COURTROOM INSIDER | Data, DNA and Emma Murray's testimony?
Vložit
- čas přidán 21. 05. 2024
- Tonight on 'Courtroom Insider,' the defense is prepared to rest after experts testify about data and DNA. Plus some questions about Emma Murray's testimony. Tune in!
Let us know if you have questions and where you are watching from.
The fact that Chad turned off his phone to avoid being tracked but didn’t tell Alex to do the same makes me think they always meant to pin it on Alex.
Also, the fact that Chad’s phone doesn’t show up at his own house on the two particular days the kids were likely buried is likewise raising red flags for me. You would see my phone data at my house every single day if I’m not out of town or something like that. The fact that’s there’s nothing seems off in and of itself.
Its that it didn't show up anywhere at all. It would be at a church or friends house if he left it behind. Its simply turned off the days of the murders. Criminal masterminds, these people are not.
Agreed!! And I think Alex's death was planned all along as well.
That was Alix's thoughts too. He told his wife, after they found out Tammy had been dug up, that "Chad going to throw me under the bus."
Yes I agree Alex was killed also. Alex had a burner phone with him I believe it want his regular phone.
Chad and Lori would not have stopped killing if they we not in jail.
Exactly!
Emma’s entire testimony is under question in my mind.
I think she is lying.
Absolutely - compare her recent testimony to the stuff she said to dateline - lies & more lies
Agree. Her answers fit so well to every charge against duddy Chud. Felt scripted to address all the things.
She sounded like a robot to me. I agree, the whole thing was scripted and she was being careful not to mess it up.
Oh I’d bet my house and all its contents that she lied
If this were my dad on trial, you can bet I would be sitting on the prosecution’s side, eagerly awaiting justice for my mom and two innocent children.
well said!
Yeah that's because your normal Emma is not she's horrible a very unlikeable individual
I was always daddy's girl and he was my knight in shining armor, but believe me, chopped/smothered/burnt bodies and an affair would make me turn in a split second.
I want to know why the hell did she move into that home when she only lived a few houses away??!! Can someone explain THAT?
Me too I would never forgive him ever! 💔
@@aimeefriedman822she was renting so it saved her money I’m guessing to me it seems money is the true Daybell religion
Emma stated that Chad told her the kids were in a safe place, not that they are safe this stood out to me
If someone said that to you, wouldn't you say to yourself or your father, "This woman is weird, the freaking FBI are searching for her kids and she's hanging out with you?"
I would ask and ask where!!!
@@monicalm2283 Me too. I'd ask why they had to be hidden/what's so bad about their grandparents/but Tyler is 16/WHAT'S DO BAD ABOUT THE COPS/and keep pushing...How long have you known my father? Didn't you know he was married? Did my mom know? Why'd you have to get married so soon and with all your problems?
Emma committed perjury, will she be held accountable?
Scares me that she is allowed to teach children and also has little ones with her belief system and refusal to view her own Mother’s autopsy results.
@@cathyhelmuth823
I’ve been saying this for years
@@cathyhelmuth823yep! She said “no one should have an autopsy” she’s literally a teacher she’s fucking stupid
If the prosecution can impeach her on the stand, she can be charged criminally. Depends if the prosecutor wants to pursue it or not.
@@cathyhelmuth823and her husband who hates police. He is also a teacher😦
I don’t know if anyone has noticed this but, Emma, char’s daughter said it was terrible for her dad to watch/witness her Mom die, but Chad said she was dead already when he woke up that morning.
That has been in my thoughts.
Hopefully the jury caught that.
Yes I have wondered about that too. So if many of us took notice, maybe the jury did too
@@SHAWNEESKYWALKERyes cuz most of us did. I bet the prosecution brings it up in closing
She could have meant it figuratively though. As in it as difficult for him to lose a wife.
I thought the same but it could be argued that 'watching my mum die' could mean slowly, over a period of time through Chad's claims of her being unwell over the weeks prior, which we all know, is untrue.
