Classical Musicians React: Sulli 'Goblin' vs 'Dorothy'

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 28. 02. 2020
  • For the 28th reaction video of Season 4 of this series, classical and jazz musicians react to Sulli's tracks 'Goblin' and 'Dorothy'.
    Listen to North Texas University's performance of Aurora Awakes here: • Aurora Awakes
    Peach drawing by Haley Chung (IG @haley.ch/Twitter @haley_chung)
    Watch Goblin here: • SULLI 설리 '고블린 (Goblin)...
    Listen to Dorothy here: • Dorothy (도로시) - Sulli ...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    CMR Reaction Release Schedule: docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
    Songs that are currently being voted on or waiting to be voted on by our musician voting panel (or votes are tied akjnfsakjdfn):
    • Not so sure list
    Will not react to list:
    docs.google.com/document/d/1b...
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ~Channel IG: @reacttothek_official
    ~Channel Twitter: @reacttothek
    ~Channel Tumblr: / reacttothek
    ~Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
    ~Join our discord! discordapp.com/invite/d7zU26X
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Video filmed & edited by Umu
    Script written by Erin Peters (Twitter: @eireaine)
    Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
    Thumbnail by Nozomi Murayama (IG: @nonchanyuzuru)
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Follow the ReacttotheK squad and keep up-to-date with our lives:
    Umu:
    IG: @_emcha_
    Tumblr: attack-on-dango, omg-horns, kpop-favs
    Twitter: @umucado
    Kevin:
    Twitter: @nerdymusicks
    CZcams: nerdymusicks
    IG: @nerdymusick
    Isaac:
    IG:@Isaac.jr.li
    Twitter: @IsaacJRLi
    Fiona:
    IG+ twitter: @fifidoghorn
    Daniel
    IG: @m.jwlee
    Aaron:
    IG: @aaronlee753
    Stephen:
    IG: @stephenmorrisdrums
    Seiji:
    IG: @seiyamashita
    Twitter: @seiyamashita3
    Elizabeth:
    IG: @ElizabethReacts
    Henry (trombone):
    IG: @henry.carpender
    Twitter: @henry_carpender
    James:
    IG: @jamesfhorn
    Melissa:
    IG: @melissa.447
    Emiel:
    IG: @trumpetoats
    Henry (vocalist):
    IG: @henrythedean
    Nick
    IG: @nqwbr
    YT: Nicholas Wilbur
    Brianna:
    IG: @brianna239
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 443

  • @snsdluna
    @snsdluna Před 4 lety +3620

    I'm tearing at how the reactors compliment Sulli's voice, because I've always loved her voice ever since F(x)'s debut, but so many people bashed her & said she couldn't sing, and I remember being so happy when 'Goblin' was released because it was like her declaration to the world that she was indeed an amazing artist. I miss her so much, and I hope that somewhere up there, she's smiling happily because her music is being praised and recognized by all of us who watch this video. Great job, ReacttotheK team!

    • @ur3487
      @ur3487 Před 4 lety +25

      lixvre same! i’ve always liked her parts in fx’s songs bc of her voice. it’s just so pretty ♡

    • @muhdamirul2225
      @muhdamirul2225 Před 4 lety +2

      Wait. How your comment is 3 month ago?

    • @snsdluna
      @snsdluna Před 4 lety +10

      @@muhdamirul2225 ReacttotheK uploaded this reaction 4 months ago but unlisted it because it might be too much for some of us fans to watch it with what was going on. They posted a link for this video on their twitter though, so whoever felt ready could watch it, and I watched it then.

  • @girliedefensor0506
    @girliedefensor0506 Před 4 lety +2679

    The intro made me cry. She is such a precious soul. I will miss her forever.

  • @trishaong338
    @trishaong338 Před 4 lety +1193

    James had it right when he said "She’s singing about having an ideal and knowing that paradise is out there,
    but the world just beats you down and you feel very broken and you look
    back on those ideals that you had and you’re like 'Oh shit. This sucks.' ”
    Hearing that now, knowing what happened to Sulli, is just heartbreaking. She was really reaching out and nobody reached back. I cried hearing Dorothy, and they're also quite right that it was like a conversation inside her head and she just wanted to break free and explode into the universe. RIP Sulli.

