Myths of WWII Panel
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 04. 2017
- Bat bombs. Pearl Harbor. The Red Army. Come learn about myths involving these subjects and more when the Marshall Foundation hosts a panel of three distinguished World War II historians.
Panelists
Dr. Michael C. C. Adams, Regents Professor of History Emeritus at Northern Kentucky University and author of The Best War Ever, will analyze the triumph of the Good War myth in the last years of the twentieth century, its consequences, and then ebb after 9/11.
Dr. Conrad C. Crane, Chief of Historical Services for the Army Heritage and Education Center at Carlisle Barracks, will discuss numerous myths of the air war, the dangers of monocausal explanations about the defeat of Japan, and the misuse of historical analogies.
Dr. Mark A. Stoler, Professor Emeritus of History at the University of Vermont and editor of volumes 6 and 7 of The Papers of George Catlett Marshall, will explore myths about prewar appeasement and U.S. “isolationism,” Pearl Harbor and U.S. entry into the war, the Grand Alliance and the Anglo-American “Special Relationship,” the American role in defeating the Axis Powers, and the impact of these myths on postwar U.S. foreign and military policies.
my right ear is informed
Speakers start at 9:00. Sound is only on the right channel.
First time I've heard the war of 1812 described as an overwhelming victory for the USA
Fraser Fleming
That's the American version of history. You know like they won WW1 and WW2 all by themselves and everyone in the world should be grateful to them.
G. C. Marshall is the MOST UNDERESTIMATED PERSONAGE IN US HISTORY.
Myths are created by nostalgia that never existed to make us feel better about the present. Very good presentation. Tour de Force.
Outstanding introductory speech with a quote bearing a reminder and warning that should always be a centre focus and corrective to future policy considerations. Thank you very much for sharing a multitude of interesting lectures on your channel!
The 2nd speaker just rambles on about his political views on current events vs. the topic. I thought this was " Myths of WW II"
Memory is the greatest of all liars. Especially when it comes to wars. We idealize it and under-emphasize the harsh realities that are all too stark especially to those on the front lines. Yet we insist on having our heroes and gloss over it.
P.I.M.E. Post incident memory enhancement
While I agree that there was a deliberate mindset in place set to leave the Germans and Russians in a bloody attritional stale-mate (or so they hoped), is it safe to assume that an invasion of Normandy would have succeeded had it been slated for 42 or 43? I am not so sure one way or the other but it is not easy to keep out of mind the disastrous Dieppe raid. That said, and as an aside, if one truly wants to understand the Second World War then one should look towards the two Civil Wars which bookended both Europe and the conflict itself. EDIT: Did Brokaw really say that 9/11 would produce a second "Greatest Generation"? Oh, but who raised those of the 'first'? It was the Lost Generation. Behind every "Great Generation" is one that was victimized and stymied and traumatized and used, and so when they inherit the world they either lose themselves completely to that madness or they raise their children in a way which they hope would save them from what they had to go through themselves.
Aid to UK certainly not free of charge
Excellent discussions by each and the best I believe was the 2nd Speaker discussing the Iraq war and lack of cultural mobilization compared to World War II, almost all the burden fall upon our professional soldiers and not upon the nation. I greatly appreciate that part and his discussion of private military companies...he is absolutely correct in explaining that such did not mobilze our people to go to war against terrorism.
Good video. I disagree with some of what was said, but for the most part these speakers provided great information. Thanks for sharing. :)
Very interesting discussion. Thanks for sharing.
Thanks - Obrigado.
Brilliantly produced and informative talks, thank you.
If you love History you will love this video. I did.
very good
Second lecturer starting from 40:00 is super boring. 1:09:30 Whataboutism by a professor I cant believe it.
thanks
With so much disagreement on WWII, has any scholar surveyed the field and tried to bring clarity to all that has been written previously? The scholarship seems to be sprawling a bit. There are books written about the interviews done with German generals after the war. Recently, I have read that they lied in most of what they said.
Excellent panel, thank you for posting
I think Americans were key to the outcome of WWII and after the war, mainly the rebuild and democratization of Western Europe...
Very interesting
Recommend World War 2 history Round Table
Thanks, interesting
Great job.
Dr. Stoler had relatively poor arguments on Soviet vs US losses. Own military losses doesn't proof exactly with same rate of war effort. In fact there are lots of reasons to claim that American warfare was ten times more effective than that of Stalin. Which power decimated more Luftwaffe: RAF, Soviet VVS or USAAF? Clear answer: USAAF. It destroyed 80% of German aviation fuel production. Besides 76%of Luftwaffe combat losses were in war against RAF/USAAF.
Agreed. Whenever people (rightly) mention the tremendous efforts of the soviets on the eastern front, they seem to forget about what the 8th air force made possible for all ground forces. It's staggering to think of 26,000 men lost in air combat.
Stalin and his henchmen added much of the gulag and Ukraine forced collectivization fatalities into the ww2 KIA's much better PR to die in battle or starve to death in a fallow field or Soviet prison
Provocative and informative May the US continue to live up to the Blood, Treasure and Human sacrifice of Our Wars....
I get no sound in this video.
Long dull water swigging into
In any war we become the enemy we attempt to defeat
This was history mixed with a great deal of personal political views. Very disappointing. Thank goodness I never had one of these speakers as a history professor.
I was in Dresden of the DDR in 1975 and it looked ok :)
Man I absolutely hat the second speaker. What an apologist/anti-American whiny presentation. Wow, he can't remember Kuwait.
Wow.. he made the largest strawman I have seen in a great while to knock down.
Introduced many myths. Not worth listening to
WW2 was more or less won by Russians alone. Rest played lip service...