How Austerity Left More Children Vulnerable To Abuse | Teresa Thornhill talks to Aaron Bastani

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 16. 05. 2024
  • Teresa Thornhill is an author and former child protection lawyer. Throughout her long career, working for both local authorities and advocating on behalf of parents, she has been a first hand witness to how the system fails parents, social workers and, most importantly, children.
    Teresa sat down with Aaron to talk about the untrained volunteers deciding children’s futures, whether drug policy matters, and how austerity will have costs for decades to come.
    You can buy Teresa’s book here: harpercollins.co.uk/products/...
    00:00 Intro
    02:19 What Exactly is ‘Child Protection’?
    07:35 What is a Child in Need?
    09:57 What Kind of Judges are Involved?
    14:40 What are the Main Causes of Child Neglect?
    18:50 What are the Costs?
    26:11 What Happens to Young Mothers Whose Children are Taken Away?
    31:19 Lack of Resources
    39:34 SureStart Centres
    42:42 How did Austerity Change Things?
    47:24 Social Work’s Intense Workload
    55:15 How do we Fix it?
    58:58 Finley Boden
    1:03:35 Management Problems
    1:11:49 Drug Policy
    1:16:12 Boarding Schools
    1:17:50 The Effects of Covid
    1:23:13 More Solutions
    Novara Live broadcasts every weekday from 6PM on CZcams and Twitch.
    Episodes of Downstream are released Sundays at 3PM on CZcams.
    __________________________
    Support our journalism by buying Novara Media merch:
    shop.novaramedia.com
    Donate one hour’s wage per month, or whatever you can afford:
    novara.media/support

Komentáře • 61

  • @missasherable
    @missasherable Před 18 dny +34

    I am a child protection social worker. The local authority I work for has a 40% vacancy rate and has been unable to perform there statutory duties. The level of poverty and mental crisis we are working with is immense. This includes families we work with but also staff. Social work as a profession is in crisis and there is no discussion about this in the public sphere.

  • @thomasdouglas2732
    @thomasdouglas2732 Před 18 dny +36

    Week after week Novara justify their subscription. Just outstanding. Having spent many years working with looked after children, youth offending services and then onwards to adult addiction and homelessness, I'm so glad that you've given the time to this important subject. It drives so much injustice and suffering in our society but is rarely mentioned.

  • @jay41234
    @jay41234 Před 18 dny +24

    I used to be a child protection social worker. The whole system is fraught with problems.
    Under staffed. I was supposed to carry a maximum of 16 cases, I never had less than 48!
    All cases are complex. It was rare for a child to name their abuser or even acknowledge that they were being abused.
    Child sex abuse perpetrated by a parent. I had one case where the father had sexually abused 7 of his children. The mother did not believe this until he confessed to her
    She talks about the background of JPs but a social worker's background can be crucial too. Families struggling do not want a social worker arriving in a flash car or speaking "down" to them.
    Children in care. Many schools refuse to accept these youngsters because they might be "disruptive" which can impact a school's rating.
    After 12 years of this work I was burnt out and had to retire through I'll health

  • @KapnScumdreg
    @KapnScumdreg Před 16 dny +8

    This interview is Novara's Downstream at its best: An in depth discussion on a particular subject with a specialist in the field.
    Very interesting and insightful.

  • @brianchapman8120
    @brianchapman8120 Před 18 dny +15

    I work in early intervention for the LA. Cuts to wellbeing and safeguarding services are ongoing. Funding grants are being cut (because the pandemic is over now. More complex cases are being passed down to lower levels, so dont even reach statutory services. We are support workers/advisors, not social workers and get families struggling with finances and benefits, housing, homelessness disability, mental health, antisocial behaviour, DV, criminality, school avoidance, bullying, young carers, parenting, childcare, family breakdown, child contact, SGO, legal. Lots of these cases wouldn't arise if there was proper funding for CAMHS, NDP, Youth Services, Housing, Education etc. In many cases its like sending someone the the pharmacy with a broken leg.

  • @victoriavelvet3689
    @victoriavelvet3689 Před 18 dny +22

    So glad this is being covered.

  • @0wishky0
    @0wishky0 Před 14 dny +4

    Thank you both so much for this outstanding interview.

  • @f0xylady100
    @f0xylady100 Před 17 dny +7

    This interview has been great for me. Sometimes I think I hate my job and feel hard done by. Hearing what conditions these social workers have been working under gives a lot of perspective.

  • @johnmckiernan2176
    @johnmckiernan2176 Před 11 dny +1

    Marvellous piece of journalism. As a teacher, this topic is close to my heart, and I leave this video more ready to do my job than I was before I watched it. What more could one ask?

  • @Nomoreanons
    @Nomoreanons Před 18 dny +8

    You know Aaron is serious when he busts out the navy jacket.

  • @azami123
    @azami123 Před 18 dny +8

    Excellent downstream dealing with important issues that need to be talked about. Practicalities are always interesting.