    • @CoraLuna
      @CoraLuna Před 4 lety +25

      What he said reminded me alot of my first listen to the Album. Especially when I saw / heared Goblin for the first time I went “Oh” and didn’t really know how to feel about it really. On one hand I felt proud of her showing such a deep topic in her music but on the other I got worried because I felt like she isn’t doing well at all. I just hoped that my bad feeling wasn’t right, so when I ended up hearing the sad news months later it ended up shocking me alot...

  • @ayse-um8sw
    @ayse-um8sw Před 4 lety +1224

    before goblin came out, i only knew of sulli from her nonconforming behavior and that she left fx, but after listening to the goblin mini, i was so obsessed with the songs. i had goblin on over and over and over again i was in love with the instrumentals, the personal lyrics, the costumes in the mv, how she portrayed DID respectfully, everything was so beautiful and i truly fell in love with the artist and kind of person sulli was, she inspired me to not be afraid of showing who i truly am and i admired her courage. she was someone who was carefree and herself, who cared about fighting against sexism and racism, who was so genuine and adamant about showing herself as she truly is, without caring about the unwritten rules and expectations of who a kpop idol should be. im going to miss my peach princess so much, i love her so so so much and she will always live in my heart as someone who fought so strongly against society, who lived every day the way she wanted to, she means so much to me. thank you for this.

    • @RipiaKim
      @RipiaKim Před 4 lety +10

      Ayse Kosebalaban peach princess, what a beautiful name for her 💞

  • @lmf221
    @lmf221 Před 4 lety +1420

    I read a quote about Sulli in regards to recent changes to remove comments from entertainment articles that touched my heart in the same way this reaction did.
    “The girl who lived her life as a wave has become a sea wall”
    As tumultuous as her life was and pure her artistic heart was she had a gift and a purpose in this world. She is gone far far too soon but she left a beautiful mark. I cried watching this. Thank you for your respectful editing and beautiful words of comfort through music. I hope she truly is heralding the sun and spreading light and color in the sky.

    • @hillaryoi8946
      @hillaryoi8946 Před 4 lety +19

      Sooyoung is a real one. You could tell from her comment that she acknowledges Sulli's impact. I just want her memory to be kept alive.

    • @ainnemiguel7389
      @ainnemiguel7389 Před 4 lety +7

      Yes. It was Sooyoung's comment about our late precious Jinri.

  • @mayafujii6518
    @mayafujii6518 Před 4 lety +497

    I found sulli too late.. the world has lost such a talented and pure human with so much life left for her and her amazing music, let us keep her alive with her music

    • @edenpffen
      @edenpffen Před 4 lety +30

      i have been a massive f(x) fan since 2018 and i can assure you didn’t find her late, it seems that she purposely released music before her suicide, since she was inactive before this and was acting. (Her final show before death being hotel del luna, a show about transition to the afterlife) :(

  • @Pizzacheese10
    @Pizzacheese10 Před 4 lety +630

    Dorothy is an amazing song. it managed to repeat the same word and vocal beats so much, but still keep your attention even through many re-listens. It is very much like meditation I think

  • @almaymay
    @almaymay Před 4 lety +506

    thank you for the beautiful reaction and the beautiful song about aurora- it reminded me so much of sulli. she was my angel and my inspiration. i still can’t listen to her without crying but thank you so much for your wonderful and deep reaction here. these songs mean so much to me and i hope they can come to mean something for all of you and help you through your dark times. sulli truly had the most stunning and pure soul- she was beautiful and such a powerful person. she never let society stop her from being who she wanted to be and from championing other women. i miss her so so much and i think about her everyday and i feel like this reaction helped me heal just a little bit. thank you 💜

  • @elskabee
    @elskabee Před 4 lety +754

    Not only is 'Goblin' incredible musically, but the music video portrays DID so respectfully and accurately. I really wish we could have seen more from her because she clearly had interesting stories she wanted to tell as an artist through her music.
    I really admired her for being a feminist and challenging SK's strict ideals about how females should look and act, she will be missed on so many levels

  • @DDDEVILDUCK
    @DDDEVILDUCK Před 4 lety +633

    This album was such a gift when it first arrived. As it comes to my ears today it is even more so. I will never forget her true, and in the best way, childlike performance. She will always be in my memory along with Hara as strong sources of inspiration and as a reason to live life as pure as possible until the end.

