Former Hamas hostage recounts horrors of captivity
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 03. 2024
- Mandana Dayani joins Morning Joe to discuss her recent interview with released Israeli hostage Moran Stela Yanai.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
Former Hamas hostage recounts horrors of captivity
#Israel #Gaza #Hamas
Such an inspirational woman . Such a brave woman. We must keep fighting for the hostages
Ask Tlaib, Jayapal and Omar why they support HAMAS.
They don't. They support Palestinians and object to genocide. You support genocide and child killing I guess
All democrats do , There religion is Islam . Republicans are Christians
Such a brave woman. And such horror.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇱 she is numb and it will take years to get through the trauma from what she went through 😢 and I bet every one of them will have post-traumatic stress disorder, it just comes with it, with trauma like that 🙏🙏🇮🇱
Palestinians have 75 years of trauma, but they dont matter.
you can really tell she was a tramatized hostage because of all the scars and vouge style clothes
Sorry some people are forgetting many Palestinians were happy and celebrating the capture of hostages...
who cause this war?
@@user-zp8ee8oy7mthe one that happening right now it’s stared by Hamas
@@user-zp8ee8oy7m every palestinian government ever to exist
Yes, they must have known about the tunnels being built under their homes.
@@Bagelsmoker1945 This didn't start Oct. 7th
The world needs to be reminded that the "innocent" people of Gaza were cheering when the hostages were shown to them.
To date, neither the UN-HCR or IRC have yet to visit the remaining (if still alive) Israeli hostages kidnapped & held by HAMAS barbarism!!
Most aid workers and emergency services are targeted, shot and bombed by IDF. How do you expect UN to get out there
If Hamas is holding its captives in secret locations, how do you know this? 🤔
Immediate ceasefire without the hostages, it implies they could be in captivity indefinitely.
Hamas documented their brutal crimes in videos and on social media. Then, they dressed nicely to sit at the table discussing humanitarian aid and negotiations. It was like a serial killer who kidnapped victims and demanded fine dining during talks. Palestinians saw the hostages and didn't say a word. Palestinians in Gaza are on their own because they're no different from Hamas.
you mean like the palestinians have been for 75 years> held captive.
@TheMusicHeals.kjhjhhg Gaza and the territories were controlled by Egypt and Jordan between 1948-1967. Israel departed Gaza in 2005. The majority of Palestinians are ruled by the PA since the 1990. So please explain what you mean by 75 years. Also not clear what you mean by "keeping them captive." They are free to go and live in the 22 nearby Arab countries, as well as Europe and the United States. Who is keeping them in Israel?
@@TheMusicHeals.kjhjhhg Muhmmad is not a prophet , there is no proof
Like the people in Gaza, right?
Be blessed Moran!!! Dayly prayers for all.of you, as a christian i pray from the love of Yeshua...❤❤❤❤❤❤
Am Yisrael Chai
You are delusional and high.
You are high
Breaks my heart. God of Israel, You must show up to protect your inheritance 🙏, please God 🙏Amen
Stop all the aid
this person wants to stave children to death.
Theree's already enough delivered to feed Africa but its not getting distributed. Nothing to do with Israel but the propaganda machine is blaming Israel of course
That was my first impulse; then I realized that the Israelis want the aid to go to the civilians of Gaza. That shows superior character to the world.