  • @user-io7yk7qb1k
    @user-io7yk7qb1k Před 18 dny +9

    Most single mothers have been married and are separated or divorced - it hasn’t been a choice to raise children as a single parent outside a family unit.
    This is a very good interview tackling issues rarely publicly addressed.
    Thank you.

    • @mtrhodesy
      @mtrhodesy Před 15 dny

      How do you know it wasn't a choice to be a single parent? Or are all single mothers forced to become separated or divorced against their wishes? As most divorces are, by some margin instigated by women, aren't they indeed able to have a choice?

  • @ZadiesLIVE
    @ZadiesLIVE Před 18 dny +8

    Novara Media, I loved this video so much, I had to hit the like button!

  • @ZhTra
    @ZhTra Před 17 dny +3

    Amazing interview!!!

  • @kayleyedwards7141
    @kayleyedwards7141 Před 18 dny +5

    Excellent conversation.

  • @abdurrahmansiddique171
    @abdurrahmansiddique171 Před 16 dny +4

    I always hated the idea of boarding school; it just baffled me why anybody would want to send the kids away when we have perfectly good state schools that can produce straight A students.

  • @monoczento
    @monoczento Před 18 dny +6

    Hello from Poland.

  • @aminawood1737
    @aminawood1737 Před 18 dny +2

    So good

  • @ellenrebeccadavies2246
    @ellenrebeccadavies2246 Před 17 dny +1

    Very interesting and great question Aaron xx

  • @aflafkhan1735
    @aflafkhan1735 Před 19 dny +14

    Blame the war and western world for all that

  • @user-oblomov
    @user-oblomov Před 19 dny +11

    Free the world from Psychopaths!

  • @naderzekrya5238
    @naderzekrya5238 Před 18 dny +8

    As a translator in public services, I see some child social workers similar to traffic wardens

  • @EamonCoyle
    @EamonCoyle Před 18 dny +8

    I worked as a youth worker for about ten years and my thoughts on child protection would be that the people taking the training seriously are the ones to watch because on a basic level you should know what "protecting" a child means !!

  • @lydiafwilliams
    @lydiafwilliams Před 18 dny +8

    Sounds like working in the education system. 😢

  • @susanmercurio1060
    @susanmercurio1060 Před 18 dny +6

    I learned Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) a long time ago and they discuss austerity.

    • @Ocinneade345
      @Ocinneade345 Před 18 dny

      I’m sad , even though I don’t totally subscribe to it as a separate theory, has been swept under the rug as non-functional. It was never in place, anyway.

    • @darrylbradshaw216
      @darrylbradshaw216 Před 17 dny

      It's a method not a theory, mis-named ​@@Ocinneade345

    • @zakpullen8113
      @zakpullen8113 Před 16 dny +1

      ​@Ocinneade345 it's an explanatory framework that works well. It's definitely making inroads in the US.

    • @susanmercurio1060
      @susanmercurio1060 Před 16 dny

      ​@@Ocinneade345MMT is a factual description of the monetary system we already have in the US.
      It's not something you "put in place."
      You display your total lack of knowledge about what MMT is with your reply.

    • @susanmercurio1060
      @susanmercurio1060 Před 16 dny

      ​@@zakpullen8113I don't know what you mean by "making inroads" in the US, because it's an empirical description of the monetary system that is in place.
      Perhaps you mean that the concept of studying the actual process is becoming more accepted in the US?
      Thanks for the support, anyway!

  • @derekwhite2929
    @derekwhite2929 Před 18 dny +2

    Not just children left open to being abused!

  • @Holismleith
    @Holismleith Před 18 dny +4

    Ok I like her - drug banter worried me a bit but she is right about schools they are designed to torture kids…. Oh ok.

  • @tomg268
    @tomg268 Před 18 dny +2

    “I’m not Peter Hitchens” - come now, Aaron, we’ve all seen the pictures

  • @svodcat7524
    @svodcat7524 Před 2 dny

    Why did this video do not so great numbers? Sincerely a bit sad about that.
    I notice it's never been recommended to me I found it on the NM page. Was it algorithm suppressed for whatever reason?

  • @chriswalker7632
    @chriswalker7632 Před 17 dny +1

    Mothers in Arms

  • @LimeyRedneck
    @LimeyRedneck Před 9 dny

    🤠💜

  • @dianecorbin8886
    @dianecorbin8886 Před 18 dny +1

    Give the power back to parents.

  • @jblazer2492
    @jblazer2492 Před 16 dny +1

    People, stop having kids, what tf is wrong with you?

  • @danielbutler760
    @danielbutler760 Před 19 dny +2

    I say fuck that too 🙂

  • @NoWindNoSunNoPower
    @NoWindNoSunNoPower Před 18 dny +2

    The safety of Britain’s children falls daily by the dinghy load.

  • @dayeah765caoni3
    @dayeah765caoni3 Před 17 dny

    It’s a losing battle from the get-go. Welfare is just a way to appease the poor from uprising

  • @CHIEF_420
    @CHIEF_420 Před 17 dny

    @TuSimple 🤝 @shell