Red card was right. Although the guy did make a meal of it the laws state under the law 12 fouls and misconduct that "ANY physical or aggressive behaviour (spitting, biting, pushing, striking out) is a straight red. I agree footballers should not dive like that but the laws the law and referee has to carry them out. So stop giving grieve to the officials as without them you won't be able to play football.
It doesn't matter, he doesn't have to have a life threatening injury, the level of damage caused is irrelevant it's the action of the offending player that is important.
As an referee (UK, not US), my view point is 1. Sending off. Entirely appropriate. Opponent baited him, but that's not an offense. You are not allowed to hit, or lay hands on someone else. If you do - there's only one punishment. Ref was entirely correct in this decision. 2. While I would have handled the red card differently (I always separate the player away from everyone else. I explain my decision, then issue any cards - removes possibility for confrontation and allows Adrenalin from incidents to subside a bit), she's entirely justified to just show the red card as she did. 3. She loses control of the players. After the incident, she starts to get surrounded. At this point, she tries to back away - but the crowd moves with her. For me, this would not happen. In the pre-match session, Referees set out how they will referee the game. I always told the players that if I signal you to move away from me, you have 3 seconds to be gone or you will get a yellow - and I always followed through on that (once players see you do it once, they don't do it again). Also, the player with the red card - I'd have explained that if he refuses to leave the pitch, that the game will be forfeited with his team carrying the blame (normally means that team forfeits the game, gets a points penalty, often financial fine). As you can imagine, all teams hate this so captains/managers usually get that player off ASAP. 4. When the red carded player starts walking off, then decides he wants to have more "words" with one of the players - this is absolutely unacceptable. When a referee issues any kind of card, we have to fill in a form detailing what we did, and why. (It's actually a reason that I hated having to issue cards). This incident should have been added to the report. So, what was a standard red card offense (leagues have a pre-listed penalty for red cards, often a 1/2 game ban and a fine) would now be escalated. 5. At 01:48 - we don't see what happens afterwards, but we do see the player in white still on the pitch later in the game. That's, absolutely, a red card offense. Is the player in black holding up the game, by holding onto the ball? - yes. Do the players in white want to play the ball quickly, and is he impeding that? - yes. Is it the player in white's job to impose his own justice here? - Absolutely not. If the referee thought the player was illegal holding up the game, it's her job to decide on a punishment - not his.
Viktor K and Jason Woodward. As armchair supporters, you seem to believe that "he hardly touched him" is some kind of defense. According to the rules - I'm afraid it's not. How much force was appropriate here? He wasn't impeded by the dark strip player, the dark strip player was not going near him in any kind of a threatening manner. No, he merely wanted to hit him, which he did. Red card. If you'd like to point me to the section of the rules that shows that this kind of action was appropriate, then I'd concede the point. However, I'm required to study the rules every year - and I know the rules (and specifically, the expansion of that section, for clarification, that has been made over the past few years) and I know you won't find anything that backs up your case. You'll find full details under Law 12, if you want to look.
The first player sent off. I would have red carded him again for dissent, makes no difference to the game but would have extended his ban. The player with white hair, should have walked as well, it looks like the ref allowed herself to be intimidated.
Hey bro, I’m a rugby referee and sometimes I wonder if it would be a good idea to trade referees one weekend a season. Just to teach football players how to respect officials.
The players from both sides are the ones totally in the wrong here. Intimidating the referee and cheating in an attempt to get more cards shown. And some people have the temerity to call it the beautiful game.
Firstly as a referee assessor videos like this are good teaching tools. Firstly the red card was correct. Regardless of the conduct of another player, the second you place your hands on another player and push with that amount of force it becomes violent conduct and therefore a red card. This wasn't just a little push, the blokes legs nearly hit him in the head. Secondly the confrontation is a learning opportunity. The referee must control that better. I find by getting the yellow card out and holding it by the side of the referee and if players start approaching say things like "if you come any closer you will be cautioned", if they step closer they are shown the yellow card. Next person is then warned that they will be next. It might take one or two but it will stop.