STOP FUNDING ISRAEL OPPRESSING PALESTINIANS PEOPLE FOR 70 years
@@valerie5817 This comment hasn't aged well since what happened to the WCK workers. Also, have you even seen the settlers blocking aid at the border, and the IDF supporting them? The settlers themselves have said on camera the IDF is with them, locked the gates for them, gave them "watermelon and candy". They are having what amounts to tail gate parties on the border to block aid, which is a war crime of collective punishment, not to mention genocidal as it kills people to cut off food, water, fuel, etc. I see loads of people condemning Hamas, but then see people like stardaddy, above supporting genocide of children. The accused UNRWA of ties to Hamas without a shred of evidence, as punishment to the UN for finding they are committing a "plausible genocide" in Gaza. And the US spokespeople like John Kirby will defend the US immediate defunding of that aid org, while saying they can't hold Israel accountable for hunting down the WCK workers, because they need evidence before they act, that Israel shooting three separate trucks in succession (probably with weapons Biden gave them) as the workers tried to flee, was intentional. So, when it's an allegation against the UN for aid to Gaza, we don't need any evidence to punish them. When it's Israel, we need more evidence, while the reality is staring us in the face. Israel funded Hamas, ignored the intelligence that told them this was coming, even told their own scouts who reported the exercises to stop talking about it. They didn't care about their own citizens with what they knew was coming, what they helped to prop up, but now put on a performative show of concern about the plight of their hostages--some of whom the IDF killed on Oct 7, and also execution style in Gaza during operations. I actually do care about the hostages. I do want them to be safe. I don't think that means I, or anyone, has to be OK with the horrifying genocide we're seeing unfolding now against civilians in Gaza. Israeli statements from leadership show that they don't believe there are any innocent civilians in Gaza, even children. And comments like stardaddy's show they also believe it's OK to even slaughter children. This is who the US has always been. So, it's not really shocking to see it now.
She is a Shinning example of how Hamas treats Hostages compared to how Israel treats it's Hostages !
Almost every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They were treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
Putin playbook:
Option 1: Blame Chechens
Option 2: Blame Ukraine
Paranoic... la fel și Hamas, Iran, Liban... cam mulți...
Animals....and if people object to that word...too bad. If you dont behave as animals then people will not call you that.
Animals do not behave like that...animals behave..
Animals? I don't think so. How about a better description, such as DEMONS.
I presume you're referring to the Israeli occupation.
NOOOO!
That is NOT non- violent resistance!
What sort of person are you!
@@azalia423 No he is talking about how muhmmad is not a prophet there is no proof . This war proves muhmmad is not a prophet
Sorry to be unhopeful but most of those hostages are probably already dead. It's been too long, especially in those conditions.
I sadly, feel the same
@@isabellrc😢
I think as IDF has got so close to last stronghold they are getting rid of life ones n claim IDF did it .
Like the video made of three hostages with Mia n two men and say the world will know there fate tomorrow n tomorrow came n a new video comes showing dead bodies of two male hostages n they try to put it on IDF . Shortly after that one they made another one with a male hostage same message n next day n video of his dead body.
They know how important it is to get even just the bodies,even if we're killed on Oct 7,so I believe they are trying to eliminate as many possibile for when things come to whatever kind of end it will be n
The mentality of Palestinians is mindd blowing as they have to know hamas steals the aide,money , everything meant for them n IDf made it clear clear it's aide for the citizens,free side .They know Hamas uses them for human shields n shoots n kills many of Palestinians, yet they still praise them .I have no doubt it's so painful,raw n for the young woman n girls to openly to public share there live
I bet all the women are pregnant😢 they probably kept them alive sick cowards😢🙏🙏🇮🇱
Not really not your business to give up.They are clearly not your friends or family so it's not like your opinion matters to anyone....
Where is the rest of the interview?
Wonder Why more people don’t watch THIS!
Maybe they don`t wanna know the truth.
Thankyou Lord for Moran you are a present help in the time of need the Lord will not forsake his people Israel
NO
WINNERS
HERE !
they looked happy at the release time
From the river to the sea Israel will be free
Stop all aid.
stop all weapons to isreal. our congressmen are literally lobbied by aipac.
God helps you to heal your heart, body, and soul 🙏
Why aren't the same people demanding a ceasefire in Gaza not calling for a ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine?
They aren't comparable
Hamas is a terrorist group, Palestinians have been under Israeli control for years, they haven't had elections; they don't have a military, airport, etc. BiBi government documents show they gave money to ham as
@@zannrebel1217 Why should Israel stand down but not Ukraine?