  • @1of1hanan
    @1of1hanan Před 4 lety +587

    I still cant listen to goblin without crying, i didn't watch it to the end, every time i think that im alright with hearing her voice now and trying to watch a reaction video or listening to the song itself i find myself ending it before its actually end. Its broke my heart how i was listening to goblin again and again before she passed away and now i can't even complete the half of the song. My baby sulli my angel you deserved so much better, i love u and im so sorry💔

    • @ReacttotheK
      @ReacttotheK  Před 4 lety +159

      Take your time to heal and no need to apologize, I’m sure she’d understand ❤️ it’s been a couple years and I still can’t listen to Jonghyun unless I have a strong mindset that day.

    • @RACHELLEcovers
      @RACHELLEcovers Před 4 lety +8

      it's the same for me, i hope she's in peace

    • @maxscott776
      @maxscott776 Před 4 lety +3

      hanan fx i completely relate. every time i think im ready, im not

    • @voidstrike3766
      @voidstrike3766 Před 4 lety +3

      I fall in love with her since i was a kid watching to the beautiful u
      Did u know that kdrama?
      And then when i heard from the news that sulli suicide im only 14
      Years old 🙁😢 i just cant believe it and then goo hara suicide too😟
      And then jonghyun😟 i cant feel
      My self i always get bullied by my sister and my brother and i feel like i want to rest too like them😟

    • @1of1hanan
      @1of1hanan Před 4 lety +1

      @@voidstrike3766 don't let anyone brings you down, you deserve to be happy you're the only one who can choose between being happy or being sad. No matter how it's get hard remember that you're precious, your self is precious. Keep fighting and it's okay to be sad sometimes but don't let the sadness kills you when you're alive. Remember your soul is precious. Hope u get through whatever makes sad, be strong for yourself🖤

  • @hystericmysteric
    @hystericmysteric Před 4 lety +366

    f(x) brought me into kpop and sulli drew me into f(x). she was my first ever bias and will always cherish the moments she gave us along with her beauitful, soft, melodic vocals. we love you so much ssul. i pray you are happy 💜

    • @KatimaMulilo
      @KatimaMulilo Před 4 lety +3

      Same. Rum-pum-pum got me hooked on kpop. Though, I still can't listen to any f(x) songs these days since the sadness is still too fresh.

  • @aerileepea1938
    @aerileepea1938 Před 4 lety +173

    I remember when Goblin was released and thinking "finally". This was it. We finally got to hear her side as an artist and I really enjoyed it. It was unfortunately short lived. I hope Sulli is resting well in peace.

  • @kylepop4371
    @kylepop4371 Před 4 lety +223

    This single album was instantly my favourite of the year when it first came out. The 3 songs she released brought me to tears. I connected with her music so personally. I still listen to it regularly. I wish I could thank her, her music has made such an impact on me, it really was a love letter out there to anyone who doesn’t feel “normal” or “accepted” or “unloved”

  • @icaiskndr
    @icaiskndr Před 4 lety +289

    i really didnt expect to cry.. i'm always listening to these songs but i literally cried while dorothy was playing. it's a very very beautiful song. and i miss my sulli so much... sulli unnie, look, there are a lot of people loving your music. you did very well, we love you!

  • @rovnmtlnz
    @rovnmtlnz Před 3 lety +25

    The fact that this was filmed before Sulli's death makes it more special. It showcases their appreciation for Sulli's artistry. Thank you for this. Sometimes, I still cry when I think about Sulli. It feels like a part of me left me, and I know some are also feeling the same. Went back here to watch people who genuinely enjoyed Sulli's music and this uplifted me very much. Again, thank you.

  • @Marine-yl5gd
    @Marine-yl5gd Před 4 lety +109

    I love Dorothy so much. Because no matter how many times she repeats Dorothy, it's anything but boring. This song is a pure treasure ❤️

  • @liyanaazizi9142
    @liyanaazizi9142 Před 4 lety +176

    it really made me tear up to watch and listen people finally appreciating the artist element in Sulli, she still had so much to say through her music but she is gone too soon, wayyyy too soon, i hope in the future, people will still remember and appreciate the music she left for us, the living.

  • @TheButtCaptain
    @TheButtCaptain Před 4 lety +250

    thank you for handling this so respectfully. MeU’s truly appreciate it with all of our hearts.