I am so glad the prosecution caught EMMA in her lies. Emma's testimony was practiced, elaborated and I don't care how much she love's her father, EMMA has committed perjury. NO DOUBT IN MY MIND!
She's been "paid $17,000 and given an SUV".
Paid to testify a certain way.
Yes!! There were several areas that she was dishonest.
Could u be more specific??
@@allysonh6410There are too many to list, but here are a few of the more obvious ones, off the top of my head: 1)She claimed she and her mother spontaneously opted to increase their life insurance when the insurance company came to their job during a regular workday. They worked at an elementary school. It was a Sunday. 2)She claimed she didn't know Chad was having an affair with Lori until after he was arrested. She was caught on video while Chad was sitting in the backseat of the police car in the day he was arrested, saying she had her own telephone account which she's been using to have telephone contact with Lori at her jail, and that she'd send her money since Chad no longer would be able to. 3)She said Tammi was not familiar with paint guns and had never seen or heard of her seeing or using a paint gun. Her brother, Garth, testified that Tammy DID know about paint guns, and that he'd actually seen her with paint guns in the past. When the prosecutor pressed her on this and told her that her brother said that, Emma's response was: "I don't believe my brother said that." 4)She claimed her mother was not training for a 4k race and that she was in terrible physical shape. Several other people testified that Tammy was, in fact, training for a 4k race and was in excellent physical shape. 5)She claimed her mother hasn't been to the doctor in two or three years, aside from treating an injured wrist. Tammy had a recent prescription for Prozac, for which she would have had to have been seen in the office at least every three months. Her prescription was valid and up to date when she died. 6)She claimed her father never advised her not to speak to or cooperate with police and FBI agents. She's on jail telephone recordings with Chad multiple times when he directed her to stop communicating with 'authorities'.
I'm sure there are a ton more, but those are the ones that are certain and not up for debate.
Tammy was anemic or had sleep apnea
I think her “fainting spells” were just getting dizzy when she stood up. Happens to a lot of us at that age
Yes, it does happen to a lot of us at that age. Welcome to menopause.
Being anemic can cause one to be dizzy. I guess if you’re dizzy you could possibly have fainting spells.
Emma stated that her mother may have had sleep apnea but you need to go to a doctor to diagnose that.
Yep !!!
@@clv3873yea, she just pulled that sleep apnea crap out of her butt
I've had low Blood Pressure my entire life and would blackout every time I stood up quickly from my teenager years onward.
It's more likely the fainting spells is a fabrication as nobody else knew about them and she spent more hours a day with the people at the school than she did with her family members
So why did Chad tell Tammy he was home burning limbs and murdering yet another woodland creature if he wasn’t there? Clearly his phone was off.
Good point!!
If it was off how did he text her?
*Locations etc were off
Coz he is a cheater!!!
@@lizbluth I can text from my computer.
My best “YES” moment from today is when the prosecutor asked the expert witness
“Do you know the seriousness of what was found in Chad Daybell’s backyard?”
Crickets
No bombshell in today’s defense
YES!
Chad did a monstrous act. When I really start to think about what those children must have felt as they are being killed I cry out loud!
Indeed. I've too have cried for them and their loved ones.
Yes what an awful person. Those poor kids were left to fend for themselves against a bunch of wackjobs 🤦♂️
I know what you mean. It keeps hitting me. I
Every time I see their sweet innocent faces I seriously say out loud, how and why? I do not and will not ever understand how not only 1 person but 3 people were 100% responsible and went along with this and two of them were family members 😢💔😢
Horrific. Just horrific.
I can understand Emma defending her father at the start. But now? She should face charges too. Something is wrong with this entire family. Watch out for yourselves Idaho!
Off yes. Some of it has to do with their religion. Most of it has to do with Chad being their father.
Thank you for remembering Charles. If someone believed him lives could have been saved.
Yes!💖🙏🙏
Not really. The police can’t do ANYTHING unless there is proof a crime has ALREADY been committed or PROOF that it will be. Someone’s word isn’t proof. So their hands were tied. They did their job and poked around and then when it lead no where they moved on. Without a warrant, which no judge will grant without cause… they have no authority.