Agreed. I am a third year referee still trying to get better every day and I have realized too that needing to control the "crowd" once you make a controversial call is just as important. But then again, even when you start doing that, and heavens forbid, you give a card for reactions to your initial card, all of the sudden you are "making the game all about you." (eye roll)
I remember that video where ref brings gun to deal with players who were trying to assault the ref. These players need to be dealt by someone like that.
The ref was not incompetent, red was a no brainer. The players were fools, they behaved like entitled brats. She could have yellowed another 3 or 4 at least. If players show no respect they deserve none.
Would be interested to know where all these clowns are today. Starbucks, living on their sisters couch. Y'know, it's a game, have fun. Two hand push, maybe red but you have to set the tone. The judo throw later probably should have been one too. And then following through with every kick - c'mon. For a bunch of guys that are going to end up needing real jobs someday, lighten up.
Stupid announcer didn't see the dude get ejected for pushing his opponent to the ground. It was the right call by the referee. She had no way to control the stupid few players who lost control and did the right thing by ending the game and no extra minutes.
If you know football you’d know that pushing someone isn’t a red card. The incident at 1:50 where the player throws the opponent is a red card offence but the ref gave nothing.
@@RovingCanada you idiot. The Referee is commonly known as the centre referee, to distinguish from an AR in certain situations (ex. if someone says I am the center ref for this game vs I am simply refereeing this game, which could mean ar also)
@@brandonl4914 I've never heard of anyone being called the centre referee. The announcer should say "the officials" or similar nor "the referees" as there i s only one.
Hard to argue the straight red to the center back. Hate to see embellishment - but the hard shove warranted the RC. The referee did seem to struggle to regain some measure of fair play afterwards - at least based on the video selection provided. No stoppage time? I suppose that's one way of stopping the ridiculously reckless play that both teams seemed to want to employ.
No, you get the captains of each teams separate to all other players, tell them to control their players and any more complaining or abuse to the referee will warrant a yellow.
I just dont see how women can be officials in the men's game. they dont seem to respect the men referees, and you can see in the clip they respect the woman official even less than the regular male official. What happens when a punch is thrown? She also didn't seem to know what to do in many situations.
Easy to see referee was out of her depth here, but hopefully this was picked up post-match and she was given feedback on where to improve. Definitely had very little authority on the match.
I like the way the commentator suggests three match officials should 'get control' of 22 players many of whom seem intent on losing control of their own composure.
Try never to show a red card in front of so many players on both teams. Wait just a bit longer, pull player aside, probably with captain, serve, and send off. No debate, no talking. Going after referee like that is embarrassing.
easy red card any day of the week. Could have been handled better, i personally pull the player away from everyone before i give whatever card i need to. It takes the adrenaline out a bit, and i have more time to think of my decision, which i explain to them. this also gives them no means of arguing as i quote the law. She loses control quickly and that isn't necessarily on her, but the idiots who kept circling around her and crowding her, more cards should have been used. In my pre game speech i have to the captains when i'm reffing NPL, NewFM or anything else where i have a game off before my center, one of my main instructions i tell them is "If you or your team has a problem with my decision, you and ONLY you are to come to me, ask me respectfully and i'll give you the answer, quote the law, give you my view and reasoning. If you come to me disrespectfully I will send you away, or card you. Remember, when me make our decisions, we need to take all emotion and discuss the considerations. If you feel you need to speak to me more about it, come to me at half time or full time and i'll give you an in depth knowledge on the law" at 1:48 I have no idea why that white player didn't get sent as well, yes he was trying to get the ball, but the way he did it was excessive, and as per the laws excessive force= red. yes the other player was holding up the ball, and delaying the restart of play. Thats a straight yellow, if you want to argue that, you really need a law book, it is literally a code in itself. I'm an aussie ref, not US or UK or anything like that. It's clear that she didn't have the best game, but from this video, it doesnt look like she had much of a chance
Simply one of the worst exhibitions of refereeing ever. The atrocious dive that caused it in the first place should have been a yellow against the side in black. The cynical diving and cheating so well exemplified by the team in Black is a canker in the game today.
You have strong opinions, but use the wrong terminology. That is not a dive! You can say it is simulation, as he exaggerates his fall, but that is up to the referee to decide and you can't see it from her angle. I would say she should have shown yellow, rather than red here, but he risks a red by pushing.
