Karen Read trial: Defense expert says John O’Keefe’s injuries ‘consistent with large dog attack’
Vložit
- čas přidán 18. 06. 2024
- The Karen Read murder trial continued Tuesday without jurors present to allow for the voir dire of three expert defense witnesses who may be called to the stand to testify at a later time.
Full Story: www.boston25news.com/news/loc...
The jury has common sense. A taillight cannot make bites and scratches.
Aipac Israel job is to bribe Congress to thief the American taxpayer money
I hope so
All the morons on the comments don't
I actually believe she has her friends& family posting on Utube
And bites and scratches cannot make a taillight. 🐕🦺
Sure can't.
Can't wait for when closing arguments happen, I like when closing arguments take place because it sounds so much better when it is puts together & makes more sense of everything, I still think defense is winning, I really don't think Karen at all did this, John's arm definitely looks like a dog attack & his face was beaten up, maybe John didn't go in the house Maybe John was beaten up on the front lawn & the dog attacted John & John passed out in the snow cause he was beaten up so bad & John then frozed to death with having hypothermia & the Alberts & the McCabes knew what had happened & they all tried covering it up. Because they all knew they would all be held accountable & because Trooper Proctor knew the families & Trooper Proctor Hated Karen & Trooper Proctor Tampered with the evidence & made it look like it was Karen that did this. one thing, is, The Judge is very Biased she always sustains everything, she always rushes everything, she always has an attitude, I don't care very much for this Judge.. She should of been removed.. I believe Karen is definitely 100% not guilty & all the ones involved should be charged & if I was Karen after this is over I would file a civil suit & sue them all. & reading some comments people couldn't possibly watched this whole trial, People are just guessing stuff as you hear it. Lol I been watching from the very beginning & John's O'Keefes family testified in the beginning , they think too that this was a cover up. People need to read & understand the whole story before just guessing & assuming & Karen was drunk dialing John but before she knew John was dead if Karen knew John was dead she would not of texted John that many times. With people just assuming without even been following this story & trial, People would just send anyone to prison This is a woman's life on the line I bet though when Karen is found not guilty, Karen doesn't drink anymore & Proctor should of been fired immediately Karen has great lawyers especially Karen's lawyer Jackson from California & I read Karen spent over 10,000 in lawyers fees
I don't like this judge.
She’s horrible snd bety obviously biased to the prosecution.
She micromanages bad.
I dislike this judge also !
She should be seriously investigated. She is supposed to be impartial and she definitely isn't. It's beyond a disgrace her behaviour
She is corrupt
The FBI reached out to the defence, not the prosecution...let that sink in.
😂😂😂😂 WHAT A JOKE of a trial
Exactly what the h*** are these people watching?
They turned everything over to the DA and the defense
Actually the FBI provided the exact same materials to the prosecution, defence and judge at the same time. The prosecution and judge also reviewed the materials and still proceeded with this case. Why? It’s so insane.
@@clairkeleher5437if I was Karen I’d prefer it go to court and be cleared. Otherwise those people would still slander her and try to make out that she just got off on technicality
@@MamaT0927 yeah even though her defense would have cost maybe a million or more, she’s exposed corruption and will have a nice law suit payment at the end of this. The stress though, awful.
She wasn't hired by the lawyers. She is also the leading dog bite expert IN THE COUNTRY!
A dog was involved and Higgins and Colin were involved> John went in the wrong door and that's is why no one saw him. They mess him up and put him on the lawn to die. Karen read is not guilty and its time everyone stands by an innocent person who tried to save his life.
John knew something about Alpert and Higgins
@@rosefitzgerald6277Colin is on drugs and John knew. He might’ve been going to turn him in…
Thats how it went down i agree!!
Those marks look exactly like dog bites...I've seen them first hand
Puncture and scratches no doubt
How the heck is the judge going to justify NOT ALLOWING TWO FBI crime scene reconstructionists, that were used for this investigation, who now the defense wishes to utilize?