Emma committed perjury! 😮
And such an EAGER and obvious perjurer!
Anyone who has several cell phones is obviously covering something up! He’s been hiding many things for a very long time!
Alone that isn’t enough. With the mound of other evidence- it’s pretty clear.
And-he refused to wear that Fitbit and Emma didn’t even realize she was telling on her secretive dad by saying that! I hope the prosecutors caught that!
More than 2 phones cuz a lot if people have personal phones and work phones. I also know a homeless guy that has a lot of phones cuz they break or don’t work cuz they are mostly the free phones. He had a good one then got another free one. I know other people that have a more than 2 free phones.
@@Leslie.dogmomChad doesnt work tho. 😂
Nine was it?
Tylee, JJ, Tammy, and Charles should be dreaming of summer coming and fun times in the sun ahead! May they all be at peace as justice comes for them!
When Emma said about her dad deleting emails and stuff…”if he knew how”. HA!! He’s an “author”! He’s known to turn his phone off and how to buy burner phones. Emma needs to face the music.
My thought was, how is it any different than deleting his own lol… hers/his it’s the same process to delete lol
Yeah, why didnt they tell her to just answer yes or no. She is so defensive.
Nate some of the testimony was confusing today and I said to my mom "Nate will explain it to me tonight." 😅 And you did! Thank you!
Same! Funny.
Me too!!!
Yep! I was bumfuzzeled
Yup! Nate's the best!
@@marshapieroni6677what a beautifully descriptive word! Love it!
I love that you honor JJ, Tyler, & Tammy every day. ❤
I want the rebuttal…so we can hear the conversations of Emma and Chad!!!! And we can nail Emma as well!
I'm not so sure that that can happen now. If rebuttal is limited to what was brought up in the defense's case-in-chief, the prosecution was actually the one who brought that up on cross. And it looks like Emma isn't even the one who is going to be called back. It's the Olsen insurance lady... if she is in fact able to be called back as a rebuttal witness.
I am going to freak out if this man gets acquitted on any or all of these charges
Ofcourse he won't.
No way!
Don't worry he won't
The question is, will he be given a life sentence or the death penalty. He's never going home. He'll never hug his grandkids. He'll never hold a woman in his arms. He'll never walk in a park again. So many things he'll never do again.
no worries. this is a done deal. I don't know he'll get death. But life for sure. Then some of his kids need to be closely watched. emma, garth, joe murray for starters. I think 1 or 2 of chads other kids are not following emma & garth.
Charles Manson wasn't present for the murders either. Still culpable.
Isn't that the truth
BOOYA!!! GREAT POINT!
💥Bam exactly
Exactly Chad was the mastermind maybe he didn’t want to get his hands dirty , Lori too used Alex as a hit man 💔
💯 ! 👍🏻
Tammy had to see a doctor for annual follow up for depression meds. I believe Emma lied about that too.
Meds can't heal you from a loser husband especially one who is obsessed with your death and obsessed with another woman.
Wasn't Tammy taking some of Garths Prozac???
@@monicalm2283 - I think Garth was the one taking Tammy's meds.
To be fair, Tammy may not have told Emma about such an appointment. Emma was Chad's spy. Still, Emma should have said she didn't know regarding Tammy's Doctor appointments, not make it seem as if she definitively knew.
I think it's very CONVINIENT and SUS that his phone (Chad)was no where , when he clearly lived there.
Yeah that is suspect on its own.
That' was my question. If his phone had been on and he was anywhere else, you know Prior would've tripped all over himself to have someone testify that his phone pinged (or binged) at the BYU library or wherever. But, nope, it looks like that phone was off. Wonder why... (/sarc)
Be a big girl and spell out the whole word.
@@OutWestRedDirtoh c'mon now
@@OutWestRedDirtwhat a weird comment
I’m wondering if Chad drove to the church, and rode back to his house with Alex, so Joe would see him or others would see him at the church. Joe Murray did him no favors saying you can’t see where they were digging, that means you couldn’t see Chad either, back there.