One of the most incompotent officials I have ever seen. Lost complete control of the situations. Why the other player in white wasn't dismissed for throwing a player to the ground is beyond me?!! She didn't even react and try to calm the situation down....USELESS!!
this what happen when man have problem with authoirty has nothing to do with women other than men thinking they can bully and srounded her to chang her rulining
So, @Npn Smith, are you saying the player wasn't pushed? Whether the player who was pushed made a meal of it, id=f his opponent pushed him - straight red is not only appropriate, it is exemplary. Good for the ref.
Push: Red Card
Body Slam: Nothing
Not sure the ref was up to this.
instablaster.
Push should’ve been yellow and the slam red
@@parkerchristie7064^^
Red card was right. Although the guy did make a meal of it the laws state under the law 12 fouls and misconduct that "ANY physical or aggressive behaviour (spitting, biting, pushing, striking out) is a straight red. I agree footballers should not dive like that but the laws the law and referee has to carry them out. So stop giving grieve to the officials as without them you won't be able to play football.
By the book yes red card but I feel it could have been handled better. I think a yellow would have done the job but im fine with the red aswell.
@@2hjhuiui referees are only able to go by the book…
This is what happens when you have an Entire Country THAT Doesn't understand Football!!
Gross generalizations are dangerous
john Baldock do you mean soccer not football
@@HenryTDBaroliKingbaroli-kx9oh in europe it is football
Actually everywhere other than America, Canada, and Australia. American egg ball is a fake sport, knock off of rugby
@@HenryTDBaroliKingbaroli-kx9oh Football IS soccer. Amerian football is not.
Wow thats high-definition video quality right there, and at night too, what camera was used for this??
panasonic AC 160A
The guy gets up as soon as the red card is shown.
It's called a drama queen :o)
It doesn't matter, he doesn't have to have a life threatening injury, the level of damage caused is irrelevant it's the action of the offending player that is important.
Still a red
@@terencekreft482 Not really.. the player who dived made it look more vicious then it actually was.
@@terencekreft482 Correct. Dismissal was the right decision.
It's called 'violent misconduct' and it includes pushing a player (if you did that on the street it's called 'common assault').
No it’s called a flop
Adam Gokel even if it was a flop that’s a straight up push, even if he didn’t fall I would call a red.
To upper class bitches it’s ‘conman assault’ to everyone else it’s a disrespectful challenge for a fight
@@adamgokel6746 Violent conduct and a red card.
Ref saw one red card, but body slam was red card too. Ref has no balls.
As an referee (UK, not US), my view point is
1. Sending off. Entirely appropriate. Opponent baited him, but that's not an offense. You are not allowed to hit, or lay hands on someone else. If you do - there's only one punishment. Ref was entirely correct in this decision.
2. While I would have handled the red card differently (I always separate the player away from everyone else. I explain my decision, then issue any cards - removes possibility for confrontation and allows Adrenalin from incidents to subside a bit), she's entirely justified to just show the red card as she did.
3. She loses control of the players. After the incident, she starts to get surrounded. At this point, she tries to back away - but the crowd moves with her. For me, this would not happen. In the pre-match session, Referees set out how they will referee the game. I always told the players that if I signal you to move away from me, you have 3 seconds to be gone or you will get a yellow - and I always followed through on that (once players see you do it once, they don't do it again). Also, the player with the red card - I'd have explained that if he refuses to leave the pitch, that the game will be forfeited with his team carrying the blame (normally means that team forfeits the game, gets a points penalty, often financial fine). As you can imagine, all teams hate this so captains/managers usually get that player off ASAP.
4. When the red carded player starts walking off, then decides he wants to have more "words" with one of the players - this is absolutely unacceptable. When a referee issues any kind of card, we have to fill in a form detailing what we did, and why. (It's actually a reason that I hated having to issue cards). This incident should have been added to the report. So, what was a standard red card offense (leagues have a pre-listed penalty for red cards, often a 1/2 game ban and a fine) would now be escalated.
5. At 01:48 - we don't see what happens afterwards, but we do see the player in white still on the pitch later in the game. That's, absolutely, a red card offense. Is the player in black holding up the game, by holding onto the ball? - yes. Do the players in white want to play the ball quickly, and is he impeding that? - yes. Is it the player in white's job to impose his own justice here? - Absolutely not. If the referee thought the player was illegal holding up the game, it's her job to decide on a punishment - not his.