  • @jonah8231
    @jonah8231 Před 4 lety +259

    I have DID and Sulli and her song Goblin mean so much to me. Many people are afraid of DID and people who have it and her song is all about how we aren't so scary. We are just people. We "just wanna tell you hi". The song and the video always make me emotional. The song recently saved my life. Another alter (personality) watched the video when very sad over Sulli's death. The alter herself had been suicidal but seeing the video made her realize that Sulli would not want her to die too.

  • @Bellalovesyou4ever
    @Bellalovesyou4ever Před 4 lety +16

    I cried because the reactors actually went back to console with us... Her fans who are in mourning over her and Goo Hara and Cha In Ha... Thank you for appreciating her even before this all happened

  • @MakaParamoreEvans
    @MakaParamoreEvans Před 4 lety +52

    I've been so scared to watch this video, not knowing what my reaction was gonna be and when I would be ready for it. Over 10 years, I've grown up with kpop as a part of my life and F(X) and Sulli were there since the beginning and meant so much to me and my love for this music. Today I finally decided to click on it, and with the intro and her music and her message, I cried through pretty much the whole video (and am still crying) but I'm so glad I watched this. It reminded me of why I love art and music and how something unsaid can be so bold and just how beautiful Sulli's art is and will continue to be after her death; how she never stopped being who she is and how her beliefs and thoughts continue on this earth even after she is gone. Thank you so much for doing this video!! Love this channel and the team 💕

  • @noname-ew7uk
    @noname-ew7uk Před 2 lety +4

    Seeing Sulli-related videos makes me happy and cry at the same time.

  • @rissabell1465
    @rissabell1465 Před 4 lety +109

    The second I heard that Aurora Awakes was the intro you chose, it immediately made me tear up. Thank you so much for choosing this piece.
    And thank you for handling this so respectfully 💖

  • @georgeimmanuel3992
    @georgeimmanuel3992 Před 4 lety +19

    I always cry bcs this lyrics
    "Don't be afraid, just wanna tell you hi"
    Imagine her fears

  • @zabe3187
    @zabe3187 Před 4 lety +77

    Honestly I've been going through a lot so I never took time to process sulli's passing. My brain kinda was like nope cant right now and filed it away. So honestly for me this was healing. Cuz It had me confront some of my grief. I'm still not in a place where I feel strong enough to do all that. But I think this helped me at least feel ok with listening to her music again.

  • @ALLI.OFFICIAL
    @ALLI.OFFICIAL Před 2 lety +4

    "Such a beautiful voice" ahhh my heart...

  • @hanamoon5474
    @hanamoon5474 Před 4 lety +51

    There are tragedies occurring every day, the world is a harsh and unforgiving place for sensitive souls. My heart broke upon the news of her passing. Thank you for being respectful of her memory

  • @sherriedily_vivi8267
    @sherriedily_vivi8267 Před 4 lety +72

    Goblin and the whole album in general held a special place in my heart even before her death since it talked about a topic ive rarely heard about before in the Korean media. I love the songs so much, and the music video for Goblin is beautifully shot. It respectfully shows DID in a way I've never seen before.
    Ever since Sulli's death, it's been hard for me to listen to her songs. Her voice is so soothing, but also so emotionally driven that when listening to Goblin I can't help but hurt. It's only been a few months since her death, and I know we're all still healing, but I hope that people appreciate her music a little more now.
    Fly high Choi Jin Ri ❤🌸
    On another note, thank you ReacttotheK for being so respectful towards Sulli. And thank you for still releasing the video reacting to Goblin. And thank you for all the nice comments towards her. ❤

  • @cloudburstt
    @cloudburstt Před 3 lety +9

    I almost get this sense that we didn't deserve an artist of Sullis calibre. I especially feel that way when listening to Dorothy. Wow.

  • @pnutbro497
    @pnutbro497 Před 4 lety +20

    i have never heard dorothy before but the way they describe the song and rearding Sulli's life, it just tears me up. she chased a dream that is no where seen and she free herself of that sorrow

  • @Anony_mous1993
    @Anony_mous1993 Před 3 lety +10

    its still so sad. she was telling us. she was telling everybody. and everybody was still bashing her and hating her.. and she finished her story.