Put a neighborhood racoon on the stand. Those murdeted racoons have family too. Prior is obsessed with them!
And Melanie Gibb.
Yup no one denies racoons exist.
Racoons don't void the facts of a murdered wife and 2 murdered children of his current wife in his yard.
So funny.
I find the entire families blasé attitude about the raccoons they seemingly regularly murdered on their property to be disgusting. Family of cold weirdos.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🦝🦝🦝
Just focus on your own production, you do a fantastic job Nate, never doubt yourself. It’s obvious that many people like your style & your reporting is top notch, keep up the good work, more success is definitely in your future. 👍🏻
Agree! He breaks everything down. Love him and his team..
I like the local aspect. I’m in Washington and it’s good to see someone local supporting Idaho during these last couple of years
@@trudyedwards5311 yes, Nate and Crew are the best !
This case honestly freaks me out. Chad is so creepy
Exactly! It's so blatant that he is GUILTY! But yet he claims innocent! Scarey to think there is a small chance he could go free!!
@@robinlynn1319it is scary, yes. If chad had not been arrested, I could see him leading a very large cult and a very dangerous one at that.
Cause he’s a psych0path. Having almost no emotions IS freaky. He feels excitement (but mostly boredom), and anger. That’s it.
LAWYER YOU KNOW is amazing and he has been so complementary to you! He will want you on his show when this is over💥
@Nate Eaton on The Lawyer You Know would be a great collaboration!
Would love to see them together discussing this case.
I like the lawyer you know he is fact based like you Nate. He uses your clips and alway gives you credit.
The prosecutors have done a fantastic job. Lock him up and throw away the keys already.
The absence of data from CD’s phone…but he txted Tammy from his phone about raccoons, which FBI picked up, absence of data on both crucial days points to more guilt, more suspicion.
Absolutely! He has no alibi and his phone was mysteriously off for that long? Even if his phone died- who doesn’t recharge it relatively soon. Most ppl have backup chargers or them in multiple places. He was a little too careful (like Brian Koehberger)
And deleting his entire life before Lori....that´s cold,man that´s cold.
It’s extremely suspect that chads cell phones don’t register at all…extremely suspect
Wouldn't it be ironic if Tammy taught him that or turned off location for him.
Burner phones though…, ?
I think that's something Chad researched himself as a chronic adulterer and the husband of a computer whiz
But 19 other unknown phones were picked up, all the burner phones ??? Emma said she was late to the cell phone game and used her parents come to check the wind direction.. so she didn't have a phone.
@Eyes.WideOpen oh for sure, I think Emma was fibbing big time
Those poor kids had no one around them to help they must have been horrified 😢
Tylee especially! She wasn’t going to leave JJ alone with Lori. 33:01 33:03
Right! No wonder that Gibbs monster 👿 said Tylee hated everyone. Of course she did! Look at the wackos that she had to deal with! She was so worried for her brother I bet. Makes my stomach ache for her. And little JJ
@@melissagardner5936it's s no wonder that Tylee was on edge and why Tammy had depression, how could you not knowing your nasty lazy husband, on top of moving you away from lived ones, not providing for you, is talking about you dying as he bangs another woman who has moved to town for him.
In Melanie Gibbs very 1st interview, she said she really didn't know Tylee. But Lori was her Best Friend. What kinda Best Friend doesn't KNOW your kids?? Frickin Weirdo!
@@peggygibbons1441 thank you! Right!
Going to be interesting about rebuttal witnesses. Prior close to resting, lets goooo!!! Nate, can you please SHOUT OUT to our troops, our Veteran's especially since May is Military Appreciation Month. God Bless America!!🇺🇸🇺🇸
Rebuttal witness I hope they go after Emma! She’s lying!
I would like to hear some of those phone calls between Chad & his kids after he was arrested. It was more than obvious that Emma was lying and/or coached on what to say. I don't trust any of his kid's testimonies.
There is too much evidence against Chad. He expressed how miserable he was having to spend time with his family. He referred to himself as Harry Potter being trapped under the stairs. They can't keep their heads buried in the sand anymore. Tammy deserved better from her children.