Red card for a push which wasn't in the face??? Damn, i'd hate to watch a game with you reffing. It'd end up abandoned every time
Yeah it's a violent offense red card right and yes isolation would be the best option also she should never have backed away
Ken Savage the push is a simple yellow. No excessive force in anyway. Unsporting behaviour, nothing more.
Viktor K and Jason Woodward. As armchair supporters, you seem to believe that "he hardly touched him" is some kind of defense. According to the rules - I'm afraid it's not.
How much force was appropriate here? He wasn't impeded by the dark strip player, the dark strip player was not going near him in any kind of a threatening manner. No, he merely wanted to hit him, which he did. Red card.
If you'd like to point me to the section of the rules that shows that this kind of action was appropriate, then I'd concede the point. However, I'm required to study the rules every year - and I know the rules (and specifically, the expansion of that section, for clarification, that has been made over the past few years) and I know you won't find anything that backs up your case. You'll find full details under Law 12, if you want to look.
@@kensavage7657 your right it was excessive force send off offense violent misconduct or serious foul play
How does Woodstock not get a red card for that?
if that ref was his woman she'd be sporting a black eye, poor impulse control again
I love how she gave the arguing coach a red card at the end. My kind of woman.....takes no shite.
Nice black long sleeve shirt, player in all white.
Good eye!!!
What a dive !
Retaliation is caught 99% of the time and the offender normally is carded…not fair that only one gets a card but a foul is a foul
The first player sent off.
I would have red carded him again for dissent, makes no difference to the game but would have extended his ban.
The player with white hair, should have walked as well, it looks like the ref allowed herself to be intimidated.
Dissent is a cautionable offence, yellow card.
Savages in the park
Weak referee.
Garcia needs a good length ban.
I like the relationship the rugby referee has with the players.
Abubakar Douglas true but she was right about the red card😉
Hey bro, I’m a rugby referee and sometimes I wonder if it would be a good idea to trade referees one weekend a season. Just to teach football players how to respect officials.
The players from both sides are the ones totally in the wrong here. Intimidating the referee and cheating in an attempt to get more cards shown. And some people have the temerity to call it the beautiful game.
0:31 i swear ive seen something that looks like this somewhere else on the internet....
Player 17 = Yellow Card/"film an injury", and again a Yellow card for stopping the play with hands.
ref did her job , game control is the key. she was very good in giving cards. try being in her shoes.
Firstly as a referee assessor videos like this are good teaching tools. Firstly the red card was correct. Regardless of the conduct of another player, the second you place your hands on another player and push with that amount of force it becomes violent conduct and therefore a red card. This wasn't just a little push, the blokes legs nearly hit him in the head. Secondly the confrontation is a learning opportunity. The referee must control that better. I find by getting the yellow card out and holding it by the side of the referee and if players start approaching say things like "if you come any closer you will be cautioned", if they step closer they are shown the yellow card. Next person is then warned that they will be next. It might take one or two but it will stop.
Agreed. I am a third year referee still trying to get better every day and I have realized too that needing to control the "crowd" once you make a controversial call is just as important. But then again, even when you start doing that, and heavens forbid, you give a card for reactions to your initial card, all of the sudden you are "making the game all about you." (eye roll)
I remember that video where ref brings gun to deal with players who were trying to assault the ref. These players need to be dealt by someone like that.
#4 is the wife beater on the team.
The whit guy should of got a red aswell might I add 😂
Crimininals in white pyjamas?
Referee is to for from the play to have a good presence for the players. That first red card would have been avoided if she was on top of the play.
Refs don't need to be right where the action happens as that could literally be anywhere on the field. Clearly you've never played or watched before.
The guy in the white with that funky hair, no manager should allow a player with that hairstyle on their team full stop😂
Barber: what style will it be today
Player: i wanna look like extra large mcdonald’s fries
Barber: i got you fam
The ref was not incompetent, red was a no brainer. The players were fools, they behaved like entitled brats. She could have yellowed another 3 or 4 at least. If players show no respect they deserve none.