It’s a power thing, “in HER court” she is the queen, justice be damned
I think she's guilty and I agree
The jury must have gone to the same school as trooper Paul.
Wonder why judge is “limiting” her witnesses but not the prosecution? Seems BIASED!
I have wasted most of this trial and this judge seems to hate the defense! She is very bias and I would like to know why she is acting this way . The more the state is caught lying the more she defends them ! She is definitely biased!
Because she is aunt bev to some of the people involved and they stay at her summer home in the Cape. She was asked to recuse herself and she refused!
Because for some unknown reason the defense didnt make their witness list and hand it over to the judge AND prosecution in the time limit!
I think the judge IS biased, BUT she couldve DENIED, LEGALLY, all of the defense witnesses that werent handed over within the normal legal time frame!
case is over. There is no way Judge Auntie Bev can do anything about it. Even if she is trying hard.
What a witch eh?
About time he fkn stand up to this horrendous judge!!!!! So sick of seeing things just continue to move on without addressing her bias behavior!!!
Those injuries are NOT from a tail light. A blind man can tell.
I think these comments are fake.
@@SunshineLove2023 so is yours.
@@Mess7739 lol 😂
yea it's the undercarriage of the car
@@jayb8053 on what planet?
It bothers me all this cops kill one of their own and don't care! I pray for justice for John we know Karen didn't kill him.
This whole trial is a joke … cops kill a fellow cop and then trying to put it up on his wife absolutely despicable
A glass doesn’t make SYMMETRICAL scratch marks. Dog teeth do that.
Great point!
Marie Russell, brilliant women ckassy lady smart smart women very impressed with her and all she has accomplished in her life never seen anything like it.. I wish her the best❤
Judge Beverly do you rent your summer cottage to these people???
Karen will own it soon
The police dog was immediately sent out of state after that night. Has that even made it to trial yet?
Chloe is a big part of the trial
Chloe Albert has a twitter account. Two barks... yes. One bark... no.
@@KnucklSandwich 😂😂
Object
And getting a lawyer is consciousness of guilt. TWO of the CW witnesses had lawyers (one of them on the stand with their cop client). Beverly C should be ashamed of herself. She is beyond biased. She doesn’t like the circus. But she has a hand in creating it.
I think Bev is gonna rule they don’t testify.. she’s walking a fine line for an unfair trial. Y is she helping the DA’s bogus case? What does she have in the game? Worst judge I’ve ever witnessed
She is connected to the Alberts they call her Auntie
A few podcaster said since the big boys paid for the dog expert and not the defense. She will be playing with her career if she denies them.
If she does, she's running the risk of reversible error. I really don't think she has much choice; there's no good reason I've found for her to justify the ruling for the record. I'd be shocked if she found one.
The cops involved literally call her "aunt bev"
She shouldn't be allowed to judge the case, conflict of interest
I unknowingly stepped in my GSD deciding to discipline my Terrier, got caught on the thigh, in shorts, by her paw! 😂 I have a scratch mark, bigger where the claw made contact, with a trail. Much like a shooting star, and EXACTLY like one of the marks on O'Keefe's arm!!!!
Now, the marks,scratches, and wounds on John's arm make complete sense. They never looked like scratches from a plastic tail light, in my small opinion.
The lead detective was so busy covering up for fellow police officer that he did a shoddy job in this investigation. The Alberts mourned John so much they couldn't be botherd to come outside to their front lawn to see what had happened to a fellow police officer. Then Proctor and his sister wishing she would kill herself. Now yesterday we heard that the cell phone says that the victim took steps down the steps after he was dropped off. You can't have it your way and pick out what evidence supports your story. The Commonwealth of Virginia had a lead investigator went to jail for extortion in 2010. The prosecution along with University are investigating to see if any of the cases he worked on were unjustly sent to prison. So if you think this case can't happen think again.
They already knew what happened to John and how he ended up dead. Better not to go outside and get asked any embarrassing questions.