  • @bbypchs_6990
    @bbypchs_6990 Před 4 lety +88

    Thank you💖 and Sulli called her fans PEACHES

  • @hawaiianpunch06
    @hawaiianpunch06 Před 4 lety +23

    Geez! Considering this was reacted to before her passing, and the songs were written and recorded a while before, too, Dorothy especially feels prophetic like Bowie's Black Star or Prince's It Always Snows in April. The idea of the girl who is not of this world anymore, ugh. Sulli was a true artist, one who could not hold in her feelings and in everything she did, we could hear what she was going through. Both of those songs are truly beautiful and so glad to hear the compliments and validation she should have gotten while she was with us.

  • @hanyeolo
    @hanyeolo Před 4 lety +102

    Thank u sm for this video. Not a lot of people have listened to her music prior to her passing and seeing this really makes me happy that they appreciate it the way us fans love it.

  • @vallinarahmadinha7016
    @vallinarahmadinha7016 Před 4 lety +51

    I remember when this mv release, i thought "ah i guess she is happy now" bc you know, all the hatred she got is too much. I really like this song, so uniquee. I thought she get better and happier, but.... yeah you'll never know. Hmm this video make me sad huhu 😢😢. Thank you for your reactions 😊😊

  • @toria7242
    @toria7242 Před 4 lety +58

    I was so excited for her future endeavours after this EP came out so it was just soul wrecking to hear the news. At least we can retain her in our thoughts by listening to her honest and beautiful music.
    As ever you handle these reactions with grace and love, thank you so much ❤️

  • @ijustchockedonmycheerios2959

    It's just so sad to see her smiling and knowing how hard of a time she was having and that stress led her going to heaven

  • @bw-xv2rz
    @bw-xv2rz Před 3 lety +4

    it's honestly so infuriating how SM put ads here

  • @erwanights5641
    @erwanights5641 Před 2 lety +7

    Sulli was such a genius ! Her EP is a pure cristal !

  • @gabi.loey5979
    @gabi.loey5979 Před 4 lety +58

    Omg Dorothy instrumentals kinda reminds me an anime song and it's so calming and sweet. I loved it, totally gonna listen.

  • @musicsk613
    @musicsk613 Před 4 lety +43

    I fell instantly in love with these two songs of Sulli when they came out. I love her music and I was so excited for more future solos. I just want to say thank you to ReacttotheK for reacting to Sulli, and thank you to Sulli for being an angel and lighting up all our lives. ❤️

  • @dorothyjean
    @dorothyjean Před 3 lety +5

    My name is Dorothy and before Sulli passed I couldn't sleep without listening to her song. It hurts knowing Sulli is gone because of the cruel words of others and I feel so bad for her brother.

  • @aichilovewisdom
    @aichilovewisdom Před 3 lety +5

    She's now our own Dorothy. The girl who's no longer here. Sulli we miss you so bad. Your eternal slumber is still too painful for us. What happened to you was still heartbreaking.

  • @blancacalderon7379
    @blancacalderon7379 Před 4 lety +12

    Dorothy is like a sweet calming lullaby with haunting beautiful vocals thank you for introducing me to this song and Sulli

  • @ciciyoongi7
    @ciciyoongi7 Před 3 lety +7

    I was crying while watching this i remember being so excited for her being to able to sing again after everything she went through and seeing people compliment and like her music moved me I always wanted her to appreciated for how talented she was i miss her so much my sulli 💜💖

  • @el6605
    @el6605 Před 3 lety +10

    When I miss her, this video is one of the videos I want to watch

  • @harumicomments
    @harumicomments Před 4 lety +14

    Honestly Sulli's album is one of my fave albums of all SM artists.
    Rest in peace there beautiful girl...

  • @sooyerm6142
    @sooyerm6142 Před 4 lety +11

    I'm not Sulli's fan but i really miss her. She was really a soul of SM and a real princess. You are so precious, Choi Jinri

  • @s.e.k1385
    @s.e.k1385 Před 3 lety +13

    Everything about Sulli makes me feel like crying in a sensitively artistic way. It's like her feelings directly reach into my own soul and pull on my heartstrings, making me feel still lonely, but a little less alone.