@@lindaminton russia came to a peace deal but it would hurt ukraine's money laundering op
@@lindaminton Did I say Israel should stand down????
Almost every israeli hostage is saying the same thing. They were treated with respect and the women were honored by Hamas.
Bet it hates some people to hear they was treated well. Doesn’t fit their narrative.
How can u sleep at night, eww
Muhmmad is not a prophet there is no proof
Where do you get your info from? Tiktok?
@@migika nope, I don't use tiktok but obviously you do
@@Timtam88414 how can you?
Everybody finds these tales horrific beyond their minds ... yet its life for most Palestinians since 1948 .....wheres the justice and publicity fir them ....wheres the humanrights for them ... where are the lights , camera action moments of fame and glory ....😢😢....we live in a sick world ....😢
Im pretty sure you said in another interview it was hamas who caught you. Now you say it was arabs who caught you and then called hamas?
Араб=хамаз!!!!
@@Hhhh-xk8vk.1 meaning?
Either way it was Islam that did it . Muhmmad is a fake prophet . There is no proof he is a prophet
One and the same
@@Lesloi6227 so he's referring that all arabs or all Palestinians are hamas? Does he also mean the Christian arabs???????
6.6 million followers and 500 likes wonder how many dislikes that represent the truth
And why would you dislike this video?
' so unbelievably brave ' .... what about palestinians for last 75 years ... what about gazans who lived under siege their whole life .... your bias is disgusting
Every Palestinian is living a life of joy, according to MSNBC
They were certainly happy when they first brought the hostages in side.
😂
They did look ecstatic on the 7th of October
Palestinians have empowered and enabled HAMAS, self proclaimed genocidal terrorist organization, since 2006. Like the German people that enabled another genocidal monster back in the 1930's, Palestinians have nobody to blame for their suffering but themselves.
Palestinians empowered and enabled Hah Maaz. Like the German people that enabled Hitler, they have nobody to blame for their suffering but themselves.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Where is all the so called GBV Org especially here in South Africa where ANC backed an Muslim businessmen an women are so active promoting Palestinian flag's where they even got flags on their roofs an cars our MPs are even running aroun with Palestine scarves
Mika you’re lying and you know it 0:21 it did NOT!
And how would you know that? You were there? Denial doesnt make you right. Maybe you should look at who you are supporting
@@annasacio6720 and how do you know who I’m supporting. I’m supporting Biden IF HE DOES WHAT HIS CONSTITUENTS WANT. Maybe You shouldn’t judge??
@@annasacio6720 by the way you can read the resolution. So I do KNOW WHAT IT SAYS.
❤
Always gaslighting us.
😭😭😱😱😱😭😱😭
Hold on!Rapture of the church is soon. Just pray.
😂😂😂 really China and Russia who are they kidding
It's shameful how little NetanYahoo cares about what happens to the hostages. He appears to consider them collateral damage in his power pipedreams
Martyrs to justify genocide
You know that hamas doesn't take deals right? They want to stop the war so hamas keeps controlling gaza, 40 hostages for a thousand terrorists including a hundred with life sentences. What deal is that??? But offcourse its israels fault there is no deal
Is that why he agreed to a 3-to-1 exchange previously, and was recently willing to trade hundreds of convicts for 40 more hostages?
@@user-oz7hu3sb8l it was even about 800 prisoners for 40 hostages including 100 with life sentences.
Hamas only takes a deal where israel stops the war leaving hamas in power
@@user-oz7hu3sb8l Israel is released women and children in previous exchange. 6 year olds are not what I'd called convicts. Did you not know who exactly got released? I can bet at the time Israel was not saying
Oh Russia and China looooooooooool…..Israel must be so scared hahaha MENACHEM BEGIN said to UN, we are not Jews with weak knees
One lesson I learned is if you keep quiet while injustice happens to others,something may happen to you ,many israhell ‘s feel happy taking over plstinians houses,seeing kids being klld by their tax, and many other bad things but they see no problem with it, they feel happy when plstnians are kept in prison without trial,They can’t be no peace in that place unless all both pple have rights like humans,
They are also known as the Democrats of the Middle East.