Corrupt, biased judge
Thank The Lord for The medical doctor. Least someone has common sense and isn’t stupid. Those scratches are not consistent with tail light glass 🙄. Do you except for Mr. O’Keefe to get The justice He very well deserves people Who keep on telling you preposterous stories like Trooper Joe Paul. He couldn’t say where or not She had hit Johns car.
😂 ".....whaddaya mean Physics..?" Yikes that was embarrassing but to know this Judge will Allow that and Allow LallyGagger who forced a Trooper Paul to go up there under Oath and to lie about "stuff" the nonsense was all talk none of these events happened ever. it's so wrong they all need to Go Byebye
Anyone with an ounce of common sense will call those scratches n bite marks from a dog
Stevie Wonder called. He wants his blindness back.
The judge is bias
1:06 “do you know what kind of animal 😮” this some dense shit
A dog named Chloe 😮
Recruse this judge!
Prosecutors got their clock cleaned.
Prosecutor represents the Commonwealth? Doesn't represent most people in Mass. The DA's office (Morrissey) seems uninterested in truth.
Even if a car dragged a body causing “road rash”, the wounds are limited to one arm? No way expert testimony should be squashed here.
The wound is clean. Did someone wash it before it was swabbed? Was the wound swabbed or just the clothes that had sat in a car for over a week, Were all the holes in the sweater swabbed or just one hole? If only one hole was swabbed and it was the last bite there wouldn't be any saliva to swab. Who took the swab(s)?
They cant convince anyone that a car traveling at 30 mph can fly 30ft and land on their cell phone!
Not guilty
Karen is innocent.
If the judge doesn’t let the testimony go forward she is crooked also
They did not hire this woman. The doctor contacted them!
Let’s watch closely, now that it’s the defense’s turn. Judge Bev will try to hurry it up. Biased at its best.
Gotta admit that it 'is' kinda peculiar that YEARS into this case, that the defense only came up with this witness a *week* ago? So, until a week ago, they had no one to testify about the bites? Yikes.
Hmm, I wonder if there happened to be a Czech Shepherd or Belgian Malinois 'on duty' that evening....
The cop who owned the home where the body was found had a German Shepherd, Chloe, for seven years. After the incident, they “re-homed” the dog.
I really don't understand this judge it doesn't feel like she wants to get the truth
That judge should not be able to do that!!!
This judge is sickening. Where is any fairness? She is unfair, malicious and needs to be voted off the bench.
FBI appointed Witnesses
Thank You FBI 🙏
Bev go home
She wasn’t hired
I got bit by a tail light once - no joke brah!
Can't they ping the phones location and see if it ever went inside the house? I thought they did that in other cases
Ted Daniel - the used car salesman look went out in the 1970's. I know you love the "Anchorman" movie with Will Ferrell, but please.
I thought it looked rather swishy.
@@chickenwing111 🙂
Theory? Its way passed that.
GUILTY
PAID OFF LIAR EXPERT
Attorney Melanie Little has a great video on the Dog Bite
czcams.com/video/Tdqz1L1o_RE/video.htmlsi=_zGH5m7-dndsWGXP
Judge conollies
Imagine how far under the jail would Ms Read be if she had not the finances to defend against a criminal frame ing/coverup by local,city police and the states compliancy with Proctors terrible investigation and connection to witnesses. Ms read will OWN the town of Canton.
While not following the trial closely, I have thought about her smirks, smiles, and find her attitude appalling.
It's also hard to believe she didn't feel a bump if she hit this man. For her to smile shows she has no feelings for the victim. I don't like this woman!
Investigate the police for the text messages bs
Police dog/k9?
Judge is biased for prosecution
They will probably have this witness on Monday. If Lally doesn’t dally.
Pure bs
People will say Anything 4 Money!!
She wasn’t paid. These experts are working for the FBI. Their findings were turned over to the defense along with the text message. Do you need to be reminded that the FBI is now involved because of the cops and their egregious behavior?
They are payed with your tax dollars. Not the defense neither the prosecution. A third party in this case The Justice Department. If that doesn’t make you think 🤔 there’s something wrong with you.
Yea, like Trooper Paul! Pack your bags Colin, you gone!