  • @alita7929
    @alita7929 Před 4 lety +76

    Thanks for this, I cried and I think I really needed it

  • @kcdohl
    @kcdohl Před 4 lety +45

    ~reposting for the repost~
    13:39 yyyyyYYYOOOOO you're telling me she was a junglist the whole time?!!?!??? this is the first time i've heard dorothy and i'm compleeeeetely in love with it. i feel like the entire first half of it has this constant tension between the triplets in the vocals and the downtempo music, and when that break comes in, it feels like everything converges and blows up. after that it's like the song reaches escape velocity on the way out of the solar system. the very last part of her trancelike chanting dorothy with every measure of the break is as if she's committed to escaping the past, or finally submitted to losing it. SSSOOOOOOO COOOOOL

  • @flowerkitties
    @flowerkitties Před 4 lety +31

    when i first heard this album upon its release, it gave me a renaissance feel, as though the music was going back to the basics and showing that the simplicity of nature could be art itself. it was unbashedly and intricately sulli: that otherworldly, natural, fairy-like aura that only she carried. thank you to all the musicians who were able to see that through these two songs, and also allowed us to take a tiny peek at her mind through this musical analysis. this is the most beautiful gift to meus and peaches and we're utmost grateful. 💜

  • @el.c.8858
    @el.c.8858 Před 3 lety +6

    really liked the respectful intro. also the comparison to lilly allen’s sound is spot on, miss sulli so much😔.

  • @zaxele
    @zaxele Před 4 lety +15

    I think the piano in Dorothy was beautiful 😗 the song was beautiful, it's a chant, like she was summoning her inner child to relive/revive her childhood dream

  • @joelle2497
    @joelle2497 Před 4 lety +22

    I couldn’t get through the intro without tearing up, thank you for doing this so respectfully. Sulli, we miss you angel 💖

  • @val875
    @val875 Před 4 lety +86

    I didn't think I was going to love Sulli's album. I was expecting the generic pop mini album most idol turned soloist release once they leave their group. I feel sorry that I wasn't able to fully appreciate and support her music when it first came out.

  • @reveeebey2088
    @reveeebey2088 Před 3 lety +3

    James just tell the truth. He's not only care about musicality but also the feeling and the message of thus song, i lil bit shocked he explained the feeling that deep

  • @Noelciaaa
    @Noelciaaa Před 4 lety +27

    this album is simply outstanding... i love a lot of genres of music but I'm also always feeling like something could be changed/added/omitted to make a particular song better. Dorothy is not that. It's one of those very few songs I feel like are simply perfect. it's one of those special ones that can convey so much despite not being very long or containing a ton of instruments and using weird metaphors and fancy words. everything is exactly the best it should be to be the kind of song it is. how many theories the reactors had proves how multilayered its meaning is... what i took away from it was different than they did though they all had similar points. to me, it's indirectly talking about pain, but it's also telling the listener, it's okay, it's okay, you will be okay. very raw yet gentle. i love it so much and it was great to hear some music theory explaining why it feels so special. i will definitely never stop coming back to this one.... it'll forever become one of those complex mood favorites, just like Moving Through Time by Angelo Badalamenti is for me.... Or Co shu Nie's Swan Song. They just touch your soul directly, see it as it is, and understand everything.

  • @iamyyy995
    @iamyyy995 Před 4 lety +27

    I never clicked so fast.. now I'm crying. Sulli will and always be an angel. I Miss her so much

  • @hyacinthic8757
    @hyacinthic8757 Před 4 lety +10

    I feel tears welling in my eyes every time i listen to Goblin, yet somehow im still listening to it on repeat. I only discovered Sulli’s music after hearing about what happened, and i wish i could have discovered her music sooner.

  • @kpotato6080
    @kpotato6080 Před 4 lety +17

    Thank you for putting it back.
    Queen Sulli’s music will live on to inspire, to feel loved and to show the world how great and talented she is.
    Rest In Peace Sulli✨

  • @archwayofcesar
    @archwayofcesar Před 4 lety +18

    I would’ve loved to hear their thoughts on “on the moon” honestly the b sides are transcendental.

  • @hailaminzu
    @hailaminzu Před 3 lety +6

    15:15 Thank you so much for give me the information about "minimalism music" (and recommend some artists of that genre). I'm gonna listen to them, I really dig into songs sound like "Dorothy".
    Just thank you very much! ♥

  • @satgotlizz
    @satgotlizz Před 4 lety +5

    I will forever miss her. Unfortunately I only started listening to her music and only fell in love with her and her music after it happened. I will miss her forever, I still weep about what happened to this day.