Yes he shouldn’t have pushed him, but man did a half Neymar show. Dude flopped down when he got pushed
A soccer player taking a dive? Heavens! You never see that at a soccer game. What a stupid sport
Would be interested to know where all these clowns are today. Starbucks, living on their sisters couch. Y'know, it's a game, have fun. Two hand push, maybe red but you have to set the tone. The judo throw later probably should have been one too. And then following through with every kick - c'mon. For a bunch of guys that are going to end up needing real jobs someday, lighten up.
yellow card for diving
If anything maybe a yellow... not a red. Ref clearly couldn't see the dive. She must've thought he actually punched the player in the face.
Give them all red cards, where is the coach?
Or how about the adults behave like adults and suck it up like an adult they are suppose to be as an adult
Fucking shameful game on both teams, but especially the one who dived and got up quickly as soon as he sees the red card.
Typical soccer players! Dive to the ground at the slightest chance for a penalty. CHEATS!
"slightest chance for a penalty"? you need to be in the box for a penalty. That comment shows how relevant your opinion is when it comes to the sport.
An opponent has to be in the 18 yard area for a penalty to be awarded for a foul.
Stupid announcer didn't see the dude get ejected for pushing his opponent to the ground. It was the right call by the referee. She had no way to control the stupid few players who lost control and did the right thing by ending the game and no extra minutes.
If you know football you’d know that pushing someone isn’t a red card. The incident at 1:50 where the player throws the opponent is a red card offence but the ref gave nothing.
@@webeatthehouse4679 wrong you lay your hands on somebody you gone
watching the center referee it looks like the she didn't give a shit about anything or she had no idea how to control the situations.
"Centre referee" ????
There is a ref.
2 assistant refs.
A 4th official.
The Fuck is a centre ref???
@@RovingCanada you idiot. The Referee is commonly known as the centre referee, to distinguish from an AR in certain situations (ex. if someone says I am the center ref for this game vs I am simply refereeing this game, which could mean ar also)
@@brandonl4914 no it doesn’t
@@brandonl4914 I've never heard of anyone being called the centre referee. The announcer should say "the officials" or similar nor "the referees" as there i s only one.
Men why doing this ? its match.
I bet on this 🤒
Soft red.
That lady ref has ovaries of steel for booking these guys like this, so cold
ref was absolutely right to send off Garcia
there you go, thats why I stopped playing the game, to much showboating, the refs need to start punishing the actors it destroys the game
Soccer players, no better thespians/actors in all of sport!
Folks clearly this is violent conduct referee made the correct decision
Hard to argue the straight red to the center back. Hate to see embellishment - but the hard shove warranted the RC. The referee did seem to struggle to regain some measure of fair play afterwards - at least based on the video selection provided. No stoppage time? I suppose that's one way of stopping the ridiculously reckless play that both teams seemed to want to employ.
No, you get the captains of each teams separate to all other players, tell them to control their players and any more complaining or abuse to the referee will warrant a yellow.
But the player in White made a Neymar-esque dive I'm not sure it have been a red card if he did. I'd have given a yellow.
Should've been a yellow for both
Don't see rugby players arguing with referees, why should soccer players think it's ok for them to do it?
Undisciplined children can't keep their hands to themselves. Grow up.
Inexperienced ref taken advantage of - it’s the diver who should have seen red for me.
Hi
hey
Hola
American footy is fucking hilarious 😂 we see more fights and challenges in Liverpool U12's!!!
WHO SAID "GET OUT YOU ANIMAL!" !?!?!?!?!??? got me triggered rrrr...
I love all the “American” bashing but this is USL ( league below MLS) over 3/4 of these players are foreign. PS you don’t own the worlds game.
Wait usl is professional right? So these idiots are actually getting paid?
great actors though.
I see how soccer is quickly becoming a "hood sport" more than other ballgames
Your white aren’t you lol
That was not a straight red at all
Learn the rules of football and then come back and comment, you obviously a yank
I must have missed violent conduct being removed the rules.
America + Football = Joke
Stan Lucky clearly you havent seen IST which is canadian. The officiating is pathetic
lol, because soccer players in other countries never dive and act like crybabies...
Some great flops by the team in black.