Nun of this could happen under Trump. PRESIDENT TRUMP WOULD HAVE MADE WORLD PIECE BUY NOW!!!!!!!! MAGA MAGA ❤
Hmmm, I wonder if this is a fake foreign paid troll account?
@@nigeltufnel9525DO YA WONDER NOW!!!
@@MakeAmericaGayAgain. as a lifelong Democrat me and my wife's pregnant boyfriend will be encouraging my pangender daughter to vote for Joe Biden😊🎉😊💙🌀🫐
@@MakeAmericaGayAgain.Nope. Now I'm sure.
Trump's Delusional Sheeple are so clueless that they are unable to comprehend that *_THEY_* are one of the threats that America needs to be saved *_from._* Trump's Delusional Sheeple are demented enough to be unwitting domestic enemies of the United States they know too little of.
Who your'e lying to ?
Shame on you
Muhmmad lied , muhmmad is not a prophet
So, she admits to being a fashion victim.
Hamas wants soldiers because normally you go for soldiers when you claim you are freedomfighters. Soldiers are worth more money the plo pays the killers.
Turned out she wasn't a soldier but was wearing cloths that looked like a uniform.
Luckily for her she isn't, the other soldiers are all still held hostage
☮️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🕊🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🕉
You need more makeup on sir 🤡
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
I'm sorry she went thru that but maybe she should take it up with her government and her parents and grandparents who have been murdering Palestinians for decades.
As a Muslim I can tell you that your comment is one of the stupidest things I've ever read
Nobody's been murdering Palestinians for decades and they have built Their Own Prison and Egypt and Israel have their walls up because of these radicalized lunatics. They had a chance at a two-state solution in 1947 and 3X after that and still rejected it because they don't want their own state if the Jews get one. They need to get over it and move on and use the billions of dollars of international Aid to fix their own surroundings instead of terrorizing their neighbors
It was always the hostile Palestinians that provoked the people of israel to treat them strictly
There is NO "but". Once you use that word, you are justifying this horror and supporting it. Your need to build a narrative leads you to your disgusting blood libel accusing Israelis of "murdering Palestinians". So, no, they haven't, BUT even if they did - still no excuse or relevance.
You're wrong! I's the other way around.It's the Palestinians who had been bombming Israel and terrorizing the jews.
Palestinians are brave, they endure this for 75 Years.
Stop the Bad Hasbara, Free Palestine
bot
No palis 75 years ago. Try again
Fake news
Can see she a liar
There are thousands of Palestinian hostages...
You mean terrorists prisoners? Convicted? None of them is innocent
Hostages of Hamas
Is she the one that has now changed her story three times? That she was treated really well by Hamas and now her story has changed.
I noticed that two. She must be one of them LIBS!! MAGA MAGA ❤
Blame the victim? Disgusting and disgraceful.
Islamic lies again 😂😂😂
That was a different one, but yes i havent yet seen sny if those early released hostages say they were maltreated. For one thing they complaining about the food and water and their continued hatred for Palestinians overall is obvious. They haven't had any hardships in their lives, yet complaining about the little Palestinians have is being shared anyway.
Am Yisrael Chai Standing with Israel I love You O Israel
Great news 🎉🎉Trump says he has $500M in cash, and can easily pay the bond in New York AG case, slams 'hack' judge
Beware of False Prophets preaching Hate & Division. Monday, we will see if he is lying 😂😂😂
PRESIDENT TRUMP HAD HIS ELECTIONS STOLED FROM HIM!!!!!! MAGA MAGA ❤
Trump says? 😂
And his son in law and
ELON have offered a ton of money as well, WIN WIN for President Trump❤❤❤
Trump's Broke send Him your Kids Collage Fund.