  • @robynbrowne1277
    @robynbrowne1277 Před 4 lety +42

    When I saw the notification, I honestly didn't think i could watch it, but i surprised myself that i got through it. Thank you so much. p.s that intro really did a number on me, i am in tears. she will be forever in our hearts always.

  • @SyndicateGila
    @SyndicateGila Před 4 lety +39

    Started to like her after I heard her voice on Dean's Dayfly

  • @dandansgi
    @dandansgi Před 4 lety +11

    진리야 보고싶어 넌 항상 빛났고 예뻤어 네가 웃으면 나도 행복했고 네가 슬퍼보이면 괜히 나도 하루가 찝찝했어 이제 너의 미소를 더이상 볼 순 없겠지만 고마웠어 내 십대를 빛내줘서

  • @paigedoesstuff
    @paigedoesstuff Před 4 lety +20

    thank you for putting so much care and respect into this video. i listen to sulli constantly so i didn’t really expect to cry, but the intro and all of the kind words they had to say about her contrasts so much to what was said before her passing. we miss you sulli, and i hope you’re smiling at all of the compliments.

  • @zzya-5807
    @zzya-5807 Před 3 lety +4

    everytime i miss her this is one of the videos i look to remind her as the beautiful artist & person she was, thanks

  • @coraline158
    @coraline158 Před 3 lety +3

    I read a comment from @Cursed Homosexual and it mentioned Kevin's description of Dorothy by Sulli at 18:42. I read that comment before I got to 18:42, so when I finally got to 18:42 (after having read CH's comment) and heard Kevin's way of describing Dorothy, it really did hit hard. It felt as though something dawned on me or I had been enlightened. It felt like a very fitting way to describe Dorothy by Sulli. At least, for me personally.
    Anyways. Listening to Sulli's music is a little hard to do without getting swept up in thinking about Sulli, her death, her pain, and everything she's been through. I currently don't know much about Sulli. Not as much as I can know about Sulli solely from the internet, at least. But I watched a video before her passing, and it had Taeyeon in it. Taeyeon was browsing a store, looking at hats, and Sulli appears. From what I remember, my first impression of her was really good. I thought she was cute and seemed like a beautiful soul even in that short amount of time. I already really liked her. So, I screenshotted my screen, or took a picture somehow, I think. I wanted to find out who she was (but not right that second). After reading the news articles about her death some time after, I realised Sulli was the one in the video with Taeyeon, and I genuinely regretted not looking into her sooner, especially after listening to her music. I feel sad whenever I listen to her songs, and sometimes I feel like I don't deserve to since I only became a fan after her passing.

  • @courtney46
    @courtney46 Před 3 lety +3

    that intro music sounded sad. now i'm crying but i'm smiling because such a queen existed in the world and i had no idea until i got into kpop a month later

  • @lolaloli9362
    @lolaloli9362 Před 4 lety +11

    One and her only solo album turns out to be a timeless masterpiece. On The Moon is my fav song out of three tracks. Even though she's no longer with us but I'm grateful that her music have been received lots of love from music-lovers.

  • @Femmadt
    @Femmadt Před 4 lety +55

    thank you for this. beautifully done

  • @meujigae2727
    @meujigae2727 Před 4 lety +60

    Thank you. We miss Sulli 💜

  • @exidiot9075
    @exidiot9075 Před 4 lety +57

    Dorothy is still so haunting.. i miss her..

    • @patatas_2132
      @patatas_2132 Před 4 lety +9

      This.. yes.. it's really haunting.. TT

  • @dangerliesbeforeyou
    @dangerliesbeforeyou Před 4 lety +14

    Thank you for releasing this wonderful tribute video, it's so heartwarming to hear everyone praising her artistry!

  • @heavenlysan1467
    @heavenlysan1467 Před 4 lety +3

    omugod the intro made me cry so hard iam a big fan of f(x) ever since 2013 and my ult is sulli and she still is. i love her so much, what happened to her pains me a lot up to now. it hurts so much and hearing good comments about her singing voice and talent makes me cry even more.. i love you guys so much and i love sulli so much, i miss her everyday..m

  • @elise3905
    @elise3905 Před 4 lety +2

    the intro made me cry so much.. thank you umu that was really beautiful

  • @dearvernon
    @dearvernon Před 4 lety +14

    the intro was absolutely gorgeous!