No he wasnt!!
GUILTY 🤬
Hi Colin, get your bags packed, you going to prison for life!
Troll
lol sure a dog bite in the blizzard - I might buy the Twinkie defense
They need to get Chloe on the stand.
They could take an impression of her teeth to see if it matches up to the bites on John Okeef
Hello Karen Read listen i know 💯 💯 💯 💯 % That You Did Not Kill AnyOne i dont know you at All but you don't look like A killlllĺllllller.❤🎉
Yeah I don't know what this Judge really is but leave it to me Mike As Judge SHE did not do it ❤ supporting her for she did nothing it's FAKE News they know the damn truths and they won't even say the rights like this made up Biden stuff that is nothingness but made up shit that we don't need. Give me A Hellllllllllllllll Yeah If U Agree With Mr. MIKE??
Damn right. I'm taking over with the best Damn Judge Donald J Trump SHE didn't want to go to Jail or prison but this don't know how to treat everyone as An American As A Judge & The Sad thing About this whole thing is I'm not A real Judge but I'd love it if I was I make the World A MuchhhhhhhBetterrrrrrrrr Place With Donald J Trump Always Our President.??
That judge is a bias b
Who murdered him
Lots of people think it was someone in that house. Two of them were fighters. All were drinking. Phone data showed he went up and down stairs. They had a basement with weights and workout stuff.
Colin and family, DUH!
Ckassy women❤ I meant sorry my spelling
No the defense didn’t ask them they were assigned by the fbi.the female dr is but the people on the thumbnail were hired by fbi
GUILTY 🤬
Hi Colin, get ready for 23 1/2 hours a day locked down all by yourself for life!
@@chhansen9813 I think that Higgins (ATF agent) did the deed. But they all took part in the subsequent framing of Karen Reed.
@@arthursmith6854 That makes ZERO sense whatsoever!
@@chhansen9813 Guess you weren't following the relationships between Karen Read, John O'Keefe and Matthew Higgins. Particularly that night at the bar. She had been flirting with Higgins for days before that night in order to make O'Keefe jealous (because she was angry about O'Keefe's involvement with another woman). Then please review the video from the 2nd (and last) bar that they were all at together the night of the murder. Then watch Higgins testimony on the stand during cross examination relating to Read's leading him on. I think after Read dropped O'Keefe off at the residence and she left, O'Keefe quickly got into a verbal confrontation with Higgins about Read and it turned physical. O'Keefe got critically injured and the group decided to cover up what had happened.
@@arthursmith6854 You should pay attention to how RATIOED your opinion is! LMMFAO!
Even if dog bit O’Keefe after down, has nothing to do with death
It proves he was in the house! This is what the whole case is about! He was beating and attacked in the house, the dog was biting him during fight!
@@recentlyretiredDoes not necessarily mean he went in the house. Dogs go outside.
@@Fido-vm9ziwatch the case
Maybe Chloe was driving the Lexus, ran over John, jumped out and bit him. Karen's guilty.
I think that Garden Knomes are the culprit!
The dog mustve been making those butt dials and hanging up before voicemail. JM was innocent the whole time. thats why they relocated the dog. deleted texts call and their whole phone to stop the dog from making butt dials.
I think Chloe was driving and jenn mc bit him
Since when does a bar glass make SYMMETRICAL scratches on a persons arm. What kind of person rehomes a family pet? Timing is everything. House sold and dog shipped out of state . Are we supposed to ignore that? Not happening.
Hi Colin, pack your bags you going to prison for life!
Repent! Always remember your sins will find you out. You may conceal them from others in this life, but when standing before the Lord in judgment they are known to Him (Psalm 90:8).
Told y'all!!!!