It's so important to remember the names of the victims - not the names of the murderers, Thank you for focusing on this.
❤ I truly don’t know what I’d do without these rundowns. I even watch all the proceedings! Sometimes the testimony drags on!❤
That’s just it tho, those of us who watch it all are doomed to check out here and there. So these recaps are awesome 😊
same here! with the time difference in the UK, and work commitments, I have to watch the trial late in the evenings. Then I watch Nate's recap the following day. Am so grateful he breaks it all down and summarises all the court jargon. This is an immense trial and I am totally hooked!
Oh what a devious & cunning man Chad is, there’s no doubt in my mind that he KNEW to TURN OFF HIS PHONE TO HIDE HIS WHEREABOUTS, most of your viewers (many smart people) have already mentioned this , I’m impressed by their informative comments here.
I hope the jury is just as smart.
I believe he just turned off his locations etc. they’re a pretty private family and he was having an affair lol I mean if his locations were on then when he turned his phone on to text Tammy the raccoon text it would have picked up his location. It didn’t
But if he did so why did he not told Alex to do the same?
@@anacristinaareia to pin everything on the fall guy imo.
@@anacristinaareia so Alex could take the fall? I honestly think though that they thought they were so high above it all that none of it would matter. Their little guardian demons 🤷♀️ would take care of them.
But I believe there had to have been one more person involved in this. Possibly above them. Especially in light of all the contractor talk on the prison phone call between Chad and Lori
OK, so one of the main deceased people and reason for this trial, ie. TAMMY, and Eller can not recall her texts???? How convenient. 🤔
I credit Prior for at least TRYING to create reasonable doubt to defend his serial killer client.
He should be charged with mur der for boring us to death.
Right? He tried to do his job. Even if people don’t like it. I don’t hate the man
@@hangemhigh3578LMAO!👍🤣
And stopping appeal for ineffective representation.
I feel like this case is going to haunt him. He had no way out of it. I am so annoyed by him but cannot fathom being forced to defend someone obviously evil and guilty!
Did they find Chad’s device pinging ELSEWHERE to prove he was NOT there?
Not that I've heard
Nope. According to Prior's logic on absence of phone data or DNA, Chad does not exist.
Chad wore gloves in his grave digging pics so likely he wore them to dig JJs grave. Alex likely placed JJ in the grave, went to the front door where his phone pinged to tell Chad JJ was in the hole. I hope they have caught Emma in a lie and get her on perjury charges bc she lied multiple times in my opinion. She lied about looking up wind direction on the night before Tylee was burned when Emma said herself she is not good at directions. She also said that Tammy had not been to a doctor for years yet she had a prescription for generic prozac which requires a doctor appointment every 90 days at least.
That’s true you do have to get a doctor at least every 90 days for a refill
Also, if she was looking up wind directions because she was “having an event” why didn’t she have the event?
That is what I was thinking regarding the gloves.
Yes I kept waiting for them to bring up the fact that yes indeed she did go to the Dr.
Have you ever used a shovel to dig earth up? You NEED gloves or your hands will be bloody and calloused after. Regardless, NO dna is weird. Most ppl would grab the shovel and other tools and put gloves on right before working.
You would be surprised what men learn how to hide when they are cheating on their wife.
Especially if they are planning to "off" their wife.
Right?! Chad is a complete tool.
So BOTH Daybell kids have perjured themselves yet neither are held accountable??? Thats some BULLSH*T
Apparently only Chad and Lorie will ever be held accountable in this. They will have to give an Account to God one day.
I agree they lied and I also think Emma displayed sadism towards her mother. Definitely contempt.
Still, in the grand scheme, they are going to be punished. Their Mother is dead and their Father will likely be put to death.
The jury will decide who is believed. Not our role!
@@IAmALawyerToo um, sure but the jury represents us, the citizens
Yes. But. Prosecution will nullify those testimonirs by calling rebuttle witnesses and the defense has no cross of them.
Chad is truly a coward!
