanukum means what you right hand possess, this occur *only* in a war, and you treat them as you treat yourself. Girlfriends does not have that right. Most of the servants became muslims and leaders. You know education is very important.
I almost left islam today because of this thank you
Dr shabir i just want you to answer arguments of jews.
Is torah forever?
Is law of torah can abrogated?
It will mean to me a lot
@El Malakh Feo Quran invites jews to follow the Quran but does not force it or impose it on them.
@El Malakh Feo I’m answering you from a Baha’i perspective. Every time God gives us a new revelation it’s expected that we should investigate it and recognise it’s truth and then accept it. Judaism was abrogated by Jesus and Christianity was abrogated by Muhammad. Each revelation was complete for the time it was revealed in. God will always guide mankind as we evolve. There is also no final messenger and no final book. Gods revelation to mankind is an ongoing guidance.
@@Natalie-fj7fs If temporary marriage is prohibited why the verse 4:24 still included in the Qur'an which is referring to permission of Nikkah Mut'ah????
Will you trust the quran coming from the best of deceivers?
The Qur'an uses the word Nisa when it talks about both wives and concubines, and uses the word azwaaj when it talks only about wives. It doesn't mean the same thing. No two words in the Qur'an means the same thing. But you have to actually look at how the words are used. I know we don't like the idea that people could have sex outside of marriage, but the very idea of marriage being a formalised contract was only one construct in ancient times. If you took a woman to yourself she was either your wife or your concubine, at any rate, she was your woman. That's why the Qur'an says Nisa, and not azwaaj.
Interesting how the prophet gets his own rules to follow. The one who “received” all the revelations
King Solomon had his own rules too 🤷🏾♂️
❌ Jesus said, why do you call me Good ?”No one is good except God alone ( Luke 18 :19 )
( This proves Jesus can't be God )
❌ The bible makes it clear God is not a man ( Numbers 23 : 19 )
( But the christians claim Jesus is human & God 🤦♂️)
❌ The bible says for there is one God & there is one mediator between God & Men, is the man Jesus, ( 1 Timothy 2:5 ) ( This proves Jesus can't be God )
❌ The Christians claim Jesus is God & he knows the future, but the bible makes it clear Jesus does not know the future ( Mark 13 : 32 ) ( This proves Jesus can't be God )
❌ Jesus, said, “Hear, o Israel the Lord our God is one (Mark 12 : 29 - 31)
( The fact that Jesus compared himself with the people by telling the people our God is one proves Jesus is not God )Bible Proves Jesus Is Not God
❌ The bible makes it clear no one can see God ( 1 John 4 : 20 & John 5 : 37 )
( This proves Jesus can't be God because Jesus has been seen )
❌ Jesus made it clear he is human by saying to the people our God is one
( Mark 12 : 29 - 31 ) ( This proves Jesus was human, not God )
@@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45 man who brought up Jesus lol - quit avoiding the point I was trying to make
ARE YOU RELYING ON INTERCESSI0N TO SAVE YOU ❓
THE M0ST PI0US PERSON C0ULD N0T SAVE HIS 0WN FAMILY MEMBERS
Aisha Reported: When the verse was revealed, “Warn your tribe and nearest kindred,”the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, stood upon mount Safa and he said, “0 Fatima, daughter of Muhammad! 0 Safiya, daughter of Abdul Muttalib! O sons of Abdul Muttalib! I have no power at all to protect you from Allah. Ask me for some of my property, as you wish.”
That day, no intercession will benefit except [that of] one to whom the Most Merciful has given permission and has accepted his word (Quran 2O : 1O9)
@@Mamluk8989, Solomon is not recognised as a prophet in the Bible but Mohammed is in Quran.
Do you not see that there is a GREAT disparity between the Koran and the Bible. You cannot have it both ways. Here you have a man with wives sanctioned by Allah. From Genesis to Revelation, God sanctions one man one woman relationships. Solomon had some 700 wives but no passage in the bible sanctions that foolishness. The text shows they led him into idolatry. Jesus the son of God, loved and honored as the only Savior from sin speaks strongly on the one man, one woman relationship. If Mohammed were a prophet of God, he would not be carrying on relationships with more than one woman. I do not know why the phrase - peace be upon him is repeated after his name. You cannot transfer or send peace to a man who is dead. It is appointed unto men, once to die and after death, the judgement. So Mohammed will be judged by God and if he does not know Christ as Savior from sin, he is going to be in a lot of trouble for eternity because no sin can enter heaven. Please do not waste your time with a man who NEVER preached CHRIST. He cannot help you. Jesus Christ who died for our sins and rose again on the third day, is the only way to God. Jesus said: I am the way, the truth and the life. NO man comes to the Father, but BY ME. John 14:6. Your eternal future will either be Heaven or Hell, depending on your relationship with Jesus Christ, the Son of God.
Visibly struggling to recreate history.
Need some white putty and paint...then only it comes white
Well, is seems like the god is not all knowing and all wise 😂😂😂😂
God?
@@waymilky442 yes
How dishonest is this guy! Time you taken to explain one verse, shows that you are making up everything.
Only for Mahhamad??!! OMG!! What a spiritual story.. 😈😈😈
He was the head of state and he married widows after the campaigns.
Every prophet could marry as many wives as they want. Solomon pbuh according to bible had 700 wives.
@@SamirSiraj8542 he is not a prop. het
He was a king 🙄
@@arcadegamer5059 in Islam, Soloman pbuh was a Prophet and a king
@@SamirSiraj8542 yeah but not for chr. istians and jews. So he isn't a pro. phet. even if you all claim so, God was angry on him and he punished him for such sins but for muhmad God was allowing him to have any number of wom' en. Con' cubines and a lot of "wom 'en offer" exclusively for him.. a. llah is very much interested in muhmad's s. ex life 🤣🤣 yeah why not because The God of is. lam is not the same God as the God of Chris' tians and jews..
why this guy is misinterpreted Quran? Total lie even interpretations of Quran.Shame on him.
How's he misinterpreting it, pray tell?
Who?
@@peacemakerofficial9610 presenter Sabir Aly
So...what are you saying..then..
Explain the lie :?
That makes perfect sense. Also the other verse which talks about nakedness is permitted in front of the “right hand possess”. Suppose a very old man is bed ridden and his grand daughter takes care of him. The grand daughter is the person his right hand posses.
... dude no
Astarghfirllah Azeem get it together with your thoughts cause that's not correct, that's very disrespectful Astarghfirllah
Careful....not to misinterpret..need w good religious person...
I wonder why you're not commenting on Ukraine crisis, is it because they are not Muslim? As a convert I feel great shame that Islamic community is silent, shame on you !
May Zelensky find peace and love from Nato..Amen
Hole’s in the narrative 😂
😂
Quran speaks of four wives but the glorious hadith says muhammad had 14 wives...unfair😅
Watch the Christian Prince to get the truth about this.
Christian prince knows trash talk nothing else, a knowledgeable person who knows is humble n doesn’t disrespect anyone let alone the religion
@@skrblade7309 from what he says he talks like he is understood in that culture.
Keeping concubines is haraam in Islam except when it is sunnah.
The desert marauder lived a life of plunder and murder