Everything Wrong With CinemaSins: Treasure Planet
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 03. 2024
- Treasure Planet is easily one of Disney's more underrated films out there. I was worried that CinemaSins would hate it, because they hated Emperor's New Groove, but thankfully, according to their description, they seemed to like it ok. But the video was still sinful, so...
Disclaimer: I don't have much ill will towards CinemaSins, I just want to point out the many mistakes they've made in their videos.
Edited by www.capcut.com/
Original video: • Everything Wrong With ...
My Letterboxd account: letterboxd.com/captain_vader/
*Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. NO COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT INTENDED. All rights belong to their respective owners. - Krátké a kreslené filmy
3:17 I mean… if she was doing it in a place and/or a way that made Jim feel uncomfortable, Jeremy would have a point here. But this is normal parenting behaviour - the frock’s he on?
8:14, no. Mrs. Bucket kept her maiden name after marrying Mr. Mop
Awww, my first sin would have been; "first off, Jeremy; how dare you sin Treasure Planet! That's an underrated, underpraised, underapperatied masterpiece of an awesome Disney movie! So here's like ten sins for even thinking about sinning Treasure Planet and you're 'no movie is without sin' motto! Treasure Planet is glorious!" lmao!
"Underapperatied"?!? WHAT THE *_@$%&_* IS THAT!?!? Don't you mean underappreciated?!?!?
@@JadenMoon1475 I don't have spellcheck on my laptop, so yes I meant underappreciated, lol!
This film, while amazing, does have genuine flaws. But no; let's pad out the runtime with college girlfriends, instead of actually exploring those.
15:38 Also, it would mean Doppler isn’t well written either, since Jeremy didn’t say it’s exclusive to female characters.
I genuinely don’t understand Jeremy complaining about Jim only having his mom around. Jim’s dad leaving IS different from most Disney films. Other Disney movies that have the protagonist with one parent, the other had died. I can’t think of any other animated film where a parent leaves besides this one
At sin #21, not only is Jeremy sinning something he likes, but also…..THAT. LAUGH. Great video, btw.
It’s not even that a couple cartoons bombed, rather they were actively sabotaged. Treasure planet itself was actively sabotaged to be overshadowed by lilo and stitch.
13:25 Yeah, honestly, I’m not even huge into those franchises, and even I’m annoyed when people conflate _Star Wars_ and _Star Trek_ just because they both have “Star” in the title. It would be like conflating _The Pirates of the Caribbean_ with _The Pirates of Penzance_ just because they both have “pirates” in the title.
Trust me, you have *no idea* how many times my mum kept bringing up Johnny Depp when we went to watch _The Pirates of Penzance_ down at the Mockingbird Lounge in Glenelg.
Another great video, and I have three things to say:
1. I really enjoyed this movie the first time I saw it, and I rate it a 9/10.
2. 15:54 Treasure Planet
3. 5:58 That reminds me of how he sinned Turning Red for how Bao traumatizes him every time someone eats a Bao bun, and in the comments section of my video for that movie, Matitya Loran said “That should be a sin of Bao.”
I’d forgotten that I said that.
*_F*CK YOU!!!_* Atlantis: The Lost Empire all the way!! And I'm not just saying that because Michael J. Fox voiced Milo Thatch in it!!
Finally he gets to the most underrated Disney film of all time and one of the best of the 2000 era
8:40 Thanks. I get really really sick of that whole "Why does every Disney protagonist have only one parent?" considering all those examples you just listed. Not to mention a lot of those characters with dead mothers are from different periods of time where dying from childbirth was fairly common. I mean can people just actually watch the actual films instead of getting their critiques from BuzzFeed articles?
5:43, unless he could memorize the entire map extremely quickly before leaving like Joshamee Gibbs in Pirates of the Caribbean 4. Which he almost certainly can’t
Missed SinSins
1:02 Jeremy admits that he only Sins logos as an outlet for his anger.
2:23 This is an intentional misdirect/red herring. And it's a common trope to have reputations not match the actual character.
3:19 Santa Claus WAS based on a real person, who's story was exaggerate and mystified. The same could be true of the Treasure Planet story as far as the mom knows, and maybe she does believe it was based on a true story, even if she didn't know how true.
4:51 No, this movie came out long before Ahsoka did, so if anything, it's the other way around.
5:44 Jeremy Sins a movie for making a reveal.