He’s a pig
Yes he is
What about the burner phones not identified…that doesn’t prove chad wasn’t there.
Nothing proves he wasn’t there. It only proves that his phone was not turned on. And the jury gets that too 😊
Emma Daybell will say whatever she has to so that her father is acquitted. She lied under oath numerous times, that was very obvious, and she should be held accountable.
Nate, I usually watch trials all the through. This one, i just couldn’t. I appreciate your hard work and putting together this for us each night. Keep up the great work!
None of Chad Daybell’s cell phones pinged. Why? He obviously turned them ALL off!
which in itself is suspect af.
“So if we’re going to call witnesses to muddy the water” has Pryor heard himself questioning his witnesses?
🤣😂😂🤪
Seriously, it's like he knows less about criminal justice than I (a French major) do. Hey, Prior, ever heard of rebuttal? Sheesh!
NO KIDDING! 😅
It's like smh- Who's side is he on again?!!
Did he hear his own freudian slip? Even defendant´s own defense attorney called Tammy´s death MURDER!
I watch every day from Australia. My husband now knows Nate's voice. I love that you make it easy to keep up and not miss the important evidence. Thank you, Nate and Peggy ❤
Hi from Melbourne 🇦🇺. We are a big contingent now!
@miriamiuricich6636 yes, we are. It's fascinating. Nate is awesome, explaining everything so we don't miss the important parts of the evidence.
My deepest respect to Tammy. She lived such an honourable life. RIP.
she really did🌹
Nate, about Tammy fainting at the temple... the same thing happened to me when i was in my 20's. While I was kneeling I was trying to maintain "good" posture and i nearly fainted. The temple helper explained to me that I simply needed to be more relaxed and i would be fine. She was right. ❤ I was told that fainting while kneeling is not uncommon.
17:34 exactly. I remember that text and he was at the property by his own admission. Gotcha Chad
Rob Wood did a great job of using Eller to reiterate the prosecution's data witnesses.
I have so much respect for you and your honest reporting. Also, the beautiful relationship you have with your wife is inspiring! Don’t ever doubt your style of reporting. It is refreshing and intriguing. You don’t use smoke and mirrors or flashy delivery. You are such a respectable journalist and we admire your integrity! Thank you for your hard work! God bless you and your sweet family1 🙏🏻
As far as the phone data,
Chad had 9 burner phones, Lori had 7 and Alex had 7 also…
I’m not far enough in the video yet. But wasn’t Chad actually sending messages to his wife about being in the backyard on the day he wasnt registered as being in his property? Just making Chad a lier either way
And we all know about the extra phones. Why would Alex have his on (Chad didn’t tell him to turn it off in case later he can say Alex did it 🤷🏻♀️)
Oh he got there quick
@@karennotAkaren1Yes he did, immediately after Alex left the property, yet, he didn’t notice a girl in his fire pit. Also, Alex didn’t have time to dig and bury JJ, Chad had already dug the hole. That hole was perfectly dug, that was done by someone who was a professional. That wasn’t a hurry job by Alex cox, I do hope the prosecutions stresses that point.
@@karennotAkaren1chad was preparing to blame these two if he got caught, all along.
Nate I really admire you!! You are great reporter!! Hi from Alberta
I am watching from South Carolina and I am so glad that you do a recap because I don't want to watch the whole thing, so thank you for keeping us up to date. Great job Nate !!
Me too!
Today was so rough…the worst two witnesses I have ever seen. I know Pryor is doing what he can,but I’m starting to think he knows chad is a disgusting person, and he is trying to help the prosecution. 😂
don't tote your phone along when you plan to commit a crime.
Turns off his phone, yet buried them in his backyard? 🤷♀️🤦♀️
Except not taking your phone with you or turning it off can be just as suspicious. I've seen cases where the defendant did that but having the phone off was suspicious because the only time their phone was off was during the time their crime was committed so that made them look more guilty.
Or take your real phone with you when you go to buy a burner phone LOL
@@RandGene-tm3se
😂😂😂😂. A genius he isn't.