I want to start with don't hate me. This is just my opinion. I am no one so my opinion means nothing but I have to get it out bc it's driving me insane and no one else I know is watching this so I have no one to talk to about it. I've tried so hard to see the defense side of this bc so many people have argued that is Karen Read's innocent but my gut has been screaming guilty. The further into the trial the harder I have tried but have been unable to silence that. I have rewatched testimony, watched videos advocating her innocence and it has not moved me to the other side. In fact, the more I watch the more I feel she is guilty and found the the perfect defense team and luckily an competitent investigation, which is so disappointing. The behavior and techniques of the defense on this case triggers my "PTSD" from being in a relationship with an (allegedly, lol!!) emotionally abusive, gaslighting, controlling narcissist. No matter what any witness says they argue it away. I agree the law enforcement completely dropped the ball thinking d/t her confession it was in the bag and the evidence was enough to make it a clear cut case so they slacked. I don't think the prosecution was prepared for the diabolical defense they were up against. jmo.
I really hope the jury has access to the transcripts of the testimonies of all the witnesses bc I have rewatched a number of the previous testimonies d/t the defense's prosecutive interrogative techniques of the witnesses (The lady doth protest too much, methinks) have found a number of inconsistencies in what the defense says what said and what was actually said!! How the prosection has missed it baffles me! False information presented as facts to one witness STATING IT WAS TESTIMONY OF ANOTHER. I doubt it will happen, but wish they would also have grand jury testimony. We only want the truth. And all the gaslighting, fact twisting and smoke screens the defense is displaying- for me personally only convinces me MORE of a guilty verdict no matter how hard I have tried to conform to what turtleboy has convinced the masses of. There, I'm done, judge me as you, or preferably ignore me. Lol
Can you explain the butt dials, Brian a and Higgins destroying their phones, Ryan nagle and friends arriving 15 seconds after karen and John then as they left they only see karen, the 6 drops of blood at the scene, the blood on the front/back of John's clothes, 2 others dna of blood on his clothes?, rehoming of the dog, selling the house that Bryan a grew up in, redoing the basement floors 2 years after it was done, oh by his friend of course, Bryan a brother Chris filling in his pool, tail light pieces johns shoe and hat not found in 3 inches of snow but after 3 ft of snow dumped, the text message, tell them that guy never came in?. There us a mountain of evidence which points to a cover up by the mcalberts. Johns arm hitting the car which turns him around and flings him 30 feet but yet no bruising below his nose?. Emotions do not point to kr hitting him but actual evidence proves he was beaten and attacked by a dog.
Obtain, the defense is going by their grand jury testimony.
I feel like you are confused. As I started to read your comment, I thought, "Okay, maybe I missed some stuff" but the further into your comment I went, the more confused I got.
Do you know that so far, the only people that have been presented have been so by the PROSECUTION. The defense has only been cross-examining people. These are NOT THE DEFENSES WITNESSES. These ARE the PROSECUTIONS witnesses.
The false information given as facts to another STATING testimony of another was a PROSECUTION witness.
Also, you say you don't think the prosecution was ready for the diabolical method of the defense team? The defense team has NOT been diabolical at all, they are just pointing out the facts and the timeline and how they don't add up. The "lead investigator" Proctor went off of what others told him. Trp Paul went off info from others. None of them went in the house, some weren't even interviewed until a year later. I don't know what you are watching but you seem to be in the mirrored frame of mind and you have flip-flopped the Prosecution and the Defense. On top of all of that, the "judge" ONLY RULES IN FAVOR OF THE PROSECUTION. She shoots down common sense repeatedly. She should be removed She's trying to help the prosecution because she is friends of the real killers.
FFS, she did not confess to killing John. I keep re-reading your comment and I'm wondering if you are the Angry Jen McCabe???
Glad you are not a juror. This trial is not about you.
@@johnkuncho7239 this!
A high paid lying Expert
Nooo!!
Shes GUILTY
I find you guilty of liking your own comments 🤣
@Sbxallday
I'm guilty of common sense& can spot a Liar Narcisist a mile away
Pamela Smart 2.0
The FBI reached out to the defence, not the prosecution...let that sink in.
😂😂😂😂 WHAT A JOKE of a trial
John made it downstairs according to his Apple watch. The dog attack marks are obvious. The lies by the Albert's numerous.
Are you watching the same trial....