6:01 Jeremy not thinking that the captain could be a woman sounds more like a Sin for him for having sexist opinions. I don't think anyone found it surprising that the captain was a woman, only that it wasn't who we were led to believe.
6:49 Jeremy says nano-bots are the reason Silver can have all these gadgets in his arm and Sins it anyway.
8:19 Sinning a Disney trope for being a Disney trope.
10:10 Jeremy suggests that ships designed for space travel wouldn't have ways to get through the dangers of space travel.
11:17 Earlier than that. Remember Hangman's Tree from Peter Pan? True, no one was hung, but what else do you think it was named after? And what about Clayton getting hung in Tarzan, which came out before this movie? The REAL Sin would be that this futuristic society still uses hanging as a death sentence.
14:13 The REAL Sin is that a single pirate was able to construct this entire planet's structure by himself. Unless he killed everyone else involved with it, which would be an astronomical number of people.
15:30 Sinning love and family. Also suggesting that people's priorities can't change in life and that she would be any less of a badass just because she's now a mother. Amelia would make one badass awesome mom. Also-also, suggesting that just because a woman becomes a mother that it's a bad thing. Also-also-also, demeaningly calling a woman a "baby factory", that's sexist.
Great video, and nice you went back to that route of editing to get the video up. I, too, found it annoying that Jeremy sinned THIS MOVIE for future Disney movies going full CGI; just as bad as sinning classic Disney movies for the modern Disney logos.
You just HAD to come after one of my favorite films…
CinemaSins is so annoying to listen to, even watching this was hard
For real, it was basically torture listening to him
Salvation is nigh!
8:19 that’s me and th3birdman reaction to cinemasins corny ass joke
3:37 I’m sorry there’s no way he actually just made a college-girlfriend-sex joke when referencing a 15 y/o character right 😃
5:07, it’s not. It’s a (mostly) legitimate criticism of an entirely different franchise
I still miss 2d movies only Japan is making them
1:00 So… is Australia just not a thing anymore?
15:57, definitely Treasure Planet over Atlantis
13:10, did he just confuse Star Wars with Star Trek? (That’s a rhetorical question. He did.)
I actually think that was an intentional joke.
@@captainvader921 Could be.
8:45, or Pinocchio
Could you do everything wrong with Ice Age next
Maybe at least the first film. Just realizing I haven't seen that movie in years
@@captainvader921blue skys death shouldn’t off happened nimona was a great movie
Oh btw I just found that Scooby Doo remix
Can you send me the link so I can put it in the description?
@@captainvader921 czcams.com/video/eJIZpYdjK_0/video.htmlsi=Saa7UNvApurfrmpv
@@captainvader921
The link keeps getting deleted
Sinning *_Morph from the 1990s X-Men cartoon_* for *_ANY_* reason!!!
*_+700,000,000,000,000,000,000 sins on Jeremy_*
*_Sentence:_* Hunted by Sentinels *_("Identification error; Non-attentive CZcamsr. Terminate immediately")_*
That sentence is a bit much...
I real hate Jeremy's fake wokeness its stupid to point out things that arent issues like there sins and two the captain having a family dont make her less badass that just makes her more badass cus shes a bad ass mother ehos a captain like the hell?
I haven't seen the Alien movies but uh... isn't Sigourney Weaver's character a mother? And isn't she considered one of the most badass characters in film history? Because if he says something positive about that, then he truly is coming across as pretty damn hypocritical here.
Also, does he not realise that men want kids too? Who does he think are meant to knock up the women who want kids?
Heck, if anything, men have more to gain from having kids, since we're usually the ones who keep our maiden names upon marriage, ergo we get to keep the family name alive by passing it on.
@@MrTristy22 Probably not the best example you could have used, because it’s pushing the w0k€ narrative that female characters have to be “strong and kickass” in order to be seen as good female characters. So… I guess Helen Morgendorffer just isn’t a thing, then?
Like… am I the only one who actually, you know, *hung out* with the girls at school, and got to know them as individuals, and saw they’re just normal people like you and me?
11:12,
What is special with this time?
@@SuperPlacido1 I was having a technical problem seeing the video at this point so I time stamped it and clicked the time stamp to solve the problem and then forgot to delete the comment
@@matityaloran9157 Ah I see! I apologize for meddling in your affairs in this case!
@@SuperPlacido1 Not really a problem. I was planning to delete the comment I just forgot