He turned it off. He just POOF! Disappeared. Like THAT isn’t suspect 😂. Alec Murdaugh made this mistake too- turned it off during the murd3rs then back in- then it tracked him running around his property like mad. Koehberger did this too- went out driving and turned it off during the murd3rs- POOF! He vanished from the earth 😂. These ppl don’t seem to realize it looks very sus when their phones conveniently go bye bye JUST during the murd3rs 😂
It’s VERY common if kneeling too long that you become light headed. They tell you that in the temple. It’s been such a stretch for the defense to use the fainting as a health issue!
Sometimes I feel so deeply sad for the children and Tammy, and for all who loved them. Just heartbreaking. I pray for their healing and that they can rebuild their family. ❤🙏
Same here. And Charles!
Why do they have a death penalty when they don't carry it out?who decides when this is carried out?Is it one person who decides.
I don’t understand how NONE of CD’s DNA is ANYWHERE ON HIS OWN TOOLS IN HIS OWN SHED….THATS BIZARRE
Well, he is lazy.....
Gloves
@@BobbiGail LOL I was just going to comment the same thing.
Not really he would have wore gloves he is to prissy to have work hands
Gloves, he worked in a cemetery, he wore gloves, that isn’t a big deal.
You do your job so well! Watching you in action on Monday while I was at court, I was so impressed with your natural ability to engage with everyone.
To me if I were a juror - there's way too much evidence against him - all the text messages, the "Love Story", Tammy's demise prediction, him (and Lori) telling people kids are in a safe place, fleeing ID for HI, kids being found on his property, him wanting to build over the property, and telling Emma he isn't coming back. ⚖️🕊 Here's to Justice being served and a verdict coming soon.
It’s a pleasure to listen to ur recaps. As a retired news reporter, I appreciate your objectivity. So many you tubers and podcasters express nothing but opinions.
Your awesome Nate! Thanks for all your good work & keeping us informed.
Thanks team at EIN
Nate, how are you such an admirable man, husband, and father? Listening to know what you have seen all this horror plus other crimes, you are one amazing human being!!❤️❤️
Thank you for compressing the ins and outs of this case. Hi from Edmonton Canada
Actually it IS a shocker that Chads DNA was not on HIS tools!! Hmmmm sounds like a wipe down. One would certainly expect his DNA to be on his tools regardless of any of this. The fact that there wasn't speaks volumes. He had plenty of time to wipe them all down thoroughly. I do hope prosecutors bring this out.
Gloves
They did not check for his DNA because it is presumed it would be there since they are his tools
My son and daughter inlaw were in the court room on monday, they ❤ watching your pod casts. And i enjoy your pod casts also.
Those shirts are great, but if I had a mugshot I would absolutely want it on East Idaho News! Thanks for keeping us all in the know with the trial. I've been watching Nate since Hawaii.
Chad allowed Alex Cox in his premises.He was smart enough to isolate his device.
On Tammy's school life policy, the question that needs to be asked is if the school administration allows employees to keep their life policy in force after they retire. Chad's comment that she needed to up it before she retired doesn't make sense if the policy coverage ends when she retires [can't take it with her]. In that case, her best benefit would be to max it out now in case she died before retirement. Nobody is asking that question.
I did. It doesn't really make sense otherwise. I suppose with some of these programs, you can continue payment after you retire. I've gotten on programs through work and stayed on them when I left. (Car insurance) it was a really good deal.
Love your content, Nate! I’m steadily watching this dark/light craziness. I look forward to your daily summaries because you are always doing a fantastic job covering a subject matter. I’ve enjoyed the interviews with the jurors from last year. Much respect from Huntsville, Alabama!
Hmm, an impatient or waning jury sounds like people who have already made up their mind for the most part, imo.
Agreed 👍👍👍
Or like people who are exhausted and stressed
@@susan9630they'll need support after this. Very traumatic experience. 😢
Today’s testimonies were long, confusing and convoluted. I had a hard time following so I could imagine how the jury felt.
This is a 2.5 month long trial and these ppl aren’t getting paid except gas money. I’d be over it too.