  • @katika17
    @katika17 Před 4 lety +6

    Thank you for being so respectful and caring towards Sulli and Peaches, this made me cry, specially the intro, it was so touching

  • @Yana-qq7yc
    @Yana-qq7yc Před 4 lety +7

    Happy international women's day QUEEN SULLI ♀️🥰 you're still an inspiration and we are grateful for you. I'm sorry the world wasn't ready for you.

  • @Samikpop
    @Samikpop Před 4 lety +10

    As a MeU for so long.........I miss her. She was always part of the group even when she left.......we MeUs still love her and supported her. Hope our angel is now happier and I know she’s looking down at her members and us 🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @itamochivargas6233
    @itamochivargas6233 Před 4 lety +6

    I really liked Dorothy. It was so atmospheric it made me feel like I was floating, and when the beat kicked in it just felt like I was floating faster. Loved it I'm adding adding it to my playlist.

  • @mhsa4895
    @mhsa4895 Před 4 lety +5

    She will rest in peace and she will be remembered by the impact she made in our lives.

  • @titislintangpambayun1875
    @titislintangpambayun1875 Před 4 lety +4

    Miss u sulli :)

  • @marukio3o687
    @marukio3o687 Před 4 lety +5

    All the song in this album is just so sad that makes me cry every time I listen to it. R.I.P. Sulli

  • @4700cat
    @4700cat Před 4 lety +5

    i really tried not to cry but as soon as the aurora descriptions came in i lost it, this was beautiful umu, thank you

  • @pebble8978
    @pebble8978 Před 4 lety +7

    Thank you for reacting to this. Everytime I hear these especially Dorothy I get emotional. I hope Sulli is in a happy place now. We love you, our Peach.

  • @rashmisingh8834
    @rashmisingh8834 Před 4 lety +10

    This world didnt deserve any of you (Jonghyun, Sulli, Goo Hara). But please know you are loved and appreciated by so many. I know you are at better place now. You did well.

  • @Micmichellelaw
    @Micmichellelaw Před 4 lety +5

    I have loved her for 8 years. Thank you for your words and compliment towards Sulli, they teared me up.
    I think she is happy for your video which acknowledge her as an artist.

  • @summers9696
    @summers9696 Před 4 lety +1

    I remember playing this intro song in high school band and how emotional I always felt playing it. I imagine light trying to break its way through pain. Thank you for discussing Sulli’s song Goblin. This song meant so much to me immediately and now carries so much more weight since she passed. I’ve always felt less alone listening and am grateful for this song and how outspoken Sulli was

  • @cyyymaaa
    @cyyymaaa Před 4 lety +2

    I missed you so much Sulli, I miss seeing your beautiful smile.
    Rest in peace angel. You will be missed forever
    Thank you so much for reacting to her

  • @jessica1228100
    @jessica1228100 Před 4 lety +4

    I had put this off because I didn't want to cry but I still ended up crying during Dorothy. Thank you for the reaction video and for being so respectful. I really appreciate the intro.

  • @5915Hyunny
    @5915Hyunny Před 4 lety +31

    한글자막이 생겼으면 좋겠다
    설리야 보고싶다

  • @tris2213
    @tris2213 Před 4 lety +3

    Sulli 언니 보고싶었어😔

  • @ken_zaire
    @ken_zaire Před 2 lety +3

    i miss sulli and f(x) so much. f(x) was the first group that i knew (i was in 3rd grade) and i used to watch sulli's kdrama when i was in elementary. i miss her so much..︶︿︶

  • @mbae123
    @mbae123 Před 4 lety +4

    I really love her first album when it came out so much that I look forward to her next. I got teary-eyed of how much the musicians love her music because it is beautiful and artistic. She would have loved this reaction. I'm so sad to see her go, I still am, but I'm just thankful to her for giving us this beautiful music. ❤

  • @xSummeraain
    @xSummeraain Před 4 lety +3

    This has been in my recomendations for a while now. I was so scared to watch it but i'm glad i did. You all were so respectful towards her as an artist and her music. Thank you for being so kind to Sulli.

  • @aerivivi
    @aerivivi Před 4 lety +6

    This was very touching. I didn’t think I would cry from seeing this but I did. Thank you for this reaction