America leave our game alone you'll never get it❤️⚽🏴
I just dont see how women can be officials in the men's game. they dont seem to respect the men referees, and you can see in the clip they respect the woman official even less than the regular male official. What happens when a punch is thrown? She also didn't seem to know what to do in many situations.
Easy to see referee was out of her depth here, but hopefully this was picked up post-match and she was given feedback on where to improve. Definitely had very little authority on the match.
I like the way the commentator suggests three match officials should 'get control' of 22 players many of whom seem intent on losing control of their own composure.
Try never to show a red card in front of so many players on both teams. Wait just a bit longer, pull player aside, probably with captain, serve, and send off. No debate, no talking. Going after referee like that is embarrassing.
Not always true. Plenty of VC/SFP situations where the red needs to be shown immediately to avoid further incidents.
easy red card any day of the week. Could have been handled better, i personally pull the player away from everyone before i give whatever card i need to. It takes the adrenaline out a bit, and i have more time to think of my decision, which i explain to them. this also gives them no means of arguing as i quote the law.
She loses control quickly and that isn't necessarily on her, but the idiots who kept circling around her and crowding her, more cards should have been used. In my pre game speech i have to the captains when i'm reffing NPL, NewFM or anything else where i have a game off before my center, one of my main instructions i tell them is "If you or your team has a problem with my decision, you and ONLY you are to come to me, ask me respectfully and i'll give you the answer, quote the law, give you my view and reasoning. If you come to me disrespectfully I will send you away, or card you. Remember, when me make our decisions, we need to take all emotion and discuss the considerations. If you feel you need to speak to me more about it, come to me at half time or full time and i'll give you an in depth knowledge on the law"
at 1:48 I have no idea why that white player didn't get sent as well, yes he was trying to get the ball, but the way he did it was excessive, and as per the laws excessive force= red.
yes the other player was holding up the ball, and delaying the restart of play. Thats a straight yellow, if you want to argue that, you really need a law book, it is literally a code in itself.
I'm an aussie ref, not US or UK or anything like that. It's clear that she didn't have the best game, but from this video, it doesnt look like she had much of a chance
Yes England is better
Girl ref. Understandable
why are all soccer players overdramatic
Yanks should stick to playing anything except Association FOOTBALL
That lady has no business as a ref.
How tf is that a red card Americans r clueless😂
About as clueless as you apparently
It appears that FIFA Laws of the Game are a mysterious dark art in some parts - that's a red card 24/7/365.
That's never a red
Dramatic acting. WOmen's futbal doesn't get this dramatic. Sup men?
THE REFEREE IS AS USEFUL AS A USED TAMPON WITH NO STRING.
Simply one of the worst exhibitions of refereeing ever. The atrocious dive that caused it in the first place should have been a yellow against the side in black. The cynical diving and cheating so well exemplified by the team in Black is a canker in the game today.
You're not allowed to push someone like that....
You have strong opinions, but use the wrong terminology. That is not a dive! You can say it is simulation, as he exaggerates his fall, but that is up to the referee to decide and you can't see it from her angle. I would say she should have shown yellow, rather than red here, but he risks a red by pushing.
One of the most incompotent officials I have ever seen. Lost complete control of the situations. Why the other player in white wasn't dismissed for throwing a player to the ground is beyond me?!! She didn't even react and try to calm the situation down....USELESS!!
female refs..no thanks.
Snowflakes
This is what happens when girls referee
this what happen when man have problem with authoirty has nothing to do with women other than men thinking they can bully and srounded her to chang her rulining
LOL...zero control of the game. Weak referee
She reacted WAYY to quickly! She should have taken her time before making that decision but oh well what do you expect from a female referee
Why are Americans so bad at football?
Adrian Ultras who said that all the players were american? They could he from other countries but live in the US
Soccer sucks
I have a question - Why is this woman refereeing a man's game, when these poor Hard working men are going to need sandwiches after?
Joke referee......hopefully they are no longer refereeing any football matches anywhere!
So, @Npn Smith, are you saying the player wasn't pushed? Whether the player who was pushed made a meal of it, id=f his opponent pushed him - straight red is not only appropriate, it is exemplary. Good for the ref.
Female referees...a JOKE!
Weak refereeing
Your "soccer" is so soft
Flopping. Soccer sucks