I wonder what that impatient juror would think if they were dismissed as an alternate. I would be so frustrated.
“Well, first off, dead people don’t roll out of the bed.” -😂😂😂 The best news reporters know how to deliver the cold hard facts with the appropriate amount of snarkiness and sass with perfect comedic timing… aka- Nate Eaton 56:46
I don’t think he will take the stand. How could he without lying?
He's probably a very good liar anyway. I don't think he can handle being questioned by the prosecutor though.
The fact that there is NO cell phone data for Chad speaks volumes!! He is not as stupid as he wants us to believe. But for that text message he sent, he might have gotten away with "not being at home"
Tammy was 48, she was a long way from retirement. That does not make sense as a reason to increase insurance.
I do love you Nate, but I can not listen to Pryor for another second today. 😖
I agree his voice is so annoying
I can’t stand his weasel sounding voice. 🫠
I've been watching the trial live until it was Prior's turn and now I just watch Nate, I can't handle listening to Prior for hours on end.
@@brightbleu Me too. I got through half an hour of Emma's testimony and that's been as much as I could handle this week.
@@ishbelharris1857 Emma's testimony was especially rough, I had a hard time listening to her even more than Prior, and that's saying something.
Alex was definitely not alone.
Bombshell takeaway from 5/22: Chad knows how to turn off his phone and wear gloves.
Wait until sentencing, I bet the line is unreal!
Nate you Are doing such a phenomenal job. It has to be mind boggling. Great job
" She bruises easily," is the very LINE that ALL abusers use in court, to try to explain away the bruises on their partner or spouse perpetrates on them. I KNOW because I have been through it.
If Chad shot and buried a raccoon on his property why wasn’t his DNA on the shovel? I guess he scrubbed it down really well after burying the raccoon ? 😮
Were any of Chads guns checked?
Were bullet casings found on the property? Was a bullet found in Tylee’s burnt remains?
Yes, I think the slug wiped down the tools which is stupid considering you live there and all your DNA and fingerprints would be found all over the house, shed, etc.
Most people wear gloves when using a shovel or yard tool. Especially someone who used to dig graves for a living…
They didn't look for DNA on the handles because it would be obviously there if you own the tools
Your reporting Nate is outstanding you seriously should teach journalism there are a number of so called journalists out on air that could certainly benefit from your honesty.
Thank you from Buhl, Idaho
Absence of evidence didn’t mean evidence of absence!
Very true👍👏👍
Full disclosure. Bloody love you, Nate! I always watch your coverage, and have done since the beginning of this horrid case. Thanks from Poole in Dorset. 😊
Wow a local haha 😅I'm in salisbury
@@juliecurtis9162 Hey! Love me a wee trip to Salisbury 😁
Good job opening the door Emma!!!! Thanks 😉
I watch your recap everyday, but because of the time difference between Idaho and Zurich Switzerland , always on the day following! You do a fantastic job covering this complicated trial & I appreciate your efforts greatly, thank you 🙏
Thanks Nate, for catching me up! Sure do appreciate you. Arizona
Didn’t Chad text Tammy on that day and tell her he shot a raccoon
Yes, so that would place him there during the same time Alex was there. He made up a big lie about burning and shooting the raccoon as a cover story and now it puts him there even if his phone was off until he texted Tammy. Hope the jury puts this together.
@@MaryGloede - I'm sure the prosecution will remind me them, either in rebuttal or in closing statements.
Chad signed the insurance policy so he knew it was increased
He likely pressured Tammy to up it
Missed the Live but here now. Thank you EIN 👍
I did not like Eller He seemed almost hostile to the prosecution Does he not realize that the defendent helped kill children? He lost my respect by trying to help the defendent
Honestly although he was obviously very smart 🎶 he came across as not very bright. 🤪🤷♀️
All about that money
@@allysonh6410I understand exactly what you're saying 😊
I agree! Him telling Ron Wood Chad’s text to Tammy didn’t prove he was on the property…. Uh what? 😂
I would not want to be on this jury, so much information to take in.